-
The Cosmic Graph: Optimal Information Extraction from Large-Scale Structure using Catalogues
Authors:
T. Lucas Makinen,
Tom Charnock,
Pablo Lemos,
Natalia Porqueres,
Alan Heavens,
Benjamin D. Wandelt
Abstract:
We present an implicit likelihood approach to quantifying cosmological information over discrete catalogue data, assembled as graphs. To do so, we explore cosmological parameter constraints using mock dark matter halo catalogues. We employ Information Maximising Neural Networks (IMNNs) to quantify Fisher information extraction as a function of graph representation. We a) demonstrate the high sensi…
▽ More
We present an implicit likelihood approach to quantifying cosmological information over discrete catalogue data, assembled as graphs. To do so, we explore cosmological parameter constraints using mock dark matter halo catalogues. We employ Information Maximising Neural Networks (IMNNs) to quantify Fisher information extraction as a function of graph representation. We a) demonstrate the high sensitivity of modular graph structure to the underlying cosmology in the noise-free limit, b) show that graph neural network summaries automatically combine mass and clustering information through comparisons to traditional statistics, c) demonstrate that networks can still extract information when catalogues are subject to noisy survey cuts, and d) illustrate how nonlinear IMNN summaries can be used as asymptotically optimal compressed statistics for Bayesian simulation-based inference. We reduce the area of joint $Ω_m, σ_8$ parameter constraints with small ($\sim$100 object) halo catalogues by a factor of 42 over the two-point correlation function, and demonstrate that the networks automatically combine mass and clustering information. This work utilises a new IMNN implementation over graph data in Jax, which can take advantage of either numerical or auto-differentiability. We also show that graph IMNNs successfully compress simulations away from the fiducial model at which the network is fitted, indicating a promising alternative to n-point statistics in catalogue simulation-based analyses.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2022; v1 submitted 11 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Lossless, Scalable Implicit Likelihood Inference for Cosmological Fields
Authors:
T. Lucas Makinen,
Tom Charnock,
Justin Alsing,
Benjamin D. Wandelt
Abstract:
We present a comparison of simulation-based inference to full, field-based analytical inference in cosmological data analysis. To do so, we explore parameter inference for two cases where the information content is calculable analytically: Gaussian random fields whose covariance depends on parameters through the power spectrum; and correlated lognormal fields with cosmological power spectra. We co…
▽ More
We present a comparison of simulation-based inference to full, field-based analytical inference in cosmological data analysis. To do so, we explore parameter inference for two cases where the information content is calculable analytically: Gaussian random fields whose covariance depends on parameters through the power spectrum; and correlated lognormal fields with cosmological power spectra. We compare two inference techniques: i) explicit field-level inference using the known likelihood and ii) implicit likelihood inference with maximally informative summary statistics compressed via Information Maximising Neural Networks (IMNNs). We find that a) summaries obtained from convolutional neural network compression do not lose information and therefore saturate the known field information content, both for the Gaussian covariance and the lognormal cases, b) simulation-based inference using these maximally informative nonlinear summaries recovers nearly losslessly the exact posteriors of field-level inference, bypassing the need to evaluate expensive likelihoods or invert covariance matrices, and c) even for this simple example, implicit, simulation-based likelihood incurs a much smaller computational cost than inference with an explicit likelihood. This work uses a new IMNNs implementation in $\texttt{Jax}$ that can take advantage of fully-differentiable simulation and inference pipeline. We also demonstrate that a single retraining of the IMNN summaries effectively achieves the theoretically maximal information, enhancing the robustness to the choice of fiducial model where the IMNN is trained.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2021; v1 submitted 15 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Catalog-free modeling of galaxy types in deep images: Massive dimensional reduction with neural networks
Authors:
Florian Livet,
Tom Charnock,
Damien Le Borgne,
Valérie de Lapparent
Abstract:
Current models of galaxy evolution are constrained by the analysis of catalogs containing the flux and size of galaxies extracted from multiband deep fields carrying inevitable observational and extraction-related biases which can be highly correlated. In practice, taking all of these effects simultaneously into account is difficult, and derived models are inevitably biased. To address this issue,…
▽ More
Current models of galaxy evolution are constrained by the analysis of catalogs containing the flux and size of galaxies extracted from multiband deep fields carrying inevitable observational and extraction-related biases which can be highly correlated. In practice, taking all of these effects simultaneously into account is difficult, and derived models are inevitably biased. To address this issue, we use robust likelihood-free methods for the inference of luminosity function parameters, made possible via massive compression of multiband images using artificial neural networks. This technique makes the use of catalogs unnecessary when comparing observed and simulated multiband deep fields and constraining model parameters. A forward modeling approach generates galaxies of multiple types depending on luminosity function parameters and paints them on photometric multiband deep fields including both the instrumental and observational characteristics. The simulated and the observed images present the same selection effects and can therefore be properly compared. We train a fully-convolutional neural network to extract the most model-parameter-sensitive summary statistics out of these realistic simulations, shrinking down the dimensionality of the summary space. Finally, using the trained network to compress both observed and simulated deep fields, the model parameter values are constrained through Population Monte Carlo likelihood-free inference. Using synthetic photometric multiband deep fields similar to the CFHTLS and D1/D2 deep fields and massively compressing them through the convolutional neural network, we demonstrate the robustness, accuracy and consistency of this new catalog-free inference method. We are able to constrain the parameters of luminosity functions of different types of galaxies and our results are fully compatible with the classic catalog extraction approaches.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2022; v1 submitted 1 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Bayesian Neural Networks
Authors:
Tom Charnock,
Laurence Perreault-Levasseur,
François Lanusse
Abstract:
In recent times, neural networks have become a powerful tool for the analysis of complex and abstract data models. However, their introduction intrinsically increases our uncertainty about which features of the analysis are model-related and which are due to the neural network. This means that predictions by neural networks have biases which cannot be trivially distinguished from being due to the…
▽ More
In recent times, neural networks have become a powerful tool for the analysis of complex and abstract data models. However, their introduction intrinsically increases our uncertainty about which features of the analysis are model-related and which are due to the neural network. This means that predictions by neural networks have biases which cannot be trivially distinguished from being due to the true nature of the creation and observation of data or not. In order to attempt to address such issues we discuss Bayesian neural networks: neural networks where the uncertainty due to the network can be characterised. In particular, we present the Bayesian statistical framework which allows us to categorise uncertainty in terms of the ingrained randomness of observing certain data and the uncertainty from our lack of knowledge about how data can be created and observed. In presenting such techniques we show how errors in prediction by neural networks can be obtained in principle, and provide the two favoured methods for characterising these errors. We will also describe how both of these methods have substantial pitfalls when put into practice, highlighting the need for other statistical techniques to truly be able to do inference when using neural networks.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2020; v1 submitted 2 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Detecting outliers in astronomical images with deep generative networks
Authors:
Berta Margalef-Bentabol,
Marc Huertas-Company,
Tom Charnock,
Carla Margalef-Bentabol,
Mariangela Bernardi,
Yohan Dubois,
Kate Storey-Fisher,
Lorenzo Zanis
Abstract:
With the advent of future big-data surveys, automated tools for unsupervised discovery are becoming ever more necessary. In this work, we explore the ability of deep generative networks for detecting outliers in astronomical imaging datasets. The main advantage of such generative models is that they are able to learn complex representations directly from the pixel space. Therefore, these methods e…
▽ More
With the advent of future big-data surveys, automated tools for unsupervised discovery are becoming ever more necessary. In this work, we explore the ability of deep generative networks for detecting outliers in astronomical imaging datasets. The main advantage of such generative models is that they are able to learn complex representations directly from the pixel space. Therefore, these methods enable us to look for subtle morphological deviations which are typically missed by more traditional moment-based approaches. We use a generative model to learn a representation of expected data defined by the training set and then look for deviations from the learned representation by looking for the best reconstruction of a given object. In this first proof-of-concept work, we apply our method to two different test cases. We first show that from a set of simulated galaxies, we are able to detect $\sim90\%$ of merging galaxies if we train our network only with a sample of isolated ones. We then explore how the presented approach can be used to compare observations and hydrodynamic simulations by identifying observed galaxies not well represented in the models.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2020; v1 submitted 18 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Super-resolution emulator of cosmological simulations using deep physical models
Authors:
Doogesh Kodi Ramanah,
Tom Charnock,
Francisco Villaescusa-Navarro,
Benjamin D. Wandelt
Abstract:
We present an extension of our recently developed Wasserstein optimized model to emulate accurate high-resolution features from computationally cheaper low-resolution cosmological simulations. Our deep physical modelling technique relies on restricted neural networks to perform a mapping of the distribution of the low-resolution cosmic density field to the space of the high-resolution small-scale…
▽ More
We present an extension of our recently developed Wasserstein optimized model to emulate accurate high-resolution features from computationally cheaper low-resolution cosmological simulations. Our deep physical modelling technique relies on restricted neural networks to perform a mapping of the distribution of the low-resolution cosmic density field to the space of the high-resolution small-scale structures. We constrain our network using a single triplet of high-resolution initial conditions and the corresponding low- and high-resolution evolved dark matter simulations from the Quijote suite of simulations. We exploit the information content of the high-resolution initial conditions as a well constructed prior distribution from which the network emulates the small-scale structures. Once fitted, our physical model yields emulated high-resolution simulations at low computational cost, while also providing some insights about how the large-scale modes affect the small-scale structure in real space.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2020; v1 submitted 15 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Neural physical engines for inferring the halo mass distribution function
Authors:
Tom Charnock,
Guilhem Lavaux,
Benjamin D. Wandelt,
Supranta Sarma Boruah,
Jens Jasche,
Michael J. Hudson
Abstract:
An ambitious goal in cosmology is to forward-model the observed distribution of galaxies in the nearby Universe today from the initial conditions of large-scale structures. For practical reasons, the spatial resolution at which this can be done is necessarily limited. Consequently, one needs a mapping between the density of dark matter averaged over ~Mpc scales, and the distribution of dark matter…
▽ More
An ambitious goal in cosmology is to forward-model the observed distribution of galaxies in the nearby Universe today from the initial conditions of large-scale structures. For practical reasons, the spatial resolution at which this can be done is necessarily limited. Consequently, one needs a mapping between the density of dark matter averaged over ~Mpc scales, and the distribution of dark matter halos (used as a proxy for galaxies) in the same region. Here we demonstrate a method for determining the halo mass distribution function by learning the tracer bias between density fields and halo catalogues using a neural bias model. The method is based on the Bayesian analysis of simple, physically motivated, neural network-like architectures, which we denote as neural physical engines, and neural density estimation. As a result, we are able to sample the initial phases of the dark matter density field whilst inferring the parameters describing the halo mass distribution function, providing a fully Bayesian interpretation of both the initial dark matter density distribution and the neural bias model. We successfully run an upgraded BORG inference using our new likelihood and neural bias model with halo catalogues derived from full N-body simulations. We notice orders of magnitude improvement in modelling compared to classical biasing techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
The Quijote simulations
Authors:
Francisco Villaescusa-Navarro,
ChangHoon Hahn,
Elena Massara,
Arka Banerjee,
Ana Maria Delgado,
Doogesh Kodi Ramanah,
Tom Charnock,
Elena Giusarma,
Yin Li,
Erwan Allys,
Antoine Brochard,
Cora Uhlemann,
Chi-Ting Chiang,
Siyu He,
Alice Pisani,
Andrej Obuljen,
Yu Feng,
Emanuele Castorina,
Gabriella Contardo,
Christina D. Kreisch,
Andrina Nicola,
Justin Alsing,
Roman Scoccimarro,
Licia Verde,
Matteo Viel
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Quijote simulations are a set of 44,100 full N-body simulations spanning more than 7,000 cosmological models in the $\{Ω_{\rm m}, Ω_{\rm b}, h, n_s, σ_8, M_ν, w \}$ hyperplane. At a single redshift the simulations contain more than 8.5 trillions of particles over a combined volume of 44,100 $(h^{-1}{\rm Gpc})^3$; each simulation follow the evolution of $256^3$, $512^3$ or $1024^3$ particles in…
▽ More
The Quijote simulations are a set of 44,100 full N-body simulations spanning more than 7,000 cosmological models in the $\{Ω_{\rm m}, Ω_{\rm b}, h, n_s, σ_8, M_ν, w \}$ hyperplane. At a single redshift the simulations contain more than 8.5 trillions of particles over a combined volume of 44,100 $(h^{-1}{\rm Gpc})^3$; each simulation follow the evolution of $256^3$, $512^3$ or $1024^3$ particles in a box of $1~h^{-1}{\rm Gpc}$ length. Billions of dark matter halos and cosmic voids have been identified in the simulations, whose runs required more than 35 million core hours. The Quijote simulations have been designed for two main purposes: 1) to quantify the information content on cosmological observables, and 2) to provide enough data to train machine learning algorithms. In this paper we describe the simulations and show a few of their applications. We also release the Petabyte of data generated, comprising hundreds of thousands of simulation snapshots at multiple redshifts, halo and void catalogs, together with millions of summary statistics such as power spectra, bispectra, correlation functions, marked power spectra, and estimated probability density functions.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2021; v1 submitted 11 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Painting halos from cosmic density fields of dark matter with physically motivated neural networks
Authors:
Doogesh Kodi Ramanah,
Tom Charnock,
Guilhem Lavaux
Abstract:
We present a novel halo painting network that learns to map approximate 3D dark matter fields to realistic halo distributions. This map is provided via a physically motivated network with which we can learn the non-trivial local relation between dark matter density field and halo distributions without relying on a physical model. Unlike other generative or regressive models, a well motivated prior…
▽ More
We present a novel halo painting network that learns to map approximate 3D dark matter fields to realistic halo distributions. This map is provided via a physically motivated network with which we can learn the non-trivial local relation between dark matter density field and halo distributions without relying on a physical model. Unlike other generative or regressive models, a well motivated prior and simple physical principles allow us to train the mapping network quickly and with relatively little data. In learning to paint halo distributions from computationally cheap, analytical and non-linear density fields, we bypass the need for full particle mesh simulations and halo finding algorithms. Furthermore, by design, our halo painting network needs only local patches of dark matter density to predict the halos, and as such, it can predict the 3D halo distribution for any arbitrary simulation box size. Our neural network can be trained using small simulations and used to predict large halo distributions, as long as the resolutions are equivalent. We evaluate our model's ability to generate 3D halo count distributions which reproduce, to a high degree, summary statistics such as the power spectrum and bispectrum, of the input or reference realizations.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2019; v1 submitted 25 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Fast likelihood-free cosmology with neural density estimators and active learning
Authors:
Justin Alsing,
Tom Charnock,
Stephen Feeney,
Benjamin Wandelt
Abstract:
Likelihood-free inference provides a framework for performing rigorous Bayesian inference using only forward simulations, properly accounting for all physical and observational effects that can be successfully included in the simulations. The key challenge for likelihood-free applications in cosmology, where simulation is typically expensive, is developing methods that can achieve high-fidelity po…
▽ More
Likelihood-free inference provides a framework for performing rigorous Bayesian inference using only forward simulations, properly accounting for all physical and observational effects that can be successfully included in the simulations. The key challenge for likelihood-free applications in cosmology, where simulation is typically expensive, is developing methods that can achieve high-fidelity posterior inference with as few simulations as possible. Density-estimation likelihood-free inference (DELFI) methods turn inference into a density estimation task on a set of simulated data-parameter pairs, and give orders of magnitude improvements over traditional Approximate Bayesian Computation approaches to likelihood-free inference. In this paper we use neural density estimators (NDEs) to learn the likelihood function from a set of simulated datasets, with active learning to adaptively acquire simulations in the most relevant regions of parameter space on-the-fly. We demonstrate the approach on a number of cosmological case studies, showing that for typical problems high-fidelity posterior inference can be achieved with just $\mathcal{O}(10^3)$ simulations or fewer. In addition to enabling efficient simulation-based inference, for simple problems where the form of the likelihood is known, DELFI offers a fast alternative to MCMC sampling, giving orders of magnitude speed-up in some cases. Finally, we introduce \textsc{pydelfi} -- a flexible public implementation of DELFI with NDEs and active learning -- available at \url{https://github.com/justinalsing/pydelfi}.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Towards online triggering for the radio detection of air showers using deep neural networks
Authors:
Florian Führer,
Tom Charnock,
Anne Zilles,
Matias Tueros
Abstract:
The detection of air-shower events via radio signals requires to develop a trigger algorithm for a clean discrimination between signal and background events in order to reduce the data stream coming from false triggers. In this contribution we will describe an approach to trigger air-shower events on a single-antenna level as well as performing an online reconstruction of the shower parameters usi…
▽ More
The detection of air-shower events via radio signals requires to develop a trigger algorithm for a clean discrimination between signal and background events in order to reduce the data stream coming from false triggers. In this contribution we will describe an approach to trigger air-shower events on a single-antenna level as well as performing an online reconstruction of the shower parameters using neural networks.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2018; v1 submitted 6 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Automatic physical inference with information maximising neural networks
Authors:
Tom Charnock,
Guilhem Lavaux,
Benjamin D. Wandelt
Abstract:
Compressing large data sets to a manageable number of summaries that are informative about the underlying parameters vastly simplifies both frequentist and Bayesian inference. When only simulations are available, these summaries are typically chosen heuristically, so they may inadvertently miss important information. We introduce a simulation-based machine learning technique that trains artificial…
▽ More
Compressing large data sets to a manageable number of summaries that are informative about the underlying parameters vastly simplifies both frequentist and Bayesian inference. When only simulations are available, these summaries are typically chosen heuristically, so they may inadvertently miss important information. We introduce a simulation-based machine learning technique that trains artificial neural networks to find non-linear functionals of data that maximise Fisher information: information maximising neural networks (IMNNs). In test cases where the posterior can be derived exactly, likelihood-free inference based on automatically derived IMNN summaries produces nearly exact posteriors, showing that these summaries are good approximations to sufficient statistics. In a series of numerical examples of increasing complexity and astrophysical relevance we show that IMNNs are robustly capable of automatically finding optimal, non-linear summaries of the data even in cases where linear compression fails: inferring the variance of Gaussian signal in the presence of noise; inferring cosmological parameters from mock simulations of the Lyman-α forest in quasar spectra; and inferring frequency-domain parameters from LISA-like detections of gravitational waveforms. In this final case, the IMNN summary outperforms linear data compression by avoiding the introduction of spurious likelihood maxima. We anticipate that the automatic physical inference method described in this paper will be essential to obtain both accurate and precise cosmological parameter estimates from complex and large astronomical data sets, including those from LSST and Euclid.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2018; v1 submitted 10 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Planck confronts large scale structure: methods to quantify discordance
Authors:
Tom Charnock,
Richard A. Battye,
Adam Moss
Abstract:
Discordance in the $Λ$CDM cosmological model can be seen by comparing parameters constrained by CMB measurements to those inferred by probes of large scale structure. Recent improvements in observations, including final data releases from both Planck and SDSS-III BOSS, as well as improved astrophysical uncertainty analysis of CFHTLenS, allows for an update in the quantification of any tension betw…
▽ More
Discordance in the $Λ$CDM cosmological model can be seen by comparing parameters constrained by CMB measurements to those inferred by probes of large scale structure. Recent improvements in observations, including final data releases from both Planck and SDSS-III BOSS, as well as improved astrophysical uncertainty analysis of CFHTLenS, allows for an update in the quantification of any tension between large and small scales. This paper is intended, primarily, as a discussion on the quantifications of discordance when comparing the parameter constraints of a model when given two different data sets. We consider KL-divergence, comparison of Bayesian evidences and other statistics which are sensitive to the mean, variance and shape of the distributions. However, as a by-product, we present an update to the similar analysis in (Battye, Charnock and Moss; 2015) where we find that, considering new data and treatment of priors, the constraints from the CMB and from a combination of LSS probes are in greater agreement and any tension only persists to a minor degree. In particular, we find the parameter constraints from the combination of LSS probes which are most discrepant with the Planck2015+Pol+BAO parameter distributions can be quantified at a 2.55$σ$ tension using the method introduced in (Battye, Charnock and Moss; 2015). If instead we use the distributions constrained by the combination of LSS probes which are in greatest agreement with those from Planck2015+Pol+BAO this tension is only 0.76$σ$.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Deep Recurrent Neural Networks for Supernovae Classification
Authors:
Tom Charnock,
Adam Moss
Abstract:
We apply deep recurrent neural networks, which are capable of learning complex sequential information, to classify supernovae\footnote{Code available at \href{https://github.com/adammoss/supernovae}{https://github.com/adammoss/supernovae}}. The observational time and filter fluxes are used as inputs to the network, but since the inputs are agnostic additional data such as host galaxy information c…
▽ More
We apply deep recurrent neural networks, which are capable of learning complex sequential information, to classify supernovae\footnote{Code available at \href{https://github.com/adammoss/supernovae}{https://github.com/adammoss/supernovae}}. The observational time and filter fluxes are used as inputs to the network, but since the inputs are agnostic additional data such as host galaxy information can also be included. Using the Supernovae Photometric Classification Challenge (SPCC) data, we find that deep networks are capable of learning about light curves, however the performance of the network is highly sensitive to the amount of training data. For a training size of 50\% of the representational SPCC dataset (around $10^4$ supernovae) we obtain a type-Ia vs. non-type-Ia classification accuracy of 94.7\%, an area under the Receiver Operating Characteristic curve AUC of 0.986 and a SPCC figure-of-merit $F_1=0.64$. When using only the data for the early-epoch challenge defined by the SPCC we achieve a classification accuracy of 93.1\%, AUC of 0.977 and $F_1=0.58$, results almost as good as with the whole light-curve. By employing bidirectional neural networks we can acquire impressive classification results between supernovae types -I,~-II and~-III at an accuracy of 90.4\% and AUC of 0.974. We also apply a pre-trained model to obtain classification probabilities as a function of time, and show it can give early indications of supernovae type. Our method is competitive with existing algorithms and has applications for future large-scale photometric surveys.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2017; v1 submitted 23 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
CMB constraints on cosmic strings and superstrings
Authors:
Tom Charnock,
Anastasios Avgoustidis,
Edmund J. Copeland,
Adam Moss
Abstract:
We present the first complete Markov chain Monte Carlo analysis of cosmological models with evolving cosmic (super)string networks, using the unconnected segment model in the unequal-time correlator formalism. For ordinary cosmic string networks, we derive joint constraints on Lambda cold dark matter (CDM) and string network parameters, namely the string tension Gmu, the loop-chopping efficiency c…
▽ More
We present the first complete Markov chain Monte Carlo analysis of cosmological models with evolving cosmic (super)string networks, using the unconnected segment model in the unequal-time correlator formalism. For ordinary cosmic string networks, we derive joint constraints on Lambda cold dark matter (CDM) and string network parameters, namely the string tension Gmu, the loop-chopping efficiency c_r and the string wiggliness α. For cosmic superstrings, we obtain joint constraints on the fundamental string tension Gmu_F, the string coupling g_s, the self-interaction coefficient c_s, and the volume of compact extra dimensions w. This constitutes the most comprehensive CMB analysis of LambdaCDM cosmology + strings to date. For ordinary cosmic string networks our updated constraint on the string tension is, in relativistic units, Gmu<1.1x10^-7, while for cosmic superstrings our constraint on the fundamental string tension is Gmu_F<2.8x10^-8, both obtained using Planck2015 temperature and polarisation data.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2016; v1 submitted 3 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Tension between the power spectrum of density perturbations measured on large and small scales
Authors:
Richard A. Battye,
Tom Charnock,
Adam Moss
Abstract:
There is a tension between measurements of the amplitude of the power spectrum of density perturbations inferred using the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and directly measured by Large-Scale Structure (LSS) on smaller scales. We show that this tension exists, and is robust, for a range of LSS indicators including clusters, lensing and redshift space distortions and using CMB data from either…
▽ More
There is a tension between measurements of the amplitude of the power spectrum of density perturbations inferred using the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and directly measured by Large-Scale Structure (LSS) on smaller scales. We show that this tension exists, and is robust, for a range of LSS indicators including clusters, lensing and redshift space distortions and using CMB data from either $Planck$ or WMAP+SPT/ACT. One obvious way to try to reconcile this is the inclusion of a massive neutrino which could be either active or sterile. Using $Planck$ and a combination of all the LSS data we find that (i) for an active neutrino $\sum m_ν= (0.357\pm0.099)\,{\rm eV}$ and (ii) for a sterile neutrino $m_{\rm sterile}^{\rm eff}= (0.67\pm0.18)\,{\rm eV}$ and $ΔN_{\rm eff}= 0.32\pm0.20$. This is, however, at the expense of a degraded fit to $Planck$ temperature data, and we quantify the residual tension at $2.5σ$ and $1.6 σ$ for massive and sterile neutrinos respectively. We also consider alternative explanations including a lower redshift for reionization that would be in conflict with polarisation measurements made by WMAP and $ad$-$hoc$ modifications to primordial power spectrum.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
