-
Spectroscopic Confirmation of Two Luminous Post-AGB Stars in the Globular Cluster M19
Authors:
Howard E. Bond,
Jacob E. Jencson,
Robin Ciardullo,
Brian D. Davis,
Michael H. Siegel
Abstract:
The visually brightest stars in globular clusters (GCs) are the ones evolving off the asymptotic giant branch (AGB) and passing through spectral types F and A--the "yellow" post-AGB (yPAGB) stars. yPAGB stars are potentially excellent "Population II" standard candles for measuring extragalactic distances. A recent survey of the Galactic GC system, using uBVI photometry to identify stars of low sur…
▽ More
The visually brightest stars in globular clusters (GCs) are the ones evolving off the asymptotic giant branch (AGB) and passing through spectral types F and A--the "yellow" post-AGB (yPAGB) stars. yPAGB stars are potentially excellent "Population II" standard candles for measuring extragalactic distances. A recent survey of the Galactic GC system, using uBVI photometry to identify stars of low surface gravities with large Balmer discontinuities, discovered a candidate luminous yPAGB star in the GC M19 (NGC 6273), designated ZNG 4. The same survey also identified a bright, hotter candidate blue PAGB star, ZNG 2, lying near the top of the white-dwarf cooling sequence. Both PAGB candidates have proper motions and parallaxes in the recent Gaia Early Data Release 3 consistent with cluster membership, but they still lacked spectroscopic verification. Here we present moderate-resolution spectra of both stars, confirming them as low-gravity objects that are extremely likely to be cluster members. Through comparison with a library of synthetic spectra, we made approximate estimates of the stars' atmospheric parameters. We find that the yPAGB star ZNG 4 has an effective temperature of Teff ~ 6500 K, a surface gravity of log g ~ 1, and a metallicity of [Fe/H] ~ -1.5, similar to that of the host cluster. The blue PAGB star ZNG 2 has Teff ~ 18000 K, log g ~ 3, and an apparently low metallicity in the range of [Fe/H] ~ -2.0 to -2.5. Both stars are bright (V=12.5 and 13.3, respectively). We urge high-dispersion spectroscopic follow-up to determine detailed atmospheric parameters and chemical compositions, and to monitor radial velocities.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Yellow Post-Asymptotic-Giant-Branch Stars as Standard Candles. I. Calibration of the Luminosity Function in Galactic Globular Clusters
Authors:
Robin Ciardullo,
Howard E. Bond,
Brian D. Davis,
Michael H. Siegel
Abstract:
We use results of a survey for low-surface-gravity stars in Galactic (and LMC) globular clusters to show that "yellow" post-asymptotic-giant-branch (yPAGB) stars are likely to be excellent extragalactic standard candles, capable of producing distances to early-type galaxies that are accurate to a few percent. We show that the mean bolometric magnitude of the 10 known yPAGB stars in globular cluste…
▽ More
We use results of a survey for low-surface-gravity stars in Galactic (and LMC) globular clusters to show that "yellow" post-asymptotic-giant-branch (yPAGB) stars are likely to be excellent extragalactic standard candles, capable of producing distances to early-type galaxies that are accurate to a few percent. We show that the mean bolometric magnitude of the 10 known yPAGB stars in globular clusters is <Mbol> = -3.38 +/- 0.03, a value that is ~0.2 mag brighter than that predicted from the latest post-horizontal-branch evolutionary tracks. More importantly, we show that the observed dispersion in the distribution is only 0.10 mag, i.e., smaller than the scatter for individual Cepheids. We describe the physics that can produce such a small dispersion, and show that, if one restricts surveys to the color range 0 < (B-V)0 < 0.5, then samples of non-variable yPAGB stars can be identified quite easily with a minimum of contamination. The bright absolute V magnitudes of these stars (<Mv> = -3.37) make them, by far, the visually brightest objects in old stellar populations and ideal Population II standard candles for measurements out to ~10 Mpc with current instrumentation. A Hubble Space Telescope survey in the halos of galaxies in the M81 and Sculptor groups could therefore serve as an effective cross-check on both the Cepheid and TRGB distance scales.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
A Census of Above-Horizontal-Branch Stars in Galactic Globular Clusters
Authors:
Brian D. Davis,
Howard E. Bond,
Michael H. Siegel,
Robin Ciardullo
Abstract:
We have carried out a search for above-horizontal-branch (AHB) stars--objects lying above the horizontal branch (HB) and blueward of the asymptotic giant branch (AGB) in the color-magnitude diagram--in 97 Galactic and seven Magellanic Cloud globular clusters (GCs). We selected AHB candidates based on photometry in the $uBVI$ system, which is optimized for detection of low-gravity stars with large…
▽ More
We have carried out a search for above-horizontal-branch (AHB) stars--objects lying above the horizontal branch (HB) and blueward of the asymptotic giant branch (AGB) in the color-magnitude diagram--in 97 Galactic and seven Magellanic Cloud globular clusters (GCs). We selected AHB candidates based on photometry in the $uBVI$ system, which is optimized for detection of low-gravity stars with large Balmer jumps, in the color range $-0.05\le(B-V)_0\le1.0$. We then used $Gaia$ astrometry and Gaussian-mixture modeling to confirm cluster membership and remove field interlopers. Our final catalog contains 438 AHB stars, classified and interpreted in the context of post-HB evolution as follows: (1) AHB1: 280 stars fainter than $M_V=-0.8$, evolving redward from the blue HB (BHB) toward the base of the AGB. (2) Post-AGB (PAGB): 13 stars brighter than $M_V\simeq-2.75$, departing from the top of the AGB and evolving rapidly blueward. (3) AHB2: 145 stars, with absolute magnitudes between those of the AHB1 and PAGB groups. This last category includes a mixture of objects leaving the extreme BHB and evolving toward the AGB, and brighter ones moving back from the AGB toward higher temperatures. Among the AHB1 stars are 59 RR Lyrae interlopers, observed by chance in our survey near maximum light. PAGB and AHB2 stars (including W Virginis Cepheids) overwhelmingly belong to GCs containing BHB stars, in accordance with predictions of post-HB evolutionary tracks. We suggest that most W Vir variables are evolving toward lower temperatures and are in their first crossings of the instability strip. Non-variable yellow PAGB stars show promise as a Population II standard candle for distance measurement.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Towards Precision Cosmology With Improved PNLF Distances Using VLT-MUSE I. Methodology and Tests
Authors:
Martin M. Roth,
George H. Jacoby,
Robin Ciardullo,
Brian D. Davis,
Owen Chase,
Peter M. Weilbacher
Abstract:
The [O III ] 5007 Planetary Nebula Luminosity Function (PNLF) is an established distance indicator that has been used for more than 30 years to measure the distances of galaxies out to ~15 Mpc. With the advent of the Multi-Unit Spectroscopic Explorer on the Very Large Telescope (MUSE) as an efficient wide-field integral field spectrograph, the PNLF method is due for a renaissance, as the spatial a…
▽ More
The [O III ] 5007 Planetary Nebula Luminosity Function (PNLF) is an established distance indicator that has been used for more than 30 years to measure the distances of galaxies out to ~15 Mpc. With the advent of the Multi-Unit Spectroscopic Explorer on the Very Large Telescope (MUSE) as an efficient wide-field integral field spectrograph, the PNLF method is due for a renaissance, as the spatial and spectral information contained in the instrument's datacubes provides many advantages over classical narrow-band imaging. Here we use archival MUSE data to explore the potential of a novel differential emission-line filter (DELF) technique to produce spectrophotometry that is more accurate and more sensitive than other methods. We show that DELF analyses are superior to classical techniques in high surface brightness regions of galaxies and we validate the method both through simulations and via the analysis of data from two early-type galaxies (NGC 1380 and NGC 474) and one late-type spiral (NGC 628). We demonstrate that with adaptive optics support or under excellent seeing conditions, the technique is capable of producing precision (< 0.05 mag) [O III ] photometry out to distances of 40 Mpc while providing discrimination between planetary nebulae and other emission-line objects such as H II regions, supernova remnants, and background galaxies. These capabilities enable us to use MUSE to measure precise PNLF distances beyond the reach of Cepheids and the tip of the red giant branch method, and become an additional tool for constraining the local value of the Hubble constant.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Two Luminous Post-AGB Stars in the Galactic Globular Cluster M19
Authors:
Howard E. Bond,
Brian D. Davis,
Michael H. Siegel,
Robin Ciardullo
Abstract:
We report the discovery of a luminous "yellow" post-asymptotic-giant-branch (PAGB) star in the globular cluster (GC) M19 (NGC 6273), identified during our uBVI survey of Galactic GCs. The uBVI photometric system is optimized to detect stars with large Balmer discontinuities, indicating very low surface gravities and high luminosities. The spectral-energy distribution (SED) of the star is consisten…
▽ More
We report the discovery of a luminous "yellow" post-asymptotic-giant-branch (PAGB) star in the globular cluster (GC) M19 (NGC 6273), identified during our uBVI survey of Galactic GCs. The uBVI photometric system is optimized to detect stars with large Balmer discontinuities, indicating very low surface gravities and high luminosities. The spectral-energy distribution (SED) of the star is consistent with an effective temperature of about 6250 K and a surface gravity of $\log g=0.5$. We use Gaia data to show that the star's proper motion and radial velocity are consistent with cluster membership. One aim of our program is to test yellow PAGB stars as candidate Population II standard candles for determining extragalactic distances. We derive a visual absolute magnitude of $M_V=-3.39\pm0.09$ for the M19 star. This is in close agreement with the $M_V$ values found for yellow PAGB stars in the GCs omega Cen, NGC 5986, and M79, indicating a very narrow luminosity function. These objects are four magnitudes brighter than RR Lyrae variables, and they can largely avoid the issues of interstellar extinction that are a problem for Population I distance indicators. We also identified a second luminous PAGB object in M19, this one a hotter "UV-bright" star. Its SED is consistent with an effective temperature of about 11,750 K and $\log g=2.0$. The two objects have nearly identical bolometric luminosities, $\log L/L_\odot=3.24$ and 3.22, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Hubble Space Telescope Spectroscopy of a Planetary Nebula in an M31 Open Cluster: Hot-Bottom Burning at $3.4 \, M_{\odot}$
Authors:
Brian D. Davis,
Howard E. Bond,
Robin Ciardullo,
George H. Jacoby
Abstract:
We use imaging and spectroscopy from the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) to examine the properties of a bright planetary nebula (PN) projected within M31's young open cluster B477-D075. We show that the probability of a chance superposition of the PN on the cluster is small, ${\lesssim}2\%$. Moreover, the radial velocity of the PN is the same as that of the cluster within the measurement error of…
▽ More
We use imaging and spectroscopy from the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) to examine the properties of a bright planetary nebula (PN) projected within M31's young open cluster B477-D075. We show that the probability of a chance superposition of the PN on the cluster is small, ${\lesssim}2\%$. Moreover, the radial velocity of the PN is the same as that of the cluster within the measurement error of ${\sim}10$ km s$^{-1}$. Given the expected ${\sim}70$ km s$^{-1}$ velocity dispersion in this region, ${\sim}$8 kpc from M31's nucleus, the velocity data again make it extremely likely that the PN belongs to the cluster. Applying isochrone fitting to archival color-magnitude photometric data from the HST Advanced Camera for Surveys, we determine the cluster age and metallicity to be 290 Myr and $Z = 0.0071$, respectively, implying an initial mass of $3.38^{+0.03}_{-0.02} \, M_{\odot}$ for any PN produced by the cluster. From HST's Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph observations and Cloudy photoionization modeling, we find that the PN is likely a Type I planetary, with a nitrogen abundance that is enhanced by ${\sim}$5-6 times over the solar value scaled to the cluster metallicity. If the PN is indeed a cluster member, these data present strong empirical evidence that hot-bottom burning occurs in AGB stars with initial masses as low as $3.4 \, M_{\odot}$.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
The True Luminosities of Planetary Nebulae in M31's Bulge: Massive Central Stars from an Old Stellar Population
Authors:
Brian D. Davis,
Robin Ciardullo,
George H. Jacoby,
John. J. Feldmeier,
Briana L. Indahl
Abstract:
We measure the Balmer decrements of 23 of the brightest planetary nebulae (PNe) in the inner bulge ($r \lesssim 3$ arcmin) of M31 and de-redden the bright end of the region's [O III] $λ5007$ planetary nebula luminosity function. We show that the most luminous PNe produce $\gtrsim 1{,}200 \, \rm{L}_{\odot}$ of power in their [O III] $λ5007$ line, implying central star luminosities of at least…
▽ More
We measure the Balmer decrements of 23 of the brightest planetary nebulae (PNe) in the inner bulge ($r \lesssim 3$ arcmin) of M31 and de-redden the bright end of the region's [O III] $λ5007$ planetary nebula luminosity function. We show that the most luminous PNe produce $\gtrsim 1{,}200 \, \rm{L}_{\odot}$ of power in their [O III] $λ5007$ line, implying central star luminosities of at least $\sim 11{,}000 \, \rm{L}_{\odot}$. Even with the most recent accelerated-evolution post-AGB models, such luminosities require central star masses in excess of $0.66 \, \rm{M}_{\odot}$, and main sequence progenitors of at least $\sim 2.5 \, \rm{M}_{\odot}$. Since M31's bulge has very few intermediate-age stars, we conclude that conventional single-star evolution cannot be responsible for these extremely luminous objects. We also present the circumstellar extinctions for the region's bright PNe and demonstrate that the distribution is similar to that found for PNe in the Large Magellanic Cloud, with a median value of $A_{5007} = 0.71$. Finally, we compare our results to extinction measurements made for PNe in the E6 elliptical NGC 4697 and the interacting lenticular NGC 5128. We show that such extinctions are not unusual, and that the existence of very high-mass PN central stars is a general feature of old stellar populations. Our results suggest that single-star population synthesis models significantly underestimate the maximum luminosities and total integrated light of AGB stars.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2018; v1 submitted 13 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
The Planetary Nebula Luminosity Function (PNLF): Contamination from Supernova Remnants
Authors:
Brian D. Davis,
Robin Ciardullo,
John J. Feldmeier,
George H. Jacoby
Abstract:
The planetary nebula luminosity function (PNLF) has been used as an extragalactic distance indicator since the 1980's, but there are still unsolved problems associated with its use. One of the most serious involves PNLF distances beyond ~ 10 Mpc, which tend to be slightly smaller than those of other methods. We consider the implications of previous spectroscopic investigations that found that seve…
▽ More
The planetary nebula luminosity function (PNLF) has been used as an extragalactic distance indicator since the 1980's, but there are still unsolved problems associated with its use. One of the most serious involves PNLF distances beyond ~ 10 Mpc, which tend to be slightly smaller than those of other methods. We consider the implications of previous spectroscopic investigations that found that several of the brightest planetary nebula (PN) candidates in M74 are actually compact supernova remnants (SNRs). Using narrow-band imaging data from the KPNO 4-m telescope, we measure the [O III] $λ$5007 and H$α$ fluxes of all the known SNRs in M31 and M33, and test whether those objects could be misidentified as bright PNe at distances beyond ~ 10 Mpc. Our results suggest that compact SNRs are not an important source of contamination in photometric surveys for extragalactic PNe.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
The Recurrent Nova Candidate M31N 1966-08a = 1968-10c is a Galactic Flare Star
Authors:
A. W. Shafter,
M. Henze,
M. J. Darnley,
R. Ciardullo,
B. D. Davis,
S. L. Hawley
Abstract:
A spectrum of the quiescent counterpart of the Recurrent Nova candidate M31N 1966-08a (= M31N 1968-10c) obtained with LRS2 on the Hobby-Eberly Telescope reveals the object to be a foreground Galactic dMe flare star, and not a nova in M31.
A spectrum of the quiescent counterpart of the Recurrent Nova candidate M31N 1966-08a (= M31N 1968-10c) obtained with LRS2 on the Hobby-Eberly Telescope reveals the object to be a foreground Galactic dMe flare star, and not a nova in M31.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
