-
Reading Between the Lines: Investigating the Ability of JWST to Identify Discerning Features in exoEarth and exoVenus Transmission Spectra
Authors:
Colby Ostberg,
Stephen R. Kane,
Andrew P. Lincowski,
Paul A. Dalba
Abstract:
The success of the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) mission has led to the discovery of an abundance of Venus Zone (VZ) terrestrial planets that orbit relatively bright host stars. Atmospheric observations of these planets play a crucial role in understanding the evolutionary history of terrestrial planets, past habitable states, and the divergence of Venus and Earth climates. The tran…
▽ More
The success of the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) mission has led to the discovery of an abundance of Venus Zone (VZ) terrestrial planets that orbit relatively bright host stars. Atmospheric observations of these planets play a crucial role in understanding the evolutionary history of terrestrial planets, past habitable states, and the divergence of Venus and Earth climates. The transmission spectrum of a Venus-like exoplanet can be difficult to distinguish from that of an Earth-like exoplanet however, which could severely limit what can be learned from studying exoVenuses. In this work we further investigate differences in transmission between hypothetical exoEarths and exoVenuses, both with varying amounts of atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO$_2$). The exoEarths and exoVenuses were modelled assuming they orbit TRAPPIST-1 on the runaway greenhouse boundary. We simulated James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) Near-Infrared Spectrograph (NIRSpec) PRISM transit observations of both sets of planets between 0.6-5.2 $μ$m, and quantified the detectability of major absorption features in their transmission spectra. The exoEarth spectra include several large methane (CH$_4$) features that can be detected in as few as 6 transits. The CH$_4$ feature at 3.4 $μ$m is the optimal for feature for discerning an exoEarth from an exoVenus since it is easily detectable and does not overlap with CO$_2$ features. The sulfur dioxide (SO$_2$) feature at 4.0 $μ$m is the best indicator of an exoVenus, but it is detectable in atmospheres with reduced CO$_2$ abundance.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
The Prospect of Detecting Volcanic Signatures on an ExoEarth Using Direct Imaging
Authors:
Colby M. Ostberg,
Scott D. Guzewich,
Stephen R. Kane,
Erika Kohler,
Luke D. Oman,
Thomas J. Fauchez,
Ravi K. Kopparapu,
Jacob Richardson,
Patrick Whelley
Abstract:
The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has provided the first opportunity to study the atmospheres of terrestrial exoplanets and estimate their surface conditions. Earth-sized planets around Sun-like stars are currently inaccessible with JWST however, and will have to be observed using the next generation of telescopes with direct imaging capabilities. Detecting active volcanism on an Earth-like pl…
▽ More
The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has provided the first opportunity to study the atmospheres of terrestrial exoplanets and estimate their surface conditions. Earth-sized planets around Sun-like stars are currently inaccessible with JWST however, and will have to be observed using the next generation of telescopes with direct imaging capabilities. Detecting active volcanism on an Earth-like planet would be particularly valuable as it would provide insight into its interior, and provide context for the commonality of the interior states of Earth and Venus. In this work we used a climate model to simulate four exoEarths over eight years with ongoing large igneous province eruptions with outputs ranging from 1.8-60 Gt of sulfur dioxide. The atmospheric data from the simulations were used to model direct imaging observations between 0.2-2.0 $μ$m, producing reflectance spectra for every month of each exoEarth simulation. We calculated the amount of observation time required to detect each of the major absorption features in the spectra, and identified the most prominent effects that volcanism had on the reflectance spectra. These effects include changes in the size of the O$_3$, O$_2$, and H$_2$O absorption features, and changes in the slope of the spectrum. Of these changes, we conclude that the most detectable and least ambiguous evidence of volcanism are changes in both O$_3$ absorption and the slope of the spectrum.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Two Warm Super-Earths Transiting the Nearby M Dwarf TOI-2095
Authors:
Elisa V. Quintana,
Emily A. Gilbert,
Thomas Barclay,
Michele L. Silverstein,
Joshua E. Schlieder,
Ryan Cloutier,
Samuel N. Quinn,
Joseph E. Rodriguez,
Andrew Vanderburg,
Benjamin J. Hord,
Dana R. Louie,
Colby Ostberg,
Stephen R. Kane,
Kelsey Hoffman,
Jason F. Rowe,
Giada N. Arney,
Prabal Saxena,
Taran Richardson,
Matthew S. Clement,
Nicholas M. Kartvedt,
Fred C. Adams,
Marcus Alfred,
Travis Berger,
Allyson Bieryla,
Paul Bonney
, et al. (33 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We report the detection and validation of two planets orbiting TOI-2095 (TIC 235678745). The host star is a 3700K M1V dwarf with a high proper motion. The star lies at a distance of 42 pc in a sparsely populated portion of the sky and is bright in the infrared (K=9). With data from 24 Sectors of observation during TESS's Cycles 2 and 4, TOI-2095 exhibits two sets of transits associated with super-…
▽ More
We report the detection and validation of two planets orbiting TOI-2095 (TIC 235678745). The host star is a 3700K M1V dwarf with a high proper motion. The star lies at a distance of 42 pc in a sparsely populated portion of the sky and is bright in the infrared (K=9). With data from 24 Sectors of observation during TESS's Cycles 2 and 4, TOI-2095 exhibits two sets of transits associated with super-Earth-sized planets. The planets have orbital periods of 17.7 days and 28.2 days and radii of 1.30 and 1.39 Earth radii, respectively. Archival data, preliminary follow-up observations, and vetting analyses support the planetary interpretation of the detected transit signals. The pair of planets have estimated equilibrium temperatures of approximately 400 K, with stellar insolations of 3.23 and 1.73 times that of Earth, placing them in the Venus zone. The planets also lie in a radius regime signaling the transition between rock-dominated and volatile-rich compositions. They are thus prime targets for follow-up mass measurements to better understand the properties of warm, transition radius planets. The relatively long orbital periods of these two planets provide crucial data that can help shed light on the processes that shape the composition of small planets orbiting M dwarfs.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Synergies between Venus & Exoplanetary Observations
Authors:
M. J. Way,
Colby Ostberg,
Bradford J. Foley,
Cedric Gillmann,
Dennis Höning,
Helmut Lammer,
Joseph O'Rourke,
Moa Persson,
Ana-Catalina Plesa,
Arnaud Salvador,
Manuel Scherf,
Matthew Weller
Abstract:
In this chapter we examine how our knowledge of present day Venus can inform terrestrial exoplanetary science and how exoplanetary science can inform our study of Venus. In a superficial way the contrasts in knowledge appear stark. We have been looking at Venus for millennia and studying it via telescopic observations for centuries. Spacecraft observations began with Mariner 2 in 1962 when we conf…
▽ More
In this chapter we examine how our knowledge of present day Venus can inform terrestrial exoplanetary science and how exoplanetary science can inform our study of Venus. In a superficial way the contrasts in knowledge appear stark. We have been looking at Venus for millennia and studying it via telescopic observations for centuries. Spacecraft observations began with Mariner 2 in 1962 when we confirmed that Venus was a hothouse planet, rather than the tropical paradise science fiction pictured. As long as our level of exploration and understanding of Venus remains far below that of Mars, major questions will endure. On the other hand, exoplanetary science has grown leaps and bounds since the discovery of Pegasus 51b in 1995, not too long after the golden years of Venus spacecraft missions came to an end with the Magellan Mission in 1994. Multi-million to billion dollar/euro exoplanet focused spacecraft missions such as JWST, and its successors will be flown in the coming decades. At the same time, excitement about Venus exploration is blooming again with a number of confirmed and proposed missions in the coming decades from India, Russia, Japan, the European Space Agency and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. In this chapter, we review what is known and what we may discover tomorrow in complementary studies of Venus and its exoplanetary cousins.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
The Demographics of Terrestrial Planets in the Venus Zone
Authors:
Colby Ostberg,
Stephen R. Kane,
Zhexing Li,
Edward W. Schwieterman,
Michelle L. Hill,
Kimberly Bott,
Paul A. Dalba,
Tara Fetherolf,
James W. Head,
Cayman T. Unterborn
Abstract:
Understanding the physical characteristics of Venus, including its atmosphere, interior, and its evolutionary pathway with respect to Earth, remains a vital component for terrestrial planet evolution models and the emergence and/or decline of planetary habitability. A statistical strategy for evaluating the evolutionary pathways of terrestrial planets lies in the atmospheric characterization of ex…
▽ More
Understanding the physical characteristics of Venus, including its atmosphere, interior, and its evolutionary pathway with respect to Earth, remains a vital component for terrestrial planet evolution models and the emergence and/or decline of planetary habitability. A statistical strategy for evaluating the evolutionary pathways of terrestrial planets lies in the atmospheric characterization of exoplanets, where the sample size provides sufficient means for determining required runaway greenhouse conditions. Observations of potential exoVenuses can help confirm hypotheses about Venus' past, as well as the occurrence rate of Venus-like planets in other systems. Additionally, the data from future Venus missions, such as DAVINCI, EnVision, and VERITAS, will provide valuable information regarding Venus, and the study of exoVenuses will be complimentary to these missions. To facilitate studies of exoVenus candidates, we provide a catalog of all confirmed terrestrial planets in the Venus Zone, including transiting and non-transiting cases, and quantify their potential for follow-up observations. We examine the demographics of the exoVenus population with relation to stellar and planetary properties, such as the planetary radius gap. We highlight specific high-priority exoVenus targets for follow-up observations including: TOI-2285 b, LTT 1445 A c, TOI-1266 c, LHS 1140 c, and L98-59 d. We also discuss follow-up observations that may yield further insight into the Venus/Earth divergence in atmospheric properties.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
A Catalog of Habitable Zone Exoplanets
Authors:
Michelle L. Hill,
Kimberly Bott,
Paul A. Dalba,
Tara Fetherolf,
Stephen R. Kane,
Ravi Kopparapu,
Zhexing Li,
Colby Ostberg
Abstract:
The search for habitable planets has revealed many planets that can vary greatly from an Earth analog environment. These include highly eccentric orbits, giant planets, different bulk densities, relatively active stars, and evolved stars. This work catalogs all planets found to reside in the HZ and provides HZ boundaries, orbit characterization, and the potential for spectroscopic follow-up observ…
▽ More
The search for habitable planets has revealed many planets that can vary greatly from an Earth analog environment. These include highly eccentric orbits, giant planets, different bulk densities, relatively active stars, and evolved stars. This work catalogs all planets found to reside in the HZ and provides HZ boundaries, orbit characterization, and the potential for spectroscopic follow-up observations. Demographics of the HZ planets are compared with a full catalog of exoplanets. Extreme planets within the HZ are highlighted, and how their unique properties may affect their potential habitability. Kepler-296 f is the most eccentric <2 $R_\oplus$ planet that spends 100% of its orbit in the HZ. HD 106270 b and HD 38529 c are the most massive planets (<13 $M_J$) that orbit within the HZ, and are ideal targets for determining the properties of potential hosts of HZ exomoons. These planets, along with the others highlighted, will serve as special edge-cases to the Earth-based scenario and observations of these targets will help test the resilience of habitability outside the standard model. The most promising observational HZ target that is known to transit is GJ 414 A b. Of the transiting, <2 $R_\oplus$ HZ planets, LHS 1140 b, TRAPPIST-1 d and K2-3 d are the most favorable. Of the non-transiting HZ planets, HD 102365 b and 55 Cnc f are the most promising, and the best non-transiting candidates that are <2 $R_\oplus$ are GJ 667 C c, Wolf 1061 c, Ross 508 b, Teegarden's Star b, and Proxima Cen b.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2022; v1 submitted 5 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Eccentricity Driven Climate Effects in the Kepler-1649 System
Authors:
Stephen R. Kane,
Zhexing Li,
Eric T. Wolf,
Colby Ostberg,
Michelle L. Hill
Abstract:
The discovery of terrestrial exoplanets is uncovering increasingly diverse architectures. Of particular interest are those systems that contain exoplanets at a variety of star-planet separations, allowing direct comparison of exoplanet evolution (comparative planetology). The Kepler-1649 system contains two terrestrial planets similar both in size and insolation flux to Venus and Earth, although t…
▽ More
The discovery of terrestrial exoplanets is uncovering increasingly diverse architectures. Of particular interest are those systems that contain exoplanets at a variety of star-planet separations, allowing direct comparison of exoplanet evolution (comparative planetology). The Kepler-1649 system contains two terrestrial planets similar both in size and insolation flux to Venus and Earth, although their eccentricities remain largely unconstrained. Here we present results of dynamical studies of the system and the potential effects on climate. The eccentricities of the Kepler-1649 system are poorly constrained, and we show that there are dynamically viable regions for further terrestrial planets in between the two known planets for a limited range of eccentricities. We investigate the effect of eccentricity of the outer planet on the dynamics of both planets and show that this results in high-frequency (1000-3000 year) eccentricity oscillations in long-term stable configurations. We calculate the resulting effect of these eccentricity variations on insolation flux and present the results of 3D climate simulations for the habitable zone planet. Our simulations demonstrate that, despite large eccentricity variations, the planet can maintain stable climates with relatively small temperature variations on the substellar hemisphere for a variety of initial climate configurations. Such systems thus provide key opportunities to explore alternative Venus/Earth climate evolution scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2024; v1 submitted 17 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Science Extraction from TESS Observations of Known Exoplanet Hosts
Authors:
Stephen R. Kane,
Jacob L. Bean,
Tiago L. Campante,
Paul A. Dalba,
Tara Fetherolf,
Teo Mocnik,
Colby Ostberg,
Joshua Pepper,
Emilie R. Simpson,
Margaret C. Turnbull,
George R. Ricker,
Roland Vanderspek,
David W. Latham,
Sara Seager,
Joshua N. Winn,
Jon M. Jenkins,
Daniel Huber,
William J. Chaplin
Abstract:
The transit method of exoplanet discovery and characterization has enabled numerous breakthroughs in exoplanetary science. These include measurements of planetary radii, mass-radius relationships, stellar obliquities, bulk density constraints on interior models, and transmission spectroscopy as a means to study planetary atmospheres. The Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) has added to th…
▽ More
The transit method of exoplanet discovery and characterization has enabled numerous breakthroughs in exoplanetary science. These include measurements of planetary radii, mass-radius relationships, stellar obliquities, bulk density constraints on interior models, and transmission spectroscopy as a means to study planetary atmospheres. The Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) has added to the exoplanet inventory by observing a significant fraction of the celestial sphere, including many stars already known to host exoplanets. Here we describe the science extraction from TESS observations of known exoplanet hosts during the primary mission. These include transit detection of known exoplanets, discovery of additional exoplanets, detection of phase signatures and secondary eclipses, transit ephemeris refinement, and asteroseismology as a means to improve stellar and planetary parameters. We provide the statistics of TESS known host observations during Cycle 1 & 2, and present several examples of TESS photometry for known host stars observed with a long baseline. We outline the major discoveries from observations of known hosts during the primary mission. Finally, we describe the case for further observations of known exoplanet hosts during the TESS extended mission and the expected science yield.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2020; v1 submitted 28 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Transits of Known Planets Orbiting a Naked-Eye Star
Authors:
Stephen R. Kane,
Selçuk Yalçınkaya,
Hugh P. Osborn,
Paul A. Dalba,
Louise D. Nielsen,
Andrew Vanderburg,
Teo Močnik,
Natalie R. Hinkel,
Colby Ostberg,
Ekrem Murat Esmer,
Stéphane Udry,
Tara Fetherolf,
Özgür Baştürk,
George R. Ricker,
Roland Vanderspek,
David W. Latham,
Sara Seager,
Joshua N. Winn,
Jon M. Jenkins,
Romain Allart,
Jeremy Bailey,
Jacob L. Bean,
Francois Bouchy,
R. Paul Butler,
Tiago L. Campante
, et al. (23 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Some of the most scientifically valuable transiting planets are those that were already known from radial velocity (RV) surveys. This is primarily because their orbits are well characterized and they preferentially orbit bright stars that are the targets of RV surveys. The Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite ({\it TESS}) provides an opportunity to survey most of the known exoplanet systems in a…
▽ More
Some of the most scientifically valuable transiting planets are those that were already known from radial velocity (RV) surveys. This is primarily because their orbits are well characterized and they preferentially orbit bright stars that are the targets of RV surveys. The Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite ({\it TESS}) provides an opportunity to survey most of the known exoplanet systems in a systematic fashion to detect possible transits of their planets. HD~136352 (Nu$^2$~Lupi) is a naked-eye ($V = 5.78$) G-type main-sequence star that was discovered to host three planets with orbital periods of 11.6, 27.6, and 108.1 days via RV monitoring with the HARPS spectrograph. We present the detection and characterization of transits for the two inner planets of the HD~136352 system, revealing radii of $1.482^{+0.058}_{-0.056}$~$R_\oplus$ and $2.608^{+0.078}_{-0.077}$~$R_\oplus$ for planets b and c, respectively. We combine new HARPS observations with RV data from Keck/HIRES and the AAT, along with {\it TESS} photometry from Sector 12, to perform a complete analysis of the system parameters. The combined data analysis results in extracted bulk density values of $ρ_b = 7.8^{+1.2}_{-1.1}$~gcm$^{-3}$ and $ρ_c = 3.50^{+0.41}_{-0.36}$~gcm$^{-3}$ for planets b and c, respectively, thus placing them on either side of the radius valley. The combination of the multi-transiting planet system, the bright host star, and the diversity of planetary interiors and atmospheres means this will likely become a cornerstone system for atmospheric and orbital characterization of small worlds.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2020; v1 submitted 21 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Predicting the Yield of Potential Venus Analogs from TESS and their Potential for Atmospheric Characterization
Authors:
Colby Ostberg,
Stephen R. Kane
Abstract:
The transit method is biased toward short orbital period planets that are interior to their host star's Habitable Zone (HZ). These planets are particularly interesting from the perspective of exploring runaway greenhouse scenarios and the possibility of potential Venus analogs. Here, we conduct an analysis of predicted TESS planet yield estimates produced by Huang et al. (2018), as well as the TES…
▽ More
The transit method is biased toward short orbital period planets that are interior to their host star's Habitable Zone (HZ). These planets are particularly interesting from the perspective of exploring runaway greenhouse scenarios and the possibility of potential Venus analogs. Here, we conduct an analysis of predicted TESS planet yield estimates produced by Huang et al. (2018), as well as the TESS Object of Interest (TOI) list resulting from the observations of sectors 1 - 13 during Cycle 1 of the TESS primary mission. In our analysis we consider potential terrestrial planets that lie within their host star's Venus Zone (Kane et al. 2014). These requirements are then applied to a predicted planetary yield from the TESS primary mission (Huang et al. 2018) and the TOI list, which results in an estimated 259 Venus analogs by the end of the TESS primary mission, and 46 Venus analogs in the TOI list for sectors 1 - 13. We also calculate the estimated transmission spectroscopy signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) for Venus analogs from the predicted yield and TOI list if they were to be observed by the Near-Infrared Imager and Slitless Spectrograph (NIRISS) on the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), as well as update the S/N cutoff values determined by Kempton et al. (2018). Our findings show that the best estimated Venus analogs and TOI Venus analogs with $R_{p} < 1.5 \, R_\odot$ have an estimated transmission spectroscopy S/N $> 40$ while planets with radii $2 \, R_\oplus < R_p < 4 \, R_\oplus$ can achieve S/N $> 100$
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
