-
Observational evidence of fractality in the large-scale distribution of galaxies
Authors:
T. Canavesi,
T. E. Tapia
Abstract:
Using a sample of 133 991 galaxies distributed in the sky region $100^{\circ} <α<270^{\circ}$ and $7^{\circ}<δ<65^{\circ}$, extracted from the SDSS NASA/AMES Value Added Galaxy Catalog (AMES-VAGC), we estimate the fractal dimension using two different methods. First, using an algorithm to estimate the correlation dimension. The second method, in a novel approach, creates a graph from the data and…
▽ More
Using a sample of 133 991 galaxies distributed in the sky region $100^{\circ} <α<270^{\circ}$ and $7^{\circ}<δ<65^{\circ}$, extracted from the SDSS NASA/AMES Value Added Galaxy Catalog (AMES-VAGC), we estimate the fractal dimension using two different methods. First, using an algorithm to estimate the correlation dimension. The second method, in a novel approach, creates a graph from the data and estimates the graph dimension purely from connectivity information. In both methods we found a dimension $D\approx 2$ in scales below 20 Mpc, which agrees with previous works. This result shows the non-homogeneity of galaxies distribution at certain scales.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2021; v1 submitted 17 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Formation of S0 galaxies through mergers. Morphological properties: tidal relics, lenses, ovals, and other inner components
Authors:
M. C. Eliche-Moral,
C. Rodriguez-Perez,
A. Borlaff,
M. Querejeta,
T. Tapia
Abstract:
Major mergers are popularly considered too destructive to produce the relaxed regular structures and the morphological inner components (ICs) usually observed in lenticular (S0) galaxies. We aim to test if major mergers can produce remnants with realistic S0 morphologies. We have selected a sample of relaxed discy remnants resulting from the dissipative merger simulations of the GalMer database an…
▽ More
Major mergers are popularly considered too destructive to produce the relaxed regular structures and the morphological inner components (ICs) usually observed in lenticular (S0) galaxies. We aim to test if major mergers can produce remnants with realistic S0 morphologies. We have selected a sample of relaxed discy remnants resulting from the dissipative merger simulations of the GalMer database and derived their properties mimicking the typical conditions of current observational data. We compare their global morphologies, visual components, and merger relics in mock photometric images with their real counterparts. Only $\sim$1-2 Gyr after the full merger, we find that: 1) many remnants (67 major and 29 minor events) present relaxed structures and typical S0 or E/S0 morphologies, for a wide variety of orbits and even in gas-poor cases. 2) Contrary to popular expectations, most of them do not exhibit any morphological traces of their past merger origin under typical observing conditions and at distances as nearby as 30 Mpc. 3) The merger relics are more persistent in minor mergers than in major ones for similar relaxing time periods. 4) No major-merger S0-like remnant develops a significant bar. 5) Nearly 58% of the major-merger S0 remnants host visually detectable ICs, such as embedded inner discs, rings, pseudo-rings, inner spirals, nuclear bars, and compact sources, very frequent in real S0s too. 6) All remnants contain a lens or oval, identically ubiquitous in local S0s. 7) These lenses and ovals do not come from bar dilution in major merger cases, but are associated with stellar halos or embedded inner discs instead (thick or thin). We conclude that the relaxed morphologies, lenses, ovals, and other ICs of real S0s do not necessarily come from internal secular evolution, gas infall or environmental mechanisms, as traditionally assumed, but they can result from major mergers as well.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2018; v1 submitted 15 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
The intrinsic shape of bulges in the CALIFA survey
Authors:
L. Costantin,
J. Méndez-Abreu,
E. M. Corsini,
M. C. Eliche-Moral,
T. Tapia,
L. Morelli,
E. Dalla Bontà,
A. Pizzella
Abstract:
The intrinsic shape of galactic bulges in nearby galaxies provides crucial information to separate bulge types. We intended to derive accurate constraints to the intrinsic shape of bulges to provide new clues on their formation mechanisms and set new limitations for future simulations. We retrieved the intrinsic shape of a sample of CALIFA bulges using a statistical approach. Taking advantage of G…
▽ More
The intrinsic shape of galactic bulges in nearby galaxies provides crucial information to separate bulge types. We intended to derive accurate constraints to the intrinsic shape of bulges to provide new clues on their formation mechanisms and set new limitations for future simulations. We retrieved the intrinsic shape of a sample of CALIFA bulges using a statistical approach. Taking advantage of GalMer numerical simulations of binary mergers we estimated the reliability of the procedure. Analyzing the $i$-band mock images of resulting lenticular remnants, we studied the intrinsic shape of their bulges at different galaxy inclinations. Finally, we introduced a new ($B/A$, $C/A$) diagram to analyze possible correlations between the intrinsic shape and the properties of bulges. We tested the method on simulated lenticular remnants, finding that for galaxies with inclinations $25^{\circ} < θ< 65^{\circ}$ we can safely derive the intrinsic shape of their bulges. We found that our CALIFA bulges tend to be nearly oblate systems (66%), with a smaller fraction of prolate spheroids (19%) and triaxial ellipsoids (15%). The majority of triaxial bulges are in barred galaxies (75%). Moreover, we found that bulges with low Sérsic indices or in galaxies with low bulge-to-total luminosity ratios form a heterogeneous class of objects; additionally, also bulges in late-type galaxies or in less massive galaxies have no preference in being oblate, prolate, or triaxial. On the contrary, bulges with high Sérsic index, in early-type galaxies, or in more massive galaxies are mostly oblate systems. We concluded that various evolutionary pathways may coexist in galaxies, with merging events and dissipative collapse being the main mechanisms driving the formation of the most massive oblate bulges and bar evolution reshaping the less massive triaxial bulges.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Formation of S0 galaxies through mergers. Evolution in the Tully-Fisher relation since $z\sim1$
Authors:
Trinidad Tapia,
M. Carmen Eliche-Moral,
Héctor Aceves,
Cristina Rodríguez-Pérez,
Alejandro Borlaff,
Miguel Querejeta
Abstract:
(Abridged version) We explore whether a scenario that combines an origin by mergers at $z\sim$1.8-1.5 with a subsequent passive evolution of the resulting S0 remnants since $z \sim$0.8-1 is compatible with observational data of S0s in the Tully-Fisher relation (TFR). We studied a set of major and minor merger experiments from the GalMer database that generate massive S0 remnants. We analysed the l…
▽ More
(Abridged version) We explore whether a scenario that combines an origin by mergers at $z\sim$1.8-1.5 with a subsequent passive evolution of the resulting S0 remnants since $z \sim$0.8-1 is compatible with observational data of S0s in the Tully-Fisher relation (TFR). We studied a set of major and minor merger experiments from the GalMer database that generate massive S0 remnants. We analysed the location of these remnants in the photometric and stellar TFRs assuming that they correspond to $z\sim0.8$ galaxies. We then estimated their evolution in these planes over the last 7 Gyr. The results were compared with data of real S0s and spirals at different redshifts. We also tested how the use of Vcirc or Vrot,max affects the results. We found that just after $\sim$1-2 Gyr of coalescence, major mergers generate S0 remnants that are outliers of the local photometric and stellar TFRs at $z\sim0.8$. After $\sim$4-7 Gyr of passive evolution in isolation, the S0 remnants move towards the local TFR, although the initial scatter among them persists. This scatter is sensitive to the indicator used for the rotation velocity: Vcirc values yield a lower scatter than when Vrot,max values are considered instead. In the planes involving Vrot,max, a clear segregation of the S0 remnants in terms of the spin-orbit coupling of the model is observed, in which the remnants of retrograde encounters overlap with local S0s hosting counter-rotating discs. The location of the S0 remnants at $z\sim 0$ agrees well with the observed distribution of local S0 galaxies in the $σ_0$-$M_K$, Vcirc-$σ_0$ and Vrot,max-$σ_0$ planes. Thus, massive S0 galaxies may have been formed through major mergers that occurred at high redshift and have later evolved towards the local TFR through passive evolution in relative isolation, a mechanism that would also contribute to the scatter observed in this relation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Creating lenticular galaxies with major mergers
Authors:
Miguel Querejeta,
M. Carmen Eliche-Moral,
Trinidad Tapia,
Alejandro Borlaff,
Glenn van de Ven,
Mariya Lyubenova,
Marie Martig,
Jesús Falcón-Barroso,
Jairo Méndez-Abreu,
Jaime Zamorano,
Jesús Gallego
Abstract:
Lenticular galaxies (S0s) represent the majority of early-type galaxies in the local Universe, but their formation channels are still poorly understood. While galaxy mergers are obvious pathways to suppress star formation and increase bulge sizes, the marked parallelism between spiral and lenticular galaxies (e.g. photometric bulge-disc coupling) seemed to rule out a potential merger origin. Here,…
▽ More
Lenticular galaxies (S0s) represent the majority of early-type galaxies in the local Universe, but their formation channels are still poorly understood. While galaxy mergers are obvious pathways to suppress star formation and increase bulge sizes, the marked parallelism between spiral and lenticular galaxies (e.g. photometric bulge-disc coupling) seemed to rule out a potential merger origin. Here, we summarise our recent work in which we have shown, through N-body numerical simulations, that disc-dominated lenticulars can emerge from major mergers of spiral galaxies, in good agreement with observational photometric scaling relations. Moreover, we show that mergers simultaneously increase the light concentration and reduce the angular momentum relative to their spiral progenitors. This explains the mismatch in angular momentum and concentration between spirals and lenticulars recently revealed by CALIFA observations, which is hard to reconcile with simple fading mechanisms (e.g. ram-pressure stripping).
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Creating S0s with major mergers: a 3D view
Authors:
Miguel Querejeta,
M. Carmen Eliche-Moral,
Trinidad Tapia,
Alejandro Borlaff,
Glenn van de Ven,
Mariya Lyubenova,
Marie Martig,
Jesús Falcón-Barroso,
Jairo Méndez-Abreu,
Jaime Zamorano,
Jesús Gallego
Abstract:
A number of simulators have argued that major mergers can sometimes preserve discs (e.g. Springel & Hernquist 2005), but the possibility that they could explain the emergence of lenticular galaxies (S0s) has been generally neglected. In fact, observations of S0s reveal a strong structural coupling between their bulges and discs, which seems difficult to reconcile with the idea that they come from…
▽ More
A number of simulators have argued that major mergers can sometimes preserve discs (e.g. Springel & Hernquist 2005), but the possibility that they could explain the emergence of lenticular galaxies (S0s) has been generally neglected. In fact, observations of S0s reveal a strong structural coupling between their bulges and discs, which seems difficult to reconcile with the idea that they come from major mergers. However, in Querejeta et al. (2015a) we have used N-body simulations of binary mergers to show that, under favourable conditions, discs are first destroyed but soon regrow out of the leftover debris, matching observational photometric scaling relations (e.g. Laurikainen et al. 2010). Additionally, in Querejeta et al. (2015b) we have shown how the merger scenario agrees with the recent discovery that S0s and most spirals are not compatible in an angular momentum--concentration plane. This important result from CALIFA constitutes a serious objection to the idea that spirals transform into S0s mainly by fading (e.g. via ram-pressure stripping, as that would not explain the observed simultaneous change in $λ_\mathrm{Re}$ and concentration), but our simulations of major mergers do explain that mismatch. From such a 3D comparison we conclude that mergers must be a relevant process in the build-up of the current population of S0s.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Formation of S0 galaxies through mergers: Explaining angular momentum and concentration change from spirals to S0s
Authors:
Miguel Querejeta,
M. Carmen Eliche-Moral,
Trinidad Tapia,
Alejandro Borlaff,
Glenn van de Ven,
Mariya Lyubenova,
Marie Martig,
Jesús Falcón-Barroso,
Jairo Méndez-Abreu
Abstract:
The CALIFA team has recently found that the stellar angular momentum and concentration of late-type spiral galaxies are incompatible with those of lenticular galaxies (S0s), concluding that fading alone cannot satisfactorily explain the evolution from spirals into S0s. Here we explore whether major mergers can provide an alternative way to transform spirals into S0s by analysing the spiral-spiral…
▽ More
The CALIFA team has recently found that the stellar angular momentum and concentration of late-type spiral galaxies are incompatible with those of lenticular galaxies (S0s), concluding that fading alone cannot satisfactorily explain the evolution from spirals into S0s. Here we explore whether major mergers can provide an alternative way to transform spirals into S0s by analysing the spiral-spiral major mergers from the GalMer database that lead to realistic, relaxed S0-like galaxies. We find that the change in stellar angular momentum and concentration can explain the differences in the $λ_\mathrm{Re}$--$R_{90}/R_{50}$ plane found by the CALIFA team. Major mergers thus offer a feasible explanation for the transformation of spirals into S0s.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Constraints on the evolutionary mechanisms of massive galaxies since $z \sim 1$ from their velocity dispersions
Authors:
L. Peralta de Arriba,
M. Balcells,
I. Trujillo,
J. Falcón-Barroso,
T. Tapia,
N. Cardiel,
J. Gallego,
R. Guzmán,
A. Hempel,
I. Martín-Navarro,
P. G. Pérez-González,
P. Sánchez-Bláquez
Abstract:
Several authors have reported that the dynamical masses of massive compact galaxies ($M_\star \gtrsim 10^{11} \ \mathrm{M_\odot}$, $r_\mathrm{e} \sim 1 \ \mathrm{kpc}$), computed as $M_\mathrm{dyn} = 5.0 \ σ_\mathrm{e}^2 r_\mathrm{e} / G$, are lower than their stellar masses $M_\star$. In a previous study from our group, the discrepancy is interpreted as a breakdown of the assumption of homology t…
▽ More
Several authors have reported that the dynamical masses of massive compact galaxies ($M_\star \gtrsim 10^{11} \ \mathrm{M_\odot}$, $r_\mathrm{e} \sim 1 \ \mathrm{kpc}$), computed as $M_\mathrm{dyn} = 5.0 \ σ_\mathrm{e}^2 r_\mathrm{e} / G$, are lower than their stellar masses $M_\star$. In a previous study from our group, the discrepancy is interpreted as a breakdown of the assumption of homology that underlie the $M_\mathrm{dyn}$ determinations. Here, we present new spectroscopy of six redshift $z \approx 1.0$ massive compact ellipticals from the Extended Groth Strip, obtained with the 10.4 m Gran Telescopio Canarias. We obtain velocity dispersions in the range $161-340 \ \mathrm{km \ s^{-1}}$. As found by previous studies of massive compact galaxies, our velocity dispersions are lower than the virial expectation, and all of our galaxies show $M_\mathrm{dyn} < M_\star$ (assuming a Salpeter initial mass function). Adding data from the literature, we build a sample covering a range of stellar masses and compactness in a narrow redshift range $\mathit{z \approx 1.0}$. This allows us to exclude systematic effects on the data and evolutionary effects on the galaxy population, which could have affected previous studies. We confirm that mass discrepancy scales with galaxy compactness. We use the stellar mass plane ($M_\star$, $σ_\mathrm{e}$, $r_\mathrm{e}$) populated by our sample to constrain a generic evolution mechanism. We find that the simulations of the growth of massive ellipticals due to mergers agree with our constraints and discard the assumption of homology.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2015; v1 submitted 2 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Formation of S0 galaxies through mergers. Bulge-disc structural coupling resulting from major mergers
Authors:
M. Querejeta,
M. C. Eliche-Moral,
T. Tapia,
A. Borlaff,
C. Rodríguez-Pérez,
J. Zamorano,
J. Gallego
Abstract:
Observations reveal a strong structural coupling between bulge and disc in S0 galaxies, which seems difficult to explain if they have formed from supposedly catastrophic events such as major mergers. We face this question by quantifying the bulge-disc coupling in dissipative simulations of major and minor mergers that result in realistic S0s. We have studied the dissipative N-body binary merger si…
▽ More
Observations reveal a strong structural coupling between bulge and disc in S0 galaxies, which seems difficult to explain if they have formed from supposedly catastrophic events such as major mergers. We face this question by quantifying the bulge-disc coupling in dissipative simulations of major and minor mergers that result in realistic S0s. We have studied the dissipative N-body binary merger simulations from the GalMer database that give rise to realistic, relaxed E/S0 and S0 remnants (67 major and 29 minor mergers). We simulate surface brightness profiles of these S0-like remnants in the K-band, mimicking typical observational conditions, to perform bulge-disc decompositions analogous to those carried out in real S0s. The global bulge-disc structure of these remnants has been compared with real data, and they distribute in the B/T - r_e - h_d parameter space consistently with real bright S0s, where B/T is the bulge-to-total luminosity ratio, r_e is the bulge effective radius, and h_d is the disc scalelength. Major mergers can rebuild a bulge-disc coupling in the remnants after having destroyed the structures of the progenitors, whereas minor mergers directly preserve them. Remnants exhibit B/T and r_e/h_d spanning a wide range of values, and their distribution is consistent with observations. Many remnants have bulge Sersic indices ranging 1<n<2, flat appearance, and contain residual star formation in embedded discs, a result which agrees with the presence of pseudobulges in real S0s. Contrary to the popular view, mergers (and in particular, major events) can result in S0 remnants with realistically coupled bulge-disc structures in less than ~3 Gyr. In conclusion, the bulge-disc coupling and the presence of pseudobulges in real S0s cannot be used as an argument against the possible major-merger origin of these galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2014; v1 submitted 17 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Formation of S0 galaxies through mergers. V. Antitruncated stellar discs resulting from major mergers
Authors:
Alejandro Borlaff,
M. Carmen Eliche-Moral,
Cristina Rodríguez-Pérez,
Miguel Querejeta,
Trinidad Tapia,
Pablo G. Pérez-González,
Jaime Zamorano,
Jesús Gallego,
John Beckman
Abstract:
Lenticular galaxies (S0s) are more likely to host antitruncated (Type-III) stellar discs than galaxies of later Hubble types. Major mergers are popularly considered too violent mechanisms to form these breaks. We have investigated whether major mergers can result into S0-like remnants with realistic antitruncated stellar discs or not. We have analysed 67 relaxed S0 and E/S0 remnants resulting from…
▽ More
Lenticular galaxies (S0s) are more likely to host antitruncated (Type-III) stellar discs than galaxies of later Hubble types. Major mergers are popularly considered too violent mechanisms to form these breaks. We have investigated whether major mergers can result into S0-like remnants with realistic antitruncated stellar discs or not. We have analysed 67 relaxed S0 and E/S0 remnants resulting from dissipative N-body simulations of major mergers from the GalMer database. We have simulated realistic R-band surface brightness profiles of the remnants to identify those with antitruncated stellar discs. Their inner and outer discs and the breaks are quantitatively characterized to compare with real data. Nearly 70% of our S0-like remnants are antitruncated, meaning that major mergers that result in S0s have a high probability of producing Type-III stellar discs. Our remnants lie on top of the extrapolations of the observational trends (towards brighter magnitudes and higher break radii) in several photometric diagrams. In scale-free photometric diagrams, simulations and observations overlap and the remnants reproduce the observational trends, so the physical mechanism after antitruncations is highly scalable. We have found novel photometric scaling relations between the characteristic parameters of the antitruncations in real S0s, which are also reproduced by our simulations. The trends in all the photometric planes can be derived from three basic scaling relations that real and simulated Type-III S0s fulfill: h_i \prop R_brkIII, h_o \prop R_brkIII, and mu_brkIII \prop R_brkIII, where h_i and h_o are the scalelenghts of the inner and outer discs, and mu_brkIII and R_brkIII are the surface brightness and radius of the breaks. Mayor mergers provide a feasible mechanism to form realistic antitruncated S0 galaxies (abridged).
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2014; v1 submitted 18 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Evolution induced by dry minor mergers onto fast-rotator S0 galaxies
Authors:
Trinidad Tapia,
M. Carmen Eliche-Moral,
Miguel Querejeta,
Marc Balcells,
A. César González-García,
Mercedes Prieto,
J. Alfonso L. Aguerri,
Jesús Gallego,
Jaime Zamorano,
Cristina Rodríguez-Pérez,
Alejandro Borlaff,
.
Abstract:
We analysed collisionless N-body simulations of intermediate and minor dry mergers onto S0s to test whether these mergers can generate S0 galaxies with kinematics intermediate between fast and slow rotators. We find that minor mergers induce a lower decrease of the global rotational support than encounters of lower mass ratios, which results in S0s with properties intermediate between fast and slo…
▽ More
We analysed collisionless N-body simulations of intermediate and minor dry mergers onto S0s to test whether these mergers can generate S0 galaxies with kinematics intermediate between fast and slow rotators. We find that minor mergers induce a lower decrease of the global rotational support than encounters of lower mass ratios, which results in S0s with properties intermediate between fast and slow rotators. The resulting remnants are intrinsically more triaxial, less flattened, and span the whole range of apparent ellipticities up to $ε_\mathrm{e} \sim 0.8$. They do not show lower apparent ellipticities in random projections than initially; on the contrary, the formation of oval distortions and the disc thickening increase the percentage of projections at $0.4 < ε_\mathrm{e} < 0.7$. In the experiments with S0b progenitor galaxies, minor mergers tend to spin up the bulge and to decrease slightly its intrinsic ellipticity, whereas in the cases of primary S0c galaxies they keep the rotational support of the bulge nearly constant and decrease significantly its intrinsic ellipticity. The remnant bulges remain nearly spherical ($B/A \sim C/A > 0.9$), but exhibit a wide range of triaxialities ($0.20 < T < 1.00$). In the plane of global anisotropy of velocities ($δ$) vs. intrinsic ellipticity ($ε_\mathrm{e,intr}$), some of our models extend the linear trend found in previous major merger simulations towards higher $ε_\mathrm{e,intr}$ values, while others depart from it. This is consistent with the wide dispersion exhibited by real S0s in this diagram compared with ellipticals, which follow the linear trend drawn by major merger simulations. The different trends exhibited by ellipticals and S0 galaxies in the $δ$ - $ε_\mathrm{e}$ diagram may be pointing to the different role played by major mergers in the build-up of each morphological type.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2014; v1 submitted 10 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
UBV(RI)_C photometry of the open clusters Be 15, Be 80, and NGC 2192
Authors:
M. T. Tapia,
W. J. Schuster,
R. Michel,
C. Chavarría-K.,
W. S. Dias,
R. Vázquez,
A. Moitinho
Abstract:
The three open clusters Be 15, Be 80, and NGC 2192 have been observed using CCD UBV(RI)_C photometry at the San Pedro Mártir Observatory, México within the framework of our open-cluster survey. The fundamental parameters of interstellar reddening, distance, and age have been derived, and also the metallicity for NGC 2192 (solar metallicity has been assumed for the other two). By shifting the col…
▽ More
The three open clusters Be 15, Be 80, and NGC 2192 have been observed using CCD UBV(RI)_C photometry at the San Pedro Mártir Observatory, México within the framework of our open-cluster survey. The fundamental parameters of interstellar reddening, distance, and age have been derived, and also the metallicity for NGC 2192 (solar metallicity has been assumed for the other two). By shifting the colours of Schmidt-Kaler in the (U-B, B-V) two-colour diagram along the appropriate reddening vector, the interstellar reddenings have been derived as E(B-V)=0.23+/-0.03 mag for Be 15, 1.31+/-0.05 for Be 80, and 0.16+/-0.03 for NGC 2192. Evidence is shown for a variable interstellar extinction across the cluster Be 80. For NGC 2192 a nicely consistent fit is obtained for both the interstellar reddening and the metallicity ([Fe/H]=-0.31) using simultaneously the F-type and red-clump stars. By fitting isochrones to the observed sequences of these three clusters in various colour-magnitude diagrams of different colour indices, (B-V, V-I, or V-R) the averages of distance moduli and heliocentric distances ((V-M_V)_o (mag); d(pc)) are the following: (10.74+/-0.01; 1202) for Be 15, (10.75+/-0.01; 1413) for Be 80, and (12.7+/-0.01; 3467) for NGC 2192, and the averages of the inferred best ages (log(age); age (Gyr)) are (8.6+/-0.05; 0.4) for Be 80, and (9.15+/-0.05; 1.4) for NGC 2192; for Be 15 there are two distinct possibilities for the age fit, depending on the membership of three brighter stars, (9.35 or 9.95+/-0.05; 2.2 or 8.9). The need for spectroscopic observations in Be 15 is emphasized to select between alternate reddening and age solutions, and for deeper UBV observations in Be 80 to study in greater detail the variable interstellar, or intracluster, reddening across this cluster.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
