-
Blind QSO reconstruction challenge: Exploring methods to reconstruct the Ly$α$ emission line of QSOs
Authors:
Bradley Greig,
Sarah E. I. Bosman,
Frederick B. Davies,
Dominika Ďurovčíková,
Hassan Fathivavsari,
Bin Liu,
Romain A. Meyer,
Zechang Sun,
Valentina D'Odorico,
Simona Gallerani,
Andrei Mesinger,
Yuan-Sen Ting
Abstract:
Reconstructing the intrinsic Ly$α$ line flux from high-$z$ QSOs can place constraints on the neutral hydrogen content of the intergalactic medium during reionisation. There are now $\gtrsim10$ different Ly$α$ reconstruction pipelines using different methodologies to predict the Ly$α$ line flux from correlations with the spectral information redward of Ly$α$. However, there have been few attempts t…
▽ More
Reconstructing the intrinsic Ly$α$ line flux from high-$z$ QSOs can place constraints on the neutral hydrogen content of the intergalactic medium during reionisation. There are now $\gtrsim10$ different Ly$α$ reconstruction pipelines using different methodologies to predict the Ly$α$ line flux from correlations with the spectral information redward of Ly$α$. However, there have been few attempts to directly compare the performance of these pipelines. Therefore, we devised a blind QSO challenge to compare these reconstruction pipelines on a uniform set of objects. Each author was provided de-identified, observed rest-frame QSO spectra with spectral information only redward of 1260Å rest-frame to ensure unbiased reconstruction. We constructed two samples of 30 QSOs, from X-Shooter and SDSS both spanning $3.5<z<4.5$. Importantly, the purpose of this comparison study was not to champion a single, best performing reconstruction pipeline but rather to explore the relative performance of these pipelines over a range of QSOs with broad observational characteristics to infer general trends. In summary, we find machine learning approaches in general provide the strongest ``best guesses" but underestimate the accompanying statistical uncertainty, although these can be recalibrated, whilst pipelines that decompose the spectral information, for example principal component or factor analysis generally perform better at predicting the Ly$α$ profile. Further, we found that reconstruction pipelines trained on SDSS QSOs performed similarly on average for both the X-Shooter and SDSS samples indicating no discernible biases owing to differences in the observational characteristics of the training set or QSO being reconstructed, although the recovered distributions of reconstructions for X-Shooter were broader likely due to an increased fraction of outliers.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Chronicling the reionization history at $6\lesssim z \lesssim 7$ with emergent quasar damping wings
Authors:
Dominika Ďurovčíková,
Anna-Christina Eilers,
Huanqing Chen,
Sindhu Satyavolu,
Girish Kulkarni,
Robert A. Simcoe,
Laura C. Keating,
Martin G. Haehnelt,
Eduardo Bañados
Abstract:
The spectra of high-redshift ($z\gtrsim 6$) quasars contain valuable information on the progression of the Epoch of Reionization (EoR). At redshifts $z<6$, the observed Lyman-series forest shows that the intergalactic medium (IGM) is nearly ionized, while at $z>7$ the observed quasar damping wings indicate high neutral gas fractions. However, there remains a gap in neutral gas fraction constraints…
▽ More
The spectra of high-redshift ($z\gtrsim 6$) quasars contain valuable information on the progression of the Epoch of Reionization (EoR). At redshifts $z<6$, the observed Lyman-series forest shows that the intergalactic medium (IGM) is nearly ionized, while at $z>7$ the observed quasar damping wings indicate high neutral gas fractions. However, there remains a gap in neutral gas fraction constraints at $6\lesssim z \lesssim 7$ where the Lyman series forest becomes saturated but damping wings have yet to fully emerge. In this work, we use a sample of 18 quasar spectra at redshifts $6.0<z<7.1$ to close this gap. We apply neural networks to reconstruct the quasars' continuum emission around the partially absorbed Lyman $α$ line to normalize their spectra, and stack these continuum-normalized spectra in three redshift bins. To increase the robustness of our results, we compare the stacks to a grid of models from two hydrodynamical simulations, ATON and CROC, and we measure the volume-averaged neutral gas fraction, $\bar{x}_{\rm HI}$, while jointly fitting for the mean quasar lifetime, $t_{\rm Q}$, for each stacked spectrum. We chronicle the evolution of neutral gas fraction using the ATON (CROC) models as follows: $\bar{x}_{\rm HI} = 0.21_{-0.07}^{+0.17}$ ($\bar{x}_{\rm HI} = 0.10_{<10^{-4}}^{+0.73}$) at $\langle z \rangle =6.10$, $\bar{x}_{\rm HI} = 0.21_{-0.07}^{+0.33}$ ($\bar{x}_{\rm HI} =0.57_{-0.47}^{+0.26}$) at $\langle z \rangle =6.46$, and $\bar{x}_{\rm HI} = 0.37_{-0.17}^{+0.17}$ ($\bar{x}_{\rm HI} =0.57_{-0.21}^{+0.26}$) at $\langle z \rangle =6.87$. At the same time we constrain the average quasar lifetime to be $t_{\rm Q} \lesssim 7\ {\rm Myr}$ across all redshift bins, in good agreement with previous studies.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
EIGER III. JWST/NIRCam observations of the ultra-luminous high-redshift quasar J0100+2802
Authors:
Anna-Christina Eilers,
Robert A. Simcoe,
Minghao Yue,
Ruari Mackenzie,
Jorryt Matthee,
Dominika Durovcikova,
Daichi Kashino,
Rongmon Bordoloi,
Simon J. Lilly
Abstract:
We present the first rest-frame optical spectrum of a high-redshift quasar observed with JWST/NIRCam in Wide Field Slitless (WFSS) mode. The observed quasar, J0100+2802, is the most luminous quasar known at $z>6$. We measure the mass of the central supermassive black hole (SMBH) by means of the rest-frame optical H$β$ emission line, and find consistent mass measurements of the quasar's SMBH of…
▽ More
We present the first rest-frame optical spectrum of a high-redshift quasar observed with JWST/NIRCam in Wide Field Slitless (WFSS) mode. The observed quasar, J0100+2802, is the most luminous quasar known at $z>6$. We measure the mass of the central supermassive black hole (SMBH) by means of the rest-frame optical H$β$ emission line, and find consistent mass measurements of the quasar's SMBH of $M_\bullet\approx10^{10}\,M_\odot$ when compared to the estimates based on the properties of rest-frame UV emission lines CIV and MgII, which are accessible from ground-based observatories. To this end, we also present a newly reduced rest-frame UV spectrum of the quasar observed with X-Shooter/VLT and FIRE/Magellan for a total of 16.8 hours. We readdress the question whether this ultra-luminous quasar could be effected by strong gravitational lensing making use of the diffraction limited NIRCam images in three different wide band filters (F115W, F200W, F356W), which improves the achieved spatial resolution compared to previous images taken with the Hubble Space Telescope by a factor of two. We do not find any evidence for a foreground deflecting galaxy, nor for multiple images of the quasar, and determine the probability for magnification due to strong gravitational lensing with image separations below the diffraction limit of $Δθ\lesssim 0.05''$ to be $\lesssim 2.2\times 10^{-3}$. Our observations therefore confirm that this quasar hosts a ten billion solar mass black hole less than $1$ Gyr after the Big Bang, which is challenging to explain with current black hole formation models.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2023; v1 submitted 29 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
A comparison of quasar emission reconstruction techniques for $z\geq5.0$ Lyman-$α$ and Lyman-$β$ transmission
Authors:
S. E. I. Bosman,
D. Ďurovčíková,
F. B. Davies,
A. C. Eilers
Abstract:
Reconstruction techniques for intrinsic quasar continua are crucial for the precision study of Lyman-$α$ (Ly-$α$) and Lyman-$β$ (Ly-$β$) transmission at $z>5.0$, where the $λ<1215 A$ emission of quasars is nearly completely absorbed. While the number and quality of spectroscopic observations has become theoretically sufficient to quantify Ly-$α$ transmission at $5.0<z<6.0$ to better than $1\%$, th…
▽ More
Reconstruction techniques for intrinsic quasar continua are crucial for the precision study of Lyman-$α$ (Ly-$α$) and Lyman-$β$ (Ly-$β$) transmission at $z>5.0$, where the $λ<1215 A$ emission of quasars is nearly completely absorbed. While the number and quality of spectroscopic observations has become theoretically sufficient to quantify Ly-$α$ transmission at $5.0<z<6.0$ to better than $1\%$, the biases and uncertainties arising from predicting the unabsorbed continuum are not known to the same level. In this paper, we systematically evaluate eight reconstruction techniques on a unified testing sample of $2.7<z<3.5$ quasars drawn from eBOSS. The methods include power-law extrapolation, stacking of neighbours, and six variants of Principal Component Analysis (PCA) using direct projection, fitting of components, or neural networks to perform weight mapping. We find that power-law reconstructions and the PCA with fewest components and smallest training sample display the largest biases in the Ly-$α$ forest ($-9.58\%/+8.22\%$ respectively). Power-law extrapolations have larger scatters than previously assumed of $+13.1\%/-13.2\%$ over Ly-$α$ and $+19.9\%/-20.1\%$ over Ly-$β$. We present two new PCAs which achieve the best current accuracies of $9\%$ for Ly-$α$ and $17\%$ for Ly-$β$. We apply the eight techniques after accounting for wavelength-dependent biases and scatter to a sample $19$ quasars at $z>5.7$ with IR X-Shooter spectroscopy, obtaining well-characterised measurements for the mean flux transmission at $4.7<z<6.3$. Our results demonstrate the importance of testing and, when relevant, training, continuum reconstruction techniques in a systematic way.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2021; v1 submitted 18 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Fully probabilistic quasar continua predictions near Lyman-α with conditional neural spline flows
Authors:
David M. Reiman,
John Tamanas,
J. Xavier Prochaska,
Dominika Ďurovčíková
Abstract:
Measurement of the red damping wing of neutral hydrogen in quasar spectra provides a probe of the epoch of reionization in the early Universe. Such quantification requires precise and unbiased estimates of the intrinsic continua near Lyman-$α$ (Ly$α$), a challenging task given the highly variable Ly$α$ emission profiles of quasars. Here, we introduce a fully probabilistic approach to intrinsic con…
▽ More
Measurement of the red damping wing of neutral hydrogen in quasar spectra provides a probe of the epoch of reionization in the early Universe. Such quantification requires precise and unbiased estimates of the intrinsic continua near Lyman-$α$ (Ly$α$), a challenging task given the highly variable Ly$α$ emission profiles of quasars. Here, we introduce a fully probabilistic approach to intrinsic continua prediction. We frame the problem as a conditional density estimation task and explicitly model the distribution over plausible blue-side continua ($1190\ \unicode{xC5} \leq λ_{\text{rest}} < 1290\ \unicode{xC5}$) conditional on the red-side spectrum ($1290\ \unicode{xC5} \leq λ_{\text{rest}} < 2900\ \unicode{xC5}$) using normalizing flows. Our approach achieves state-of-the-art precision and accuracy, allows for sampling one thousand plausible continua in less than a tenth of a second, and can natively provide confidence intervals on the blue-side continua via Monte Carlo sampling. We measure the damping wing effect in two $z>7$ quasars and estimate the volume-averaged neutral fraction of hydrogen from each, finding $\bar{x}_\text{HI}=0.304 \pm 0.042$ for ULAS J1120+0641 ($z=7.09$) and $\bar{x}_\text{HI}=0.384 \pm 0.133$ for ULAS J1342+0928 ($z=7.54$).
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2020; v1 submitted 31 May, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
New Methods for Identifying Lyman Continuum Leakers and Reionization-Epoch Analogues
Authors:
Harley Katz,
Dominika Ďurovčíková,
Taysun Kimm,
Joki Rosdahl,
Jeremy Blaizot,
Martin G. Haehnelt,
Julien Devriendt,
Adrianne Slyz,
Richard Ellis,
Nicolas Laporte
Abstract:
Identifying low-redshift galaxies that emit Lyman Continuum radiation (LyC leakers) is one of the primary, indirect methods of studying galaxy formation in the epoch of reionization. However, not only has it proved challenging to identify such systems, it also remains uncertain whether the low-redshift LyC leakers are truly "analogues" of the sources that reionized the Universe. Here, we use high-…
▽ More
Identifying low-redshift galaxies that emit Lyman Continuum radiation (LyC leakers) is one of the primary, indirect methods of studying galaxy formation in the epoch of reionization. However, not only has it proved challenging to identify such systems, it also remains uncertain whether the low-redshift LyC leakers are truly "analogues" of the sources that reionized the Universe. Here, we use high-resolution cosmological radiation hydrodynamics simulations to examine whether simulated galaxies in the epoch of reionization share similar emission line properties to observed LyC leakers at $z\sim3$ and $z\sim0$. We find that the simulated galaxies with high LyC escape fractions ($f_{\rm esc}$) often exhibit high O32 and populate the same regions of the R23-O32 plane as $z\sim3$ LyC leakers. However, we show that viewing angle, metallicity, and ionisation parameter can all impact where a galaxy resides on the O32-$f_{\rm esc}$ plane. Based on emission line diagnostics and how they correlate with $f_{\rm esc}$, lower-metallicity LyC leakers at $z\sim3$ appear to be good analogues of reionization-era galaxies. In contrast, local [SII]-deficient galaxies do not overlap with the simulated high-redshift LyC leakers on the SII-BPT diagram; however, this diagnostic may still be useful for identifying leakers. We use our simulated galaxies to develop multiple new diagnostics to identify LyC leakers using IR and nebular emission lines. We show that our model using only [CII]$_{\rm 158μm}$ and [OIII]$_{\rm 88μm}$ can identify potential leakers from non-leakers from the local Dwarf Galaxy Survey. Finally, we apply this diagnostic to known high-redshift galaxies and find that MACS1149_JD1 at $z=9.1$ is the most likely galaxy to be actively contributing to the reionization of the Universe.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2020; v1 submitted 4 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Reionization history constraints from neural network based predictions of high-redshift quasar continua
Authors:
D. Ďurovčíková,
H. Katz,
S. E. I. Bosman,
F. B. Davies,
J. Devriendt,
A. Slyz
Abstract:
Observations of the early Universe suggest that reionization was complete by $z\sim6$, however, the exact history of this process is still unknown. One method for measuring the evolution of the neutral fraction throughout this epoch is via observing the Ly$α$ damping wings of high-redshift quasars. In order to constrain the neutral fraction from quasar observations, one needs an accurate model of…
▽ More
Observations of the early Universe suggest that reionization was complete by $z\sim6$, however, the exact history of this process is still unknown. One method for measuring the evolution of the neutral fraction throughout this epoch is via observing the Ly$α$ damping wings of high-redshift quasars. In order to constrain the neutral fraction from quasar observations, one needs an accurate model of the quasar spectrum around Ly$α$, after the spectrum has been processed by its host galaxy but before it is altered by absorption and damping in the intervening IGM. In this paper, we present a novel machine learning approach, using artificial neural networks, to reconstruct quasar continua around Ly$α$. Our QSANNdRA algorithm improves the error in this reconstruction compared to the state-of-the-art PCA-based model in the literature by 14.2% on average, and provides an improvement of 6.1% on average when compared to an extension thereof. In comparison with the extended PCA model, QSANNdRA further achieves an improvement of 22.1% and 16.8% when evaluated on low-redshift quasars most similar to the two high-redshift quasars under consideration, ULAS J1120+0641 at $z=7.0851$ and ULAS J1342+0928 at $z=7.5413$, respectively. Using our more accurate reconstructions of these two $z>7$ quasars, we estimate the neutral fraction of the IGM using a homogeneous reionization model and find $\bar{x}_\mathrm{HI} = 0.25^{+0.05}_{-0.05}$ at $z=7.0851$ and $\bar{x}_\mathrm{HI} = 0.60^{+0.11}_{-0.11}$ at $z=7.5413$. Our results are consistent with the literature and favour a rapid end to reionization.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2020; v1 submitted 2 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
