-
The polarisation properties of the HD 181327 debris ring. Evidence for sub-micron particles from scattered light observations
Authors:
Julien Milli,
Elodie Choquet,
Ryo Tazaki,
François Ménard,
Jean-Charles Augereau,
Johan Olofsson,
Philippe Thébault,
Olivier Poch,
Anny-Chantal Levasseur-Regourd,
Jérémie Lasue,
Jean-Baptiste Renard,
Edith Hadamcik,
Clément Baruteau,
Hans Martin Schmid,
Natalia Engler,
Rob G. van Holstein,
Evgenij Zubko,
Anne-Marie Lagrange,
Sebastian Marino,
Chirstophe Pinte,
Carsten Dominik,
Anthony Boccaletti,
Maud Langlois,
Alice Zurlo,
Célia Desgrange
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Polarisation is a powerful remote-sensing tool to study the nature of particles scattering the starlight. It is widely used to characterise interplanetary dust particles in the Solar System and increasingly employed to investigate extrasolar dust in debris discs' systems. We aim to measure the scattering properties of the dust from the debris ring around HD 181327 at near-infrared wavelengths. We…
▽ More
Polarisation is a powerful remote-sensing tool to study the nature of particles scattering the starlight. It is widely used to characterise interplanetary dust particles in the Solar System and increasingly employed to investigate extrasolar dust in debris discs' systems. We aim to measure the scattering properties of the dust from the debris ring around HD 181327 at near-infrared wavelengths. We obtained high-contrast polarimetric images of HD 181327 in the H band with the SPHERE / IRDIS instrument on the Very Large Telescope (ESO). We complemented them with archival data from HST / NICMOS in the F110W filter reprocessed in the context of the Archival Legacy Investigations of Circumstellar Environments (ALICE) project. We developed a combined forward-modelling framework to simultaneously retrieve the scattering phase function in polarisation and intensity. We detected the debris disc around HD 181327 in polarised light and total intensity. We measured the scattering phase function and the degree of linear polarisation of the dust at 1.6 micron in the birth ring. The maximum polarisation is 23.6% +/- 2.6% and occurs between a scattering angle of 70 deg and 82 deg. We show that compact spherical particles made of a highly refractive and relatively absorbing material in a differential power-law size distribution of exponent $-3.5$ can simultaneously reproduce the polarimetric and total intensity scattering properties of the dust. This type of material cannot be obtained with a mixture of silicates, amorphous carbon, water ice, and porosity, and requires a more refracting component such as iron-bearing minerals. We reveal a striking analogy between the near-infrared polarisation of comets and that of HD 181327. The methodology developed here combining VLT/SPHERE and HST/NICMOS may be applicable in the future to combine the polarimetric capabilities of SPHERE with the sensitivity of JWST.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Stumbling over planetary building blocks: AU Microscopii as an example of the challenge of retrieving debris-disk dust properties
Authors:
Jessica A. Arnold,
Alycia J. Weinberger,
Gorden Videen,
Evgenij S. Zubko
Abstract:
We explore whether assumptions about dust grain shape affect resulting estimates of the composition and grain size distribution of the AU Microscopii (AU Mic) debris disk from scattered light data collected by Lomax et al. (2018). The near edge-on orientation of the AU Mic debris disk makes it ideal for studying the effect of the scattering phase function (SPF) on the measured flux ratios as a fun…
▽ More
We explore whether assumptions about dust grain shape affect resulting estimates of the composition and grain size distribution of the AU Microscopii (AU Mic) debris disk from scattered light data collected by Lomax et al. (2018). The near edge-on orientation of the AU Mic debris disk makes it ideal for studying the effect of the scattering phase function (SPF) on the measured flux ratios as a function of wavelength and projected distance. Previous efforts to model the AU Mic debris disk have invoked a variety of dust grain compositions and explored the effect of porosity, but did not undertake a systematic effort to explore a full range of size distributions and compositions to understand possible degeneracies in fitting the data. The degree to which modelling dust grains with more realistic shapes compounds these degeneracies has also not previously been explored. We find differences in the grain properties retrieved depending on the grain shape model used. We also present here our calculations of porous grains of size parameters x = 0.1 to 48 and complex refractive indices (m = n+ik) ranging from n = 1.1 to 2.43 and k = 0 to 1.0, covering multiple compositions at visible and near infrared wavelengths such as ice, silicates, amorphous carbon, and tholins.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Comet C/2011 J2 (LINEAR): Photometry and Stellar transit
Authors:
Oleksandr Ivanova,
Serhi Borysenko,
Evgenij Zubko,
Zuzana Seman Krišandová,
Ján Svoreň,
Aleksandr Baransky,
Maksim Gabdeev
Abstract:
We present results of two-year photometric monitoring of Comet C/2011 J2 (LINEAR) that spans the time period from February 2013 through December 2014, before and after perihelion passage. The observations were conducted with broadband R filter. Analysis of observations of Comet C/2011 J2 (LINEAR) allows estimating the nucleus radius as function of geometric albedo and phase-darkening coefficient.…
▽ More
We present results of two-year photometric monitoring of Comet C/2011 J2 (LINEAR) that spans the time period from February 2013 through December 2014, before and after perihelion passage. The observations were conducted with broadband R filter. Analysis of observations of Comet C/2011 J2 (LINEAR) allows estimating the nucleus radius as function of geometric albedo and phase-darkening coefficient. Furthermore, our observations showed split of the comet. Fragment (B) additional to the primary C/2011 J2 nucleus was unambiguously detected; relative velocity is estimated to be near 0.17 ''/day. We derive the Afrho parameter and estimate the dust production rate in Comet C/2011 J2 (LINEAR) over the entire run of observations. We found a noticeable increase in Afrho parameter between September 18, 2014 and November 5, 2014, epoch when the nucleus presumably got split. On September 28, 2014, we observed a transit of the 16-magnitude star (USNO-A2 1275-18299027) near nucleus of the Comet C/2011 J2 (LINEAR). We retrieve the optical depth of the coma 0.034. The filling factor f that corresponds to such optical depth is in good quantitative agreement with the value that can be derived from the Afrho parameter under reasonable assumption on geometric albedo of cometary dust.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Imaging polarimetry and photometry of comet 21P/Giacobini-Zinner
Authors:
E. Chornaya E. Zubko,
I. Luk'yanyk,
A. Kochergin,
M. Zheltobryukhov,
O. V. Ivanova,
G. Kornienko,
A. Matkin,
A. Baransky,
I. E. Molotov,
V. S. Sharoshchenko,
G. Videen
Abstract:
We report results of polarimetric observations of comet 21P/Giacobini-Zinner made at phase angles, α=76-78 deg, between 10 and 17 of September 2018, and compare them with previous measurements. We find significant variations in the polarimetric signals that appear consistent with those reported previously. These variations and subsequent modeling suggest that the particles in the coma are replenis…
▽ More
We report results of polarimetric observations of comet 21P/Giacobini-Zinner made at phase angles, α=76-78 deg, between 10 and 17 of September 2018, and compare them with previous measurements. We find significant variations in the polarimetric signals that appear consistent with those reported previously. These variations and subsequent modeling suggest that the particles in the coma are replenished within a period of approximately one day. This period is significantly shorter for highly absorbing carbonaceous particles than for non-absorbing Mg-rich silicate particles. Such a difference in the relative abundances of these components can lead to variations in the polarization response of the coma. The strong positive polarization in the subsolar direction suggests a large relative abundance of carbonaceous material, which may be an indicator of jet-type activity.
△ Less
Submitted 24 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Monitoring polarization in comet 46P/Wirtanen
Authors:
M. Zheltobryukhov,
E. Zubko,
E. Chornaya,
I. Luk'yanyk,
O. Ivanova,
A. Kochergin,
G. Kornienko,
D. Mkrtichian,
S. Poshyachinda,
I. E. Molotov,
S. S. Kim,
G. Videen
Abstract:
We measure the degree of linear polarization of comet 46P/Wirtanen during two months, embracing the perihelion passage in 2018 December with phase angles ranging from α=18.1 to 46.4 deg. The polarimetric response PQ obtained resembles what was previously found in comet C/1975 V1 (West). This suggests 46P/Wirtanen belongs to a group of comets with high maximum positive polarization. We conducted BV…
▽ More
We measure the degree of linear polarization of comet 46P/Wirtanen during two months, embracing the perihelion passage in 2018 December with phase angles ranging from α=18.1 to 46.4 deg. The polarimetric response PQ obtained resembles what was previously found in comet C/1975 V1 (West). This suggests 46P/Wirtanen belongs to a group of comets with high maximum positive polarization. We conducted BVRI photometry of 46P and found either neutral or blue colour of its dust which is in good accordance with measurements of C/1975 V1 (West). While aperture-average polarimetry of 46P/Wirtanen reveals a nearly zero polarization PQ at the lowest phase angle α = 18.1 deg, simultaneous imaging polarimetry suggests that the negative polarization (PQ<0) arises in a region of within 5000 km of the nucleus, where the negative polarization could be as strong as PQ=-(1.44 +/- 0.15) percent. This observation suggests the existence of the circumnucleus halo and that the coma is populated by at least two types of dust particles. One of those reveals a low positive polarization at side scattering and high negative polarization near backscattering. Both polarimetric features are simultaneously produced by weakly absorbing Mg-rich silicate particles. Another type of dust produces solely positive polarization that could be attributed to carbonaceous particles. This composition of 46P/Wirtanen coma appears to be similar with what was previously found in comet C/1975 V1 (West).
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Extremely low linear polarization of comet C/2018 V1 (Machholz-Fujikawa-Iwamoto)
Authors:
E. Zubko,
E. Chornaya,
M. Zheltobryukhov,
A. Matkin,
O. V. Ivanova,
D. Bodewits,
A. Kochergin,
G. Kornienko,
I. Luk'yanyk,
D. C. Hines,
G. Videen
Abstract:
We measured the degree of linear polarization P of comet C/2018 V1 (Machholz-Fujikawa-Iwamoto) with the broadband Johnson V filter in mid-November of 2018. Within a radius of \r{ho}=17,000 km of the inner coma, we detected an extremely low linear polarization at phase angles from 83 to 91.2 degree and constrained the polarization maximum to Pmax = (6.8 +/- 1.8)%. This is the lowest Pmax ever measu…
▽ More
We measured the degree of linear polarization P of comet C/2018 V1 (Machholz-Fujikawa-Iwamoto) with the broadband Johnson V filter in mid-November of 2018. Within a radius of \r{ho}=17,000 km of the inner coma, we detected an extremely low linear polarization at phase angles from 83 to 91.2 degree and constrained the polarization maximum to Pmax = (6.8 +/- 1.8)%. This is the lowest Pmax ever measured in a comet. Using model agglomerated debris particles, we reproduced the polarimetric response of comet C/2018 V1. Four retrieved refractive indices closely match what was experimentally found in Mg-rich silicates with little or no iron content. Moreover, the size distribution of the agglomerated debris particles appears in good quantitative agreement with the in situ findings of comet 1P/Halley. The dust model of polarization of comet C/2018 V1 suggests a strongly negative polarization with amplitude |Pmin| = 5%-7%; whereas, an interpretation based on gaseous emission requires no negative polarization at small phase angles. This dramatic difference could be used to discriminate gaseous-emission and dust explanations in low-Pmax comets in future.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Comet 29P/Schwassmann-Wachmann 1 dust environment from photometric observation at the SOAR Telescope
Authors:
E. Picazzio,
I. V. Luk'yanyk,
O. V. Ivanova,
E. Zubko,
O. Cavichia,
G. Videen,
S. M. Andrievsky
Abstract:
We report photometric observations of comet 29P/Schwassmann-Wachmann 1 made on August 12, 2016 with the broadband B, V, R and I filters and the SOAR 4.1-meter telescope (Chile). We find the comet active at that time. Enhanced images obtained in all filters reveal three radial features in the 29P/ Schwassmann-Wachmann 1 coma, regardless of the image-processing algorithm. Using a high-resolution spe…
▽ More
We report photometric observations of comet 29P/Schwassmann-Wachmann 1 made on August 12, 2016 with the broadband B, V, R and I filters and the SOAR 4.1-meter telescope (Chile). We find the comet active at that time. Enhanced images obtained in all filters reveal three radial features in the 29P/ Schwassmann-Wachmann 1 coma, regardless of the image-processing algorithm. Using a high-resolution spectrum of comet 29P/Schwassmann-Wachmann 1 reported by Ivanova et al. (2018) on the same date, we estimate the relative contribution of the gaseous emission and the continuum to the total response measured with our broadband B and V filters. The gaseous-emission contribution appears to be very small 2.5%. We compute the dust production Af\r{ho} in 29P/ Schwassmann-Wachmann 1 for the four filters and find its growth with the wavelength, from 3,393 cm in the B filter to 8,561 cm in the I filter. We model the color slope of dust in Comet 29P/Schwassmann-Wachmann 1 using agglomerated debris particles. Simultaneous analysis of the color slope in the B-R and R-I pairs suggests a single dominant chemical species of 29P/Schwassmann-Wachmann 1 dust particles consisting of Fe-Mg silicates and obeying a power-law size distribution with index n=2.55. This conclusion is consistent with the previous thermal-emission study of 29P/Schwassmann-Wachmann 1.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
The case for a multi-channel polarization sensitive LIDAR for investigation of insolation-driven ices and atmospheres
Authors:
Adrian J. Brown,
Gorden Videen,
Evgenij Zubko,
Nicholas Heavens,
Nicole-Jeanne Schlegel,
Patricio Becerra,
Young-Jun Choi,
Colin R. Meyer,
Tanya N. Harrison,
Paul Hayne,
Rachel W. Obbard,
Tim Michaels,
Michael J. Wolff,
Scott Guzewich,
Yongxiang Hu,
Claire Newman,
Christian J. Grund,
Chae Kyung Sim,
Peter B. Buhler,
Margaret E. Landis,
Timothy J. Stubbs,
Aymeric Spiga,
Devanshu Jha
Abstract:
All LIDAR instruments are not the same, and advancement of LIDAR technology requires an ongoing interest and demand from the community to foster further development of the required components. The purpose of this paper is to make the community aware of the need for further technical development, and the potential payoff of investing experimental time, money and thought into the next generation of…
▽ More
All LIDAR instruments are not the same, and advancement of LIDAR technology requires an ongoing interest and demand from the community to foster further development of the required components. The purpose of this paper is to make the community aware of the need for further technical development, and the potential payoff of investing experimental time, money and thought into the next generation of LIDARs.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Rapid variations of dust colour in comet 41P/Tuttle-Giacobini-Kresák
Authors:
Igor Luk'yanyk,
Evgenij Zubko,
Marek Husárik,
Oleksandra Ivanova,
Ján Svoreň,
Anton Kochergin,
Alexandr Baransky,
Gorden Videen
Abstract:
We monitor the inner coma of comet 41P/Tuttle-Giacobini-Kresák searching for variations of its colour. Fast changes in colour of the comet 41P/Tuttle-Giacobini-Kresák provide important clues for better understanding of the microphysical properties of its dust. Using the 61-cm and 70-cm telescopes we measured the apparent magnitude of the comet with the V and R Johnson-Cousins filters from January…
▽ More
We monitor the inner coma of comet 41P/Tuttle-Giacobini-Kresák searching for variations of its colour. Fast changes in colour of the comet 41P/Tuttle-Giacobini-Kresák provide important clues for better understanding of the microphysical properties of its dust. Using the 61-cm and 70-cm telescopes we measured the apparent magnitude of the comet with the V and R Johnson-Cousins filters from January 29 until April 25 of 2017. The inner coma ({\sim} 2000 km) reveals fast and significant variations of colour. The most significant change was found between March 3 and 4 of 2017, when it changed from blue with a colour slope S {\approx}(-10.15 {\pm} 3.43){\%} per 0.1 μm to red with S {\approx} (16.48 {\pm} 4.27){\%} per 0.1 μm. This finding appears in good accordance with what was previously reported by Ivanova et al. (2017) for long-period comet C/2013 UQ4 (Catalina), suggesting that fast and significant variations of colour of dust could be a common feature of short- and long-period comets. We model observations of comet 41P/Tuttle-Giacobini-Kresák using the agglomerated debris particles and conclude that its inner coma consists of a mixture of at least two types of particles made of Mg-rich silicates and organics or Mg-Fe silicates.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
The effect of dust composition and shape on radiation-pressure forces and blowout sizes of particles in debris disks
Authors:
Jessica A. Arnold,
Alycia J. Weinberger,
Gorden Videen,
Evgenij S. Zubko
Abstract:
The light scattered from dust grains in debris disks is typically modeled as compact spheres using Lorenz-Mie theory or as porous spheres by incorporating an effective medium theory. In this work we examine the effect of incorporating a more realistic particle morphology on estimated radiation-pressure blowout sizes. To calculate the scattering and absorption cross sections of irregularly shaped d…
▽ More
The light scattered from dust grains in debris disks is typically modeled as compact spheres using Lorenz-Mie theory or as porous spheres by incorporating an effective medium theory. In this work we examine the effect of incorporating a more realistic particle morphology on estimated radiation-pressure blowout sizes. To calculate the scattering and absorption cross sections of irregularly shaped dust grains, we use the discrete dipole approximation. These cross sections are necessary to calculate the $β$-ratio, which determines whether dust grains can remain gravitationally bound to their star. We calculate blowout sizes for a range of stellar spectral types corresponding with stars known to host debris disks. As with compact spheres, more luminous stars blow out larger irregularly shaped dust grains. We also find that dust grain composition influences blowout size such that absorptive grains are more readily removed from the disk. Moreover, the difference between blowout sizes calculated assuming spherical particles versus particle morphologies more representative of real dust particles is compositionally dependent as well, with blowout size estimates diverging further for transparent grains. We find that the blowout sizes calculated have a strong dependence on the particle model used, with differences in the blowout size calculated being as large as an order of magnitude for particles of similar porosities.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Color variations of Comet C/2013 UQ4 (Catalina)
Authors:
Oleksandra Ivanova,
Evgenij Zubko,
Gorden Videen,
Michael Mommert,
Joseph L. Hora,
Zuzana Seman Krišandová,
Ján Svoreň,
Artyom Novichonok,
Serhii Borysenko,
Olena Shubina
Abstract:
We report observations of color in the inner coma of Comet C/2013 UQ4 (Catalina) with the broadband B and R filters. We find significant temporal variations of the color slope, ranging from -12.67 $\pm$ 8.16 \% per 0.1~$μ$m up to $35.09 \pm 11.7$ \% per 0.1~$μ$m.It is significant that the comet changes color from red to blue over only a two-day period. Such dispersion cannot be characterized with…
▽ More
We report observations of color in the inner coma of Comet C/2013 UQ4 (Catalina) with the broadband B and R filters. We find significant temporal variations of the color slope, ranging from -12.67 $\pm$ 8.16 \% per 0.1~$μ$m up to $35.09 \pm 11.7$ \% per 0.1~$μ$m.It is significant that the comet changes color from red to blue over only a two-day period. Such dispersion cannot be characterized with an average color slope. We also observe Comet C/2013 UQ4 (Catalina) in infrared using Spitzer and find no significant CO/CO$_{2}$ gaseous species in its coma. Therefore, we classify Comet C/2013 UQ4 (Catalina) as a dust-rich comet and attribute the measured color slope to its dust. We analyze the color slope using the model of agglomerated debris particles and conclude that the C/2013 UQ4 coma was chemically heterogeneous, consisting of at least two components. The first component producing the bluest color is consistent with Mg-rich silicates. There are three different options for the second component producing the reddest color. This color is consistent with either Mg-Fe silicates, kerogen type II, or organic matter processed with a low dose of UV radiation.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Hubble Space Telescope Pre-Perihelion ACS/WFC Imaging Polarimetry of Comet ISON (C/2012 S1) at 3.81 AU
Authors:
Dean C. Hines,
Gorden Videen,
Evgenij Zubko,
Karri Muinonen,
Yuriy Shkuratov,
Vadim G. Kaydash,
Matthew M. Knight,
Michael L. Sitko,
Carey M. Lisse,
Max Mutchler,
Derek Hammer,
Padmavati A. Yanamandra-Fisher
Abstract:
We present polarization images of Comet ISON (C/2012 S1) taken with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) on UTC 2013 May 8 (rh = 3.81 AU, Delta = 4.34 AU), when the phase angle was alpha = 12.16 degrees. This phase angle is approximately centered in the negative polarization branch for cometary dust. The region beyond 1000 km from the nucleus shows a negative polarization amplitude of p% -1.6%. Within…
▽ More
We present polarization images of Comet ISON (C/2012 S1) taken with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) on UTC 2013 May 8 (rh = 3.81 AU, Delta = 4.34 AU), when the phase angle was alpha = 12.16 degrees. This phase angle is approximately centered in the negative polarization branch for cometary dust. The region beyond 1000 km from the nucleus shows a negative polarization amplitude of p% -1.6%. Within 1000 km of the nucleus, the polarization position angle rotates to be approximately perpendicular to the scattering plane, with an amplitude p% +2.5%. Such positive polarization has been observed previously as a characteristic feature of cometary jets, and we show that Comet ISON does indeed harbor a jet-like feature. These HST observations of Comet ISON represent the first visible light, imaging polarimetry with sub-arcsecond spatial resolution of a Nearly Isotropic Comet (NIC) beyond 3.8 AU from the Sun at a small phase angle. The observations provide an early glimpse of the properties of the cometary dust preserved in this Oort-cloud comet.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Comet 9P/Tempel 1: Interpretation with the Deep Impact Results
Authors:
Satoru Yamamoto,
Hiroshi Kimura,
Evgenij Zubko,
Hiroshi Kobayashi,
Koji Wada,
Masateru Ishiguro,
Takafumi Matsui
Abstract:
According to our common understandings, the original surface of a short-period comet nucleus has been lost by sublimation processes during its close approaches to the Sun. Sublimation results in the formation of a dust mantle on the retreated surface and in chemical differentiation of ices over tens or hundreds of meters below the mantle. In the course of NASA's Deep Impact mission, optical and…
▽ More
According to our common understandings, the original surface of a short-period comet nucleus has been lost by sublimation processes during its close approaches to the Sun. Sublimation results in the formation of a dust mantle on the retreated surface and in chemical differentiation of ices over tens or hundreds of meters below the mantle. In the course of NASA's Deep Impact mission, optical and infrared imaging observations of the ejecta plume were conducted by several researchers, but their interpretations of the data came as a big surprise: (1) The nucleus of comet 9P/Tempel 1 is free of a dust mantle, but maintains its pristine crust of submicron-sized carbonaceous grains; (2) Primordial materials are accessible already at a depth of several tens of cm with abundant silicate grains of submicrometer sizes. In this study, we demonstrate that a standard model of cometary nuclei explains well available observational data: (1) A dust mantle with a thickness of ~1-2 m builds up on the surface, where compact aggregates larger than tens of micrometers dominate; (2) Large fluffy aggregates are embedded in chemically differentiated layers as well as in the deepest part of the nucleus with primordial materials. We conclude that the Deep Impact results do not need any peculiar view of a comet nucleus.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2008; v1 submitted 11 December, 2007;
originally announced December 2007.
