-
Seven white dwarfs with circumstellar gas discs II: Tracing the composition of exoplanetary building blocks
Authors:
L. K. Rogers,
A. Bonsor,
S. Xu,
A. M. Buchan,
P. Dufour,
B. L. Klein,
S. Hodgkin,
M. Kissler-Patig,
C. Melis,
C. Walton,
A. Weinberger
Abstract:
This second paper presents an in-depth analysis of the composition of the planetary material that has been accreted onto seven white dwarfs with circumstellar dust and gas emission discs with abundances reported in Paper I. The white dwarfs are accreting planetary bodies with a wide range of oxygen, carbon, and sulfur volatile contents, including one white dwarf that shows the most enhanced sulfur…
▽ More
This second paper presents an in-depth analysis of the composition of the planetary material that has been accreted onto seven white dwarfs with circumstellar dust and gas emission discs with abundances reported in Paper I. The white dwarfs are accreting planetary bodies with a wide range of oxygen, carbon, and sulfur volatile contents, including one white dwarf that shows the most enhanced sulfur abundance seen to date. Three white dwarfs show tentative evidence (2-3$σ$) of accreting oxygen-rich material, potentially from water-rich bodies, whilst two others are accreting dry, rocky material. One white dwarf is accreting a mantle-rich fragment of a larger differentiated body, whilst two white dwarfs show an enhancement in their iron abundance and could be accreting core-rich fragments. Whilst most planetary material accreted by white dwarfs display chondritic or bulk Earth-like compositions, these observations demonstrate that core-mantle differentiation, disruptive collisions, and the accretion of core-mantle differentiated material are important. Less than one percent of polluted white dwarfs host both observable circumstellar gas and dust. It is unknown whether these systems are experiencing an early phase in the disruption and accretion of planetary bodies, or alternatively if they are accreting larger planetary bodies. From this work there is no substantial evidence for significant differences in the accreted refractory abundance ratios for those white dwarfs with or without circumstellar gas, but there is tentative evidence for those with circumstellar gas discs to be accreting more water rich material which may suggest that volatiles accrete earlier in a gas-rich phase.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Cosmic dust fertilization of glacial prebiotic chemistry on early Earth
Authors:
Craig R. Walton,
Jessica K. Rigley,
Alexander Lipp,
Robert Law,
Martin D. Suttle,
Maria Schonbachler,
Mark Wyatt,
Oliver Shorttle
Abstract:
Earth's surface is deficient in available forms of many elements considered limiting for prebiotic chemistry. In contrast, many extraterrestrial rocky objects are rich in these same elements. Limiting prebiotic ingredients may, therefore, have been delivered by exogenous material; however, the mechanisms by which exogeneous material may be reliably and non-destructively supplied to a planetary sur…
▽ More
Earth's surface is deficient in available forms of many elements considered limiting for prebiotic chemistry. In contrast, many extraterrestrial rocky objects are rich in these same elements. Limiting prebiotic ingredients may, therefore, have been delivered by exogenous material; however, the mechanisms by which exogeneous material may be reliably and non-destructively supplied to a planetary surface remains unclear. Today, the flux of extraterrestrial matter to Earth is dominated by fine-grained cosmic dust. Although this material is rarely discussed in a prebiotic context due to its delivery over a large surface area, concentrated cosmic dust deposits are known to form on Earth today due to the action of sedimentary processes. Here we combine empirical constraints on dust sedimentation with dynamical simulations of dust formation and planetary accretion to show that localized sedimentary deposits of cosmic dust could have accumulated in arid environments on early Earth, in particular glacial settings that today produce cryoconite sediments. Our results challenge the widely held assumption that cosmic dust is incapable of fertilizing prebiotic chemistry. Cosmic dust deposits may have plausibly formed on early Earth and acted to fertilize prebiotic chemistry.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Phanerozoic biological reworking of the continental carbonate rock reservoir
Authors:
Craig R. Walton,
Oliver Shorttle
Abstract:
Understanding the co-evolution of complex life with Earth's geology is an enduring challenge. The rock record evidences remarkable correlations between changes in biology and the wider Earth system, yet cause and effect remain unclear. Here, we link the evolutionary history of eukaryotes with the rise and fall of carbonate rock fraction within continental crust - a key variable in controlling the…
▽ More
Understanding the co-evolution of complex life with Earth's geology is an enduring challenge. The rock record evidences remarkable correlations between changes in biology and the wider Earth system, yet cause and effect remain unclear. Here, we link the evolutionary history of eukaryotes with the rise and fall of carbonate rock fraction within continental crust - a key variable in controlling the efficiency of carbon drawdown during weathering, solid Earth degassing rates, and ultimately nutrient supply to life. We use geospatial database analyses to demonstrate a strongly non-linear growth and then collapse in Earth's continental crust carbonate reservoir. Biomineralisers reshaped Earth's surface in their image; armouring continental margins with carbonate platforms, such that the continental carbonate reservoir increased in size by 5-fold in under 100 Myr after the Cambrian Radiation of animal life. This Paleozoic carbonate revolution represents among the most dramatic crustal evolutionary events in Earth's history. The Permo-Triassic extinction event coupled to the rise of open ocean calcifiers initiated a steady decline in continental crustal carbonate content; one that still continues today, which unabated would produce Precambrian-style crustal carbonate distributions in around 500-1000 Myr. Our results demonstrate strongly non-linear crustal evolution after the rise of the complex Phanerozoic biosphere. This outcome suggests that complex life may generate unique biogeochemical trajectories on otherwise geologically similar worlds, posing a new challenge in the hunt for life beyond Earth.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Ancient and recent collisions revealed by phosphate minerals in the Chelyabinsk meteorite
Authors:
Craig R. Walton,
Oliver Shorttle,
Sen Hu,
Auriol S. P. Rae,
Ji Jianglong,
Ana Černok,
Helen Williams,
Yu Liu,
Guoqiang Tang,
Qiuli Li,
Mahesh Anand
Abstract:
The collision history of asteroids is an important archive of inner Solar System evolution. Evidence for these collisions is brought to Earth by meteorites, which can preserve impact-reset radioisotope mineral ages. However, as meteorites often preserve numerous mineral ages, their interpretation is controversial. Here, we combine analysis of phosphate U-Pb ages and mineral microtextures to constr…
▽ More
The collision history of asteroids is an important archive of inner Solar System evolution. Evidence for these collisions is brought to Earth by meteorites, which can preserve impact-reset radioisotope mineral ages. However, as meteorites often preserve numerous mineral ages, their interpretation is controversial. Here, we combine analysis of phosphate U-Pb ages and mineral microtextures to construct a collision history for the highly shocked Chelyabinsk meteorite. We show that phosphate U-Pb ages in the meteorite are independent of thermal history at macro-to-microscales, correlating instead with phosphate microtexture. Isotopic data from pristine phosphate domains is largely concordant, whereas fracture-damaged domains universally display discordance. Combining both populations best constrains upper (4,473 +/- 11 Ma) and lower intercept (-9 +/- 55 Ma, i.e., within error of the present day) U-Pb ages for Chelyabinsk phosphates. We conclude that all phosphate U-Pb ages were completely reset during an ancient high energy collision. Fracture-damaged phosphate domains experienced further Pb-loss during mild collisional heating in the geologically recent past, and must be targeted to properly constrain a lower intercept age. Targeting textural sub-populations of phosphate grains can significantly improve the calculation and interpretation of U-Pb ages, permitting more robust reconstruction of both ancient and recent asteroidal collision histories.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2022; v1 submitted 11 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Microtextures in the Chelyabinsk impact breccia reveal the history of Phosphorus-Olivine-Assemblages in chondrites
Authors:
Craig R. Walton,
Ioannis Baziotis,
Ana Černok,
Oliver Shorttle,
Paul D. Asimow,
Ludovic Ferrière,
Mahesh Anand
Abstract:
The geochemistry and textural associations of chondritic phosphate minerals can provide insights into the geological histories of parental asteroids, but the processes governing their formation and deformation remain poorly constrained. Here, we present a quantitative assessment of phosphorus-bearing mineral textures in the three variously-shocked lithologies (light, dark, and melt) of the Chelyab…
▽ More
The geochemistry and textural associations of chondritic phosphate minerals can provide insights into the geological histories of parental asteroids, but the processes governing their formation and deformation remain poorly constrained. Here, we present a quantitative assessment of phosphorus-bearing mineral textures in the three variously-shocked lithologies (light, dark, and melt) of the Chelyabinsk (LL5) ordinary chondrite using scanning electron microscope, electron microprobe, cathodoluminescence, and electron backscatter diffraction techniques. Phase associations, microtextures, and microstructures of phosphates are extremely variable within and between the differently-shocked lithologies investigated in the Chelyabinsk meteorite. We observe continuously strained as well as recrystallized, strain-free phosphate populations. Recrystallized grains (with strain-free subdomains) are present only in the more intensely shocked dark lithology, indicating that phosphate growth in Chelyabinsk predates the development of primary shock-metamorphic textures. This disruption event is also recorded by complete melting of portions of the meteorite to produce the shock-melt lithology, which contains a population of phosphorus-rich olivine grains. We interpret the textures and phase associations of Chelyabinsk to have resulted from initial phosphate growth via metasomatic olivine replacement, followed by major deformation during an early shock-melting impact and a subsequent minor shock event. This minor event appears to have generated a sub-population of phosphates that display patchy CL textures, in both the light and dark lithology. Finally, we propose a new classification scheme to describe various types of Phosphorus-Olivine-Assemblages (Type I-III POAs), which can be used to classify shock metamorphic events and define the associated physicochemical processes.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2021; v1 submitted 21 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
