Review: 21322 Pirates of Barracuda Bay
Posted by CapnRex101,
Pirates was introduced during 1989 and remains among the most acclaimed LEGO themes. 21322 Pirates of Barracuda Bay celebrates this splendid legacy, updating certain popular sets and paying homage to the range through copious enjoyable references. Modern variants of some interesting minifigures are provided too.
The excellent project created by Bricky_Brick lacked such conspicuous references and varied substantially from the updated design which features brighter colours and may be transformed into the marauding Black Seas Barracuda with ease. The resulting structure includes extensive detail and looks absolutely spectacular!
Box and Contents
Nostalgia undoubtedly influenced the design of 21322 Pirates of Barracuda Bay and that becomes instantly apparent from its packaging. The yellow stripe across the corner appeared on 'LEGOLAND' branded sets during the 1980s, encompassing early Pirates products. This is an appealing detail and has been integrated effectively, moving to accommodate the current position of the LEGO logo.
Opening the box reveals 27 bags which are numbered between one and fifteen while three additional bags without numbers hold the larger pieces. Fortunately, no stickers are necessary as any decorated elements are printed, thereby corresponding with many previous Ideas sets and the famed 6285 Black Seas Barracuda.
The instruction manual is rather substantial, comprising 460 pages. Several pages are dedicated to comments from the fan designer, Pablo Sánchez, along with the LEGO designers, Milan Madge and Austin Carlson. Some interesting photos of the development models are also provided, showing how The Pirate Bay eventually became 21322 Pirates of Barracuda Bay through multiple iterations.
Furthermore, some information about the minifigures and the original Pirates story is available here. This comic is particularly impressive, depicting how the Black Seas Barracuda became shipwrecked and the tales surrounding the fate of Captain Redbeard. Ideally, its artistic style would have matched 6255 Pirates Comic but this design instead recalls the comic panels from 1999 Star Wars instruction manuals.
Minifigures
LEGO has created numerous original characters, the most well-known of whom is probably Captain Redbeard. Several minifigures resembling this infamous pirate have been produced but the newest example seems notably faithful to his origins, sporting an elegant black jacket with metallic gold trim. The contrasting green shirt and golden epaulettes look fantastic and I love the dark bluish grey hook. Age is beginning to affect the captain's revered beard but he remains recognisable and should prove extremely popular.
Lady Anchor was not identified by name in the original Pirates range, although female pirates were present. This minifigure bears little resemblance to her predecessors, sharing only the pearls around her neck. Nevertheless, the splash of bright blue on this new torso is appealing and I like the metallic gold highlights as well, matching those on Captain Redbeard's dishevelled uniform.
While some minifigures incorporate new components, Quartermaster Riggings consists entirely of existing pieces. His striped torso was originally created for the 2009 Pirates series and this head has previously appeared in 60243 Police Helicopter Chase. It looks perfect here though, featuring rugged facial hair and an eyepatch which mirrors Captain Redbeard's ever-present patch.
Forestmen ran concurrently with the original Pirates range and I think Robin Loot might have been inspired by the popular Castle subtheme, given both her name and her distinctive green and reddish brown clothing. This torso is unique while the dual-moulded hat and hair element was created for the new Pirate Girl Collectable Minifigure. However, the reddish brown and blonde colour combination is exclusively available here.
Tattooga takes inspiration from another early Pirates minifigure who was distinguished by an anchor tattoo decorating his chest. Several more designs have been added since then, including two parrots, mermaids and the Black Seas Barracuda at sea! These tattoos are extraordinarily intricate and I love his name which makes reference to the tattoos and the Haitian island of Tortuga that was historically favoured by pirates.
Younger characters have appeared in many Pirates sets and Jack 'Dark Shark' Doubloons is the newest such figure, taking his nickname from an alternative term for the Black Seas Barracuda. His blue clothing looks nice and I appreciate the worn edges of the new vest. The medium nougat satchel is a pleasing inclusion too, having only appeared once before in this colour.
Pirates wearing blue and white striped shirts, with contrasting bandanas, have appeared consistently across the Pirates theme. Port and Starboard Broadside continue that tradition here. These brothers are presumably related to Governor Broadside and have inherited his enormous moustache, although that is now represented by a separate textured component rather than printing.
The vest with red stripes has been available since 2015 but the blue vest is new, albeit shared with 'Dark Shark' Doubloons. I would have preferred the pirates to wear different clothing but the satchel sported by the younger minifigure disguises their similarity to some degree. Their varied heights are similarly useful in that regard.
An outstanding selection of accessories are provided with the minifigures. These include dark bluish cutlasses, flintlock pistols, rifles and printed maps. The map is not unique which is slightly unfortunate as this would have been an ideal opportunity to include another reference to the original Pirates series. The design from 2015 is beautifully detailed though.
The Completed Model
Several island refuges have appeared within the Pirates theme, although 21322 Pirates of Barracuda Bay surpasses any previous structure in scale and detail. This model measures 64cm wide and 59cm in height, exceeding even the enormous 70840 Welcome to Apocalypseburg! which features comparable proportions. Despite relying heavily upon reddish brown pieces, the island also integrates bright colours so looks magnificent on display.
This set was certainly intended for viewing from in front, although the reverse is reasonably detailed and provides access to some internal space. I particularly appreciate the dark tan rigging that allows minifigures to climb between different levels and this rigging piece has not been available in dark tan until now. It feels very consistent with the surrounding structures and foliage is visible here too.
Larger models are frequently quite difficult to move around, especially those focused upon locations. Fortunately, this island can divide in half very easily, as demonstrated below. Despite their top-heavy appearance, both sections feel stable and they slot together neatly. No connectors are provided but I think they are unnecessary here.
Pirates sets almost invariably contain palm trees when visiting land and Pablo's project incorporated several such plants. However, the dedicated palm tree components which appeared with the original submission have not been available since 2004 so Technic elements are employed to fantastic effect instead. These palm trees look brilliant, due in particular to the colour variation in their fronds. I like the flowers placed between the trees as well.
Islanders is among the most popular Pirates subthemes and the head from an ancient statue is accordingly included, matching those in the original sets. The statue has been partially concealed beneath the sand but its design remains almost unchanged when compared with the sets released during 1994! In fact, only its colour and the horns have been updated while the feathers on top have been omitted.
Wooden jetties have been assembled around the shipwreck, ingeniously combining smooth surfaces and studs which give the impression of salvaged materials. This ramshackle design looks great and I like the scattered foliage which assists in breaking up the reddish brown colour scheme. Furthermore, black lanterns are distributed around the platforms and these seem suitably traditional.
The dark blue sign outside José's Inn also stands out. This tavern is named after the fan designer's father, who introduced Pablo to LEGO. The accompanying graphic makes reference to 6067 Guarded Inn, displaying the same golden grapes and goblets. Two bright green fronds are fixed on the roof and the curved shape between them is perfect, leaving space for an elevated cannon.
Another firing cannon is situated on a platform outside the tavern. These weapons can launch 1x1 round bricks an impressive distance, reaching approximately two metres. Reddish brown and dark brown tiles are placed haphazardly across the front of the inn. I appreciate these offset construction techniques but the exposed 1x2 ball cups which are visible on either side look rather awkward.
Dark tan plates form the deck of the Black Seas Barracuda, contrasting nicely with the reddish brown platforms surrounding this vessel. The deck is easily accessible for minifigures and some accessories are scattered here which further conveys the disorderly environment inhabited by the pirates. However, plenty of room remains for the minifigures to stand or control the aforementioned cannon.
Prison cells are inherently associated with piratical activities and this structure accordingly includes a small cell. Once again, the roof is decorated with realistic greenery but the stone walls appear notably incongruous as the other buildings are wooden. The pearl dark grey door and golden lock look superb though and the unfortunate skeleton inside is a fun detail.
Two deck panels are easily removable, permitting access to the detailed interior. The tavern features various goblets and bottles beside a keg and a nautical painting on the wall. There is sufficient space for minifigures to stand around the counter, although actually reaching inside is fairly difficult because the edges of the deck are intended to remain in position.
Fortunately, the sleeping area may also be accessed from behind which permits easier play. A pair of striped beds are located inside, presumably belonging to the Broadside brothers given their preferred colours. I think the 1x3x2 inverted bows which are placed along the external walls look wonderful and the internal wall is equally attractive. Its black and white colours are reminiscent of wattle and daub.
Matching colours appear across the exterior, standing out against the reddish brown platforms. This section is particularly spacious so several medium nougat crates are placed here, holding fruit and a baguette. The wooden supports beneath the jetty seem realistic as some are fixed on the sand while others reach into the water and the angled 1x6 tiles across the front also look nice.
Separating the two halves of Barracuda Bay reveals a treasure chest hidden underneath the central platform! I appreciate such efficient use of the available space, although an easily removable access panel would have been welcome. Three metallic gold ingots are found inside the chest. Gold chrome ingots have been available previously but this metallic shade is a reasonable alternative.
While the original Ideas project contained two pigs, only one appears here. Nevertheless, this is an appealing inclusion and I like the medium nougat 1x1 round plates which represent food. Despite its apparent similarity to the pig from 70357 Knighton Castle, this animal is unique because its eyes have been updated so they appear more consistent with other LEGO creatures.
Crabs, frogs and parrots also populate the island, providing lovely splashes of bright colour. Another wooden jetty is situated beside the pig and that definitely captures the ramshackle aesthetic which is evident throughout this model. I am especially impressed with the dark brown driftwood floating in the water and the uneven positioning of the supports is perfect.
Remarkably few changes have been made to the rowing boat since this component was introduced during 1989 and it continues to look brilliant. The contrasting dark tan benches are effective while the flag displays delightful printed detail. A dark bluish grey shark is also included, harassing the pirates at every opportunity when they leave their island home!
While numerous alterations have been made to Pablo's outstanding submission, the angled bow is somewhat familiar and looks absolutely magnificent. Two ball joints connect the bow to rocks on the island, creating an unusual position. I like how the palm tree seems to wrap around this structure and green vines are attached to the bowsprit, giving the impression of advancing age.
However, my favourite aspect of the bow and its integration with the island is definitely the exposed keel. This would generally be submerged beneath the water but has instead become trapped on the sand, exhibiting extraordinary attention to detail. Narrow gaps do remain visible but I think it would be almost impossible to improve upon this design and it looks great when viewed from the front.
Crates, barrels and oars are stored in an area beside the bow. This chamber seems relatively simple but does include an interesting angled window which was present on the original LEGO Ideas project. Additionally, a skeleton wearing a shako can be found inside and one of these storage barrels is black. That element has not been available since 1682 Space Shuttle Launch was released during 1990!
The rearmost section of the Black Seas Barracuda is situated above this storage room and appears impressive. I love the irregular shape of the dark tan platform outside while the cylindrical pillar looks great, despite offering very limited support. The rudder is brilliant too, forming a door while the ship is connected to the island and lining up neatly with the staircase.
Behind that door lies a modest kitchen. Various food accessories and bottles are found inside, along with the stove and a preparation table. The stove seems particularly interesting as these dark orange 1x2 masonry bricks are new. Otherwise, the furnishings are somewhat bland but that may be partially excused because they serve an important structural purpose, supporting the angled sides of the ship.
Black and yellow shades are inherently associated with 6285 Black Seas Barracuda and that classic colour scheme has been faithfully replicated here, albeit interrupted by palm fronds and vines. These are liberally distributed across the stern and I like the wooden panel which covers one of the windows. The suspended ship's wheel is another excellent detail, further revealing the extensive damage which has been suffered by this vessel.
The poop deck appears slightly odd without the wheel, instead featuring two weapons and a Technic pin hole where the wheel may be attached. An additional cannon is also situated here beside several cannon balls and the vital rammer which is clipped to the side. Each cannon is mounted on wheels so they can move easily, although this one has a dangerous field of fire because of the nearby masts.
Narrow steps connect the captain's cabin to the main deck in the shipwrecked configuration while the poop deck can be reached by climbing the rigging. The designer evidently gave serious consideration to how minifigures would navigate this environment which is always appreciated because I think these details improve both the play and display value.
Removing the uppermost deck reveals a spacious interior, including a large desk for studying charts and a chair that was designed specifically for Captain Redbeard. Two studs allow his standard leg to connect on one side while his peg leg rests on a smooth surface! The candelabra looks wonderful too and I like the smaller accessories placed on the windowsill.
This chamber also contains an overflowing treasure chest, a decorative bust and a bed that can fold against the wall. Its black and white stripes make reference to another of Captain Redbeard's classic vessels, 6286 Skull's Eye Schooner. Unfortunately, the cabin is reasonably deep which makes access difficult, although introducing an opening wall might compromise the whole structure.
Both masts evidently survived the shipwreck, although not without sustaining damage as two yards have been knocked askew while another has been broken. This design looks effective, especially in combination with foliage and the furled sails which have not appeared on earlier vessels. Admittedly, furling the sails can cause some crinkling so a second set would have been helpful.
The spanker has been removed entirely, leaving behind the gaff which supports a simple crane. This swings back and forth so is helpful for transporting goods but there is no dedicated winch mechanism. Fortunately, that motion can be recreated manually by detaching the string and wrapping it around the mast to keep the barrel secure.
Removing the wrecked Black Seas Barracuda leaves behind two islands which are joined by various platforms. This structure does appear relatively bland without the substantial ship sections, although I think the colourful palm trees and lime green leaves seem even more attractive in this form. Moreover, the jetties still appear cohesive in my opinion and contrast with the rounded sandbanks beneath.
However, without the ship components in position, the staircases on each island look slightly awkward as they seem to lead nowhere. The elevated supports which originally held the main hull section seem out of place too, although some attractive flowers become visible around the wooden blocks and these provide welcome colour.
While the pink and aqua plants seem appropriate within this tropical environment, the larger yellow flower fixed among them looks odd. This element originates from 6285 Black Seas Barracuda where two such flowers adorned the stern. They are omitted from this rendition of the Black Seas Barracuda but I appreciate this subtle reminder of the original design.
LEGO has produced numerous impressive vessels which are based upon the Age of Sail. However, this depiction of the menacing Black Seas Barracuda appears far more realistic and includes greater detail than any previous design. The ship measures 61cm in length so seems appropriately imposing but I think the most important development is the bulging hull, recreating the distinctive proportions of vessels from the Golden Age of Piracy.
Despite these notable advancements, the model remains immediately recognisable when compared with its predecessor. For example, the yellow figurehead and bow structure each remain intact, albeit now exhibiting much smoother integration. Flexible tubes are employed to lovely effect on either flank and the bowsprit feels exceptionally secure. However, the light bluish grey 1x2 ball cup which supports the bowsprit looks awkward.
The impressive forecastle is constructed almost exclusively from black elements, contrasting against the reddish brown hull components underneath. Its shaping is brilliant and the golden lattice windows really stand out, giving the impression of interior space. None is actually present here but it looks nice from the exterior and minifigures can reach the elevated deck by climbing angled steps.
Simple cones form balusters around the edge of each deck, appearing in yellow and black. They are certainly effective but my favourite detail is probably the rotating capstan which is fixed at the base of the foremast. I think this looks fairly realistic and it functions perfectly, smoothly releasing or retracting the anchor which can hang from either side of the ship.
Deck space has traditionally been relatively limited on LEGO ships, due primarily to the presence of cannons and ammunition boxes. Substantially more room is therefore available here and the varying textures are welcome. The three 8x8 lattice plates are particularly important in that respect and these also enable light to reach below decks so compare favourably with historic vessels.
Crates and barrels are distributed across the decks too. Such details are extremely basic but I think they look marvellous here, maintaining the chaotic atmosphere which was present on the shipwreck. Moreover, the 2x2 boxes have not appeared in medium nougat before and I expect this colour might prove notably versatile.
Further to looking good, these crates and barrels occupy an important practical role as they facilitate removal of the deck panels. The individual rooms remain unaltered, although the kitchen now adjoins the sleeping area and cannot be accessed from above because the captain's cabin was not designed for removal. That could be solved with some modification though and I would recommend making this change if you are intending to display the Black Seas Barracuda in her assembled configuration.
Four opening gunports are situated along either flank, nestling between 2x2x3 slopes which recreate the distinctive bulge associated with ships from this period. The black and white colour bands appear authentic and I like how the ladders have been integrated on each side. Minifigures can climb aboard through gaps in the balustrade and the ladder height is ideal for interaction with the rowing boat.
Pearl gold windows are fixed inside each gunport, preventing the deployment of cannons. While this seems slightly odd, the lattices can be removed and replaced with cannons, as demonstrated here. I appreciate these options but some furniture must be removed from inside to create enough space for the weapons, corresponding with the officers' quarters on historic ships where cannons could replace tables and chairs during battle.
Angular steps provide access to the elevated poop deck and the ornate balustrade continues along here. The rearmost section is substantially taller than its counterpart on 6285 Black Seas Barracuda and could perhaps have been improved with textured detail across its internal surface. It looks lovely when viewed from the exterior though and the ship's wheel is perfectly positioned as well.
Increasing the size of this structure has also swelled the quantity of yellow pieces. The yellow bricks which appeared on the sides of the original vessel have therefore been replaced with black elements here. However, their shape remains intact as several smaller parts recreate the decorative bricks that were fitted above the windows on the ship from 1989. The lanterns have been similarly updated using modern pieces.
Attractive lattice windows surround Captain Redbeard's cabin and the lower deck features two more gunports, flanking the rudder. The interior was not designed to accommodate stern chase guns but it could be modified quite easily. The adjustable rudder also looks fantastic and I like the shaping of the hull, although potential for minor improvement remains as the studs beneath the stern windows could have been covered.
Corresponding with its predecessor, this model of the Black Seas Barracuda incorporates two masts with six striped sails. Their material is unusually smooth and the sails are only decorated on one side. Even so, they look fantastic and offer realistic motion as the spanker can swing sideways. Two crow's nests are found above the rigging. These are great for displaying minifigures but feel rather fragile.
String connects different sections of the sail structure, accurately recreating an essential detail from historic ships. Each element includes studs at either end, thereby negating any need for small knots and permitting easy replacement if the string is damaged. My favourite features are the 1x2 rounded plates that resemble blocks and the martingale which hangs vertically beneath the bowsprit, securing the jib.
Flags are planted atop each mast, displaying the Jolly Roger emblem which has been affiliated with piracy since the eighteenth century. Their differing sizes reflect the original model but these flags are considerably sturdier and the printed designs have been updated. The skull appears more angular to match the shape of minifigure heads but the tattering along the edge remains nearly identical.
Overall
21322 Pirates of Barracuda Bay encapsulates everything exciting about the Pirates theme! This set appears extraordinarily detailed and includes numerous references to earlier sets while concurrently offering some outstanding innovations. The most notable of these are apparent on the modern Black Seas Barracuda which closely resembles historic ships, improving upon past models in every regard.
Furthermore, the ship appears similarly impressive when shipwrecked. Switching between these two configurations is tedious but the result is appealing and I think the balance between bright foliage and darker colours is perfect. The price of £179.99 or $199.99 is certainly justified in my opinion, given the remarkable density of subtle detail, so I am extremely satisfied with this Ideas set.
I hope you have found this review informative. Let us know by liking this article and share your opinion of the set in the comments.
This set was provided for review by The LEGO Group but the review is an expression of my own opinions.
283 likes
74 comments on this article
For $200 it would be nice to have one or two more minifigures, but it looks like a fantastic set and I’m excited to get it after quarantine!
You almost made me want to buy this. Almost.
Magnificent
I'm desperate to own this one, and it looks to be on backorder until late spring here in the USA. Hopefully the lady pirate in the next collectible minifigure series will also be available by then.
Man wish I had the funds for this one...
Nothing like a good Brickset article to keep me entertained during the apocalypse...
It's bad timing for such big sets...
An absolute beauty.
If only my order would leave the warehouse. I fear it will be stuck there until sometime next week, or longer...
Great review, excellent pictures - will definitely be picking this up in-store one day in the (possibly distant) future!
A definite buy with the next cool Gift With Purchase.
@meesajarjar72 said:
"If only my order would leave the warehouse. I fear it will be stuck there until sometime next week, or longer..."
Same here in Germany. Still waiting for the Bay leaving the warehouse...
PS: Big thx for the great review. It makes me even a bit more desperate ;-)
@parsom said:
"It's bad timing for such big sets..."
I disagree, this is exactly when people want it!
...I guess it's causing them to not be able to keep up with demand though...
I'd love to see a side-by-side with 10210 Imperial Flagship! I'm tempted to get this as a complement to it, but am not sure on how they'll match as a result of size and age differences.
Fantastic set...the more i see it the more i like it. I just don't have space for it and $200 is a lot to spend to keep it packed away for a later date. The other issue is I would display it as the full ship instead of the shipwreck...leaving a lot of unused pieces / $$$. With that said I understand and appreciate the motivations for designing the set as they did. Top-notch stuff but, sadly, it'll probably be a pass for me.
If this is too big for you or out of your budget range, check out my micro version and get the instructions at https://rebrickable.com/mocs/MOC-38553/veyniac/micro-barracuda-bay/ comments
This is beautiful structurally, design and detail wise, loads of great features and minifigs, I probably won't but it but I might bricks n pieces or brick owl the pig crabs & shark!!
But this Tops apocalypseburg too 10/10...
The more I see of this set the more I want it...
I kind of hope we see Lego Ideas continue to pay these tributes to old Lego themes; this is very much to Pirates what the Mech was to Classic Space. The upcoming Blacksmith hopefully will be that to Castle, and I have my fingers crossed that Sokoda's Bionicle projects goes through for the same reason. Might be a good time to try and get some Western, Trains, and Adventurers projects up to 10,000 too to see if we can give them a chance.
I really like the set they are releasing.
And I'm not saying this to bitch because I get why this occurs I worked on consumer product for years, but there is a big part of me that wishes that the set was closer to the original design. That was an EPIC build. Somewhere between the set that they finally created and the original would have suited me nicely.
Love the play aspect with the ship coming off the base. LOVE it. But that voice still keeps nagging at me a little, that 'what if' voice, knowhatI'msayin?? :)
Great review as always captain. Still gonna have to pick this up someday, but with so many custom MOC's and sets I'm not sure where to put this haha
Many thanks for this top-notch review of a fantastic set!
This was a day one purchase for me. Unfortunately I was sad that they did not include an updated yellow hand/feet monkey for this set. Hopefully there is enough demand to bring back the pirates theme for future sets.
This is a must buy. The more I see of it, the more I’m convinced I’m gonna buy one.
This is on my to buy list of sets, not a fan of Pirates but this beauty made me change the opinion.
Very cool set!
Ordered mine yesterday, can't wait to build this one
This review totally justified my day one order. Very excited!
Just can't wait to get my hands on this beauty and line her up beside Black Seas Barracuda, which I rebuilt a few years back (sans original sails - stupid mold!). It will be awhile longer than I hoped for though, just found out today my wife has been laid off. Thanks for this review and for being here for us though Brickset, really lifted my spirits!
I hope to own this someday. I enjoyed the attention to period (both Lego and historic) detail in the review.
Man, I sure hope and pray I am employed again soon so I can afford to splurge on this beauty!
One thing not pointed out in this review: there are only 3 cannons, while both the original BSB and this upgraded version have 4. Does it seem possible (with additional furniture removal) to equip a fourth cannon so that one could have a full firing line along either the port or starboard?
Going to wait for the next 2x VIP points for this one, but a definite buy. Always wanted a Pirate ship. Great review!
Oh, I'm in love.
I'll never afford to pick up the original Black Seas Barracuda, but this will work nicely. I've always wanted a giant Lego pirate ship, and yep, this is good.
I agree it is missing a monkey, though. Everything else is fine (sure, a couple more minifigs wouldn't have hurt), but it's a shame about the monkey.
My family put in an order for this and some other sets this afternoon—unfortunately, they got back to us later and said that it was out of stock! Kicking myself for not getting the order in earlier—now it probably won't get here until May. At least the other sets ought to help tide me over until then.
Has anyone done a side-by-side comparison with any of the ships since 2009? I'd love to know how it compares with the Imperial Flagship in particular. So far I've only seen it compared with the original Black Seas Barracuda.
Hey... maybe Brickset could do a comparison article similar to the ones they did for the Creator Classic Cars...
Thanks for this highly detailed review!
As others have requested, will someone please do a comparison with 10210 Imperial Flag Ship?
I always wanted this set was I was younger, but my parents could never afford it. I'll definitely be buying this in a few months.
The whole set is phenomenal! Definite buy for me at some point (probably after it gets back in stock)
@noigez said:
" @meesajarjar72 said:
"If only my order would leave the warehouse. I fear it will be stuck there until sometime next week, or longer..."
Same here in Germany. Still waiting for the Bay leaving the warehouse...
PS: Big thx for the great review. It makes me even a bit more desperate ;-)"
I waited on hold for over an hour with Lego customer service today, and they informed me that shipments are being delayed about a week after they are boxed. So, if you see it “in warehouse”, it should ship out in 4-5 business days. It is a combination of lack of carriers and wanting packages to sit for a bit before they go out to eliminate a chance of viral spread.
Looks incredible and I'm super excited for the Pirate fans!
Random observation about Robin Loot… it seems to be widely assumed that she was created solely for this set as a new crew member, and if so, that WOULD be a good way for the designers to stay faithful to the two female characters in the original project (one in red, one in green).
That said, the instruction manual identifies her as "the former gunner of the CrossBone Clipper ship". And while that set had a female pirate (with the same printing as the Barracuda crew member who Lady Anchor was inspired by), it also had a separate crew member in a green vest, white ghillie shirt, and brown hat: https://brickset.com/minifigs/pi049/pirate-green-vest-red-legs-brown-pirate-triangle-hat
Perhaps the designers decided to swap the outfits of the two unnamed Cross Bone Clipper crew members so they'd have two female classic Pirates characters with a clearer distinction between them and clearer parallels to the original Ideas project?
Or perhaps, could the green-vested pirate in the original set have been a woman cross-dressing and wearing false facial hair in order to join a pirate crew — a well-documented occurrence in the age of piracy?
I myself would even be cool with interpreting her as a trans woman. Historically, that's a pretty remote possibility, given sailors' many superstitions and prejudices against allowing women aboard their ships, and I'm sure lots would consider it absurd for me to even bring it up.
But by that argument, her and Lady Anchor are already both in defiance of historical records and societal norms by openly presenting as female — so this set and the classic LEGO Pirates line are just as deeply entrenched in the realm of fantasy and imagination one way or another! Might as well have fun with the possibilities!
Will comment more later — this rabbit-hole of research into the history of LEGO Pirates AND real pirates seems to have eaten up my entire evening! Definitely love the set and the review, though!
What an extensive review, well done!!!
Outstanding review Cap't, as always. I stayed up until midnight on April 1st to place my order and was told yesterday that it has been shipped! I'm new to the Pirates Theme but have the chess set which I will use to populate the 'cuda with her crew. Now all I need is the Imperial Flagship to stage a broadside battle! The decision by Lego ideas to incorporate an updated Black Seas Barracuda with this set is genius, especially as many missed out on the original (just like me)! Hopefully they will do the same with Emerald Night one day - Ideas anyone? Stay safe in these dark times.
Thanks for the review. The set is growing on me. I have the original built in the Lego room. This updated version of the ship looks great. The hideout area looks neat also, but I think I’d build just the ship if I ever get it.
But like many others, will have to wait for money...
Fantastic model, fantastic review, fantastic photos. Many thanks.
One question though: if the sails are rolled-up for a time on the island, will they then hang nicely unfurled on the ship?
WHERE IS THE MONKEY???
@Hovie said:
"WHERE IS THE MONKEY???"
Sadly the monkey is too busy these days making Pirate films with Johnny Depp instead
all in all a great set. however at that price they could have used sails with printing on both sides, as in the original barracuda.
It's interesting timing for me as over the past several days I've been finally getting around to seeing if there's anything I can do to de-glue(!) a 6286 Skulls Eye Schooner I once picked up in a job-lot. I'd sort of given up with it but then this set comes along, and like some others here, the review has got me tempted. I'd have to totally justify it to myself somehow, but I do really like the set.
First post here, so Hi everyone :)
Had to sell Apollo Saturn V On Ebay to fund it but it’s ordered! Looking forward to it very much - good review!
This set is absolutely magnificent. I can't currently justify spending my money on it. But it's gorgeous.
I can only hope we get a set of this magnitude one day for space or castle.
Awesome review of a great set, thanks Cap'n! :-)
Really looking forward to it.
Only the monkey (and maybe a second pig) are missing.
I will order it as soon as a cool GWP will be available. Then, I'll replace the sails of the shipwreck with those from 71042 Silent Mary. :-)
@Veyniac said:
"If this is too big for you or out of your budget range, check out my micro version and get the instructions at https://rebrickable.com/mocs/MOC-38553/veyniac/micro-barracuda-bay/ comments"
Brilliant. Kudos to you.
Thankfully, I was able to order this (thanks Budapest Lego Store for doing pre-orders!) Now all I have to hope for is that it arrives next week...
Where's the monkey? Running my country...
Nah, that's an insult to the monkey.
I intend on buying 2 of these sets. One, to have on display, with the bar, and the second set, for just the ship (with the rest of the pieces going to my spare pieces collection), full of pirates, coming to have a celebratory drink at the bar, after a successful looting of Port Royal.
If I have enough $ afterwords, I will be buying a third set just for ship parts, such as hull and sails.
I wish the creator would release MOC instructions for the original set, so that I could build that and display it beside the 2 in 1 model.
Mmmh, with the monkey I could have already bought one. Without It, I should learn first how to work acrylic glass, because my furniture was designed for modular-size. Too big...but I must have It and expose next to my Red Beard Runner
I really like this set and I can't wait to have it after this gorgeous review. Hopefully mine will be shipped soon.
It would have been nice to have the original ideas set though. I had forgotten how different it is to this design. The contrast is quite striking, I would argue that they are two different sets. I feel somewhat disappointed. I recently brought the Old Fishing Store off ebay and that was quite faithful to the original, so its a bit of a shame to see the extreme modifications.
I still love the set, but I do wish they had been a bit more faithful to the original MOC and released this as another separate set.
I would love a glossary for all the ship terms. Some I understood, but others were unfamiliar. I guess I'll have to start googling.
I ordered this day 1 and can’t wait to get it. I loved the Pirates theme as a kid and always wanted one of the ships. Now I hope the Caribbean Clipper on Lego Ideas gets to 10K votes too!
This was a first day buy...easily. Great throwback to the theme that really got me into Lego. I would spend countless hours battling with pirates, soldiers and islanders. The statue head is such a great nod to the islanders. My daughter has recently gotten interested in pirates and can’t wait to build this with her. Hopefully, like others, mine “ships” soon. SeeWhatIDidThere
Indeed they are very different.
The original design was a building on an island with some scattered pieces of shipwrecks.
The Lego set is a wrecked ship on an island.
I submit that to the vast majority of Lego buyers the concept of an actually wrecked ship that can be reverse-wrecked into probably the best-ever Lego (pirate) sail ship is LIGHT YEARS more attractive.
@Robot99 said:
" @parsom said:
"It's bad timing for such big sets..."
I disagree, this is exactly when people want it!
...I guess it's causing them to not be able to keep up with demand though..."
It's a great set to assemble during lockdown, for sure. But it's bad timing because of the economy. I was about to buy this day one. But since the covid struck my household lost half of its monthly income and in the future months it will be even worse. So, no Barracuda for me, food is more important.
@MaxA said:
" @noigez said:
" @meesajarjar72 said:
"If only my order would leave the warehouse. I fear it will be stuck there until sometime next week, or longer..."
Same here in Germany. Still waiting for the Bay leaving the warehouse...
PS: Big thx for the great review. It makes me even a bit more desperate ;-)"
I waited on hold for over an hour with Lego customer service today, and they informed me that shipments are being delayed about a week after they are boxed. So, if you see it “in warehouse”, it should ship out in 4-5 business days. It is a combination of lack of carriers and wanting packages to sit for a bit before they go out to eliminate a chance of viral spread. "
Ouch. Sounds a bit too long. Recent scientific evidence suggests the virus will last 24 hours on cardboard. But the issue is that it will be handled by a lot of people; should each employee of the delivery chain let it rest for 1 day before putting their hands on it, it will delay shipments tremendously. And I am not only talking about our beloved toys, but even more critical produce.
I understand these are complicated times, and I myself do not like taking risks, especially for hobbies.
But what makes me wonder is that I received an order the week before and it lasted only a few days. Germany (where I live) was already in lockdown back then. Also, a few people who ordered their set even later than I did received it, with or without the GWP egg. Some even got it before the delivery service announced it (as crazy as it may sounds). And one mentions getting it surprisingly while his order was still "In Warehouse". So it makes me wonder if Lego doesn't select regions where they can ship first, and then leave the rest for later.
So it makes me think: 1) one'd better live close to the warehouse; 2) hopefully one did not obtain the GWP like I luckily did (although already having one, I could not care less), or it will delay it even more, as it's added material to sit for a day......
All these things aside, it's just bricks for fun. I'd rather see safety coming first...
Finally shipped. Now it should take 2 business days, according to the email.
Very good review, thanks!
I just finished building this awesome set. Had a lot of nostalgic moments =).
I don’t say this easily but for me this might be the best Lego set ever.
Incredibly beautiful set, fun to look at, tons of storytelling elements and play features and very reasonably priced. PERFECT!
Thank you Lego!
Well DPD have been very good, unlike lego. It arrived there last night, and its now being delivered. That's how it should be. I feel like some companies are using this situation as an excuse. I know and I understand that its difficult, but when a company like DPD performs that well, you start to query why others don't.
Great set! Great review! Thanks!
@BovineBrick, @thomsedavi, @twentythree :
User with both ships checking in! I just created a comparison album of the Imperial Flagship, the new Barracuda and the Skull Eye Schooner.
For your viewing pleasure: https://adobe.ly/39WuDOP
Although the pictures are possibly more expressive, I feel like to sum up in words:
- the Imperial Flagship is larger, hands down. Taller, definitely longer and feels wider because of the stern. When you place them next to each other, it also feels larger.
- Their shape is just different. The Imperial Flagship is a warship, very similar to HMS Victory, realistic shape for a Lego set. The new Barracuda continues this more realistic trend, but it is a galleon shape (I hope I'm correct). The sails are much wider (!), however the ship overall feels narrower even though they use the same baseplate elements. Possibly because of the concave hull and narrow stern.
- The height of both ship's hull is precisely the same (from floor to railings).
- Although the Skull Eye is just a bit longer then the Barracuda, it feels like a toy compared to them.
Some random notes:
- the island form is magnificient, I will definitely display it that way
- curling up the sails is a bad idea, it does crease the sails
@DocUnseelie
I definitely didn't think rolling up the sails was a good idea. I would just remove them if I displayed it in shipwreck form.
Hopefully these start shipping to the people in the states soon. I'm still waiting for mine to ship.
I think Silent Mary style sails would look great on this
I like the "Dark Shark" reference
Dark Shark was the name of Black Seas Barracuda in the UK if you don't know
@daniellesa said:
"Well DPD have been very good, unlike lego. It arrived there last night, and its now being delivered. That's how it should be. I feel like some companies are using this situation as an excuse. I know and I understand that its difficult, but when a company like DPD performs that well, you start to query why others don't."
For me, it has been the reverse. Lego has shipped rather rapidly, but here in Belgium, DPD has been a huge mess. Had to wait 4 days for my order to arrive, while the DPD sorting center is only a few kilometers from my house.
I think the trophy in Redbeard's room might be a reference to his appearance in the Lego Racers game hmmm
How long is the ship, would love to know what it looks like next to the Imperial Flag ship!
@sabazadeh said:
"How long is the ship, would love to know what it looks like next to the Imperial Flag ship!"
See my post above. There is album comparison between the Imperial Flagship, new Barracuda and the Schooner.