-
Turbulence and Anomalous Resistivity inside Near-Earth Magnetic Clouds
Authors:
Debesh Bhattacharjee,
Prasad Subramanian,
Teresa Nieves-Chinchilla,
Angelos Vourlidas
Abstract:
We use in-situ data from the Wind spacecraft to survey the amplitude of turbulent fluctuations in the proton density and total magnetic field inside a large sample of near-Earth magnetic clouds (MCs) associated with coronal mass ejections (CMEs) from the Sun. We find that the most probable value of the modulation index for proton density fluctuations ($δn_{p}/n_{p}$) inside MCs ranges from 0.13 to…
▽ More
We use in-situ data from the Wind spacecraft to survey the amplitude of turbulent fluctuations in the proton density and total magnetic field inside a large sample of near-Earth magnetic clouds (MCs) associated with coronal mass ejections (CMEs) from the Sun. We find that the most probable value of the modulation index for proton density fluctuations ($δn_{p}/n_{p}$) inside MCs ranges from 0.13 to 0.16, while the most probable values for the modulation index of the total magnetic field fluctuations ($δB/B$) range from 0.04 to 0.05. We also find that the most probable value of the Mach number fluctuations ($δM$) inside MCs is $\approx 0.1$. The anomalous resistivity inside near-Earth MCs arising from electron scattering due to turbulent magnetic field fluctuations exceeds the (commonly used) Spitzer resistivity by a factor of $\approx 500-1000$. The enhanced Joule heating arising from this anomalous resistivity could impact our understanding of the energetics of CME propagation.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
On the specific energy and pressure in near-Earth magnetic clouds
Authors:
Debesh Bhattacharjee,
Prasad Subramanian,
Angelos Vourlidas,
Teresa Nieves-Chinchilla,
Niranjana Thejaswi,
Nishtha Sachdeva
Abstract:
The pressure and energy density of the gas and magnetic field inside solar coronal mass ejections (in relation to that in the ambient solar wind) is thought to play an important role in determining their dynamics as they propagate through the heliosphere. We compare the specific energy (${\rm erg\,g^{-1}}$) [comprising kinetic ($H_{\rm k}$), thermal ($H_{\rm th }$) and magnetic field (…
▽ More
The pressure and energy density of the gas and magnetic field inside solar coronal mass ejections (in relation to that in the ambient solar wind) is thought to play an important role in determining their dynamics as they propagate through the heliosphere. We compare the specific energy (${\rm erg\,g^{-1}}$) [comprising kinetic ($H_{\rm k}$), thermal ($H_{\rm th }$) and magnetic field ($H_{\rm mag}$) contributions] inside MCs and the solar wind background. We examine if the excess thermal + magnetic pressure and specific energy inside MCs (relative to the background) is correlated with their propagation and internal expansion speeds. We ask if the excess thermal + magnetic specific energy inside MCs might make them resemble rigid bodies in the context of aerodynamic drag. We use near-Earth in-situ data from the WIND spacecraft to identify a sample of 152 well observed interplanetary coronal mass ejections and their MC counterparts. We compute various metrics using these data to address our questions. We find that the total specific energy ($H$) inside MCs is approximately equal to that in the background solar wind. We find that the the excess (thermal + magnetic) pressure and specific energy are not well correlated with the near-Earth propagation and expansion speeds. We find that the excess thermal+magnetic specific energy $\gtrsim$ the specific kinetic energy of the solar wind incident on 81--89 \% of the MCs we study. This might explain how MCs retain their structural integrity and resist deformation by the solar wind bulk flow.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
On modeling ICME cross-sections as static MHD columns
Authors:
Debesh Bhattacharjee,
Prasad Subramanian,
Volker Bothmer,
Teresa Nieves-Chinchilla,
Angelos Vourlidas
Abstract:
Solar coronal mass ejections are well known to expand as they propagate through the heliosphere. Despite this, their cross-sections are usually modeled as static plasma columns within the magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) framework. We test the validity of this approach using in-situ plasma data from 151 magnetic clouds (MCs) observed by the WIND spacecraft and 45 observed by the Helios spacecrafts. We f…
▽ More
Solar coronal mass ejections are well known to expand as they propagate through the heliosphere. Despite this, their cross-sections are usually modeled as static plasma columns within the magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) framework. We test the validity of this approach using in-situ plasma data from 151 magnetic clouds (MCs) observed by the WIND spacecraft and 45 observed by the Helios spacecrafts. We find that the most probable cross-section expansion speeds for the WIND events are only $\approx 0.06$ times the Alfvén speed inside the MCs while the most probable cross-section expansion speeds for the Helios events is $\approx 0.03$. MC cross-sections can thus be considered to be nearly static over an Alfvén crossing timescale. Using estimates of electrical conductivity arising from Coulomb collisions, we find that the Lundquist number inside MCs is high ($\approx 10^{13}$), suggesting that the MHD description is well justified. The Joule heating rates using our conductivity estimates are several orders of magnitude lower than the requirement for plasma heating inside MCs near the Earth. While the (low) heating rates we compute are consistent with the MHD description, the discrepancy with the heating requirement points to possible departures from MHD and the need for a better understanding of plasma heating in MCs.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Turbulent Proton Heating Rate in the Solar Wind from $5$ to $45~R_{\odot}$
Authors:
K. Sasikumar Raja,
Prasad Subramanian,
Madhusudan Ingale,
R. Ramesh,
Milan Maksimovic
Abstract:
Various remote sensing observations have been used so far to probe the turbulent properties of the solar wind. Using the recently reported density modulation indices that are derived using angular broadening observations of Crab Nebula during 1952 - 2013, we measured the solar wind proton heating using the kinetic $\rm Alfv\acute{e}n$ wave dispersion equation. The estimated heating rates vary from…
▽ More
Various remote sensing observations have been used so far to probe the turbulent properties of the solar wind. Using the recently reported density modulation indices that are derived using angular broadening observations of Crab Nebula during 1952 - 2013, we measured the solar wind proton heating using the kinetic $\rm Alfv\acute{e}n$ wave dispersion equation. The estimated heating rates vary from $\approx 1.58 \times 10^{-14}$ to $1.01 \times 10^{-8} ~\rm erg~ cm^{-3}~ s^{-1}$ in the heliocentric distance range 5 - 45 $\rm R_{\odot}$. Further, we found that heating rates vary with the solar cycle in correlation with density modulation indices. The models derived using in-situ measurements (for example, electron/proton density, temperature, and magnetic field) that the recently launched Parker Solar Probe observes (planned closest perihelia $\rm 9.86~ R_{\odot}$ from the center of the Sun) are useful in the estimation of the turbulent heating rate precisely. Further, we compared our heating rate estimates with the one derived using previously reported remote sensing and in-situ observations.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
X-ray Dips in AGN and Microquasars -- Collapse Timescales of Inner Accretion Disc
Authors:
Mayur B. Shende,
Prashali Chauhan,
Prasad Subramanian
Abstract:
The temporal behaviour of X-rays from some AGN and microquasars is thought to arise from the rapid collapse of the hot, inner parts of their accretion discs. The collapse can occur over the radial infall timescale of the inner accretion disc. However, estimates of this timescale are hindered by a lack of knowledge of the operative viscosity in the collisionless plasma comprising the inner disc. We…
▽ More
The temporal behaviour of X-rays from some AGN and microquasars is thought to arise from the rapid collapse of the hot, inner parts of their accretion discs. The collapse can occur over the radial infall timescale of the inner accretion disc. However, estimates of this timescale are hindered by a lack of knowledge of the operative viscosity in the collisionless plasma comprising the inner disc. We use published simulation results for cosmic ray diffusion through turbulent magnetic fields to arrive at a viscosity prescription appropriate to hot accretion discs. We construct simplified disc models using this viscosity prescription and estimate disc collapse timescales for 3C 120, 3C 111, and GRS 1915+105. The Shakura-Sunyaev α parameter resulting from our model ranges from 0.02 to 0.08. Our inner disc collapse timescale estimates agree well with those of the observed X-ray dips. We find that the collapse timescale is most sensitive to the outer radius of the hot accretion disc.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Validating inversions for toroidal flows using normal-mode coupling
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
Shravan Hanasoge
Abstract:
Normal-mode coupling is a helioseismic technique that uses measurements of mode eigenfunctions to infer the interior structure of the Sun. This technique has led to insights into the evolution and structure of toroidal flows in the solar interior. Here, we validate an inversion algorithm for normal-mode coupling by generating synthetic seismic measurements associated with input flows and comparing…
▽ More
Normal-mode coupling is a helioseismic technique that uses measurements of mode eigenfunctions to infer the interior structure of the Sun. This technique has led to insights into the evolution and structure of toroidal flows in the solar interior. Here, we validate an inversion algorithm for normal-mode coupling by generating synthetic seismic measurements associated with input flows and comparing the input and inverted velocities. We study four different cases of input toroidal flows and compute synthetics that take into account the partial visibility of the Sun. We invert the synthetics using Subtractive Optimally Localized Averages (SOLA) and also try to mitigate the systematics of mode leakage. We demonstrate that, ultimately, inversions are only as good as the model we assume for the correlation between flow velocities.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Global Solar Magnetic-field and Interplanetary Scintillations During the Past Four Solar Cycles
Authors:
K. Sasikumar Raja,
P. Janardhan,
Susanta Kumar Bisoi,
Madhusudan Ingale,
Prasad Subramanian,
K. Fujiki,
Milan Maksimovic
Abstract:
The extended minimum of Solar Cycle 23, the extremely quiet solar-wind conditions prevailing, and the mini-maximum of Solar Cycle 24 drew global attention and many authors have since attempted to predict the amplitude of the upcoming Solar Cycle 25, which is predicted to be the third successive weak cycle; it is a unique opportunity to probe the Sun during such quiet periods. Earlier work has esta…
▽ More
The extended minimum of Solar Cycle 23, the extremely quiet solar-wind conditions prevailing, and the mini-maximum of Solar Cycle 24 drew global attention and many authors have since attempted to predict the amplitude of the upcoming Solar Cycle 25, which is predicted to be the third successive weak cycle; it is a unique opportunity to probe the Sun during such quiet periods. Earlier work has established a steady decline, over two decades, in solar photospheric fields at latitudes above $45^{\circ}$ and a similar decline in solar-wind micro-turbulence levels as measured by interplanetary scintillation (IPS) observations. However, the relation between the photospheric magnetic fields and those in the low corona/solar-wind are not straightforward. Therefore, in the present article, we have used potential-field source-surface (PFSS) extrapolations to deduce global magnetic-fields using synoptic magnetograms observed with National Solar Observatory (NSO), Kitt Peak, USA (NSO/KP) and Solar Optical Long-term Investigation of the Sun (NSO/SOLIS) instruments during 1975-2018. Furthermore, we have measured the normalized scintillation index [m] using the IPS observations carried out at the Institute of Space Earth Environment Research (ISEE), Japan during 1983-2017. From these observations, we have found that, since the mid-1990s, the magnetic-field over different latitudes at 2.5 $\rm R_{\odot}$ and 10 $\rm R_{\odot}$(extrapolated using PFSS method) has decreased by $\approx 11.3-22.2 \%$. In phase with the declining magnetic-fields, the quantity m also declined by $\approx 23.6 \%$. These observations emphasize the inter-relationship between the global magnetic-field and various turbulence parameters in the solar corona and solar wind.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2020; v1 submitted 24 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Automated Detection of Solar Radio Bursts using a Statistical Method
Authors:
Dayal Singh,
K. Sasikumar Raja,
Prasad Subramanian,
R. Ramesh,
Christian Monstein
Abstract:
Radio bursts from the solar corona can provide clues to forecast space weather hazards. After recent technology advancements, regular monitoring of radio bursts has increased and large observational data sets are produced. Hence, manual identification and classification of them is a challenging task. In this paper, we describe an algorithm to automatically identify radio bursts from dynamic solar…
▽ More
Radio bursts from the solar corona can provide clues to forecast space weather hazards. After recent technology advancements, regular monitoring of radio bursts has increased and large observational data sets are produced. Hence, manual identification and classification of them is a challenging task. In this paper, we describe an algorithm to automatically identify radio bursts from dynamic solar radio spectrograms using a novel statistical method. We used e-CALLISTO radio spectrometer data observed at Gauribidanur observatory near Bangalore in India during 2013 - 2014. We have studied the classifier performance using the receiver operating characteristics. Further, we studied type III bursts observed in the year 2014 and found that $75\%$ of the observed bursts were below 200 MHz. Our analysis shows that the positions of the flare sites which are associated with the type III bursts with upper-frequency cut-off $\gtrsim 200$ MHz originate close to the solar disk center
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Episodic Jets from Black Hole Accretion Disks
Authors:
Mayur B. Shende,
Prasad Subramanian,
Nishtha Sachdeva
Abstract:
Several active galactic nuclei and microquasars are observed to eject plasmoids that move at relativistic speeds. We envisage the plasmoids as pre-existing current carrying magnetic flux ropes that were initially anchored in the accretion disk-corona. The plasmoids are ejected outwards via a mechanism called the toroidal instability (TI). The TI, which was originally explored in the context of lab…
▽ More
Several active galactic nuclei and microquasars are observed to eject plasmoids that move at relativistic speeds. We envisage the plasmoids as pre-existing current carrying magnetic flux ropes that were initially anchored in the accretion disk-corona. The plasmoids are ejected outwards via a mechanism called the toroidal instability (TI). The TI, which was originally explored in the context of laboratory tokamak plasmas, has been very successful in explaining coronal mass ejections from the Sun. Our model predictions for plasmoid trajectories compare favorably with a representative set of multi-epoch observations of radio emitting knots from the radio galaxy 3C120, which were preceded by dips in Xray intensity.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Dissipation scale lengths of density turbulence in the inner solar wind
Authors:
K. Sasikumar Raja,
Prasad Subramanian,
Madhusudan Ingale,
R. Ramesh
Abstract:
Knowing the lengthscales at which turbulent fluctuations dissipate is key to understanding the nature of weakly compressible magnetohydrodynamic turbulence. We use radio wavelength interferometric imaging observations which measure the extent to which distant cosmic sources observed against the inner solar wind are scatter-broadened. We interpret these observations to determine that the dissipatio…
▽ More
Knowing the lengthscales at which turbulent fluctuations dissipate is key to understanding the nature of weakly compressible magnetohydrodynamic turbulence. We use radio wavelength interferometric imaging observations which measure the extent to which distant cosmic sources observed against the inner solar wind are scatter-broadened. We interpret these observations to determine that the dissipation scales of solar wind density turbulence at heliocentric distances of 2.5 -- 20.27 $R_{\odot}$ range from $\approx$ 13500 to 520 m. Our estimates from $\approx$ 10--20 $R_{\odot}$ suggest that the dissipation scale corresponds to the proton gyroradius. They are relevant to in-situ observations to be made by the Parker Solar Probe, and are expected to enhance our understanding of solar wind acceleration.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Energetics of small electron acceleration episodes in the solar corona from radio noise storm observations
Authors:
Tomin James,
Prasad Subramanian
Abstract:
Observations of radio noise storms can act as sensitive probes of nonthermal electrons produced in small acceleration events in the solar corona. We use data from noise storm episodes observed jointly by the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT) and the Nancay Radioheliograph (NRH) to study characteristics of the nonthermal electrons involved in the emission. We find that the electrons carry…
▽ More
Observations of radio noise storms can act as sensitive probes of nonthermal electrons produced in small acceleration events in the solar corona. We use data from noise storm episodes observed jointly by the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT) and the Nancay Radioheliograph (NRH) to study characteristics of the nonthermal electrons involved in the emission. We find that the electrons carry $10^{21}$ to $10^{24}$ erg/s, and that the energy contained in the electrons producing a representative noise storm burst ranges from $10^{20}$ to $10^{23}$ ergs. These results are a direct probe of the energetics involved in ubiquitous, small-scale electron acceleration episodes in the corona, and could be relevant to a nanoflare-like scenario for coronal heating.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Was the cosmic ray burst detected by the GRAPES-3 on 22 June 2015 caused by transient weakening of geomagnetic field or by an interplanetary anisotropy?
Authors:
P. K. Mohanty,
K. P. Arunbabu,
T. Aziz,
S. R. Dugad,
S. K. Gupta,
B. Hariharan,
P. Jagadeesan,
A. Jain,
S. D. Morris,
P. K. Nayak,
P. S. Rakshe,
K. Ramesh,
B. S. Rao,
M. Zuberi,
Y. Hayashi,
S. Kawakami,
P. Subramanian,
S. Raha,
S. Ahmad,
A. Oshima,
S. Shibata,
H. Kojima
Abstract:
The GRAPES-3 muon telescope in Ooty, India had claimed detection of a 2 hour (h) high-energy ($\sim$20 GeV) burst of galactic cosmic-rays (GCRs) through a $>$50$σ$ surge in GeV muons, was caused by reconnection of the interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) in the magnetosphere that led to transient weakening of Earth's magnetic shield. This burst had occurred during a G4-class geomagnetic storm (stor…
▽ More
The GRAPES-3 muon telescope in Ooty, India had claimed detection of a 2 hour (h) high-energy ($\sim$20 GeV) burst of galactic cosmic-rays (GCRs) through a $>$50$σ$ surge in GeV muons, was caused by reconnection of the interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) in the magnetosphere that led to transient weakening of Earth's magnetic shield. This burst had occurred during a G4-class geomagnetic storm (storm) with a delay of $\frac{1}{2}$h relative to the coronal mass ejection (CME) of 22 June 2015 (Mohanty et al., 2016). However, recently a group interpreted the occurrence of the same burst in a subset of 31 neutron monitors (NMs) to have been the result of an anisotropy in interplanetary space (Evenson et al., 2017) in contrast to the claim in (Mohanty et al., 2016). A new analysis of the GRAPES-3 data with a fine 10.6$^{\circ}$ angular segmentation shows the speculation of interplanetary anisotropy to be incorrect, and offers a possible explanation of the NM observations. The observed 28 minutes (min) delay of the burst relative to the CME can be explained by the movement of the reconnection front from the bow shock to the surface of Earth at an average speed of 35 km/s, much lower than the CME speed of 700 km/s. This measurement may provide a more accurate estimate of the start of the storm.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
CALLISTO Spectrometer at IISER-Pune
Authors:
K. Sasikumar Raja,
Prasad Subramanian,
S. Ananthakrishnan,
Christian Monstein
Abstract:
A CALLISTO spectrometer to monitor solar radio transient emissions from $\approx 0.8-1.6~R_{\odot}$ (above photosphere) is installed at IISER, Pune, India (longitude $73^{\circ} 55'$ E and latitude $18^{\circ}31'$ N). In this paper, we illustrate the instrumental details (log-periodic dipole antenna and the receiver system) along with the recorded solar radio bursts and radio frequency interferenc…
▽ More
A CALLISTO spectrometer to monitor solar radio transient emissions from $\approx 0.8-1.6~R_{\odot}$ (above photosphere) is installed at IISER, Pune, India (longitude $73^{\circ} 55'$ E and latitude $18^{\circ}31'$ N). In this paper, we illustrate the instrumental details (log-periodic dipole antenna and the receiver system) along with the recorded solar radio bursts and radio frequency interferences produced by the thunderstorms in the frequency range 45-870 MHz. We also developed the image processing pipelines using `sunpy' and in-house developed python library called `pycallisto'.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Turbulent density fluctuations and proton heating rate in the solar wind from 9-20~R_{\odot}
Authors:
K. Sasikumar Raja,
Prasad Subramanian,
R. Ramesh,
Angelos Vourlidas,
Madhusudan Ingale
Abstract:
We obtain scatter broadened images of the Crab Nebula at 80 MHz as it transits through the inner solar wind in June 2016 and 2017. These images are anisotropic, with the major axis oriented perpendicular to the radially outward coronal magnetic field. Using these data, we deduce that the density modulation index (δN_e/N_e) caused by turbulent density fluctuations in the solar wind ranges from 1.9…
▽ More
We obtain scatter broadened images of the Crab Nebula at 80 MHz as it transits through the inner solar wind in June 2016 and 2017. These images are anisotropic, with the major axis oriented perpendicular to the radially outward coronal magnetic field. Using these data, we deduce that the density modulation index (δN_e/N_e) caused by turbulent density fluctuations in the solar wind ranges from 1.9 \times 10^{-3} to 7.7 \times 10^{-3} between 9-20 R_{\odot}. We also find that the heating rate of solar wind protons at these distances ranges from 2.2 \times 10^{-13} to 1.0 \times 10^{-11} ~erg~cm^{-3}~s^{-1}. On two occasions, the line of sight intercepted a coronal streamer. We find that the presence of the streamer approximately doubles the thickness of the scattering screen.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Imaging Spectroscopy of Solar Radio Burst Fine Structures
Authors:
E. P. Kontar,
S. Yu,
A. A. Kuznetsov,
A. G. Emslie,
B. Alcock,
N. L. S. Jeffrey,
V. N. Melnik,
N. H. Bian,
P. Subramanian
Abstract:
Solar radio observations provide a unique diagnostic of the outer solar atmosphere. However, the inhomogeneous turbulent corona strongly affects the propagation of the emitted radio waves, so decoupling the intrinsic properties of the emitting source from the effects of radio-wave propagation has long been a major challenge in solar physics. Here we report quantitative spatial and frequency charac…
▽ More
Solar radio observations provide a unique diagnostic of the outer solar atmosphere. However, the inhomogeneous turbulent corona strongly affects the propagation of the emitted radio waves, so decoupling the intrinsic properties of the emitting source from the effects of radio-wave propagation has long been a major challenge in solar physics. Here we report quantitative spatial and frequency characterization of solar radio burst fine structures observed with the LOw Frequency Array (LOFAR), an instrument with high time resolution that also permits imaging at scales much shorter than those corresponding to radio-wave propagation in the corona. The observations demonstrate that radio-wave propagation effects, and not the properties of the intrinsic emission source, dominate the observed spatial characteristics of radio burst images. These results permit more accurate estimates of source brightness temperatures, and open opportunities for quantitative study of the mechanisms that create the turbulent coronal medium through which the emitted radiation propagates.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2018; v1 submitted 22 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Small electron acceleration episodes in the solar corona
Authors:
Tomin James,
Prasad Subramanian,
Eduard P Kontar
Abstract:
We study the energetics of nonthermal electrons produced in small acceleration episodes in the solar corona. We carried out an extensive survey spanning 2004--2015 and shortlisted 6 impulsive electron events detected at 1 AU that was not associated with large solar flares(GOES soft X-ray class $>$ C1) or with coronal mass ejections. Each of these events had weak, but detectable hard Xray (HXR) emi…
▽ More
We study the energetics of nonthermal electrons produced in small acceleration episodes in the solar corona. We carried out an extensive survey spanning 2004--2015 and shortlisted 6 impulsive electron events detected at 1 AU that was not associated with large solar flares(GOES soft X-ray class $>$ C1) or with coronal mass ejections. Each of these events had weak, but detectable hard Xray (HXR) emission near the west limb, and were associated with interplanetary type III bursts. In some respects, these events seem like weak counterparts of "cold/tenuous" flares. The energy carried by the HXR producing electron population was $\approx 10^{23}$ -- $10^{25}$ erg, while that in the corresponding population detected at 1 AU was $\approx 10^{24}$--$10^{25}$ erg. The number of electrons that escape the coronal acceleration site and reach 1 AU constitute 6 % to 148 % of those that precipitate downwards to produce thick target HXR emission.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
CME dynamics using STEREO & LASCO observations: the relative importance of Lorentz forces and solar wind drag
Authors:
Nishtha Sachdeva,
Prasad Subramanian,
Angelos Vourlidas,
Volker Bothmer
Abstract:
We seek to quantify the relative contributions of Lorentz forces and aerodynamic drag on the propagation of solar coronal mass ejections (CMEs). We use Graduated Cylindrical Shell (GCS) model fits to a representative set of 38 CMEs observed with the SOHO and STEREO spacecraft. We find that the Lorentz forces generally peak between 1.65 and 2.45 Rsun for all CMEs. For fast CMEs, Lorentz forces beco…
▽ More
We seek to quantify the relative contributions of Lorentz forces and aerodynamic drag on the propagation of solar coronal mass ejections (CMEs). We use Graduated Cylindrical Shell (GCS) model fits to a representative set of 38 CMEs observed with the SOHO and STEREO spacecraft. We find that the Lorentz forces generally peak between 1.65 and 2.45 Rsun for all CMEs. For fast CMEs, Lorentz forces become negligible in comparison to aerodynamic drag as early as 3.5--4 Rsun. For slow CMEs, however, they become negligible only by 12--50 Rsun. For these slow events, our results suggest that some of the magnetic flux might be expended in CME expansion or heating. In other words, not all of it contributes to directed propagation. Our results are expected to be important in building a physical model for understanding the Sun-Earth dynamics of CMEs.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2017; v1 submitted 13 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Amplitude of solar wind density turbulence from 10--45 $R_{\odot}$
Authors:
K. Sasikumar Raja,
Madhusudan Ingale,
R. Ramesh,
Prasad Subramanian,
P. K. Manoharan,
P. Janardhan
Abstract:
We report on the amplitude of the density turbulence spectrum ($C_{N}^{2}$) and the density modulation index ($δN/N$) in the solar wind between $10$ and $45 R_{\odot}$. We derive these quantities using a structure function that is observationally constrained by occultation observations of the Crab nebula made in 2011 and 2013 and similar observations published earlier. We use the most general form…
▽ More
We report on the amplitude of the density turbulence spectrum ($C_{N}^{2}$) and the density modulation index ($δN/N$) in the solar wind between $10$ and $45 R_{\odot}$. We derive these quantities using a structure function that is observationally constrained by occultation observations of the Crab nebula made in 2011 and 2013 and similar observations published earlier. We use the most general form of the structure function, together with currently used prescriptions for the inner/dissipation scale of the turbulence spectrum. Our work yields a comprehensive picture of a) the manner in which $C_{N}^{2}$ and $δN/N$ vary with heliocentric distance in the solar wind and b) of the solar cycle dependence of these quantities.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Relative contribution of the magnetic field barrier and solar wind speed in ICME-associated Forbush decreases
Authors:
Ankush Bhaskar,
Prasad Subramanian,
Geeta Vichare
Abstract:
We study 50 cosmic ray Forbush decreases (FDs) from the Oulu neutron monitor data during 1997-2005 that were associated with Earth-directed interplanetary coronal mass ejections (ICMEs). Such events are generally thought to arise due to the shielding of cosmic rays by a propagating diffusive barrier. The main processes at work are the diffusion of cosmic rays across the large-scale magnetic fields…
▽ More
We study 50 cosmic ray Forbush decreases (FDs) from the Oulu neutron monitor data during 1997-2005 that were associated with Earth-directed interplanetary coronal mass ejections (ICMEs). Such events are generally thought to arise due to the shielding of cosmic rays by a propagating diffusive barrier. The main processes at work are the diffusion of cosmic rays across the large-scale magnetic fields carried by the ICME and their advection by the solar wind. In an attempt to better understand the relative importance of these effects, we analyse the relationship between the FD profiles and those of the interplanetary magnetic field (B) and the solar wind speed (Vsw). Over the entire duration of a given FD, we find that the FD profile is generally well (anti)correlated with the B and Vsw profiles. This trend holds separately for the FD main and recovery phases too. For the recovery phases, however, the FD profile is highly anti-correlated with the Vsw profile, but not with the B profile. While the total duration of the FD profile is similar to that of the Vsw profile, it is significantly longer than that of the B profile.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2016; v1 submitted 31 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
"Blobs" in blazar jets
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian
Abstract:
The concept of highly relativistic electrons confined to blobs that are moving out with modestly relativistic speeds is often invoked to explain high energy blazar observations. The important parameters in this model such as the bulk Lorentz factor of the blob ($Γ$), the random Lorentz factor of the electrons ($γ$) and the blob size are typically observationally constrained, but its not clear how…
▽ More
The concept of highly relativistic electrons confined to blobs that are moving out with modestly relativistic speeds is often invoked to explain high energy blazar observations. The important parameters in this model such as the bulk Lorentz factor of the blob ($Γ$), the random Lorentz factor of the electrons ($γ$) and the blob size are typically observationally constrained, but its not clear how and why the energetic electrons are held together as a blob. Here we present some preliminary ideas based on scenarios for cosmic ray electron self-confinement that could lead to a coherent picture.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
CME propagation: Where does solar wind drag take over?
Authors:
Nishtha Sachdeva,
Prasad Subramanian,
Robin Colaninno,
Angelos Vourlidas
Abstract:
We investigate the Sun-Earth dynamics of a set of eight well observed solar coronal mass ejections (CMEs) using data from the STEREO spacecraft. We seek to quantify the extent to which momentum coupling between these CMEs and the ambient solar wind (i.e., the aerodynamic drag) influences their dynamics. To this end, we use results from a 3D flux rope model fit to the CME data. We find that solar w…
▽ More
We investigate the Sun-Earth dynamics of a set of eight well observed solar coronal mass ejections (CMEs) using data from the STEREO spacecraft. We seek to quantify the extent to which momentum coupling between these CMEs and the ambient solar wind (i.e., the aerodynamic drag) influences their dynamics. To this end, we use results from a 3D flux rope model fit to the CME data. We find that solar wind aerodynamic drag adequately accounts for the dynamics of the fastest CME in our sample. For the relatively slower CMEs, we find that drag-based models initiated below heliocentric distances ranging from 15 to 50 $R_{\odot}$ cannot account for the observed CME trajectories. This is at variance with the general perception that the dynamics of slow CMEs are influenced primarily by solar wind drag from a few $R_{\odot}$ onwards. Several slow CMEs propagate at roughly constant speeds above 15--50 $R_{\odot}$. Drag-based models initiated above these heights therefore require negligible aerodynamic drag to explain their observed trajectories.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2015; v1 submitted 18 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
How are Forbush decreases related to interplanetary magnetic field enhancements ?
Authors:
K. P. Arunbabu,
H. M. Antia,
S. R. Dugad,
S. K. Gupta,
Y. Hayashi,
S. Kawakami,
P. K. Mohanty,
A. Oshima,
P. Subramanian
Abstract:
Aims. Forbush decrease (FD) is a transient decrease followed by a gradual recovery in the observed galactic cosmic ray intensity. We seek to understand the relationship between the FDs and near-Earth interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) enhancements associated with solar coronal mass ejections (CMEs). Methods. We use muon data at cutoff rigidities ranging from 14 to 24 GV from the GRAPES-3 tracking…
▽ More
Aims. Forbush decrease (FD) is a transient decrease followed by a gradual recovery in the observed galactic cosmic ray intensity. We seek to understand the relationship between the FDs and near-Earth interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) enhancements associated with solar coronal mass ejections (CMEs). Methods. We use muon data at cutoff rigidities ranging from 14 to 24 GV from the GRAPES-3 tracking muon telescope to identify FD events. We select those FD events that have a reasonably clean profile, and magnitude > 0.25%. We use IMF data from ACE/WIND spacecrafts. We look for correlations between the FD profile and that of the one hour averaged IMF. We ask if the diffusion of high energy protons into the large scale magnetic field is the cause of the lag observed between the FD and the IMF. Results. The enhancement of the IMF associated with FDs occurs mainly in the shock-sheath region, and the turbulence level in the magnetic field is also enhanced in this region. The observed FD profiles look remarkably similar to the IMF enhancement profiles. The FDs typically lag the IMF enhancement by a few hours. The lag corresponds to the time taken by high energy protons to diffuse into the magnetic field enhancement via cross-field diffusion. Conclusions. Our findings show that high rigidity FDs associated with CMEs are caused primarily by the cumulative diffusion of protons across the magnetic field enhancement in the turbulent sheath region between the shock and the CME.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2015; v1 submitted 24 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
The structure of solar radio noise storms
Authors:
Claude Mercier,
Prasad Subramanian,
Gilbert Chambe,
P. Janardhan
Abstract:
The Nançay Radioheliograph (NRH) routinely produces snapshot images of the full sun at frequencies between 150 and 450 MHz, with typical resolution 3 arcmin and time cadence 0.2 s. Combining visibilities from the NRH and from the Giant Meterwave Radio Telescope (GMRT) allows us to produce images of the sun at 236 or 327 MHz, with a large FOV, high resolution and time cadence. We seek to investigat…
▽ More
The Nançay Radioheliograph (NRH) routinely produces snapshot images of the full sun at frequencies between 150 and 450 MHz, with typical resolution 3 arcmin and time cadence 0.2 s. Combining visibilities from the NRH and from the Giant Meterwave Radio Telescope (GMRT) allows us to produce images of the sun at 236 or 327 MHz, with a large FOV, high resolution and time cadence. We seek to investigate the structure of noise storms (the most common non-thermal solar radio emission). We focus on the relation of position and altitude of noise storms with the observing frequency and on the lower limit of their sizes. We present results for noise storms on four days. The results consist of an extended halo and of one or several compact cores with relative intensity changing over a few seconds. We found that core sizes can be almost stable over one hour, with a minimum in the range 31-35 arcsec (less than previously reported) and can be stable over one hour. The heliocentric distances of noise storms are $\sim 1.20$ and 1.35 $R_{\odot}$ at 432 and 150 MHz, respectively. Regions where storms originate are thus much denser than the ambient corona and their vertical extent is found to be less than expected from hydrostatic equilibrium. The smallest observed sizes impose upper limits on broadening effects due to scattering on density inhomogeneities in the low and medium corona and constrain the level of density turbulence in the solar corona. It is possible that scatter broadening has been overestimated in the past, and that the observed sizes cannot only be attributed to scattering. The vertical structure of the noise storms is difficult to reconcile with the classical columnar model.
△ Less
Submitted 30 December, 2014; v1 submitted 28 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Coronal turbulence and the angular broadening of radio sources - the role of the structure function
Authors:
M. Ingale,
P. Subramanian,
Iver Cairns
Abstract:
The amplitude of density turbulence in the extended solar corona, especially near the dissipation scale, impinges on several problems of current interest. Radio sources observed through the turbulent solar wind are broadened due to refraction by and scattering off density inhomogeneities, and observations of scatter broadening are often employed to constrain the turbulence amplitude. The extent of…
▽ More
The amplitude of density turbulence in the extended solar corona, especially near the dissipation scale, impinges on several problems of current interest. Radio sources observed through the turbulent solar wind are broadened due to refraction by and scattering off density inhomogeneities, and observations of scatter broadening are often employed to constrain the turbulence amplitude. The extent of such scatter broadening is usually computed using the structure function, which gives a measure of the spatial correlation measured by an interferometer. Most such treatments have employed analytical approximations to the structure function that are valid in the asymptotic limits $s \gg l_{i}$ or $s \ll l_{i}$, where $s$ is the interferometer spacing and $l_{i}$ is the inner scale of the density turbulence spectrum. We instead use a general structure function (GSF) that straddles these regimes, and quantify the errors introduced by the use of these approximations. We have included the effects of anisotropic scattering for distant cosmic sources viewed through the solar wind at small elongations. We show that the regimes where the GSF predictions are more accurate than those of the asymptotic expressions are not only of practical relevance, but are where inner scale effects influence estimates of scatter broadening. Taken together, we argue that the GSF should henceforth be used for scatter broadening calculations and estimates of turbulence amplitudes in the solar corona and solar wind.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Infrared Spectra and Chemical Abundance of Methyl Propionate in Icy Astrochemical Conditions
Authors:
B. Sivaraman,
N. Radhika,
A. Das,
G. Gopakumar,
L. Majumdar,
S. K. Chakrabarti,
K. P. Subramanian,
B. N. Raja Sekhar,
M. Hada
Abstract:
We carried out an experiment in order to obtain the InfraRed (IR) spectra of methyl propionate (CH3CH2COOCH3) in astrochemical conditions and present the IR spectra for future identification of this molecule in the InterStellar Medium (ISM). The experimental IR spectrum is compared with the theoretical spectrum and an attempt was made to assign the observed peak positions to their corresponding mo…
▽ More
We carried out an experiment in order to obtain the InfraRed (IR) spectra of methyl propionate (CH3CH2COOCH3) in astrochemical conditions and present the IR spectra for future identification of this molecule in the InterStellar Medium (ISM). The experimental IR spectrum is compared with the theoretical spectrum and an attempt was made to assign the observed peak positions to their corresponding molecular vibrations in condensed phase. Moreover, our calculations suggest that methyl propionate must be synthesized efficiently within the complex chemical network of the ISM and therefore be present in cold dust grains, awaiting identification.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
A study of density modulation index in the inner heliospheric solar wind during solar cycle 23
Authors:
Susanta Kumar Bisoi,
P. Janardhan,
M. Ingale,
P. Subramanian,
S. Ananthakrishnan,
M. Tokumaru,
K. Fujiki
Abstract:
The ratio of the rms electron density fluctuations to the background density in the solar wind (density modulation index, $ε_{N} \equiv Δ{N}/N$) is of vital importance in understanding several problems in heliospheric physics related to solar wind turbulence. In this paper, we have investigated the behavior of $ε_{N}$ in the inner-heliosphere from 0.26 to 0.82 AU. The density fluctuations $Δ{N}$ h…
▽ More
The ratio of the rms electron density fluctuations to the background density in the solar wind (density modulation index, $ε_{N} \equiv Δ{N}/N$) is of vital importance in understanding several problems in heliospheric physics related to solar wind turbulence. In this paper, we have investigated the behavior of $ε_{N}$ in the inner-heliosphere from 0.26 to 0.82 AU. The density fluctuations $Δ{N}$ have been deduced using extensive ground-based observations of interplanetary scintillation (IPS) at 327 MHz, which probe spatial scales of a few hundred km. The background densities ($N$) have been derived using near-Earth observations from the Advanced Composition Explorer ($\it{ACE}$). Our analysis reveals that $0.001 \lesssim ε_{N} \lesssim 0.02$ and does not vary appreciably with heliocentric distance. We also find that $ε_{N}$ declines by 8% from 1998 to 2008. We discuss the impact of these findings on problems ranging from our understanding of Forbush decreases to the behavior of the solar wind dynamic pressure over the recent peculiar solar minimum at the end of cycle 23..
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Constraining the amplitude of turbulence in solar corona using observations of angular broadening of radio sources
Authors:
Madhusudan Ingale,
Prasad Subramanian,
Iver H. Cairns
Abstract:
The angular broadening of compact radio sources observed through a medium having turbulent density irregularities is usually estimated using the phase structure function. We employ an exact formulation for the phase structure function that helps in obtaining an accurate estimate of angular broadening when the baseline lengths are comparable to the inner scale of the turbulent spectrum.
The angular broadening of compact radio sources observed through a medium having turbulent density irregularities is usually estimated using the phase structure function. We employ an exact formulation for the phase structure function that helps in obtaining an accurate estimate of angular broadening when the baseline lengths are comparable to the inner scale of the turbulent spectrum.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
How are Forbush decreases related with IP magnetic field enhancements ?
Authors:
Arunbabu K. P.,
P. Subramanian,
Sunil Gupta,
H. M. Antia
Abstract:
Cosmic ray Forbush decreases (FDs) are usually thought to be due to Earth-directed coronal mass ejections (CMEs) from the Sun and their associated shocks. When CMEs and their shocks reach the Earth, they cause magnetic field compressions. We seek to understand the relation between these magnetic field compressions and FDs at rigidities between 12 and 42 GV using data from the GRAPES-3 instrument a…
▽ More
Cosmic ray Forbush decreases (FDs) are usually thought to be due to Earth-directed coronal mass ejections (CMEs) from the Sun and their associated shocks. When CMEs and their shocks reach the Earth, they cause magnetic field compressions. We seek to understand the relation between these magnetic field compressions and FDs at rigidities between 12 and 42 GV using data from the GRAPES-3 instrument at Ooty. We find that the shapes of the Forbush decrease profiles show a startling similarity to that of the magnetic field compression in the near-Earth IP medium. We seek to understand the implications of this interesting result.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Self-similar expansion of solar coronal mass ejections: implications for Lorentz self-force driving
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
K. P. Arunbabu,
Angelos Vourlidas,
Adwiteey Mauriya
Abstract:
We examine the propagation of several CMEs with well-observed flux rope signatures in the field of view of the SECCHI coronagraphs aboard the STEREO satellites using the GCS fitting method of Thernisien, Vourlidas \& Howard (2009). We find that the manner in which they propagate is approximately self-similar; i.e., the ratio ($κ$) of the flux rope minor radius to its major radius remains approxima…
▽ More
We examine the propagation of several CMEs with well-observed flux rope signatures in the field of view of the SECCHI coronagraphs aboard the STEREO satellites using the GCS fitting method of Thernisien, Vourlidas \& Howard (2009). We find that the manner in which they propagate is approximately self-similar; i.e., the ratio ($κ$) of the flux rope minor radius to its major radius remains approximately constant with time. We use this observation of self-similarity to draw conclusions regarding the local pitch angle ($γ$) of the flux rope magnetic field and the misalignment angle ($χ$) between the current density ${\mathbf J}$ and the magnetic field ${\mathbf B}$. Our results suggest that the magnetic field and current configurations inside flux ropes deviate substantially from a force-free state in typical coronagraph fields of view, validating the idea of CMEs being driven by Lorentz self-forces.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Interacting CMEs and their associated flare and SEP activities
Authors:
A. Shanmugaraju,
S. Prasanna Subramanian
Abstract:
We have analyzed a set of 25 interacting events which are associated with the DH type II bursts. These events are selected from the Coronal Mass Ejections observed during the period 1997-2010 in SOHO/LASCO and DH type IIs in Wind/WAVES. Their pre and primary CMEs from nearby active regions are identified using LASCO and EIT images and their height-time diagrams. Their interacting time and height a…
▽ More
We have analyzed a set of 25 interacting events which are associated with the DH type II bursts. These events are selected from the Coronal Mass Ejections observed during the period 1997-2010 in SOHO/LASCO and DH type IIs in Wind/WAVES. Their pre and primary CMEs from nearby active regions are identified using LASCO and EIT images and their height-time diagrams. Their interacting time and height are obtained, and their associated activities, such as, flares and solar energetic particles (>10pfu) are also investigated. Results from the analysis are: primary CMEs are much faster than the pre-CMEs, their X-ray flares are also stronger (X and M class) compared to the flares (C and M class) of pre-CMEs. Most of the events occurred during the period 2000-2006. From the observed width and speed of pre and primary CMEs, the pre-CMEs are found to be less energetic than the primary CMEs. While the primary CMEs are tracked up to the end of LASCO field of view, most of the pre-CMEs are tracked up to < 26Rs. The SEP intensity is found to be related with the integrated flux of the X-ray flares associated with the primary CMEs for nine events originating from the western region.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
High rigidity Forbush decreases: due to CMEs or shocks?
Authors:
Arun Babu,
H. M. Antia,
S. R. Dugad,
S. K. Gupta,
Y. Hayashi,
S. Kawakami,
P. K. Mohanty,
T. Nonaka,
A. Oshima,
P. Subramanian
Abstract:
We seek to identify the primary agents causing Forbush decreases (FDs) observed at the Earth in high rigidity cosmic rays. In particular, we ask if such FDs are caused mainly by coronal mass ejections (CMEs) from the Sun that are directed towards the Earth, or by their associated shocks. We use the muon data at cutoff rigidities ranging from 14 to 24 GV from the GRAPES-3 tracking muon telescope to…
▽ More
We seek to identify the primary agents causing Forbush decreases (FDs) observed at the Earth in high rigidity cosmic rays. In particular, we ask if such FDs are caused mainly by coronal mass ejections (CMEs) from the Sun that are directed towards the Earth, or by their associated shocks. We use the muon data at cutoff rigidities ranging from 14 to 24 GV from the GRAPES-3 tracking muon telescope to identify FD events. We select those FD events that have a reasonably clean profile, and can be reasonably well associated with an Earth-directed CME and its associated shock. We employ two models: one that considers the CME as the sole cause of the FD (the CME-only model) and one that considers the shock as the only agent causing the FD (the shock-only model). We use an extensive set of observationally determined parameters for both these models. The only free parameter in these models is the level of MHD turbulence in the sheath region, which mediates cosmic ray diffusion (into the CME, for the CME-only model and across the shock sheath, for the shock-only model).
We find that good fits to the GRAPES-3 multi-rigidity data using the CME-only model require turbulence levels in the CME sheath region that are only slightly higher than those estimated for the quiet solar wind. On the other hand, reasonable model fits with the shock-only model require turbulence levels in the sheath region that are an order of magnitude higher than those in the quiet solar wind.
This observation naturally leads to the conclusion that the Earth-directed CMEs are the primary contributors to FDs observed in high rigidity cosmic rays.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Can solar wind viscous drag account for CME deceleration?
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
Alejandro Lara,
Andrea Borgazzi
Abstract:
The forces acting on solar Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs) in the interplanetary medium have been evaluated so far in terms of an empirical drag coefficient $C_{\rm D} \sim 1$ that quantifies the role of the aerodynamic drag experienced by a typical CME due to its interaction with the ambient solar wind. We use a microphysical prescription for viscosity in the turbulent solar wind to obtain an analy…
▽ More
The forces acting on solar Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs) in the interplanetary medium have been evaluated so far in terms of an empirical drag coefficient $C_{\rm D} \sim 1$ that quantifies the role of the aerodynamic drag experienced by a typical CME due to its interaction with the ambient solar wind. We use a microphysical prescription for viscosity in the turbulent solar wind to obtain an analytical model for the drag coefficient $C_{\rm D}$. This is the first physical characterization of the aerodynamic drag experienced by CMEs. We use this physically motivated prescription for $C_{\rm D}$ in a simple, 1D model for CME propagation to obtain velocity profiles and travel times that agree well with observations of deceleration experienced by fast CMEs.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
TeV blazar variability: the firehose instability?
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
Amit Shukla,
Peter A. Becker
Abstract:
Recently observed minute timescale variability of blazar emission at TeV energies has imposed severe constraints on jet models and TeV emission mechanisms. We focus on a robust jet instability to explain this variability. As a consequence of the bulk outflow of the jet plasma, the pressure is likely to be anisotropic, with the parallel pressure $P_{||}$ in the forward jet direction exceeding the p…
▽ More
Recently observed minute timescale variability of blazar emission at TeV energies has imposed severe constraints on jet models and TeV emission mechanisms. We focus on a robust jet instability to explain this variability. As a consequence of the bulk outflow of the jet plasma, the pressure is likely to be anisotropic, with the parallel pressure $P_{||}$ in the forward jet direction exceeding the perpendicular pressure $P_{\perp}$. Under these circumstances, the jet is susceptible to the firehose instability, which can cause disruptions in the large scale jet structure and result in variability of the observed radiation. For a realistic range of parameters, we find that the growth timescale of the firehose instability is $\approx$ a few minutes, in good agreement with the observed TeV variability timescales for Mrk 501 (Albert et al. 2007) and PKS 2155-304 (Aharonian et al. 2007).
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2012;
originally announced March 2012.
-
Constraints on coronal turbulence models from source sizes of noise storms at 327 MHz
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
Iver Cairns
Abstract:
We seek to reconcile observations of small source sizes in the solar corona at 327 MHz with predictions of scattering models that incorporate refractive index effects, inner scale effects and a spherically diverging wavefront. We use an empirical prescription for the turbulence amplitude $C_{N}^{2}(R)$ based on VLBI observations by Spangler and coworkers of compact radio sources against the solar…
▽ More
We seek to reconcile observations of small source sizes in the solar corona at 327 MHz with predictions of scattering models that incorporate refractive index effects, inner scale effects and a spherically diverging wavefront. We use an empirical prescription for the turbulence amplitude $C_{N}^{2}(R)$ based on VLBI observations by Spangler and coworkers of compact radio sources against the solar wind for heliocentric distances $R \approx$ 10--50 $R_{\odot}$. We use the Coles & Harmon model for the inner scale $l_{i}(R)$, that is presumed to arise from cyclotron damping. In view of the prevalent uncertainty in the power law index that characterizes solar wind turbulence at various heliocentric distances, we retain this index as a free parameter. We find that the inclusion of spherical divergence effects suppresses the predicted source size substantially. We also find that inner scale effects significantly reduce the predicted source size. An important general finding for solar sources is that the calculations substantially underpredict the observed source size. Three possible, non-exclusive, interpretations of this general result are proposed. First and simplest, future observations with better angular resolution will detect much smaller sources. Consistent with this, previous observations of small sources in the corona at metric wavelengths are limited by the instrument resolution. Second, the spatially-varying level of turbulence $C_{N}^{2}(R)$ is much larger in the inner corona than predicted by straightforward extrapolation Sunwards of the empirical prescription, which was based on observations between 10--50 $R_{\odot}$. Either the functional form or the constant of proportionality could be different. Third, perhaps the inner scale is smaller than the model, leading to increased scattering.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2011; v1 submitted 16 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Driving Currents for Flux Rope Coronal Mass Ejections
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
Angelos Vourlidas
Abstract:
We present a method for measuring electrical currents enclosed by flux rope structures that are ejected within solar coronal mass ejections (CMEs). Such currents are responsible for providing the Lorentz self-force that propels CMEs. Our estimates for the driving current are based on measurements of the propelling force obtained using data from the LASCO coronagraphs aboard the SOHO satellite. W…
▽ More
We present a method for measuring electrical currents enclosed by flux rope structures that are ejected within solar coronal mass ejections (CMEs). Such currents are responsible for providing the Lorentz self-force that propels CMEs. Our estimates for the driving current are based on measurements of the propelling force obtained using data from the LASCO coronagraphs aboard the SOHO satellite. We find that upper limits on the currents enclosed by CMEs are typically around $10^{10}$ Amperes. We estimate that the magnetic flux enclosed by the CMEs in the LASCO field of view is a few $\times 10^{21}$ Mx.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2008;
originally announced October 2008.
-
Forbush decreases and turbulence levels at CME fronts
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
H. M. Antia,
S. R. Dugad,
U. D. Goswami,
S. K. Gupta,
Y. Hayashi,
N. Ito,
S. Kawakami,
H. Kojima,
P. K. Mohanty,
P. K. Nayak,
T. Nonaka,
A. Oshima,
K. Sivaprasad,
H. Tanaka,
S. C. Tonwar
Abstract:
We seek to estimate the average level of MHD turbulence near coronal mass ejection (CME) fronts as they propagate from the Sun to the Earth. We examine the cosmic ray data from the GRAPES-3 tracking muon telescope at Ooty, together with the data from other sources for three well observed Forbush decrease events. Each of these events are associated with frontside halo Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs…
▽ More
We seek to estimate the average level of MHD turbulence near coronal mass ejection (CME) fronts as they propagate from the Sun to the Earth. We examine the cosmic ray data from the GRAPES-3 tracking muon telescope at Ooty, together with the data from other sources for three well observed Forbush decrease events. Each of these events are associated with frontside halo Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs) and near-Earth magnetic clouds. In each case, we estimate the magnitude of the Forbush decrease using a simple model for the diffusion of high energy protons through the largely closed field lines enclosing the CME as it expands and propagates from the Sun to the Earth. We use estimates of the cross-field diffusion coefficient $D_{\perp}$ derived from published results of extensive Monte Carlo simulations of cosmic rays propagating through turbulent magnetic fields. Our method helps constrain the ratio of energy density in the turbulent magnetic fields to that in the mean magnetic fields near the CME fronts. This ratio is found to be $\sim$ 2% for the 11 April 2001 Forbush decrease event, $\sim$ 6% for the 20 November 2003 Forbush decrease event and $\sim$ 249% for the much more energetic event of 29 October 2003.
△ Less
Submitted 29 December, 2008; v1 submitted 16 October, 2008;
originally announced October 2008.
-
Hybrid viscosity and the magnetoviscous instability in hot, collisionless accretion disks
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
Peter A. Becker,
Menas Kafatos
Abstract:
We aim to illustrate the role of hot protons in enhancing the magnetorotational instability (MRI) via the ``hybrid'' viscosity, which is due to the redirection of protons interacting with static magnetic field perturbations, and to establish that it is the only relevant mechanism in this situation. It has recently been shown by Balbus \cite{PBM1} and Islam & Balbus \cite{PBM11} using a fluid app…
▽ More
We aim to illustrate the role of hot protons in enhancing the magnetorotational instability (MRI) via the ``hybrid'' viscosity, which is due to the redirection of protons interacting with static magnetic field perturbations, and to establish that it is the only relevant mechanism in this situation. It has recently been shown by Balbus \cite{PBM1} and Islam & Balbus \cite{PBM11} using a fluid approach that viscous momentum transport is key to the development of the MRI in accretion disks for a wide range of parameters. However, their results do not apply in hot, advection-dominated disks, which are collisionless. We develop a fluid picture using the hybrid viscosity mechanism, that applies in the collisionless limit. We demonstrate that viscous effects arising from this mechanism can significantly enhance the growth of the MRI as long as the plasma $β\gapprox 80$. Our results facilitate for the first time a direct comparison between the MHD and quasi-kinetic treatments of the magnetoviscous instability in hot, collisionless disks.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2008;
originally announced February 2008.
-
An evaluation of possible mechanisms for anomalous resistivity in the solar corona
Authors:
K. A. P. Singh,
Prasad Subramanian
Abstract:
A wide variety of transient events in the solar corona seem to require explanations that invoke fast reconnection. Theoretical models explaining fast reconnection often rely on enhanced resistivity. We start with data derived from observed reconnection rates in solar flares and seek to reconcile them with the chaos-induced resistivity model of Numata & Yoshida (2002) and with resistivity arising…
▽ More
A wide variety of transient events in the solar corona seem to require explanations that invoke fast reconnection. Theoretical models explaining fast reconnection often rely on enhanced resistivity. We start with data derived from observed reconnection rates in solar flares and seek to reconcile them with the chaos-induced resistivity model of Numata & Yoshida (2002) and with resistivity arising out of the kinetic Alfvén wave (KAW) instability. We find that the resistivities arising from either of these mechanisms, when localized over lengthscales of the order of an ion skin depth, are capable of explaining the observationally mandated Lundquist numbers.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2007;
originally announced June 2007.
-
Electron acceleration in a post-flare decimetric continuum source
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
S. M. White,
M. Karlický,
R. Sych,
H. S. Sawant,
S. Ananthakrishnan
Abstract:
Aims: To calculate the power budget for electron acceleration and the efficiency of the plasma emission mechanism in a post-flare decimetric continuum source. Methods: We have imaged a high brightness temperature ($\sim 10^{9}$K) post-flare source at 1060 MHz with the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT). We use information from these images and the dynamic spectrum from the Hiraiso spectrogra…
▽ More
Aims: To calculate the power budget for electron acceleration and the efficiency of the plasma emission mechanism in a post-flare decimetric continuum source. Methods: We have imaged a high brightness temperature ($\sim 10^{9}$K) post-flare source at 1060 MHz with the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT). We use information from these images and the dynamic spectrum from the Hiraiso spectrograph together with the theoretical method described in Subramanian & Becker (2006) to calculate the power input to the electron acceleration process. The method assumes that the electrons are accelerated via a second-order Fermi acceleration mechanism. Results: We find that the power input to the nonthermal electrons is in the range $3\times 10^{25}$--$10^{26}$ erg/s. The efficiency of the overall plasma emission process starting from electron acceleration and culminating in the observed emission could range from $2.87\times 10^{-9}$ to $2.38 \times 10^{-8}$.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2007;
originally announced March 2007.
-
Electron acceleration in solar noise storms
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian
Abstract:
We present an up-to-date review of the physics of electron acceleration in solar noi se storms. We describe the observed characteristics of noise storm emission, emphasi zing recent advances in imaging observations. We briefly describe the general method ology of treating particle acceleration problems and apply it to the specific proble m of electron acceleration in noise storms. We dwell on th…
▽ More
We present an up-to-date review of the physics of electron acceleration in solar noi se storms. We describe the observed characteristics of noise storm emission, emphasi zing recent advances in imaging observations. We briefly describe the general method ology of treating particle acceleration problems and apply it to the specific proble m of electron acceleration in noise storms. We dwell on the issue of the efficiency of the overall noise storm emission process and outline open problems in this area.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2007;
originally announced January 2007.
-
Energetics of solar coronal mass ejections
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
Angelos Vourlidas
Abstract:
Aims: We investigate whether solar coronal mass ejections are driven mainly by coupling to the ambient solar wind or through the release of internal magnetic energy. Methods: We examine the energetics of 39 flux-rope like coronal mass ejections (CMEs) from the Sun using data in the distance range $\sim$ 2--20 $R_{\odot}$ from the Large Angle Spectroscopic Coronograph (LASCO) aboard the Solar and…
▽ More
Aims: We investigate whether solar coronal mass ejections are driven mainly by coupling to the ambient solar wind or through the release of internal magnetic energy. Methods: We examine the energetics of 39 flux-rope like coronal mass ejections (CMEs) from the Sun using data in the distance range $\sim$ 2--20 $R_{\odot}$ from the Large Angle Spectroscopic Coronograph (LASCO) aboard the Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO). This comprises a complete sample of the best examples of flux-rope CMEs observed by LASCO in 1996-2001. Results: We find that 69% of the CMEs in our sample experience a clearly identifiable driving power in the LASCO field of view. For the CMEs that are driven, we examine if they might be deriving most of their driving power by coupling to the solar wind. We do not find conclusive evidence in favor of this hypothesis. On the other hand, we find that their internal magnetic energy is a viable source of the required driving power. We have estimated upper and lower limits on the power that can possibly be provided by the internal magnetic field of a CME. We find that, on average, the lower limit to the available magnetic power is around 74% of what is required to drive the CMEs, while the upper limit can be as much as an order of magnitude larger.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2007; v1 submitted 6 January, 2007;
originally announced January 2007.
-
Further constraints on electron acceleration in solar noise storms
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
Peter A. Becker
Abstract:
We reexamine the energetics of nonthermal electron acceleration in solar noise storms. A new result is obtained for the minimum nonthermal electron number density required to produce a Langmuir wave population of sufficient intensity to power the noise storm emission. We combine this constraint with the stochastic electron acceleration formalism developed by Subramanian & Becker (2005) to derive…
▽ More
We reexamine the energetics of nonthermal electron acceleration in solar noise storms. A new result is obtained for the minimum nonthermal electron number density required to produce a Langmuir wave population of sufficient intensity to power the noise storm emission. We combine this constraint with the stochastic electron acceleration formalism developed by Subramanian & Becker (2005) to derive a rigorous estimate for the efficiency of the overall noise storm emission process, beginning with nonthermal electron acceleration and culminating in the observed radiation. We also calculate separate efficiencies for the electron acceleration -- Langmuir wave generation stage and the Langmuir wave -- noise storm production stage. In addition, we obtain a new theoretical estimate for the energy density of the Langmuir waves in noise storm continuum sources.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2006;
originally announced February 2006.
-
Combining visibilities from the Giant Meterwave Radio Telescope and the Nancay Radio Heliograph: High dynamic range snapshot images of the solar corona at 327 MHz
Authors:
Claude Mercier,
Prasad Subramanian,
Alain Kerdraon,
Monique Pick,
S. Ananthakrishnan,
P. Janardhan
Abstract:
We report first results from an ongoing program of combining visibilities from the Giant Meterwave Radio Telescope (GMRT) and the Nancay Radio Heliograph (NRH) to produce composite snapshot images of the sun at meter wavelengths. We describe the data processing, including a specific multi-scale CLEAN algorithm. We present results of a) simulations for two models of the sun at 327 MHz, with diffe…
▽ More
We report first results from an ongoing program of combining visibilities from the Giant Meterwave Radio Telescope (GMRT) and the Nancay Radio Heliograph (NRH) to produce composite snapshot images of the sun at meter wavelengths. We describe the data processing, including a specific multi-scale CLEAN algorithm. We present results of a) simulations for two models of the sun at 327 MHz, with differing complexity b) observations of a complex noise storm on the sun at 327 MHz on Aug 27 2002. Our results illustrate the capacity of this method to produce high dynamic range snapshot images when the solar corona has structures with scales ranging from the image resolution of 49" to the size of the whole sun.
We find that we cannot obtain reliable snapshot images for complex objects when the visibilities are sparsely sampled.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2005;
originally announced August 2005.
-
Cosmic ray electron acceleration in the remnant of nova GK Persei?
Authors:
N. G. Kantharia,
G. C. Anupama,
Prasad Subramanian
Abstract:
Radio observations of the nova remnant of GK Per around 1985 (epoch 1) have shown it to have a spectral index of -0.4 (S propto nu^alpha) at frequencies <1.4 GHz and a spectral index of -0.7 at frequencies >1.4 GHz (Seaquist et al 1989, Biermann et al 1995). This spectrum is either due to secondary electrons from p-p interactions (Biermann et al 1995) or due to the presence of at least two elect…
▽ More
Radio observations of the nova remnant of GK Per around 1985 (epoch 1) have shown it to have a spectral index of -0.4 (S propto nu^alpha) at frequencies <1.4 GHz and a spectral index of -0.7 at frequencies >1.4 GHz (Seaquist et al 1989, Biermann et al 1995). This spectrum is either due to secondary electrons from p-p interactions (Biermann et al 1995) or due to the presence of at least two electron populations which dominate the emission at different frequencies. Our radio observations (Anupama & Kantharia 2005) of the remnant of GK Persei using the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT) and archival Very Large Array (VLA) data show that the nova remnant has a low frequency (<1.3 GHz) spectral index alpha ~ -0.85 (in 2003; epoch 3) and a high frequency spectral index of alpha ~ -0.7 (1997; epoch 2). Moreover the higher frequencies show an annual secular decrease of ~ 2.1 % between epochs 1 and 2 whereas there is no change at 0.33 GHz. This suggests a significant evolution of the spectrum over 20 years. In this paper, we discuss a possible physical basis for this spectral evolution based on a comparison of the synchrotron loss and electron acceleration timescales.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2005;
originally announced August 2005.
-
Using transport coefficients of cosmic rays in turbulent magnetic fields to determine hybrid viscosity in hot accretion disks around AGN
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
Peter A. Becker,
Menas Kafatos
Abstract:
The nature of the viscosity operative in hot, two-temperature accretion disks around AGN has been a long-standing, unsolved problem. It has been previously suggested that protons, in conjunction with the turbulent magnetic field that is likely to exist in the accretion disk, might be crucial in providing this viscosity. Several authors have recently determined diffusion coefficients for charged…
▽ More
The nature of the viscosity operative in hot, two-temperature accretion disks around AGN has been a long-standing, unsolved problem. It has been previously suggested that protons, in conjunction with the turbulent magnetic field that is likely to exist in the accretion disk, might be crucial in providing this viscosity. Several authors have recently determined diffusion coefficients for charged particles (cosmic rays) propagating in turbulent magnetic fields by means of extensive Monte Carlo simulations. We use the diffusion coefficients for protons determined by these simulations to find the effective mean free path for protons in hot accretion disks. This in turn yields good estimates of the viscosity due to energetic protons embedded in the turbulent magnetic field of a hot, two-temperature accretion disk. We combine this with a simple two-temperature accretion disk model to determine the Shakura-Sunyaev $α$ viscosity parameter arising out of this mechanism. We find that protons diffusing in the turbulent magentic field embedded in a hot accretion d isk provide a physically reasonable source of viscosity in hot accretion disks around AGN.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2005;
originally announced July 2005.
-
Energetics of Coronal Mass Ejections
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
Angelos Vourlidas
Abstract:
We examine the energetics of the best examples of flux-rope CMEs observed by LASCO in 1996-2001. We find that 69% of the CMEs in our sample experience a driving power in the LASCO field of view. For these CMEs which are driven, we examine if they might be deriving most of their driving energy by coupling to the solar wind. We do not find conclusive evidence to support this hypothesis. We adopt t…
▽ More
We examine the energetics of the best examples of flux-rope CMEs observed by LASCO in 1996-2001. We find that 69% of the CMEs in our sample experience a driving power in the LASCO field of view. For these CMEs which are driven, we examine if they might be deriving most of their driving energy by coupling to the solar wind. We do not find conclusive evidence to support this hypothesis. We adopt two different methods to estimate the energy that can possibly be released by the internal magnetic fields of the CMEs. We find that the internal magnetic fields are a viable source of driving power for these CMEs.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2005;
originally announced February 2005.
-
Restrictions on the Physical Prescription for the Viscosity in Advection-Dominated Accretion Disks
Authors:
Peter A. Becker,
Prasad Subramanian
Abstract:
It has recently been demonstrated that the Shakura-Sunyaev prescription for the kinematic viscosity in an advection-dominated accretion disk yields physically reasonable solutions for the structure of the inflow close to the event horizon. In particular, no violations of relativistic causality occur at the horizon. This is somewhat surprising considering the diffusive nature of the angular momen…
▽ More
It has recently been demonstrated that the Shakura-Sunyaev prescription for the kinematic viscosity in an advection-dominated accretion disk yields physically reasonable solutions for the structure of the inflow close to the event horizon. In particular, no violations of relativistic causality occur at the horizon. This is somewhat surprising considering the diffusive nature of the angular momentum transport in the Shakura-Sunyaev scenario, and it is therefore natural to ask whether one can also obtain acceptable solutions for the disk structure based on the various alternative models for the viscosity that have been proposed, including the "deterministic" forms. In this paper we perform a rigorous asymptotic analysis of the structure of an advection-dominated accretion disk close to the event horizon of a nonrotating black hole based on three of the alternative prescriptions for the viscosity that have been suggested in the literature. We constrain the physical disk model by stipulating that the stress must vanish at the horizon, which is the fundamental inner boundary condition imposed by general relativity. Surprisingly, we find that none of the three alternative viscosity prescriptions yield physically acceptable disk structures close to the horizon when the zero-torque condition is applied, whether the flow is in vertical hydrostatic equilibrium or free-fall. Hence we conclude that the original Shakura-Sunyaev prescription is the only one proposed so far that is physically consistent close to the event horizon.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2004;
originally announced November 2004.
-
Noise storm continua: power estimates for electron acceleration
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
Peter A. Becker
Abstract:
We use a generic stochastic acceleration formalism to examine the power $L_{\rm in}$ (${\rm erg s^{-1}}$) input to nonthermal electrons that cause noise storm continuum emission. The analytical approach includes the derivation of the Green's function for a general second-order Fermi process, and its application to obtain the particular solution for the nonthermal electron distribution resulting…
▽ More
We use a generic stochastic acceleration formalism to examine the power $L_{\rm in}$ (${\rm erg s^{-1}}$) input to nonthermal electrons that cause noise storm continuum emission. The analytical approach includes the derivation of the Green's function for a general second-order Fermi process, and its application to obtain the particular solution for the nonthermal electron distribution resulting from the acceleration of a Maxwellian source in the corona. We compare $L_{\rm in}$ with the power $L_{\rm out}$ observed in noise storm radiation. Using typical values for the various parameters, we find that $L_{\rm in} \sim 10^{23-26}$ ${\rm erg s^{-1}}$, yielding an efficiency estimate $η\equiv L_{\rm out}/L_{\rm in}$ in the range $10^{-10} \lsim η\lsim 10^{-6}$ for this nonthermal acceleration/radiation process. These results reflect the efficiency of the overall process, starting from electron acceleration and culminating in the observed noise storm emission.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2004;
originally announced August 2004.
-
Angular momentum transport in accretion disks
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
B. S. Pujari,
Peter A. Becker
Abstract:
We reexamine arguments advanced by Hayashi & Matsuda (2001), who claim that several simple, physically motivated derivations based on mean free path theory for calculating the viscous torque in a quasi-Keplerian accretion disk yield results that are inconsistent with the generally accepted model. If correct, the ideas proposed by Hayashi & Matsuda would radically alter our understanding of the n…
▽ More
We reexamine arguments advanced by Hayashi & Matsuda (2001), who claim that several simple, physically motivated derivations based on mean free path theory for calculating the viscous torque in a quasi-Keplerian accretion disk yield results that are inconsistent with the generally accepted model. If correct, the ideas proposed by Hayashi & Matsuda would radically alter our understanding of the nature of the angular momentum transport in the disk, which is a central feature of accretion disk theory. However, in this paper we point out several fallacies in their arguments and show that there indeed exists a simple derivation based on mean free path theory that yields an expression for the viscous torque that is proportional to the radial derivative of the angular velocity in the accretion disk, as expected. The derivation is based on the analysis of the epicyclic motion of gas parcels in adjacent eddies in the disk.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2004; v1 submitted 16 March, 2004;
originally announced March 2004.
-
Giant Meterwave Radio Telescope observations of an M2.8 flare: insights into the initiation of a flare-coronal mass ejection event
Authors:
Prasad Subramanian,
S. Ananthakrishnan,
P. Janardhan,
M. R. Kundu,
S. M. White,
V. I. Garaimov
Abstract:
We present the first observations of a solar flare with the GMRT. An M2.8 flare observed at 1060 MHz with the GMRT on Nov 17 2001 was associated with a prominence eruption observed at 17 GHz by the Nobeyama radioheliograph and the initiation of a fast partial halo CME observed with the LASCO C2 coronograph. Towards the start of the eruption, we find evidence for reconnection above the prominence…
▽ More
We present the first observations of a solar flare with the GMRT. An M2.8 flare observed at 1060 MHz with the GMRT on Nov 17 2001 was associated with a prominence eruption observed at 17 GHz by the Nobeyama radioheliograph and the initiation of a fast partial halo CME observed with the LASCO C2 coronograph. Towards the start of the eruption, we find evidence for reconnection above the prominence. Subsequently, we find evidence for rapid growth of a vertical current sheet below the erupting arcade, which is accompanied by the flare and prominence eruption.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2003;
originally announced September 2003.