-
Solid tidal friction in multi-layer planets: Application to Earth, Venus, a Super Earth and the TRAPPIST-1 planets. Can a multi-layer planet be approximated as a homogeneous planet?
Authors:
Emeline Bolmont,
Sylvain N. Breton,
Gabriel Tobie,
Caroline Dumoulin,
Stéphane Mathis,
Olivier Grasset
Abstract:
With the discovery of TRAPPIST-1 and its seven planets within 0.06 au, the correct treatment of tidal interactions is becoming necessary. The eccentricity, rotation, and obliquity of the planets of TRAPPIST-1 are indeed the result of tidal evolution over the lifetime of the system. Tidal interactions can also lead to tidal heating in the interior of the planets, which can then be responsible for v…
▽ More
With the discovery of TRAPPIST-1 and its seven planets within 0.06 au, the correct treatment of tidal interactions is becoming necessary. The eccentricity, rotation, and obliquity of the planets of TRAPPIST-1 are indeed the result of tidal evolution over the lifetime of the system. Tidal interactions can also lead to tidal heating in the interior of the planets, which can then be responsible for volcanism and/or surface deformation. In the majority of studies to estimate the rotation of close-in planets or their tidal heating, the planets are considered as homogeneous bodies and their rheology is often taken to be a Maxwell rheology.
We investigate here the impact of considering a multi-layer structure and an Andrade rheology on the way planets dissipate tidal energy as a function of the excitation frequency. We use an internal structure model, which provides the radial profile of structural and rheological quantities to compute the tidal response of multi-layer bodies. We then compare the outcome to the dissipation of a homogeneous planet.
We find that for purely rocky bodies, it is possible to approximate the response of a multi-layer planet by that of a homogeneous planet. However, using average profiles of shear modulus and viscosity to compute the homogeneous planet response leads to an overestimation of the averaged dissipation. We provide fitted values of shear modulus and viscosity to be able to reproduce the response of various types of rocky planets. However, we find that if the planet has an icy layer, its tidal response can no longer be approximated by a homogeneous body because of the very different properties of the icy layers, which lead to a second dissipation peak at higher frequencies. We also compute the tidal heating profiles for the outer TRAPPIST-1 planets (e to h).
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Role of the global water ocean on the evolution of Titan's primitive atmosphere
Authors:
Nadejda Marounina,
Olivier Grasset,
Gabriel Tobie,
Sabrina Carpy
Abstract:
During the accretion of Titan, impact heating may have been sufficient to allow the global melting of water ice and the release of volatile compounds, mainly constituted of CO2, CH4 and NH3. The duration and efficiency of exchange between the primitive massive atmosphere and the global impact-induced water ocean likely play a key role in the chemical evolution of the early Titan's atmosphere. To i…
▽ More
During the accretion of Titan, impact heating may have been sufficient to allow the global melting of water ice and the release of volatile compounds, mainly constituted of CO2, CH4 and NH3. The duration and efficiency of exchange between the primitive massive atmosphere and the global impact-induced water ocean likely play a key role in the chemical evolution of the early Titan's atmosphere. To investigate the atmospheric composition of early Titan for a wide range of global (atmosphere + ocean) composition in volatils, we first developed a gas-liquid equilibrium model of the NH3-CO2-H2O system, where the non-ideal behavior of both gas and liquid phases, and the speciation of volatiles dissolved in the aqueous phase are taken into account. We show that the relative abundance of CO2 and NH3 determine the composition of Titan's atmosphere. For CO2/NH3 < 1, CO2 is massively dissolved in the ocean. On the contrary, for CO2/NH3 > 1, CO2 is the main constituent of Titan's primitive atmosphere while the NH3 atmospheric content is dramatically decreased. We then investigate the conditions for the formation of CH4-rich clathrates hydrates at Titan's surface that could be the main reservoir of methane for the present-day atmosphere. In absence of reliable experimental data in the CH4-CO2-NH3-H2O system, the dissolution of methane in water is included using a simplified Henry's law approach. We find that if the concentration of CH4 in Titan's building block was higher than ~0.1 mol.kg-1 and CO2/NH3 < 3, a large fraction of methane may be stored in the primordial crust, which would form at temperature below ~10°C.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Formation, Habitability, and Detection of Extrasolar Moons
Authors:
René Heller,
Darren Williams,
David Kipping,
Mary Anne Limbach,
Edwin Turner,
Richard Greenberg,
Takanori Sasaki,
Émeline Bolmont,
Olivier Grasset,
Karen Lewis,
Rory Barnes,
Jorge I. Zuluaga
Abstract:
The diversity and quantity of moons in the Solar System suggest a manifold population of natural satellites exist around extrasolar planets. Of peculiar interest from an astrobiological perspective, the number of sizable moons in the stellar habitable zones may outnumber planets in these circumstellar regions. With technological and theoretical methods now allowing for the detection of sub-Earth-s…
▽ More
The diversity and quantity of moons in the Solar System suggest a manifold population of natural satellites exist around extrasolar planets. Of peculiar interest from an astrobiological perspective, the number of sizable moons in the stellar habitable zones may outnumber planets in these circumstellar regions. With technological and theoretical methods now allowing for the detection of sub-Earth-sized extrasolar planets, the first detection of an extrasolar moon appears feasible. In this review, we summarize formation channels of massive exomoons that are potentially detectable with current or near-future instruments. We discuss the orbital effects that govern exomoon evolution, we present a framework to characterize an exomoon's stellar plus planetary illumination as well as its tidal heating, and we address the techniques that have been proposed to search for exomoons. Most notably, we show that natural satellites in the range of 0.1 - 0.5 Earth mass (i) are potentially habitable, (ii) can form within the circumplanetary debris and gas disk or via capture from a binary, and (iii) are detectable with current technology.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
EChO - Exoplanet Characterisation Observatory
Authors:
G. Tinetti,
J. P. Beaulieu,
T. Henning,
M. Meyer,
G. Micela,
I. Ribas,
D. Stam,
M. Swain,
O. Krause,
M. Ollivier,
E. Pace,
B. Swinyard,
A. Aylward,
R. van Boekel,
A. Coradini,
T. Encrenaz,
I. Snellen,
M. R. Zapatero-Osorio,
J. Bouwman,
J. Y-K. Cho,
V. Coudé du Foresto,
T. Guillot,
M. Lopez-Morales,
I. Mueller-Wodarg,
E. Palle
, et al. (109 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
A dedicated mission to investigate exoplanetary atmospheres represents a major milestone in our quest to understand our place in the universe by placing our Solar System in context and by addressing the suitability of planets for the presence of life. EChO -the Exoplanet Characterisation Observatory- is a mission concept specifically geared for this purpose. EChO will provide simultaneous, multi-w…
▽ More
A dedicated mission to investigate exoplanetary atmospheres represents a major milestone in our quest to understand our place in the universe by placing our Solar System in context and by addressing the suitability of planets for the presence of life. EChO -the Exoplanet Characterisation Observatory- is a mission concept specifically geared for this purpose. EChO will provide simultaneous, multi-wavelength spectroscopic observations on a stable platform that will allow very long exposures. EChO will build on observations by Hubble, Spitzer and groundbased telescopes, which discovered the first molecules and atoms in exoplanetary atmospheres. EChO will simultaneously observe a broad enough spectral region -from the visible to the mid-IR- to constrain from one single spectrum the temperature structure of the atmosphere and the abundances of the major molecular species. The spectral range and resolution are tailored to separate bands belonging to up to 30 molecules to retrieve the composition and temperature structure of planetary atmospheres. The target list for EChO includes planets ranging from Jupiter-sized with equilibrium temperatures Teq up to 2000 K, to those of a few Earth masses, with Teq ~300 K. We have baselined a dispersive spectrograph design covering continuously the 0.4-16 micron spectral range in 6 channels (1 in the VIS, 5 in the IR), which allows the spectral resolution to be adapted from several tens to several hundreds, depending on the target brightness. The instrument will be mounted behind a 1.5 m class telescope, passively cooled to 50 K, with the instrument structure and optics passively cooled to ~45 K. EChO will be placed in a grand halo orbit around L2. We have also undertaken a first-order cost and development plan analysis and find that EChO is easily compatible with the ESA M-class mission framework.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2011;
originally announced December 2011.
-
The extreme physical properties of the CoRoT-7b super-Earth
Authors:
A. Léger,
O. Grasset,
B. Fegley,
F. Codron,
A. F. Albarede,
P. Barge,
R. Barnes,
P. Cance,
S. Carpy,
F. Catalano,
C. Cavarroc,
O. Demangeon,
S. Ferraz-Mello,
P. Gabor,
J. -M. Griessmeier,
J. Leibacher,
G. Libourel,
A-S. Maurin,
S. N. Raymond,
D. Rouan,
B. Samuel,
L. Schaefer,
J. Schneider,
P. A. Schuller,
F. Selsis
, et al. (1 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The search for rocky exoplanets plays an important role in our quest for extra-terrestrial life. Here, we discuss the extreme physical properties possible for the first characterized rocky super-Earth, CoRoT-7b (R_pl = 1.58 \pm 0.10 R_Earth, Mpl = 6.9 \pm 1.2 M_Earth). It is extremely close to its star (a = 0.0171 AU = 4.48 R_st), with its spin and orbital rotation likely synchronized. The compari…
▽ More
The search for rocky exoplanets plays an important role in our quest for extra-terrestrial life. Here, we discuss the extreme physical properties possible for the first characterized rocky super-Earth, CoRoT-7b (R_pl = 1.58 \pm 0.10 R_Earth, Mpl = 6.9 \pm 1.2 M_Earth). It is extremely close to its star (a = 0.0171 AU = 4.48 R_st), with its spin and orbital rotation likely synchronized. The comparison of its location in the (Mpl, Rpl) plane with the predictions of planetary models for different compositions points to an Earth-like composition, even if the error bars of the measured quantities and the partial degeneracy of the models prevent a definitive conclusion. The proximity to its star provides an additional constraint on the model. It implies a high extreme-UV flux and particle wind, and the corresponding efficient erosion of the planetary atmosphere especially for volatile species including water. Consequently, we make the working hypothesis that the planet is rocky with no volatiles in its atmosphere, and derive the physical properties that result. As a consequence, the atmosphere is made of rocky vapours with a very low pressure (P \leq 1.5 Pa), no cloud can be sustained, and no thermalisation of the planetary is expected. The dayside is very hot (2474 \leq 71 K at the sub-stellar point) while the nightside is very cold (50 to 75 K). The sub-stellar point is as hot as the tungsten filament of an incandescent bulb, resulting in the melting and distillation of silicate rocks and the formation of a lava ocean. These possible features of CoRoT-7b could be common to many small and hot planets, including the recently discovered Kepler-10b. They define a new class of objects that we propose to name "Lava-ocean planets".
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Transiting exoplanets from the CoRoT space mission VIII. CoRoT-7b: the first Super-Earth with measured radius
Authors:
A. Leger,
D. Rouan,
J. Schneider,
P. Barge,
M. Fridlund,
B. Samuel,
M. Ollivier,
E. Guenther,
M. Deleuil,
H. J. Deeg,
M. Auvergne,
R. Alonso,
S. Aigrain,
A. Alapini,
J. M. Almenara,
A. Baglin,
M. Barbieri,
H. Bruntt,
P. Borde,
F. Bouchy,
J. Cabrera,
C. Catala,
L. Carone,
S. Carpano,
Sz. Csizmadia
, et al. (29 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We report the discovery of very shallow (DF/F = 3.4 10-4), periodic dips in the light curve of an active V = 11.7 G9V star observed by the CoRoT satellite, which we interpret as due to the presence of a transiting companion. We describe the 3-colour CoRoT data and complementary ground-based observations that support the planetary nature of the companion. Methods. We use CoRoT color information,…
▽ More
We report the discovery of very shallow (DF/F = 3.4 10-4), periodic dips in the light curve of an active V = 11.7 G9V star observed by the CoRoT satellite, which we interpret as due to the presence of a transiting companion. We describe the 3-colour CoRoT data and complementary ground-based observations that support the planetary nature of the companion. Methods. We use CoRoT color information, good angular resolution ground-based photometric observations in- and out- of transit, adaptive optics imaging, near-infrared spectroscopy and preliminary results from Radial Velocity measurements, to test the diluted eclipsing binary scenarios. The parameters of the host star are derived from optical spectra, which were then combined with the CoRoT light curve to derive parameters of the companion. We examine carefully all conceivable cases of false positives, and all tests performed support the planetary hypothesis. Blends with separation larger than 0.40 arcsec or triple systems are almost excluded with a 8 10-4 risk left. We conclude that, as far as we have been exhaustive, we have discovered a planetary companion, named CoRoT-7b, for which we derive a period of 0.853 59 +/- 3 10-5 day and a radius of Rp = 1.68 +/- 0.09 REarth. Analysis of preliminary radial velocity data yields an upper limit of 21 MEarth for the companion mass, supporting the finding.
CoRoT-7b is very likely the first Super-Earth with a measured radius.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2009; v1 submitted 3 August, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
-
A Study of the Accuracy of Mass-Radius Relationships for Silicate-Rich and Ice-Rich Planets up to 100 Earth Masses
Authors:
O. Grasset,
J. Schneider,
C. Sotin
Abstract:
A mass-radius relationship is proposed for solid planets and solid cores ranging from 1 to 100 Earth-mass planets. It relies on the assumption that solid spheres are composed of iron and silicates, around which a variable amount of water is added. The M-R law has been set up assuming that the planetary composition is similar to the averaged composition for silicates and iron obtained from the ma…
▽ More
A mass-radius relationship is proposed for solid planets and solid cores ranging from 1 to 100 Earth-mass planets. It relies on the assumption that solid spheres are composed of iron and silicates, around which a variable amount of water is added. The M-R law has been set up assuming that the planetary composition is similar to the averaged composition for silicates and iron obtained from the major elements ratio of 94 stars hosting exoplanets. Except on Earth for which a tremendous amount of data is available, the composition of silicate mantles and metallic cores cannot be constrained. Similarly, thermal profiles are poorly known. In this work, the effect of compositional parameters and thermal profiles on radii estimates is quantified. It will be demonstrated that uncertainties related to composition and temperature are of second order compared to the effect of the water amount. The Super-Earths family includes four classes of planets: iron-rich, silicate-rich, water-rich, or with a thick atmosphere. For a given mass, the planetary radius increases significantly from the ironrich to the atmospheric-rich planet. Even if some overlaps are likely, M-R measurements could be accurate enough to ascertain the discovery of an earth-like planet .The present work describes how the amount of water can be assessed from M-R measurements. Such an estimate depends on several assumptions including i) the accuracy of the internal structure model and ii) the accuracy of mass and radius measurements. It is shown that if the mass and the radius are perfectly known, the standard deviation on the amount of water is about 4.5 %. This value increases rapidly with the radius uncertainty but does not strongly depend on the mass uncertainty.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2009;
originally announced February 2009.
-
Diversity among other worlds: characterization of exoplanets by direct detection
Authors:
J. Schneider,
A. Boccaletti,
A. Aylward,
P. Baudoz,
J. -L. Beuzit,
R. Brown,
J. Cho,
K. Dohlen,
M. Ferrari,
R. Galicher,
O. Grasset,
L. Grenfell,
J. -M. Griessmeier,
O. Guyon,
J. Hough,
M. Kasper,
Ch. Keller,
A. Longmore,
B. Lopez,
E. Martin,
D. Mawet,
F. Menard,
B. Merin,
E. Palle,
G. Perrin
, et al. (12 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The physical characterization of exoplanets will require to take spectra at several orbital positions. For that purpose, a direct imaging capability is necessary. Direct imaging requires an efficient stellar suppression mechanism, associated with an ultrasmooth telescope. We show that before future large space missions (interferometer, 4-8 m class coronograph, external occulter or Fresnel imager…
▽ More
The physical characterization of exoplanets will require to take spectra at several orbital positions. For that purpose, a direct imaging capability is necessary. Direct imaging requires an efficient stellar suppression mechanism, associated with an ultrasmooth telescope. We show that before future large space missions (interferometer, 4-8 m class coronograph, external occulter or Fresnel imager), direct imaging of giant planets and close-by super-Earth are at the cross-road of a high scientific interest and a reasonable feasibility. The scientific interest lies in the fact that super-Earths share common geophysical attributes with Earths. They already begin to be detected by radial velocity (RV) and, together with giant planets, they have a larger area than Earths, making them detectable with a 1.5-2 m class telescope in reflected light. We propose such a (space) telescope be a first step before large direct imaging missions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2008; v1 submitted 15 November, 2008;
originally announced November 2008.
-
Could we identify hot Ocean-Planets with CoRoT, Kepler and Doppler velocimetry?
Authors:
F. Selsis,
B. Chazelas,
P. Borde,
M. Ollivier,
F. Brachet,
M. Decaudin,
F. Bouchy,
D. Ehrenreich,
J. -M. Griessmeier,
H. Lammer,
C. Sotin,
O. Grasset,
C. Moutou,
P. Barge,
M. Deleuil,
D. Mawet,
D. Despois,
J. F. Kasting,
A. Leger
Abstract:
Planets less massive than about 10 MEarth are expected to have no massive H-He atmosphere and a cometary composition (50% rocks, 50% water, by mass) provided they formed beyond the snowline of protoplanetary disks. Due to inward migration, such planets could be found at any distance between their formation site and the star. If migration stops within the habitable zone, this will produce a new k…
▽ More
Planets less massive than about 10 MEarth are expected to have no massive H-He atmosphere and a cometary composition (50% rocks, 50% water, by mass) provided they formed beyond the snowline of protoplanetary disks. Due to inward migration, such planets could be found at any distance between their formation site and the star. If migration stops within the habitable zone, this will produce a new kind of planets, called Ocean-Planets. Ocean-planets typically consist in a silicate core, surrounded by a thick ice mantle, itself covered by a 100 km deep ocean. The existence of ocean-planets raises important astrobiological questions: Can life originate on such body, in the absence of continent and ocean-silicate interfaces? What would be the nature of the atmosphere and the geochemical cycles ?
In this work, we address the fate of Hot Ocean-Planets produced when migration ends at a closer distance. In this case the liquid/gas interface can disappear, and the hot H2O envelope is made of a supercritical fluid. Although we do not expect these bodies to harbor life, their detection and identification as water-rich planets would give us insight as to the abundance of hot and, by extrapolation, cool Ocean-Planets.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2007; v1 submitted 22 January, 2007;
originally announced January 2007.
-
On the Possible Properties of Small and Cold Extrasolar Planets: Is OGLE-2005-BLG-390Lb Entirely Frozen?
Authors:
David Ehrenreich,
Alain Lecavelier Des Etangs,
Jean-Philippe Beaulieu,
Olivier Grasset
Abstract:
Extrasolar planets as light as a few Earths are now being detected. Such planets are likely not gas or ice giants. Here, we present a study on the possible properties of the small and cold extrasolar planets, applied to the case of the recently discovered planet OGLE-2005-BLG-390Lb (Beaulieu et al. 2006). This planet (5.5[+5.5/-2.7] Earth masses) orbits 2.6[+1.5/-0.6]-astronomical units away fro…
▽ More
Extrasolar planets as light as a few Earths are now being detected. Such planets are likely not gas or ice giants. Here, we present a study on the possible properties of the small and cold extrasolar planets, applied to the case of the recently discovered planet OGLE-2005-BLG-390Lb (Beaulieu et al. 2006). This planet (5.5[+5.5/-2.7] Earth masses) orbits 2.6[+1.5/-0.6]-astronomical units away from an old M-type star of the Galactic Bulge. The planet should be entirely frozen given the low surface temperature (35 to 47 K). However, depending on the rock-to-ice mass ratio in the planet, the radiogenic heating could be sufficient to make the existence of liquid water within an icy crust possible. This possibility is estimated as a function of the planetary mass and the illumination received from the parent star, both being strongly related by the observational constraints. The results are presented for water-poor and water-rich planets. We find that no oceans can be present in any cases at 9-10 Gyr, a typical age for a star of the Bulge. However, we find that, in the past when the planet was < 5-billion-years old, liquid water was likely present below an icy surface. Nevertheless, the planet is now likely to be entirely frozen.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2006;
originally announced July 2006.
