-
Energetic proton losses reveal Io's extended and longitudinally asymmetrical atmosphere
Authors:
H. L. F. Huybrighs,
C. P. A. van Buchem,
A. Blöcker,
V. Dols,
C. F. Bowers,
C. M. Jackman
Abstract:
Along the I24, I27 and I31 flybys of Io (1999-2001), the Energetic Particle Detector (EPD) onboard the Galileo spacecraft observed localised regions of energetic protons losses (155 keV-1250 keV). Using back-tracking particle simulations combined with a prescribed atmospheric distribution and a magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) model of the plasma/atmosphere interaction, we investigate the possible cause…
▽ More
Along the I24, I27 and I31 flybys of Io (1999-2001), the Energetic Particle Detector (EPD) onboard the Galileo spacecraft observed localised regions of energetic protons losses (155 keV-1250 keV). Using back-tracking particle simulations combined with a prescribed atmospheric distribution and a magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) model of the plasma/atmosphere interaction, we investigate the possible causes of these depletions. We focus on a limited region within two Io radii, which is dominated by Io's SO$_2$ atmosphere. Our results show that charge exchange of protons with the SO$_2$ atmosphere, absorption by the surface and the configuration of the electromagnetic field contribute to the observed proton depletion along the Galileo flybys. In the 155-240 keV energy range, charge exchange is either a major or the dominant loss process, depending on the flyby altitude. In the 540-1250 keV range, as the charge exchange cross sections are small, the observed decrease of the proton flux is attributed to absorption by the surface and the perturbed electromagnetic fields, which divert the protons away from the detector. From a comparison between the modelled losses and the data we find indications of an extended atmosphere on the day/downstream side of Io, a lack of atmospheric collapse on the night/upstream side as well as a more global extended atmospheric component ($> 1$ Io radius). Our results demonstrate that observations and modeling of proton depletion around the moon constitute an important tool to constrain the electromagnetic field configuration around Io and the radial and longitudinal atmospheric distribution, which is still poorly understood.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
The case for studying other planetary magnetospheres and atmospheres in Heliophysics
Authors:
Ian J. Cohen,
Chris Arridge,
Abigail Azari,
Chris Bard,
George Clark,
Frank Crary,
Shannon Curry,
Peter Delamere,
Ryan M. Dewey,
Gina A. DiBraccio,
Chuanfei Dong,
Alexander Drozdov,
Austin Egert,
Rachael Filwett,
Jasper Halekas,
Alexa Halford,
Andréa Hughes,
Katherine Garcia-Sage,
Matina Gkioulidou,
Charlotte Goetz,
Cesare Grava,
Michael Hirsch,
Hans Leo F. Huybrighs,
Peter Kollmann,
Laurent Lamy
, et al. (15 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Heliophysics is the field that "studies the nature of the Sun, and how it influences the very nature of space - and, in turn, the atmospheres of planetary bodies and the technology that exists there." However, NASA's Heliophysics Division tends to limit study of planetary magnetospheres and atmospheres to only those of Earth. This leaves exploration and understanding of space plasma physics at oth…
▽ More
Heliophysics is the field that "studies the nature of the Sun, and how it influences the very nature of space - and, in turn, the atmospheres of planetary bodies and the technology that exists there." However, NASA's Heliophysics Division tends to limit study of planetary magnetospheres and atmospheres to only those of Earth. This leaves exploration and understanding of space plasma physics at other worlds to the purview of the Planetary Science and Astrophysics Divisions. This is detrimental to the study of space plasma physics in general since, although some cross-divisional funding opportunities do exist, vital elements of space plasma physics can be best addressed by extending the expertise of Heliophysics scientists to other stellar and planetary magnetospheres. However, the diverse worlds within the solar system provide crucial environmental conditions that are not replicated at Earth but can provide deep insight into fundamental space plasma physics processes. Studying planetary systems with Heliophysics objectives, comprehensive instrumentation, and new grant opportunities for analysis and modeling would enable a novel understanding of fundamental and universal processes of space plasma physics. As such, the Heliophysics community should be prepared to consider, prioritize, and fund dedicated Heliophysics efforts to planetary targets to specifically study space physics and aeronomy objectives.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2023; v1 submitted 22 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
In-situ detection of Europa's water plumes is harder than previously thought
Authors:
Rowan Dayton-Oxland,
Hans L. F. Huybrighs,
Thomas O. Winterhalder,
Arnaud Maheiux,
David Goldstein
Abstract:
Europa's subsurface ocean is a potential candidate for life in the outer solar system. It is thought that plumes may exist which eject ocean material out into space, which may be detected by a spacecraft flyby. Previous work on the feasibility of these detections has assumed a collisionless model of the plume particles. New models of the plumes including particle collisions have shown that a shock…
▽ More
Europa's subsurface ocean is a potential candidate for life in the outer solar system. It is thought that plumes may exist which eject ocean material out into space, which may be detected by a spacecraft flyby. Previous work on the feasibility of these detections has assumed a collisionless model of the plume particles. New models of the plumes including particle collisions have shown that a shock can develop in the plume interior as rising particles collide with particles falling back to the moon's surface, limiting the plume's altitude. Results show that the region over Europa's surface within which plumes would be separable from the H$_2$O atmosphere by JUICE (the region of separability) is reduced by up to a half with the collisional model compared to the collisionless model. Putative plume sources which are on the border of the region of separability for the collisionless model cannot be separated from the atmosphere when the shock is considered for a mass flux case of 100kg/s. Increasing the flyby altitude by 100km such that the spacecraft passes above the shock canopy results in a reduction in region of separability by a third, whilst decreasing the flyby altitude by 100km increases the region of separability by the same amount. We recommend flybys pass through or as close to the shock as possible to sample the most high-density region. If the spacecraft flies close to the shock, the structure of the plume could be resolvable using the neutral mass spectrometer on JUICE, allowing us to test models of the plume physics and understand the underlying physics of Europa's plumes. As the altitude of the shock is uncertain and dependent on unpredictable plume parameters, we recommend flybys be lowered where possible to reduce the risk of passing above the shock and losing detection coverage, density and duration.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Reply to comment on "An Active Plume Eruption on Europa During Galileo Flyby E26 as Indicated by Energetic Proton Depletions"
Authors:
H. L. F. Huybrighs,
E. Roussos,
A. Blöcker,
N. Krupp,
Y. Futaana,
S. Barabash,
L. Z. Hadid,
M. K. G. Holmberg,
O. Witasse
Abstract:
In Huybrighs et al., 2020 we investigated energetic proton depletions along Galileo's Europa flyby E26. Based on a particle tracing analysis we proposed that depletions are caused by perturbed electrogmagnetic fields combined with atmospheric charge exchange and possible plumes. One depletion feature identified as a plume signature was shown to be an artefact Jia et al., 2021. Despite that, here w…
▽ More
In Huybrighs et al., 2020 we investigated energetic proton depletions along Galileo's Europa flyby E26. Based on a particle tracing analysis we proposed that depletions are caused by perturbed electrogmagnetic fields combined with atmospheric charge exchange and possible plumes. One depletion feature identified as a plume signature was shown to be an artefact Jia et al., 2021. Despite that, here we emphasize that Huybrighs et al., 2020 demonstrates that plumes can cause proton depletions and that these features should be sought after. Furthermore, the conclusions on the importance of perturbed electromagnetic fields and atmospheric charge exchange on the depletions are unaffected. We suggest that the artefact's cause is a mistagging of protons as heavier ions by EPD. The artefact prevents us from confirming or excluding that there is a plume associated depletion. We also address comments on the MHD simulations and demonstrate that 540-1040 keV losses are not necessarily inconsistent with 115-244 keV losses by plume associated charge exchange.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
A search for signatures of Europa's atmosphere and plumes in Galileo charged particle data
Authors:
Hans Leo Frans Huybrighs
Abstract:
Remote sensing observations indicate that Europa is surrounded by a tenuous atmosphere. Furthermore, recent observations and historic data from Galileo hint at the occurrence of water vapour eruptions originating from the interior that create 200 km high plumes. Due to the lack of adequate measurements large uncertainties exist in the properties of Europa's atmosphere (e.g. loss rate and structure…
▽ More
Remote sensing observations indicate that Europa is surrounded by a tenuous atmosphere. Furthermore, recent observations and historic data from Galileo hint at the occurrence of water vapour eruptions originating from the interior that create 200 km high plumes. Due to the lack of adequate measurements large uncertainties exist in the properties of Europa's atmosphere (e.g. loss rate and structure) and plumes (e.g. structure, source location, duration), of the latter one the existence is not even confirmed. Unexploited opportunities to constrain properties of the atmosphere or plumes remain in the in-situ data collected by the Galileo mission, the only mission that has surveyed Europa from close by. In this thesis, I investigate how to constrain the properties (density, scale height) of Europa's tenuous atmosphere and plumes, using data from the Galileo in-situ particle detector instruments (PLS, EPD). I simulate the depletion of energetic protons and oxygen ions measured during the E12 flyby. A Monte Carlo particle tracing method is used to simulate the particle trajectories and determine where they are depleted: at the surface or in the atmosphere. The simulations show that the depletions of energetic ions observed in the range 80 to 540 keV can be explained by charge exchange with neutral atmospheric particles, but not by impact on the surface alone. This suggests that an atmosphere must have been present during the E12 flyby. The simulations best represent the sublimated component of the atmosphere and favour higher surface densities than the literature, but are not sensitive to the scale height. Furthermore, an additional depletion is visible very briefly in the energetic protons with energies from 540 to 1040 keV. This feature could be consistent with localized losses from a Europa plume, although such a solution is not unique.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
On the in-situ detectability of Europa's water vapour plumes from a flyby mission
Authors:
Hans L. F. Huybrighs,
Yoshifumi Futaana,
Stanislav Barabash,
Martin Wieser,
Peter Wurz,
Norbert Krupp,
Karl-Heinz Glassmeier,
Bert Vermeersen
Abstract:
We investigate the feasibility of detecting water molecules (H2O) and water ions (H20+) from the Europa plumes from a flyby mission. A Monte Carlo particle tracing method is used to simulate the trajectories of neutral particles under the influence of Europa's gravity field and ionized particles under the influence of Jupiter's magnetic field and the convectional electric field. As an example miss…
▽ More
We investigate the feasibility of detecting water molecules (H2O) and water ions (H20+) from the Europa plumes from a flyby mission. A Monte Carlo particle tracing method is used to simulate the trajectories of neutral particles under the influence of Europa's gravity field and ionized particles under the influence of Jupiter's magnetic field and the convectional electric field. As an example mission case we investigate the detection of neutral and ionized molecules using the Particle Environment Package (PEP), which is part of the scientific payload of the future JUpiter ICy moon Explorer mission (JUICE). We consider plumes that have a mass flux that is three orders of magnitude lower than what has been inferred from recent Hubble observations (Roth et al., 2014a). We demonstrate that the in-situ detection of H2O and H2O+ from these low mass flux plumes is possible by the instruments with large margins with respect to background and instrument noise. The signal to noise ratio for neutrals is up to ~5700 and ~33 for ions. We also show that the geometry of the plume source, either a point source or 1000 km-long crack, does not influence the density distributions, and thus, their detectability. Furthermore, we discuss how to separate the plume-originating H2O and H2O+ from exospheric H2O and H2O+ . The separation depends strongly on knowledge of the density distribution of Europa's exosphere.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
