-
Topology and obliquity of core magnetic fields in shaping seismic properties of slowly rotating evolved stars
Authors:
Shyeh Tjing Loi
Abstract:
It is thought that magnetic fields must be present in the interiors of stars to resolve certain discrepancies between theory and observation (e.g. angular momentum transport), but such fields are difficult to detect and characterise. Asteroseismology is a powerful technique for inferring the internal structures of stars by measuring their oscillation frequencies, and succeeds particularly with evo…
▽ More
It is thought that magnetic fields must be present in the interiors of stars to resolve certain discrepancies between theory and observation (e.g. angular momentum transport), but such fields are difficult to detect and characterise. Asteroseismology is a powerful technique for inferring the internal structures of stars by measuring their oscillation frequencies, and succeeds particularly with evolved stars, owing to their mixed modes, which are sensitive to the deep interior. The goal of this work is to present a phenomenological study of the combined effects of rotation and magnetism in evolved stars, where both are assumed weak enough that first-order perturbation theory applies, and we focus on the regime where Coriolis and Lorentz forces are comparable. Axisymmetric "twisted-torus" field configurations are used, which are confined to the core and allowed to be misaligned with respect to the rotation axis. Factors such as the field radius, topology and obliquity are examined. We observe that fields with finer-scale radial structure and/or smaller radial extent produce smaller contributions to the frequency shift. The interplay of rotation and magnetism is shown to be complex: we demonstrate that it is possible for nearly symmetric multiplets of apparently low multiplicity to arise even under a substantial field, which might falsely appear to rule out its presence. Our results suggest that proper modelling of rotation and magnetism, in a simultaneous fashion, may be required to draw robust conclusions about the existence/non-existence of a core magnetic field in any given object.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Effect of a strong magnetic field on gravity-mode period spacings in red giant stars
Authors:
Shyeh Tjing Loi
Abstract:
When a star evolves into a red giant, the enhanced coupling between core-based gravity modes and envelope-based pressure modes forms mixed modes, allowing its deep interior to be probed by asteroseismology. The ability to obtain information about stellar interiors is important for constraining theories of stellar structure and evolution, for which the origin of various discrepancies between predic…
▽ More
When a star evolves into a red giant, the enhanced coupling between core-based gravity modes and envelope-based pressure modes forms mixed modes, allowing its deep interior to be probed by asteroseismology. The ability to obtain information about stellar interiors is important for constraining theories of stellar structure and evolution, for which the origin of various discrepancies between prediction and observation are still under debate. Ongoing speculation surrounds the possibility that some red giant stars may harbour strong (dynamically significant) magnetic fields in their cores, but interpretation of the observational data remains controversial. In part, this is tied to shortfalls in our understanding of the effects of strong fields on the seismic properties of gravity modes, which lies beyond the regime of standard perturbative methods. Here we seek to investigate the effect of a strong magnetic field on the asymptotic period spacings of gravity modes. We use a Hamiltonian ray approach to measure the volume of phase space occupied by mode-forming rays, this being roughly proportional to the average density of modes (number of modes per unit frequency interval). A strong field appears to systematically increase this by about 10%, which predicts a ~10% smaller period spacing. Evidence of near integrability in the ray dynamics hints that the gravity-mode spectrum may still exhibit pseudo-regularities under a strong field.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Magneto-gravity wave packet dynamics in strongly magnetised cores of evolved stars
Authors:
Shyeh Tjing Loi
Abstract:
Magnetic fields are believed to be generated in the cores of massive main sequence stars, and these may survive on to later stages of evolution. Observations of depressed dipole modes in red giant stars have been touted as evidence for these fields, but the predictions of existing magnetic theories have difficulty accommodating several aspects, including the need to return a fraction of wave energ…
▽ More
Magnetic fields are believed to be generated in the cores of massive main sequence stars, and these may survive on to later stages of evolution. Observations of depressed dipole modes in red giant stars have been touted as evidence for these fields, but the predictions of existing magnetic theories have difficulty accommodating several aspects, including the need to return a fraction of wave energy from the core to the envelope, and the persistent gravity-like character of affected modes. In this work we perform a Hamiltonian ray tracing study investigating the dynamics of magneto-gravity waves in full spherical geometry, using realistic stellar models and magnetic field configurations. This technique applies in the limit where wavelengths are much shorter than scales of background variation. We conduct a comprehensive exploration of parameter space, examining the roles of wave frequency, spherical harmonic degree, wavevector polarisation, incoming latitude, field strength, field radius, and evolutionary state. We demonstrate that even in the presence of a strong field, there exist trajectories where waves remain predominantly gravity-like in character, and these are able to undergo reflection out of the core much like pure gravity waves. The remaining trajectories are ones where waves acquire significant Alfven character, becoming trapped and eventually dissipated. Orientation effects, i.e. wavevector polarisation and incoming latitude, are found to be crucial factors in determining the outcome (trapped versus reflected) of individual wave packets. The allowance for partial energy return from the core offers a solution to the conundrum faced by the magnetic hypothesis.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Low-degree mixed modes in red giant stars with moderate core magnetic fields
Authors:
Shyeh Tjing Loi,
John C. B. Papaloizou
Abstract:
Observations of pressure-gravity mixed modes, combined with a theoretical framework for understanding mode formation, can yield a wealth of information about deep stellar interiors. In this paper, we seek to develop a formalism for treating the effects of deeply buried core magnetic fields on mixed modes in evolved stars, where the fields are moderate, i.e. not strong enough to disrupt wave propag…
▽ More
Observations of pressure-gravity mixed modes, combined with a theoretical framework for understanding mode formation, can yield a wealth of information about deep stellar interiors. In this paper, we seek to develop a formalism for treating the effects of deeply buried core magnetic fields on mixed modes in evolved stars, where the fields are moderate, i.e. not strong enough to disrupt wave propagation, but where they may be too strong for non-degenerate first-order perturbation theory to be applied. The magnetic field is incorporated in a way that avoids having to use this. Inclusion of the Lorentz force term is shown to yield a system of differential equations that allows for the magnetically-affected eigenfunctions to be computed from scratch, rather than following the approach of first-order perturbation theory. For sufficiently weak fields, coupling between different spherical harmonics can be neglected, allowing for reduction to a second-order system of ordinary differential equations akin to the usual oscillation equations that can be solved analogously. We derive expressions for (i) the mixed-mode quantisation condition in the presence of a field and (ii) the frequency shift associated with the magnetic field. In addition, for modes of low degree we uncover an extra offset term in the quantisation condition that is sensitive to properties of the evanescent zone. These expressions may be inverted to extract information about the stellar structure and magnetic field from observational data.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Effects of a strong magnetic field on internal gravity waves: trapping, phase mixing, reflection and dynamical chaos
Authors:
Shyeh Tjing Loi,
John C. B. Papaloizou
Abstract:
The spectrum of oscillation modes of a star provides information not only about its material properties (e.g. mean density), but also its symmetries. Spherical symmetry can be broken by rotation and/or magnetic fields. It has been postulated that strong magnetic fields in the cores of some red giants are responsible for their anomalously weak dipole mode amplitudes (the "dipole dichotomy" problem)…
▽ More
The spectrum of oscillation modes of a star provides information not only about its material properties (e.g. mean density), but also its symmetries. Spherical symmetry can be broken by rotation and/or magnetic fields. It has been postulated that strong magnetic fields in the cores of some red giants are responsible for their anomalously weak dipole mode amplitudes (the "dipole dichotomy" problem), but a detailed understanding of how gravity waves interact with strong fields is thus far lacking. In this work, we attack the problem through a variety of analytical and numerical techniques, applied to a localised region centred on a null line of a confined axisymmetric magnetic field which is approximated as being cylindrically symmetric. We uncover a rich variety of phenomena that manifest when the field strength exceeds a critical value, beyond which the symmetry is drastically broken by the Lorentz force. When this threshold is reached, the spatial structure of the g-modes becomes heavily altered. The dynamics of wave packet propagation transitions from regular to chaotic, which is expected to fundamentally change the organisation of the mode spectrum. In addition, depending on their frequency and the orientation of field lines with respect to the stratification, waves impinging on different parts of the magnetised region are found to undergo either reflection or trapping. Trapping regions provide an avenue for energy loss through Alfven wave phase mixing. Our results may find application in various astrophysical contexts, including the dipole dichotomy problem, the solar interior, and compact star oscillations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Torsional Alfvén resonances as an efficient damping mechanism for non-radial oscillations in red giant stars
Authors:
Shyeh Tjing Loi,
John C. B. Papaloizou
Abstract:
Stars are self-gravitating fluids in which pressure, buoyancy, rotation and magnetic fields provide the restoring forces for global modes of oscillation. Pressure and buoyancy energetically dominate, while rotation and magnetism are generally assumed to be weak perturbations and often ignored. However, observations of anomalously weak dipole mode amplitudes in red giant stars suggest that a substa…
▽ More
Stars are self-gravitating fluids in which pressure, buoyancy, rotation and magnetic fields provide the restoring forces for global modes of oscillation. Pressure and buoyancy energetically dominate, while rotation and magnetism are generally assumed to be weak perturbations and often ignored. However, observations of anomalously weak dipole mode amplitudes in red giant stars suggest that a substantial fraction of these are subject to an additional source of damping localised to their core region, with indirect evidence pointing to the role of a deeply buried magnetic field. It is also known that in many instances the gravity-mode character of affected modes is preserved, but so far no effective damping mechanism has been proposed that accommodates this aspect. Here we present such a mechanism, which damps the oscillations of stars harbouring magnetised cores via resonant interactions with standing Alfvén modes of high harmonic index. The damping rates produced by this mechanism are quantitatively on par with those associated with turbulent convection, and in the range required to explain observations, for realistic stellar models and magnetic field strengths. Our results suggest that magnetic fields can provide an efficient means of damping stellar oscillations without needing to disrupt the internal structure of the modes, and lay the groundwork for an extension of the theory of global stellar oscillations that incorporates these effects.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
A new angle for probing field-aligned irregularities with the Murchison Widefield Array
Authors:
Shyeh Tjing Loi,
Tara Murphy,
Iver H. Cairns,
Cathryn M. Trott,
Natasha Hurley-Walker,
Lu Feng,
Paul J. Hancock,
David L. Kaplan
Abstract:
Electron density irregularities in the ionosphere are known to be magnetically anisotropic, preferentially elongated along the lines of force. While many studies of their morphology have been undertaken by topside sounding and whistler measurements, it is only recently that detailed regional-scale reconstructions have become possible, enabled by the advent of widefield radio telescopes. Here we pr…
▽ More
Electron density irregularities in the ionosphere are known to be magnetically anisotropic, preferentially elongated along the lines of force. While many studies of their morphology have been undertaken by topside sounding and whistler measurements, it is only recently that detailed regional-scale reconstructions have become possible, enabled by the advent of widefield radio telescopes. Here we present a new approach for visualising and studying field-aligned irregularities (FAIs), which involves transforming interferometric measurements of TEC gradients onto a magnetic shell tangent plane. This removes the perspective distortion associated with the oblique viewing angle of the irregularities from the ground, facilitating the decomposition of dynamics along and across magnetic field lines. We apply this transformation to the dataset of Loi et al. [2015a], obtained on 15 October 2013 by the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA) radio telescope and displaying prominent FAIs. We study these FAIs in the new reference frame, quantifying field-aligned and field-transverse behaviour, examining time and altitude dependencies, and extending the analysis to FAIs on sub-array scales. We show that the inclination of the plane can be derived solely from the data, and verify that the best-fit value is consistent with the known magnetic inclination. The ability of the model to concentrate the fluctuations along a single spatial direction may find practical application to future calibration strategies for widefield interferometry, by providing a compact representation of FAI-induced distortions.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Density duct formation in the wake of a travelling ionospheric disturbance: Murchison Widefield Array observations
Authors:
Shyeh Tjing Loi,
Iver H. Cairns,
Tara Murphy,
Philip J. Erickson,
Martin E. Bell,
Antonia Rowlinson,
Balwinder Singh Arora,
John Morgan,
Ronald D. Ekers,
Natasha Hurley-Walker,
David L. Kaplan
Abstract:
Geomagnetically-aligned density structures with a range of sizes exist in the near-Earth plasma environment, including 10-100 km-wide VLF/HF wave-ducting structures. Their small diameters and modest density enhancements make them difficult to observe, and there is limited evidence for any of the several formation mechanisms proposed to date. We present a case study of an event on 26 August 2014 wh…
▽ More
Geomagnetically-aligned density structures with a range of sizes exist in the near-Earth plasma environment, including 10-100 km-wide VLF/HF wave-ducting structures. Their small diameters and modest density enhancements make them difficult to observe, and there is limited evidence for any of the several formation mechanisms proposed to date. We present a case study of an event on 26 August 2014 where a travelling ionospheric disturbance (TID) shortly precedes the formation of a complex collection of field-aligned ducts, using data obtained by the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA) radio telescope. Their spatiotemporal proximity leads us to suggest a causal interpretation. Geomagnetic conditions were quiet at the time, and no obvious triggers were noted. Growth of the structures proceeds rapidly, within 0.5 hr of the passage of the TID, attaining their peak prominence 1-2 hr later and persisting for several more hours until observations ended at local dawn. Analyses of the next two days show field-aligned structures to be preferentially detectable under quiet rather than active geomagnetic conditions. We used a raster scanning strategy facilitated by the speed of electronic beamforming to expand the quasi-instantaneous field of view of the MWA by a factor of three. These observations represent the broadest angular coverage of the ionosphere by a radio telescope to date.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Quantifying ionospheric effects on time-domain astrophysics with the Murchison Widefield Array
Authors:
Shyeh Tjing Loi,
Tara Murphy,
Martin E. Bell,
David L. Kaplan,
Emil Lenc,
Andre R. Offringa,
Natasha Hurley-Walker,
G. Bernardi,
J. D. Bowman,
F. Briggs,
R. J. Cappallo,
B. E. Corey,
A. A. Deshpande,
D. Emrich,
B. M. Gaensler,
R. Goeke,
L. J. Greenhill,
B. J. Hazelton,
M. Johnston-Hollitt,
J. C. Kasper,
E. Kratzenberg,
C. J. Lonsdale,
M. J. Lynch,
S. R. McWhirter,
D. A. Mitchell
, et al. (17 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Refraction and diffraction of incoming radio waves by the ionosphere induce time variability in the angular positions, peak amplitudes and shapes of radio sources, potentially complicating the automated cross-matching and identification of transient and variable radio sources. In this work, we empirically assess the effects of the ionosphere on data taken by the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA) rad…
▽ More
Refraction and diffraction of incoming radio waves by the ionosphere induce time variability in the angular positions, peak amplitudes and shapes of radio sources, potentially complicating the automated cross-matching and identification of transient and variable radio sources. In this work, we empirically assess the effects of the ionosphere on data taken by the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA) radio telescope. We directly examine 51 hours of data observed over 10 nights under quiet geomagnetic conditions (global storm index Kp < 2), analysing the behaviour of short-timescale angular position and peak flux density variations of around ten thousand unresolved sources. We find that while much of the variation in angular position can be attributed to ionospheric refraction, the characteristic displacements (10-20 arcsec) at 154 MHz are small enough that search radii of 1-2 arcmin should be sufficient for cross-matching under typical conditions. By examining bulk trends in amplitude variability, we place upper limits on the modulation index associated with ionospheric scintillation of 1-3% for the various nights. For sources fainter than ~1 Jy, this variation is below the image noise at typical MWA sensitivities. Our results demonstrate that the ionosphere is not a significant impediment to the goals of time-domain science with the MWA at 154 MHz.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Power spectrum analysis of ionospheric fluctuations with the Murchison Widefield Array
Authors:
Shyeh Tjing Loi,
Cathryn M. Trott,
Tara Murphy,
Iver H. Cairns,
Martin Bell,
Natasha Hurley-Walker,
John Morgan,
Emil Lenc,
A. R. Offringa,
L. Feng,
P. J. Hancock,
D. L. Kaplan,
N. Kudryavtseva,
G. Bernardi,
J. D. Bowman,
F. Briggs,
R. J. Cappallo,
B. E. Corey,
A. A. Deshpande,
D. Emrich,
B. M. Gaensler,
R. Goeke,
L. J. Greenhill,
B. J. Hazelton,
M. Johnston-Hollitt
, et al. (23 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Low-frequency, wide field-of-view (FoV) radio telescopes such as the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA) enable the ionosphere to be sampled at high spatial completeness. We present the results of the first power spectrum analysis of ionospheric fluctuations in MWA data, where we examined the position offsets of radio sources appearing in two datasets. The refractive shifts in the positions of celesti…
▽ More
Low-frequency, wide field-of-view (FoV) radio telescopes such as the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA) enable the ionosphere to be sampled at high spatial completeness. We present the results of the first power spectrum analysis of ionospheric fluctuations in MWA data, where we examined the position offsets of radio sources appearing in two datasets. The refractive shifts in the positions of celestial sources are proportional to spatial gradients in the electron column density transverse to the line of sight. These can be used to probe plasma structures and waves in the ionosphere. The regional (10-100 km) scales probed by the MWA, determined by the size of its FoV and the spatial density of radio sources (typically thousands in a single FoV), complement the global (100-1000 km) scales of GPS studies and local (0.01-1 km) scales of radar scattering measurements. Our data exhibit a range of complex structures and waves. Some fluctuations have the characteristics of travelling ionospheric disturbances (TIDs), while others take the form of narrow, slowly-drifting bands aligned along the Earth's magnetic field.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Real-time imaging of density ducts between the plasmasphere and ionosphere
Authors:
Shyeh Tjing Loi,
Tara Murphy,
Iver H. Cairns,
Frederick W. Menk,
Colin L. Waters,
Philip J. Erickson,
Cathryn M. Trott,
Natasha Hurley-Walker,
John Morgan,
Emil Lenc,
Andre R. Offringa,
Martin E. Bell,
Ronald D. Ekers,
B. M. Gaensler,
Colin J. Lonsdale,
Lu Feng,
Paul J. Hancock,
David L. Kaplan,
G. Bernardi,
J. D. Bowman,
F. Briggs,
R. J. Cappallo,
A. A. Deshpande,
L. J. Greenhill,
B. J. Hazelton
, et al. (16 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Ionization of the Earth's atmosphere by sunlight forms a complex, multi-layered plasma environment within the Earth's magnetosphere, the innermost layers being the ionosphere and plasmasphere. The plasmasphere is believed to be embedded with cylindrical density structures (ducts) aligned along the Earth's magnetic field, but direct evidence for these remains scarce. Here we report the first direct…
▽ More
Ionization of the Earth's atmosphere by sunlight forms a complex, multi-layered plasma environment within the Earth's magnetosphere, the innermost layers being the ionosphere and plasmasphere. The plasmasphere is believed to be embedded with cylindrical density structures (ducts) aligned along the Earth's magnetic field, but direct evidence for these remains scarce. Here we report the first direct wide-angle observation of an extensive array of field-aligned ducts bridging the upper ionosphere and inner plasmasphere, using a novel ground-based imaging technique. We establish their heights and motions by feature-tracking and parallax analysis. The structures are strikingly organized, appearing as regularly-spaced, alternating tubes of overdensities and underdensities strongly aligned with the Earth's magnetic field. These findings represent the first direct visual evidence for the existence of such structures.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
