-
On the Origin of Solar Hemispheric Helicity Rules: Rise of 3D Magnetic Flux Concentrations through a Background Magnetic Field
Authors:
Bhishek Manek,
Nicholas Brummell
Abstract:
Sunspots and active regions observed on the solar surface are widely believed to be manifestations of compact predominantly-toroidal magnetic field structures (``flux tubes") that emerge by magnetic buoyancy from the deeper interior of the Sun. Much work has examined the evolution of such magnetic structures, typically considering them as idealized isolated magnetic entities and not as more realis…
▽ More
Sunspots and active regions observed on the solar surface are widely believed to be manifestations of compact predominantly-toroidal magnetic field structures (``flux tubes") that emerge by magnetic buoyancy from the deeper interior of the Sun. Much work has examined the evolution of such magnetic structures, typically considering them as idealized isolated magnetic entities and not as more realistic magnetic concentrations in a volume-filling background magnetic field. Here, we report results that explore the buoyant rise dynamics of magnetic concentrations in a volume-filling field in the full three dimensions. Earlier 2.5D work in this series (arXiv:1805.08806, arXiv:2101.03472, arXiv:2204.13078) established the remarkable fact that the twist orientation of a flux concentration relative to the background field affected it's likelihood to rise and emerge, regardless of whether the buoyant rise took place in the absence or presence of convection. The contrasting dynamics between structures with differing orientations leads to a selection mechanism that reproduces characteristics of the ``solar hemispheric helicity rule(s)" (SHHR) observations strikingly well. Here, we show that this two-dimensional selection mechanism persists in the face of the added complexity of three-dimensional dynamics. Arching of the magnetic structure in the third dimension, as might be expected in the solar application, is introduced. The role of tension force leading to this selection mechanism is elucidated and subtle differences that arise due to the three-dimensional geometry are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
The Puzzling Structure of Solar Convection: Window into the Dynamo
Authors:
Nicholas A. Featherstone,
Kyle C. Augustson,
Jonathan M. Aurnou,
Catherine Blume,
Benjamin P. Brown,
Nicholas Brummell,
Keaton J. Burns,
Michael A. Calkins,
Maria Camisassa,
Mausumi Dikpati,
Yuhong Fan,
J. R. Fuentes,
Gustavo Guerrero,
Bradley W. Hindman,
Keith Julien,
Irina N. Kitiashvili,
Lydia Korre,
Daniel Lecoanet,
Bhishek Manek,
Loren Matilsky,
Mark Miesch,
Nicholas J. Nelson,
Jeffrey S. Oishi,
Whitney T. Powers,
Matthias Rempel
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The operation of the solar dynamo, with all of its remarkable spatio-temporal ordering, remains an outstanding problem of modern solar physics. A number of mechanisms that might plausibly contribute to its operation have been proposed, but the relative role played by each remains unclear. This uncertainty stems from continuing questions concerning the speed and structure of deep-seated convective…
▽ More
The operation of the solar dynamo, with all of its remarkable spatio-temporal ordering, remains an outstanding problem of modern solar physics. A number of mechanisms that might plausibly contribute to its operation have been proposed, but the relative role played by each remains unclear. This uncertainty stems from continuing questions concerning the speed and structure of deep-seated convective flows. Those flows are in-turn thought to sustain both the Sun's turbulent EMF and the large-scale flows of differential rotation and meridional circulation suspected of influencing the dynamo's organization and timing. Continued progress in this area is complicated by (i) inconsistencies between helioseismic measurements of convective and meridional flow made with different techniques and instruments, and (ii) a lack of high-latitude data for convection, differential rotation, and meridional flow. We suggest that the path forward to resolving these difficulties is twofold. First, the acquisition of long-term helioseismic and emissivity measurements obtained from a polar vantage point is vital to complete our picture of the Sun's outer convection zone. Second, sustained and expanded investment in theory-oriented and combined theory/observational research initiatives will be crucial to fully exploit these new observations and to resolve inconsistencies between existing measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
The Rise of Buoyant Magnetic Structures through Convection with a Background Magnetic Field
Authors:
Bhishek Manek,
Christina Pontin,
Nicholas Brummell
Abstract:
Inspired by observations of sunspots embedded in active regions, it is often assumed that large-scale, strong magnetic flux emerges from the Sun's deep interior in the form of arched, cylindrical structures, colloquially known as flux tubes. Here, we continue to examine the different dynamics encountered when these structures are considered as concentrations in a volume-filling magnetic field rath…
▽ More
Inspired by observations of sunspots embedded in active regions, it is often assumed that large-scale, strong magnetic flux emerges from the Sun's deep interior in the form of arched, cylindrical structures, colloquially known as flux tubes. Here, we continue to examine the different dynamics encountered when these structures are considered as concentrations in a volume-filling magnetic field rather than as isolated entities in a field-free background. Via 2.5D numerical simulations, we consider the buoyant rise of magnetic flux concentrations from a radiative zone through an overshooting convection zone that self-consistently (via magnetic pumping) arranges a volume-filling large-scale background field. This work extends earlier papers that considered the evolution of such structures in a purely adiabatic stratification with an assumed form of the background field. This earlier work established the existence of a bias that created an increased likelihood of successful rise for magnetic structures with one (relative) orientation of twist and a decreased likelihood for the other. When applied to the solar context, this bias is commensurate with the solar hemispherical helicity rules (SHHR). This paper establishes the robustness of this selection mechanism in a model incorporating a more realistic background state, consisting of overshooting convection and a turbulently-pumped mean magnetic field. Ultimately, convection only weakly influences the selection mechanism, since it is enacted at the initiation of the rise, at the edge of the overshoot zone. Convection does however add another layer of statistical fluctuations to the bias, which we investigate in order to explain variations in the SHHR.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
On the origin of the solar hemispherical helicity rules: Simulations of the rise of magnetic flux concentrations in a background field
Authors:
Bhishek Manek,
Nicholas Brummell
Abstract:
Solar active regions and sunspots are believed to be formed by the emergence of strong toroidal magnetic flux from the solar interior. Modeling of such events has focused on the dynamics of compact magnetic entities, colloquially known as "flux tubes", often considered to be isolated magnetic structures embedded in an otherwise field-free environment. In this paper, we show that relaxing such idea…
▽ More
Solar active regions and sunspots are believed to be formed by the emergence of strong toroidal magnetic flux from the solar interior. Modeling of such events has focused on the dynamics of compact magnetic entities, colloquially known as "flux tubes", often considered to be isolated magnetic structures embedded in an otherwise field-free environment. In this paper, we show that relaxing such idealized assumptions can lead to surprisingly different dynamics. We consider the rise of tube-like flux concentrations embedded in a large-scale volume-filling horizontal field in an initially quiescent adiabatically-stratified compressible fluid. In a previous letter, we revealed the unexpected major result that concentrations that have their twist aligned with the background field at the bottom of the tube are more likely to rise than the opposite orientation (for certain values of the parameters). This bias leads to a selection rule which, when applied to solar dynamics, is in agreement with the observations known as the solar hemispheric helicity rule(s) (SHHR). Here, we examine this selection mechanism in more detail than was possible in the earlier letter. We explore the dependence on the parameters via simulations, delineating the Selective Rise Regime (SRR), where the bias operates. We provide a theoretical model to predict and explain the simulation dynamics. Furthermore, we create synthetic helicity maps from Monte Carlo simulations to mimic the SHHR observations and demonstrate that our mechanism explains the observed scatter in the rule and its variation over the solar cycle.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
The Rise of a Magnetic Flux Tube in a Background Field: Solar Helicity Selection Rules
Authors:
Bhishek Manek,
Nicholas Brummell,
Dongwook Lee
Abstract:
The buoyant transport of magnetic fields from the solar interior towards the surface plays an important role in the emergence of active regions, the formation of sunspots and the overall solar dynamo. Observations suggest that toroidal flux concentrations often referred to as "flux tubes", rise from their region of initiation likely in the solar tachocline towards the solar surface due to magnetic…
▽ More
The buoyant transport of magnetic fields from the solar interior towards the surface plays an important role in the emergence of active regions, the formation of sunspots and the overall solar dynamo. Observations suggest that toroidal flux concentrations often referred to as "flux tubes", rise from their region of initiation likely in the solar tachocline towards the solar surface due to magnetic buoyancy. Many studies have assumed the existence of such magnetic structures and studied the buoyant rise of an isolated flux tube in a quiescent, field-free environment. Here, motivated by their formation (Cline et al. 2003; Brummell et al. 2002), we relax the latter assumption and study the rise of a toroidal flux tube embedded in a large-scale poloidal background magnetic field. We find that the presence of the large-scale background field severely affects the dynamics of the rising tube. A relatively weak background field, as low as 6% of the tube strength, can destroy the rise of a tube that would otherwise rise in the absence of the background field. Surprisingly, the rise of tubes with one sign of the twist is suppressed by a significantly weaker background field than the other. This demonstrates a potential mechanism for the selection of the preferred helicity of rising and emerging tubes for the solar case that is commensurate with many features of the hemispherical rule.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
