-
High Redshift Massive Quiescent Galaxies are as Flat as Star Forming Galaxies: The Flattening of Galaxies and the Correlation with Structural Properties in CANDELS/3D-HST
Authors:
Allison R. Hill,
Arjen van der Wel,
Marijn Franx,
Adam Muzzin,
Rosalind E. Skelton,
Iva Momcheva,
Pieter van Dokkum,
Katherine E. Whitaker
Abstract:
We investigate the median flattening of galaxies at $0.2<z<4.0$ in all five CANDELS/3D-HST fields via the apparent axis ratio $q$. We separate the sample into bins of redshift, stellar-mass, sérsic index, size, and UVJ determined star-forming state to discover the most important drivers of the median $q$ ($q_{med}$). Quiescent galaxies at $z<1$ and $M_{*}>10^{11}M_{\odot}$ are rounder than those a…
▽ More
We investigate the median flattening of galaxies at $0.2<z<4.0$ in all five CANDELS/3D-HST fields via the apparent axis ratio $q$. We separate the sample into bins of redshift, stellar-mass, sérsic index, size, and UVJ determined star-forming state to discover the most important drivers of the median $q$ ($q_{med}$). Quiescent galaxies at $z<1$ and $M_{*}>10^{11}M_{\odot}$ are rounder than those at lower masses, consistent with the hypothesis that they have grown significantly through dry merging. The massive quiescent galaxies at higher redshift become flatter, and are as flat as star forming massive galaxies at $2.5<z<3.5$, consistent with formation through direct transformations or wet mergers. We find that in quiescent galaxies, correlations with $q_{med}$ and $M_{*}$, $z$ and $r_{e}$ are driven by the evolution in the sérsic index ($n$), consistent with the growing accumulation of minor mergers at lower redshift. Interestingly, $n$ does not drive these trends fully in star-forming galaxies. Instead, the strongest predictor of $q$ in star-forming galaxies is the effective radius, where larger galaxies are flatter. Our findings suggest that $q_{med}$ is tracing bulge-to-total ($B/T$) galaxy ratio which would explain why smaller/more massive star-forming galaxies are rounder than their extended/less massive analogues, although it is unclear why sérsic index correlates more weakly with flattening for star forming galaxies than for quiescent galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
The Mass Growth and Stellar Ages of Galaxies: Observations versus Simulations
Authors:
Allison R. Hill,
Adam Muzzin,
Marijn Franx,
Danilo Marchesini
Abstract:
Using observed stellar mass functions out to $z=5$, we measure the main progenitor stellar mass growth of descendant galaxies with masses of $\log{M_{*}/M_{\odot}}=11.5,11.0,10.5,10.0$ at $z\sim0.1$ using an evolving cumulative number density selection. From these mass growth histories, we are able to measure the time at which half the total stellar mass of the descendant galaxy was assembled,…
▽ More
Using observed stellar mass functions out to $z=5$, we measure the main progenitor stellar mass growth of descendant galaxies with masses of $\log{M_{*}/M_{\odot}}=11.5,11.0,10.5,10.0$ at $z\sim0.1$ using an evolving cumulative number density selection. From these mass growth histories, we are able to measure the time at which half the total stellar mass of the descendant galaxy was assembled, $t_{a}$, which, in order of decreasing mass corresponds to redshifts of $z_{a}=1.28, 0.92, 0.60$ and $0.51$. We compare this to the median light-weighted stellar age $t_{*}$ ($z_{*} = 2.08, 1.49, 0.82$ and $0.37$) of a sample of low redshift SDSS galaxies (from the literature) and find the timescales are consistent with more massive galaxies forming a higher fraction of their stars ex-situ compared to lower mass descendants. We find that both $t_{*}$ and $t_{a}$ strongly correlate with mass which is in contrast to what is found in the EAGLE hydrodynamical simulation which shows a flat relationship between $t_{a}$ and $M_{*}$. However, the semi-analytic model of \citet{henriques2015} is consistent with the observations in both $t_{a}$ and $t_{*}$ with $M_{*}$, showing the most recent semi-analytic models are better able to decouple the evolution of the baryons from the dark matter in lower-mass galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
The mass, colour, and structural evolution of today's massive galaxies since z~5
Authors:
Allison R. Hill,
Adam Muzzin,
Marijn Franx,
Bart Clauwens,
Corentin Schreiber,
Danilo Marchesini,
Mauro Stefanon,
Ivo Labbe,
Gabriel Brammer,
Karina Caputi,
Johan Fynbo,
Bo Milvang-Jensen,
Rosalind E. Skelton,
Pieter van Dokkum,
Katherine E. Whitaker
Abstract:
In this paper, we use stacking analysis to trace the mass-growth, colour evolution, and structural evolution of present-day massive galaxies ($\log(M_{*}/M_{\odot})=11.5$) out to $z=5$. We utilize the exceptional depth and area of the latest UltraVISTA data release, combined with the depth and unparalleled seeing of CANDELS to gather a large, mass-selected sample of galaxies in the NIR (rest-frame…
▽ More
In this paper, we use stacking analysis to trace the mass-growth, colour evolution, and structural evolution of present-day massive galaxies ($\log(M_{*}/M_{\odot})=11.5$) out to $z=5$. We utilize the exceptional depth and area of the latest UltraVISTA data release, combined with the depth and unparalleled seeing of CANDELS to gather a large, mass-selected sample of galaxies in the NIR (rest-frame optical to UV). Progenitors of present-day massive galaxies are identified via an evolving cumulative number density selection, which accounts for the effects of merging to correct for the systematic biases introduced using a fixed cumulative number density selection, and find progenitors grow in stellar mass by $\approx1.5~\mathrm{dex}$ since $z=5$. Using stacking, we analyze the structural parameters of the progenitors and find that most of the stellar mass content in the central regions was in place by $z\sim2$, and while galaxies continue to assemble mass at all radii, the outskirts experience the largest fractional increase in stellar mass. However, we find evidence of significant stellar mass build up at $r<3~\mathrm{kpc}$ beyond $z>4$ probing an era of significant mass assembly in the interiors of present day massive galaxies. We also compare mass assembly from progenitors in this study to the EAGLE simulation and find qualitatively similar assembly with $z$ at $r<3~\mathrm{kpc}$. We identify $z\sim1.5$ as a distinct epoch in the evolution of massive galaxies where progenitors transitioned from growing in mass and size primarily through in-situ star formation in disks to a period of efficient growth in $r_{e}$ consistent with the minor merger scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
The evolution in the stellar mass of Brightest Cluster Galaxies over the past 10 billion years
Authors:
Sabine Bellstedt,
Chris Lidman,
Adam Muzzin,
Marijn Franx,
Susanna Guatelli,
Allison R. Hill,
Henk Hoekstra,
Noah Kurinsky,
Ivo Labbe,
Danilo Marchesini,
Z. Cemile Marsan,
Mitra Safavi-Naeini,
Cristobal Sifon,
Mauro Stefanon,
Jesse van de Sande,
Pieter van Dokkum,
Catherine Weigel
Abstract:
Using a sample of 98 galaxy clusters recently imaged in the near infra-red with the ESO NTT, WIYN and WHT telescopes, supplemented with 33 clusters from the ESO archive, we measure how the stellar mass of the most massive galaxies in the universe, namely Brightest Cluster Galaxies (BCG), increases with time. Most of the BCGs in this new sample lie in the redshift range $0.2<z<0.6$, which has been…
▽ More
Using a sample of 98 galaxy clusters recently imaged in the near infra-red with the ESO NTT, WIYN and WHT telescopes, supplemented with 33 clusters from the ESO archive, we measure how the stellar mass of the most massive galaxies in the universe, namely Brightest Cluster Galaxies (BCG), increases with time. Most of the BCGs in this new sample lie in the redshift range $0.2<z<0.6$, which has been noted in recent works to mark an epoch over which the growth in the stellar mass of BCGs stalls. From this sample of 132 clusters, we create a subsample of 102 systems that includes only those clusters that have estimates of the cluster mass. We combine the BCGs in this subsample with BCGs from the literature, and find that the growth in stellar mass of BCGs from 10 billion years ago to the present epoch is broadly consistent with recent semi-analytic and semi-empirical models. As in other recent studies, tentative evidence indicates that the stellar mass growth rate of BCGs may be slowing in the past 3.5 billion years. Further work in collecting larger samples, and in better comparing observations with theory using mock images is required if a more detailed comparison between the models and the data is to be made.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2016; v1 submitted 9 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Stellar Velocity Dispersion for a Strongly-Lensed, Intermediate-Mass Quiescent Galaxy at z=2.8
Authors:
Allison R. Hill,
Adam Muzzin,
Marijn Franx,
Jesse van de Sande
Abstract:
Measuring stellar velocity dispersions of quiescent galaxies beyond $z\sim2$ is observationally challenging. Such measurements require near-infrared spectra with a continuum detection of at least moderate signal-to-noise, often necessitating long integrations. In this paper, we present deep X-Shooter spectroscopy of one of only two known gravitationally-lensed massive quiescent galaxies at $z>2$.…
▽ More
Measuring stellar velocity dispersions of quiescent galaxies beyond $z\sim2$ is observationally challenging. Such measurements require near-infrared spectra with a continuum detection of at least moderate signal-to-noise, often necessitating long integrations. In this paper, we present deep X-Shooter spectroscopy of one of only two known gravitationally-lensed massive quiescent galaxies at $z>2$. This galaxy is quadruply imaged, with the brightest images magnified by a factor of $\sim5$. The total exposure time of our data is 9.8 hours on-source; however the magnification, and the slit placement encompassing 2 images, provides a total equivalent exposure time of 215 hours. From this deep spectrum we measure a redshift ($z_{\mathrm{spec}}=2.756\pm0.001$), making this one of the highest redshift quiescent galaxies that is spectroscopically confirmed. We simultaneously fit both the spectroscopic and photometric data to determine stellar population parameters and conclude this galaxy is relatively young, intermediate-mass, consistent with low dust content, and has quenched only relatively recently. This recent quenching is confirmed by strong Balmer absorption, particularly $Hδ$. Remarkably, this proves that at least some intermediate-mass galaxies have already quenched as early as $z\sim2.8$. Additionally, we have measured a velocity dispersion ($σ=187\pm43~\mathrm{km/s}$), making this the highest-redshift quiescent galaxy with a dispersion measurement. We confirm that this galaxy falls on the same mass fundamental plane (MFP) as galaxies at z=2.2, consistent with little to no evolution in the MFP up to z=2.8. Overall this galaxy is proof of existence of intermediate-mass quenched galaxies in the distant universe, and that lensing is a powerful tool for determining their properties with improved accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
High Signal-to-Noise Ratio Mid-Infrared Quasar Spectral Templates
Authors:
Allison R. Hill,
S. C. Gallagher,
R. P. Deo,
E. Peeters,
Gordon T. Richards
Abstract:
Mid-infrared (MIR) quasar spectra exhibit a suite of emission features including high ionization coronal lines from the narrow line region (NLR) illuminated by the ionizing continuum, and hot dust features from grains, as well as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) features from star formation in the host galaxy. Few features are detected in most spectra because of typically low signal-to-noise…
▽ More
Mid-infrared (MIR) quasar spectra exhibit a suite of emission features including high ionization coronal lines from the narrow line region (NLR) illuminated by the ionizing continuum, and hot dust features from grains, as well as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) features from star formation in the host galaxy. Few features are detected in most spectra because of typically low signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) data. By generating spectral composites in three different luminosity bins from over 180 Spitzer Infrared Spectrograph (IRS) observations, we boost the S/N and reveal important features in the complex spectra. We detect high-ionization, forbidden emission lines in all templates, PAH features in all but the most luminous objects, and broad silicate and graphite features in emission whose strength increases relative to the continuum with luminosity. We find that the intrinsic quasar spectrum for all luminosity templates is consistent, and the differences in the spectra can be explained by host galaxy contamination in the lower luminosity templates. We also posit that star formation may be active in most quasar host galaxies, but the spectral features of star formation are only detectable if the quasar is faint.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Characterizing Quasars in the Mid-infrared: High Signal-to-Noise Spectral Templates
Authors:
Allison R. Hill,
S. C. Gallagher,
R. P. Deo,
E. Peeters,
Gordon T. Richards
Abstract:
Mid-infrared (MIR) quasar spectra exhibit a suite of emission features including high ionization coronal lines from the narrow line region illuminated by the ionizing continuum, broad dust bumps from silicates and graphites, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) features from star formation in the host galaxy. However, in Spitzer Infared Spectrograph (IRS) data, few features are detected in mo…
▽ More
Mid-infrared (MIR) quasar spectra exhibit a suite of emission features including high ionization coronal lines from the narrow line region illuminated by the ionizing continuum, broad dust bumps from silicates and graphites, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) features from star formation in the host galaxy. However, in Spitzer Infared Spectrograph (IRS) data, few features are detected in most individual spectra because of typically low signal-to-noise ratios (S/N). By generating spectral composites from over 180 IRS observations of Sloan Digital Sky Survey broad-line quasars, we boost the S/N and reveal features in the complex spectra that are otherwise lost in the noise. In addition to an overall composite, we generate composites in three different luminosity bins that span the range of 5.6 micron luminosities of 10$^{40}$--10$^{46}$ (erg~s$^{-1}$). We detect the high-ionization, forbidden emission lines of [SIV], [OIV], and [NeV] 14 micron in all templates and PAH features in all but the most luminous template. Ratios of lines with a range of ionization potentials show no evidence for a strong difference in the shape of the 41--97 eV ionizing continuum over this range of luminosities. The scaling of the emission-line luminosities as a function of continuum luminosity is consistent with what is expected, and shows no indication of a ``disappearing narrow-line region.'' The broad 10 and 18 micron silicate features in emission increase in strength with increasing luminosity, and a broad 3--5 micron black body consistent with graphite emission at 750 K is evident in the highest luminosity template. We find that the intrinsic quasar continua for all luminosity templates are consistent; apparent differences arise primarily from host galaxy contamination most evident at low luminosity.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Looking for the Wind in the Dust
Authors:
S. C. Gallagher,
J. E. Everett,
S. K. Keating,
A. R. Hill,
R. P. Deo
Abstract:
The blue-shifted broad emission lines and/or broad absorption lines seen in many luminous quasars are striking evidence for a broad line region in which radiation driving plays an important role. We consider the case for a similar role for radiation driving beyond the dust sublimation radius by focussing on the infrared regime where the relationship between luminosity and the prominence of the 3-5…
▽ More
The blue-shifted broad emission lines and/or broad absorption lines seen in many luminous quasars are striking evidence for a broad line region in which radiation driving plays an important role. We consider the case for a similar role for radiation driving beyond the dust sublimation radius by focussing on the infrared regime where the relationship between luminosity and the prominence of the 3-5 micron bump may be key. To investigate this further, we apply the 3D hydrodynamic wind model of Everett (2005) to predict the infrared spectral energy distributions of quasars. The presence of the 3-5 micron bump and strong, broad silicate features can be reproduced with this dynamical wind model when radiation driving on dust is taken into account.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
-
The merger history, AGN and dwarf galaxies of Hickson Compact Group 59
Authors:
I. S. Konstantopoulos,
S. C. Gallagher,
K. Fedotov,
P. R. Durrell,
P. Tzanavaris,
A. R. Hill,
A. I. Zabludoff,
M. L. Maier,
D. M. Elmegreen,
J. C. Charlton,
K. E. Johnson,
W. N. Brandt,
L. M. Walker,
M. Eracleous,
A. Maybhate,
C. Gronwall,
J. English,
A. E. Hornschemeier,
J. S. Mulchaey
Abstract:
Compact group galaxies often appear unaffected by their unusually dense environment. Closer examination can, however, reveal the subtle, cumulative effects of multiple galaxy interactions. Hickson Compact Group (HCG) 59 is an excellent example of this situation. We present a photometric study of this group in the optical (HST), infrared (Spitzer) and X-ray (Chandra) regimes aimed at characterizing…
▽ More
Compact group galaxies often appear unaffected by their unusually dense environment. Closer examination can, however, reveal the subtle, cumulative effects of multiple galaxy interactions. Hickson Compact Group (HCG) 59 is an excellent example of this situation. We present a photometric study of this group in the optical (HST), infrared (Spitzer) and X-ray (Chandra) regimes aimed at characterizing the star formation and nuclear activity in its constituent galaxies and intra-group medium. We associate five dwarf galaxies with the group and update the velocity dispersion, leading to an increase in the dynamical mass of the group of up to a factor of 10 (to 2.8e13 Msun), and a subsequent revision of its evolutionary stage. Star formation is proceeding at a level consistent with the morphological types of the four main galaxies, of which two are star-forming and the other two quiescent. Unlike in some other compact groups, star-forming complexes across HCG 59 closely follow mass-radius scaling relations typical of nearby galaxies. In contrast, the ancient globular cluster populations in galaxies HCG 59A and B show intriguing irregularities, and two extragalactic HII regions are found just west of B. We age-date a faint stellar stream in the intra-group medium at ~1 Gyr to examine recent interactions. We detect a likely low-luminosity AGN in HCG 59A by its ~10e40 erg/s X-ray emission; the active nucleus rather than star formation can account for the UV+IR SED. We discuss the implications of our findings in the context of galaxy evolution in dense environments.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2011;
originally announced October 2011.
