-
Experimental Investigation of the Photochemical Production of Hydrocarbons in Warm Gas Giant Exoplanet Atmospheres
Authors:
Benjamin Fleury,
Yves Benilan,
Olivia Venot,
Bryana L. Henderson,
Mark Swain,
Murthy S. Gudipati
Abstract:
In warm (equilibrium temperature <1000 K) gas giant exoplanet atmospheres, the observation of trace species in abundances deviating from thermochemical equilibrium predictions could be used as an indicator of disequilibrium chemical processes, such as photochemistry. To predict which compounds could be used as such tracers, it is therefore essential to study how photochemical processes affect thei…
▽ More
In warm (equilibrium temperature <1000 K) gas giant exoplanet atmospheres, the observation of trace species in abundances deviating from thermochemical equilibrium predictions could be used as an indicator of disequilibrium chemical processes, such as photochemistry. To predict which compounds could be used as such tracers, it is therefore essential to study how photochemical processes affect their abundances. For this purpose, we investigated experimentally the efficiency of the photochemical formation of hydrocarbons in gas mixtures representative of warm gas giant atmospheres as a function of the gas temperature at millibar pressures. We find that, compared to thermal reactions alone, photochemistry efficiently promotes, under the studied conditions, the formation of hydrocarbons, with the detection of acetylene, ethane, and propane, as well as carbon monoxide. Therefore, our results confirm the importance of photochemistry in exoplanet atmospheres as a disequilibrium process. Ethane is the major hydrocarbon formed in our experiments, in apparent contradiction with the prediction by thermophotochemical models that acetylene should be the main hydrocarbon product. We also observe an evolution of the hydrocarbon production efficiency as a function of the temperature, a behavior not reproduced by a 0D thermophotochemical model. Additional studies are necessary to definitively understand the origin of the differences between the experimental and modeling results and to infer the importance of our results for understanding hydrocarbon formation in warm gas giant exoplanet atmospheres. Finally, our work demonstrates the importance of experimental studies together with modeling studies to accurately interpret, understand, and predict observations of exoplanet atmospheres.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Thermal Behavior of Astrophysical Amorphous Molecular Ices
Authors:
Murthy S. Gudipati,
Benjamin Fleury,
Robert Wagner,
Bryana L. Henderson,
Kathrin Altwegg,
Martin Rubin
Abstract:
Ice is a major component of astrophysical environment - from interstellar molecular clouds through protoplanetary disks to evolved solar systems. Ice and complex organic matter coexist in these environments as well, and it is thought primordial ice brought the molecules of life to Earth four billion years ago, which could have kickstarted the origin of life on Earth. To understand the journey of i…
▽ More
Ice is a major component of astrophysical environment - from interstellar molecular clouds through protoplanetary disks to evolved solar systems. Ice and complex organic matter coexist in these environments as well, and it is thought primordial ice brought the molecules of life to Earth four billion years ago, which could have kickstarted the origin of life on Earth. To understand the journey of ice and organics from their origins to becoming a part of evolved planetary systems, it is important to complement high spatial and spectral resolution telescopes such as JWST with laboratory experimental studies that provide deeper insight into the processes that occur in these astrophysical environments. Our laboratory studies are aimed at providing this knowledge. In this article we present simultaneous mass spectrometric and infrared spectroscopic investigation on how molecular ice mixtures behave at different temperatures and how this information is critical to interpret observational data from protoplanetary disks as well as comets. We find that amorphous to crystalline water ice transformation is the most critical phenomenon that differentiates between outgassing of trapped volatiles such as CO2 vs. outgassing of pure molecular ice domains of the same in a mixed molecular ice. Crystalline water ice is found to trap only a small fraction of other volatiles (<5%), indicating ice grain composition in astrophysical and planetary environments must be different depending on whether the ice is in amorphous phase or transformed into crystalline phase, even if the crystalline ice undergoes radiation-induced amorphization subsequently. Crystallization of water ice is a key differentiator for many ices in astronomical environments as well as in our Solar System.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2023; v1 submitted 20 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
High-fidelity reaction kinetic modeling of hot-Jupiter atmospheres incorporating thermal and UV photochemistry enhanced by metastable CO(a3Pi)
Authors:
Jeehyun Yang,
Murthy S. Gudipati,
Bryana L Henderson,
Benjamin Fleury
Abstract:
A detailed modeling of simultaneous UV-photochemical and thermochemical processes in exoplanet atmosphere-like conditions is essential for the analysis and interpretation of a vast amount of current and future spectral data from exoplanets. However, a detailed reaction kinetic model that incorporates both UV photochemistry and thermal chemistry is challenging due to the massive size of the chemica…
▽ More
A detailed modeling of simultaneous UV-photochemical and thermochemical processes in exoplanet atmosphere-like conditions is essential for the analysis and interpretation of a vast amount of current and future spectral data from exoplanets. However, a detailed reaction kinetic model that incorporates both UV photochemistry and thermal chemistry is challenging due to the massive size of the chemical system as well as to the lack of understanding of photochemistry compared to thermal-only chemistry. Here, we utilize an automatic chemical reaction mechanism generator to build a high-fidelity thermochemical reaction kinetic model later then incorporated with UV-photochemistry enhanced by metastable triplet-state carbon monoxide (a3Pi). Our model results show that two different photochemical reactions driven by Lyman-a photons (i.e. H2 + CO(a3Pi) -> H + HCO and CO(X1Sig+) + CO(a3Pi) -> C(3P) + CO2) can enhance thermal chemistry resulting in significant increases in the formation of CH4, H2O, and CO2 in H2-dominated systems with trace amounts of CO, which qualitatively matches with the observations from previous experimental studies. Our model also suggests that at temperatures above 2000 K, thermal chemistry becomes the dominant process. Finally, the chemistry simulated up to 2500 K does not produce any larger species such as C3 species, benzene or larger (i.e. PAHs). This might indicate that the photochemistry of C2 species such as C2H2 might play a key role in the formation of organic aerosols observed in the previous experimental study.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2023; v1 submitted 16 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Influence of C/O Ratio on Hot Jupiter Atmospheric Chemistry
Authors:
Benjamin Fleury,
Murthy S. Gudipati,
Bryana L. Henderson,
Mark Swain
Abstract:
We have conducted laboratory experiments to study the chemistry in hot Jupiter atmospheres with C/O ratio of 0.35. We have compared our results with the ones obtained previously for atmospheres with a C/O ratio of 1 to investigate the influence of the C/O ratio on the chemistry and formation of photochemical organic aerosol. We found that the C/O ratio and the gas mixture compositions strongly inf…
▽ More
We have conducted laboratory experiments to study the chemistry in hot Jupiter atmospheres with C/O ratio of 0.35. We have compared our results with the ones obtained previously for atmospheres with a C/O ratio of 1 to investigate the influence of the C/O ratio on the chemistry and formation of photochemical organic aerosol. We found that the C/O ratio and the gas mixture compositions strongly influence the pathways responsible for the formation of CO2. Thermochemical reactions are primarily responsible for the formation of CO2 in low C/O ratio atmospheres, while photochemistry is the dominant process in high C/O ratio atmospheres even if the final CO2 concentration is the same in both cases. Our results show that low C/O atmospheres at the thermochemical equilibrium contain a higher water abundance, while high C/O atmospheres are significantly depleted in water. However, in low C/O atmospheres, the water abundance is not affected by UV photolysis, while our previous work demonstrated that significant amount of water can be produced in high C/O ratio atmospheres. This contrast in water production suggests that photochemistry should be considered when interpreting exoplanet transit spectra. Finally, we did not observe the formation of a detectable amount of non-volatile photochemical aerosols in low C/O atmospheres, in contrast to our previous study. We infer that for C/O ratio < 1, water likely inhibits organic growth and aerosol formation, suggesting that photochemical organic aerosols are likely to be observed in planets presenting a carbon enrichment compared to their host stars.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Photochemistry in hot H2-dominated exoplanet atmospheres
Authors:
Benjamin Fleury,
Murthy S. Gudipati,
Bryana L. Henderson,
Mark Swain
Abstract:
Photochemistry has the potential to substantially impact the atmospheric composition of exoplanets with consequences on the radiative transfer, thermal structure and dynamics of the atmospheres, particularly in UV-rich stellar environments. Here, we present the results of a first laboratory experimental simulation of photochemistry in carbon-rich exoplanet atmospheres at elevated temperatures. Evo…
▽ More
Photochemistry has the potential to substantially impact the atmospheric composition of exoplanets with consequences on the radiative transfer, thermal structure and dynamics of the atmospheres, particularly in UV-rich stellar environments. Here, we present the results of a first laboratory experimental simulation of photochemistry in carbon-rich exoplanet atmospheres at elevated temperatures. Evolution of gas-phase molecular composition was quantitatively monitored with infrared spectroscopy and mass spectrometry. We found that H2/CO gas compositions can change significantly from thermal equilibria compositions when irradiated with Lyman-alpha photons at temperatures ranging from 600 K to 1500 K. Carbon dioxide and water were found to be the main products caused by photolysis, while formation of methane was also observed to a lesser extent. We find that photochemistry efficiency is strongly correlated with increasing temperature. Our finding that water is efficiently produced by photochemistry in a super Solar C/O=1 environment, representing C enhancement relative to solar values C/O ratio = 0.54, has significant implications for the interpretation of many exoplanet transmission spectra. We also find the formation of an organic solid condensate at 1500 K and under Lyman-alpha UV-radiation, confirming the possibility of forming photochemical hazes in hot-Jupiter exoplanet atmospheres with an enhanced C/O ratio compared to Solar.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
The Importance of Prioritizing Exoplanet Experimental Facilities
Authors:
Erika Kohler,
Chao He,
Sarah E. Moran,
S. -H. Dan Shim,
Karalee K. Brugman,
Aleisha C. Johnson,
Pilar C. Vergeli,
Maggie A. Thompson,
Heather Graham,
Murthy S. Gudipati,
Benjamin Fleury,
Bryana L. Henderson
Abstract:
Continuous improvements of observations and modeling efforts have led to tremendous strides in exoplanetary science. However, as instruments and techniques advance laboratory data becomes more important to interpret exoplanet observations and verify theoretical modeling. Though experimental studies are often deferred due to their high costs and long timelines, it is imperative that laboratory inve…
▽ More
Continuous improvements of observations and modeling efforts have led to tremendous strides in exoplanetary science. However, as instruments and techniques advance laboratory data becomes more important to interpret exoplanet observations and verify theoretical modeling. Though experimental studies are often deferred due to their high costs and long timelines, it is imperative that laboratory investigations are prioritized to ensure steady advances in the field of exoplanetary science. This White Paper discusses the importance of prioritizing exoplanetary laboratory efforts, and discusses several experimental facilities currently performing exoplanetary research.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
