-
Hubble tension may indicate time-dependent dark matter comoving energy density
Authors:
Noriaki Kitazawa
Abstract:
The values of Hubble constant H0 by direct measurements with standard distance ladder are typically larger than those obtained from the observation of cosmic microwave background and the galaxy survey with inverse distance ladder. On the other hand, although the errors are still large, various determinations of the value of matter density parameter Omega_m are consistent with each other. Therefore…
▽ More
The values of Hubble constant H0 by direct measurements with standard distance ladder are typically larger than those obtained from the observation of cosmic microwave background and the galaxy survey with inverse distance ladder. On the other hand, although the errors are still large, various determinations of the value of matter density parameter Omega_m are consistent with each other. Therefore, it is possible that the difference in Hubble constant is translated to the difference of physical matter energy density omega_m = Omega_m h^2, where h = H0 / (100 Km/s/Mpc). In this article it is examined the possibility of an increase of the physical dark matter energy density (comoving energy density without the effect of expansion of the universe) by a fast transition at a certain value of redshift as a possible resolution of the Hubble tension. A phenomenological fluid model of the dark sector, which is the modification of a so-called unified dark matter model, is introduced to concretely realize such a fast transition in the physical dark matter energy density.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2024; v1 submitted 6 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Late-time data require smaller sound horizon at recombination
Authors:
Noriaki Kitazawa
Abstract:
The Hubble constant problem is that the values of Hubble constant from the observation of cosmic microwave background assuming the LambdaCDM model disagrees with the values from direct measurements. This problem suggests some new physics beyond the LambdaCDM model. Typically there are two ways of reconciliation: one is the realization of smaller value of sound horizon at recombination, and the oth…
▽ More
The Hubble constant problem is that the values of Hubble constant from the observation of cosmic microwave background assuming the LambdaCDM model disagrees with the values from direct measurements. This problem suggests some new physics beyond the LambdaCDM model. Typically there are two ways of reconciliation: one is the realization of smaller value of sound horizon at recombination, and the other is the modification of the way of expansion of the universe after recombination. In this letter we examine the latter possibility by comparing two typical phenomenological dark energy models with the distance-redshift relation provided by Pantheon catalogue of supernova observations and galaxy surveys by BOSS and eBOSS collaborations. Though these phenomenological dark energy models globally fit observations better than the LambdaCDM model, they are strongly disfavored by the distance-redshift relation as almost the same level as the LambdaCDM model defined by cosmic microwave background observations. The distance-redshift relation strongly suggests some new physics which realize smaller value of sound horizon at recombination.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Inflaton as a pseudo-Nambu-Goldstone boson
Authors:
Noriaki Kitazawa
Abstract:
In the realistic model of cosmic inflation the inflaton potential should be flat and stable under quantum corrections. It is natural to imagine that there is some symmetry behind and an idea of the inflaton as a Nambu-Goldstone boson of spontaneous breaking of some symmetry has been examined. We give a general formulation of this idea using the non-linear realization of Nambu-Goldstone boson in lo…
▽ More
In the realistic model of cosmic inflation the inflaton potential should be flat and stable under quantum corrections. It is natural to imagine that there is some symmetry behind and an idea of the inflaton as a Nambu-Goldstone boson of spontaneous breaking of some symmetry has been examined. We give a general formulation of this idea using the non-linear realization of Nambu-Goldstone boson in low-energy effective theory with some explicit symmetry breaking to generate non-trivial potential. The potential is naturally a simple function, typically the mass term of inflaton, and the scenario of "warm inflation" should necessarily be applied under the present observational constraints. We investigate the generation mechanism of necessary thermal dissipation term in inflaton field equation for "warm inflation" without large thermal corrections to inflaton potential. A simple numerical analysis is given to investigate the viability of this scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2022; v1 submitted 17 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Reionization process dependence of the ratio of CMB polarization power spectra at low-$\ell$
Authors:
Noriaki Kitazawa
Abstract:
We investigate how much the ratio of cosmic microwave background (CMB) polarization power spectra $C^{BB}_\ell/C^{EE}_\ell$ at low-$\ell$ ($\ell \lesssim 10$) depends on the process of reionization. Both such low-$\ell$ B-mode and E-mode polarization powers are dominantly produced by Thomson scattering of CMB photons off the free electrons which are produced in the process of reionization. Since t…
▽ More
We investigate how much the ratio of cosmic microwave background (CMB) polarization power spectra $C^{BB}_\ell/C^{EE}_\ell$ at low-$\ell$ ($\ell \lesssim 10$) depends on the process of reionization. Both such low-$\ell$ B-mode and E-mode polarization powers are dominantly produced by Thomson scattering of CMB photons off the free electrons which are produced in the process of reionization. Since the reionization should be finished until at least the redshift $z \simeq 6$ and the low-$\ell$ polarization powers are produced at late time, the ratio is rather insensitive by the ionization process at higher redshifts, but it is sensitive to the value of optical depth.The value of the ratio at $\ell=2$, however, is almost insensitive to the reionization process including the value of optical depth, and the value is approximately half of the value of tensor-to-scalar ratio. This fact can be utilized for future determination of tensor-to-scalar ratio in spite of the ambiguity due to cosmic variance.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2022; v1 submitted 7 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Polarization of CMB and possible time dependence of dark energy
Authors:
Noriaki Kitazawa
Abstract:
Dark energy has been introduced to explain the present accelerating expansion of the universe. In the LambdaCDM model, the present standard model of cosmology, dark energy is described as a cosmological constant which is time independent. The possibility of the time dependence of dark energy has been investigated to obtain deeper understanding of it by looking redshit-magnitude relation of type Ia…
▽ More
Dark energy has been introduced to explain the present accelerating expansion of the universe. In the LambdaCDM model, the present standard model of cosmology, dark energy is described as a cosmological constant which is time independent. The possibility of the time dependence of dark energy has been investigated to obtain deeper understanding of it by looking redshit-magnitude relation of type Ia supernova, for example. We investigate the constraints to the time dependence of dark energy with several phenomenological models by fitting their parameters to the redshit-magnitude relation of the Pantheon supernova catalog, and confirm that little time dependence can not be excluded by the goodness-of-fit criterion only. Such a non-trivial time dependence causes different expansion rate in the period of reionization, which affects the low-l polarization power spectrum of CMB. We investigate the possibility to detect the effect in future probe like LiteBIRD, for example. We find that the low-l EE polarization power spectrum is enhanced in general, but it will be difficult to be detected as far as looking the EE polarization power spectrum only because of the limitation by cosmic variance.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2021; v1 submitted 30 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Polarizations of CMB and the Hubble tension
Authors:
Noriaki Kitazawa
Abstract:
Future precision measurements of CMB polarizations can shed new light on the problem so called Hubble tension. The Hubble tension comes from the difference of the evolutions of the Hubble parameter which are determined with two different distance ladders. The standard distance ladder with the observation of Cepheid variables and type Ia supernovae gives larger values of the Hubble constant, and th…
▽ More
Future precision measurements of CMB polarizations can shed new light on the problem so called Hubble tension. The Hubble tension comes from the difference of the evolutions of the Hubble parameter which are determined with two different distance ladders. The standard distance ladder with the observation of Cepheid variables and type Ia supernovae gives larger values of the Hubble constant, and the inverse distance ladder with the observation of the baryon acoustic oscillations both in the CMB and in the clustering of galaxies gives smaller values of the Hubble constant. These different evolutions of the Hubble parameter indicate different evolutions of the free electron density in the process of the reionization of the universe and different magnitudes of low-l polarizations of the CMB, since these polarizations are mainly produced through the Thomson scattering of CMB photons off these free electrons. We investigate the effect on CMB E-mode and B-mode polarizations of l < 12 assuming non-trivially time-dependent equation of state of dark energy. We find that the case of the standard distance ladder gives higher power of polarizations than the prediction in the LambdaCDM model.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2021; v1 submitted 23 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
On CMB B-modes and the Onset of Inflation
Authors:
Noriaki Kitazawa
Abstract:
The temperature perturbations of the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMB) appear systematically suppressed, at large angular scales, with respect to the prediction of the LambdaCDM concordance model. This behavior might be a glimpse of the inflaton deceleration from fast-roll at the start of inflation. If this were true, the spectrum of primordial tensor perturbations should be distorted in…
▽ More
The temperature perturbations of the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMB) appear systematically suppressed, at large angular scales, with respect to the prediction of the LambdaCDM concordance model. This behavior might be a glimpse of the inflaton deceleration from fast-roll at the start of inflation. If this were true, the spectrum of primordial tensor perturbations should be distorted in a corresponding way, with a suppression of large angular scale B-mode polarization that might be within reach for future probes like LiteBIRD. We investigate this scenario by a semi-analytic method based on a truncation of the B-mode polarization spectrum, which in our opinion has the virtue of highlighting the underlying Physics. We present some mild evidence that, with sufficient knowledge of the reionization process, the suppression of large-scale B-modes might be within reach.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2019; v1 submitted 18 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
The Evens and Odds of CMB Anomalies
Authors:
A. Gruppuso,
N. Kitazawa,
M. Lattanzi,
N. Mandolesi,
P. Natoli,
A. Sagnotti
Abstract:
The lack of power of large--angle CMB anisotropies is known to increase its statistical significance at higher Galactic latitudes, where a string--inspired pre--inflationary scale $Δ$ can also be detected. Considering the Planck 2015 data, and relying largely on a Bayesian approach, we show that the effect is mostly driven by the \emph{even}--$\ell$ harmonic multipoles with $\ell \lesssim 20$, whi…
▽ More
The lack of power of large--angle CMB anisotropies is known to increase its statistical significance at higher Galactic latitudes, where a string--inspired pre--inflationary scale $Δ$ can also be detected. Considering the Planck 2015 data, and relying largely on a Bayesian approach, we show that the effect is mostly driven by the \emph{even}--$\ell$ harmonic multipoles with $\ell \lesssim 20$, which appear sizably suppressed in a way that is robust with respect to Galactic masking, along with the corresponding detections of $Δ$. On the other hand, the first \emph{odd}--$\ell$ multipoles are only suppressed at high Galactic latitudes. We investigate this behavior in different sky masks, constraining $Δ$ through even and odd multipoles, and we elaborate on possible implications. We include low--$\ell$ polarization data which, despite being noise--limited, help in attaining confidence levels of about 3 $σ$ in the detection of $Δ$. We also show by direct forecasts that a future all--sky $E$--mode cosmic--variance--limited polarization survey may push the constraining power for $Δ$ beyond 5 $σ$.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2018; v1 submitted 8 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Pre-Inflationary Relics in the CMB?
Authors:
A. Gruppuso,
N. Kitazawa,
N. Mandolesi,
P. Natoli,
A. Sagnotti
Abstract:
String Theory and Supergravity allow, in principle, to follow the transition of the inflaton from pre-inflationary fast roll to slow roll. This introduces an infrared depression in the primordial power spectrum that might have left an imprint in the CMB anisotropy, if it occurred at accessible wavelengths. We model the effect extending $Λ$CDM with a scale $Δ$ related to the infrared depression and…
▽ More
String Theory and Supergravity allow, in principle, to follow the transition of the inflaton from pre-inflationary fast roll to slow roll. This introduces an infrared depression in the primordial power spectrum that might have left an imprint in the CMB anisotropy, if it occurred at accessible wavelengths. We model the effect extending $Λ$CDM with a scale $Δ$ related to the infrared depression and explore the constraints allowed by {\sc Planck} data, employing also more conservative, wider Galactic masks in the low resolution CMB likelihood. In an extended mask with $f_{sky}=39\%$, we thus find $Δ= (0.351 \pm 0.114) \times 10^{-3} \, \mbox{Mpc}^{-1}$, at $99.4\%$ confidence level, to be compared with a nearby value at $88.5\%$ with the standard $f_{sky}=94\%$ mask. With about 64 $e$--folds of inflation, these values for $Δ$ would translate into primordial energy scales ${\cal O}(10^{14})$ GeV.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2015; v1 submitted 3 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Revolving D-branes and Spontaneous Gauge Symmetry Breaking
Authors:
Satoshi Iso,
Noriaki Kitazawa
Abstract:
We propose a new mechanism of spontaneous gauge symmetry breaking in the world-volume theory of revolving D-branes around a fixed point of orbifolds. In this paper, we consider a simple model of the T6/Z3 orbifold on which we put D3-branes, D7-branes and their anti-branes. The configuration breaks supersymmetry, but the R-R tadpole cancellation conditions are satisfied. A set of three D3-branes at…
▽ More
We propose a new mechanism of spontaneous gauge symmetry breaking in the world-volume theory of revolving D-branes around a fixed point of orbifolds. In this paper, we consider a simple model of the T6/Z3 orbifold on which we put D3-branes, D7-branes and their anti-branes. The configuration breaks supersymmetry, but the R-R tadpole cancellation conditions are satisfied. A set of three D3-branes at an orbifold fixed point can separate from the point, but when they move perpendicular to the anti-D7-branes put on the fixed point, they are forced to be pulled back due to an attractive interaction between the D3 and anti-D7 branes. In order to stabilize the separation of the D3-branes at nonzero distance, we consider revolution of the D3-branes around the fixed point. Then the gauge symmetry on D3-branes is spontaneously broken, and the rank of the gauge group is reduced. The distance can be set at our will by appropriately choosing the angular momentum of the revolving D3-branes, which should be determined by the initial condition of the cosmological evolution of D-brane configurations. The distance corresponds to the vacuum expectation values of brane moduli fields in the world-volume theory and, if it is written as M/Ms^2 in terms of the string scale Ms, the scale of gauge symmetry breaking is given by M. Angular momentum conservation of revolving D3-branes assures the stability of the scale M against Ms.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2015; v1 submitted 17 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
A String-Inspired Model for the Low-$\ell$ CMB
Authors:
N. Kitazawa,
A. Sagnotti
Abstract:
We present a semi--analytic exploration of some low--$\ell$ angular power spectra inspired by "Brane Supersymmetry Breaking". This mechanism splits Bose and Fermi excitations in String Theory, leaving behind an exponential potential that is just too steep for the inflaton to emerge from the initial singularity while descending it. As a result, the scalar generically bounces against the exponential…
▽ More
We present a semi--analytic exploration of some low--$\ell$ angular power spectra inspired by "Brane Supersymmetry Breaking". This mechanism splits Bose and Fermi excitations in String Theory, leaving behind an exponential potential that is just too steep for the inflaton to emerge from the initial singularity while descending it. As a result, the scalar generically bounces against the exponential wall, which typically introduces an infrared depression and a pre--inflationary peak in the power spectrum of scalar perturbations. We elaborate on a possible link between this phenomenon and the low--$\ell$ CMB. For the first 32 multipoles, combining the hard exponential with a milder one leading to $n_s\simeq 0.96$ and with a small gaussian bump we have attained a reduction of $χ^{\,2}$ to about 46% of the standard $Λ$CDM setting, with both WMAP9 and PLANCK 2013 data. This result corresponds to a $χ^{\,2}/DOF$ of about 0.45, to be compared with a $Λ$CDM value of about 0.85. The preferred choices combine naturally quadrupole depression, a first peak around $\ell=5$ and a wide minimum around $\ell=20$. We have also gathered some evidence that similar spectra emerge if the hard exponential is combined with more realistic models of inflation. A problem of the preferred examples is their slow convergence to an almost scale--invariant profile.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2015; v1 submitted 15 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
String Theory clues for the low-$\ell$ CMB ?
Authors:
N. Kitazawa,
A. Sagnotti
Abstract:
"Brane Supersymmetry Breaking" is a peculiar string-scale mechanism that can unpair Bose and Fermi excitations in orientifold models. It results from the simultaneous presence, in the vacuum, of collections of D-branes and orientifolds that are not mutually BPS, and is closely tied to the scale of string excitations. It also leaves behind, for a mixing of dilaton and internal breathing mode, an ex…
▽ More
"Brane Supersymmetry Breaking" is a peculiar string-scale mechanism that can unpair Bose and Fermi excitations in orientifold models. It results from the simultaneous presence, in the vacuum, of collections of D-branes and orientifolds that are not mutually BPS, and is closely tied to the scale of string excitations. It also leaves behind, for a mixing of dilaton and internal breathing mode, an exponential potential that is just too steep for a scalar to emerge from the initial singularity while descending it. As a result, in this class of models the scalar can generically bounce off the exponential wall, and this dynamics brings along, in the power spectrum, an infrared depression typically followed by a pre-inflationary peak. We elaborate on a possible link between this type of bounce and the low-$\ell$ end of the CMB angular power spectrum. For the first 32 multipoles, one can reach a 50 % reduction in $χ^{\,2}$ with respect to the standard $Λ$CDM setting.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2014; v1 submitted 24 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Pre - Inflationary Clues from String Theory ?
Authors:
N. Kitazawa,
A. Sagnotti
Abstract:
"Brane supersymmetry breaking" occurs in String Theory when the only available combinations of D-branes and orientifolds are not mutually BPS and yet do not introduce tree-level tachyon instabilities. It is characterized by the emergence of a steep exponential potential, and thus by the absence of maximally symmetric vacua. The corresponding low-energy supergravity admits intriguing spatially-flat…
▽ More
"Brane supersymmetry breaking" occurs in String Theory when the only available combinations of D-branes and orientifolds are not mutually BPS and yet do not introduce tree-level tachyon instabilities. It is characterized by the emergence of a steep exponential potential, and thus by the absence of maximally symmetric vacua. The corresponding low-energy supergravity admits intriguing spatially-flat cosmological solutions where a scalar field is forced to climb up toward the steep potential after an initial singularity, and additional milder terms can inject an inflationary phase during the ensuing descent. We show that, in the resulting power spectra of scalar perturbations, an infrared suppression is typically followed by a pre-inflationary peak that reflects the end of the climbing phase and can lie well apart from the approximately scale invariant profile. A first look at WMAP9 raw data shows that, while the chi^2 fits for the low-l CMB angular power spectrum are clearly compatible with an almost scale invariant behavior, they display nonetheless an eye-catching preference for this type of setting within a perturbative string regime.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2014; v1 submitted 6 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
CMB Imprints of a Pre-Inflationary Climbing Phase
Authors:
E. Dudas,
N. Kitazawa,
S. P. Patil,
A. Sagnotti
Abstract:
We discuss the implications for cosmic microwave background (CMB) observables, of a class of pre-inflationary dynamics suggested by string models where SUSY is broken due to the presence of D-branes and orientifolds preserving incompatible portions of it. In these models the would-be inflaton is forced to emerge from the initial singularity climbing up a mild exponential potential, until it bounce…
▽ More
We discuss the implications for cosmic microwave background (CMB) observables, of a class of pre-inflationary dynamics suggested by string models where SUSY is broken due to the presence of D-branes and orientifolds preserving incompatible portions of it. In these models the would-be inflaton is forced to emerge from the initial singularity climbing up a mild exponential potential, until it bounces against a steep exponential potential of "brane SUSY breaking" scenarios, and as a result the ensuing descent gives rise to an inflationary epoch that begins when the system is still well off its eventual attractor. If a pre-inflationary climbing phase of this type had occurred within 6-7 e-folds of the horizon exit for the largest observable wavelengths, displacement off the attractor and initial-state effects would conspire to suppress power in the primordial scalar spectrum, enhancing it in the tensor spectrum and typically superposing oscillations on both. We investigate these imprints on CMB observables over a range of parameters, examine their statistical significance, and provide a semi-analytic rationale for our results. It is tempting to ascribe at least part of the large-angle anomalies in the CMB to pre-inflationary dynamics of this type.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2012; v1 submitted 29 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
