-
The evolution of lithium in FGK dwarf stars. Influence of planets and Galactic migration
Authors:
F. Llorente de Andrés,
R. de la Reza,
P. Cruz,
D. Cuenda-Muñoz,
E. J. Alfaro,
C. Chavero,
C. Cifuentes
Abstract:
This work aims to investigate the behaviour of the lithium abundance in stars with and without detected planets. Our study is based on a sample of 1332 FGK main-sequence stars with measured lithium abundances, for 257 of which planets were detected. Our method reviews the sample statistics and is addressed specifically to the influence of tides and orbital decay, with special attention to planets…
▽ More
This work aims to investigate the behaviour of the lithium abundance in stars with and without detected planets. Our study is based on a sample of 1332 FGK main-sequence stars with measured lithium abundances, for 257 of which planets were detected. Our method reviews the sample statistics and is addressed specifically to the influence of tides and orbital decay, with special attention to planets on close orbits, whose stellar rotational velocity is higher than the orbital period of the planet. In this case, tidal effects are much more pronounced. The analysis also covers the orbital decay on a short timescale, with planets spiralling into their parent star. Furthermore, the sample allows us to study the relation between the presence of planets and the physical properties of their host stars, such as the chromospheric activity, metallicity, and lithium abundance. In the case of a strong tidal influence, we cannot infer from any of the studies described that the behaviour of Li differs between stars that host planets and those that do not. Our sample includes stars with super-solar metallicity ([Fe/H]>0.15 dex) and a low lithium abundance (A(Li) <1.0 dex). This enabled us to analyse scenarios of the origin and existence of these stars. Considering the possible explanation of the F dip, we show that it is not a plausible scenario. Our analysis is based on a kinematic study and concludes that the possible time that elapsed in the travel from their birth places in the central regions of the Galaxy to their current positions in the solar neighbourhood is not enough to explain the high lithium depletion. It is remarkable that those of our high-metallicity low-lithium stars with the greatest eccentricity (e>0.2) are closest to the Galactic centre. A dedicated study of a set of high-metallicity low-Li stars is needed to test the migration-depletion scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Some Old Globular Clusters (and Stars) Inferring That the Universe Is Older Than Commonly Accepted
Authors:
Félix Llorente de Andrés
Abstract:
The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has made startling discoveries regarding the early universe. It has revealed galaxies as soon as 300 million years after the Big Bang, challenging current galaxy formation models. Additionally, it has identified massive, bright galaxies in the young universe, contradicting the standard ΛCDM model's age estimate of 13.8 Gyr. This prompts a reevaluation of galax…
▽ More
The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has made startling discoveries regarding the early universe. It has revealed galaxies as soon as 300 million years after the Big Bang, challenging current galaxy formation models. Additionally, it has identified massive, bright galaxies in the young universe, contradicting the standard ΛCDM model's age estimate of 13.8 Gyr. This prompts a reevaluation of galaxy formation and cosmological models. There is a strong tension between JWST high-redshift galaxy observations and Planck Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) satellite measurements. Even alternative cosmological models, including those incorporating dark matter baryon interaction, f(R) gravity, and dynamical dark have failed to resolve this tension. One possible solution is that the Universe's age exceeds predictions by the ΛCDM model. The study challenges this by introducing a method based on blue straggler stars (BSs) within GCs, comparing ages with other models. The ages obtained are compared with those of different models to certify that they are equally valid. These values are comparable within the error ranges except for the clusters: NGC104, NGC 5634, IC 4499, NGC 6273 and NGC 4833, finding their respective ages to be between 14.7 and 21.6 Gyr, surpassing the commonly accepted age of the Universe. These results inferred an age for the Universe of around 26 Gyr, close to 26.7 Gyr. This value aligns with that suggested by the cosmological model named Covarying Coupling Constants + TL (CCC+TL). Such a value is consistent with early universe observations from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). The results of the present paper reinforce the advocating for a critical review of models encompassing dark mass, dark energy, and the dynamics of the Universe, particularly in explaining the presence of primitive massive galaxies, very old GCs, and very old and poor metallic stars.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2024; v1 submitted 21 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Could the number of blue straggler stars help to determine the age of their parent globular cluster?
Authors:
Félix Llorente de Andrés
Abstract:
A recent study shows, from an empirical deduction, that the number and the presence of the blue straggler stars (BSS) in an open cluster follow a function whose components are the ratio between age and the relaxation time, $\it f$, and a factor, $\varpi$ , which is an indicator of stellar collisions plus primordial binaries. The relation among the number of blue straggler stars, the factor…
▽ More
A recent study shows, from an empirical deduction, that the number and the presence of the blue straggler stars (BSS) in an open cluster follow a function whose components are the ratio between age and the relaxation time, $\it f$, and a factor, $\varpi$ , which is an indicator of stellar collisions plus primordial binaries. The relation among the number of blue straggler stars, the factor $\it f$, and the factor $\varpi$ of each globular cluster allows for deriving the age of the respective globular clusters. This method has been applied individually over 56 globular clusters containing BSS. The values derived for the cluster ages from our methodology do not differ from those derived from other methods. A special case is cluster NGC 104 whose age exceeds 13.8 Gyr (its age is between 19.04 and 20.30 Gyr), which would have a very exotic explanation: the existence of an intermediate black hole in the center of the cluster. That black hole main-sequence star (BH-MS) binaries with an initial orbital period less than the bifurcation period can evolve into ultra-compact X-ray binaries (UCXBs) that can be detected by LISA. On the other hand, if that age were true, it would call into question the expansion velocity for a flat Universe. This would call into question the case for dark energy dominated Universe.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Searching for the nature of stars with debris disks and planets
Authors:
R. de la Reza,
C. Chavero,
S. Roca-Fàbrega,
F. Llorente de Andrés,
P. Cruz,
C. Cifuentes
Abstract:
The nature of the few known solar-mass stars simultaneously containing debris disks and planets remains an open question. A number of works have shown that this property appears to be independent of planetary masses as well as of stellar age, but possible correlations with stellar kinematics and metallicity have not been investigated. In this paper, we show that the majority of known stars contain…
▽ More
The nature of the few known solar-mass stars simultaneously containing debris disks and planets remains an open question. A number of works have shown that this property appears to be independent of planetary masses as well as of stellar age, but possible correlations with stellar kinematics and metallicity have not been investigated. In this paper, we show that the majority of known stars containing both debris disks and planets belong to the metal-enriched Galactic thin disk. The few exceptions are stars that seem to be born in the star formation peak occurring in times of thick disk formation (i.e., HD 10700, HD 20794, and HD 40307), that is, between 11 and 8 Gyr. The mass of the dusty disk of these three old stars measured at 70 $μ$m is very small - in fact, it is lower than that of the Kuiper belt of our Solar system by several orders of magnitude. These results are not surprising, as they remain within the values expected for the stellar disk evolution of such primitive stars. In parallel, we found another six thick-disk stars containing only debris disks or planets. These results enable us to establish a correlation between stellar metallicity and the mass of the dust disk modulated by the different formation epochs of the thick and thin Galactic disks.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Open clusters: time-scales, core collapse and blue stragglers
Authors:
Félix Llorente de Andrés,
Carmen Morales-Durán
Abstract:
We developed a mathematical model to derive time scales and the presence of BS stars. The model is based on the variation of mass through a circle into the cluster defined by a radius, and at a time; this mass cross is translated into a differential equation that it can be integrated for a given radius (r) and a determined time (t). From this equation we can derive the different time scales that a…
▽ More
We developed a mathematical model to derive time scales and the presence of BS stars. The model is based on the variation of mass through a circle into the cluster defined by a radius, and at a time; this mass cross is translated into a differential equation that it can be integrated for a given radius (r) and a determined time (t). From this equation we can derive the different time scales that allows us to reach conclusions like: clusters not containing blue strugglers (BS) stars disappear younger than those clusters containing BS. In clusters containing BS stars, the volume which takes up half of the cluster mass is bigger than the one corresponding to clusters without BS stars but the time to catch it up is shorter. We also studied, by means of this equation, the core collapse of stars of the cluster and the region where this concentration is stopped/retained; this region is identified by means of the relation $c/ch$, being $c=\log(rt/rc)$ and $ch=\log(rc/rh)$. Where rt and rc are the tidal and the core radius respectively, and rh is the radius where half of the cluster mass is concentrated. The model also drove us to the conclusion that the number of the blue straggler stars in a cluster follows a distribution function whose components are the ratio between relaxation time and the age, labelled as $\it f$, and a factor, named $\varpi$, which is an indicator of the origin of the BS; $\varpi$ increases as the number of BS increase but it is limited to$\sim$5.0. The mentioned distribution function is expressed as $\it NBS$ $\sim$ $\it f^3$($\frac{1}{e^{\frac{f}{\varpi}}-1}$). The validity of this function was carried out by means of matching the number of observed blue straggler (BS) stars to the number of predicted ones in the available sample of OC.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
The bi-modal $^7$Li distribution of the Milky Way's thin-disk dwarf stars: The role of Galactic-scale events and stellar evolution
Authors:
Santi Roca-Fàbrega,
Félix Llorente de Andrés,
Carolina Chavero,
Carlos Cifuentes,
Ramiro de la Reza
Abstract:
The lithium abundance, A(Li), in stellar atmospheres suffers from various enhancement and depletion processes during the star's lifetime. While several studies have demonstrated that these processes are linked to the physics of stellar formation and evolution, the role that Galactic-scale events play in the galactic A(Li) evolution is not yet well understood. We aim to demonstrate that the observe…
▽ More
The lithium abundance, A(Li), in stellar atmospheres suffers from various enhancement and depletion processes during the star's lifetime. While several studies have demonstrated that these processes are linked to the physics of stellar formation and evolution, the role that Galactic-scale events play in the galactic A(Li) evolution is not yet well understood. We aim to demonstrate that the observed A(Li) bi-modal distribution, in particular in the FGK-dwarf population, is not a statistical artefact and that the two populations connect through a region with a low number of stars. We also want to investigate the role that Galactic-scale events play in shaping the A(Li) distribution of stars in the thin disk. We use statistical techniques along with a Galactic chemical evolution model for A(Li) that includes most of the well-known $^7$Li production and depletion channels. We confirm that the FGK main-sequence stars belonging to the Milky Way's thin disk present a bi-modal A(Li) distribution. We demonstrate that this bi-modality can be generated by a particular Milky Way star formation history profile combined with the stellar evolution's $^7$Li depletion mechanisms. We show that A(Li) evolution can be used as an additional proxy for the star formation history of our Galaxy.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
The evolution of lithium in FGK dwarf stars: The Li rotation connection and the Li desert
Authors:
F. Llorente de Andrés,
C. Chavero,
R. de la Reza,
S. Roca-Fàbrega,
C. Cifuentes
Abstract:
We investigate two topics regarding solar mass FGK-type stars, the lithium rotation connection (LRC) and the existence of the "lithium desert". We determine the minimum critical rotation velocity ($v \sin i$) related with the LRC separating slow from rapid stellar rotators, as being 5 km s$^{-1}$. This value also split different stellar properties. For the first time we explore the behaviour of th…
▽ More
We investigate two topics regarding solar mass FGK-type stars, the lithium rotation connection (LRC) and the existence of the "lithium desert". We determine the minimum critical rotation velocity ($v \sin i$) related with the LRC separating slow from rapid stellar rotators, as being 5 km s$^{-1}$. This value also split different stellar properties. For the first time we explore the behaviour of the LRC for some stellar associations with ages between 45 Myr and 120 Myr. This allows us to study the LRC age dependence at the beginning of the general spin down stage for low mass stars, which starts at $\sim$ 30-40 Myr. We find that each stellar group presents a characteristic minimum lithium (Li) depletion connected to a specific large rotation velocity and that this minimum changes with age. For instance, this minimum changes from $\sim$ 50 km s$^{-1}$ to less than 20 km s$^{-1}$ in 200 Myr. Regarding the lithium desert, it was described as a limited region in the A(Li)-$T_{\rm eff}$ map containing no stars. Using $T_{\rm eff}$ from {\em Gaia} DR2 we detect 30 stars inside and/or near the same box defined originally as the Li desert. Due to their intrinsic $T_{\rm eff}$ errors some of these stars may be inside or outside the box, implying a large probability that the box contains several stars. Considering this last fact the "lithium desert" appears to be more a statistical distribution fluctuation than a real problem.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Emerging trends in metallicity and lithium properties of debris disc stars
Authors:
C. Chavero,
R. de la Reza,
L. Ghezzi,
F. Llorente de Andrés,
C. B. Pereira,
C. Giuppone,
G. Pinzón,
.
Abstract:
Dwarf stars with debris discs and planets appear to be excellent laboratories to study the core accretion theory of planets formation. These systems are however, insufficiently studied. In this paper we present the main metallicity and lithium abundance properties of these stars together with stars with only debris discs and stars with only planets. Stars without detected planets nor discs are als…
▽ More
Dwarf stars with debris discs and planets appear to be excellent laboratories to study the core accretion theory of planets formation. These systems are however, insufficiently studied. In this paper we present the main metallicity and lithium abundance properties of these stars together with stars with only debris discs and stars with only planets. Stars without detected planets nor discs are also considered. The analysed sample is formed by main-sequence FGK field single stars. Apart from the basic stellar parameters, we include the use of dusty discs masses. The main results show for the first time that the dust mass of debris disc stars with planets correlate with metallicity. We confirm that these disc dust masses are related to their central stellar masses. Separately, the masses of stars and those of planets also correlate with metallicity. We conclude that two conditions are necessary to form giant planets: to have a sufficient metallicity and also a sufficient protoplanetary mass of gas and dust. The debris discs masses of stars without giant planets do not correlate with metallicity, because they do not fulfil these two conditions. Concerning lithium, by adopting a stellar model for lithium depletion based on a strong interaction between the star and a protoplanetary disc, we found that in agreement with the model predictions, observations indicate that the main lithium depletion occurs during this initial protoplanetary evolution stage. We show that the ultimately lithium depletion is independent of the presence or absence of planets and appears to be only age dependent.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
