-
Small-scale and large-scale dynamos in global convection simulations of solar-like stars
Authors:
Jörn Warnecke,
Maarit J. Korpi-Lagg,
Matthias Rheinhard,
Mariangela Viviani,
Ameya Prabhu
Abstract:
It has been recently shown that a small-scale dynamo (SSD) instability could be possible in solar-like low magnetic Prandtl number Pm plasmas. It has been proposed that the presence of SSD can potentially have a significant impact on the dynamics of the large-scale dynamo (LSD) in the stellar convection zones. Studying these two dynamos, SSD and LSD, together in a global magnetoconvection model re…
▽ More
It has been recently shown that a small-scale dynamo (SSD) instability could be possible in solar-like low magnetic Prandtl number Pm plasmas. It has been proposed that the presence of SSD can potentially have a significant impact on the dynamics of the large-scale dynamo (LSD) in the stellar convection zones. Studying these two dynamos, SSD and LSD, together in a global magnetoconvection model requires high-resolution simulations and large amounts of computational resources. Starting from a well-studied global convective dynamo model that produces cyclic magnetic fields, we systematically increased the resolution and lowered the diffusivities to enter the regime of Reynolds numbers that allow for the excitation of SSD on top of the LSD. We studied how the properties of convection, generated differential rotation profiles, and LSD solutions change with the presence of SSD. We performed convective dynamo simulations in a spherical wedge with the Pencil Code. The resolutions of the models were increased in 4 steps by a total factor of 16 to achieve maximal fluid and magnetic Reynolds numbers of over 500. We found that the differential rotation is strongly quenched by the presence of the LSD and SSD. Even though the small-scale magnetic field only mildly decreases increasing Re, the large-scale field strength decreases significantly. We do not find the SSD dynamo significantly quenching the convective flows as claimed recently by other authors; in contrast, the convective flows first grow and then saturate for increasing Re. Furthermore, the angular momentum transport is highly affected by the presence of small-scale magnetic fields, which are mostly generated by LSD. These fields not only change the Reynolds stresses, but also generate dynamically important Maxwell stresses. The LSD evolution in terms of its pattern and field distribution is rather independent of the increase in Rm.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Almost fifty years of Metsähovi solar observations on 37 GHz with recovered digitised historical maps
Authors:
Sami Kivistö,
Frederick Gent,
Merja Tornikoski,
Joni Tammi,
Maarit Korpi-Lagg
Abstract:
Context. Aalto University Metsähovi Radio Observatory has collected solar intensity maps for over 45 years. Most data coverage is on the 37 GHz frequency band, tracking emissions primarily at the chromosphere and coronal transition region. The data spans four sunspot cycles or two solar magnetic cycles. Aims. We present solar maps, including recently restored data prior to 1989, spanning 1978 to 2…
▽ More
Context. Aalto University Metsähovi Radio Observatory has collected solar intensity maps for over 45 years. Most data coverage is on the 37 GHz frequency band, tracking emissions primarily at the chromosphere and coronal transition region. The data spans four sunspot cycles or two solar magnetic cycles. Aims. We present solar maps, including recently restored data prior to 1989, spanning 1978 to 2020 after correcting for observational and temporal bias. Methods. The solar maps consist of radio intensity sampled along scanlines of the antenna sweep. We fit a circular disk to the set of intensity samples, neglecting any exceptional features in the fitting process to improve accuracy. Applying a simple astronomical model of Sun and Earth, we assign each radio specimen its heliographic coordinates at the time of observation. We bin the sample data by time and heliographic latitude to construct a diagram analoguous to the classic butterfly diagram of sunspot activity. Results. Radio butterfly diagram at 37 GHz, spanning solar cycles 21 to 24 and extending near to the poles. Conclusions. We have developed a method for compensating for seasonal and atmospheric bias in the radio data, as well as correcting for the effects of limb brightening and beamwidth convolution to isolate physical features. Our observations are consistent with observations in nearby bandwidths and indicate the possibility of polar cyclic behaviour with a period exceeding the solar 11 year cycle. Key words. Solar physics, radioastronomy, butterfly diagram, solar cycle
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Computational approaches to modeling dynamos in galaxies
Authors:
Maarit J. Korpi-Lagg,
Mordecai-Mark Mac Low,
Frederick A. Gent
Abstract:
Galaxies are observed to host magnetic fields with a typical total strength of around 15microgauss. A coherent large-scale field constitutes up to a few microgauss of the total, while the rest is built from strong magnetic fluctuations over a wide range of spatial scales. This represents sufficient magnetic energy for it to be dynamically significant. Several questions immediately arise: What is t…
▽ More
Galaxies are observed to host magnetic fields with a typical total strength of around 15microgauss. A coherent large-scale field constitutes up to a few microgauss of the total, while the rest is built from strong magnetic fluctuations over a wide range of spatial scales. This represents sufficient magnetic energy for it to be dynamically significant. Several questions immediately arise: What is the physical mechanism that gives rise to such magnetic fields? How do these magnetic fields affect the formation and evolution of galaxies? In which physical processes do magnetic fields play a role, and how can that role be characterized? Numerical modelling of magnetized flows in galaxies is playing an ever-increasing role in finding those answers. We review major techniques used for these models. Current results strongly support the conclusion that field growth occurs during the formation of the first galaxies on timescales shorter than their accretion timescales due to small-scale turbulent dynamos. The saturated small-scale dynamo maintains field strengths at a few percent of equipartition with turbulence. The subsequent action of large-scale dynamos in differentially rotating discs produces observed modern field strengths in equipartition with the turbulence and having power at large scales. The field structure resulting appears consistent with observations including Faraday rotation and polarisation from synchrotron and dust thermal emission. Major remaining challenges include scaling numerical models toward realistic scale separations and Prandtl and Reynolds numbers.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
From convective stellar dynamo simulations to Zeeman-Doppler images
Authors:
Thomas Hackman,
Oleg Kochukhov,
Mariangela Viviani,
Jörn Warnecke,
Maarit J. Korpi-Lagg,
Jyri J. Lehtinen
Abstract:
Zeeman-Doppler imaging (ZDI) is used to reconstruct the surface magnetic field of late-type stars from high resolution spectropolarimetric observations. The results are usually described in terms of characteristics of the field topology, i.e. poloidality vs. toroidality and axi-symmetry vs. non-axisymmetry in addition to the field strength. We want to test how well these characteristics are preser…
▽ More
Zeeman-Doppler imaging (ZDI) is used to reconstruct the surface magnetic field of late-type stars from high resolution spectropolarimetric observations. The results are usually described in terms of characteristics of the field topology, i.e. poloidality vs. toroidality and axi-symmetry vs. non-axisymmetry in addition to the field strength. We want to test how well these characteristics are preserved when applying the ZDI method on simulated data, i.e. how accurately the field topology is preserved and to what extent stellar parameters influence the reconstruction. We use published magnetic field data from direct numerical MHD simulations. These have variable rotation rates, and hence represent different levels of activity, of an otherwise Sun-like setup. Our ZDI reconstruction is based on spherical harmonics expansion. By comparing the original values to those of the reconstructed images, we study the ability to reconstruct the surface magnetic field in terms of various characteristics of the field. The main large-scale features are reasonably well recovered, but the strength of the recovered magnetic field is just a fraction of the original input. The quality of the reconstruction shows clear correlations with the data quality. Furthermore, there are some spurious dependencies between stellar parameters and the characteristics of the field. Our study uncovers some limits of ZDI. Firstly, the recovered field strength will generally be lower than the "real" value as smaller structures with opposite polarities will be blurred in the inversion. Secondly, the axisymmetry is overestimated. The poloidality vs. toroidality is better recovered. The reconstruction works better for a stronger field and faster rotation velocity. Still, the ZDI method works surprisingly well even for a weaker field and slow rotation, provided the data has a high signal-to-noise and good rotation phase coverage.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2024; v1 submitted 13 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Transition from small-scale to large-scale dynamo in a supernova-driven, multiphase medium
Authors:
Frederick A. Gent,
Mordecai-Mark Mac Low,
Maarit J. Korpi-Lagg
Abstract:
Magnetic fields are widely recognised as critical at many scales to galactic dynamics and structure, including multiphase pressure balance, dust processing, and star formation. Using imposed magnetic fields cannot reliably model the interstellar medium's (ISM) dynamical structure nor phase interactions. Dynamos must be modelled. ISM models exist of turbulent magnetic fields using small-scale dynam…
▽ More
Magnetic fields are widely recognised as critical at many scales to galactic dynamics and structure, including multiphase pressure balance, dust processing, and star formation. Using imposed magnetic fields cannot reliably model the interstellar medium's (ISM) dynamical structure nor phase interactions. Dynamos must be modelled. ISM models exist of turbulent magnetic fields using small-scale dynamo (SSD). Others model the large-scale dynamo (LSD) organising magnetic fields at scale of the disc or spiral arms. Separately, neither can fully describe the galactic magnetic field dynamics nor topology. We model the LSD and SSD together at sufficient resolution to use the low explicit Lagrangian resistivity required. The galactic SSD saturates within 20 Myr. We show that the SSD is quite insensitive to the presence of an LSD and is even stronger in the presence of a large-scale shear flow. The LSD grows more slowly in the presence of SSD, saturating after 5 Gyr vs. 1--2 Gyr in studies where the SSD is weak or absent. The LSD primarily grows in warm gas in the galactic midplane. Saturation of the LSD occurs due to $α$-quenching near the midplane as the growing mean field produces a magnetic $α$ that opposes the kinetic $α$. The magnetic energy in our models of the LSD shows slightly sublinear response to increasing resolution, indicating that we are converging towards the physical solution at 1 pc resolution. Clustering supernovae in OB associations increases the growth rates for both the SSD and the LSD, compared to a horizontally uniform supernova distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2023; v1 submitted 12 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Numerical evidence for a small-scale dynamo approaching solar magnetic Prandtl numbers
Authors:
Jörn Warnecke,
Maarit J. Korpi-Lagg,
Frederick A. Gent,
Matthias Rheinhardt
Abstract:
Magnetic fields on small scales are ubiquitous in the universe. Though they can often be observed in detail, their generation mechanisms are not fully understood. One possibility is the so-called small-scale dynamo (SSD). Prevailing numerical evidence, however, appears to indicate that an SSD is unlikely to exist at very low magnetic Prandtl numbers ($Pr_M$) such as are present in the Sun and othe…
▽ More
Magnetic fields on small scales are ubiquitous in the universe. Though they can often be observed in detail, their generation mechanisms are not fully understood. One possibility is the so-called small-scale dynamo (SSD). Prevailing numerical evidence, however, appears to indicate that an SSD is unlikely to exist at very low magnetic Prandtl numbers ($Pr_M$) such as are present in the Sun and other cool stars. We have performed high-resolution simulations of isothermal forced turbulence employing the lowest $Pr_M$ values so far achieved. Contrary to earlier findings, the SSD turns out to be not only possible for $Pr_M$ down to 0.0031, but even becomes increasingly easier to excite for $Pr_M$ below $\simeq\,$0.05. We relate this behaviour to the known hydrodynamic phenomenon referred to as the bottleneck effect. Extrapolating our results to solar values of $Pr_M$ indicates that an SSD would be possible under such conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Small-scale dynamos: From idealized models to solar and stellar applications
Authors:
Matthias Rempel,
Tanayveer Bhatia,
Luis Bellot Rubio,
Maarit J. Korpi-Lagg
Abstract:
In this article we review small-scale dynamo processes that are responsible for magnetic field generation on scales comparable to and smaller than the energy carrying scales of turbulence. We provide a review of critical observation of quiet Sun magnetism, which have provided strong support for the operation of a small-scale dynamo in the solar photosphere and convection zone. After a review of ba…
▽ More
In this article we review small-scale dynamo processes that are responsible for magnetic field generation on scales comparable to and smaller than the energy carrying scales of turbulence. We provide a review of critical observation of quiet Sun magnetism, which have provided strong support for the operation of a small-scale dynamo in the solar photosphere and convection zone. After a review of basic concepts we focus on numerical studies of kinematic growth and non-linear saturation in idealized setups, with special emphasis on the role of the magnetic Prandtl number for dynamo onset and saturation. Moving towards astrophysical applications we review convective dynamo setups that focus on the deep convection zone and the photospheres of solar-like stars. We review the critical ingredients for stellar convection setups and discuss their application to the Sun and solar-like stars including comparison against available observations.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
The small-scale dynamo in a multiphase supernova-driven medium
Authors:
Frederick A. Gent,
Mordecai-Mark Mac Low,
Maarit J. Korpi-Lagg,
Nishant K. Singh
Abstract:
Magnetic fields grow quickly, even at early cosmological times, suggesting the action of a small-scale dynamo (SSD) in the interstellar medium (ISM) of galaxies. Many studies have focused on idealized, isotropic, homogeneous, turbulent driving of the SSD. Here we analyze more realistic simulations of supernova-driven turbulence to understand how it drives an SSD. We find that SSD growth rates are…
▽ More
Magnetic fields grow quickly, even at early cosmological times, suggesting the action of a small-scale dynamo (SSD) in the interstellar medium (ISM) of galaxies. Many studies have focused on idealized, isotropic, homogeneous, turbulent driving of the SSD. Here we analyze more realistic simulations of supernova-driven turbulence to understand how it drives an SSD. We find that SSD growth rates are intermittently variable as a result of the evolving multiphase ISM structure. Rapid growth in the magnetic field typically occurs in hot gas, with the highest overall growth rates occurring when the fractional volume of hot gas is large. SSD growth rates correlate most strongly with vorticity and fluid Reynolds number, which also both correlate strongly with gas temperature. Rotational energy exceeds irrotational energy in all phases, but particularly in the hot phase while SSD growth is most rapid. Supernova (SN) rate does not significantly affect the ISM average kinetic energy density. Rather, higher temperatures associated with high SN rates tend to increase SSD growth rates. SSD saturates with total magnetic energy density around 5% of equipartition to kinetic energy density, increasing slightly with magnetic Prandtl number. While magnetic energy density in the hot gas can exceed that of the other phases when SSD grows most rapidly, it saturates below 5% of equipartition with kinetic energy in the hot gas, while in the cold gas it attains 100%. Fast, intermittent growth of the magnetic field appears to be a characteristic behavior of SN-driven, multiphase turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2022; v1 submitted 10 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Solar-Cycle Variation of quiet-Sun Magnetism and Surface Gravity Oscillation Mode
Authors:
Maarit J. Korpi-Lagg,
Andreas Korpi-Lagg,
Nigul Olspert,
Hong-Linh Truong
Abstract:
The origin of the quiet Sun magnetism is under debate. Investigating the solar cycle variation observationally in more detail can give us clues about how to resolve the controversies. We investigate the solar cycle variation of the most magnetically quiet regions and their surface gravity oscillation ($f$-) mode integrated energy ($E_f$). We use 12 years of HMI data and apply a stringent selection…
▽ More
The origin of the quiet Sun magnetism is under debate. Investigating the solar cycle variation observationally in more detail can give us clues about how to resolve the controversies. We investigate the solar cycle variation of the most magnetically quiet regions and their surface gravity oscillation ($f$-) mode integrated energy ($E_f$). We use 12 years of HMI data and apply a stringent selection criteria, based on spatial and temporal quietness, to avoid any influence of active regions (ARs). We develop an automated high-throughput pipeline to go through all available magnetogram data and to compute $E_f$ for the selected quiet regions. We observe a clear solar cycle dependence of the magnetic field strength in the most quiet regions containing several supergranular cells. For patch sizes smaller than a supergranular cell, no significant cycle dependence is detected. The $E_f$ at the supergranular scale is not constant over time. During the late ascending phase of Cycle 24 (SC24, 2011-2012), it is roughly constant, but starts diminishing in 2013, as the maximum of SC24 is approached. This trend continues until mid-2017, when hints of strengthening at higher southern latitudes are seen. Slow strengthening continues, stronger at higher latitudes than at the equatorial regions, but $E_f$ never returns back to the values seen in 2011-2012. Also, the strengthening trend continues past the solar minimum, to the years when SC25 is already clearly ascending. Hence the $E_f$ behavior is not in phase with the solar cycle. The anticorrelation of $E_f$ with the solar cycle in gross terms is expected, but the phase shift of several years indicates a connection to the poloidal large-scale magnetic field component rather than the toroidal one. Calibrating AR signals with the QS $E_f$ does not reveal significant enhancement of the $f$-mode prior to AR emergence.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
V889 Her: abrupt changes in the magnetic field or differential rotation?
Authors:
Teemu Willamo,
Thomas Hackman,
Jyri J. Lehtinen,
Maarit Korpi-Lagg,
Oleg Kochukhov
Abstract:
We have applied Zeeman-Doppler imaging (ZDI) to an extensive spectropolarimetric HARPSpol data set of the magnetically active young solar analogue V889 Her, covering 35 spectra obtained during six nights in May 2011. The data set allows us to study Stokes V profiles of the star at almost identical rotational phases, separated by one or more stellar rotations. We use these data to study if the line…
▽ More
We have applied Zeeman-Doppler imaging (ZDI) to an extensive spectropolarimetric HARPSpol data set of the magnetically active young solar analogue V889 Her, covering 35 spectra obtained during six nights in May 2011. The data set allows us to study Stokes V profiles of the star at almost identical rotational phases, separated by one or more stellar rotations. We use these data to study if the line profiles evolve from one rotation to the next, and find that some evolution does indeed occur. We consider two possible explanations for this: abrupt changes in the large-scale magnetic field or differential rotation. We find it quite difficult to distinguish between the two alternatives using ZDI alone. A strong differential rotation could, however, explain the changes in the line profiles, so we conclude that it must be present, and the abrupt magnetic field evolution is left uncertain. Commonly, rapidly rotating stars are assumed to have only weak differential rotation. If the strong differential rotation of V889 Her is indeed present, as has been found in other studies as well, it could indicate that the theoretical and numerical results of differential rotation still need to be revised. The rapid changes that may have occurred in the magnetic field indicate that one should be quite cautious when interpreting ZDI maps constructed from data over long time intervals.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2022; v1 submitted 24 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
