-
Markov Walk Exploration of Model Spaces: Bayesian Selection of Dark Energy Models with Supernovae
Authors:
Benedikt Schosser,
Tobias Röspel,
Bjoern Malte Schaefer
Abstract:
Central to model selection is a trade-off between performing a good fit and low model complexity: A model of higher complexity should only be favoured over a simpler model if it provides significantly better fits. In Bayesian terms, this can be achieved by considering the evidence ratio, enabling choices between two competing models. We generalise this concept by constructing Markovian random walk…
▽ More
Central to model selection is a trade-off between performing a good fit and low model complexity: A model of higher complexity should only be favoured over a simpler model if it provides significantly better fits. In Bayesian terms, this can be achieved by considering the evidence ratio, enabling choices between two competing models. We generalise this concept by constructing Markovian random walks for exploring the entire model spaces governed by the logarithmic evidence ratio, in analogy to the logarithmic likelihood ratio in parameter estimation problems. The theory of Markovian model exploration has an analytical description with partition functions, which we derive for both the canonical and macrocanonical case. We apply our methodology to selecting a polynomial for the dark energy equation of state function $w(a)$ fulfilling sensible physical priors, on the basis of data for the supernova distance-redshift relation. We conclude by commenting on the Jeffrey scale for Bayesian evidence ratios, choices of model priors and derived quantities like Shannon entropies for posterior model probabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Bayesian distances for quantifying tensions in cosmological inference and the surprise statistic
Authors:
Benedikt Schosser,
Pedro Riba Mello,
Miguel Quartin,
Bjoern Malte Schaefer
Abstract:
Tensions between cosmological parameters derived through different channels can be a genuine signature of new physics that $Λ$CDM as the standard model is not able to reproduce, in particular in the missing consistency between parameter estimates from measurements the early and late Universe. Or, they could be caused by yet to be understood systematics in the measurements as a more mundane explana…
▽ More
Tensions between cosmological parameters derived through different channels can be a genuine signature of new physics that $Λ$CDM as the standard model is not able to reproduce, in particular in the missing consistency between parameter estimates from measurements the early and late Universe. Or, they could be caused by yet to be understood systematics in the measurements as a more mundane explanation. Commonly, cosmological tensions are stated in terms of mismatches of the posterior parameter distributions, often assuming Gaussian statistics. More importantly, though, would be a quantification if two data sets are consistent to each other before combining them into a joint measurement, ideally isolating hints at individual data points that have a strong influence in generating the tension. For this purpose, we start with statistical divergences applied to posterior distributions following from different data sets and develop the theory of a Fisher metric between two data sets, in analogy to the Fisher metric for different parameter choices. As a topical example, we consider the tension in the Hubble-Lemaître constant $H_0$ from supernova and measurements of the cosmic microwave background, derive a ranking of data points in order of their influence on the tension on $H_0$. For this particular example, we compute Bayesian distance measures and show that in the light of CMB data, supernovae are commonly too bright, whereas the low-$\ell$ CMB spectrum is too high, in agreement with intuition about the parameter sensitivity.
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Optimal, fast, and robust inference of reionization-era cosmology with the 21cmPIE-INN
Authors:
Benedikt Schosser,
Caroline Heneka,
Tilman Plehn
Abstract:
Modern machine learning will allow for simulation-based inference from reionization-era 21cm observations at the Square Kilometre Array. Our framework combines a convolutional summary network and a conditional invertible network through a physics-inspired latent representation. It allows for an optimal and extremely fast determination of the posteriors of astrophysical and cosmological parameters.…
▽ More
Modern machine learning will allow for simulation-based inference from reionization-era 21cm observations at the Square Kilometre Array. Our framework combines a convolutional summary network and a conditional invertible network through a physics-inspired latent representation. It allows for an optimal and extremely fast determination of the posteriors of astrophysical and cosmological parameters. The sensitivity to non-Gaussian information makes our method a promising alternative to the established power spectra.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Cornering Extended Starobinsky Inflation with CMB and SKA
Authors:
Tanmoy Modak,
Lennart Röver,
Björn Malte Schäfer,
Benedikt Schosser,
Tilman Plehn
Abstract:
Starobinsky inflation is an attractive, fundamental model to explain the Planck measurements, and its higher-order extension may allow us to probe quantum gravity effects. We show that future CMB data combined with the 21cm intensity map from SKA will meaningfully probe such an extended Starobinsky model. A combined analysis will provide a precise measurement and intriguing insight into inflationa…
▽ More
Starobinsky inflation is an attractive, fundamental model to explain the Planck measurements, and its higher-order extension may allow us to probe quantum gravity effects. We show that future CMB data combined with the 21cm intensity map from SKA will meaningfully probe such an extended Starobinsky model. A combined analysis will provide a precise measurement and intriguing insight into inflationary dynamics, even accounting for correlations with astrophysical parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2023; v1 submitted 11 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
