-
Unveiling complex magnetic field configurations in red giant stars
Authors:
Srijan Bharati Das,
Lukas Einramhof,
Lisa Bugnet
Abstract:
Recent measurements of magnetic field strength inside the radiative interior of red giant stars open the way towards the characterization of the geometry of stable large-scale magnetic fields. However, current measurements do not properly constrain the topology of magnetic fields due to degeneracies on the observed magnetic field signature on such $\ell=1$ mode frequencies. Efforts focused towards…
▽ More
Recent measurements of magnetic field strength inside the radiative interior of red giant stars open the way towards the characterization of the geometry of stable large-scale magnetic fields. However, current measurements do not properly constrain the topology of magnetic fields due to degeneracies on the observed magnetic field signature on such $\ell=1$ mode frequencies. Efforts focused towards unambiguous detections of magnetic field configurations are now key to better understand angular momentum transport in stars. We investigate the detectability of complex magnetic field topologies inside the radiative interior of red giants. We focus on a field composed of a combination of a dipole and a quadrupole (quadrudipole), and on an offset field. We explore the potential of probing such magnetic field topologies from a combined measurement of magnetic signatures on $\ell=1$ and quadrupolar ($\ell=2$) mixed mode oscillation frequencies. We first derive the asymptotic theoretical formalism for computing the asymmetric signature in frequency pattern for $\ell=2$ modes due to a quadrudipole magnetic field. The degeneracy of the quadrudipole with a dipole is lifted when considering both $\ell=1$ and $\ell=2$ mode frequencies. In addition to the analytical derivation for the quadrudipole, we present the prospect for complex magnetic field inversions using magnetic sensitivity kernels from standard perturbation analysis for forward modeling. Using this method, we demonstrate that offset fields may be mistaken for weak and centered magnetic fields, resulting in underestimating magnetic field strength in stellar cores. We emphasize the need to characterize $\ell=2$ mixed-mode frequencies, (along with the currently characterized $\ell=1$ mixed modes), to unveil the higher-order components of the geometry of buried magnetic fields, and better constrain angular momentum transport inside stars.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Detectability of axisymmetric magnetic fields from the core to the surface of oscillating post-main sequence stars
Authors:
Shatanik Bhattacharya,
Srijan Bharati Das,
Lisa Bugnet,
Subrata Panda,
Shravan M. Hanasoge
Abstract:
Magnetic fields in the stellar interiors are key candidates to explain observed core rotation rates inside solar-like stars along their evolution. Recently, asteroseismic estimates of radial magnetic field amplitudes near the hydrogen-burning shell (H-shell) inside about 24 red-giants (RGs) have been obtained by measuring frequency splittings from their power spectra. Using general Lorentz-stress…
▽ More
Magnetic fields in the stellar interiors are key candidates to explain observed core rotation rates inside solar-like stars along their evolution. Recently, asteroseismic estimates of radial magnetic field amplitudes near the hydrogen-burning shell (H-shell) inside about 24 red-giants (RGs) have been obtained by measuring frequency splittings from their power spectra. Using general Lorentz-stress (magnetic) kernels, we investigated the potential for detectability of near-surface magnetism in a 1.3 $M_{\odot}$ star of super-solar metallicity as it evolves from a mid sub-giant to a late sub-giant into an RG. Based on these sensitivity kernels, we decompose an RG into three zones - deep core, H-shell, and near-surface. The sub-giants instead required decomposition into an inner core, an outer core, and a near-surface layer. Additionally, we find that for a low-frequency g-dominated dipolar mode in the presence of a typical stable magnetic field, ~25% of the frequency shift comes from the H-shell and the remaining from deeper layers. The ratio of the subsurface tangential field to the radial field in H-burning shell decides if subsurface fields may be potentially detectable. For p-dominated dipole modes close to $ν_\rm{max}$, this ratio is around two orders of magnitude smaller in subgiant phases than the corresponding RG. Further, with the availability of magnetic kernels, we propose lower limits of field strengths in crucial layers in our stellar model during its evolutionary phases. The theoretical prescription outlined here provides the first formal way to devise inverse problems for stellar magnetism and can be seamlessly employed for slow rotators.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Magnetic flux in the Sun emerges unaffected by supergranular-scale surface flows
Authors:
Prasad Mani,
Chris S. Hanson,
Siddarth Dhanpal,
Shravan Hanasoge,
Srijan Bharati Das,
Matthias Rempel
Abstract:
Magnetic flux emergence from the convection zone into the photosphere and beyond is a critical component of the behaviour of large-scale solar magnetism. Flux rarely emerges amid field-free areas at the surface, but when it does, the interaction between magnetism and plasma flows can be reliably explored. Prior ensemble studies identified weak flows forming near emergence locations, but the low si…
▽ More
Magnetic flux emergence from the convection zone into the photosphere and beyond is a critical component of the behaviour of large-scale solar magnetism. Flux rarely emerges amid field-free areas at the surface, but when it does, the interaction between magnetism and plasma flows can be reliably explored. Prior ensemble studies identified weak flows forming near emergence locations, but the low signal-to-noise required averaging over the entire dataset, erasing information about variation across the sample. Here, we apply deep learning to achieve improved signal-to-noise, enabling a case-by-case study. We find that these associated flows are dissimilar across instances of emergence and also occur frequently in the quiet convective background. Our analysis suggests diminished influence of supergranular-scale convective flows and magnetic buoyancy on flux rise. Consistent with numerical evidence, we speculate that small-scale surface turbulence and / or deep-convective processes play an outsize role in driving flux emergence.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Minuscule corrections to near-surface solar internal rotation using mode-coupling
Authors:
Srijan Bharati Das,
Samarth G. Kashyap,
Deniz Oktay,
Shravan M. Hanasoge,
Jeroen Tromp
Abstract:
The observed solar oscillation spectrum is influenced by internal perturbations such as flows and structural asphericities. These features induce splitting of characteristic frequencies and distort the resonant-mode eigenfunctions. Global axisymmertric flow -- differential rotation -- is a very prominent perturbation. Tightly constrained rotation profiles as a function of latitude and radius are p…
▽ More
The observed solar oscillation spectrum is influenced by internal perturbations such as flows and structural asphericities. These features induce splitting of characteristic frequencies and distort the resonant-mode eigenfunctions. Global axisymmertric flow -- differential rotation -- is a very prominent perturbation. Tightly constrained rotation profiles as a function of latitude and radius are products of established helioseismic pipelines that use observed Dopplergrams to generate frequency-splitting measurements at high precision. However, the inference of rotation using frequency-splittings do not consider the effect of mode-coupling. This approximation worsens for high-angular-degree modes, as they become increasingly proximal in frequency. Since modes with high angular degrees probe the near-surface layers of the Sun, inversions considering coupled modes could potentially lead to more accurate estimates of rotation very close to the surface. In order to investigate if this is indeed the case, we perform inversions for solar differential rotation, considering coupling of modes for angular degrees $160 \leq \ell \leq 300$ in the surface gravity $f$-branch and first-overtone $p$ modes. In keeping with the character of mode coupling, we carry out a non-linear inversion using an eigenvalue solver. Differences in inverted profiles for frequency splitting measurements from MDI and HMI are compared and discussed. We find that corrections to the near-surface differential rotation profile, when accounting for mode-coupling effects, are smaller than 0.003 nHz and hence are insignificant. These minuscule corrections are found to be correlated with the solar cycle. We also present corrections to even-order splitting coefficients, which could consequently impact inversions for structure and magnetic fields.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Recipe for inferring sub-surface solar magnetism via local mode-coupling using Slepian basis functions
Authors:
Srijan Bharati Das
Abstract:
Direct seismic imaging of sub-surface flow, sound-speed and magnetic field is crucial for predicting flux tube emergence on the solar surface, an important ingredient for space weather. The sensitivity of helioseismic mode-amplitude cross-correlation to $p$- and $f$-mode oscillations enable formal inversion of such sub-photospheric perturbations. It is well-known that such problems are written in…
▽ More
Direct seismic imaging of sub-surface flow, sound-speed and magnetic field is crucial for predicting flux tube emergence on the solar surface, an important ingredient for space weather. The sensitivity of helioseismic mode-amplitude cross-correlation to $p$- and $f$-mode oscillations enable formal inversion of such sub-photospheric perturbations. It is well-known that such problems are written in the form of an integral equation that connects the perturbations to the observations via ``sensitivity kernels". While the sensitivity kernels for flow and sound-speed have been known for decades and have been used extensively, formulating kernels for general magnetic perturbations had been elusive. A recent study proposed sensitivity kernels for Lorentz-stresses corresponding to global magnetic fields of general geometry. The present study is devoted to proposing kernels for inferring Lorentz-stresses as well as the solenoidal magnetic field in a local patch on the Sun via Cartesian mode-coupling. Moreover, for the first time in solar physics, Slepian functions are employed to parameterize perturbations in the horizontal dimension. This is shown to increase the number of data constraints in the inverse problem, implying an increase in the precision of inferred parameters. This paves the path to reliably imaging sub-surface solar magnetic features in, e.g., supergranules, sunspots and (emerging) active regions.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Inferring solar differential rotation through normal-mode coupling using Bayesian statistics
Authors:
Samarth G. Kashyap,
Srijan Bharati Das,
Shravan M. Hanasoge,
Martin F. Woodard,
Jeroen Tromp
Abstract:
Normal-mode helioseismic data analysis uses observed solar oscillation spectra to infer perturbations in the solar interior due to global and local-scale flows and structural asphericity. Differential rotation, the dominant global-scale axisymmetric perturbation, has been tightly constrained primarily using measurements of frequency splittings via "$a$-coefficients". However, the frequency-splitti…
▽ More
Normal-mode helioseismic data analysis uses observed solar oscillation spectra to infer perturbations in the solar interior due to global and local-scale flows and structural asphericity. Differential rotation, the dominant global-scale axisymmetric perturbation, has been tightly constrained primarily using measurements of frequency splittings via "$a$-coefficients". However, the frequency-splitting formalism invokes the approximation that multiplets are isolated. This assumption is inaccurate for modes at high angular degrees. Analysing eigenfunction corrections, which respect cross coupling of modes across multiplets, is a more accurate approach. However, applying standard inversion techniques using these cross-spectral measurements yields $a$-coefficients with a significantly wider spread than the well-constrained results from frequency splittings. In this study, we apply Bayesian statistics to infer $a$-coefficients due to differential rotation from cross spectra for both $f$-modes and $p$-modes. We demonstrate that this technique works reasonably well for modes with angular degrees $\ell=50-291$. The inferred $a_3-$coefficients are found to be within $1$ nHz of the frequency splitting values for $\ell > 200$. We also show that the technique fails at $\ell < 50$ owing to the insensitivity of the measurement to the perturbation. These results serve to further establish mode coupling as an important helioseismic technique with which to infer internal structure and dynamics, both axisymmetric (e.g., meridional circulation) and non-axisymmetric perturbations.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Sensitivity kernels for inferring Lorentz stresses from normal-mode frequency splittings in the Sun
Authors:
Srijan Bharati Das,
Tuneer Chakraborty,
Shravan M. Hanasoge,
Jeroen Tromp
Abstract:
Departures from standard spherically symmetric solar models, in the form of perturbations such as global and local-scale flows and structural asphericities, result in the splitting of eigenfrequencies in the observed spectrum of solar oscillations. Drawing from prevalent ideas in normal-mode coupling theory in geophysical literature, we devise a procedure that enables the computation of sensitivit…
▽ More
Departures from standard spherically symmetric solar models, in the form of perturbations such as global and local-scale flows and structural asphericities, result in the splitting of eigenfrequencies in the observed spectrum of solar oscillations. Drawing from prevalent ideas in normal-mode coupling theory in geophysical literature, we devise a procedure that enables the computation of sensitivity kernels for general Lorentz stress fields in the Sun. Mode coupling due to any perturbation requires careful consideration of self- and cross-coupling of multiplets. Invoking the isolated-multiplet approximation allows for limiting the treatment to purely self-coupling, requiring significantly less computational resources. We identify the presence of such isolated multiplets under the effect of Lorentz stresses in the Sun. Currently, solar missions allow precise measurements of self-coupling of multiplets via "$a$-coefficients" and the cross-spectral correlation signal which enables the estimation of the "structure coefficients". We demonstrate the forward problem for both self-coupling ($a$-coefficients) and cross-coupling (structure coefficients). In doing so, we plot the self-coupling kernels and estimate $a$-coefficients arising from a combination of deep-toroidal and surface-dipolar axisymmetric fields. We also compute the structure coefficients for an arbitrary general magnetic field (real and solenoidal) and plot the corresponding "splitting function", a convenient way to visualize the splitting of multiplets under 3D internal perturbations. The results discussed in this paper pave the way to formally pose an inverse problem, and infer solar internal magnetic fields.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Modeling star-planet interactions in far-out planetary and exoplanetary systems
Authors:
Srijan Bharati Das,
Arnab Basak,
Dibyendu Nandy,
Bhargav Vaidya
Abstract:
The outflowing magnetized wind from a host star shapes planetary and exoplanetary magnetospheres dictating the extent of its impact. We carry out three-dimensional (3D) compressible magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations of the interactions between magnetized stellar winds and planetary magnetospheres corresponding to a far-out star-planet system, with and without planetary dipole obliquity. We ide…
▽ More
The outflowing magnetized wind from a host star shapes planetary and exoplanetary magnetospheres dictating the extent of its impact. We carry out three-dimensional (3D) compressible magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations of the interactions between magnetized stellar winds and planetary magnetospheres corresponding to a far-out star-planet system, with and without planetary dipole obliquity. We identify the pathways that lead to the formation of a dynamical steady-state magnetosphere and find that magnetic reconnection plays a fundamental role in the process. The magnetic energy density is found to be greater on the night-side than that on the day-side and the magnetotail is comparatively more dynamic. Magnetotail reconnection events are seen to associated with stellar wind plasma injection into the inner magnetosphere. We further study magnetospheres with extreme tilt angles keeping in perspective the examples of Uranus and Neptune. High dipole obliquities may also manifest due to polarity excursions during planetary field reversals. We find that global magnetospheric reconnection sites change for large planetary dipole obliquity and more complex current sheet structures are generated. We discuss the implications of these findings for injection of interplanetary species and energetic particles into the inner magnetosphere, auroral activity and magnetospheric radio emission. This study is relevant for exploring star planet interactions in the solar and extra-solar systems.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Wavelet-Based Characterization of Small-Scale Solar Emission Features at Low Radio Frequencies
Authors:
Akshay Suresh,
Rohit Sharma,
Divya Oberoi,
Srijan B. Das,
Victor Pankratius,
Brian Timar,
Colin J. Lonsdale,
Judd D. Bowman,
Frank Briggs,
Roger J. Cappallo,
Brian E. Corey,
Avinash A. Deshpande,
David Emrich,
Robert Goeke,
Lincoln J. Greenhill,
Bryna J. Hazelton,
Melanie Johnston-Hollitt,
David L. Kaplan,
Justin C. Kasper,
Eric Kratzenberg,
Mervyn J. Lynch,
S. Russell McWhirter,
Daniel A. Mitchell,
Miguel F. Morales,
Edward Morgan
, et al. (14 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Low radio frequency solar observations using the Murchison Widefield Array have recently revealed the presence of numerous weak, short-lived and narrow-band emission features, even during moderately quiet solar conditions. These non-thermal features occur at rates of many thousands per hour in the 30.72 MHz observing bandwidth, and hence, necessarily require an automated approach for their detecti…
▽ More
Low radio frequency solar observations using the Murchison Widefield Array have recently revealed the presence of numerous weak, short-lived and narrow-band emission features, even during moderately quiet solar conditions. These non-thermal features occur at rates of many thousands per hour in the 30.72 MHz observing bandwidth, and hence, necessarily require an automated approach for their detection and characterization. Here, we employ continuous wavelet transform using a mother Ricker wavelet for feature detection from the dynamic spectrum. We establish the efficacy of this approach and present the first statistically robust characterization of the properties of these features. In particular, we examine distributions of their peak flux densities, spectral spans, temporal spans and peak frequencies. We can reliably detect features weaker than 1 SFU, making them, to the best of our knowledge, the weakest bursts reported in literature. The distribution of their peak flux densities follows a power law with an index of -2.23 in the 12-155 SFU range, implying that they can provide an energetically significant contribution to coronal and chromospheric heating. These features typically last for 1-2 seconds and possess bandwidths of about 4-5 MHz. Their occurrence rate remains fairly flat in the 140-210 MHz frequency range. At the time resolution of the data, they appear as stationary bursts, exhibiting no perceptible frequency drift. These features also appear to ride on a broadband background continuum, hinting at the likelihood of them being weak type-I bursts.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2017; v1 submitted 3 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
