Showing 1–50 of 107 results for author: Gopal-Krishna

Clues on the nature of the quasi-periodic optical outbursts of the blazar OJ 287

Authors: Gopal-Krishna

Abstract: The fascination with the blazar OJ 287 stems not only from its status as a prominent candidate for a close supermassive black hole (SMBH) binary, but also because of the thermal bremsstrahlung origin proposed for its giant optical outbursts. These outbursts arrive as pairs, quasi-periodically every $\sim 12$ years, based on the unique 130-year-long, well-sampled optical light curve available for t… ▽ More The fascination with the blazar OJ 287 stems not only from its status as a prominent candidate for a close supermassive black hole (SMBH) binary, but also because of the thermal bremsstrahlung origin proposed for its giant optical outbursts. These outbursts arrive as pairs, quasi-periodically every $\sim 12$ years, based on the unique 130-year-long, well-sampled optical light curve available for this blazar. For its three well-known, large quasi-periodic optical outbursts (QPOOs), observed in 1983, 2007 and 2015, optical photo-polarimetric monitoring has been reported in the literature. For these initially radio-undetected QPOOs, widely acclaimed as `bremsstrahlung flares', we have scrutinised the available measurements of optical polarisation and spectral index during the rising phase. Several inconsistencies of these data with the optical bremsstrahlung interpretation are noted, which point towards a synchrotron-dominated alternative interpretation for all these prominent QPOOs, just as for the optical emission observed between the outbursts. Possible reasons for the radio non-detection of the QPOOs during the initial stage are outlined. △ Less

Submitted 12 July, 2024; originally announced July 2024.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Astronomy & Astrophysics (Letters)

A sample of 25 radio galaxies with highly unusual radio morphologies, selected from the LoTSS-DR2 survey at 144 MHz

Authors: Gopal-Krishna, Dusmanta Patra, Ravi Joshi

Abstract: From a careful visual scrutiny of the radio structures of a well-defined sample of 2428 sources in the LoTSS DR2 survey made at 144 MHz with a 6" beam, we have selected a subset of 25 (i.e., 1%) sources showing highly unusual radio structures, not conforming to the prevalent radio morphological classification. Here we present and briefly discuss the basic properties of these rare morphological out… ▽ More From a careful visual scrutiny of the radio structures of a well-defined sample of 2428 sources in the LoTSS DR2 survey made at 144 MHz with a 6" beam, we have selected a subset of 25 (i.e., 1%) sources showing highly unusual radio structures, not conforming to the prevalent radio morphological classification. Here we present and briefly discuss the basic properties of these rare morphological outliers and attempt to dissect their morphological peculiarities, based on multi-wavelength radio images and radio-optical overlays. Also, we underscore the need to accord due importance to such anomalous radio sources, considering the challenge they pose to the standard theoretical models and simulations of extragalactic double radio sources. △ Less

Submitted 17 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 28 pages, 25 figures, submitted to Journal of Astrophysics and Astronomy, Comments welcome

In-situ acceleration of radio-emitting particles in the lobes of radio galaxies: Evolving observational perspective and recent clues

Authors: Gopal-Krishna, Paul Wiita

Abstract: The issue of radiation mechanisms had triggered in 1950-60s the first applications of plasma physics to understand the nature of radio galaxies. This interplay has steadily intensified during the past five decades, due to the premise of in-situ acceleration of relativistic electrons occurring in the lobes of radio galaxies. This article briefly traces the chain of these remarkable developments, la… ▽ More The issue of radiation mechanisms had triggered in 1950-60s the first applications of plasma physics to understand the nature of radio galaxies. This interplay has steadily intensified during the past five decades, due to the premise of in-situ acceleration of relativistic electrons occurring in the lobes of radio galaxies. This article briefly traces the chain of these remarkable developments, largely from an observational perspective. We recount several observational and theoretical milestones established along the way and the lessons drawn from them. We also present a new observational clue about in-situ acceleration of the relativistic particles radiating in the lobes of radio galaxies, gleaned by us from the very recently published sensitive radio observations of a tailed radio source in the galaxy cluster Abell 1033. △ Less

Submitted 15 February, 2024; v1 submitted 10 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Comments: 10 pages, 2 figures, in press in The Journal of Astrophysics and Astronomy; minor additions and edits made

Precession-induced Variability in AGN Jets and OJ 287

Authors: Silke Britzen, Michal Zajaček, Gopal-Krishna, Christian Fendt, Emma Kun, Frédéric Jaron, Aimo Sillanpää, Andreas Eckart

Abstract: The combined study of the flaring of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) at radio wavelengths and pc-scale jet kinematics with Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) has led to the view that i) the observed flares are associated with ejections of synchrotron blobs from the core, and ii) most of the flaring would follow a one-to-one correlation with the component ejection. Recent results have provided m… ▽ More The combined study of the flaring of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) at radio wavelengths and pc-scale jet kinematics with Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) has led to the view that i) the observed flares are associated with ejections of synchrotron blobs from the core, and ii) most of the flaring would follow a one-to-one correlation with the component ejection. Recent results have provided mounting evidence that the quasi-regular component injections into the relativistic jet may not be the only cause of the flux variability. We propose that AGN flux variability and jet morphology changes can both be of deterministic nature, i.e. having a geometric/kinetic origin linked to the time-variable Doppler beaming of the jet emission as its direction changes due to precession (and nutation). The physics of the underlying jet leads to shocks, instabilities, or to ejections of plasmoids. The appearance (morphology, flux, etc.) of the jet can, however, be strongly affected and modulated by precession. We demonstrate this modulating power of precession for OJ 287. For the first time, we show that the spectral state of the Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) can be directly related to the jet's precession phase. We model the SED evolution and reproduce the precession parameters. Further, we apply our precession model to eleven prominent AGN. We show that for OJ 287 precession seems to dominate the long-term variability ($\gtrsim 1\,{\rm yr}$) of the AGN flux, SED spectral state, and jet morphology, while stochastic processes affect the variability on short timescales ($\lesssim 0.2\,{\rm yr}$). △ Less

Submitted 13 July, 2023; v1 submitted 11 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 48 pages, 26 figures, 14 tables; published in the Astrophysical Journal

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal (2023), Volume 951, Issue 2, id.106, 38 pp

Pathway to Devasthal Astronomical Observatory, ARIES

Authors: Ram Sagar, Gopal-Krishna

Abstract: Devasthal observatory, established over a time span of about 5 decades, is located in central Himalayan region of Devabhumi in Nainital district of Uttarakhand state, India. Operated and maintained by the Aryabhatta Research Institute of observational sciencES (ARIES), its location was selected after an extensive site survey. The first measurements of atmospheric seeing and extinctions at Devastha… ▽ More Devasthal observatory, established over a time span of about 5 decades, is located in central Himalayan region of Devabhumi in Nainital district of Uttarakhand state, India. Operated and maintained by the Aryabhatta Research Institute of observational sciencES (ARIES), its location was selected after an extensive site survey. The first measurements of atmospheric seeing and extinctions at Devasthal were carried out during 1997 to 2001. Since 2010, three optical telescopes of 1.3 m, 3.6 m and 4 m apertures have been successfully installed at Devasthal. Optical and near infrared observations taken with these telescopes testify to the global competitiveness of Devasthal observatory for astronomical observations. The article chronicles the collaboration with the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, beginning around 1996, for the purpose of establishing the observatory. A brief overview of the main science results obtained so far, using these facilities, is also presented. △ Less

Submitted 15 July, 2023; v1 submitted 6 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 21 pages, 9 Figures, one Table

MSC Class: Historical note

Journal ref: Indian Journal of History of Science (2024) vol 59 (1) page 90-107

Spectral index variation across X-shaped radio galaxies

Authors: Dusmanta Patra, Ravi Joshi, Gopal-Krishna

Abstract: The formation mechanism of the enigmatic subclass of radio galaxies, called 'X-shaped radio galaxies' (XRGs), or 'winged' radio galaxies, which account for $\sim 10\%$ of the radio galaxy population, can be effectively constrained using the radio spectral-index distribution across their twin pairs of radio lobes. If indeed, the existing claims of no systematic spectral index difference between the… ▽ More The formation mechanism of the enigmatic subclass of radio galaxies, called 'X-shaped radio galaxies' (XRGs), or 'winged' radio galaxies, which account for $\sim 10\%$ of the radio galaxy population, can be effectively constrained using the radio spectral-index distribution across their twin pairs of radio lobes. If indeed, the existing claims of no systematic spectral index difference between the wing and the associated primary lobe are valid in general, this would provide impetus to the XRG model attributing their origin to an unresolved binary of active supermassive black holes within the nucleus of the host galaxy. To investigate this interesting possibility, we have mapped spatial variation of spectral index for a well-defined sample of 25 XRGs, by combining their 1.4 GHz VLA (FIRST survey)/uGMRT maps with their 144 MHz maps (LoTSS-DR2). This has yielded the best available combination of sensitivity, angular resolution, frequency range and sample size, for spectral mapping of an XRG sample. A rich diversity of spectral index patterns is thus revealed in our XRG sample, but we find at most one case where a secondary lobe (wing) exhibits a flatter spectrum compared to its associated primary lobe. We conclude that such a spectral pattern is exceedingly rare and by no means a common trait of XRGs. △ Less

Submitted 29 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 20 pages, 2 figures, 2 tables, accepted for publication in MNRAS

The 'spectral index-flux density relation' for extragalactic radio sources selected at metre and decametre wavelengths

Authors: Pratik Dabhade, Gopal-Krishna

Abstract: We use the recent releases of sensitive VLA/LOFAR large-area surveys at 340 MHz and 54 MHz, in conjunction with the 1.4 GHz NVSS, to accurately determine the `spectral index - flux density relation' ($α$ - S) for extragalactic radio sources selected at metre and decametre wavelengths, the latter for the first time. This newly determined $α$ - S$_{\rm 340~MHz}$ relation shows a progressive flatteni… ▽ More We use the recent releases of sensitive VLA/LOFAR large-area surveys at 340 MHz and 54 MHz, in conjunction with the 1.4 GHz NVSS, to accurately determine the `spectral index - flux density relation' ($α$ - S) for extragalactic radio sources selected at metre and decametre wavelengths, the latter for the first time. This newly determined $α$ - S$_{\rm 340~MHz}$ relation shows a progressive flattening of $α_{\rm median}$ towards lower flux densities, starting from its steepest value (peak)occurring near S$_{\rm 340~MHz}$ $\sim$ 1-2 Jy. This resolves the controversy extant in the literature since the 1980s. The $α$ - S$_{\rm 54~MHz}$ relation, too, shows a spectral index flattening with decreasing flux density which, however, is significantly milder and the relation is less sharply peaked than that found at 340 MHz. A possible reason for the difference could be that the 54 MHz sample has a distinctly stronger/conspicuous presence ( at $\sim$ 20% level) of very steep spectrum sources having $α_{54}^{1400} <$ -1.3, most of which are probably associated with clusters of galaxies. △ Less

Submitted 19 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: Accepted for Publication in A&A Letters. 4 Figures and 2 tables. Comments are welcome

Journal ref: A&A 675, L3 (2023)

Intranight optical variability of TeV blazars with parsec-scale jets dominated by slow-moving radio knots

Authors: Vibhore Negi, Gopal-Krishna, Hum Chand, Silke Britzen

Abstract: BL Lac objects detected at TeV energies preferentially belong to the subclass called 'high-frequency-peaked' BL Lacs (HBLs). Parsec-scale radio jets in these TeV-HBLs often show dominant, slow moving radio knots that are at most mildly superluminal. We report the first systematic campaign to characterise the Intra-Night Optical Variability (INOV) of TeV-HBLs using a representative sample of 6 such… ▽ More BL Lac objects detected at TeV energies preferentially belong to the subclass called 'high-frequency-peaked' BL Lacs (HBLs). Parsec-scale radio jets in these TeV-HBLs often show dominant, slow moving radio knots that are at most mildly superluminal. We report the first systematic campaign to characterise the Intra-Night Optical Variability (INOV) of TeV-HBLs using a representative sample of 6 such sources, all showing a fairly high degree of optical polarization. Our campaign consists of high-sensitivity monitoring of this sample in 24 sessions of more than 3 hour duration each. For these TeV-HBLs, we find a striking lack of INOV and based on this, we discuss the importance of superluminal motion of the radio knots vis-a-vis the optical polarization, as the key diagnostic for INOV detection. △ Less

Submitted 9 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: accepted for publication in MNRAS letters

Intranight Optical Variability of Blazars and Radio-quiet Quasars using the ZTF Survey

Authors: Vibhore Negi, Gopal-Krishna, Ravi Joshi, Hum Chand, Paul Wiita, Navaneeth P K, Ravi S. Singh

Abstract: We explore the potential of the ongoing Zwicky-Transient-Facility (ZTF) survey for studying Intra-Night Optical Variability (INOV) of active galactic nuclei (AGN), in particular for picking rare events of large INOV amplitudes, whose detection may require extensive temporal coverage. For this, we have used the available high cadence subsets of the ZTF database to build a well-defined large sample… ▽ More We explore the potential of the ongoing Zwicky-Transient-Facility (ZTF) survey for studying Intra-Night Optical Variability (INOV) of active galactic nuclei (AGN), in particular for picking rare events of large INOV amplitudes, whose detection may require extensive temporal coverage. For this, we have used the available high cadence subsets of the ZTF database to build a well-defined large sample of 53 blazars (BLs) and another sample of 132 radio-quiet quasars (RQQs), matched to the blazar sample in the redshift-magnitude plane. High-cadence ZTF monitoring of these two matched samples are available, respectively, for 156 and 418 intranight sessions. Median durations for both sets of sessions are 3.7 hours. The two classes of powerful AGN monitored in these sessions represent opposite extremes of jet activity. The present analysis of their ZTF light curves has revealed some strong INOV events which, although not exceptionally rare for blazars, are indeed so for RQQs, and their possible nature is briefly discussed. △ Less

Submitted 21 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS

A physically-motivated perspective of the Fanaroff-Riley classification of radio galaxies

Authors: Gopal-Krishna, Paul J. Wiita, Ravi Joshi, Dusmanta Patra

Abstract: A small subset of extragalactic double radio sources, termed HYMORS (HYbrid MOrpholgy Radio Sources), is distinguished by a very unusual, hybrid morphology in terms of the Fanaroff-Riley (FR) classification. In HYMORS, one radio lobe appears edge-darkened (FR I), while the other shows a well-defined emission peak near its outer edge (edge-brightened, FR II). Such sources are rare but critical for… ▽ More A small subset of extragalactic double radio sources, termed HYMORS (HYbrid MOrpholgy Radio Sources), is distinguished by a very unusual, hybrid morphology in terms of the Fanaroff-Riley (FR) classification. In HYMORS, one radio lobe appears edge-darkened (FR I), while the other shows a well-defined emission peak near its outer edge (edge-brightened, FR II). Such sources are rare but critical for constraining the mechanism responsible for the FR dichotomy, a widely debated issue in extragalactic astrophysics. Here we highlight the need for caution in assigning FR type, in view of some upcoming observational campaigns to confirm HYMORS among the candidates. To illustrate this we highlight the cases of 3 radio sources which have been perceived to be HYMORS, including the radio galaxy 0500+630 (4C +63.07) which has been claimed to be a good, original example of a HYMORS, with a FR I western lobe and a FR II eastern lobe marked by a prominent terminal hot spot. However, its recent VLASS map at 3 GHz has revealed that the western lobe actually extends much farther out than reported and terminates in a well-defined emission peak. This implies that the source is a regular FR II radio galaxy and not a HYMORS. We also provide a brief perspective of the HYMORS phenomenon and underscore the need to confirm a FR I classification by ruling out additional FR II characteristics, such as an inward lobe-widening and spectral steepening, as well as a lack of prominent radio jet within the lobe. △ Less

Submitted 20 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Comments: 9 Pages, 2 Figures, Accepted For Publication in JAA

The transience and persistence of high optical polarization state in beamed radio quasars

Authors: Krishan Chand, Gopal-Krishna, Amitesh Omar, Hum Chand, P. S. Bisht

Abstract: We examine the long-term stability (on decade-like time scales) of optical `high polarization' (HP) state with $p_{opt}$ $> 3\%$, which commonly occurs in flat-spectrum (i.e., beamed) radio quasars (FSRQs) and is a prominent marker of blazar state. Using this clue, roughly a quarter of the FSRQ population has been reported to undergo HP $\leftrightarrow$ non-HP state transition on year-like time s… ▽ More We examine the long-term stability (on decade-like time scales) of optical `high polarization' (HP) state with $p_{opt}$ $> 3\%$, which commonly occurs in flat-spectrum (i.e., beamed) radio quasars (FSRQs) and is a prominent marker of blazar state. Using this clue, roughly a quarter of the FSRQ population has been reported to undergo HP $\leftrightarrow$ non-HP state transition on year-like time scales. This work examines the extent to which HP (i.e., blazar) state can endure in a FSRQ, despite these `frequent' state transitions. This is the first attempt to verify, using purely opto-polarimetric data for a much enlarged sample of blazars, the recent curious finding that blazar state in individual quasars persists for {\it at least} a few decades, despite its changing/swinging observed fairly commonly on year-like time scales. The present analysis is based on a well-defined sample of 83 radio quasars, extracted from the opto-polarimetric survey RoboPol (2013-17), for which old opto-polarimetric data taken prior to 1990 could be found in the literature. By a source-wise comparison of these two datasets of the same observable ($p_{opt}$), we find that $\sim$ 90% of the 63 quasars found in blazar state in our RoboPol sample, were also observed to be in that state about 3 decades before. On the other hand, within the RoboPol survey itself, we find that roughly a quarter of the blazars in our sample migrated to the other polarization state on year-like time scales, by crossing the customary $p_{opt}$ = 3% threshold. Evidently, these relatively frequent transitions (in either direction) do not curtail the propensity of a radio quasar to retain its blazar (i.e., HP) state for at least a few decades. The observed transitions/swings of polarization state are probably manifestation of transient processes, like ejections of synchrotron plasma blobs (VLBI radio knots) from the active nucleus. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: Accepted for publication in PASA

Intranight optical variability of low-mass Active Galactic Nuclei: A Pointer to blazar-like activity

Authors: Gopal-Krishna, Krishan Chand, Hum Chand, Vibhore Negi, Sapna Mishra, S. Britzen, P. S. Bisht

Abstract: This study aims to characterise, for the first time, intranight optical variability (INOV) of low-mass active galactic nuclei (LMAGN) which host a black hole (BH) of mass $M_{BH} \sim 10^6 M_{\odot}$, i.e., even less massive than the Galactic centre black hole Sgr A* and 2-3 orders of magnitude below the supermassive black holes (SMBH, $M_{BH}$ $\sim$ $10^8 - 10^9 M_{\odot}$) which are believed to… ▽ More This study aims to characterise, for the first time, intranight optical variability (INOV) of low-mass active galactic nuclei (LMAGN) which host a black hole (BH) of mass $M_{BH} \sim 10^6 M_{\odot}$, i.e., even less massive than the Galactic centre black hole Sgr A* and 2-3 orders of magnitude below the supermassive black holes (SMBH, $M_{BH}$ $\sim$ $10^8 - 10^9 M_{\odot}$) which are believed to power quasars. Thus, LMAGN are a crucial subclass of AGN filling the wide gap between SMBH and stellar-mass BHs of Galactic X-ray binaries. We have carried out a 36-session campaign of intranight optical monitoring of a well-defined, representative sample of 12 LMAGNs already detected in X-ray and radio bands. This set of LMAGN is found to exhibit INOV at a level statistically comparable to that observed for blazars (M$_{BH} \gtrsim$ 10$^{8-9}$ M$_{\odot}$) and for the $γ$-ray detected Narrow-line Seyfert1 galaxies (M$_{BH}\sim 10^7$ M$_{\odot}$) which, too, are believed to have relativistic jets. This indicates that the blazar-level activity can even be sustained by central engines with black holes near the upper limit for Intermediate Mass Black Holes ($M_{BH}$ $\sim$ $10^3 - 10^6 M_{\odot}$). △ Less

Submitted 11 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS Letters

Discovery of inverse-Compton X-ray emission and estimate of the volume-averaged magnetic field in a galaxy group

Authors: F. Mernier, N. Werner, J. Bagchi, M. -L. Gendron-Marsolais, Gopal-Krishna, M. Guainazzi, A. Richard-Laferrière, T. W. Shimwell, A. Simionescu

Abstract: Observed in a significant fraction of clusters and groups of galaxies, diffuse radio synchrotron emission reveals the presence of relativistic electrons and magnetic fields permeating large-scale systems of galaxies. Although these non-thermal electrons are expected to upscatter cosmic microwave background photons up to hard X-ray energies, such inverse-Compton (IC) X-ray emission has so far not b… ▽ More Observed in a significant fraction of clusters and groups of galaxies, diffuse radio synchrotron emission reveals the presence of relativistic electrons and magnetic fields permeating large-scale systems of galaxies. Although these non-thermal electrons are expected to upscatter cosmic microwave background photons up to hard X-ray energies, such inverse-Compton (IC) X-ray emission has so far not been unambiguously detected on cluster/group scales. Using deep, new proprietary XMM-Newton observations ($\sim$200 ks of clean exposure), we report a 4.6$σ$ detection of extended IC X-ray emission in MRC 0116+111, an extraordinary group of galaxies at $z = 0.131$. Assuming a spectral slope derived from low-frequency radio data, the detection remains robust to systematic uncertainties. Together with low-frequency radio data from GMRT, this detection provides an estimate for the volume-averaged magnetic field of $(1.9 \pm 0.3)$ $μ$G within the central part of the group. This value can serve as an anchor for studies of magnetic fields in the largest gravitationally bound systems in the Universe. △ Less

Submitted 28 July, 2023; v1 submitted 20 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Comments: 11 pages, 7 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

The radio source in Abell 980: A Detached-Double-Double Radio Galaxy?

Authors: Gopal-Krishna, Surajit Paul, Sameer Salunkhe, Satish Sonkamble

Abstract: It is argued that the new morphological and spectral information gleaned from the recently published LoFAR Two meter Sky Survey data release 2 (LoTSS-2 at 144 MHz) observations of the cluster Abell 980 (A980), in combination with its existing GMRT and VLA observations at higher frequencies, provide the much-needed evidence to strengthen the proposal that the cluster's radio emission comes mainly f… ▽ More It is argued that the new morphological and spectral information gleaned from the recently published LoFAR Two meter Sky Survey data release 2 (LoTSS-2 at 144 MHz) observations of the cluster Abell 980 (A980), in combination with its existing GMRT and VLA observations at higher frequencies, provide the much-needed evidence to strengthen the proposal that the cluster's radio emission comes mainly from two double radio sources, both produced by the brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) in two major episodes of jet activity. The two radio lobes left from the previous activity have become diffuse and developed an ultra-steep radio spectrum while rising buoyantly through the confining hot intra-cluster medium (ICM) and, concomitantly, the host galaxy has drifted to the cluster centre and entered a new active phase manifested by a coinciding younger double radio source. The new observational results and arguments presented here bolster the case that the old and young double radio sources in A980 conjointly represent a `double-double' radio galaxy whose two lobe-pairs have lost colinearity due to the (lateral) drift of their parent galaxy, making this system by far the most plausible case of a `Detached-Double-Double Radio Galaxy' (dDDRG). △ Less

Submitted 11 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Comments: Accepted for publication by Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia (PASA); 10 pages, 6 figures

X-shaped radio galaxy 3C 223.1: A 'double boomerang' with an anomalous spectral gradient

Authors: Gopal-Krishna, Pratik Dabhade

Abstract: A comparison of the recent LOFAR 144 MHz map of the radio source 3C 223.1 (J094124.028+394441.95) with the VLA maps at 4.9 GHz and 8.3 GHz that we built based on archival data, establishes this X-shaped radio galaxy (XRG) as a singularly robust case where the 'wings' exhibit a distinctly flatter radio spectrum than the primary lobes. The details of its anomalous spectral gradient are unravelled he… ▽ More A comparison of the recent LOFAR 144 MHz map of the radio source 3C 223.1 (J094124.028+394441.95) with the VLA maps at 4.9 GHz and 8.3 GHz that we built based on archival data, establishes this X-shaped radio galaxy (XRG) as a singularly robust case where the 'wings' exhibit a distinctly flatter radio spectrum than the primary lobes. The details of its anomalous spectral gradient are unravelled here with unprecedented precision. We also highlight the 'double boomerang' type radio morphology of this XRG. It appears plausible that the peculiar spectral gradient in this XRG is owed to particle acceleration associated with the rebounding of the collimated backflows of synchrotron plasma streaming through its two primary lobes, as they impinge upon and encounter the magnetic tension in the prominent dusty disk of the elliptical galaxy hosting this XRG. We also draw attention to an intriguing new morphological peculiarity among XRGs, namely, a lateral offset observed between the (parallel) axes of the two primary radio lobes. △ Less

Submitted 20 July, 2022; v1 submitted 8 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Comments: Accepted for publication in A&A Letters |3 figures and 2 tables | Comments are welcome

Journal ref: A&A 663, L8 (2022)

Deciphering the ultra-steep spectrum diffuse radio sources discovered in the cool-core cluster Abell~980

Authors: Sameer Salunkhe, Surajit Paul, Gopal-Krishna, Satish Sonkamble, Shubham Bhagat

Abstract: Clusters of galaxies are excellent laboratories for studying recurring nuclear activity in galactic nuclei since their hot gaseous medium can vastly prolong the detectability of their radio lobes via better confinement. We report here a multi-band study of the sparsely studied galaxy cluster Abell 980, based on our analysis of {\it{Chandra}} X-ray and the GMRT (150 and 325 MHz) and EVLA (1.5 GHz)… ▽ More Clusters of galaxies are excellent laboratories for studying recurring nuclear activity in galactic nuclei since their hot gaseous medium can vastly prolong the detectability of their radio lobes via better confinement. We report here a multi-band study of the sparsely studied galaxy cluster Abell 980, based on our analysis of {\it{Chandra}} X-ray and the GMRT (150 and 325 MHz) and EVLA (1.5 GHz) radio archival data, revealing an unusually rich phenomenology. It is shown to be a quasi-relaxed cluster with a cool core ($T\sim4.2$ keV) surrounded by a hot and extensive intracluster medium (ICM) at $T\sim6.8$ keV. The radio emission shows a rich diversity, having (i) two large diffuse sources of ultra-steep spectrum (USS), extending to opposite extremities of the ICM, each associated with an X-ray brightness discontinuity (cold front), (ii) a bright radio-double of size $\sim55$ kpc coinciding with the central BCG, and (iii) a diffuse radio source, likely a mini-halo of size $\sim110$~kpc around the BCG which possesses a huge ellipsoidal stellar halo of extent $\sim 80$~kpc. The association of cold fronts with two highly aged (~ 260 Myr) USS sources in a cool-core cluster, makes it a very rare system. These USS sources are probably radio lobes from a previous episode of jet activity in the BCG, driven buoyantly towards the outskirts of the X-ray halo, thereby creating the cold fronts. A deeper radio image of this cluster may provide a rare opportunity to verify the recently proposed alternative model which explains radio mini-haloes as the aggregate radio emission from Type I supernovae occurring in the giant stellar halo extended across the cluster core. △ Less

Submitted 27 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

Comments: 8 pages, 6 figures, Accepted for publication in A&A

Journal ref: A&A 664, A186 (2022)

Persistence of blazar state in flat-spectrum radio quasars

Authors: Krishan Chand, Gopal-Krishna

Abstract: Flat-spectrum radio quasars (FSRQs) whose brightness is dominated by a relativistically beamed core, are frequently found in 'blazar state' commonly inferred from a high optical polarization ( > 3%), and/or a large continuum variability. Here we use these two prime optical markers to investigate continuance of an FSRQ in blazar (or non-blazar) state over an exceptionally long time baseline spannin… ▽ More Flat-spectrum radio quasars (FSRQs) whose brightness is dominated by a relativistically beamed core, are frequently found in 'blazar state' commonly inferred from a high optical polarization ( > 3%), and/or a large continuum variability. Here we use these two prime optical markers to investigate continuance of an FSRQ in blazar (or non-blazar) state over an exceptionally long time baseline spanning 4 decades. Our basic sample is a well-defined, unbiased set of 80 FSRQs whose blazar state stood confirmed during 1980s from optical polarimetry. Four decades later, blazar state of each FSRQ is ascertained here from variability of their optical light-curves of typical duration $\sim$ 3.5 years, a low noise (rms $\sim$ 2%) and good cadence ($\sim$ 3 days), obtained under the Zwicky Transient Facility project ongoing since 2018. For about 40% of these FSRQs, blazar state could be ascertained additionally from the opto-polarimetric survey RoboPol (2013-2017). From both these databases it is found that only $\sim$ 10% of the FSRQs have undergone a blazar $\leftrightarrow$ non-blazar state transition over the past 3 - 4 decades. This reinforces the case for a long-term stability of blazar state in individual FSRQs, despite their state fluctuating more commonly on year-like time scales. △ Less

Submitted 23 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS Letter

The Twin Radio galaxy TRG J104454+354055

Authors: Gopal-Krishna, Ravi Joshi, Dusmanta Patra, Xiaolong Yang, Luis C. Ho, Paul J. Wiita, Amitesh Omar

Abstract: We report observations of a bright dumb-bell system of galaxies ($z =0.162$) with the upgraded Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope ($u$GMRT), which show that each member of this gravitationally bound pair of galaxies hosts bipolar radio jets extended on 100 kiloparsec scales. Only two cases of such radio morphology have been reported previously, both being dumb-bell systems, as well. The famous first… ▽ More We report observations of a bright dumb-bell system of galaxies ($z =0.162$) with the upgraded Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope ($u$GMRT), which show that each member of this gravitationally bound pair of galaxies hosts bipolar radio jets extended on 100 kiloparsec scales. Only two cases of such radio morphology have been reported previously, both being dumb-bell systems, as well. The famous first example, 3C 75, was discovered 4 decades ago, and the second case was discovered 3 decades ago. This implies that such `Twin-Radio-Galaxies' (TRGs) are an exceedingly rare phenomenon. As in the case of its two senior cousins, the bi-polar radio jets of the present TRG (J104454+354055) exhibit strong wiggles and are edge-darkened (Fanaroff-Riley class I). However, there are important differences, too. For instance, the jets in the present TRG do not merge and, moreover, show no signs of distortion due to an external crosswind. This makes the present TRG a much neater laboratory for studying the physics of (sideway) colliding jets of relativistic plasma. This TRG has a Wide-Angle-Tail (WAT) neighbour hosted by another bright galaxy belonging to the same group, which appears to be moving towards the TRG. △ Less

Submitted 9 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: 5 Pages, 2 Figures, Accepted for Publication in MNRAS-LETTERs

Discovery of X-shaped Morphology of the Giant Radio Galaxy GRG 0503-286

Authors: Pratik Dabhade, Gopal-Krishna

Abstract: The high surface-brightness sensitivity of the GLEAM survey image of the giant radio galaxy GRG 0503-28 at 70-230 MHz has revealed an inversion-symmetric bending of its two lobes, while maintaining between their bent portions a ~200 kpc wide strip-like radio emission gap. This lends the source the appearance of a mega-sized X-shaped radio galaxy. Identifying the emission gap with the presence of a… ▽ More The high surface-brightness sensitivity of the GLEAM survey image of the giant radio galaxy GRG 0503-28 at 70-230 MHz has revealed an inversion-symmetric bending of its two lobes, while maintaining between their bent portions a ~200 kpc wide strip-like radio emission gap. This lends the source the appearance of a mega-sized X-shaped radio galaxy. Identifying the emission gap with the presence of a gaseous layer, probably a WHIM-filled sheet in the cosmic web, we suggest that the layer is the most likely cause of the inversion-symmetric bending of the two radio lobes. Multiple observational manifestations of such gaseous layers are noted. The two lobes of this GRG, known to extend very asymmetrically from the host galaxy, are remarkably symmetric about the emission gap, confirming a curious trend noted earlier for double radio sources of normal dimensions. The anomalous radio spectral gradient reported for the northern lobe of this GRG is not substantiated. △ Less

Submitted 2 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Comments: Accepted for publication in A&A Letters | 5 pages and 3 figures | Comments are welcome | Dedicated to Prof Govind Swarup, FRS

Journal ref: A&A 660, L10 (2022)

Intranight variability of UV emission from powerful blazars

Authors: Krishan Chand, Gopal-Krishna, Amitesh Omar, Hum Chand, Sapna Mishra, P. S. Bisht, S. Britzen

Abstract: We report the first study to characterise intranight variability of the blazar class from the perspective of (rest-frame) UV emission. For this, we carried out intranight optical monitoring of 14 flat-spectrum radio quasars (FSRQs) located at high redshifts (1.5 < $z$ < 3.7), in 42 sessions of median duration $\sim$ 5.4 hr. These sources were grouped into two samples distinguished by published fra… ▽ More We report the first study to characterise intranight variability of the blazar class from the perspective of (rest-frame) UV emission. For this, we carried out intranight optical monitoring of 14 flat-spectrum radio quasars (FSRQs) located at high redshifts (1.5 < $z$ < 3.7), in 42 sessions of median duration $\sim$ 5.4 hr. These sources were grouped into two samples distinguished by published fractional optical polarisation: (i) nine low-polarisation sources with $p_{opt} < 3\%$ and (ii) five high-polarisation sources. Unexpectedly, a high duty cycle (DC $\sim$ 30$\%$) is found for intranight variability (with amplitude $ψ> 3\%$) of the low-polarisation sources. This DC is a few times higher than that reported for low-polarisation FSRQs located at moderate redshifts ($z$ $\sim$ 0.7) and hence typically monitored in the rest-frame blue-optical. Further, we found no evidence for an increased intranight variability of UV emission with polarisation, in contrast to the strong correlation found for intranight variability of optical emission. We briefly discuss this in the context of an existing scenario which posits that the nonthermal UV emission of blazars arises from a relativistic particle population different from that radiating up to near-infrared/optical frequencies. △ Less

Submitted 8 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS Letter

A Search for Blazar Activity in Broad-Absorption-Line Quasars

Authors: Sapna Mishra, Gopal-Krishna, Hum Chand, Krishan Chand, Amit Kumar, Vibhore Negi

Abstract: Our recently reported lack of Intra-Night Optical Variability (INOV) among Broad-Absorption-Line (BAL) quasars exhibiting some blazar-like radio properties, either questions polar ejection of BAL clouds, and/or hints at a physical state of the relativistic jet modified due to interaction with the thermal BAL wind on the innermost sub-parsec scale. As a robust check on this unexpected finding for t… ▽ More Our recently reported lack of Intra-Night Optical Variability (INOV) among Broad-Absorption-Line (BAL) quasars exhibiting some blazar-like radio properties, either questions polar ejection of BAL clouds, and/or hints at a physical state of the relativistic jet modified due to interaction with the thermal BAL wind on the innermost sub-parsec scale. As a robust check on this unexpected finding for the BAL_blazar candidates, we report here the INOV study of a new and much more rigorously defined comparison sample consisting of 9 normal (non-BAL) blazars, matched in both magnitude and redshift to the aforementioned sample of BAL_blazar candidates. The present campaign spanning 27 sessions yields an INOV duty cycle of ~23% for the comparison sample of normal blazars, employing the enhanced F-test. However, even this more sensitive test does not detect INOV for the sample of BAL_blazar candidates. This stark INOV contrast found here between the BAL_blazar candidates and normal blazars can probably be traced to a physical interaction of the relativistic jet with the thermal wind, within sub-parsec range from the nucleus. The consequent enfeebling of the jet would additionally explain the striking deficiency among BAL quasars of powerful FR II radio lobes on the much larger scale of 10-100 kpc. △ Less

Submitted 11 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRASL

Intra-night optical variability of $γ-$ray detected narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies

Authors: Vineet Ojha, Hum Chand, Gopal-Krishna

Abstract: We report the first attempt to systematically characterise intra-night optical variability (INOV) of the rare and enigmatic subset of Narrow-Line Seyfert1 galaxies (NLSy1s), which is marked by detection in the $γ$-ray band and is therefore endowed with Doppler boosted relativistic jets, like blazars. However, the central engines in these two types of AGN are thought to operate in different regimes… ▽ More We report the first attempt to systematically characterise intra-night optical variability (INOV) of the rare and enigmatic subset of Narrow-Line Seyfert1 galaxies (NLSy1s), which is marked by detection in the $γ$-ray band and is therefore endowed with Doppler boosted relativistic jets, like blazars. However, the central engines in these two types of AGN are thought to operate in different regimes of accretion rate. Our INOV search in a fairly large and unbiased sample of 15 $γ$-ray NLSy1s was conducted in 36 monitoring sessions, each lasting $\geq$ 3 hrs. In our analysis, special care has been taken to address the possible effect on the differential light curves, of any variation in the seeing disc during the session, since that might lead to spurious claims of INOV from such AGN due to the possibility of a significant contribution from the host galaxy to the total optical emission. From our observations, a duty cycle (DC) of INOV detection in the $γ$-ray NLSy1s is estimated to be around 25% - 30%, which is comparable to that known for blazars. This estimate of DC will probably need an upward revision, once it becomes possible to correct for the dilution of the AGN's nonthermal optical emission by the (much steadier) optical emission contributed not only by the host galaxy but also the nuclear accretion disc in these high Eddington rate accretors. Finally, we also draw attention to the possibility that sharp optical flux changes on sub-hour time scale are less rare for $γ$-ray NLSy1s, in comparison to blazars. △ Less

Submitted 18 December, 2020; v1 submitted 2 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 15 pages, 4 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

uGMRT HI 21-cm absorption observations of two extremely inverted spectrum sources

Authors: Mukul Mhaskey, Surajit Paul, Neeraj Gupta, Dipanjan Mukherjee, Gopal-Krishna

Abstract: We report the detection of HI 21-cm absorption in a member of the rare and recently discovered class of compact radio sources, 'Extremely Inverted Spectrum Extragalactic Radio Sources (EISERS)'. EISERS conceivably form a special sub-class of the inverted spectrum radio galaxies since the spectral index of the optically thick part of the spectrum for these sources crosses the synchrotron self absor… ▽ More We report the detection of HI 21-cm absorption in a member of the rare and recently discovered class of compact radio sources, 'Extremely Inverted Spectrum Extragalactic Radio Sources (EISERS)'. EISERS conceivably form a special sub-class of the inverted spectrum radio galaxies since the spectral index of the optically thick part of the spectrum for these sources crosses the synchrotron self absorption limit of $α=+2.5$ (S($ν$) $\propto$ $ν^α$). We have searched for HI absorption in two EISERS using the recently upgraded Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (uGMRT) and detected an absorption feature in one of them. The strong associated HI absorption detected against the source J1209$-$2032 ($z$=0.4040) implies an optical depth of 0.178$\pm$0.02 corresponding to an HI column density of 34.8$\pm$2.9 $\times$10$^{20}$ cm$^{-2}$, for an assumed HI spin temperature of 100 K and covering factor of 1. This is among the highest known optical depth and HI column densities found for compact radio sources of GPC/CSS type and supports the free-free absorption model for the steeply inverted radio spectrum of this source. For the other source, J1549$+$5038 ($z$ = 2.171), no HI absorption was detected in our observations. △ Less

Submitted 26 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: Accepted for publication in A&A

Journal ref: A&A 643, A174 (2020)

Comparative intra-night optical variability of X-ray and $γ$-ray detected narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies

Authors: Ojha Vineet, Chand Hum, Gopal-Krishna, Mishra Sapna, Chand Krishan

Abstract: In a systematic program to characterise the intra-night optical variability (INOV) of different classes of narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies (NLSy1s), we report here the first comparative INOV study of NLSy1 sets detected in the X-ray and $γ$-ray bands. Our sample consists of 18 sources detected in X-ray but not in $γ$-rays (hereafter x$\textunderscore$NLSy1s) and 7 sources detected in $γ$-rays (here… ▽ More In a systematic program to characterise the intra-night optical variability (INOV) of different classes of narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies (NLSy1s), we report here the first comparative INOV study of NLSy1 sets detected in the X-ray and $γ$-ray bands. Our sample consists of 18 sources detected in X-ray but not in $γ$-rays (hereafter x$\textunderscore$NLSy1s) and 7 sources detected in $γ$-rays (hereafter g$\textunderscore$NLSy1s), out of which 5 are detected also in X-rays. We have monitored these two sets of NLSy1s, respectively, in 24 and 21 sessions of a minimum of 3 hours duration each. The INOV duty cycles for these two sets are found to be 12\% and 53\%, respectively (at a 99\% confidence level). In the set of 18 x$\textunderscore$NLSy1s, INOV duty cycle is found to be zero for the 13 radio-quiet members (monitored in 14 sessions) and 43\% for the 5 radio-loud members (10 sessions). The latter is very similar to the aforementioned duty cycle of 53\% found here for the set of g$\textunderscore$NLSy1s (all of which are radio-loud). Thus it appears that the radio loudness level is the prime factor behind the INOV detection and the pattern of the high-energy radiation plays only a minor role. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS. This manuscript consists of 14 pages including 7 figures, 3 tables in the paper and two tables in the appendix

Multiband optical flux density and polarization microvariability study of optically bright blazars

Authors: Magdalena Pasierb, Arti Goyal, Michał Ostrowski, Łukasz Stawarz, Paul J. Wiita, Gopal-Krishna, Valeri M. Larionov, Daria A. Morozova, Ryosuke Itoh, Fahri Alicavus, Ahmet Erdem, Santosh Joshi, Staszek Zola, Georgy A. Borman, Tatiana S. Grishina, Evgenia N. Kopatskaya, Elena G. Larionova, Sergey S. Savchenko, Anna A. Nikiforova, Yulia V. Troitskaya, Ivan S. Troitsky, Hiroshi Akitaya, Miho Kawabata, Tatsuya Nakaoka

Abstract: We present the results of flux density, spectral index, and polarization intra-night monitoring studies of a sample of eight optically bright blazars, carried out by employing several small to moderate aperture (0.4\,m to 1.5\,m diameter) telescopes fitted with CCDs and polarimeters located in Europe, India, and Japan. The duty cycle of flux variability for the targets is found to be $\sim 45$ per… ▽ More We present the results of flux density, spectral index, and polarization intra-night monitoring studies of a sample of eight optically bright blazars, carried out by employing several small to moderate aperture (0.4\,m to 1.5\,m diameter) telescopes fitted with CCDs and polarimeters located in Europe, India, and Japan. The duty cycle of flux variability for the targets is found to be $\sim 45$ percent, similar to that reported in earlier studies. The computed two-point spectral indices are found to be between 0.65 to 1.87 for our sample, comprised of low- and intermediate frequency peaked blazars, with one exception; they are also found to be statistically variable for about half the instances where `confirmed' variability is detected in flux density. In the analysis of the spectral evolution of the targets on hourly timescale, a counter-clockwise loop (soft-lagging) is noted in the flux-spectral index plane on two occasions, and in one case a clear spectral flattening with the decreasing flux is observed. In our data set, we also observe a variety of flux-polarization degree variability patterns, including instances with a relatively straightforward anti-correlation, correlation, or counter-clockwise looping. These changes are typically reflected in the flux-polarization angle plane: the anti-correlation between the flux and polarization degree is accompanied by an anti-correlation between the polarization angle and flux, while the counter-clockwise flux-PD looping behaviour is accompanied by a clockwise looping in the flux-polarization angle representation. We discuss our findings in the framework of the internal shock scenario for blazar sources. △ Less

Submitted 11 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: MNRAS accepted

X-shaped Radio Galaxies: Optical Properties, Large-scale Environment and Relationship to Radio Structure

Authors: Ravi Joshi, Gopal-Krishna, Xiaolong Yang, Jingjing Shi, Si-Yue Yu, Paul J. Wiita, Luis C. Ho, Xue-Bing Wu, Tao An, Ran Wang, Smitha Subramanian, Hassen Yesuf

Abstract: In order to find clues to the origin of the "winged" or "X-shaped" radio galaxies (XRGs) we investigate here the parent galaxies of a large sample of 106 XRGs for optical-radio axes alignment, interstellar medium, black hole mass, and large-scale environment. For 41 of the XRGs it was possible to determine the optical major axis and the primary radio axis and the strong tendency for the two axes t… ▽ More In order to find clues to the origin of the "winged" or "X-shaped" radio galaxies (XRGs) we investigate here the parent galaxies of a large sample of 106 XRGs for optical-radio axes alignment, interstellar medium, black hole mass, and large-scale environment. For 41 of the XRGs it was possible to determine the optical major axis and the primary radio axis and the strong tendency for the two axes to be fairly close is confirmed. However, several counter-examples were also found and these could challenge the widely discussed backflow diversion model for the origin of the radio wings. Comparison with a well-defined large sample of normal FR II radio galaxies has revealed that: (i) XRGs possess slightly less massive central black holes than the normal radio galaxies (average masses being log$M_{\rm BH} \sim$ 8.81 $M_{\odot}$ and 9.07 $M_{\odot}$, respectively); (ii) a much higher fraction of XRGs ($\sim$ 80%) exhibits red mid-IR colors ($W2 - W3 > 1.5$), indicating a population of young stars and/or an enhanced dust mass, probably due to relatively recent galaxy merger(s). A comparison of the large-scale environment (i.e., within $\sim$ 1 Mpc) shows that both XRGs and FRII radio galaxies inhabit similarly poor galaxy clustering environments (medium richness being 8.94 and 11.87, respectively). Overall, the origin of XRGs seems difficult to reconcile with a single dominant physical mechanism and competing mechanisms seem prevalent. △ Less

Submitted 31 October, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: 17 Pages, 9 Figures, 3 Tables (Accepted for the Publications in ApJ main Journal)

GMRT observations of a first sample of Extremely Inverted Spectrum Extragalactic Radio Sources (EISERS) candidates in the Northern sky

Authors: Mukul Mhaskey, Gopal-Krishna, Surajit Paul, Pratik Dabhade, Sameer Salunkhe, Shubham Bhagat, Abhijit Bendre

Abstract: We present an extension of our search for Extremely Inverted Spectrum Extragalactic Radio Sources (EISERS) to the northern celestial hemisphere. With an inverted radio spectrum of slope $α$ > +2.5, these rare sources would either require a non-standard particle acceleration mechanism (in the framework of synchrotron self-absorption hypothesis), or a severe free-free absorption which attenuates pra… ▽ More We present an extension of our search for Extremely Inverted Spectrum Extragalactic Radio Sources (EISERS) to the northern celestial hemisphere. With an inverted radio spectrum of slope $α$ > +2.5, these rare sources would either require a non-standard particle acceleration mechanism (in the framework of synchrotron self-absorption hypothesis), or a severe free-free absorption which attenuates practically all of their synchrotron radiation at metre wavelengths. By applying a sequence of selection filters, a list of 15 EISERS candidates is extracted out by comparing two large-sky radio surveys, WENSS (325 MHz) and TGSS-ADR1 (150 MHz), which overlap across 1.03$π$ steradian of the sky. Here we report quasi-simultaneous GMRT observations of these 15 EISERS candidates at 150 MHz and 325 MHz, in an attempt to accurately define their spectra below the turnover frequency. Out of the 15 candidates observed, two are confirmed as EISERS, since the slope of the inverted spectrum between these two frequencies is found to be significantly larger than the critical value $α_c$ = +2.5: the theoretical limit for the standard case of synchrotron self-absorption (SSA). For another 3 sources, the spectral slope is close to, or just above the critical value $α_c$. Nine of the sources have GPS type radio spectra. The parsec-scale radio structural information available for the sample is also summarised. △ Less

Submitted 23 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS. Comments are welcome

Journal ref: Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 2019, Volume 489, Issue 3: pp. 3506

Are there broad absorption-line blazars?

Authors: Sapna Mishra, Gopal-Krishna, Hum Chand, Krishan Chand, Vineet Ojha

Abstract: We report the first systematic search for blazars among broad-absorption-line (BAL) quasars. This is based on our intranight optical monitoring of a well-defined sample of 10 candidates selected on the criteria of a flat spectrum and an abnormally high linear polarization at radio wavelengths. A small population of BAL blazars can be expected in the 'polar model' of BAL quasars. However, no such c… ▽ More We report the first systematic search for blazars among broad-absorption-line (BAL) quasars. This is based on our intranight optical monitoring of a well-defined sample of 10 candidates selected on the criteria of a flat spectrum and an abnormally high linear polarization at radio wavelengths. A small population of BAL blazars can be expected in the 'polar model' of BAL quasars. However, no such case is found, since none of our 30 monitoring sessions devoted to the 10 candidates yielded a positive detection of intra-night optical variability (INOV), which is uncharacteristic of blazars. This lack of INOV detection contrasts with the high duty cycle of INOV observed for a comparison sample of 15 'normal' (i.e., non-BAL) blazars. Some possible implications of this are pointed out. △ Less

Submitted 2 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS Letter

The diversity of AGN variability: Some highlights and challenges

Authors: Gopal-Krishna, Silke Britzen, Paul Wiita

Abstract: This article focuses on certain variability and emission characteristics of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN), especially their radio-loud subset consisting of quasars, BL Lacs and $γ$-ray detected narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies, all of which exhibit relativistically beamed jets of nonthermal radiation. Several striking trends and correlations, including some that have received scant attention, drawn f… ▽ More This article focuses on certain variability and emission characteristics of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN), especially their radio-loud subset consisting of quasars, BL Lacs and $γ$-ray detected narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies, all of which exhibit relativistically beamed jets of nonthermal radiation. Several striking trends and correlations, including some that have received scant attention, drawn from the available comparatively recent literature are highlighted. These can provide very useful inputs to models of AGN and be probed at a deeper level using the optical telescopes recently set up at Devasthal (Nainital). △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: 10 pages, 8 figures, in second Belgo-Indian Network for Astronomy & astrophysics (BINA) conference, ed. M. De Becker, to appear in Bull. Liege Royal Society of Sciences

Catching butterflies in the sky: Extended catalog of winged or X-shaped radio sources from the latest FIRST data release

Authors: Xiaolong Yang, Ravi Joshi, Gopal-Krishna, Tao An, Luis C. Ho, Paul J. Wiita, Xiang Liu, Jun Yang, Ran Wang, Xuebing Wu, Xiaofeng Yang

Abstract: We present a catalog of 290 "winged" or X-shaped radio galaxies (XRGs) extracted from the latest (2014 December 17) data release of the "Very Large Array Faint Images of the Radio Sky at Twenty centimeter." We have combined these radio images with their counterparts in the TIFR GMRT sky survey at 150 MHz, in an attempt to identify any low surface brightness radio emission present in these sources.… ▽ More We present a catalog of 290 "winged" or X-shaped radio galaxies (XRGs) extracted from the latest (2014 December 17) data release of the "Very Large Array Faint Images of the Radio Sky at Twenty centimeter." We have combined these radio images with their counterparts in the TIFR GMRT sky survey at 150 MHz, in an attempt to identify any low surface brightness radio emission present in these sources. This has enabled us to assemble a sample of 106 "strong" XRG candidates and 184 "probable" XRG candidates whose XRG designation needs to be verified by further observations. The present sample of 290 XRG candidates is almost twice as large as the number of XRGs currently known. Twenty-five of our 290 XRG candidates (9 "strong" and 16 "probable") are identified as quasars. Double-peaked narrow emission lines are seen in the optical spectra of three of the XRG candidates (two "strong" and one "probable"). Nearly 90% of the sample is located in the FR II domain of the Owen-Ledlow diagram. A few of the strong XRG candidates have a rather flat radio spectrum (spectral index alpha flatter than -0.3) between 150 MHz and 1.4 GHz, or between 1.4 and 5 GHz. Since this is not expected for lobe-dominated extragalactic radio sources (like nearly all known XRGs), these sources are particularly suited for follow-up radio imaging and near-simultaneous measurement of the radio spectrum. △ Less

Submitted 22 July, 2020; v1 submitted 15 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 22 pages, 9 figures, 3 tables, accepted for publication in ApJS

Journal ref: ApJS 245 17 (2019)

GMRT observations of extragalactic radio sources with steeply inverted spectra

Authors: Mukul Mhaskey, Gopal-Krishna, Pratik Dabhade, Surajit Paul, Sameer Salunkhe, S. K. Sirothia

Abstract: We report quasi-simultaneous GMRT observations of seven extragalactic radio sources at 150, 325, 610 and 1400 MHz, in an attempt to accurately define their radio continuum spectra, particularly at frequencies below the observed spectral turnover. We had previously identified these sources as candidates for a sharply inverted integrated radio spectrum whose slope is close to, or even exceeds $α_c$… ▽ More We report quasi-simultaneous GMRT observations of seven extragalactic radio sources at 150, 325, 610 and 1400 MHz, in an attempt to accurately define their radio continuum spectra, particularly at frequencies below the observed spectral turnover. We had previously identified these sources as candidates for a sharply inverted integrated radio spectrum whose slope is close to, or even exceeds $α_c$ = +2.5, the theoretical limit due to synchrotron self-absorption (SSA) in a source of incoherent synchrotron radiation arising from relativistic particles with the canonical (i.e., power-law) energy distribution. We find that four out of the seven candidates have an inverted radio spectrum with a slope close to or exceeding +2.0, while the critical spectral slope $α_c$ is exceeded in at least one case. These sources, together with another one or two reported in very recent literature, may well be the archetypes of an extremely rare class, from the standpoint of violation of the SSA limit in compact extragalactic radio sources. However, the alternative possibility that free-free absorption is responsible for their ultra-sharp spectral turnover cannot yet be discounted. △ Less

Submitted 31 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS. Comments are welcome

Search for HI emission from superdisk candidates associated with radio galaxies

Authors: Abhijeet Anand, Nirupam Roy, Gopal-Krishna

Abstract: Giant gaseous layers (termed "superdisk") have been hypothesized in the past to account for the strip-like radio emission gap (or straight-edged central brightness depression) observed between the twin radio lobes, in over a dozen relatively nearby powerful Fanaroff-Riley Class II radio galaxies. They could also provide a plausible alternative explanation for a range of observations. Although a nu… ▽ More Giant gaseous layers (termed "superdisk") have been hypothesized in the past to account for the strip-like radio emission gap (or straight-edged central brightness depression) observed between the twin radio lobes, in over a dozen relatively nearby powerful Fanaroff-Riley Class II radio galaxies. They could also provide a plausible alternative explanation for a range of observations. Although a number of explanations have been proposed for the origin of the superdisks, little is known about their material content. Some X-ray observations of superdisk candidates indicate the presence of hot gas, but a cool dusty medium also seems to be common in them. If they are made of entirely or partly neutral gas, it may be directly detectable and we report here a first attempt to detect/image any neutral hydrogen gas present in the superdisks that are inferred to be present in four nearby radio galaxies. We have not found a positive HI signal in any of the four sources, resulting in tight upper limits on the HI number density in the postulated superdisks, estimated directly from the central rms noise values of the final radio continuum subtracted image. The estimated ranges of the upper limit on neutral hydrogen number density and column density are $10^{-4}-10^{-3}$ atoms per cm$^3$ and $10^{19}-10^{20}$ atoms per cm$^{2}$, respectively. No positive HI signal is detected even after combining all the four available HI images (with inverse variance weighting). This clearly rules out an HI dominated superdisk as a viable model to explain these structures, however, the possibility of superdisk being made of warm/hot gas still remains open. △ Less

Submitted 17 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Comments: 9 pages, 4 figures, 2 Tables. Accepted for publication in Research in Astronomy and Astrophysics (RAA)

Journal ref: 2019, Res. Astron. Astrophys., 19, 83

Intra-Night Optical monitoring of three γ-ray detected Narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies

Authors: Vineet Ojha, Gopal-Krishna, Hum Chand

Abstract: For 3 radio-loud $γ$-ray detected Narrow-Line Seyfert 1 ($γ$-ray NLSy1) galaxies, we report optical variability on intra-night and/or week-like time scales, based on five $\geq$ 3 hours long monitoring sessions for each galaxy. The radio-loudness factors (R$_{1.4 GHz}$) for these galaxies, namely 1H 0323$+$342 (z = 0.0629), PKS J1222$+$0413 (z = 0.966) and PKS J1505$+$0326 (z = 0.408) are $\sim$31… ▽ More For 3 radio-loud $γ$-ray detected Narrow-Line Seyfert 1 ($γ$-ray NLSy1) galaxies, we report optical variability on intra-night and/or week-like time scales, based on five $\geq$ 3 hours long monitoring sessions for each galaxy. The radio-loudness factors (R$_{1.4 GHz}$) for these galaxies, namely 1H 0323$+$342 (z = 0.0629), PKS J1222$+$0413 (z = 0.966) and PKS J1505$+$0326 (z = 0.408) are $\sim$318, $\sim$1534 and $\sim$3364 at 1.4 GHz, respectively. For the most distant $γ$-ray NLSy1, PKS J1222$+$0413, Intra-Night Optical Variability (INOV) characterisation is presented for the first time. The blazar-like behaviour of the nearest $γ$-ray NLSy1 1H 0323$+$342, which showed strong INOV on 4 of the 5 nights, was unexpected in view of its recent reclassification as `radio intermediate' (R$_{5 GHz}$ $\lesssim$ 25). Its particularly violent INOV is manifested by two optical outbursts lasting $\sim$ 1 hour, whose rapid brightening phase is shown to imply a doubling time of $\sim$ 1 hour for the optical synchrotron flux, after (conservatively) deducting the thermal optical emission contributed by the host galaxy and the Seyfert nucleus. A more realistic `decontamination' could well reduce substantially the flux doubling time, bringing it still closer in rapidity to the ultra-fast VHE ($>$ 100 GeV) flares reported for the blazars PKS 1222$+$216 and PKS 2155$-$304. A large contamination by thermal optical emission may, in fact, be common for NLSy1s as they are high Eddington rate accretors. The present study further suggests that superluminal motion in the radio jet could be a robust diagnostic of INOV. △ Less

Submitted 26 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS. 14 pages, 3 figures

Determining the composition of radio plasma via circular polarization: the prospects of the Cygnus A hot spots

Authors: Torsten A. Enßlin, Sebastian Hutschenreuter, Gopal-Krishna

Abstract: The composition of the relativistic plasma produced in active galactic nuclei and ejected via powerful jets into the interstellar/intergalactic medium is still a major unsettled issue. It might be a positron-electron plasma in case the plasma was created by pair production in the intense photon fields near accreting super-massive black holes. Alternatively, it might be an electron-proton plasma in… ▽ More The composition of the relativistic plasma produced in active galactic nuclei and ejected via powerful jets into the interstellar/intergalactic medium is still a major unsettled issue. It might be a positron-electron plasma in case the plasma was created by pair production in the intense photon fields near accreting super-massive black holes. Alternatively, it might be an electron-proton plasma in case magnetic fields lift and accelerate the thermal gas of accretion discs into relativistic jets as the recent detection of $γ$-rays from blazars indicates. Despite various attempts to unambiguously establish the composition of the relativistic jets, this remains a major unknown. Here, we propose a way to settle the question via sensitive measurements of circular polarization (CP) in the radio emission of the hot spots of bright radio galaxies like Cygnus A. The CP of synchrotron emission is determined by the circular motions of the radiating relativistic leptons. In case of charge symmetric energy spectra of a electron-positron plasma, it should be exactly zero. In case of an electron-proton plasma the electrons imprint their gyration onto the CP and we expect the hot spots of Cygnus A to exhibit a fractional CP at a level of $10^{-3}\,(ν/\mbox{GHz})^{-{1}/{2}}$, which is challenging to measure, but not completely unfeasible. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2019; v1 submitted 21 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: 6 pages, no figures, accepted by JCAP, erratum with respect to accepted version applied, numerical corrections leading to a stronger effect

Towards building a first northern-sky sample of 'Extremely Inverted Spectrum Extragalactic Radio Sources (EISERS)'

Authors: Mukul Mhaskey, Gopal-Krishna, Surajit Paul

Abstract: We present here an extension of our search for EISERS (Extremely Inverted Spectrum Extragalactic Radio Sources) to the northern hemisphere. With an inverted radio spectrum of slope $α$ $>$ + 2.5, these rare sources would either require a non-standard particle acceleration mechanism (in the framework of synchrotron self-absorption hypothesis), or a severe free-free absorption which attenuates pract… ▽ More We present here an extension of our search for EISERS (Extremely Inverted Spectrum Extragalactic Radio Sources) to the northern hemisphere. With an inverted radio spectrum of slope $α$ $>$ + 2.5, these rare sources would either require a non-standard particle acceleration mechanism (in the framework of synchrotron self-absorption hypothesis), or a severe free-free absorption which attenuates practically all of their synchrotron radiation at metre wavelengths. A list of 15 EISERS candidates is presented here. It was assembled by applying a sequence of selection filters, starting with the two available large-sky radio surveys, namely the WENSS (325 MHz) and the ADR-TGSS (150 MHz). These surveys offer the twin advantages of being fairly deep (typical rms $<$ 10 mJy/beam) and having a sub-arcminute resolution. Their zone of overlap spreads over 1.3$π$ steradian in the northern hemisphere. Radio spectra are presented for the entire sample of 15 EISERS candidates, of which 8 spectra are of GPS type. Eleven members of the sample are associated with previously known quasars. Information on the parsec-scale radio structure, available for several of these sources, is also summarized. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Polarimetric and spectroscopic study of radio-quiet weak emission line quasars

Authors: Parveen Kumar, H. Chand, R. Srianand, C. S. Stalin, P. Petitjean, Gopal-Krishna

Abstract: A small subset of optically selected radio-quiet quasars showing weak or no emission lines may turn out to be the elusive radio-quiet BL Lac objects, or simply be radio-quiet QSOs with a still-forming/shielded broad line region (BLR). High polarisation ($p$ $>$ 3$-$4$\%$), a hallmark of BL Lacs, can be used to test whether some optically selected `radio-quiet weak emission line quasars' (RQWLQs) s… ▽ More A small subset of optically selected radio-quiet quasars showing weak or no emission lines may turn out to be the elusive radio-quiet BL Lac objects, or simply be radio-quiet QSOs with a still-forming/shielded broad line region (BLR). High polarisation ($p$ $>$ 3$-$4$\%$), a hallmark of BL Lacs, can be used to test whether some optically selected `radio-quiet weak emission line quasars' (RQWLQs) show a fractional polarisation high enough to qualify as radio-quiet analogs of BL Lac objects. Out of the observed six RQWLQs candidates showing an insignificant proper motion, only two are found to have $p$ $>$ 1$\%$. For these two RQWLQs, namely J142505.59$+$035336.2, J154515.77+003235.2, we found polarisation of 1.03$\pm$0.36$\%$, 1.59$\pm$0.53$\%$ respectively, which again is too modest to justify a (radio-quiet) BL Lac classification. We also present here a statistical comparison of the optical spectral index, for a set of 40 RQWLQs with redshift-luminosity matched control sample of 800 QSOs and an equivalent sample of 120 blazars. The spectral index distribution of RQWLQs is found to differ, at a high significance level, from that of blazars and is consistent with that of the ordinary QSOs. Likewise, a structure-function analysis of photometric light curves presented here suggests that the mechanism driving optical variability in RQWLQs is similar to that operating in QSOs and different from that of blazars. These findings are consistent with the common view that the central engine in RQWLQs, as a population, is akin to that operating in normal QSOs and the primary differences between them might be related to differences in the BLR. △ Less

Submitted 2 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: 9 pages, 5 figures, Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Optical monitoring of Active Galactic Nuclei from ARIES

Authors: Gopal-Krishna, Paul J. Wiita

Abstract: This overview provides a historical perspective highlighting the pioneering role which the fairly modest observational facilities of ARIES have played since the 1990s in systematically characterizing the optical variability on hour-like time scale (intra-night optical variability, or INOV) of several major types of high-luminosity Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN). Such information was previously avail… ▽ More This overview provides a historical perspective highlighting the pioneering role which the fairly modest observational facilities of ARIES have played since the 1990s in systematically characterizing the optical variability on hour-like time scale (intra-night optical variability, or INOV) of several major types of high-luminosity Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN). Such information was previously available only for blazars. Similar studies have since been initiated in at least a dozen countries, giving a boost to AGN variability research. Our work has, in particular, provided strong indication that mild INOV occurs in radio-quiet QSOs (amplitude up to $\sim 3-5\%$ and duty cycle $\sim 10\%$) and, moreover, has demonstrated that similarly mild INOV is exhibited even by the vast majority of radio-loud quasars which possess powerful relativistic jets (even including many that are beamed towards us). The solitary outliers are blazars, the tiny strongly polarized subset of powerful AGN, which frequently exhibit a pronounced INOV. Among the blazars, BL Lac objects often show a bluer-when-brighter chromatic behavior, while the flat spectrum radio quasars seem not to. Quantifying any differences of INOV among the major subclasses of non-blazar type AGNs will require dedicated monitoring programs using $2-3$ metre class telescopes. △ Less

Submitted 14 November, 2017; originally announced November 2017.

Comments: 10 pages, 1 figure, to appear in proceedings of the First Belgo-Indian Network for Astronomy & Astrophysics (BINA) Workshop

On the incidence of MgII absorbers along the blazar sightlines

Authors: S. Mishra, H. Chand, Gopal-Krishna, R. Joshi, Y. A. Shchekinov, T. A. Fatkhullin

Abstract: It is widely believed that the cool gas clouds traced by MgII absorption, within a velocity offset of 5000 km/s relative to the background quasar are mostly associated with the quasar itself, whereas the absorbers seen at larger velocity offsets towards us are intervening absorber systems and hence their existence is completely independent of the background quasar. Recent evidence by Bergeron et a… ▽ More It is widely believed that the cool gas clouds traced by MgII absorption, within a velocity offset of 5000 km/s relative to the background quasar are mostly associated with the quasar itself, whereas the absorbers seen at larger velocity offsets towards us are intervening absorber systems and hence their existence is completely independent of the background quasar. Recent evidence by Bergeron et al. (2011, hereinafter BBM) has seriously questioned this paradigm, by showing that the number density of intervening MgII absorbers towards the 45 blazars in their sample is nearly 2 times the expectation based on the MgII absorption systems seen towards normal QSOs. Given its serious implications, it becomes important to revisit this finding, by enlarging the blazar sample and subjecting it to an independent analysis. Here, we first report the outcome of our re-analysis of the available spectroscopic data for the BBM sample itself. Our analysis of the BBM sample reproduces their claimed factor of 2 excess of dN/dz along blazar sightlines, vis-a-vis normal QSOs. We have also assembled a ~3 times larger sample of blazars, albeit with moderately sensitive optical spectra. Using this sample together with the BBM sample, our analysis shows that the dN/dz of the MgII absorbers statistically matches that known for normal QSO sightlines. Further, the analysis indicates that associated absorbers might be contributing significantly to the estimated dN/dz upto offset speeds Δv ~0.2c relative to the blazar. △ Less

Submitted 11 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 12 pages, 6 figures, 7 tables, accepted for publication in MNRAS

Stochastic modeling of multiwavelength variability of the classical BL Lac object OJ 287 on timescales ranging from decades to hours

Authors: A. Goyal, L. Stawarz, S. Zola, V. Marchenko, M. Soida, K. Nilsson, S. Ciprini, A. Baran, M. Ostrowski, P. J. Wiita, Gopal-Krishna, A. Siemiginowska, M. Sobolewska, S. Jorstad, A. Marscher, M. F. Aller H. D. Aller T. Hovatta, D. B. Caton, D. Reichart, K. Matsumoto, K. Sadakane, K. Gazeas, M. Kidger, V. Piirola, H. Jermak, F. Alicavus , et al. (87 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We present the results of our power spectral density analysis for the BL Lac object OJ\,287, utilizing the {\it Fermi}-LAT survey at high-energy $γ$-rays, {\it Swift}-XRT in X-rays, several ground-based telescopes and the {\it Kepler} satellite in the optical, and radio telescopes at GHz frequencies. The light curves are modeled in terms of continuous-time auto-regressive moving average (CARMA) pr… ▽ More We present the results of our power spectral density analysis for the BL Lac object OJ\,287, utilizing the {\it Fermi}-LAT survey at high-energy $γ$-rays, {\it Swift}-XRT in X-rays, several ground-based telescopes and the {\it Kepler} satellite in the optical, and radio telescopes at GHz frequencies. The light curves are modeled in terms of continuous-time auto-regressive moving average (CARMA) processes. Owing to the inclusion of the {\it Kepler} data, we were able to construct \emph{for the first time} the optical variability power spectrum of a blazar without any gaps across $\sim6$ dex in temporal frequencies. Our analysis reveals that the radio power spectra are of a colored-noise type on timescales ranging from tens of years down to months, with no evidence for breaks or other spectral features. The overall optical power spectrum is also consistent with a colored noise on the variability timescales ranging from 117 years down to hours, with no hints of any quasi-periodic oscillations. The X-ray power spectrum resembles the radio and optical power spectra on the analogous timescales ranging from tens of years down to months. Finally, the $γ$-ray power spectrum is noticeably different from the radio, optical, and X-ray power spectra of the source: we have detected a characteristic relaxation timescale in the {\it Fermi}-LAT data, corresponding to $\sim 150$\,days, such that on timescales longer than this, the power spectrum is consistent with uncorrelated (white) noise, while on shorter variability timescales there is correlated (colored) noise. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2018; v1 submitted 13 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Comments: ApJ accepted

Multi-epoch intra-night optical monitoring of 8 radio-quiet BL Lac candidates

Authors: P. Kumar, Gopal-Krishna, C. S. Stalin, H. Chand, R. Srianand, P. Petitjean

Abstract: For a new sample of 8 weak-line-quasars (WLQs) we report a sensitive search in 20 intranight monitoring sessions, for blazar-like optical flux variations on hour-like and longer time scale (day/month/year$-$like). The sample consists exclusively of the WLQs that are not radio$-$loud and have either been classified as `radio-weak probable BL Lac candidates' and/or are known to have exhibited at lea… ▽ More For a new sample of 8 weak-line-quasars (WLQs) we report a sensitive search in 20 intranight monitoring sessions, for blazar-like optical flux variations on hour-like and longer time scale (day/month/year$-$like). The sample consists exclusively of the WLQs that are not radio$-$loud and have either been classified as `radio-weak probable BL Lac candidates' and/or are known to have exhibited at least one episode of large, blazar$-$like optical variability. Whereas only a hint of intra$-$night variability is seen for two of these WLQs, J104833.5$+$620305.0(z = 0.219) and J133219.6$+$622715.9 (z = 3.15), statistically significant inter$-$night variability at a few per cent level is detected for three of the sources, including the radio-intermediate WLQ J133219.6$+$622715.9 (z = 3.15) and the well known bona$-$fide radio$-$quiet WLQs J121221.5$+$534128.0 (z = 3.10) and WLQ J153259.9$-$003944.1 (z = 4.62). In the rest$-$frame, this variability is intra-day and in the far$-$UV band. On the time scale of a decade, we find for three of the WLQs large brightness changes, amounting to 1.655$\pm$0.009, 0.163$\pm$0.010 and 0.144$\pm$0.018 mag, for J104833.5$+$620305.0, J123743.1$+$630144.9 and J232428.4$+$144324.4, respectively. Whereas the latter two are confirmed radio-quiet WLQs, the extragalactic nature of J104833.5$+$620305.0 remains to be well established, thanks to the absence of any feature(s) in its available optical spectra. The present study forms a part of our ongoing campaign of intranight optical monitoring of radio quiet weak-line quasars, in order to improve the understanding of this enigmatic class of Active Galactic Nuclei and to look among them for a possible tiny, elusive population of radio-quiet BL Lacs. △ Less

Submitted 8 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: Accepted to MNRAS. 12 pages, 1 figure, 4 Table

Multi-wavelength variability study of the classical BL Lac object PKS 0735+178 on timescales ranging from decades to minutes

Authors: Arti Goyal, Lukasz Stawarz, Michal Ostrowski, Valeri Larionov, Gopal-Krishna, Paul J. Wiita, Santosh Joshi, Marian Soida, Ivan Agudo

Abstract: We present the results of our power spectral analysis for the BL Lac object PKS 0735+178 utilizing the Fermi-LAT survey at high-energy $γ$-rays, several ground-based optical telescopes, and single-dish radio telescopes operating at GHz frequencies. The novelty of our approach is that, by combining long-term and densely sampled intra-night light curves in the optical regime, we were able to constru… ▽ More We present the results of our power spectral analysis for the BL Lac object PKS 0735+178 utilizing the Fermi-LAT survey at high-energy $γ$-rays, several ground-based optical telescopes, and single-dish radio telescopes operating at GHz frequencies. The novelty of our approach is that, by combining long-term and densely sampled intra-night light curves in the optical regime, we were able to construct for the first time the optical power spectrum of the blazar for a time domain extending from 23 years down to minutes. Our analysis reveals that: (i) the optical variability is consistent with a pure red noise, for which the power spectral density can well be approximated by a single power-law throughout the entire time domain probed; (ii) the slope of power spectral density at high-energy $γ$-rays ($\sim 1$), is significantly flatter than that found at radio and optical frequencies ($\sim 2$) within the corresponding time variability range; (iii) for the derived power spectra we did not detect any low-frequency flattening, nor do we see any evidence for cut-offs at the highest frequencies down to the noise floor levels due to measurement uncertainties. We interpret our findings in terms of a model where the blazar variability is generated by the underlying single stochastic process (at radio and optical frequencies), or a linear superposition of such processes (in the $γ$-ray regime). Along with the detailed PSD analysis, we also present the results of our extended (1998-2015) intra-night optical monitoring program and newly acquired optical photo-polarimetric data for the source. △ Less

Submitted 5 March, 2017; v1 submitted 8 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: The Astrophysical Journal, in press

Intranight Optical Variability of Radio-Quiet Weak Emission Line Quasars-IV

Authors: Parveen Kumar, Hum Chand, Gopal-Krishna

Abstract: We report an extension of our program to search for radio-quiet BL Lac candidates using intra-night optical variability (INOV) as a probe. The present INOV observations cover a well-defined representative set of 10 `radio-quiet weak-emission-line quasars' (RQWLQs), selected from a newly published sample of 46 such sources, derived from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (Data release 7). Intra-night CCD… ▽ More We report an extension of our program to search for radio-quiet BL Lac candidates using intra-night optical variability (INOV) as a probe. The present INOV observations cover a well-defined representative set of 10 `radio-quiet weak-emission-line quasars' (RQWLQs), selected from a newly published sample of 46 such sources, derived from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (Data release 7). Intra-night CCD monitoring of the 10 RQWLQs was carried out in 18 sessions lasting at least 3.5 hours. For each session, differential light curves (DLCs) of the target RQWLQ were derived relative to two steady comparison stars monitored simultaneously. Combining these new data with those already published by us for 15 RQWLQs monitored in 30 sessions, we estimate an INOV duty cycle of $\sim 3\%$ for the RQWLQs, which appears inconsistent with BL Lacs. However, the observed INOV events (which occurred in just two of the sessions) are strong (with a fractional variability amplitude $ψ>$ 10\%), hence blazar-like. We briefly point out the prospects of an appreciable rise in the estimated INOV duty cycle for RQWLQs with a relatively modest increase in sensitivity for monitoring these rather faint objects. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

Comments: 8 pages, 2 figures, accepted in MNRAS

Intranight Optical Variability of Radio-Quiet Weak Emission Line Quasars-III

Authors: Parveen Kumar, Gopal-Krishna, Hum Chand

Abstract: This is continuation of our programme to search for the elusive radio-quiet BL Lacs, by carrying out a systematic search for intranight optical variability (INOV) in a subset of `weak-line quasars' which are already designated as `high-confidence BL Lac candidate' and are also known to be radio-quiet. For 6 such radio-quiet weak-line quasars (RQWLQs), we present here new INOV observations taken in… ▽ More This is continuation of our programme to search for the elusive radio-quiet BL Lacs, by carrying out a systematic search for intranight optical variability (INOV) in a subset of `weak-line quasars' which are already designated as `high-confidence BL Lac candidate' and are also known to be radio-quiet. For 6 such radio-quiet weak-line quasars (RQWLQs), we present here new INOV observations taken in 11 sessions of duration >3 hours each. Combining these data with our previously published INOV monitoring of RQWLQs in 19 sessions yields INOV observations for a set of 15 RQWLQs monitored in 30 sessions, each lasting more than 3 hours. The 30 differential light curves, thus obtained for the 15 RQWLQs, were subjected to a statistical analysis using the F-test, and the deduced INOV characteristics of the RQWLQs then compared with those published recently for several prominent AGN classes, also applying the F-test. From our existing INOV observations, there is a hint that RQWLQs in our sample show a significantly higher INOV duty cycle than radio-quiet quasars and radio lobe-dominated quasars. Two sessions when we have detected strong (blazar-like) INOV for RQWLQs are pointed out, and these two RQWLQs are therefore the best known candidates for radio-quiet BL Lacs, deserving to be pursued. For a proper comparison with the INOV properties already established for (brighter) members of several prominent classes of AGN, a factor of 2-3 improvement in the INOV detection threshold for the RQWLQs is needed and it would be very interesting to check if that would yield a significantly higher estimate for INOV duty cycle than is found here. △ Less

Submitted 9 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: 9 pages, 1 figure and 4 tables, accepted for publication in MNRAS main journal. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1212.5384, arXiv:1403.7440

Extragalactic radio sources with sharply inverted spectrum at metre wavelengths

Authors: Gopal-Krishna, S. K. Sirothia, Mukul Mhaskey, Pritesh Ranadive, Paul J. Wiita, A. Goyal, N. G. Kantharia, C. H. Ishwara-Chandra

Abstract: We present the first results of a systematic search for the rare extragalactic radio sources showing an inverted (integrated) spectrum, with spectral index $α\ge +2.0$, a previously unexplored spectral domain. The search is expected to yield strong candidates for $α\ge +2.5$, for which the standard synchrotron self-absorption (characterized by a single power-law energy distribution of relativistic… ▽ More We present the first results of a systematic search for the rare extragalactic radio sources showing an inverted (integrated) spectrum, with spectral index $α\ge +2.0$, a previously unexplored spectral domain. The search is expected to yield strong candidates for $α\ge +2.5$, for which the standard synchrotron self-absorption (characterized by a single power-law energy distribution of relativistic electron population) would not be a plausible explanation, even in an ideal case of a perfectly homogeneous source of incoherent synchrotron radiation. Such sharply inverted spectra, if found, would require alternative explanations, e.g., free-free absorption, or non-standard energy distribution of relativistic electrons which differs from a power-law (e.g., Maxwellian). The search was carried out by comparing two sensitive low-frequency radio surveys made with sub-arcminute resolution, namely, the WISH survey at 352 MHz and TGSS/DR5 at 150 MHz. The overlap region between these two surveys contains 7056 WISH sources classified as `single' and brighter than 100 mJy at 352 MHz. We focus here on the seven of these sources for which we find $α> +2.0$. Two of these are undetected at 150 MHz and are particularly good candidates for $α> +2.5$. Five of the seven sources exhibit a `Gigahertz-Peaked-Spectrum' (GPS). △ Less

Submitted 16 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: 8 pages, 2 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

Mega parsec relativistic jets launched from an accreting supermassive blackhole in an extreme spiral galaxy

Authors: Joydeep Bagchi, Vivek M., Vinu Vikram, Ananda Hota, Biju K. G., S. K. Sirothia, Raghunathan Srianand, Gopal-Krishna, Joe Jacob

Abstract: Radio galaxy phenomenon is directly connected to mass accreting, spinning supermassive black holes found in the active galactic nuclei (AGN). It is still unclear how the collimated jets of relativistic plasma on hundreds to thousands of kpc scale form, and why nearly always they are launched from the nuclei of bulge dominated elliptical galaxies and not flat spirals. Here we present the discovery… ▽ More Radio galaxy phenomenon is directly connected to mass accreting, spinning supermassive black holes found in the active galactic nuclei (AGN). It is still unclear how the collimated jets of relativistic plasma on hundreds to thousands of kpc scale form, and why nearly always they are launched from the nuclei of bulge dominated elliptical galaxies and not flat spirals. Here we present the discovery of giant radio source J2345-0449 (z=0.0755), a clear and extremely rare counter example where relativistic jets are ejected from a luminous and massive spiral galaxy on scale of ~1.6 Mpc, the largest known so far. Extreme physical properties observed for this bulgeless spiral host, such as its high optical and infra-red luminosity, large dynamical mass, rapid disk rotation, and episodic jet activity are possibly the results of its unusual formation history, which has also assembled, via gas accretion from a disk, its central black hole of mass >2 x 10^8 M_sun. The very high mid-IR luminosity of the galaxy suggests that it is actively forming stars and still building a massive disk. We argue that the launch of these powerful jets is facilitated by an advection dominated, magnetized accretion flow at low Eddington rate onto this unusually massive (for a bulgeless disk galaxy) and possibly fast-spinning central black hole. Therefore, J2345-0449 is an extremely rare, unusual galactic system whose properties challenge the standard paradigms for black hole growth and formation of relativistic jets in disk galaxies. Thus, it provides fundamental insight into accretion disk -- relativistic jet coupling processes. △ Less

Submitted 28 April, 2014; v1 submitted 28 April, 2014; originally announced April 2014.

Comments: To be published in Astrophysical Journal. Current version match with the revised draft after receiving referee's comments. Some minor problem with Figures corrected from the last version. About 30 pages, 3 tables and 9 figures

Intranight Optical Variability of Radio-Quiet Weak Emission Line Quasars-II

Authors: Hum Chand, Parveen Kumar, Gopal-Krishna

Abstract: This is continuation of our search for the elusive radio-quiet blazars, by carrying out a systematic programme to detect intranight optical variability (INOV) in a subset of `Weak-Lines-Quasars' (WLQs) which are designated as `high confidence BL Lac candidates' and are known to be radio-quiet. For 10 such RQWLQs, we present here the INOV observations taken in 16 sessions of durations > 3.5 hours e… ▽ More This is continuation of our search for the elusive radio-quiet blazars, by carrying out a systematic programme to detect intranight optical variability (INOV) in a subset of `Weak-Lines-Quasars' (WLQs) which are designated as `high confidence BL Lac candidates' and are known to be radio-quiet. For 10 such RQWLQs, we present here the INOV observations taken in 16 sessions of durations > 3.5 hours each. Combining these data with our previously published INOV monitoring of RQWLQs in 13 sessions, gives a set of INOV observations of 15 RQWLQs monitored in 29 sessions each lasting more than 3.5 hours. The 29 differential light curves (DLCs), thus obtained for the 15 RQWLQs, were subjected to an statistical analysis using the F-test and the deduced INOV characteristics of the RQWLQs are compared with those published recently for several prominent AGN classes, also using the F-test. However, since the RQWLQs are generally 1-2 magnitudes fainter, a rigorous comparison has to wait for somewhat more sensitive INOV observations than those presented here. Based on our existing INOV observations, it seems that RQWLQs in our sample show a significantly higher INOV duty cycle than radio-quiet quasars and radio lobe-dominated quasars. Two sessions when we detected rather strong (blazar-like) INOV for RQWLQs are pointed out and both these RQWLQs are therefore candidates for radio-quiet BL Lacs. △ Less

Submitted 28 March, 2014; originally announced March 2014.

Comments: 8 pages, 2 figures and 3 tables, accepted for publication in MNRAS main journal

Constraints on supermassive black hole spins from observations of active galaxy jets

Authors: E. Kun, P. J. Wiita, L. Á. Gergely, Z. Keresztes, Gopal-Krishna, P. L. Biermann

Abstract: We discuss the origin of the low-energy cutoff, or LEC, seen in the radio spectra of many extragalactic jets and relate this to the spin of the supermassive black holes that presumably power them. Pion decay via proton-proton collisions is a possible mechanism to supply a secondary positron population with a low energy limit. We expect that pion production would occur in advection dominated accret… ▽ More We discuss the origin of the low-energy cutoff, or LEC, seen in the radio spectra of many extragalactic jets and relate this to the spin of the supermassive black holes that presumably power them. Pion decay via proton-proton collisions is a possible mechanism to supply a secondary positron population with a low energy limit. We expect that pion production would occur in advection dominated accretion flows or ADAFs. In radiatively inefficient ADAFs the heat energy of the accreting gas is unable to radiate in less than the accretion time and the particle temperature could be high enough so that thermal protons can yield such pion production. Strong starbursts are another option for the injection of a truncated particle population into the jet. The role of both mechanisms is discussed with respect to the black hole spin estimate. The energy demanded to produce the pion decay process involves a minimum threshold for kinetic energy of the interacting protons. Therefore the mean proton speed in the flow can determine whether a LEC is generated. In ADAFs the random velocity of the protons can exceed the minimum speed limit of pion production around the jet launching region in the innermost part of the flow. Finally we summarize the additional work needed to put the model assumptions on a more rigorous basis. △ Less

Submitted 16 December, 2013; originally announced December 2013.

Journal ref: Astronomical Notes (Astronomische Nachrichten) 334, 1024-1027 (2013)

Supermassive black hole mergers as dual sources for electromagnetic flares in the jet emission and gravitational waves

Authors: M. Tápai, L. Á. Gergely, Z. Keresztes, P. J. Wiita, Gopal-Krishna, P. L. Biermann

Abstract: We present a new type of observation relating the gravitational wave emission of supermassive black hole mergers to their electromagnetic counterparts. This dual emission involves variability of a relativistic jet arising from the spin-orbit precession of the supermassive black hole binary at its base. We present a new type of observation relating the gravitational wave emission of supermassive black hole mergers to their electromagnetic counterparts. This dual emission involves variability of a relativistic jet arising from the spin-orbit precession of the supermassive black hole binary at its base. △ Less

Submitted 7 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: to appear in Astronomical Notes (Astronomische Nachrichten), issue 9, 2013

Journal ref: Astronomical Notes (Astronomische Nachrichten) 334, 1032-1035 (2013)

Improved characterisation of intra-night optical variability of prominent AGN classes

Authors: Arti Goyal, Gopal-Krishna, Paul J. Wiita, C. S. Stalin, Ram Sagar

Abstract: The incidence of intra-night optical variability (INOV) is known to to differ significantly among different classes of powerful active galactic nuclei (AGN). A number of statistical methods have been employed in the literature for testing the presence of INOV in the light curves, sometimes leading to discordant results. In this paper we compare the INOV characteristics of six prominent classes of… ▽ More The incidence of intra-night optical variability (INOV) is known to to differ significantly among different classes of powerful active galactic nuclei (AGN). A number of statistical methods have been employed in the literature for testing the presence of INOV in the light curves, sometimes leading to discordant results. In this paper we compare the INOV characteristics of six prominent classes of AGN, as evaluated using three commonly used statistical tests, namely the $χ^2-$test, the modified $C-$test and the $F-$test, which has recently begun to gain popularity. The AGN classes considered are: radio-quiet quasars (RQQs), radio-intermediate quasars (RIQs), lobe-dominated quasars (LDQs), low optical polarization core-dominated quasars (LPCDQs), high optical polarization core-dominated quasars (HPCDQs), and TeV blazars. Our analysis is based on a large body of AGN monitoring data, involving 262 sessions of intra-night monitoring of a total 77 AGN, using 1-2 metre class optical telescopes located in India. In order to compare the usefulness of the statistical tests, we have also subjected them to a `sanity check' by comparing the number of false positives yielded by each test with the corresponding statistical prediction. The present analysis is intended to serve as a benchmark for future INOV studies of AGN of different classes. △ Less

Submitted 22 July, 2013; originally announced July 2013.

Comments: 26 pages, 2 tables, Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Incidence of Strong MgII Absorbers Towards Different Types of Quasars

Authors: Ravi Joshi, Hum Chand, Gopal-Krishna

Abstract: We report the first comparative study of strong MgII absorbers seen towards radio-loud quasars of core-dominated (CDQs) and lobe-dominated (LDQs) types and normal QSOs. The MgII associated absorption systems having a velocity offset v < 5000km/s from the systemic velocity of the background quasar were also excluded. Existing spectroscopic data for redshift-matched sightlines of 3975 CDQs and 1583… ▽ More We report the first comparative study of strong MgII absorbers seen towards radio-loud quasars of core-dominated (CDQs) and lobe-dominated (LDQs) types and normal QSOs. The MgII associated absorption systems having a velocity offset v < 5000km/s from the systemic velocity of the background quasar were also excluded. Existing spectroscopic data for redshift-matched sightlines of 3975 CDQs and 1583 LDQs, covering a emission redshift range 0.39-4.87, were analysed and 864 strong MgII absorbers were found, covering the redshift range 0.45-2.17. The conclusions reached using this well-defined large dataset of strong MgII absorbers are: (i) The number density, dN/dz, towards CDQs shows a small, marginally significant excess over the estimate available for QSOs; (ii) In the redshift space, this difference is reflected in terms of a 1.6sigma excess of dN/dz over the QSOs, within the narrow redshift interval 1.2-1.8; (iii) The dN/dbeta distribution (with beta=v/c) for CDQs shows a significant excess over the distribution found for a redshift and luminosity matched sample of QSOs, at beta in the range 0.05-0.1. This leads us to infer that a significant fraction of strong MgII absorption systems seen in this offset velocity range are probably associated with the CDQs and might be accelerated into the line of sight by their powerful jets and/or due to the accretion-disk outflows close to our direction. Support to this scenario comes from a consistency check in which we only consider the spectral range corresponding to beta > 0.2. The computed redshift distribution for strong MgII absorbers towards CDQs now shows excellent agreement with that known for QSOs, as indeed is expected for purely intervening absorption systems. Thus, it appears that for CDQs the associated strong MgII absorbers can be seen at much larger velocities relative to the nucleus than the commonly adopted upper limit of 5000km/s. △ Less

Submitted 15 July, 2013; originally announced July 2013.

Comments: 9 Pages, 6 Figures, 1 Table, Accepted for the publication in MNRAS main-journal