Looking for a bargain? – Check out the best tech deals in Australia

Best Media Players Compared: Roku vs. Apple TV vs. Google TV

Related:

You Can Trust Our Reviews

Since 1982, PCMag has tested and rated thousands of products to help you make better buying decisions. Read our editorial mission & see how we test.

Deeper Dive: Our Top Tested Picks

  • Roku LT

    Roku LT

    4.0 Excellent

    Bottom Line:

    You won't get full 1080p HD output or Angry Birds, but for a mere $50, the Roku LT will hook you up with Netflix, Hulu Plus, HBO GO, and dozens of other Web-streaming services. It's the perfect low-cost way to upgrade your years-old home theater.
    • Pros

      • Inexpensive.
      • Easy to set up.
      • Offers the same content as the more-expensive Roku boxes and other home entertainment devices.
    • Cons

      • Video resolution maxes at 720p.
      • No Ethernet port or card slot.
    Learn MoreRoku LT
  • Western Digital WD TV Live Hub

    Western Digital WD TV Live Hub

    4.0 Excellent

    Bottom Line:

    With its 1TB hard drive and ability to play nearly any audio or video file, the Western Digital WD TV Live Hub is a great set-top box for organizing and browsing local and online media.
    • Pros

      • Impressive file support.
      • Vastly improved interface from previous iterations.
      • 1TB internal storage.
    • Cons

      • Organizing local files takes some effort.
      • No built-in Wi-Fi.
  • Apple TV (2012)

    Apple TV (2012)

    4.0 Excellent

    Bottom Line:

  • Roku 2 XS

    Roku 2 XS

    3.0 Good

    Bottom Line:

    Learn MoreRoku 2 XS

Buying Guide: Best Media Players Compared: Roku vs. Apple TV vs. Google TV

Set-Top Box Showdown: Apple TV vs. Google TV, Roku, and the Rest

There are plenty of Web video services that would look great on your HDTV, and there are several media hubs that can put them there. If you want to access online content and your HDTV or Blu-ray player doesn't offer integrated Web services (or it doesn't have the services you want), you can take one of three routes: Apple TV, a Google TV device, or a Web-service-based set-top box à la Roku. Each one has its own advantages and disadvantages. The products we'll outline below are all different, and the best solution for watching your iTunes movie library isn't going to be the best way to watch Netflix on a budget. If you're ready to get into the Web streaming game, read on.

Apple TV
Apple's $99 set-top box supports 1080p playback and can access the iTunes store so you can watch movies, play Internet radio, use a handful of services like Netflix and YouTube, and, if you pay $25 per year, access your entire music library including ripped CDs through iTunes Match. If you use an iPad, iPhone, or iPod touch, its most compelling, exclusive feature is Apple's AirPlay wireless streaming. With AirPlay on the Apple TV, you can stream photos, video, and music stored on your iOS device to your HDTV.

Apple TV isn't perfect, though. While AirPlay makes it a great accessory to an iPhone or an iPad, Apple TV's video services beyond Netflix, YouTube, and the iTunes library are pretty sparse. You can't use Hulu Plus or any of the other major video services through the Apple TV, and even though the box runs on iOS, it has no support for apps, and offers very little in the way of expandability or customization.

Google TV
Google TV is to Android what Apple TV is to iOS, which makes perfect sense because Google TV is powered by Android, just like Apple TV is powered by iOS. The Logitech Revue set-top box, Sony's Google TV-integrated HDTVs and Blu-ray players use Google TV, and set-top boxes and other products are expected from LG, Vizio, and other HDTV manufacturers later this year. The Logitech Revue is no longer available from Logitech itself, but you can still pick one up online from Amazon and other vendors.

Google TV uses apps downloaded from the Android Market, offers a full version of the Google Chrome Web browser, and generally handles like a tablet on your HDTV, with a keyboard and touchpad to control it rather than a touch screen. You can look up movie information on IMDB, listen to your music library through Google Music, and even just sit in front of a digital fireplace with the Classy Fireplace app.

All that power comes with a fair amount of inconvenience: The interface isn't terribly polished or cleanly integrated across different apps; Google TV apps are as hit-or-miss as standard Android apps; and to fully take advantage of Google TV you need a wireless keyboard remote.

Service-Based Set-Top Boxes
The $200 Boxee Box is a powerful service-based set-top box with more similarities to Google TV boxes than Roku-type products. Boxee offers tons of services, including 1080p video streaming from Vudu, a Web browser, and live television programming if you pick up the Boxee Live TV USB tuner. Its interface isn't nearly as polished as the Apple TV, though, and its apps aren't as varied as Google TV's selection.

Besides Boxee, other service-based set-top boxes are simpler than Apple TV or Google TV, and they can also be less expensive. Roku is the best-known brand of streaming-media boxes, and the $50 Roku LT stands as our Editors' Choice in budget media hubs. Roku arranges different services as channels, and lets you access Netflix, Hulu Plus, and more specific video channels like Crunchyroll, Funny or Die, and G4. They don't deliver as many networked-media features as the Apple TV and they don't offer a Web browser or a lot of apps like Google TV products, but they're simple to set up and let you jump right into watching online video services without much effort.

Other boxes include Western Digital's WD TV Live Hub, which serves up plenty of video services and solid support for viewing media from a built-in hard drive, or over your home network. The Netgear NeoTV NTV200 doesn't have the networked media support or storage, but makes up for it with plenty of content channels and a low $50 price.

 

MEDIA HUBS IN THIS STORY

Apple TV

$99 direct
The new Apple TV is just a 1080p version of the old Apple TV with updated firmware, but it's still one of the best ways to watch your videos on your HDTV. Read the full review ››



Logitech Revue With Google TV

$99 list
The Logitech Revue is no longer directly available from Logitech, but you can find it elsewhere online. An update to Google TV 3.1 makes it a capable set-top box for anyone looking to try Google TV. Read the full review ››




SERVICE-BASED MEDIA HUBS

Boxee Box

$199.99 list
The Boxee Box offers plenty of Web services, a full Web browser, and even an optional TV tuner, but its higher price and awkward design hold it back. Read the full review ››



Netgear NeoTV NTV200

$49.99 list
Netgear's NTV200 is a $50 Netflix-and-other-video-services box for your HDTV, but its interface isn't as polished as those you'll find on Apple TV or Roku boxes. Read the full review ››



Roku LT

$49.99 direct
You won't get full 1080p HD output or Angry Birds, but for a mere $50, the Roku LT will hook you up with Netflix, Hulu Plus, HBO GO, and dozens of other Web-streaming services. It's the perfect low-cost way to upgrade your years-old home theater. Read the full review ››



Roku 2 XS

$99.99 direct
The Roku 2 XS puts a ton of online content, including Angry Birds, at your fingertips and on your television affordably, but it doesn't seem as useful as it did years ago, before many Blu-ray players and HDTVs offered the same services and more. Read the full review ››



Western Digital WD TV Live Hub

$199.99 direct
With its 1TB hard drive and ability to play nearly any audio or video file, the Western Digital WD TV Live Hub is a versatile and capable set-top box for organizing and browsing local and online media. Read the full review ››

Compare SpecsBest Media Players Compared: Roku vs. Apple TV vs. Google TV
Our Pick
Editor's Rating
Editors' Choice
4.0 Excellent
Editors' Choice
4.0 Excellent
4.0 Excellent
3.0 Good
Panel Type
HDTV & Home Theater Accessories, Media Hubs & Receivers

About Will Greenwald