-
Monitoring AGNs with H$β$ Asymmetry. IV. First Reverberation Mapping Results of 14 AGNs
Authors:
T. E. Zastrocky,
Michael S. Brotherton,
Pu Du,
Jacob N. McLane,
Kianna A. Olson,
D. A. Dale,
H. A. Kobulnicky,
Jaya Maithil,
My L. Nguyen,
William T. Chick,
David H. Kasper,
Derek Hand,
C. Adelman,
Z. Carter,
G. Murphree,
M. Oeur,
T. Roth,
S. Schonsberg,
M. J. Caradonna,
J. Favro,
A. J. Ferguson,
I. M. Gonzalez,
L. M. Hadding,
H. D. Hagler,
C. J. Rogers
, et al. (19 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We report first-time reverberation mapping results for 14 AGNs from the ongoing Monitoring AGNs with H$β$ Asymmetry campaign (MAHA). These results utilize optical spectra obtained with the Long Slit Spectrograph on the Wyoming Infrared 2.3m Telescope between 2017 November-2023 May. MAHA combines long-duration monitoring with high cadence. We report results from multiple observing seasons for 9 of…
▽ More
We report first-time reverberation mapping results for 14 AGNs from the ongoing Monitoring AGNs with H$β$ Asymmetry campaign (MAHA). These results utilize optical spectra obtained with the Long Slit Spectrograph on the Wyoming Infrared 2.3m Telescope between 2017 November-2023 May. MAHA combines long-duration monitoring with high cadence. We report results from multiple observing seasons for 9 of the 14 objects. These results include H$β$ time lags, supermassive black hole masses, and velocity-resolved time lags. The velocity-resolved lags allow us to investigate the kinematics of the broad-line region.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Monitoring AGNs with H$β$ Asymmetry. III. Long-term Reverberation Mapping Results of 15 Palomar-Green Quasars
Authors:
Dong-Wei Bao,
Michael S. Brotherton,
Pu Du,
Jacob N. McLane,
T. E. Zastrocky,
Kianna A. Olson,
Feng-Na Fang,
Shuo Zhai,
Zheng-Peng Huang,
Kai Wang,
Bi-Xuan Zhao,
Sha-Sha Li,
Sen Yang,
Yong-Jie Chen,
Jun-Rong Liu,
Zhu-Heng Yao,
Yue-Chang Peng,
Wei-Jian Guo,
Yu-Yang Songsheng,
Yan-Rong Li,
Bo-Wei Jiang,
David H. Kasper,
William T. Chick,
My L. Nguyen,
Jaya Maithil
, et al. (20 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
In this third paper of the series reporting on the reverberation mapping (RM) campaign of active galactic nuclei with asymmetric H$β$ emission-line profiles, we present results for 15 Palomar-Green (PG) quasars using spectra obtained between the end of 2016 to May 2021. This campaign combines long time spans with relatively high cadence. For 8 objects, both the time lags obtained from the entire l…
▽ More
In this third paper of the series reporting on the reverberation mapping (RM) campaign of active galactic nuclei with asymmetric H$β$ emission-line profiles, we present results for 15 Palomar-Green (PG) quasars using spectra obtained between the end of 2016 to May 2021. This campaign combines long time spans with relatively high cadence. For 8 objects, both the time lags obtained from the entire light curves and the measurements from individual observing seasons are provided. Reverberation mapping of 9 of our targets has been attempted for the first time, while the results for 6 others can be compared with previous campaigns. We measure the H$β$ time lags over periods of years and estimate their black hole masses. The long duration of the campaign enables us to investigate their broad line region (BLR) geometry and kinematics for different years by using velocity-resolved lags, which demonstrate signatures of diverse BLR geometry and kinematics. The BLR geometry and kinematics of individual objects are discussed. In this sample, the BLR kinematics of Keplerian/virialized motion and inflow is more common than outflow.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Kinematics of the Central Stars Powering Bowshock Nebulae and the Large Multiplicity Fraction of Runaway OB Stars
Authors:
Henry A. Kobulnicky,
William T. Chick
Abstract:
OB stars powering stellar bowshock nebulae (SBNe) have been presumed to have large peculiar velocities. We measured peculiar velocities of SBN central stars to assess their kinematics relative to the general O star population using $Gaia$ EDR3 data for 267 SBN central stars and a sample of 455 Galactic O stars to derive projected velocities $v_{\rm 2D}$. For a subset of each sample we obtained new…
▽ More
OB stars powering stellar bowshock nebulae (SBNe) have been presumed to have large peculiar velocities. We measured peculiar velocities of SBN central stars to assess their kinematics relative to the general O star population using $Gaia$ EDR3 data for 267 SBN central stars and a sample of 455 Galactic O stars to derive projected velocities $v_{\rm 2D}$. For a subset of each sample we obtained new optical spectroscopy to measure radial velocities and identify multiple-star systems. We find a minimum multiplicity fraction of 36$\pm$6% among SBN central stars, consistent with $>$28% among runaway Galactic O stars. The large multiplicity fraction among runaways implicates very efficient dynamical ejection rather than binary-supernova origins. The median $v_{\rm 2D}$ of SBN central stars is $v_{\rm 2D}$=14.6 km s$^{-1}$, larger than the median $v_{\rm 2D}$=11.4 km s$^{-1}$ for non-bowshock O stars. Central stars of SBNe have a runaway ($v_{\rm 2D}$$>$25 km s$^{-1}$) fraction of 24$^{+9}_{-7}$%, consistent with the 22$^{+3}_{-3}$% for control-sample O stars. Most (76%) of SBNe central stars are not runaways. Our analysis of alignment ($Δ_{\rm PA}$) between the nebular morphological and $v_{\rm 2D}$ kinematic position angles reveals two populations: a highly aligned ($σ_{PA}$=25$^\circ$) population that includes stars with the largest $v_{\rm 2D}$ (31% of the sample) and a random (non-aligned) population (69% of the sample). SBNe that lie within or near HII regions comprise a larger fraction of this latter component than SBNe in isolated environments, implicating localized ISM flows as a factor shaping their orientations and morphologies. We outline a new conceptual approach to computing the Solar LSR motion, yielding [U$_\odot$, V$_\odot$, W$_\odot$]= [5.5, 7.5, 4.5] km s$^{-1}$.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Monitoring AGNs with Hβ Asymmetry. II. Reverberation Mapping of Three Seyfert Galaxies Historically Displaying Hβ Profiles with Changing Asymmetry: Mrk 79, NGC 3227, and Mrk 841
Authors:
Michael S. Brotherton,
Pu Du,
Ming Xiao,
Dong-Wei Bao,
Bixuan Zhao,
Jacob N. McLane,
Kianna A. Olson,
Kai Wang,
Zheng-Peng Huang,
Chen Hu,
David H. Kasper,
William T. Chick,
My L. Nguyen,
Jaya Maithil,
Derek Hand,
Yan-Rong Li,
Luis C. Ho,
Jin-Ming Bai,
Wei-Hao Bian,
Jian-Min Wang
Abstract:
We report the results of reverberation mapping three bright Seyfert galaxies, Mrk 79, NGC 3227, and Mrk 841, from a campaign conducted from December 2016 to May 2017 with the Wyoming Infrared Observatory (WIRO) 2.3-meter telescope. All three of these targets have shown asymmetric broad H$β$ emission lines in the past, although their emission lines were relatively symmetric during our observations.…
▽ More
We report the results of reverberation mapping three bright Seyfert galaxies, Mrk 79, NGC 3227, and Mrk 841, from a campaign conducted from December 2016 to May 2017 with the Wyoming Infrared Observatory (WIRO) 2.3-meter telescope. All three of these targets have shown asymmetric broad H$β$ emission lines in the past, although their emission lines were relatively symmetric during our observations. We measured Hβ time lags for all three targets and estimated masses of their black holes -- for the first time in the case of Mrk 841. For Mrk 79 and NGC 3227, the data are of sufficient quality to resolve distinct time lags as a function of velocity and to compute two-dimensional velocity-delay maps. Mrk 79 shows smaller time lags for high-velocity gas but the distribution is not symmetric, and its complex velocity-delay map could result from the combination of both inflowing and outflowing Hβ emitting disks that may be part of a single larger structure. NGC 3227 shows the largest time lags for blueshifted gas and the two-dimensional velocity-delay map suggests a disk with some inflow. We compare our results with previous work and find evidence for different time lags despite similar luminosities, as well as evolving broad line region structures.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Mass-loss rates for O and early B stars powering bowshock nebulae: evidence for bi-stability behavior
Authors:
Henry A. Kobulnicky,
William T. Chick,
Matthew S. Povich
Abstract:
Second only to initial mass, the rate of wind-driven mass loss determines the final mass of a massive star and the nature of its remnant. Motivated by the need to reconcile observational values and theory, we use a recently vetted technique to analyze the mass-loss rates in a sample of OB stars that generate bowshock nebulae. We measure peculiar velocities from new Gaia parallax and proper motion…
▽ More
Second only to initial mass, the rate of wind-driven mass loss determines the final mass of a massive star and the nature of its remnant. Motivated by the need to reconcile observational values and theory, we use a recently vetted technique to analyze the mass-loss rates in a sample of OB stars that generate bowshock nebulae. We measure peculiar velocities from new Gaia parallax and proper motion data and their spectral types from new optical and infrared spectroscopy. For our sample of 67 central stars in morphologically selected bowshocks nebulae, 67 are OB stars. The median peculiar velocity is 11 km/s, significantly smaller than classical `runaway star' velocities. Mass-loss rates for these O and early B stars agree with recently lowered theoretical predictions, ranging from ~10^-7 Msun/yr for mid-O dwarfs to 10^-9 Msun/yr for late-O dwarfs---a factor of about 2.7 lower than the often-used Vink et al. (2001) formulation. Our results provide the first observational mass-loss rates for B0--B3 dwarfs and giants---10^-9 to 10^-8 Msun/yr. We find evidence for an increase in the mass-loss rates below a critical effective temperature, consistent with predictions of the bi-stability phenomenon in the range Teff=19,000--27,000 K. The sample exhibits a correlation between modified wind momentum and luminosity, consistent in slope but lower by 0.43 dex in magnitude compared to canonical wind-luminosity relations. We identify a small subset of objects deviating most significantly from theoretical expectations as probable radiation-driven bow wave nebulae by virtue of their low stellar-to-nebular luminosity ratios. For these, the inferred mass-loss rates must be regarded as upper limits.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Monitoring AGNs with Hβ Asymmetry. I. First Results: Velocity-resolved Reverberation Mapping
Authors:
Pu Du,
Michael S. Brotherton,
Kai Wang,
Zheng-Peng Huang,
Chen Hu,
David H. Kasper,
William T. Chick,
My L. Nguyen,
Jaya Maithil,
Derek Hand,
Yan-Rong Li,
Luis C. Ho,
Jin-Ming Bai,
Wei-Hao Bian,
Jian-Min Wang
Abstract:
We have started a long-term reverberation mapping project using the Wyoming Infrared Observatory 2.3 meter telescope titled "Monitoring AGNs with Hβ Asymmetry" (MAHA). The motivations of the project are to explore the geometry and kinematics of the gas responsible for complex Hβ emission-line profiles, ideally leading to an understanding of the structures and origins of the broad-line region (BLR)…
▽ More
We have started a long-term reverberation mapping project using the Wyoming Infrared Observatory 2.3 meter telescope titled "Monitoring AGNs with Hβ Asymmetry" (MAHA). The motivations of the project are to explore the geometry and kinematics of the gas responsible for complex Hβ emission-line profiles, ideally leading to an understanding of the structures and origins of the broad-line region (BLR). Furthermore, such a project provides the opportunity to search for evidence of close binary supermassive black holes. We describe MAHA and report initial results from our first campaign, from December 2016 to May 2017, highlighting velocity-resolved time lags for four AGNs with asymmetric Hβ lines. We find that 3C 120, Ark 120, and Mrk 6 display complex features different from the simple signatures expected for pure outflow, inflow, or a Keplerian disk. While three of the objects have been previously reverberation mapped, including velocity-resolved time lags in the cases of 3C 120 and Mrk 6, we report a time lag and corresponding black hole mass measurement for SBS 1518+593 for the first time. Furthermore, SBS 1518+593, the least asymmetric of the four, does show velocity-resolved time lags characteristic of a Keplerian disk or virialized motion more generally. Also, the velocity-resolved time lags of 3C 120 have significantly changed since previously observed, indicating an evolution of its BLR structure. Future analyses of the data for these objects and others in MAHA will explore the full diversity of Hβ lines and the physics of AGN BLRs.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Demonstration of a novel method for measuring mass-loss rates for massive stars
Authors:
Henry A. Kobulnicky,
William T. Chick,
Matthew S. Povich
Abstract:
The rate at which massive stars eject mass in stellar winds significantly influences their evolutionary path. Cosmic rates of nucleosynthesis, explosive stellar phenomena, and compact object genesis depend on this poorly known facet of stellar evolution. We employ an unexploited observational technique for measuring the mass-loss rates of O- and early-B stars. Our approach, which has no adjustable…
▽ More
The rate at which massive stars eject mass in stellar winds significantly influences their evolutionary path. Cosmic rates of nucleosynthesis, explosive stellar phenomena, and compact object genesis depend on this poorly known facet of stellar evolution. We employ an unexploited observational technique for measuring the mass-loss rates of O- and early-B stars. Our approach, which has no adjustable parameters, uses the principle of pressure equilibrium between the stellar wind and the ambient interstellar medium for a high-velocity star generating an infrared bowshock nebula. Results for twenty bowshock-generating stars show good agreement with two sets of theoretical predictions for O5--O9.5 main-sequence stars, yielding $\dot M=$1.3$\times$10$^{-6}$ to 2$\times$10$^{-9}$ solar masses per year. Although $\dot M$ values derived for this sample are smaller than theoretical expectations by a factor of about two, this discrepancy is greatly reduced compared to canonical mass-loss methods. Bowshock-derived mass-loss rates are factors of ten smaller than H$α$-based measurements (uncorrected for clumping) for similar stellar types and are nearly an order of magnitude larger than P$^{4+}$ and some other UV absorption-line-based diagnostics. Ambient interstellar densities of at least several cm$^{-3}$ appear to be required for formation of a prominent infrared bowshock nebula. $\dot M$ measurements for early-B stars are not yet compelling owing to the small number in our sample and the lack of clear theoretical predictions in the regime of lower stellar luminosities. These results may constitute a partial resolution of the extant "weak-wind problem" for late-O stars. The technique shows promise for determining mass-loss rates in the weak-wind regime.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Infrared Photometric Properties of 709 Candidate Stellar Bowshock Nebulae
Authors:
Henry A. Kobulnicky,
Danielle P. Schurhammer,
Daniel J. Baldwin,
William T. Chick,
Don M. Dixon,
Daniel Lee,
Matthew S. Povich
Abstract:
Arcuate infrared nebulae are ubiquitous throughout the Galactic Plane and are candidates for partial shells, bubbles, or bowshocks produced by massive runaway stars. We tabulate infrared photometry for 709 such objects using images from the Spitzer Space Telescope (SST), Wide-Field Infrared Explorer (WISE), and Herschel Space Observatory (HSO). Of the 709 objects identified at 24 or 22 microns, 42…
▽ More
Arcuate infrared nebulae are ubiquitous throughout the Galactic Plane and are candidates for partial shells, bubbles, or bowshocks produced by massive runaway stars. We tabulate infrared photometry for 709 such objects using images from the Spitzer Space Telescope (SST), Wide-Field Infrared Explorer (WISE), and Herschel Space Observatory (HSO). Of the 709 objects identified at 24 or 22 microns, 422 are detected at the HSO 70 micron bandpass. Of these, only 39 are detected at HSO 160 microns. The 70 micron peak surface brightnesses are 0.5 to 2.5 Jy/square arcminute. Color temperatures calculated from the 24 micron to 70 micron ratios range from 80 K to 400 K. Color temperatures from 70 micron to 160 micron ratios are systematically lower, 40 K to 200 K. Both of these temperature are, on average, 75% higher than the nominal temperatures derived by assuming that dust is in steady-state radiative equilibrium. This may be evidence of stellar wind bowshocks sweeping up and heating --- possibly fragmenting but not destroying --- interstellar dust. Infrared luminosity correlates with standoff distance, R_0, as predicted by published hydrodynamical models. Infrared spectral energy distributions are consistent with interstellar dust exposed to a either single radiant energy density, U=10^3 to 10^5 (in more than half of the objects) or a range of radiant energy densities U_min=25 to U_max=10^3 to 10^5 times the mean interstellar value for the remainder. Hence, the central OB stars dominate the energetics, making these enticing laboratories for testing dust models in constrained radiation environments. SEDs are consistent with PAH fractions q_PAH <1% in most objects.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
How Similar are the Properties of Quasars with Nearly Identical Ultraviolet Spectra?
Authors:
Thomas Rochais,
Vikram Singh,
William Chick,
Jaya Maithil,
Jessica Sutter,
Michael Brotherton,
Zhouhui Shang
Abstract:
The spectrum of a quasar contains important information about its properties. Thus, it can be expected that two quasars with similar spectra will have similar properties, but just how similar has not before been quantified. Here we compare the ultraviolet spectra of a sample of 5553 quasars from Data Release 7 of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey, focusing on the $1350$ Å\ $\leq λ\leq 2900$ Å\ rest-fra…
▽ More
The spectrum of a quasar contains important information about its properties. Thus, it can be expected that two quasars with similar spectra will have similar properties, but just how similar has not before been quantified. Here we compare the ultraviolet spectra of a sample of 5553 quasars from Data Release 7 of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey, focusing on the $1350$ Å\ $\leq λ\leq 2900$ Å\ rest-frame region which contains prominent emission lines from \SiIV, O IV], \CIV, \CIII, and \MgII\ species. We use principal component analysis to determine the dominant components of spectral variation, as well as to quantitatively measure spectral similarity. As suggested by both the Baldwin effect and modified Baldwin effect, quasars with similar spectra have similar properties: bolometric luminosity, Eddington fraction, and black hole mass. The latter two quantities are calculated from the luminosity in conjunction with spectral features, and the variation between quasars with virtually identical spectra (which we call doppelgängers) is driven by the variance in the luminosity plus measurement uncertainties. In the doppelgangers the luminosity differences show 1$σ$ uncertainties of 57\% (or 0.63 magnitudes) and $\sim$70\% 1$σ$ uncertainties for mass and Eddington fraction. Much of the difference in luminosities may be attributable to time lags between the spectral lines and the continuum. Furthermore, we find that suggestions that the mostly highly accreting quasars should be better standard candles than other quasars are not bourne out for doppelgangers. Finally, we discuss the implications for using quasars as cosmological probes and the nature of the first two spectral principal components.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
A comprehensive search for stellar bowshock nebulae in the Milky Way: a catalog of 709 mid-infrared selected candidates
Authors:
Henry A. Kobulnicky,
William T. Chick,
Danielle P. Schurhammer,
Julian E. Andrews,
Matthew S. Povich,
Stephan A. Munari,
Grace M. Olivier,
Rebecca L. Sorber,
Heather N. Wernke,
Daniel A. Dale,
Don M. Dixon
Abstract:
We identify 709 arc-shaped mid-infrared nebula in 24 micron Spitzer Space Telescope or 22 micron Wide Field Infrared Explorer surveys of the Galactic Plane as probable dusty interstellar bowshocks powered by early-type stars. About 20% are visible at 8 microns or shorter mid-infrared wavelengths as well. The vast majority (660) have no previous identification in the literature. These extended infr…
▽ More
We identify 709 arc-shaped mid-infrared nebula in 24 micron Spitzer Space Telescope or 22 micron Wide Field Infrared Explorer surveys of the Galactic Plane as probable dusty interstellar bowshocks powered by early-type stars. About 20% are visible at 8 microns or shorter mid-infrared wavelengths as well. The vast majority (660) have no previous identification in the literature. These extended infrared sources are strongly concentrated near Galactic mid-Plane with an angular scale height of ~0.6 degrees. All host a symmetrically placed star implicated as the source of a stellar wind sweeping up interstellar material. These are candidate "runaway" stars potentially having high velocities in the reference frame of the local medium. Among the 286 objects with measured proper motions, we find an unambiguous excess having velocity vectors aligned with the infrared morphology --- kinematic evidence that many of these are "runaway" stars with large peculiar motions responsible for the bowshock signature. We discuss a population of "in-situ" bowshocks (103 objects) that face giant HII regions where the relative motions between the star and ISM may be caused by bulk outflows from an overpressured bubble. We also identify 58 objects that face 8 micron bright-rimmed clouds and apparently constitute a sub-class of in-situ bowshocks where the stellar wind interacts with a photo-evaporative flow from an eroding molecular cloud interface (i.e., "PEF bowshocks"). Orientations of the arcuate nebulae exhibit a correlation over small angular scales, indicating that external influences such as HII regions are responsible for producing some bowshock nebulae. However, the vast majority of this sample appear to be isolated (499 objects) from obvious external influences.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
