-
Gnevyshev gap in the large-scale magnetic field
Authors:
V. N. Obridko,
A. S. Shibalova,
D. D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
The phenomenon of the Gnevyshev gap was first identified in the solar-corona irradiance data (green line). Later, it was studied in the sunspot, coronal, and heliospheric data. We have investigated the Gnevyshev gap in the magnetic field data and have arrived at the conclusion that it reflects the behavior of the large-scale magnetic field. The Gnevyshev gap occurs at the polarity reversal of the…
▽ More
The phenomenon of the Gnevyshev gap was first identified in the solar-corona irradiance data (green line). Later, it was studied in the sunspot, coronal, and heliospheric data. We have investigated the Gnevyshev gap in the magnetic field data and have arrived at the conclusion that it reflects the behavior of the large-scale magnetic field. The Gnevyshev gap occurs at the polarity reversal of the solar magnetic field at the photosphere level. The presence of the Gnevyshev gap in sunspot data at the photosphere level is disguised by non-global structures that retain dependence on both latitude and longitude (the accepted mathematical term is tessaral, see below for more details). However, it is clearly visible in the magnetic field data at the photosphere level and is even more pronounced at the source surface (i.e., in the corona).
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Cyclic variations of the structure and energetics of solar magnetic fields
Authors:
V. N. Obridko,
A. S. Shibalova,
D. D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
The solar cycle is a complex phenomenon, a comprehensive understanding of which requires the study of various tracers. Here, we consider the solar cycle as manifested in the harmonics of the solar large-scale surface magnetic field, including zonal, sectorial and tesseral harmonics, divided into odd and even relative to the solar equator. In addition to considering the amplitudes of the harmonics,…
▽ More
The solar cycle is a complex phenomenon, a comprehensive understanding of which requires the study of various tracers. Here, we consider the solar cycle as manifested in the harmonics of the solar large-scale surface magnetic field, including zonal, sectorial and tesseral harmonics, divided into odd and even relative to the solar equator. In addition to considering the amplitudes of the harmonics, we analyze their contribution to the magnetic energy. It turns out that the relative contribution of different types of harmonics to the magnetic energy is virtually independent of the cycle height. We identify different phases of the activity cycle using harmonics of different symmetries. A possible way to incorporate the obtained result into the solar dynamo theory is proposed.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
The Structure of the Solar Cycle and of the Activity Cycles of Late-Type Stars
Authors:
V. N. Obridko,
D. D. Sokoloff,
M. M. Katsova
Abstract:
It is shown that the description of the solar cycle that takes into account the odd zonal harmonic of the solar magnetic field allows us to deepen our knowledge of two important aspects of the solar activity. First, to clarify and expand predictions of the evolution of the cyclic activity of the Sun in the near future. Second, to develop a program for monitoring the spectrophotometric characterist…
▽ More
It is shown that the description of the solar cycle that takes into account the odd zonal harmonic of the solar magnetic field allows us to deepen our knowledge of two important aspects of the solar activity. First, to clarify and expand predictions of the evolution of the cyclic activity of the Sun in the near future. Second, to develop a program for monitoring the spectrophotometric characteristics of radiation of the solar-type stars aimed at obtaining new information about their magnetic fields.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Relating photometric and magnetic properties of structures at solar surface
Authors:
V. N. Obridko,
D. D. Sokoloff,
M. K. Katsova
Abstract:
We investigate sharp structures visible in solar magnetic field tracers. It is shown that the sunspot magnetic boundaries do not coincide with the photometric ones. Moreover, there is no clear boundary of the magnetic field in the vicinity of sunspots. Thus, the widely accepted concept of magnetic tubes with sharp edges is not always correct and should be used with caution. It is also shown that e…
▽ More
We investigate sharp structures visible in solar magnetic field tracers. It is shown that the sunspot magnetic boundaries do not coincide with the photometric ones. Moreover, there is no clear boundary of the magnetic field in the vicinity of sunspots. Thus, the widely accepted concept of magnetic tubes with sharp edges is not always correct and should be used with caution. It is also shown that even in the moments of complete absence of visible spots on the Sun, there are magnetic fields over 800 Gauss. The nature of these strong magnetic fields remains unclear; they may originate at relatively small depths under the photosphere.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Some comments on the matching of photometric and magnetic properties of structures at the solar surface
Authors:
V. N. Obridko,
D. D. Sokoloff,
M. M. Katsova
Abstract:
We investigate sharply outlined features recorded in solar magnetic field tracers. It is shown that the magnetic boundaries of a sunspot do not coincide with the photometric ones. Moreover, there is no clear magnetic boundary around sunspots. Thus, the widely accepted concept of a magnetic tube with clearly pronounced borders is not always correct and should be used with caution. It is also shown…
▽ More
We investigate sharply outlined features recorded in solar magnetic field tracers. It is shown that the magnetic boundaries of a sunspot do not coincide with the photometric ones. Moreover, there is no clear magnetic boundary around sunspots. Thus, the widely accepted concept of a magnetic tube with clearly pronounced borders is not always correct and should be used with caution. It is also shown that even in the periods of complete absence of visible spots on the Sun, there are magnetic fields over 800 Gauss. The nature of these strong magnetic fields remains unclear; they may originate at relatively small depths under the photosphere.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Estimates of the Height and Date of the 25th Cycle of Solar Activity
Authors:
V. N. Obridko,
D. D. Sokoloff,
M. M. Katsova
Abstract:
Further development of the work of Obridko et al. [1] based on recent data confirms the assumption that the 25th cycle of solar activity is a medium-low cycle. Its height is expected to be $125.2\pm5.6$, and the expected date of the maximum phase is the end of 2023 or the first quarter of 2024.
Further development of the work of Obridko et al. [1] based on recent data confirms the assumption that the 25th cycle of solar activity is a medium-low cycle. Its height is expected to be $125.2\pm5.6$, and the expected date of the maximum phase is the end of 2023 or the first quarter of 2024.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Growth rate of the initial magnetic energy in isotropic velocity field with non-Gaussian distribution
Authors:
E. A. Illarionov,
D. D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
We propose a method for including the effects of non-Gaussian velocity field distribution in the estimation of growth rate of the magnetic energy in a random flow with finite memory time. The method allows a reduction to the Gaussian case that was investigates earlier. For illustration we consider the multivariate Laplace distribution and compare it against the Gaussian one.
We propose a method for including the effects of non-Gaussian velocity field distribution in the estimation of growth rate of the magnetic energy in a random flow with finite memory time. The method allows a reduction to the Gaussian case that was investigates earlier. For illustration we consider the multivariate Laplace distribution and compare it against the Gaussian one.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
The Extended Solar Cycle and Asymmetry of the Large-Scale Magnetic Field
Authors:
V. N. Obridko,
A. S. Shibalova,
D. D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
Traditionally, the solar activity cycle is thought as an interplay of the main dipole component of the solar poloidal magnetic field and the toroidal magnetic field. However, the real picture as presented in the extended solar-cycle models is much more complicated. Here, we develop the concept of the extended solar cycle clarifying what zonal harmonics are responsible for the equatorward and polar…
▽ More
Traditionally, the solar activity cycle is thought as an interplay of the main dipole component of the solar poloidal magnetic field and the toroidal magnetic field. However, the real picture as presented in the extended solar-cycle models is much more complicated. Here, we develop the concept of the extended solar cycle clarifying what zonal harmonics are responsible for the equatorward and polarward propagating features in the surface activity tracers. We arrive at a conclusion that the zonal harmonics with L = 5 play a crucial role in separating the phenomena of both types, which are associated with the odd zonal harmonics. Another objective of our analysis is the role of even zonal harmonics, which prove to be rather associated with the North-South asymmetry of the solar activity than with its 11-year solar periodicity.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Evolution of solar and stellar dynamo theory
Authors:
Paul Charbonneau,
Dmitry Sokoloff
Abstract:
In this paper, written as a general historical and technical introduction to the various review papers collected in the special issue ``Solar and Stellar Dynamo: A New Era'', we review the evolution and current state of dynamo theory and modelling, with emphasis on the solar dynamo. Starting with a historical survey, we then focus on a set of ``tension points'' that are still left unresolved despi…
▽ More
In this paper, written as a general historical and technical introduction to the various review papers collected in the special issue ``Solar and Stellar Dynamo: A New Era'', we review the evolution and current state of dynamo theory and modelling, with emphasis on the solar dynamo. Starting with a historical survey, we then focus on a set of ``tension points'' that are still left unresolved despite the remarkable progress of the past century. In our discussion of these tension points we touch upon the physical well-posedness of mean-field electrodynamics; constraints imposed by magnetic helicity conservation; the troublesome role of differential rotation; meridional flows and flux transpost dynamos; competing inductive mechanisms and Babcock-Leighton dynamos; the ambiguous precursor properties of the solar dipole; cycle amplitude regulation and fluctuation through nonlinear backreaction and stochastic forcing, including Grand Minima; and the promises and puzzles offered by global magnethydrodynamical numerical simulations of convection and dynamo action. We close by considering the potential bridges to be constructed between solar dynamo theory and modelling, and observations of magnetic activity in late-type stars.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Relative efficiency of three mechanisms of vector fields growth in a random media
Authors:
E. A. Illarionov,
D. D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
We consider a model of a random media with fixed and finite memory time with abrupt losses of memory (renovation model). Within the memory intervals we can observe either amplification or oscillation of the vector field in a given particle. The cumulative effect of amplifications in many subsequent intervals leads to amplification of the mean field and mean energy. Similarly, the cumulative effect…
▽ More
We consider a model of a random media with fixed and finite memory time with abrupt losses of memory (renovation model). Within the memory intervals we can observe either amplification or oscillation of the vector field in a given particle. The cumulative effect of amplifications in many subsequent intervals leads to amplification of the mean field and mean energy. Similarly, the cumulative effect of intermittent amplifications or oscillations also leads to amplification of the mean field and mean energy, however, at a lower rate. Finally, the random oscillations alone can resonate and yield the growth of the mean field and energy. These are the three mechanisms that we investigate and compute analytically and numerically the growth rates based on the Jacobi equation with the random curvature parameter.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Migrating Dynamo Waves and Consequences for Stellar Current Sheets
Authors:
E. Maiewski,
H. Malova,
V. Popov,
D. Sokoloff,
E. Yushkov
Abstract:
We study the relation between stellar dynamo-wave propagation and the structure of the stellar magnetic field. Modeling dynamo waves by the well-known Parker migratory dynamo, we vary the intensity of dynamo drivers in order to obtain activity-wave propagation toward the Equator (as in the solar-activity cycle) or towards the Poles. We match the magnetic field in the dynamo active shell with that…
▽ More
We study the relation between stellar dynamo-wave propagation and the structure of the stellar magnetic field. Modeling dynamo waves by the well-known Parker migratory dynamo, we vary the intensity of dynamo drivers in order to obtain activity-wave propagation toward the Equator (as in the solar-activity cycle) or towards the Poles. We match the magnetic field in the dynamo active shell with that in the surrounding stellar material, using a simple dissipativ magnetohydrodynamic system for the transition region. Introducing a weak asymmetry between the stellar hemispheres, we study phase shifts of the dipole, quadrupole, and octupole magnetic components at various distances from the star to demonstrate that several-percent asymmetry in dynamo drivers are sufficient to obtain a realistic relation between solar dipole and quadrupole moments. We study the behavior of the stellar current sheets and show that for the poleward propagating activity it is substantially different from solar ones. In particular, we demonstrate conditions in which the conical current sheets propagate opposite to the solar directions.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Clarifying Physical Properties of Magnetic Fields in Sunspots
Authors:
V. N. Obridko,
M. M. Katsova,
D. D. Sokoloff,
B. D. Shelting,
I. M. Livshits
Abstract:
We demonstrate that the radial magnetic-field component at the outer boundary of the sunspot penumbra is about 550 Mx cm$^{-2}$ independent of the sunspot area and the maximum magnetic field in the umbra. The mean magnetic-field intensity in sunspots grows slightly as the sunspot area increases up to 500 -- 1000 millionth of visual hemisphere (m.v.h.) and may reach about 900 -- 2000 Mx cm$^{-2}$.…
▽ More
We demonstrate that the radial magnetic-field component at the outer boundary of the sunspot penumbra is about 550 Mx cm$^{-2}$ independent of the sunspot area and the maximum magnetic field in the umbra. The mean magnetic-field intensity in sunspots grows slightly as the sunspot area increases up to 500 -- 1000 millionth of visual hemisphere (m.v.h.) and may reach about 900 -- 2000 Mx cm$^{-2}$. The total magnetic flux weakly depends on the maximum field strength in a sunspot and is determined by the spottedness, i.e. the sunspot number and the total sunspot area; however, the relation between the total flux and the sunspot area is substantially nonlinear. We suggest an explicit parametrization for this relation. The contribution of the magnetic flux associated with sunspots to the total magnetic flux is small, not achieving more than 20% even at the maximum of the solar activity.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Solar and stellar activity cycles -- no synchronization with exoplanets
Authors:
V. N. Obridko,
M. M. Katsova,
D. D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
Cyclic activity on the Sun and stars is primarily explained by generation of the magnetic field by a dynamo mechanism, which converts the energy of the poloidal field into the energy of the toroidal component due to differential rotation. There is, however, an alternative point of view, which explains the field generation by gravitational influence of the planetary system and, first of all, Jupite…
▽ More
Cyclic activity on the Sun and stars is primarily explained by generation of the magnetic field by a dynamo mechanism, which converts the energy of the poloidal field into the energy of the toroidal component due to differential rotation. There is, however, an alternative point of view, which explains the field generation by gravitational influence of the planetary system and, first of all, Jupiter. This hypothesis can be verified by comparing the characteristics of exoplanets with the activity variations on their associated stars. We have performed such a comparison and have drawn a negative conclusion. No relationship between the gravitational influence of the exoplanets and cycle of the host star could be found in any of the cases considered. Moreover, there are reasons to believe that a strong gravitational influence may completely eliminate cyclic variation in stellar activity.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Solar and stellar flares: frequency, active regions and stellar dynamo
Authors:
M. M. Katsova,
V. N. Obridko,
D. D. Sokoloff,
I. M. Livshits
Abstract:
We demonstrate that for weak flares the dependence on spottedness can be rather weak. The fact is that such flares can occur both in small and large active regions. At the same time, powerful large flares of classes M and X occur much more often in large active regions. In energy estimates, the mean magnetic field in starspots can also be assumed equal to the mean field in the sunspot umbra. So th…
▽ More
We demonstrate that for weak flares the dependence on spottedness can be rather weak. The fact is that such flares can occur both in small and large active regions. At the same time, powerful large flares of classes M and X occur much more often in large active regions. In energy estimates, the mean magnetic field in starspots can also be assumed equal to the mean field in the sunspot umbra. So the effective mean magnetic field is 900 Mx/cm$^2$ in sunspots and 2000 Mx/cm$^2$ in starspots. Moreover, the height of the energy storage cannot be strictly proportional to A$^{1/2}$. For stars, the fitting factor is an order of magnitude smaller. The analysis of the occurrence rate of powerful solar X-ray flares of class M and X and superflares on stars shows that, with allowance for the difference in the spottedness and compactness of active regions, both sets can be described by a single model. Thus, the problem of superflares on stars and their absence on the Sun is reduced to the problem of difference in the effectiveness of the dynamo mechanisms.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Synthetic solar cycle for active regions violating the Hale's polarity law
Authors:
A. Zhukova,
A. Khlystova,
V. Abramenko,
D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
Long observational series for bipolar active regions (ARs) provide significant information about the mutual transformation of the poloidal and toroidal components of the global solar magnetic field. The direction of the toroidal field determines the polarity of leading sunspots in ARs in accordance with the Hale's polarity law. The vast majority of bipolar ARs obey this regularity, whereas a few p…
▽ More
Long observational series for bipolar active regions (ARs) provide significant information about the mutual transformation of the poloidal and toroidal components of the global solar magnetic field. The direction of the toroidal field determines the polarity of leading sunspots in ARs in accordance with the Hale's polarity law. The vast majority of bipolar ARs obey this regularity, whereas a few percent of ARs have the opposite sense of polarity (anti-Hale ARs). However, the study of these ARs is hampered by their poor statistics. The data for five 11-year cycles (16-18 and 23,24) were combined here to compile a synthetic cycle of unique time length and latitudinal width. The synthetic cycle comprises data for 14838 ARs and 367 of them are the anti-Hale ARs. A specific routine to compile the synthetic cycle was demonstrated. We found that, in general, anti-Hale ARs follow the solar cycle and are spread throughout the time-latitude diagram evenly, which implies their fundamental connection with the global dynamo mechanism and the toroidal flux system. The increase in their number and percentage occurs in the second part of the cycle, which is in favour of their contribution to the polar field reversal. The excess in the anti-Hale ARs percentage at the edges of the butterfly diagram and near an oncoming solar minimum (where the toroidal field weakens) might be associated with strengthening of the influence of turbulent convection and magnetic field fluctuations on the arising flux tubes. The evidence of the misalignment between the magnetic and heliographic equators is also found.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Zonal harmonics of solar magnetic field for solar cycle forecast
Authors:
V. N. Obridko,
D. D. Sokoloff,
V. V. Pipin,
A. S. Shibalova,
I. M. Livshits
Abstract:
According to the scheme of action of the solar dynamo, the poloidal magnetic field can be considered a source of production of the toroidal magnetic field by the solar differential rotation. From the polar magnetic field proxies, it is natural to expect that solar Cycle 25 will be weak as recorded in sunspot data. We suggest that there are parameters of the zonal harmonics of the solar surface mag…
▽ More
According to the scheme of action of the solar dynamo, the poloidal magnetic field can be considered a source of production of the toroidal magnetic field by the solar differential rotation. From the polar magnetic field proxies, it is natural to expect that solar Cycle 25 will be weak as recorded in sunspot data. We suggest that there are parameters of the zonal harmonics of the solar surface magnetic field, such as the magnitude of the $\ell$=3 harmonic or the effective multipole index, that can be used as a reasonable addition to the polar magnetic field proxies. We discuss also some specific features of solar activity indices in Cycles 23 and 24.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2021; v1 submitted 24 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Finite memory time and anisotropy effects for initial magnetic energy growth in random flow of conducting media
Authors:
E. A. Illarionov,
D. D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
The dynamo mechanism is a process of magnetic field self-excitation in a moving electrically conducting fluid. One of the most interesting applications of this mechanism related to the astrophysical systems is the case of a random motion of plasma. For the very first stage of the process, the governing dynamo equation can be reduced to a system of first order ordinary differential equations. For t…
▽ More
The dynamo mechanism is a process of magnetic field self-excitation in a moving electrically conducting fluid. One of the most interesting applications of this mechanism related to the astrophysical systems is the case of a random motion of plasma. For the very first stage of the process, the governing dynamo equation can be reduced to a system of first order ordinary differential equations. For this case we suggest a regular method to calculate the growth rate of magnetic energy. Based on this method we calculate the growth rate for random flow with finite memory time and anisotropic statistical distribution of the stretching matrix and compare the results with corresponding ones for isotropic case and for short-correlated approximation. We find that for moderate Strouhal numbers and moderate anisotropy the analytical results reproduce the numerically estimated growth rates reasonably well, while for larger governing parameters the quantitative difference becomes substantial. In particular, analytical approximation is applicable for the Strouhal numbers s<0.6 and we find some numerical models and observational examples for which this region might be relevant. Rather unexpectedly, we find that the mirror asymmetry does not contribute to the growth rates obtained, although the mirror asymmetry effects are known to be crucial for later stages of dynamo action.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Magnetic fields in the accretion disks for various inner boundary conditions
Authors:
Daniela V. Boneva,
Evgeny A. Mikhailov,
Maria V. Pashentseva,
Dmitriy D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
The magnetic fields of accretion disks play an important role in studying their evolution. We may assume that its generation is connected to the dynamo mechanism, which is similar with that in the galactic disks. Here, we propose a model of the magnetic field of the accretion disk that uses the same approaches that have been used for galaxies. It is necessary to obtain the field, which is expected…
▽ More
The magnetic fields of accretion disks play an important role in studying their evolution. We may assume that its generation is connected to the dynamo mechanism, which is similar with that in the galactic disks. Here, we propose a model of the magnetic field of the accretion disk that uses the same approaches that have been used for galaxies. It is necessary to obtain the field, which is expected to be less than the equipartition value, and without destroying the disk. To do so, it is necessary to formulate the basic properties of the ionized medium and to estimate the parameters governing the dynamo. We used the no-z approximation that has been developed for thin disks. We also take different boundary conditions that can change the value of the field significantly. We show that the magnetic field strictly depends on the boundary conditions. Taking zero conditions and the fixed magnetic field condition on the inner boundary, which are connected to the physical properties of the accretion disk, we can avoid solutions that are greater than the equipartition field.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Solar large-scale magnetic field and cycle patterns in solar dynamo
Authors:
V. N. Obridko,
V. V. Pipin,
D. D. Sokoloff,
A. S. Shibalova
Abstract:
We compare spectra of the zonal harmonics of the large-scale magnetic field of the Sun using observation results and solar dynamo models. The main solar activity cycle as recorded in these tracers is a much more complicated phenomenon than the eigen solution of solar dynamo equations with the growth saturated by a back reaction of the dynamo-driven magnetic field on solar hydrodynamics. The nomina…
▽ More
We compare spectra of the zonal harmonics of the large-scale magnetic field of the Sun using observation results and solar dynamo models. The main solar activity cycle as recorded in these tracers is a much more complicated phenomenon than the eigen solution of solar dynamo equations with the growth saturated by a back reaction of the dynamo-driven magnetic field on solar hydrodynamics. The nominal 11(22)-year cycle as recorded in each mode has a specific phase shift varying from cycle to cycle; the actual length of the cycle varies from one cycle to another and from tracer to tracer. Both the observation and the dynamo model show an exceptional role of the axisymmetric $\ell_{5}$ mode. Its origin seems to be readily connected with the formation and evolution of sunspots on the solar surface. The results of observations and dynamo models show a good agreement for the low $\ell_{1}$ and $\ell_{3}$ modes. The results for these modes do not differ significantly for the axisymmetric and nonaxisymmetric models. Our findings support the idea that the sources of the solar dynamo arise as a result of both the distributed dynamo processes in the bulk of the convection zone and the surface magnetic activity.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2021; v1 submitted 14 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
A Catalog of Bipolar Active Regions Violating the Hale Polarity Law, 1989-2018
Authors:
A. Zhukova,
A. Khlystova,
V. Abramenko,
D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
There is no list of bipolar active regions (ARs) with reverse polarity (anti-Hale regions), although statistical investigations of such ARs (bearing the imprint of deep subphotospheric processes) are important for understanding solar-cycle mechanisms. We studied 8606 ARs from 1 January 1989 to 31 December 2018 to detect anti-Hale regions and to compile a catalog. The Solar and Heliospheric Observa…
▽ More
There is no list of bipolar active regions (ARs) with reverse polarity (anti-Hale regions), although statistical investigations of such ARs (bearing the imprint of deep subphotospheric processes) are important for understanding solar-cycle mechanisms. We studied 8606 ARs from 1 January 1989 to 31 December 2018 to detect anti-Hale regions and to compile a catalog. The Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO) and the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) data, as well as the Debrecen Photoheliographic Data, the Mount Wilson Observatory catalog and drawings, and the USAF/NOAA Solar Region Summary were used. Complex, ambiguous cases related to anti-Hale region identification were analyzed. Two basic and four additional criteria to identify an AR as an anti-Hale region were formulated. The basic criteria assume that: i) dominating features of an AR have to form a bipole of reverse polarity with sunspots/pores of both polarities being present; ii) magnetic connections between the opposite polarities has to be observed. A catalog of anti-Hale regions (275 ARs) is compiled. The catalog contains: NOAA number, date of the greatest total area of sunspots, coordinates, and corrected sunspot area for this date. The tilt and the most complex achieved Mount Wilson magnetic class are also provided. The percentage of anti-Hale groups meeting the proposed criteria is ~3.0% from all studied ARs, which is close to early estimations by authors who had examined each AR individually: ~2.4% by Hale and Nicholson (Ap.J. 62, 270, 1925) and ~3.1% by Richardson (Ap.J. 107, 78, 1948). The enchancement of the anti-Hale percentage in later research might be related to: i) increasing sensitivity of instruments (considering smaller and smaller bipoles); ii) the ambiguities in the anti-Hale region identification.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Shape of solar cycles and mid-term solar activity oscillations
Authors:
D. D. Sokoloff,
A. S. Shibalova,
V. N. Obridko,
V. V. Pipin
Abstract:
The evolution of the solar activity comprises, apart from the well-known 11-year cycle, various temporal scales ranging from months up to the secondary cycles known as mid-term oscillations. Its nature deserves a physical explanation. In this work, we consider the 5-to-6 year oscillations as derived both from sunspot and from solar magnetic dipole time series. Using the solar dynamo model, we dedu…
▽ More
The evolution of the solar activity comprises, apart from the well-known 11-year cycle, various temporal scales ranging from months up to the secondary cycles known as mid-term oscillations. Its nature deserves a physical explanation. In this work, we consider the 5-to-6 year oscillations as derived both from sunspot and from solar magnetic dipole time series. Using the solar dynamo model, we deduced that these variations may be a manifestation of the dynamo nonlinearities and non-harmonic shape of the solar activity cycles. We conclude that the observed mid-term oscillations are related to the nonlinear saturation of the dynamo processes in the solar interior.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2020; v1 submitted 29 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Estimates of current helicity and tilt of solar active regions and Joy's law
Authors:
K. Kuzanyan,
N. Kleeorin,
I. Rogachevskii,
D. Sokoloff,
H. Zhang
Abstract:
The tilt angle, current helicity and twist of solar magnetic fields can be observed in solar active regions. We carried out estimates of these parameters by two ways. Firstly, we consider the model of turbulent convective cells (super-granules) which have a loop floating structure towards the surface of the Sun. Their helical properties are attained during the rising process in the rotating strati…
▽ More
The tilt angle, current helicity and twist of solar magnetic fields can be observed in solar active regions. We carried out estimates of these parameters by two ways. Firstly, we consider the model of turbulent convective cells (super-granules) which have a loop floating structure towards the surface of the Sun. Their helical properties are attained during the rising process in the rotating stratified convective zone. The other estimate is obtained from a simple mean-field dynamo model that accounts magnetic helicity conservation. The both values are shown to be capable to give important contributions to the observable tilt, helicity and twist.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Wavelet analysis of the long-term activity of V833 Tau
Authors:
R. Stepanov,
N. I. Bondar',
M. M. Katsova,
D. Sokoloff,
P. Frick
Abstract:
The bulk of available stellar activity observations is frequently checked for the manifestation of signs in comparison with the known characteristic of solar magnetic modulation. The problem is that stellar activity records are usually an order of magnitude shorter than available observations of solar activity variation. Therefore, the resolved time scales of stellar activity are insufficient to d…
▽ More
The bulk of available stellar activity observations is frequently checked for the manifestation of signs in comparison with the known characteristic of solar magnetic modulation. The problem is that stellar activity records are usually an order of magnitude shorter than available observations of solar activity variation. Therefore, the resolved time scales of stellar activity are insufficient to decide reliably that a cyclic variation for a particular star is similar to the well-known 11-yr sunspot cycles. As a result, recent studies report several stars with double or multiple cycles which serve to challenge the underlying theoretical understanding. This is why a consistent method to separate 'true' cycles from stochastic variations is required. In this paper, we suggest that a conservative method, based on the best practice of wavelet analysis previously applied to the study of solar activity, for studying and interpreting the longest available stellar activity record - photometric monitoring of V833 Tau for more than 100 years. We find that the observed variations of V833 Tau with timescales of 2-50 yr should be comparable with the known quasi-periodic solar mid-term variations, whereas the true cycle of V833 Tau, if it exists, should be of about a century or even longer. We argue that this conclusion does not contradict the expectations from stellar dynamo theory.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Generation of strong magnetic fields in a nascent neutron star accounting for the chiral magnetic effect
Authors:
Maxim Dvornikov,
V. B. Semikoz,
D. D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
We propose the mean field dynamo model for the generation of strongest magnetic fields, $B\sim 10^{15}\,{\rm G}$, in a neutron star (NS) accounting for the chiral magnetic effect (CME) driven by the shock in a supernova (SN) progenitor of that NS. The temperature jump at a narrow shock front, where an initial magnetic field existing in inflowing matter rises sharply, is the source of the CME that…
▽ More
We propose the mean field dynamo model for the generation of strongest magnetic fields, $B\sim 10^{15}\,{\rm G}$, in a neutron star (NS) accounting for the chiral magnetic effect (CME) driven by the shock in a supernova (SN) progenitor of that NS. The temperature jump at a narrow shock front, where an initial magnetic field existing in inflowing matter rises sharply, is the source of the CME that prevails significantly the erasure of the CME due to the spin-flip through Coulomb collisions in plasma. The growth of the magnetic field just behind the shock given by the instability term $\nabla\times (α{\bf B})$ in induction equation, stops after a successful SN explosion that throws out the mantle of a protoneutron star. As a result, such an explosion interrupts the transfer of strongly magnetized plasma from the shock onto NS surface and leads to the saturation of the magnetic field. Assuming the rigid protostar rotation, we employ the mean field dynamo, which is similar to the $α^2$-dynamo known in the standard magnetohydrodynamics (MHD). The novelty of our model is that $α^2$-dynamo is based on concepts of particle physics, applied in MHD, rather than by a mirror asymmetry of convective vortices in the rotating convection.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Cyclic variations in the main components of the solar large-scale magnetic field
Authors:
V. N. Obridko,
D. D. Sokoloff,
B. D. Shelting,
A. S. Shibalova,
I. M. Livshits
Abstract:
We considered variations the dipole and the quadrupole components of the solar large-scale magnetic field. Both the axial and the equatorial dipoles exhibit a systematic decrease in the past four cycles in accordance with the general decrease of solar activity. The transition of the pole of a dipole from the polar region to mid latitudes occurs rather quickly, so that the longitude of the pole cha…
▽ More
We considered variations the dipole and the quadrupole components of the solar large-scale magnetic field. Both the axial and the equatorial dipoles exhibit a systematic decrease in the past four cycles in accordance with the general decrease of solar activity. The transition of the pole of a dipole from the polar region to mid latitudes occurs rather quickly, so that the longitude of the pole changes little. With time, however, this inclined dipole region shifts to larger longitudes, which suggests an acceleration of the dipole rotation. The mean rotation rate exceeds the Carrington velocity by 0.6%. The behavior of the quadrupole differs dramatically. Its decrease over last four cycles was much smaller than that of the dipole moment. The ratio of the quadrupole and dipole moments has increased for four cycles more than twice in contrast to the sunspot numbers, which displayed a twofold decrease for the same time interval. What about quadrupole rotation, the mean longitude of the poles of one sign decreased by 600 degrees over four cycles, which suggests that the mean rotation rate was lower than the Carrington velocity by 0.28%. We do not see however any conclusive evidence that, in the period under discussion, a mode of quadrupole symmetry was excited on the Sun along with the dipole mode.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
The origin and effect of hemispheric helicity imbalance in solar dynamo
Authors:
S. Yang,
V. V. Pipin,
D. D. Sokoloff,
K. M. Kuzanyan,
H. Zhang
Abstract:
In this paper we study the effects of hemispheric imbalance of magnetic helicity density on breaking the equatorial reflection symmetry of the dynamo generated large-scale magnetic field. Our study employs the axisymmetric dynamo model which takes into account the nonlinear effect of magnetic helicity conservation. We find that the evolution of the net magnetic helicity density, in other words, th…
▽ More
In this paper we study the effects of hemispheric imbalance of magnetic helicity density on breaking the equatorial reflection symmetry of the dynamo generated large-scale magnetic field. Our study employs the axisymmetric dynamo model which takes into account the nonlinear effect of magnetic helicity conservation. We find that the evolution of the net magnetic helicity density, in other words, the magnetic helicity imbalance, on the surface follows the evolution of the parity of the large-scale magnetic field. Random fluctuations of the $α$-effect and the helicity fluxes can inverse the causal relationship, i.e., the magnetic helicity imbalance or the imbalance of magnetic helicity fluxes can drive the magnetic parity breaking. We also found that evolution of the net magnetic helicity of the small-scale fields follows the evolution of the net magnetic helicity of the large-scale fields with some time lag. We interpret this as an effect of the difference of the magnetic helicity fluxes out of the Sun from the large and small scales.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2020; v1 submitted 24 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Spectral characteristic of mid-term quasi-periodicities in sunspots data
Authors:
P. Frick,
D. Sokoloff,
R. Stepanov,
V. Pipin,
I. Usoskin
Abstract:
Numerous analyses suggest the existence of various quasi-periodicities in solar activity. The power spectrum of solar activity recorded in sunspot data is dominated by the $\sim$11-year quasi-periodicity, known as the Schwabe cycle. In the mid-term range (1 month -- 11 years) a pronounced variability known as a quasi-biennial oscillation (QBO) is widely discussed. In the shorter time scale a prono…
▽ More
Numerous analyses suggest the existence of various quasi-periodicities in solar activity. The power spectrum of solar activity recorded in sunspot data is dominated by the $\sim$11-year quasi-periodicity, known as the Schwabe cycle. In the mid-term range (1 month -- 11 years) a pronounced variability known as a quasi-biennial oscillation (QBO) is widely discussed. In the shorter time scale a pronounced peak, corresponding to the synodic solar rotation period ($\sim$ 27 days) is observed. Here we revisited the mid-term solar variability in terms of statistical dynamic of fully turbulent systems, where solid arguments are required to accept an isolated dominant frequency in a continuous (smooth) spectrum. For that, we first undertook an unbiased analysis of the standard solar data, sunspot numbers and the F10.7 solar radioflux index, by applying a wavelet tool, which allows one to perform a frequency-time analysis of the signal. Considering the spectral dynamics of solar activity cycle by cycle, we showed that no single periodicity can be separated, in a statistically significant manner, in the specified range of periods. We examine whether a model of solar dynamo can reproduce the mid-term oscillation pattern observed in solar data. We found that a realistically observed spectrum can be explained if small spatial (but not temporal) scales are effectively smoothed. This result is important because solar activity is a it global feature, although monitored via small-scale tracers like sunspots.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Generation of strong magnetic fields in old neutron stars accounting for continuous chiral magnetic effect
Authors:
Maxim Dvornikov,
V. B. Semikoz,
D. D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
We suggest a new mean field dynamo model in anomalous MagnetoHydroDynamics (AMHD) accounting for the mean spin (polarization) of the magnetized chiral (ultrarelativistic) plasma of a neutron star (NS). For simplicity we consider a non-superfluid NS with its rigid rotation neglecting also any matter turbulence (convection) within a star. On this way, we recover the Chiral Magnetic Effect (CME) as a…
▽ More
We suggest a new mean field dynamo model in anomalous MagnetoHydroDynamics (AMHD) accounting for the mean spin (polarization) of the magnetized chiral (ultrarelativistic) plasma of a neutron star (NS). For simplicity we consider a non-superfluid NS with its rigid rotation neglecting also any matter turbulence (convection) within a star. On this way, we recover the Chiral Magnetic Effect (CME) as a possible source for the amplification of a seed, sufficiently strong magnetic field, $B\sim 10^{13}\,\text{G}$, up to values $B\gtrsim 10^{18}\,\text{G}$ in old NS's, having ages $t\gtrsim 10^6\,\text{yr}$. The important issue in AMHD model suggested is the continuous evolution of the chiral imbalance providing the CME for these ages, $\partial_tμ_5 (t)\neq 0$, in spite of the fast spin-flip in Coulomb collisions in the dense NS plasma that leads to vanishing $μ_5\to 0$ at an earlier epoch in the corresponding protoneutron star. In contrast to the conventional mean-field dynamos, the dynamo drivers in the model are produced due to magnetic field generated at the previous stages of stellar evolution. It makes our model basically nonlinear.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2020; v1 submitted 7 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
A short and sudden increase of the magnetic field strength and the accompanying spectral variability in the O9.7V star HD54879
Authors:
S. Hubrig,
M. Kueker,
S. P. Jarvinen,
A. F. Kholtygin,
M. Schöller,
E. B. Ryspaeva,
D. D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
Only eleven O-type stars have been confirmed to possess large-scale organized magnetic fields. The presence of a -600G longitudinal magnetic field in the O9.7V star HD54879 with a lower limit of the dipole strength of ~2kG, was discovered a few years ago in the framework of the ESO large program "B-fields in OB stars". Our FORS2 spectropolarimetric observations from 2017 October 4 to 2018 February…
▽ More
Only eleven O-type stars have been confirmed to possess large-scale organized magnetic fields. The presence of a -600G longitudinal magnetic field in the O9.7V star HD54879 with a lower limit of the dipole strength of ~2kG, was discovered a few years ago in the framework of the ESO large program "B-fields in OB stars". Our FORS2 spectropolarimetric observations from 2017 October 4 to 2018 February 21 reveal the presence of short and long-term spectral variability and a gradual magnetic field decrease from about -300G down to about -90G. Surprisingly, we discover on the night of 2018 February 17 a sudden, short-term increase of the magnetic field strength and measure a longitudinal magnetic field of -833G. The inspection of the FORS2 spectrum acquired during the observed magnetic field increase indicates a very strong change in spectral appearance with a significantly lower photospheric temperature and a decrease of the radial velocity by several 10km/s. Different scenarios are discussed in an attempt to interpret our observations. The FORS2 radial velocity measurements indicate that HD54879 is a member of a long-period binary.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2019; v1 submitted 13 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Magnetic arms of NGC6946 traced in the Faraday cubes at low radio frequencies
Authors:
Anton Chupin,
Rainer Beck,
Peter Frick,
George Heald,
Dmitry Sokoloff,
Rodion Stepanov
Abstract:
Magnetic fields in galaxies exist on various spatial scales. Large-scale magnetic fields are thought to be generated by the $α-Ω$ dynamo. Small-scale galactic magnetic fields (1 kpc and below) can be generated by tangling the large-scale field or by the small-scale turbulent dynamo. The analysis of field structures with the help of polarized radio continuum emission is hampered by the effect of Fa…
▽ More
Magnetic fields in galaxies exist on various spatial scales. Large-scale magnetic fields are thought to be generated by the $α-Ω$ dynamo. Small-scale galactic magnetic fields (1 kpc and below) can be generated by tangling the large-scale field or by the small-scale turbulent dynamo. The analysis of field structures with the help of polarized radio continuum emission is hampered by the effect of Faraday dispersion (due to fluctuations in magnetic field and/or thermal electron density) that shifts signals from large to small scales. At long observation wavelengths large-scale magnetic fields may become invisible, as in the case of spectro-polarimetric data cube of the spiral galaxy NGC~6946 observed with the Westerbork Radio Synthesis Telescope in the wavelength range 17-23 cm. The application of RM Synthesis alone does not overcome this problem. We propose to decompose the Faraday data cube into data cubes at different spatial scales by a wavelet transform. Signatures of the `magnetic arms' observed in NGC~6946 at shorter wavelengths become visible. Our method allows us to search for large-scale field patterns in data cubes at long wavelengths, as provided by new-generation radio telescopes.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Superflares on Giant Stars
Authors:
M. M. Katsova,
L. L. Kitchatinov,
D. Moss,
K. Olah,
D. D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
The Kepler mission identified huge flares on various stars including some of solar type. These events are substantially more energetic than solar flares, and so they are referred to as superflares. Even a small probability of such a superflare on the Sun would be a menace to modern society. A flare comparable in energy with that of superflares was observed on 24th and 25th September on the binary…
▽ More
The Kepler mission identified huge flares on various stars including some of solar type. These events are substantially more energetic than solar flares, and so they are referred to as superflares. Even a small probability of such a superflare on the Sun would be a menace to modern society. A flare comparable in energy with that of superflares was observed on 24th and 25th September on the binary HK Lac. Unlike the Kepler stars, there are observations of differential rotation for HK Lac. This differential rotation appears to be anti-solar. For anti-solar differential rotation, dynamo models can give magnetic activity waves of dipole symmetry as well as quasi-stationary magnetic configurations with quadrupole symmetry. The magnetic energy of such stationary configurations is usually about two orders of magnitude higher than that associated with activity waves. We believe that this mechanism could provide sufficient energy to produce superflares on late type stars, and present some simple models in support of this idea.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2018; v1 submitted 17 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Path integrals for mean-field equations in nonlinear dynamos
Authors:
Dmitry Sokoloff,
Nobumitsu Yokoi
Abstract:
Mean-field dynamo equations are addressed with the aid of the path-integral method. The evolution of magnetic field is treated as a three-dimensional Wiener random process, and the mean magnetic-field equations are obtained with the Wiener integral over all the trajectories of fluid particle. The form of the equations is just the same as the conventional mean-field equations, but the present equat…
▽ More
Mean-field dynamo equations are addressed with the aid of the path-integral method. The evolution of magnetic field is treated as a three-dimensional Wiener random process, and the mean magnetic-field equations are obtained with the Wiener integral over all the trajectories of fluid particle. The form of the equations is just the same as the conventional mean-field equations, but the present equations are derived with the velocity-field realization affected by the magnetic-field force. In this sense, the present ones are nonlinear dynamo equations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2018; v1 submitted 8 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Can superflares occur on the Sun? A view from dynamo theory
Authors:
M. M. Katsova,
L. L. Kitchatinov,
M. A. Livshits,
D. L. Moss,
D. D. Sokoloff,
I. G. Usoskin
Abstract:
Recent data from the Kepler mission has revealed the occurrence of superflares in sun-like stars which exceed by far any observed solar flares in release of energy. A natural idea is that the dynamo mechanism in superflaring stars differs in some respect from that in the Sun. We search for a difference in the dynamo-related parameters between superflaring stars and the Sun to suggest a dynamo-mech…
▽ More
Recent data from the Kepler mission has revealed the occurrence of superflares in sun-like stars which exceed by far any observed solar flares in release of energy. A natural idea is that the dynamo mechanism in superflaring stars differs in some respect from that in the Sun. We search for a difference in the dynamo-related parameters between superflaring stars and the Sun to suggest a dynamo-mechanism as close as possible to the conventional solar/stellar dynamo but capable of providing much higher magnetic energy. Dynamo based on joint action of differential rotation and mirror asymmetric motions can in principle result in excitation of two types of magnetic fields. First of all, it is well-known in solar physics dynamo waves. The point is that another magnetic configuration with initial growth and further stabilisation is also possible for excitation. For comparable conditions, magnetic field strength of second configuration is much larger rather of the first one just because dynamo do not spend its efforts for periodic magnetic field inversions but use its for magnetic field growth. We analysed available data from the Kepler mission concerning the superflaring stars in order to find tracers of anomalous magnetic activity. Starting from the recent paper, we find that anti-solar differential rotation or anti-solar sign of the mirror-asymmetry of stellar convection can provide the desired strong magnetic field in dynamo models. We confirm this concept by numerical models of stellar dynamos with corresponding governing parameters. We conclude that the proposed mechanism can plausibly explain the superflaring events at least for some cool stars, including binaries, subgiants and, possibly, low-mass stars and young rapid rotators.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Parity fluctuations in stellar dynamos
Authors:
D. L. Moss,
D. D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
Observations of the solar butterfly diagram from sunspot records suggest persistent fluctuation in parity, away from the overall, approximately dipolar structure. We use a simple mean-field dynamo model with a solar-like rotation law, and perturb the $α$-effect. We find that the parity of the magnetic field with respect to the rotational equator can demonstrate what we describe as resonant behavio…
▽ More
Observations of the solar butterfly diagram from sunspot records suggest persistent fluctuation in parity, away from the overall, approximately dipolar structure. We use a simple mean-field dynamo model with a solar-like rotation law, and perturb the $α$-effect. We find that the parity of the magnetic field with respect to the rotational equator can demonstrate what we describe as resonant behaviour, while the magnetic energy behaves in a more or less expected way. We discuss possible applications of the phenomena in the context of various deviations of the solar magnetic field from dipolar symmetry, as reported from analysis of archival sunspot data. We deduce that our model produces fluctuations in field parity, and hence in the butterfly diagram, that are consistent with observed fluctaions in solar behaviour.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
An Optical Atmospheric Phenomenon Observed in 1670 over the City of Astrakhan Was not a Mid-Latitude Aurora
Authors:
I. G. Usoskin,
G. A. Kovaltsov,
L. N. Mishina,
D. D. Sokoloff,
J. Vaquero
Abstract:
It has been recently claimed (Zolotova and Ponyavin, Solar Phys., 291, 2869, 2016, ZP16 henceforth) that a mid-latitude optical phenomenon, which took place over the city of Astrakhan in July 1670, according to Russian chronicles, was a strong aurora borealis. If this was true, it would imply a very strong or even severe geomagnetic storm during the quietest part of the Maunder minimum. However, a…
▽ More
It has been recently claimed (Zolotova and Ponyavin, Solar Phys., 291, 2869, 2016, ZP16 henceforth) that a mid-latitude optical phenomenon, which took place over the city of Astrakhan in July 1670, according to Russian chronicles, was a strong aurora borealis. If this was true, it would imply a very strong or even severe geomagnetic storm during the quietest part of the Maunder minimum. However, as we argue in this article, this conclusion is erroneous and caused by a misinterpretation of the chronicle record. As a result of a thorough analysis of the chronicle text, we show that the described phenomenon occurred during the daylight period of the day ("the last morning hour"), in the south direction ("towards noon"), and its description does not match that of an aurora. The date of the event was also incorrectly interpreted. We conclude that this phenomenon was not a mid-latitude aurora but an atmospheric phenomenon, the so-called sundog (or parhelion) which is a particular type of solar halo. Accordingly, the claim about a strong mid-latitude aurora during the deep Maunder minimum is not correct and should be dismissed.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Galactic winds and the origin of large-scale magnetic fields
Authors:
David Moss,
Dmitri Sokoloff
Abstract:
Observations of dwarf galaxies suggest the presence of large-scale magnetic fields. However the size and slow rotation of these galaxies appear insufficient to support a mean-field dynamo action to excite such fields. Here we suggest a new mechanism to explain large-scale magnetic fields in galaxies that are too small to support mean-field dynamo action. The key idea is that we do not identify lar…
▽ More
Observations of dwarf galaxies suggest the presence of large-scale magnetic fields. However the size and slow rotation of these galaxies appear insufficient to support a mean-field dynamo action to excite such fields. Here we suggest a new mechanism to explain large-scale magnetic fields in galaxies that are too small to support mean-field dynamo action. The key idea is that we do not identify large-scale and mean magnetic fields. In our scenario the the magnetic structures originate from a small-scale dynamo which produces small-scale magnetic field in the galactic disc and a galactic wind that transports this field into the galactic halo where the large turbulent diffusion increases the scale and order of the field. As a result, the magnetic field becomes large-scale; however its mean value remains vanishing in a strict sense. We verify the idea by numerical modelling of two distinct simplified configurations, a thin disc model using the no-$z$ approximation, and an axisymmetric model using cylindrical $r,z$ coordinates. Each of these allows reduction of the problem to two spatial dimensions. Taken together, the models support the proposition that the general trends will persist in a fully 3D model. We demonstrate that a pronounced large-scale pattern can develop in the galactic halo for a wide choice of the dynamo governing parameters. We believe that our mechanism can be relevant to explaining the presence of the fields observed in the halos of dwarf galaxies. We emphasize that detailed modelling of the proposed scenario needs 3D simulations, and adjustment to the specific dynamo governing parameters of dwarf galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Magnetic fields in ring galaxies
Authors:
D. Moss,
E. Mikhailov,
O. Silchenko,
D. Sokoloff,
C. Horellou,
R. Beck
Abstract:
Many galaxies contain magnetic fields supported by galactic dynamo action. However, nothing definitive is known about magnetic fields in ring galaxies. Here we investigate large-scale magnetic fields in a previously unexplored context, namely ring galaxies, and concentrate our efforts on the structures that appear most promising for galactic dynamo action, i.e. outer star-forming rings in visually…
▽ More
Many galaxies contain magnetic fields supported by galactic dynamo action. However, nothing definitive is known about magnetic fields in ring galaxies. Here we investigate large-scale magnetic fields in a previously unexplored context, namely ring galaxies, and concentrate our efforts on the structures that appear most promising for galactic dynamo action, i.e. outer star-forming rings in visually unbarred galaxies. We use tested methods for modelling $α-Ω$ galactic dynamos, taking into account the available observational information concerning ionized interstellar matter in ring galaxies. Our main result is that dynamo drivers in ring galaxies are strong enough to excite large-scale magnetic fields in the ring galaxies studied. The variety of dynamo driven magnetic configurations in ring galaxies obtained in our modelling is much richer than that found in classical spiral galaxies. In particular, various long-lived transients are possible. An especially interesting case is that of NGC 4513 where the ring counter-rotates with respect to the disc. Strong shear in the region between the disc and the ring is associated with unusually strong dynamo drivers for the counter-rotators. The effect of the strong drivers is found to be unexpectedly moderate. With counter-rotation in the disc, a generic model shows that a steady mixed parity magnetic configuration, unknown for classical spiral galaxies, may be excited, although we do not specifically model NGC 4513. We deduce that ring galaxies constitute a morphological class of galaxies in which identification of large-scale magnetic fields from observations of polarized radio emission, as well as dynamo modelling, may be possible. Such studies have the potential to throw additional light on the physical nature of rings, their lifetimes and evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Generation of hypermagnetic helicity and leptogenesis in early universe
Authors:
V. B. Semikoz,
Alexander Yu. Smirnov,
D. D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
We study hypermagnetic helicity and lepton asymmetry evolution in plasma of the early Universe before the electroweak phase transition (EWPT) accounting for chirality flip processes via inverse Higgs decays and sphaleron transitions which violate the left lepton number and wash out the baryon asymmetry of the Universe (BAU). In the scenario where the right electron asymmetry supports the BAU alone…
▽ More
We study hypermagnetic helicity and lepton asymmetry evolution in plasma of the early Universe before the electroweak phase transition (EWPT) accounting for chirality flip processes via inverse Higgs decays and sphaleron transitions which violate the left lepton number and wash out the baryon asymmetry of the Universe (BAU). In the scenario where the right electron asymmetry supports the BAU alone through the conservation law $B/3 - L_{eR}=const$ at temperatures $T>T_{RL}\simeq 10~TeV$ the following universe cooling leads to the production of a non-zero left lepton (electrons and neutrinos) asymmetry. This is due to the Higgs decays becoming more faster when entering the equilibrium at $T=T_{RL}$ with the universe expansion, $Γ_{RL}\sim T> H\sim T^2$ , resulting in the parallel evolution of the right and the left electron asymmetries at $T<T_{RL}$ through the corresponding Abelian anomalies in SM in the presence of a seed hypermagnetic field. The hypermagnetic helicity evolution proceeds in a self-consistent way with the lepton asymmetry growth. The role of sphaleron transitions decreasing the left lepton number turns out to be negligible in given scenario. The hypermagnetic helicity plays a key role in lepto/baryogenesis in our scenario and the more hypermagnetic field is close to the maximum helical one the faster BAU grows up the observable value , $B_{obs}\sim 10^{-10}$.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2016; v1 submitted 8 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Dynamo generated magnetic configurations in accretion discs and the nature of quasi-periodic oscillations in accreting binary systems
Authors:
David Moss,
Dmitri Sokoloff,
Valery Suleimanov
Abstract:
Magnetic fields are important for accretion disc structure. Magnetic fields in a disc system may be transported with the accreted matter. They can be associated with either the central body and/or jet, and be fossil or dynamo excited in situ. We consider dynamo excitation of magnetic fields in accretion discs of accreting binary systems in an attempt to clarify possible configurations of dynamo ge…
▽ More
Magnetic fields are important for accretion disc structure. Magnetic fields in a disc system may be transported with the accreted matter. They can be associated with either the central body and/or jet, and be fossil or dynamo excited in situ. We consider dynamo excitation of magnetic fields in accretion discs of accreting binary systems in an attempt to clarify possible configurations of dynamo generated magnetic fields. We first model the entire disc with realistic radial extent and thickness using an alpha-quenching non-linearity. We then study the simultaneous effect of feedback from the Lorentz force from the dynamo-generated field. We perform numerical simulations in the framework of a relatively simple mean-field model which allows the generation of global magnetic configurations. We explore a range of possibilities for the dynamo number, and find quadrupolar-type solutions with irregular temporal oscillations that might be compared to observed rapid luminosity fluctuations. The dipolar symmetry models with $R_α<0$ have lobes of strong toroidal field adjacent to the rotation axis that could be relevant to jet launching phenomena. We have explored and extended the solutions known for thin accretion discs.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
The dynamics of Wolf numbers based on nonlinear dynamo with magnetic helicity: comparisons with observations
Authors:
Ya. Kleeorin,
N. Safiullin,
N. Kleeorin,
S. Porshnev,
I. Rogachevskii,
D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
We investigate the dynamics of solar activity using a nonlinear one-dimensional dynamo model and a phenomenological equation for the evolution of Wolf numbers. This system of equations is solved numerically. We take into account the algebraic and dynamic nonlinearities of the alpha effect. The dynamic nonlinearity is related to the evolution of a small-scale magnetic helicity, and it leads to a co…
▽ More
We investigate the dynamics of solar activity using a nonlinear one-dimensional dynamo model and a phenomenological equation for the evolution of Wolf numbers. This system of equations is solved numerically. We take into account the algebraic and dynamic nonlinearities of the alpha effect. The dynamic nonlinearity is related to the evolution of a small-scale magnetic helicity, and it leads to a complicated behavior of solar activity. The evolution equation for the Wolf number is based on a mechanism of formation of magnetic spots as a result of the negative effective magnetic pressure instability (NEMPI). This phenomenon was predicted 25 years ago and has been investigated intensively in recent years through direct numerical simulations and mean-field simulations. The evolution equation for the Wolf number includes the production and decay of sunspots. Comparison between the results of numerical simulations and observational data of Wolf numbers shows a 70 % correlation over all intervals of observation (about 270 years). We determine the dependence of the maximum value of the Wolf number versus the period of the cycle and the asymmetry of the solar cycles versus the amplitude of the cycle. These dependencies are in good agreement with observations.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2016; v1 submitted 14 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Magnetic and gaseous spiral arms in M83
Authors:
P. Frick,
R. Stepanov,
R. Beck,
D. Sokoloff,
A. Shukurov,
M. Ehle,
A. Lundgren
Abstract:
Isotropic and anisotropic wavelet transforms are used to decompose the images of the spiral galaxy M83 in various tracers to quantify structures in a range of scales from 0.2 to 10 kpc. We used radio polarization observations at λ6 cm and 13 cm obtained with the VLA, Effelsberg and ATCA telescopes and APEX sub-mm observations at 870 μm, which are first published here, together with maps of the emi…
▽ More
Isotropic and anisotropic wavelet transforms are used to decompose the images of the spiral galaxy M83 in various tracers to quantify structures in a range of scales from 0.2 to 10 kpc. We used radio polarization observations at λ6 cm and 13 cm obtained with the VLA, Effelsberg and ATCA telescopes and APEX sub-mm observations at 870 μm, which are first published here, together with maps of the emission of warm dust, ionized gas, molecular gas, and atomic gas. The spatial power spectra are similar for the tracers of dust, gas, and total magnetic field, while the spectra of the ordered magnetic field are significantly different. The wavelet cross-correlation between all material tracers and total magnetic field is high, while the structures of the ordered magnetic field are poorly correlated with those of other tracers. -- The magnetic field configuration in M83 contains pronounced magnetic arms. Some of them are displaced from the corresponding material arms, while others overlap with the material arms. The magnetic field vectors at λ6 cm are aligned with the outer material arms, while significant deviations occur in the inner arms and in the bar region, possibly due to non-axisymmetric gas flows. Outside the bar region, the typical pitch angles of the material and magnetic spiral arms are very close to each other at about 10°. The typical pitch angle of the magnetic field vectors is about 20° larger than that of the material spiral arms. One of the main magnetic arms in M83 is displaced from the gaseous arms, while the other main arm overlaps a gaseous arm. We propose that a regular spiral magnetic field generated by a mean-field dynamo is compressed in material arms and partly aligned with them. The interaction of galactic dynamo action with a transient spiral pattern is a promising mechanism for producing such complicated spiral patterns as in M83.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2015; v1 submitted 2 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Current helicity and magnetic field anisotropy in solar active regions
Authors:
H. Xu,
R. Stepanov,
K. Kuzanyan,
D. Sokoloff,
H. Zhang,
Y. Gao
Abstract:
The electric current helicity density $\displaystyle χ=\langleε_{ijk}b_i\frac{\partial b_k}{\partial x_j}\rangle$ contains six terms, where $b_i$ are components of the magnetic field. Due to the observational limitations, only four of the above six terms can be inferred from solar photospheric vector magnetograms. By comparing the results for simulation we distinguished the statistical difference…
▽ More
The electric current helicity density $\displaystyle χ=\langleε_{ijk}b_i\frac{\partial b_k}{\partial x_j}\rangle$ contains six terms, where $b_i$ are components of the magnetic field. Due to the observational limitations, only four of the above six terms can be inferred from solar photospheric vector magnetograms. By comparing the results for simulation we distinguished the statistical difference of above six terms for isotropic and anisotropic cases. We estimated the relative degree of anisotropy for three typical active regions and found that it is of order 0.8 which means the assumption of local isotropy for the observable current helicity density terms is generally not satisfied for solar active regions. Upon studies of the statistical properties of the anisotropy of magnetic field of solar active regions with latitudes and with evolution in the solar cycle, we conclude that the consistency of that assumption of local homogeneity and isotropy requires further analysis in the light of our findings.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
The Maunder minimum (1645--1715) was indeed a Grand minimum: A reassessment of multiple datasets
Authors:
Ilya G. Usoskin,
Rainer Arlt,
Eleanna Asvestari,
Ed Hawkins,
Maarit Käpylä,
Gennady A. Kovaltsov,
Natalie Krivova,
Michael Lockwood,
Kalevi Mursula,
Jezebel O'Reilly,
Matthew Owens,
Chris J. Scott,
Dmitry D. Sokoloff,
Sami K. Solanki,
Willie Soon,
José M. Vaquero
Abstract:
Aims: Although the time of the Maunder minimum (1645--1715) is widely known as a period of extremely low solar activity, claims are still debated that solar activity during that period might still have been moderate, even higher than the current solar cycle #24. We have revisited all the existing pieces of evidence and datasets, both direct and indirect, to assess the level of solar activity durin…
▽ More
Aims: Although the time of the Maunder minimum (1645--1715) is widely known as a period of extremely low solar activity, claims are still debated that solar activity during that period might still have been moderate, even higher than the current solar cycle #24. We have revisited all the existing pieces of evidence and datasets, both direct and indirect, to assess the level of solar activity during the Maunder minimum.
Methods: We discuss the East Asian naked-eye sunspot observations, the telescopic solar observations, the fraction of sunspot active days, the latitudinal extent of sunspot positions, auroral sightings at high latitudes, cosmogenic radionuclide data as well as solar eclipse observations for that period. We also consider peculiar features of the Sun (very strong hemispheric asymmetry of sunspot location, unusual differential rotation and the lack of the K-corona) that imply a special mode of solar activity during the Maunder minimum.
Results: The level of solar activity during the Maunder minimum is reassessed on the basis of all available data sets.
Conclusions: We conclude that solar activity was indeed at an exceptionally low level during the Maunder minimum. Although the exact level is still unclear, it was definitely below that during the Dalton minimum around 1800 and significantly below that of the current solar cycle #24. Claims of a moderate-to-high level of solar activity during the Maunder minimum are rejected at a high confidence level.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Solar small-scale dynamo and polarity of sunspot groups
Authors:
D. Sokoloff,
A. Khlystova,
V. Abramenko
Abstract:
In order to clarify a possible role of small-scale dynamo in formation of solar magnetic field, we suggest an observational test for small-scale dynamo action based on statistics of anti-Hale sunspot groups. As we have shown, according to theoretical expectations the small-scale dynamo action has to provide a population of sunspot groups which do not follow the Hale polarity law, and the density o…
▽ More
In order to clarify a possible role of small-scale dynamo in formation of solar magnetic field, we suggest an observational test for small-scale dynamo action based on statistics of anti-Hale sunspot groups. As we have shown, according to theoretical expectations the small-scale dynamo action has to provide a population of sunspot groups which do not follow the Hale polarity law, and the density of such groups on the time-latitude diagram is expected to be independent on the phase of the solar cycle. Correspondingly, a percentage of the anti-Hale groups is expected to reach its maximum values during solar minima. For several solar cycles, we considered statistics of anti-Hale groups obtained by several scientific teams, including ours, to find that the percentage of anti-Hale groups becomes indeed maximal during a solar minimum. Our interpretation is that this fact may be explained by the small-scale dynamo action inside the solar convective zone.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
The formation of regular interarm magnetic fields in spiral galaxies
Authors:
David Moss,
Rodion Stepanov,
Marita Krause,
Rainer Beck,
Dmitri Sokoloff
Abstract:
Observations of regular magnetic fields in several nearby galaxies reveal magnetic arms situated between the material arms. The nature of these magnetic arms is a topic of active debate. Previously we found a hint that taking into account the effects of injections of small-scale magnetic fields generated, e.g., by turbulent dynamo action, into the large-scale galactic dynamo can result in magnetic…
▽ More
Observations of regular magnetic fields in several nearby galaxies reveal magnetic arms situated between the material arms. The nature of these magnetic arms is a topic of active debate. Previously we found a hint that taking into account the effects of injections of small-scale magnetic fields generated, e.g., by turbulent dynamo action, into the large-scale galactic dynamo can result in magnetic arm formation. We now investigate the joint roles of an arm/interarm turbulent diffusivity contrast and injections of small-scale magnetic field on the formation of large-scale magnetic field ("magnetic arms") in the interarm region. We use the relatively simple "no-$z$" model for the galactic dynamo. This involves projection on to the galactic equatorial plane of the azimuthal and radial magnetic field components; the field component orthogonal to the galactic plane is estimated from the solenoidality condition. We find that addition of diffusivity gradients to the effect of magnetic field injections makes the magnetic arms much more pronounced. In particular, the regular magnetic field component becomes larger in the interarm space compared to that within the material arms.The joint action of the turbulent diffusivity contrast and small-scale magnetic field injections (with the possible participation of other effects previously suggested) appears to be a plausible explanation for the phenomenon of magnetic arms.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2015; v1 submitted 29 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Towards understanding dynamo action in M dwarfs
Authors:
D. Shulyak,
D. Sokoloff,
L. Kitchatinov,
D. Moss
Abstract:
Recent progress in observational studies of magnetic activity in M dwarfs urgently requires support from ideas of stellar dynamo theory. We propose a strategy to connect observational and theoretical studies. In particular, we suggest four magnetic configurations that appear relevant to dwarfs from the viewpoint of the most conservative version of dynamo theory, and discuss observational tests to…
▽ More
Recent progress in observational studies of magnetic activity in M dwarfs urgently requires support from ideas of stellar dynamo theory. We propose a strategy to connect observational and theoretical studies. In particular, we suggest four magnetic configurations that appear relevant to dwarfs from the viewpoint of the most conservative version of dynamo theory, and discuss observational tests to identify the configurations observationally. As expected, any such identification contains substantial uncertainties. However the situation in general looks less pessimistic than might be expected. Several identifications between the phenomenology of individual stars and dynamo models are suggested. Remarkably, all models discussed predict substantial surface magnetic activity at rather high stellar latitudes. This prediction looks unexpected from the viewpoint of our experience observing the Sun (which of course differs in some fundamental ways from these late-type dwarfs). We stress that a fuller understanding of the topic requires a long-term (at least 15 years) monitoring of M dwarfs by Zeeman-Doppler imaging.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Evolution of Magnetic Helicity and Energy Spectra of Solar Active Regions
Authors:
Hongqi Zhang,
Axel Brandenburg,
D. D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
We adopt an isotropic representation of the Fourier-transformed two-point correlation tensor of the magnetic field to estimate the magnetic energy and helicity spectra as well as current helicity spectra of two individual active regions (NOAA 11158 and NOAA 11515) and the change of the spectral indices during their development as well as during the solar cycle. The departure of the spectral indice…
▽ More
We adopt an isotropic representation of the Fourier-transformed two-point correlation tensor of the magnetic field to estimate the magnetic energy and helicity spectra as well as current helicity spectra of two individual active regions (NOAA 11158 and NOAA 11515) and the change of the spectral indices during their development as well as during the solar cycle. The departure of the spectral indices of magnetic energy and current helicity from 5/3 are analyzed, and it is found that it is lower than the spectral index of the magnetic energy spectrum. Furthermore, the fractional magnetic helicity tends to increase when the scale of the energy-carrying magnetic structures increases. The magnetic helicity of NOAA 11515 violates the expected hemispheric sign rule, which is interpreted as an effect of enhanced field strengths at scales larger than 30-60Mm with opposite signs of helicity. This is consistent with the general cycle dependence, which shows that around the solar maximum the magnetic energy and helicity spectra are steeper, emphasizing the large-scale field.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2016; v1 submitted 3 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Magnetic Field Tomography in Nearby Galaxies with the Square Kilometre Array
Authors:
George Heald,
Rainer Beck,
W. J. G. de Blok,
Ralf-Juergen Dettmar,
Andrew Fletcher,
Bryan Gaensler,
Marijke Haverkorn,
Volker Heesen,
Cathy Horellou,
Marita Krause,
Sui Ann Mao,
Niels Oppermann,
Anna Scaife,
Dmitry Sokoloff,
Jeroen Stil,
Fatemeh Tabatabaei,
Keitaro Takahashi,
Russ Taylor,
Anna Williams
Abstract:
Magnetic fields play an important role in shaping the structure and evolution of the interstellar medium (ISM) of galaxies, but the details of this relationship remain unclear. With SKA1, the 3D structure of galactic magnetic fields and its connection to star formation will be revealed. A highly sensitive probe of the internal structure of the magnetoionized ISM is the partial depolarization of sy…
▽ More
Magnetic fields play an important role in shaping the structure and evolution of the interstellar medium (ISM) of galaxies, but the details of this relationship remain unclear. With SKA1, the 3D structure of galactic magnetic fields and its connection to star formation will be revealed. A highly sensitive probe of the internal structure of the magnetoionized ISM is the partial depolarization of synchrotron radiation from inside the volume. Different configurations of magnetic field and ionized gas within the resolution element of the telescope lead to frequency-dependent changes in the observed degree of polarization. The results of spectro-polarimetric observations are tied to physical structure in the ISM through comparison with detailed modeling, supplemented with the use of new analysis techniques that are being actively developed and studied within the community such as Rotation Measure Synthesis. The SKA will enable this field to come into its own and begin the study of the detailed structure of the magnetized ISM in a sample of nearby galaxies, thanks to its extraordinary wideband capabilities coupled with the combination of excellent surface brightness sensitivity and angular resolution.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Structure, dynamical impact and origin of magnetic fields in nearby galaxies in the SKA era
Authors:
Rainer Beck,
Dominik Bomans,
Sergio Colafrancesco,
Ralf-Jürgen Dettmar,
Katia Ferrière,
Andrew Fletcher,
George Heald,
Volker Heesen,
Cathy Horellou,
Marita Krause,
Yu-Qing Lou,
Sui Ann Mao,
Rosita Paladino,
Eva Schinnerer,
Dmitry Sokoloff,
Jeroen Stil,
Fatemeh Tabatabaei
Abstract:
Magnetic fields are an important ingredient of the interstellar medium (ISM). Besides their importance for star formation, they govern the transport of cosmic rays, relevant to the launch and regulation of galactic outflows and winds, which in turn are pivotal in shaping the structure of halo magnetic fields. Mapping the small-scale structure of interstellar magnetic fields in many nearby galaxies…
▽ More
Magnetic fields are an important ingredient of the interstellar medium (ISM). Besides their importance for star formation, they govern the transport of cosmic rays, relevant to the launch and regulation of galactic outflows and winds, which in turn are pivotal in shaping the structure of halo magnetic fields. Mapping the small-scale structure of interstellar magnetic fields in many nearby galaxies is crucial to understand the interaction between gas and magnetic fields, in particular how gas flows are affected. Elucidation of the magnetic role in, e.g., triggering star formation, forming and stabilising spiral arms, driving outflows, gas heating by reconnection and magnetising the intergalactic medium has the potential to revolutionise our physical picture of the ISM and galaxy evolution in general. Radio polarisation observations in the very nearest galaxies at high frequencies (>= 3 GHz) and with high spatial resolution (<= 5") hold the key here. The galaxy survey with SKA1 that we propose will also be a major step to understand the galactic dynamo, which is important for models of galaxy evolution and for astrophysical magnetohydrodynamics in general. Field amplification by turbulent gas motions, which is crucial for efficient dynamo action, has been investigated so far only in simulations, while compelling evidence of turbulent fields from observations is still lacking.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
The Properties of the Tilts of Bipolar Solar Regions
Authors:
E. Illarionov,
A. Tlatov,
D. Sokoloff
Abstract:
We investigate various properties associated with the tilt of isolated magnetic bipoles in magnetograms taken at the solar surface. We show that bipoles can be divided into two groups which have tilts of opposite signs, and reveal similar properties with respect to bipole area, flux and bipolar moment. Detailed comparison of these physical quantities shows that the dividing point between the two t…
▽ More
We investigate various properties associated with the tilt of isolated magnetic bipoles in magnetograms taken at the solar surface. We show that bipoles can be divided into two groups which have tilts of opposite signs, and reveal similar properties with respect to bipole area, flux and bipolar moment. Detailed comparison of these physical quantities shows that the dividing point between the two types of bipoles corresponds to a bipole area of about 300 millionths of the solar hemisphere (MHS). The time-latitude distribution of small bipoles differs substantially from that for large bipoles. Such behaviour in terms of dynamo theory may indicate that small and large bipoles trace different components of the solar magnetic field. The other possible viewpoint is that the difference in tilt data for small and large bipoles is connected with spectral helicity separation, which results in opposite tilts for small and large bipoles. We note that the data available do not provide convincing reasons to prefer either interpretation.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.