-
Comparative analysis of the SFR of AGN and non-AGN galaxies, as a function of stellar mass, AGN power, cosmic time and obscuration
Authors:
G. Mountrichas,
V. A. Masoura,
A. Corral,
F. J. Carrera
Abstract:
This study involves a comparative analysis of the SFRs of AGN and non-AGN galaxies and of the SFRs of type 1 and 2 AGN. To carry out this investigation, we assembled a dataset consisting of 2\,677 X-ray AGN detected by the XMM-Newton observatory and a control sample of 64\,556 galaxies devoid of AGN. We generated SEDs for these objects using photometric data from the DES, VHS, and AllWISE surveys,…
▽ More
This study involves a comparative analysis of the SFRs of AGN and non-AGN galaxies and of the SFRs of type 1 and 2 AGN. To carry out this investigation, we assembled a dataset consisting of 2\,677 X-ray AGN detected by the XMM-Newton observatory and a control sample of 64\,556 galaxies devoid of AGN. We generated SEDs for these objects using photometric data from the DES, VHS, and AllWISE surveys, and we harnessed the CIGALE code to extract measurements for the (host) galaxy properties. Our dataset encompasses sources spanning a range from $\rm 9.5<\log\,[M_*(M_\odot)]<12.0$, $\rm 42<\log\,[L_{X,2-10keV}(ergs^{-1})]<45.5$, and $\rm 0.3<z<2.5$. To compare SFRs, we calculated the SFR$_{norm}$ parameter. Our analysis revealed that AGN tend to exhibit elevated SFRs compared to non-AGN galaxies, particularly beyond a certain threshold in L$_X$. Notably, this threshold increases as we move towards more massive galaxies. Additionally, for AGN systems with the same L$_X$, the magnitude of the SFR$_{norm}$ decreases as we consider more massive galaxies. This suggests that in galaxies with AGN, the increase in SFR as a function of M$_*$ is not as prominent as in galaxies without AGN. This interpretation finds support in the shallower slope we identify in the X-ray star-forming MS in contrast to the galaxy MS. Employing CIGALE's measurements, we classified AGN into type 1 and type 2. In our investigation, we focused on a subset of 652 type 1 AGN and 293 type 2 AGN with $\rm 10.5<\log,[M_(M_\odot)]<11.5$. Based on our results, type 1 AGN display higher SFRs than type 2 AGN, at redshifts below $\rm z<1$. However, at higher redshifts, the SFRs of the two AGN populations tend to be similar. At redshifts $\rm z<1$, type 1 AGN show augmented SFRs in comparison to non-AGN galaxies. In contrast, type 2 AGN exhibit lower SFRs when compared to galaxies that do not host an AGN.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Star-forming early- and quiescent late-type galaxies in the local Universe
Authors:
E. -D. Paspaliaris,
E. M. Xilouris,
A. Nersesian,
S. Bianchi,
I. Georgantopoulos,
V. A. Masoura,
G. E. Magdis,
M. Plionis
Abstract:
The general consensus is that LTGs undergo intense star-formation activity, while ETGs are mostly inactive. We question this general rule and investigate the existence of star-forming ETGs and quiescent LTGs in the local Universe. By computing the physical properties of 2,209 such galaxies in the GAMA survey being morphologically classified and using information on their structural properties as w…
▽ More
The general consensus is that LTGs undergo intense star-formation activity, while ETGs are mostly inactive. We question this general rule and investigate the existence of star-forming ETGs and quiescent LTGs in the local Universe. By computing the physical properties of 2,209 such galaxies in the GAMA survey being morphologically classified and using information on their structural properties as well as the density of their local environment, we seek for understanding the differences from their 'typical' counterparts.
We separate galaxies into subsets based on their dominant ionising process, making use of criteria based on the WH$_α$ width and the [NII/H$_α$] ratio. Taking advantage of the SED fitting code CIGALE we derive galaxy properties, such as the $M_\text{star}$, $M_\text{dust}$, and SFR and also estimate the unattenuated and the dust-absorbed stellar emission, for both the young and old stellar populations.
Ongoing star-formation activity is found in 47% of ETGs and 8% of LTGs are quiescent. The star-forming E galaxies, together with the LBSs, constitute a population that follows very well the SFMS of spiral galaxies. The fraction of the luminosity originating from young stars in the star-forming ETGs is quite substantial ($\sim$ 25%) and similar to that of the star-forming LTGs. Investigating possible differences between star-forming and quiescent galaxies we find that the intrinsic shape of the SED of the star-forming galaxies is, on average, very similar for all morphological types. Concerning their structural parameters, quiescent galaxies tend to show larger values of the Sérsic index and larger $R_\text{eff}$ (compared to star-forming galaxies). Finally, we find that star-forming galaxies preferably reside in lower-density environments compared to the quiescent ones, which exhibit a higher percentage of sources being members of groups.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Star formation of X-ray AGN in COSMOS: The role of AGN activity and galaxy stellar mass
Authors:
G. Mountrichas,
V. A. Masoura,
E. M. Xilouris,
I. Georgantopoulos,
V. Buat,
E. -D. Paspaliaris
Abstract:
We use $\sim 1,000$ X-ray sources in the COSMOS-Legacy survey and study the position of the AGN relative to the star forming main sequence (MS). We also construct a galaxy (non-AGN) reference sample that includes $\sim 90,000$ sources. We apply the same photometric selection criteria on both datasets and construct their spectral energy distributions (SEDs) using optical to far-infrared photometry…
▽ More
We use $\sim 1,000$ X-ray sources in the COSMOS-Legacy survey and study the position of the AGN relative to the star forming main sequence (MS). We also construct a galaxy (non-AGN) reference sample that includes $\sim 90,000$ sources. We apply the same photometric selection criteria on both datasets and construct their spectral energy distributions (SEDs) using optical to far-infrared photometry compiled by the HELP project. We perform SED fitting, using the X-CIGALE algorithm and the same parametric grid for both datasets, to measure the star formation rate (SFR) and stellar mass of the sources. The mass completeness of the data is calculated at different redshift intervals and is applied on both samples. We define our own main sequence, based on the distributions of the specific SFR at different redshift ranges and exclude quiescent galaxies from our analysis. These allow us to compare the SFR of the two populations in a uniform manner, minimizing systematics and selection effects. Our results show that at low to moderate X-ray luminosities, AGN tend to have lower or, at most, equal star formation rates compared to non-AGN systems with similar stellar mass and redshift. At higher ($\rm L_{X,2-10keV} > 2-3\times 10^{44}\,erg\,s^{-1}$), we observe an increase of the SFR of AGN, for systems that have $\rm 10.5 < log\,[M_*(M_\odot)] < 11.5$.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Galaxy properties of type 1 and 2 X-ray selected AGN and comparison among different classification criteria
Authors:
G. Mountrichas,
V. Buat,
I. Georgantopoulos,
G. Yang,
V. A. Masoura,
M. Boquien,
D. Burgarella
Abstract:
We present analyses of host galaxy properties of type 1 and type 2 X-ray selected AGNs in the XMM-XXL field, which have available optical spectroscopic classification. We model their optical to far-infrared spectral energy distributions (SEDs) using the X-CIGALE code. X-CIGALE allows the fitting of X-ray flux and accounts for the viewing angle of dusty torus and the attenuation from polar dust. By…
▽ More
We present analyses of host galaxy properties of type 1 and type 2 X-ray selected AGNs in the XMM-XXL field, which have available optical spectroscopic classification. We model their optical to far-infrared spectral energy distributions (SEDs) using the X-CIGALE code. X-CIGALE allows the fitting of X-ray flux and accounts for the viewing angle of dusty torus and the attenuation from polar dust. By selecting matched type 1 and 2 subsamples in the X-ray luminosity and redshift parameter space, we find that both types live in galaxies with similar star formation. However, type 2 AGN tend to reside in more massive systems ($10.87^{+0.06}_{-0.12}\,\rm M_\odot$) compared to their type 1 counterparts ($10.57^{+0.20}_{-0.12}\,\rm M_\odot$). In the second part of our analysis, we compare the spectroscopic classification with that from the SED fitting. X-CIGALE successfully identifies all spectroscopic type 2 sources either by estimating an inclination angle that corresponds to edge on viewing of the source or by measuring increased polar dust in these systems. $\sim 85\%$ of spectroscopic type 1 AGN are also identified as such, based on the SED fitting analysis. There is a small number of sources ($\sim 15\%$ of the sample), that present broad lines in their spectra, but show strong indications of obscuration, based on SED analysis. These, could be systems that are viewed face on and have an extended dust component along the polar direction. The performance of X-CIGALE in classifying AGN is similar at low and high redshifts, under the condition that there is sufficient photometric coverage. Finally, usage of optical/mid-IR colour criteria to identify optical red AGN (${\it{u}}-\rm W3$), suggests that these criteria are better suited for IR selected AGN and their efficiency drops for the low to moderate luminosity sources included in X-ray samples.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
The physical properties of local (U)LIRGs: a comparison with nearby early- and late-type galaxies
Authors:
E. -D. Paspaliaris,
E. M. Xilouris,
A. Nersesian,
V. A. Masoura,
M. Plionis,
I. Georgantopoulos,
S. Bianchi,
S. Katsioli,
G. Mountrichas
Abstract:
In order to pinpoint the place of the (U)LIRGs in the local Universe we examine the properties of a sample of 67 such systems and compare them with those of 268 ETGs and 542 LTGs from the DustPedia database. We make use of multi-wavelength photometric data and the CIGALE SED fitting code to extract their physical parameters. The median SEDs as well as the values of the derived parameters were comp…
▽ More
In order to pinpoint the place of the (U)LIRGs in the local Universe we examine the properties of a sample of 67 such systems and compare them with those of 268 ETGs and 542 LTGs from the DustPedia database. We make use of multi-wavelength photometric data and the CIGALE SED fitting code to extract their physical parameters. The median SEDs as well as the values of the derived parameters were compared to those of the local ETGs and LTGs. In addition to that, (U)LIRGs were divided into seven classes, according to the merging stage of each system, and variations in the derived parameters were investigated. (U)LIRGs occupy the `high-end' on the dust and stellar mass, and SFR in the local Universe with median values of 5.2$\times10^7~M_{\odot}$, 6.3$\times10^{10}~M_{\odot}$ and 52$~M_{\odot}$yr$^{-1}$, respectively. The PDR-dust emission in (U)LIRGs is 11.7% of the total dust luminosity, significantly higher than ETGs (1.6%) and the LTGs (5.2%). The median value of the dust temperature in (U)LIRGs is 32 K, which is higher compared to both the ETGs (28 K) and the LTGs (22 K). Small differences, in the derived parameters, are seen for the seven merging classes of our sample of (U)LIRGs with the most evident one being on the star-formation rate, where in systems in late merging stages the median SFR reaches up to 99 M$_{\odot}$ yr$^{-1}$ compared to 26 M$_{\odot}$ yr$^{-1}$ for the isolated ones. In contrast to the local normal galaxies where old stars dominate the stellar emission, the young stars in (U)LIRGs contribute with 64% of their luminosity to the total stellar luminosity. The fraction of the dust-absorbed stellar luminosity is extremely high in (U)LIRGs (78%) compared to 7% and 25% in ETGs and ETGs, respectively. The fraction of the stellar luminosity used to heat up the dust grains is very high in (U)LIRGs, while 74% of the dust emission comes from the young stars.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
The relation between AGN type and host galaxy properties
Authors:
V. A. Masoura,
G. Mountrichas,
I. Georgantopoulos,
M. Plionis
Abstract:
We use 3,213 Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs) from the $\it{XMM}$-XXL northern field to investigate the relation of AGN type with host galaxy properties. Applying a Bayesian method, we derive the hardness ratios (HRs) and through these the hydrogen column density ($\rm N_H$) for each source. We consider as absorbed sources (type-2) those with $\rm N_H > 10^{21.5}\, \rm{cm^{-2}}$. We examine the star…
▽ More
We use 3,213 Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs) from the $\it{XMM}$-XXL northern field to investigate the relation of AGN type with host galaxy properties. Applying a Bayesian method, we derive the hardness ratios (HRs) and through these the hydrogen column density ($\rm N_H$) for each source. We consider as absorbed sources (type-2) those with $\rm N_H > 10^{21.5}\, \rm{cm^{-2}}$. We examine the star formation rate (SFR) as well the stellar mass (M$_*$) distributions for both absorbed and unabsorbed sources. Our work indicates that there is no significant link between the AGN type and these host galaxy properties. Next, we investigate whether the AGN power, as represented by its X-ray luminosity, $\rm L_X$, correlates with any deviation of the host galaxy's place from the so-called Main Sequence of galaxies, and we examine this separately for the obscured and the unobscured AGN populations. To take into account the effect of M$_*$ and redshift on SFR, we use the normalised SFR (SFR$_{norm}$). We find that the correlation between $\rm L_X$ and SFR$_{norm}$, follows approximately the same trend for both absorbed and unabsorbed sources, a result that favours the standard AGN unification models. Finally, we explore the connection between the obscuration, $\rm N_H$, and the SFR. We find that there is no relation between these, suggesting that the obscuration is not related to the large scale SFR in the galaxy.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
The $\it{XXL}$ survey: XL. Obscuration properties of red AGN in $\it{XXL-N}$
Authors:
V. A. Masoura,
I. Georgantopoulos,
G. Mountrichas,
C. Vignali,
E. Koulouridis,
L. Chiappetti,
S. Fotopoulou,
S. Paltani,
M. Pierre
Abstract:
The combination of optical and mid-infrared (MIR) photometry has been extensively used to select red active galactic nuclei (AGNs). Our aim is to explore the obscuration properties of these red AGNs with both X-ray spectroscopy and spectral energy distributions (SEDs). In this study, we re-visit the relation between optical/MIR extinction and X-ray absorption. We use IR selection criteria, specifi…
▽ More
The combination of optical and mid-infrared (MIR) photometry has been extensively used to select red active galactic nuclei (AGNs). Our aim is to explore the obscuration properties of these red AGNs with both X-ray spectroscopy and spectral energy distributions (SEDs). In this study, we re-visit the relation between optical/MIR extinction and X-ray absorption. We use IR selection criteria, specifically the $W1$ and $W2$ WISE bands, to identify 4798 AGNs in the $\it{XMM-XXL}$ area ($\sim 25$deg$^2$). Application of optical/MIR colours ($r- W2 > 6$) reveals 561 red AGNs (14$\%$). Of these, 47 have available X-ray spectra with at least 50 net (background-subtracted) counts per detector. For these sources, we construct SEDs from the optical to the MIR using the CIGALE code. The SED fitting shows that 44 of these latter 47 sources present clear signs of obscuration based on the AGN emission and the estimated inclination angle. Fitting the SED also reveals ten systems ($\sim20\%$) which are dominated by the galaxy. In these cases, the red colours are attributed to the host galaxy rather than AGN absorption. Excluding these ten systems from our sample and applying X-ray spectral fitting analysis shows that up to $76\%$ (28/37) of the IR red AGNs present signs of X-ray absorption. Thus, there are nine sources ($\sim20\%$ of the sample) that although optically red, are not substantially X-ray absorbed. Approximately $50\%$ of these sources present broad emission lines in their optical spectra. We suggest that the reason for this apparent discrepancy is that the r-W2 criterion is sensitive to smaller amounts of obscuration relative to the X-ray spectroscopy. In conclusion, it appears that the majority of red AGNs present considerable obscuration levels as shown by their SEDs. Their X-ray absorption is moderate with a mean of $\rm N_H \sim 10^{22}\, \rm{cm^{-2}}$.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2020; v1 submitted 9 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
A binning-free method reveals a continuous relationship between galaxies' AGN power and offset from main sequence
Authors:
L. P. Grimmett,
J. R. Mullaney,
E. P. Bernhard,
C. M. Harrison,
D. M. Alexander,
F. Stanley,
V. A. Masoura,
K. Walters
Abstract:
Studies investigating the relationship between AGN power and the star formation rates (SFRs) of their host galaxies often rely on averaging techniques -- such as stacking -- to incorporate information from non-detections. However, averages, and especially means, can be strongly affected by outliers and can therefore give a misleading indication of the "typical" case. Recently, a number of studies…
▽ More
Studies investigating the relationship between AGN power and the star formation rates (SFRs) of their host galaxies often rely on averaging techniques -- such as stacking -- to incorporate information from non-detections. However, averages, and especially means, can be strongly affected by outliers and can therefore give a misleading indication of the "typical" case. Recently, a number of studies have taken a step further by binning their sample in terms of AGN power (approximated by the 2-10keV luminosity of the AGN), and investigating how the SFR distribution differs between these bins. These bin thresholds are often weakly motivated, and binning implicitly assumes that sources within the same bin have similar (or even identical) properties. In this paper, we investigate whether the distribution of host SFRs -- relative to the locus of the star-forming main sequence (i.e., $R_{\rm MS}$) -- changes continuously as a function of AGN power. We achieve this by using a hierarchical Bayesian model that completely removes the need to bin in AGN power. In doing so, we find strong evidence that the $R_{\rm MS}$ distribution changes with 2-10keV X-ray luminosity. The results suggest that higher X_ray luminosity AGNs have a tighter physical connection to the star-forming process than lower X-ray luminosity AGNs, at least within the $0.8 < z < 1.2$ redshift range considered here.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2020; v1 submitted 30 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Disentangling the AGN and Star-Formation connection using XMM-Newton
Authors:
V. A. Masoura,
G. Mountrichas,
I. Georgantopoulos,
A. Ruiz,
G. Magdis,
M. Plionis
Abstract:
There is growing evidence supporting the coeval growth of galaxies and their resident SMBH. Most studies also claim a correlation between the activity of the SMBH and the star-formation of the host galaxy. It is unclear, though, whether this correlation extends to all redz and LX. In this work, we use data from the X-ATLAS and XMM-XXL North fields and compile the largest X-ray sample up to date, t…
▽ More
There is growing evidence supporting the coeval growth of galaxies and their resident SMBH. Most studies also claim a correlation between the activity of the SMBH and the star-formation of the host galaxy. It is unclear, though, whether this correlation extends to all redz and LX. In this work, we use data from the X-ATLAS and XMM-XXL North fields and compile the largest X-ray sample up to date, to investigate how X-ray AGN affect the star-formation of their host galaxies in a wide redz and luminosity baseline, i.e., 0.03<z<3 and log LX (2-10 keV)= (41-45.5) ergs-1. Our sample consists of 3336 AGN. 1872 X-ray objects have spectroscopic redz. For the remaining sources we calculate photometric redz using TPZ, a machine-learning algorithm. We estimate stellar masses (M*) and Star Formation Rates (SFRs) by applying SED fitting through the CIGALE code, using optical, near-IR and mid-IR photometry. 608 of our sources also have far-IR photometry (Herschel). We use these sources to calibrate the SFR calculations of the rest of our X-ray sample. Our results show a correlation between the LX and the SFR, at all redz and LX spanned by our sample. We also find a dependence of the specific SFR (sSFR) on redz, while there are indications that LX enhances the sSFR even at low redz. We then disentangle the effects of M* and redz on the SFR and study again its dependence on the LX. Towards this end, we use the Schreiber et al. formula to estimate the SFR of main sequence galaxies that have the same stellar mass and redshift as our X-ray AGN. Our analysis reveals that the AGN enhances the star-formation of its host galaxy, when the galaxy lies below the main sequence and quenches the star-formation of the galaxy it lives in, when the host lies above the main sequence. Therefore, the effect of AGN on the SFR of the host galaxy, depends on the location of the galaxy relative to the main sequence.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2018; v1 submitted 4 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Estimating Photometric Redshifts for X-ray sources in the X-ATLAS field, using machine-learning techniques
Authors:
G. Mountrichas,
A. Corral,
V. A. Masoura,
I. Georgantopoulos,
A. Ruiz,
A. Georgakakis,
F. J. Carrera,
S. Fotopoulou
Abstract:
We present photometric redshifts for 1,031 X-ray sources in the X-ATLAS field, using the machine learning technique TPZ (Carrasco Kind & Brunner 2013). X-ATLAS covers 7.1 deg2 observed with the XMM-Newton within the Science Demonstration Phase (SDP) of the H-ATLAS field, making it one of the largest contiguous areas of the sky with both XMMNewton and Herschel coverage. All of the sources have avai…
▽ More
We present photometric redshifts for 1,031 X-ray sources in the X-ATLAS field, using the machine learning technique TPZ (Carrasco Kind & Brunner 2013). X-ATLAS covers 7.1 deg2 observed with the XMM-Newton within the Science Demonstration Phase (SDP) of the H-ATLAS field, making it one of the largest contiguous areas of the sky with both XMMNewton and Herschel coverage. All of the sources have available SDSS photometry while 810 have additionally mid-IR and/or near-IR photometry. A spectroscopic sample of 5,157 sources primarily in the XMM/XXL field, but also from several X-ray surveys and the SDSS DR13 redshift catalogue, is used for the training of the algorithm. Our analysis reveals that the algorithm performs best when the sources are split, based on their optical morphology, into point-like and extended sources. Optical photometry alone is not enough for the estimation of accurate photometric redshifts, but the results greatly improve when, at least, mid-IR photometry is added in the training process. In particular, our measurements show that the estimated photometric redshifts for the X-ray sources of the training sample, have a normalized absolute median deviation, n_mad=0.06, and the percentage of outliers, eta=10-14 percent, depending on whether the sources are extended or point-like. Our final catalogue contains photometric redshifts for 933 out of the 1,031 X-ray sources with a median redshift of 0.9.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
