-
Abundance, Sizes, and Major Element Compositions of Components in CR and LL Chondrites: Formation from Single Reservoirs
Authors:
Denton S. Ebel,
Marina E. Gemma,
Samuel P. Alpert,
Jasmine Bayron,
Ana H. Lobo,
Michael K. Weisberg
Abstract:
Abundances, apparent sizes, and individual chemical compositions of chondrules, refractory inclusions, other objects and surrounding matrix have been determined for Semarkona (LL3.00) and Renazzo (CR2) using consistent methods and criteria on x-ray element intensity maps. These represent the non-carbonaceous (NC, Semarkona) and carbonaceous chondrite (CC, Renazzo) superclans of chondrite types. We…
▽ More
Abundances, apparent sizes, and individual chemical compositions of chondrules, refractory inclusions, other objects and surrounding matrix have been determined for Semarkona (LL3.00) and Renazzo (CR2) using consistent methods and criteria on x-ray element intensity maps. These represent the non-carbonaceous (NC, Semarkona) and carbonaceous chondrite (CC, Renazzo) superclans of chondrite types. We compare object and matrix abundances with similar data for CM, CO, K, and CV chondrites. We assess, pixel-by-pixel, the major element abundance in each object and in the entire matrix. We determine the abundance of "metallic chondrules" in LL chondrites. Chondrules with high Mg/Si and low Fe/Si and matrix carrying opposing ratios complement each other to make whole rocks with near-solar major element ratios in Renazzo. Similar Mg/Si and Fe/Si chondrule-matrix relationships are seen in Semarkona, which is within 11% of solar Mg/Si but significantly Fe-depleted. These results provide a robust constraint in support of single-reservoir models for chondrule formation and accretion, ruling out whole classes of astrophysical models and constraining processes of chondrite component formation and accretion into chondrite parent bodies.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Djerfisherite: Nebular Source of Refractory Potassium
Authors:
Denton S. Ebel,
Richard O. Sack
Abstract:
Djerfisherite is an important carrier of potassium in highly reduced enstatite chondrites, where it occurs in sub-round metal-sulfide nodules. These nodules were once free-floating objects in the protoplanetary nebula. Here, we analyze existing and new data to derive an equation of state (EOS) for djerfisherites of K_{6}(Cu,Fe,Ni)^{B} (Fe,Ni,Cu)^{C}_{24} S_{26}Cl structural formula. We use this EO…
▽ More
Djerfisherite is an important carrier of potassium in highly reduced enstatite chondrites, where it occurs in sub-round metal-sulfide nodules. These nodules were once free-floating objects in the protoplanetary nebula. Here, we analyze existing and new data to derive an equation of state (EOS) for djerfisherites of K_{6}(Cu,Fe,Ni)^{B} (Fe,Ni,Cu)^{C}_{24} S_{26}Cl structural formula. We use this EOS to calculate the thermal stability of djerfisherite coexisting in equilibrium with a cooling vapor of solar composition enriched in a dust analogous to anhydrous, chondritic interplanetary dust (C-IDP). We find that condensed mineral assemblages closely match those found in enstatite chondrites, with djerfisherite condensing above 1000 K in C-IDP dust enriched systems. Results may have implications for the volatile budgets of terrestrial planets, and the incorporation of K into early-formed, highly reduced, planetary cores. Previous work links enstatite chondrites to the planet Mercury, where the surface has a terrestrial K/Th ratio, high S/Si ratio, and very low FeO content. Mercury's accretion history may yield insights into Earth's.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Laser Scanning Confocal Microscopy of Comet Material in Aerogel
Authors:
Michael Greenberg,
Denton S. Ebel
Abstract:
We report non-destructive 3-dimensional imaging and analysis techniques for material returned by the Stardust cometary collector. Our technique utilizes 3-dimensional laser scanning confocal microscopy (3D LSCM) to image whole Stardust tracks, in situ, with attainable resolutions <90 nm/pixel edge. LSCM images illustrate track morphology and fragmentation history; image segmentation techniques pro…
▽ More
We report non-destructive 3-dimensional imaging and analysis techniques for material returned by the Stardust cometary collector. Our technique utilizes 3-dimensional laser scanning confocal microscopy (3D LSCM) to image whole Stardust tracks, in situ, with attainable resolutions <90 nm/pixel edge. LSCM images illustrate track morphology and fragmentation history; image segmentation techniques provide quantifiable volumetric and dynamic measurements. We present a method for multipart image acquisition and registration in 3-D. Additionally, we present a 3D deconvolution method for aerogel, using a theoretically calculated point spread function for first-order corrections of optical aberrations induced by light diffraction and refractive index mismatches. LSCM is a benchtop technique and is an excellent alternative to synchrotron x-ray computed microtomography for optically transparent media. Our technique, developed over the past 2 years, is a non-invasive, rapid technique for fine-scale imaging of high value returned samples from the Stardust mission, as well as various other samples from the geosciences.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Equilibrium Condensation from Chondritic Porous IDP Enriched Vapor: Implications for Mercury and Enstatite Chondrite Origins
Authors:
Denton S. Ebel,
Conel M. O'D. Alexander
Abstract:
The origin of Mercury's anomalous core and low FeO surface mineralogy are outstanding questions in planetary science. Mercury's composition may result from cosmochemical controls on the precursor solids that accreted to form Mercury. High temperatures and enrichment in solid condensates are likely conditions near the midplane of the inner solar protoplanetary disk. Silicate liquids similar to the…
▽ More
The origin of Mercury's anomalous core and low FeO surface mineralogy are outstanding questions in planetary science. Mercury's composition may result from cosmochemical controls on the precursor solids that accreted to form Mercury. High temperatures and enrichment in solid condensates are likely conditions near the midplane of the inner solar protoplanetary disk. Silicate liquids similar to the liquids quenched in ferromagnesian chondrules are thermodynamically stable in oxygen-rich systems that are highly enriched in dust of CI-chondrite composition. In contrast, the solids surviving into the orbit of Mercury's accretion zone were probably similar to highly unequilibrated, anhydrous, interstellar organic- and presolar grain-bearing chondritic, porous interplanetary dust particles (C-IDPs). Chemical systems enriched in an assumed C-IDP composition dust produce condensates (solid + liquid assemblages in equilibrium with vapor) with super-chondritic atomic Fe/Si ratios at high temperatures, approaching 50% of that estimated for bulk Mercury. Sulfur behaves as a refractory element, but at lower temperatures, in these chemical systems. Stable minerals are FeO-poor, and include CaS and MgS, species found in enstatite chondrites. Disk gradients in volatile compositions of planetary and asteroidal precursors can explain Mercury's anomalous composition, as well as enstatite chondrite and aubrite parent body compositions. This model predicts high sulfur content, and very low FeO content of Mercury's surface rocks.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
The Origin of Chondrules: Constraints from Matrix-Chondrule Complementarity
Authors:
Herbert Palme,
Dominik C. Hezel,
Denton S. Ebel
Abstract:
One of the major unresolved problems in cosmochemistry is the origin of chondrules, once molten, spherical silicate droplets with diameters of 0.2 to 2 mm. Chondrules are an essential component of primitive meteorites and perhaps of all early solar system materials including the terrestrial planets. Numerous hypotheses have been proposed for their origin. Many carbonaceous chondrites are composed…
▽ More
One of the major unresolved problems in cosmochemistry is the origin of chondrules, once molten, spherical silicate droplets with diameters of 0.2 to 2 mm. Chondrules are an essential component of primitive meteorites and perhaps of all early solar system materials including the terrestrial planets. Numerous hypotheses have been proposed for their origin. Many carbonaceous chondrites are composed of about equal amounts of chondrules and fine-grained matrix. Recent data confirm that matrix in carbonaceous chondrites has high Si/Mg and Fe/Mg ratios when compared to bulk carbonaceous chondrites with solar abundance ratios. Chondrules have the opposite signature, low Si/Mg and Fe/Mg ratios. In some carbonaceous chondrites chondrules have low Al/Ti ratios, matrix has the opposite signature and the bulk is chondritic. It is shown in detail that these complementary relationships cannot have evolved on the parent asteroid(s) of carbonaceous chondrites. They reflect preaccretionary processes. Both chondrules and matrix must have formed from a single, solar-like reservoir. Consequences of complementarity for chondrule formation models are discussed. An independent origin and/or random mixing of chondrules and matrix can be excluded. Hence, complementarity is a strong constraint for all astrophysical-cosmochemical models of chondrule formation. Although chondrules and matrix formed from a single reservoir, the chondrule-matrix system was open to the addition of oxygen and other gaseous components.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Properties of Original Impactors Estimated from Three-Dimensional Analysis of Whole Stardust Tracks
Authors:
Michael Greenberg,
Denton S. Ebel
Abstract:
The Stardust mission captured comet Wild 2 particles in aerogel at 6.1 km/sec. We performed high resolution three-dimensional imaging and X-ray fluorescence mapping of whole cometary tracks in aerogel. We present the results of a survey of track structures using Laser Scanning Confocal Microscopy, including measurements of track volumes, entry hole size and cross-sectional profiles. We compare var…
▽ More
The Stardust mission captured comet Wild 2 particles in aerogel at 6.1 km/sec. We performed high resolution three-dimensional imaging and X-ray fluorescence mapping of whole cometary tracks in aerogel. We present the results of a survey of track structures using Laser Scanning Confocal Microscopy, including measurements of track volumes, entry hole size and cross-sectional profiles. We compare various methods for measuring track parameters. We demonstrate a methodology for discerning hypervelocity particle ablation rates using synchrotron-based X-ray fluorescence, combined with mass and volume estimates of original impactors derived from measured track properties. Finally, we present a rough framework for reconstruction of original impactor size, and volume of volatilized material, using our measured parameters. The bulk of this work is in direct support of non-destructive analysis and identification of cometary grains in whole tracks, and its eventual application to the reconstruction of the size, shape, porosity and chemical composition of whole Stardust impactors.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Thermochemical Stability of Low-Iron, Manganese-Enriched Olivine in Astrophysical Environments
Authors:
Denton S. Ebel,
Michael K. Weisberg,
John R. Beckett
Abstract:
Low-iron, manganese-enriched (LIME) olivine grains are found in cometary samples returned by the Stardust mission to comet 81P/Wild 2. Similar grains are found in primitive meteoritic clasts and unequilibrated meteorite matrix. LIME olivine is thermodynamically stable in a vapor of solar composition at high temperature at total pressures of a millibar to a microbar, but enrichment of solar composi…
▽ More
Low-iron, manganese-enriched (LIME) olivine grains are found in cometary samples returned by the Stardust mission to comet 81P/Wild 2. Similar grains are found in primitive meteoritic clasts and unequilibrated meteorite matrix. LIME olivine is thermodynamically stable in a vapor of solar composition at high temperature at total pressures of a millibar to a microbar, but enrichment of solar composition vapor in a dust of chondritic composition causes the FeO/MnO ratio of olivine to increase. The compositions of LIME olivines in primitive materials indicate oxygen fugacities close to that of a very reducing vapor of solar composition. The compositional zoning of LIME olivines in amoeboid olivine aggregates is consistent with equilibration with nebular vapor in the stability field of olivine, without reequilibration at lower temperatures. A similar history is likely for LIME olivines found in comet samples and in interplanetary dust particles. LIME olivine is not likely to persist in nebular conditions in which silicate liquids are stable.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Experimental Investigation of Condensation Predictions for Dust-Enriched Systems
Authors:
Gokce Ustunisik,
Denton S. Ebel,
David Walker,
Joseph S. Boesenberg
Abstract:
Condensation models describe the equilibrium distribution of elements between coexisting mineral solid solutions, silicate liquid, and vapor in a closed chemical system, vapor phase always present, using equations of state of the phases involved at a fixed total P (< 1 bar) and temperature T. The VAPORS code uses a CaO-MgO-Al$_2$O$_3$-SiO$_2$ liquid model at T above the stability field of olivine…
▽ More
Condensation models describe the equilibrium distribution of elements between coexisting mineral solid solutions, silicate liquid, and vapor in a closed chemical system, vapor phase always present, using equations of state of the phases involved at a fixed total P (< 1 bar) and temperature T. The VAPORS code uses a CaO-MgO-Al$_2$O$_3$-SiO$_2$ liquid model at T above the stability field of olivine and the MELTS algorithm at lower T. Quenched high-T crystal + liquid assemblages are preserved in meteorites as Type B Ca-, Al-rich inclusions (CAIs) and olivine-rich ferromagnesian chondrules. Experimental tests of compositional regions may clarify the nature of the phases present, the phase boundaries, and the partition of trace elements among these phases. Twenty-three Pt-loop equilibrium experiments in seven phase fields on twelve bulk compositions at specific T and dust enrichment factors tested the predicted stability fields of forsteritic olivine (Mg$_2$SiO$_4$), enstatite (MgSiO$_3$), Cr-bearing spinel (MgAl$_2$O$_4$), perovskite (CaTiO$_3$), melilite (Ca$_2$Al$_2$SiO$_7$ - Ca$_2$Mg$_2$Si$_2$O$_7$) and/or grossite (CaAl4O7) crystallizing from liquid. Experimental results for forsterite, enstatite, and grossite are in very good agreement with predictions, both in chemistry and phase abundances. On the other hand, the stability of spinel with olivine, and stability of perovskite and gehlenite are quite different from predictions. Perovskite is absent in all experiments. Even at low oxygen fugacity (IW-3.4), the most TiO$_2$-rich experiments do not crystallize Al-, Ti-bearing calcic pyroxene. The stability of spinel and olivine together is limited to a smaller phase field than is predicted. The melilite stability field is much larger than predicted, indicating a deficiency of current liquid or melilite activity models. In that respect, these experiments contribute to improving the data for calibrating thermodynamic models including MELTS.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Condensation in Dust-Enriched Systems
Authors:
Denton S. Ebel,
Lawrence Grossman
Abstract:
Full chemical equilibrium calculations of the sequence of condensation of the elements from cosmic gases made by total vaporization of dust-enriched systems were performed to investigate the oxidation state of the resulting condensates. Computations included 23 elements and 374 gas species over a range of -3=log10(total P) to -6 bar and for enrichments to 1000x in dust of C1 chondritic composition…
▽ More
Full chemical equilibrium calculations of the sequence of condensation of the elements from cosmic gases made by total vaporization of dust-enriched systems were performed to investigate the oxidation state of the resulting condensates. Computations included 23 elements and 374 gas species over a range of -3=log10(total P) to -6 bar and for enrichments to 1000x in dust of C1 chondritic composition relative to a system of solar composition. Because liquids are stable condensates in these systems, the MELTS non-ideal solution model for silicate liquids was used. Condensation at logP=-3 bar and dust enrichments of 100x, 500x and 1000x occurs at oxygen fugacities of IW-3.1, IW-1.7 and IW-1.2, respectively, and, at the temperature of cessation of direct condensation of olivine from the vapor, yields X(fayalite) of 0.019, 0.088 and 0.164, respectively. Silicate liquid is a stable condensate at dust enrichments >~12.5x at logP=-3. At 1000x, the Na and K oxide contents of the last liquid reach 10.1 and 1.3 wt%, respectively, at logP=-3 bar. At logP=-3 bar, iron sulfide liquids are stable condensates at dust enrichments at least as low as 500x, and the predicted distribution of Fe between metal, silicate and sulfide at 1310K and a dust enrichment of 560x matches that found in H chondrites, and at 1330K and 675x matches that of L chondrites prior to metal loss. With some exceptions, many chondrule glass compositions fall along bulk composition trajectories for liquids in equilibrium with cosmic gases at logP=-3 bar and dust enrichments between 600x and 1000x. If these chondrules formed by secondary melting of mixtures of condensates that formed at different T, nebular regions with characteristics such as these would have been necessary to prevent loss of Na by evaporation and FeO by reduction from the liquid precursors, assuming that liquids and gas were hot for enough time to have equilibrated.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Condensation of Rocky Material in Astrophysical Environments
Authors:
Denton S. Ebel
Abstract:
Volatility-dependent fractionation of the rock-forming elements at high temperatures is an early, widespread process during formation of the earliest solids in protoplanetary disks. Equilibrium condensation calculations allow prediction of the identities and compositions of mineral and liquid phases coexisting with gas under presumed bulk chemical, pressure and temperature conditions. A graphical…
▽ More
Volatility-dependent fractionation of the rock-forming elements at high temperatures is an early, widespread process during formation of the earliest solids in protoplanetary disks. Equilibrium condensation calculations allow prediction of the identities and compositions of mineral and liquid phases coexisting with gas under presumed bulk chemical, pressure and temperature conditions. A graphical survey of such results is presented for systems of solar and non-solar bulk composition. Chemical equilibrium was approached to varying degrees in the local regions where meteoritic chondrules, Ca-Al-rich inclusions, matrix and other components formed. Early, repeated vapor-solid cycling and homogenization, followed by hierarchical accretion in dust-rich regions, is hypothesized for meteoritic inclusions. Disequilibrium chemical effects appear to have been common at all temperatures, but increasingly so in less refractory meteoritic components. Work is needed to better model high-temperature solid solutions, indicators of these processes.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Trace Element Partitioning between CAI-Type Melts and Grossite, Melilite, Hibonite, and Olivine
Authors:
Gokce Ustunisik,
Denton S. Ebel,
David Walker,
Roger L. Nielsen,
Marina E. Gemma
Abstract:
We determined the mineral-melt partition coefficients (Di's) and the compositional and/or temperature dependency between grossite, melilite, hibonite, olivine and Ca-, Al-inclusion (CAI)-type liquids for a number of light (LE), high field strength (HFSE), large ion lithophile (LILE), and rare earth (REE) elements including Li, Be, B, Sr, Zr, Nb, Ba, La, Ce, Eu, Dy, Ho, Yb, Hf, Ta, Th. A series of…
▽ More
We determined the mineral-melt partition coefficients (Di's) and the compositional and/or temperature dependency between grossite, melilite, hibonite, olivine and Ca-, Al-inclusion (CAI)-type liquids for a number of light (LE), high field strength (HFSE), large ion lithophile (LILE), and rare earth (REE) elements including Li, Be, B, Sr, Zr, Nb, Ba, La, Ce, Eu, Dy, Ho, Yb, Hf, Ta, Th. A series of isothermal crystallization experiments was conducted at 5 kbar pressure and IW+1 in graphite capsules. The starting compositions were selected based on the calculated and experimentally confirmed phase relations during condensation in CI dust-enriched systems (Ebel and Grossman, 2000; Ebel, 2006; Ustunisik et al., 2014). Partition coefficients between melt and gehlenite, hibonite, and grossite show that the trace element budget of igneous CAIs is controlled by these three major Al-bearing phases in addition to pyroxene. In general, LE, LILE, REE, and HFSE partition coefficients (by mass) decrease in the order of Di(Gehlenite-Melt) > Di(Hibonite-Melt) > Di(Grossite-Melt). Results suggest that Di(Gehlenite-Melt) vary by a factor of 2-3 in different melt compositions at the same T (~1500 C). Increased melt Al and Ca, relative to earlier work, increases the compatibility of Di(Gehlenite-Melt), and also the compatibility of Di(Hibonite-Melt), especially for La and Ce. Olivine partitioning experiments confirm that olivine contribution to the trace element budget of CAIs is small due to the low Di(Olivine-Melt) at a range of temperatures while D-Eu, Yb(Olivine-Melt) are sensitive to changes in T and oxygen fugacity. The development of a predictive model for partitioning in CAI-type systems would require more experimental data and the use of analytical instruments capable of obtaining single phase analyses for crystals < 5 micron.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Vapor-Melt Exchange -- Constraints on Chondrite Formation Conditions and Processes
Authors:
Denton S. Ebel,
Conel M. O'D. Alexander,
Guy Libourel
Abstract:
The bulk volatile contents of chondritic meteorites provide clues to their origins. Matrix and chondrules carry differing abundances of moderately volatile elements, with chondrules carrying a refractory signature. At the high temperatures of chondrule formation and the low pressures of the solar nebula, many elements, including Na and Fe, should have been volatile. Yet the evidence is that even a…
▽ More
The bulk volatile contents of chondritic meteorites provide clues to their origins. Matrix and chondrules carry differing abundances of moderately volatile elements, with chondrules carrying a refractory signature. At the high temperatures of chondrule formation and the low pressures of the solar nebula, many elements, including Na and Fe, should have been volatile. Yet the evidence is that even at peak temperatures, at or near the liquidus, Na and Fe (as FeO and Fe-metal) were present in about their current abundances in molten chondrules. This seems to require very high solid densities during chondrule formation to prevent significant evaporation. Evaporation should also be accompanied by isotopic mass fractionation. Evidence from a wide range of isotopic systems indicates only slight isotopic mass fractionations of moderately vola-tile elements, further supporting high solid densities. However, olivine-rich, FeO-poor chondrules commonly have pyroxene-dominated outer zones that have been interpreted as the prod-ucts of late condensation of SiO2 into chondrule melts. Late condensation of more refractory SiO2 is inconsistent with the apparent abundances of more volatile Na, FeO and Fe-metal in many chondrules. Despite significant recent experimental work bearing on this problem, the conditions under which chondrules behaved as open systems remain enigmatic.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Abundance, Major Element Composition and Size of Components and Matrix in CV, CO and Acfer 094 Chondrites
Authors:
Denton S. Ebel,
Chelsea Brunner,
Kevin Konrad,
Kristin Leftwich,
Isabelle Erb,
Muzhou Lu,
Hugo Rodriguez,
Ellen J. Crapster-Pregont,
Jon M. Friedrich,
Michael K. Weisberg
Abstract:
The relative abundances and chemical compositions of the macroscopic components or "inclusions" (chondrules and refractory inclusions) and fine-grained mineral matrix in chondritic meteorites provide constraints on astrophysical theories of inclusion formation and chondrite accretion. We present new techniques for analysis of low count per pixel Si, Mg, Ca, Al, Ti and Fe x-ray intensity maps of ro…
▽ More
The relative abundances and chemical compositions of the macroscopic components or "inclusions" (chondrules and refractory inclusions) and fine-grained mineral matrix in chondritic meteorites provide constraints on astrophysical theories of inclusion formation and chondrite accretion. We present new techniques for analysis of low count per pixel Si, Mg, Ca, Al, Ti and Fe x-ray intensity maps of rock sections, and apply them to large areas of CO and CV chondrites, and the ungrouped Acfer 094 chondrite. For many thousands of manually segmented and type-identified inclusions, we are able to assess, pixel-by-pixel, the major element content of each inclusion. We quantify the total fraction of those elements accounted for by various types of inclusion and matrix. Among CO chondrites, both matrix and inclusion Mg to Si ratios approach the solar (and bulk CO) ratio with increasing petrologic grade, but Si remains enriched in inclusions relative to matrix. The oxidized CV chondrites with higher matrix-inclusion ratios exhibit more severe aqueous alteration (oxidation), and their excess matrix accounts for their higher porosity relative to reduced CV chondrites. Porosity could accommodate an original ice component of matrix as the direct cause of local alteration of oxidized CV chondrites. We confirm that major element abundances among inclusions differ greatly, across a wide range of CO and CV chondrites. These abundances in all cases add up to near-chondritic (solar) bulk abundance ratios in these chondrites, despite wide variations in matrix-inclusion ratios and inclusion sizes: chondrite components are complementary. This "complementarity" provides a robust meteoritic constraint for astrophysical disk models.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2023; v1 submitted 21 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Condensation Calculations in Planetary Science and Cosmochemistry
Authors:
Denton S. Ebel
Abstract:
Cool a piece of the Sun to 1000 K at one millibar pressure to yield a mineral assemblage consistent with those found in the most primitive meteorites. This is an equilibrium or fractional condensation experiment simulated by calculations using equations of state for hundreds of gaseous molecules, condensed mineral solids, and silicate liquids, the products of a century of experimental measurements…
▽ More
Cool a piece of the Sun to 1000 K at one millibar pressure to yield a mineral assemblage consistent with those found in the most primitive meteorites. This is an equilibrium or fractional condensation experiment simulated by calculations using equations of state for hundreds of gaseous molecules, condensed mineral solids, and silicate liquids, the products of a century of experimental measurements and theoretical studies. Such calculations have revolutionized our understanding of the chemistry of the cosmos.
The mid-20th Century realization that meteorites are fossil records of the early Solar System made chemistry central to understanding planetary origins. Thus "condensation", the distribution of elements and isotopes between vapor and condensed solids and/or liquids at or approaching chemical equilibrium, deeply informs discussion of how meteor/comet compositions bear on planets.
Condensation calculations have been applied to disks around young stars, to the mineral "rain" of mineral grains expected to form in cool dwarf star atmospheres, to the expanding envelopes of giant stars, to the vapor plumes that form in planetary impacts, and to the chemically and isotopically distinct "shells" computed and observed to exist in supernovae. As with all sophisticated calculations, there are inherent caveats, subtleties, and computational difficulties.
Local chemistry has yet to be consistently integrated into dynamical astrophysical simulations so that effects like the blocking of radiation by grains, absorption and reemission of light by grains, and buffering of heat by grain evaporation/condensation feed back into the physics at each node of a gridded calculation over time. A deeper integration of thermochemistry with physical models makes the prospect of a general protoplanetary disk model as hopeful now as a general circulation model for global climate was in the early 1970's.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Dust dynamics in current sheets within protoplanetary disks. I. Isothermal models including ambipolar diffusion and Ohmic resistivity
Authors:
U. Lebreuilly,
M. -M. Mac Low,
B. Commerçon,
D. S. Ebel
Abstract:
Context: Chondrules originate from the reprocessing of dust grains. They are key building blocks of telluric planets, yet their formation, which must happen in strongly localized regions of high temperature, remains poorly understood. Aims: We examine the dust spatial distribution near regions of strong local heating produced by current sheets, as a step toward exploring a potential path for chond…
▽ More
Context: Chondrules originate from the reprocessing of dust grains. They are key building blocks of telluric planets, yet their formation, which must happen in strongly localized regions of high temperature, remains poorly understood. Aims: We examine the dust spatial distribution near regions of strong local heating produced by current sheets, as a step toward exploring a potential path for chondrule formation. We further aim to investigate current sheet formation under various conditions in protoplanetary disks in the presence of ambipolar diffusion and Ohmic resistivity and the effect of current sheet morphology on dust dynamics in their vicinity. Methods: We use the RAMSES code including modules for non-ideal magnetohydrodynamics and solution of the dynamics of multiple sizes of dust grains to compute unstratified shearing box simulations of current sheet formation. We investigate, through seven models the effect of the ambipolar diffusion and Ohmic resistivity strength, the initial density, and magnetic field, as well as the resolution and box size. Results: We find that current sheets form in all our models, with typical widths of 0.001-0.01 AU and that strong dust fraction variations occur for millimeter-sized grains. These variations are typically of an order of magnitude and up to two orders of magnitude for the most favorable cases. We also show that the box size and resolution has a strong impact on the current sheet distribution and intensity. Conclusions: The formation of current sheets that can intensely heat their surroundings near strong dynamical dust fraction variations could have important implications for chondrule formation, as it appears likely to happen in regions of large dust fraction.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Fine-grained Material Associated with a Large Sulfide returned from Comet 81P/Wild 2
Authors:
Zack Gainsforth,
Andrew J. Westphal,
Anna L. Butterworth,
Christine E. Jilly-Rehak,
Donald E. Brownlee,
Dave Joswiak,
Ryan C. Ogliore,
Michael E. Zolensky,
Hans A. Bechtel,
Denton S. Ebel,
Gary R. Huss,
Scott A. Sandford,
Amanda J. White
Abstract:
In a consortium analysis of a large particle captured from the coma of comet 81P/Wild 2 by the Stardust spacecraft, we report the discovery of a field of fine-grained material (FGM) in contact with a large sulfide particle. The FGM was partially located in an embayment in the sulfide, so appears to have been largely protected from damage during hypervelocity capture in aerogel. Some of the FGM par…
▽ More
In a consortium analysis of a large particle captured from the coma of comet 81P/Wild 2 by the Stardust spacecraft, we report the discovery of a field of fine-grained material (FGM) in contact with a large sulfide particle. The FGM was partially located in an embayment in the sulfide, so appears to have been largely protected from damage during hypervelocity capture in aerogel. Some of the FGM particles are indistinguishable in their characteristics from common components of chondritic-porous interplanetary dust particles (CP-IDPs), including glass with embedded metals and sulfides (GEMS) and equilibrated aggregates (EAs). The sulfide exhibits surprising Ni-rich lamellae, which may indicate that this particle experienced a long-duration heating event after its formation but before incorporation into Wild 2. We discuss the relationship of the FGM to the sulfide, to other Wild 2 particles and to the history of the Solar nebula.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Dust concentration and chondrule formation
Authors:
Alexander Hubbard,
Mordecai-Mark Mac Low,
Denton S. Ebel
Abstract:
Meteoritical and astrophysical models of planet formation make contradictory predictions for dust concentration factors in chondrule forming regions of the solar nebula. Meteoritical and cosmochemical models strongly suggest that chondrules, a key component of the meteoritical record, formed in regions with solids-to-gas mass ratios orders of magnitude above background. However, models of dust gra…
▽ More
Meteoritical and astrophysical models of planet formation make contradictory predictions for dust concentration factors in chondrule forming regions of the solar nebula. Meteoritical and cosmochemical models strongly suggest that chondrules, a key component of the meteoritical record, formed in regions with solids-to-gas mass ratios orders of magnitude above background. However, models of dust grain dynamics in protoplanetary disks struggle to surpass factors of a few outside of very brief windows in the lifetime of the dust grains. Worse, those models do not predict significant concentration factors for dust grains the size of chondrule precursors. We briefly develop the difficulty in concentrating dust particles in the context of nebular chondrule formation and show that the disagreement is sufficiently stark that cosmochemists should explore ideas that might revise the concentration factor requirements downwards.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
The Elusive Origin of Mercury
Authors:
Denton S. Ebel,
Sarah T. Stewart
Abstract:
The MESSENGER mission sought to discover what physical processes determined Mercury's high metal to silicate ratio. Instead, the mission has discovered multiple anomalous characteristics about our innermost planet. The lack of FeO and the reduced oxidation state of Mercury's crust and mantle are more extreme than nearly all other known materials in the solar system. In contrast, moderately volatil…
▽ More
The MESSENGER mission sought to discover what physical processes determined Mercury's high metal to silicate ratio. Instead, the mission has discovered multiple anomalous characteristics about our innermost planet. The lack of FeO and the reduced oxidation state of Mercury's crust and mantle are more extreme than nearly all other known materials in the solar system. In contrast, moderately volatile elements are present in abundances comparable to the other terrestrial planets. No single process during Mercury's formation is able to explain all of these observations. Here, we review the current ideas for the origin of Mercury's unique features. Gaps in understanding the innermost regions of the solar nebula limit testing different hypotheses. Even so, all proposed models are incomplete and need further development in order to unravel Mercury's remaining secrets.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
The motion of chondrules and other particles in a protoplanetary disc with temperature fluctuations
Authors:
Christoph Loesche,
Gerhard Wurm,
Thorben Kelling,
Jens Teiser,
Denton S. Ebel
Abstract:
We consider the mechanism of photophoretic transport in protoplanetary disks that are optically thick to radiation. Here, photophoresis is not caused by the central star but by temperature fluctuations that subject suspended solid particles, including chondrules, to non-isotropic thermal radiation within the disk. These short-lived temperature fluctuations can explain time-of-flight size sorting a…
▽ More
We consider the mechanism of photophoretic transport in protoplanetary disks that are optically thick to radiation. Here, photophoresis is not caused by the central star but by temperature fluctuations that subject suspended solid particles, including chondrules, to non-isotropic thermal radiation within the disk. These short-lived temperature fluctuations can explain time-of-flight size sorting and general number density enhancements. The same mechanism will also lead to velocity fluctuations of dust aggregates beyond $100\,\mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ for mm-sized particles in protoplanetary disks. Applying this in future research will change our understanding of the early phases of collisional dust evolution and aggregate growth as particles cross the bouncing barrier and as mass transfer rates are altered.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2016; v1 submitted 7 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Semarkona: Lessons for chondrule and chondrite formation
Authors:
Alexander Hubbard,
Denton S. Ebel
Abstract:
We consider the evidence presented by the LL3.0 chondrite Semarkona, including its chondrule fraction, chondrule size distribution and matrix thermal history. We show that no more than a modest fraction of the ambient matrix material in the Solar Nebula could have been melted into chondrules; and that much of the unprocessed matrix material must have been filtered out at some stage of Semarkona's…
▽ More
We consider the evidence presented by the LL3.0 chondrite Semarkona, including its chondrule fraction, chondrule size distribution and matrix thermal history. We show that no more than a modest fraction of the ambient matrix material in the Solar Nebula could have been melted into chondrules; and that much of the unprocessed matrix material must have been filtered out at some stage of Semarkona's parent body formation process. We conclude that agglomerations of many chondrules must have formed in the Solar Nebula, which implies that chondrules and matrix grains had quite different collisional sticking parameters. Further, we note that the absence of large melted objects in Semarkona means that chondrules must have exited the melting zone rapidly, before the chondrule agglomerations could form. The simplest explanation for this rapid exit is that chondrule melting occurred in surface layers of the disk. The newly formed, compact, chondrules then settled out of those layers on short time scales.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Chondrule size and related physical properties: a compilation and evaluation of current data across all meteorite groups
Authors:
Jon M. Friedrich,
Michael K. Weisberg,
Denton S. Ebel,
Alison E. Biltz,
Bernadette M. Corbett,
Ivan V. Iotzov,
Wajiha S. Khan,
Matthew D. Wolman
Abstract:
The examination of the physical properties of chondrules has generally received less emphasis than other properties of meteorites such as their mineralogy, petrology, and chemical and isotopic compositions. Among the various physical properties of chondrules, chondrule size is especially important for the classification of chondrites into chemical groups, since each chemical group possesses a dist…
▽ More
The examination of the physical properties of chondrules has generally received less emphasis than other properties of meteorites such as their mineralogy, petrology, and chemical and isotopic compositions. Among the various physical properties of chondrules, chondrule size is especially important for the classification of chondrites into chemical groups, since each chemical group possesses a distinct size-frequency distribution of chondrules. Knowledge of the physical properties of chondrules is also vital for the development of astrophysical models for chondrule formation, and for understanding how to utilize asteroidal resources in space exploration. To examine our current knowledge of chondrule sizes, we have compiled and provide commentary on available chondrule dimension literature data. We include all chondrite chemical groups as well as the acapulcoite primitive achondrites, some of which contain relict chondrules. We also compile and review current literature data for other astrophysically-relevant physical properties (chondrule mass and density). Finally, we briefly examine some additional physical aspects of chondrules such as the frequencies of compound and 'cratered' chondrules. A purpose of this compilation is to provide a useful resource for meteoriticists and astrophysicists alike.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Protoplanetary dust porosity and FU Orionis Outbursts: Solving the mystery of Earth's missing volatiles
Authors:
Alexander Hubbard,
Denton S. Ebel
Abstract:
The Earth is known to be depleted in volatile lithophile elements in a fashion that defies easy explanation. We resolve this anomaly with a model that combines the porosity of collisionally grown dust grains in protoplanetary disks with heating from FU Orionis events that dramatically raise protoplanetary disk temperatures. The heating from an FU Orionis event alters the aerodynamical properties o…
▽ More
The Earth is known to be depleted in volatile lithophile elements in a fashion that defies easy explanation. We resolve this anomaly with a model that combines the porosity of collisionally grown dust grains in protoplanetary disks with heating from FU Orionis events that dramatically raise protoplanetary disk temperatures. The heating from an FU Orionis event alters the aerodynamical properties of the dust while evaporating the volatiles. This causes the dust to settle, abandoning those volatiles. The success of this model in explaining the elemental composition of the Earth is a strong argument in favor of highly porous collisionally grown dust grains in protoplanetary disks outside our Solar System. Further, it demonstrates how thermal (or condensation based) alterations of dust porosity, and hence aerodynamics, can be a strong factor in planet formation, leading to the onset of rapid gravitational instabilities in the dust disk and the subsequent collapse that forms planetesimals.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Mineral Processing by Short Circuits in Protoplanetary Disks
Authors:
Colin P. McNally,
Alexander Hubbard,
Mordecai-Mark Mac Low,
Denton S. Ebel,
Paola D'Alessio
Abstract:
Meteoritic chondrules were formed in the early solar system by brief heating of silicate dust to melting temperatures. Some highly refractory grains (Type B calcium-aluminum-rich inclusions, CAIs) also show signs of transient heating. A similar process may occur in other protoplanetary disks, as evidenced by observations of spectra characteristic of crystalline silicates. One possible environment…
▽ More
Meteoritic chondrules were formed in the early solar system by brief heating of silicate dust to melting temperatures. Some highly refractory grains (Type B calcium-aluminum-rich inclusions, CAIs) also show signs of transient heating. A similar process may occur in other protoplanetary disks, as evidenced by observations of spectra characteristic of crystalline silicates. One possible environment for this process is the turbulent magnetohydrodynamic flow thought to drive accretion in these disks. Such flows generally form thin current sheets, which are sites of magnetic reconnection, and dissipate the magnetic fields amplified by a disk dynamo. We suggest that it is possible to heat precursor grains for chondrules and other high-temperature minerals in current sheets that have been concentrated by our recently described short-circuit instability. We extend our work on this process by including the effects of radiative cooling, taking into account the temperature dependence of the opacity; and by examining current sheet geometry in three-dimensional, global models of magnetorotational instability. We find that temperatures above 1600 K can be reached for favorable parameters that match the ideal global models. This mechanism could provide an efficient means of tapping the gravitational potential energy of the protoplanetary disk to heat grains strongly enough to form high-temperature minerals. The volume-filling nature of turbulent magnetic reconnection is compatible with constraints from chondrule-matrix complementarity, chondrule-chondrule complementarity, the occurrence of igneous rims, and compound chondrules. The same short-circuit mechanism may perform other high-temperature mineral processing in protoplanetary disks such as the production of crystalline silicates and CAIs.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2013; v1 submitted 8 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Chondrule Formation and Protoplanetary Disk Heating by Current Sheets in Non-Ideal Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence
Authors:
M. K. Ryan Joung,
Mordecai-Mark Mac Low,
Denton S. Ebel
Abstract:
We study magnetic field steepening due to ambipolar diffusion (Brandenburg & Zweibel 1994) in protoplanetary disk environments and draw the following conclusions. Current sheets are generated in magnetically active regions of the disk where the ionization fraction is high enough for the magnetorotational instability to operate. In late stages of solar nebula evolution, the surface density is exp…
▽ More
We study magnetic field steepening due to ambipolar diffusion (Brandenburg & Zweibel 1994) in protoplanetary disk environments and draw the following conclusions. Current sheets are generated in magnetically active regions of the disk where the ionization fraction is high enough for the magnetorotational instability to operate. In late stages of solar nebula evolution, the surface density is expected to have lowered and dust grains to have gravitationally settled to the midplane. If the local dust-to-gas mass ratio near the midplane is increased above cosmic abundances by factors > 10^3, current sheets reach high enough temperatures to melt millimeter-sized dust grains, and hence may provide the mechanism to form meteoritic chondrules. In addition, these current sheets possibly explain the near-infrared excesses observed in spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of young stellar objects. Direct imaging of protoplanetary disks via a nulling interferometer or, in the future, a multi-band, adaptive optics coronagraph can test this hypothesis.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2003;
originally announced September 2003.
