-
Age uncertainties of red giants due to cumulative rotational mixing of progenitors calibrated by asteroseismology
Authors:
D. J. Fritzewski,
C. Aerts,
J. S. G. Mombarg,
S. Gossage,
T. Van Reeth
Abstract:
Galactic archaeology largely relies on precise ages of distant evolved stars in the Milky Way. Nowadays, asteroseismology can deliver ages for many red giants observed with high-cadence, high-precision photometric space missions. Our aim is to quantify age uncertainties of slowly-rotating red giants due to the cumulative effect of their fast rotation during core-hydrogen burning. Their rotation in…
▽ More
Galactic archaeology largely relies on precise ages of distant evolved stars in the Milky Way. Nowadays, asteroseismology can deliver ages for many red giants observed with high-cadence, high-precision photometric space missions. Our aim is to quantify age uncertainties of slowly-rotating red giants due to the cumulative effect of their fast rotation during core-hydrogen burning. Their rotation in earlier evolutionary phases caused mixing resulting in heavier helium cores and the prolongation of their main sequence. These rotational effects are usually ignored when age-dating red giants, despite our knowledge of fast rotation for stars with $M\ge1.3\,$M$_\odot$. We use a sample of 490 $γ$ Doradus pulsators with precise asteroseismic estimates of their internal rotation rate and with luminosity estimates from Gaia. For this sample, which includes stars rotating from nearly 0 to about 60% of the critical rate, we compute the cumulative effect on the age in their post-main sequence evolution caused by rotational mixing on the main sequence. We use stellar model grids with different physical prescriptions mimicking rotational mixing to assess systematic uncertainties on the age. With respect to non-rotating models, the sample of 490 stars, as red giant progenitors, reveals age differences up to 5% by the time they start hydrogen-shell burning when relying on the theory of rotationally induced diffusive mixing as included in the MIST isochrones. Using rotational mixing based on an advective-diffusive approach including meridional circulation leads to an age shift of 20% by the time of the TRGB. Age-dating of red giants is affected by the cumulative effect of rotational mixing during the main sequence. Such rotationally-induced age shifts should be taken into account in addition to other effects if the aim is to perform Galactic archaeological studies at the highest precision. (abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Asteroseismology of the young open cluster NGC 2516 I: Photometric and spectroscopic observations
Authors:
Gang Li,
Conny Aerts,
Timothy R. Bedding,
Dario J. Fritzewski,
Simon J. Murphy,
Timothy Van Reeth,
Benjamin T. Montet,
Mingjie Jian,
Joey S. G. Mombarg,
Seth Gossage,
K. R. Sreenivas
Abstract:
Asteroseismic modelling of isolated star presents significant challenges due to the difficulty in accurately determining stellar parameters, particularly the stellar age. These challenges can be overcomed by observing stars in open clusters, whose coeval members share an initial chemical composition. The light curves by TESS allow us to investigate and analyse stellar variations in clusters with a…
▽ More
Asteroseismic modelling of isolated star presents significant challenges due to the difficulty in accurately determining stellar parameters, particularly the stellar age. These challenges can be overcomed by observing stars in open clusters, whose coeval members share an initial chemical composition. The light curves by TESS allow us to investigate and analyse stellar variations in clusters with an unprecedented level. We aim to detect gravity-mode oscillations in the early-type main-sequence members of the young open cluster NGC 2516. We selected the 301 member stars as our sample and analysed the TESS FFI light curves. We also collected high-resolution spectra using the FEROS for the g-mode pulsators. By fitting the theoretical isochrones to the colour-magnitude diagram (CMD) of a cluster, we determined an age of 102 $\pm$ 15 Myr and inferred the extinction at 550 nm ($A_0$) is 0.53 $\pm$ 0.04 mag. We identified 147 stars with surface brightness modulations, 24 with g-mode pulsations ($γ$ Doradus or Slowly Pulsating B stars), and 35 with p-mode pulsations ($δ$ Sct stars). When sorted by colour index, the amplitude spectra of the $δ$ Sct stars show a distinct ordering and reveal a discernible frequency-temperature relationship. The near-core rotation rates, measured from period spacing patterns in two SPB and nine $γ$ Dor stars, reach up to 3/d . This is at the high end of the values found from Kepler data of field stars of similar variability type. The $γ$ Dor stars have internal rotation rates as high as 50% of their critical value, whereas the SPB stars exhibit rotation rates close to their critical rate. We did not find long-term brightness and colour variations in the mid-infrared, which suggests that there are no disk or shell formation events in our sample. We also discussed the results of our spectroscopic observations for the g-mode pulsators.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2024; v1 submitted 28 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Age-dating the young open cluster UBC 1 with g-mode asteroseismology, gyrochronology, and isochrone fitting
Authors:
D. J. Fritzewski,
T. Van Reeth,
C. Aerts,
J. Van Beeck,
S. Gossage,
G. Li
Abstract:
UBC 1 is an open cluster discovered in Gaia data and located near the edge of the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite's (TESS) continuous viewing zone. We aim to provide age constraints for this poorly studied open cluster from the combination of gravity-mode (g-mode) asteroseismology, gyrochronology, and isochrone fitting. We established the members of UBC 1 from a spatial-kinematic filtering a…
▽ More
UBC 1 is an open cluster discovered in Gaia data and located near the edge of the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite's (TESS) continuous viewing zone. We aim to provide age constraints for this poorly studied open cluster from the combination of gravity-mode (g-mode) asteroseismology, gyrochronology, and isochrone fitting. We established the members of UBC 1 from a spatial-kinematic filtering and estimate the cluster age and its parameters. Firstly, we fitted rotating isochrones to the single star cluster sequence. Secondly, using TESS time-series photometry, we explored the variability of the upper main sequence members and identified potential g-mode pulsators. For one star, we found a clear period spacing pattern that we used to deduce the buoyancy travel time, the near-core rotation rate, and an asteroseismic age. For a third independent age estimate, we employed the rotation periods of low-mass members of UBC 1. Based on isochrone fitting, we find $\log t = 8.1\pm0.4$, where the large uncertainty occurs because UBC 1 does not host evolved stars. From asteroseismology of one g-mode pulsator, we find a constrained age of $\log t= 8.24^{+0.43}_{-0.14}$. From gyrochronology based on 17 cool star cluster members, we estimate $\log t = 8.35^{+0.16}_{-0.25}$. Combined, all three methods lead to a consistent age in the range of 150-300 Myr. Our results show that even a single cluster member with identified g modes can improve age-dating of young open clusters. Combining gyrochronology of low-mass members with asteroseismology of intermediate-mass members is a powerful tool for young open cluster modelling, including high-precision age-dating.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
A rotational age for the open cluster NGC 2281
Authors:
D. J. Fritzewski,
S. A. Barnes,
J. Weingrill,
T. Granzer,
E. Cole-Kodikara,
K. G. Strassmeier
Abstract:
Cool star rotation periods have become an important tool in determining ages of open clusters. We aim to estimate the age of the open cluster NGC 2281 based on the rotational properties of its low-mass members. Previous age estimates for this open cluster range from 275 Myr to 630 Myr. Based on an eight month-long photometric time series obtained at the 1.2 m robotic STELLA telescope in Tenerife,…
▽ More
Cool star rotation periods have become an important tool in determining ages of open clusters. We aim to estimate the age of the open cluster NGC 2281 based on the rotational properties of its low-mass members. Previous age estimates for this open cluster range from 275 Myr to 630 Myr. Based on an eight month-long photometric time series obtained at the 1.2 m robotic STELLA telescope in Tenerife, we measured rotation periods for 126 cool star members (70% of the observed members) of NGC 2281. The large set of rotation periods allows us to construct a rich colour-period diagram for NGC 2281 with very few outliers above the slow rotator sequence. We identify an evolved fast rotator sequence which can be used to accurately age date the open cluster relative to other open clusters. Comparisons with M37 and M48 show that all three open clusters are roughly coeval, and we estimate the age of NGC 2281 to be $435\pm50$ Myr. Through comparisons with the younger NGC 3532 and the older Praesepe, we determine the spin down rates of mid-K and early-M fast rotators to be significantly lower than for early-K stars. We suspect that the spin down of early-K fast rotators might be governed by an additional mass dependence. Finally, we show the path towards an empirical description of the evolved fast rotator sequences in open clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
A detailed understanding of the rotation-activity relationship using the 300 Myr old open cluster NGC 3532
Authors:
D. J. Fritzewski,
S. A. Barnes,
D. J. James,
S. P. Järvinen,
K. G. Strassmeier
Abstract:
The coeval stars of young open clusters provide insights into the formation of the rotation-activity relationship that elude studies of multi-age field populations. We measure the chromospheric activity of cool stars in the 300 Myr old open cluster NGC 3532 in concert with their rotation periods to study the mass-dependent morphology of activity for this transitional coeval population. Using multi…
▽ More
The coeval stars of young open clusters provide insights into the formation of the rotation-activity relationship that elude studies of multi-age field populations. We measure the chromospheric activity of cool stars in the 300 Myr old open cluster NGC 3532 in concert with their rotation periods to study the mass-dependent morphology of activity for this transitional coeval population. Using multi-object spectra of the Ca ii infrared triplet region obtained with the AAOmega spectrograph at the Anglo- Australian Telescope, we measure the chromospheric emission ratios for 454 FGKM cluster members of NGC 3532. The morphology of activity against colour appears to be a near-mirror image of the cluster's rotational behaviour. In particular, we identify a group of 'desaturated transitional rotators' that branches off from the main group of unsaturated FGK slow rotators, and from which it is separated by an 'activity gap'. The few desaturated gap stars are identical to the ones in the rotational gap. Nevertheless, the rotation-activity diagram is completely normal. In fact, the relationship is so tight that it allows us to predict rotation periods for many additional stars. We then precisely determine these periods from our photometric light curves. Our activity measurements show that all fast rotators of near-solar mass have evolved to become slow rotators, demonstrating that the absence of fast rotators in a colour-period diagram is not a detection issue but an astrophysical fact. We also identify a new population of low-activity stars among the early M dwarfs, enabling us to populate the extended slow rotator sequence in the colour-period diagram. The joint analysis of chromospheric activity and photometric time series data thus enables comprehensive insights into the evolution of the rotation and activity of stars during the transitional phase between the Pleiades and Hyades age. (Abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Rotation periods for cool stars in the open cluster NGC 3532. The transition from fast to slow rotation
Authors:
D. J. Fritzewski,
S. A. Barnes,
D. J. James,
K. G. Strassmeier
Abstract:
A cluster intermediate in age between the Pleiades (150 Myr) and the Hyades (600 Myr) is needed to probe the rotational evolution, especially the transition between fast and slow rotation that occurs between the two ages. We study the rich 300 Myr-old open cluster NGC 3532 to provide constraints on angular momentum loss. Measuring the rotation periods builds on our prior work of providing spectros…
▽ More
A cluster intermediate in age between the Pleiades (150 Myr) and the Hyades (600 Myr) is needed to probe the rotational evolution, especially the transition between fast and slow rotation that occurs between the two ages. We study the rich 300 Myr-old open cluster NGC 3532 to provide constraints on angular momentum loss. Measuring the rotation periods builds on our prior work of providing spectroscopic membership information for the cluster, and it supports the chromospheric activity measurements of cluster stars that we provide in a companion paper. Using 42 d-long photometric time series observations, we measured rotation periods for members of NGC 3532 and compared them with the predictions of angular momentum evolution models. We directly measured 176 photometric rotation periods for the cluster members. An additional 113 photometric rotation periods were identified using activity information resulting in a total sample containing 279 rotation periods for FGKM stars in NGC 3532. The colour-period diagram constructed from this rich data set shows a well-populated and structured slow rotator sequence, and a fast rotator sequence evolved beyond zero-age main sequence age whose stars are in transition from fast to slow rotation. We also identify an extended slow rotator sequence, apparently the analogue of the one we previously identified in NGC 2516. We compare our period distribution to rotational isochrones in colour-period space and find that all considered models have certain shortcomings. Using more detailed spin-down models, we evolve the rotation periods of the younger NGC 2516 forward in time and find that the spindown of the models is too aggressive with respect to the slow rotators. In contrast, stars on the evolved fast rotator sequence are not spun down strongly enough by these models. Our observations suggest a shorter crossing time for the rotational gap. (Abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
The rotation period distribution of the rich Pleiades-age Southern open cluster NGC 2516. Existence of a representative zero-age main sequence distribution
Authors:
D. J. Fritzewski,
S. A. Barnes,
D. J. James,
K. G. Strassmeier
Abstract:
We wish to measure the cool star rotation period distribution for the Pleiades-age rich open cluster NGC 2516 and use it to determine whether cluster-to-cluster variations exist in otherwise identical open clusters. We obtained 42 d-long time-series CCD photometry of NGC 2516 using the Yale 1 m telescope at CTIO and performed a number of related analyses, including PSF-based time-series photometry…
▽ More
We wish to measure the cool star rotation period distribution for the Pleiades-age rich open cluster NGC 2516 and use it to determine whether cluster-to-cluster variations exist in otherwise identical open clusters. We obtained 42 d-long time-series CCD photometry of NGC 2516 using the Yale 1 m telescope at CTIO and performed a number of related analyses, including PSF-based time-series photometry. Our data are complemented with additional information from several photometric datasets, literature radial velocities, and Gaia DR2 astrometry. All available data are used to construct an integrated membership list for NGC 2516, containing 844 stars in our 1deg FoV. We derived 308 rotation periods for late-F to mid-M cluster members from our photometry. We identified an additional 247 periodic M dwarf stars from a prior study as cluster members, and used these to construct a 555-star rotation period distribution for NGC 2516. We find a group of slowly rotating M dwarfs (10d<P<23d), forming a branch in the colour-period diagram which we call the 'extended slow rotator sequence'. This, and other features of the rotational distribution can also be found in the Pleiades, making the colour-period diagrams of the two clusters nearly indistinguishable. We demonstrate the existence of a representative ZAMS rotational distribution and provide a simple colour-independent way to represent it. We perform a detailed comparison of the NGC 2516 rotation period data with a number of recent rotational evolution models. Using X-ray data from the literature, we also construct the first rotation-activity diagram for solar-type stars in NGC 2516. The two clusters NGC 2516 and Pleiades can be considered twins in terms of stellar rotation and related properties, suggesting that otherwise identical open clusters also have intrinsically similar cool star rotation and activity distributions. (Abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Spectroscopic membership for the populous 300 Myr-old open cluster NGC 3532
Authors:
D. J. Fritzewski,
S. A. Barnes,
D. J. James,
A. M. Geller,
S. Meibom,
K. G. Strassmeier
Abstract:
NGC 3532 is an extremely rich open cluster embedded in the Galactic disc, hitherto lacking a comprehensive, documented membership list. We provide membership probabilities from new radial velocity observations of solar-type and low-mass stars in NGC 3532, in part as a prelude to a subsequent study of stellar rotation in the cluster. Using extant optical and infra-red photometry we constructed a pr…
▽ More
NGC 3532 is an extremely rich open cluster embedded in the Galactic disc, hitherto lacking a comprehensive, documented membership list. We provide membership probabilities from new radial velocity observations of solar-type and low-mass stars in NGC 3532, in part as a prelude to a subsequent study of stellar rotation in the cluster. Using extant optical and infra-red photometry we constructed a preliminary photometric membership catalogue, consisting of 2230 dwarf and turn-off stars. We selected 1060 of these for observation with the AAOmega spectrograph at the Anglo-Australian Telescope and 391 stars for observations with the Hydra-South spectrograph at the Victor Blanco Telescope, obtaining spectroscopic observations over a decade for 145 stars. We measured radial velocities for our targets through cross-correlation with model spectra and standard stars, and supplemented them with radial velocities for 433 additional stars from the literature. We also measured log g, Teff, and [Fe/H] from the AAOmega spectra. Together with proper motions from Gaia DR2 we find 660 exclusive members. The members are distributed across the whole cluster sequence, from giant stars to M dwarfs, making NGC 3532 one of the richest Galactic open clusters known to date, on par with the Pleiades. From further spectroscopic analysis of 153 dwarf members we find the metallicity to be marginally sub-solar, with [Fe/H]=-0.07. Exploiting trigonometric parallax measurements from Gaia DR2 we find a distance of $484^{+35}_{-30}$ pc. Based on the membership we provide an empirical cluster sequence in multiple photometric passbands. A comparison of the photometry of the measured cluster members with several recent model isochrones enables us to confirm the 300 Myr cluster age. However, all of the models evince departures from the cluster sequence in particular regions, especially in the lower mass range. (abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Long-Term Photometry of IC 348 with the YETI Network
Authors:
D. J. Fritzewski,
M. Kitze,
M. Mugrauer,
R. Neuhäuser,
C. Adam,
C. Briceño,
S. Buder,
T. Butterley,
W. -P. Chen,
B. Dinçel,
V. S. Dhillon,
R. Errmann,
Z. Garai,
H. F. W. Gilbert,
C. Ginski,
J. Greif,
L. K. Hardy,
J. Hernández,
P. C. Huang,
A. Kellerer,
E. Kundra,
S. P. Littlefair,
M. Mallonn,
C. Marka,
A. Pannicke
, et al. (7 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present long-term photometric observations of the young open cluster IC 348 with a baseline time-scale of 2.4 yr. Our study was conducted with several telescopes from the Young Exoplanet Transit Initiative (YETI) network in the Bessel $R$ band to find periodic variability of young stars. We identified 87 stars in IC 348 to be periodically variable; 33 of them were unreported before. Additionall…
▽ More
We present long-term photometric observations of the young open cluster IC 348 with a baseline time-scale of 2.4 yr. Our study was conducted with several telescopes from the Young Exoplanet Transit Initiative (YETI) network in the Bessel $R$ band to find periodic variability of young stars. We identified 87 stars in IC 348 to be periodically variable; 33 of them were unreported before. Additionally, we detected 61 periodic non-members of which 41 are new discoveries. Our wide field of view was the key to those numerous newly found variable stars. The distribution of rotation periods in IC 348 has always been of special interest. We investigate it further with our newly detected periods but we cannot find a statistically significant bimodality. We also report the detection of a close eclipsing binary in IC 348 composed of a low-mass stellar component ($M \gtrsim 0.09\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}$) and a K0 pre-main sequence star ($M \approx 2.7\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}$). Furthermore, we discovered three detached binaries among the background stars in our field of view and confirmed the period of a fourth one.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Rotation periods for cool stars in the 4 Gyr-old open cluster M67, the solar-stellar connection, and the applicability of gyrochronology to at least solar age
Authors:
Sydney A. Barnes,
Joerg Weingrill,
Dario Fritzewski,
Klaus G. Strassmeier
Abstract:
We report rotation periods for 20 cool (FGK) main sequence member stars of the 4 Gyr-old open cluster M 67 (= NGC 2682), obtained by analysing data from Campaign 5 of the K2 mission with the Kepler Space Telescope. The rotation periods delineate a sequence in the color-period diagram (CPD) of increasing period with redder color. This sequence represents a cross-section at the cluster age of the su…
▽ More
We report rotation periods for 20 cool (FGK) main sequence member stars of the 4 Gyr-old open cluster M 67 (= NGC 2682), obtained by analysing data from Campaign 5 of the K2 mission with the Kepler Space Telescope. The rotation periods delineate a sequence in the color-period diagram (CPD) of increasing period with redder color. This sequence represents a cross-section at the cluster age of the surface P = P (t, M), suggested in prior work to extend to at least solar age. The current Sun is located marginally (approx. one sigma) above M 67 in the CPD, as its relative age leads us to expect, and lies on the P = P (t, M) surface to within measurement precision. We therefore conclude that the solar rotation rate is normal, as compared with cluster stars, a fact which strengthens the solar-stellar connection. The agreement between the M\,67 rotation period measurements and prior predictions further implies that rotation periods, especially when coupled with appropriate supporting work such as spectroscopy, can provide reliable ages via gyrochronology for other similar FGK dwarfs from the early main sequence to solar age and likely till the main sequence turnoff. The M 67 rotators have a rotational age of 4.2 Gyr, with a standard deviation of 0.7 Gyr, implying that similar field stars can be age-dated to precisions of ~17%. The rotational age of the M 67 cluster as a whole is therefore 4.2 Gyr, but with a lower (averaged) uncertainty of 0.2 Gyr.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
