-
Are NH$_3$ and CO$_2$ ice present on Miranda?
Authors:
Riley A. DeColibus,
Nancy J. Chanover,
Richard J. Cartwright
Abstract:
Published near-infrared spectra of the four largest classical Uranian satellites display the presence of discrete deposits of CO$_2$ ice, along with subtle absorption features around 2.2 $μ$m. The two innermost satellites, Miranda and Ariel, also possess surfaces heavily modified by past endogenic activity. Previous observations of the smallest satellite, Miranda, have not detected the presence of…
▽ More
Published near-infrared spectra of the four largest classical Uranian satellites display the presence of discrete deposits of CO$_2$ ice, along with subtle absorption features around 2.2 $μ$m. The two innermost satellites, Miranda and Ariel, also possess surfaces heavily modified by past endogenic activity. Previous observations of the smallest satellite, Miranda, have not detected the presence of CO$_2$ ice, and a report of an absorption feature at 2.2 $μ$m has not been confirmed. An absorption feature at 2.2 $μ$m could result from exposed or emplaced NH$_3$- or NH$_4$-bearing species, which have a limited lifetime on Miranda's surface, and therefore may imply that Miranda's internal activity was relatively recent. In this work, we analyzed near-infrared spectra of Miranda to determine whether CO$_2$ ice and the 2.2-$μ$m feature are present. We measured the band area and depth of the CO$_2$ ice triplet (1.966, 2.012, and 2.070 $μ$m), a weak 2.13-$μ$m band attributed to CO$_2$ ice mixed with H$_2$O ice, and the 2.2-$μ$m band. We confirmed a prior detection of a 2.2-$μ$m band on Miranda, but we found no evidence for CO$_2$ ice, either as discrete deposits or mixed with H$_2$O ice. We compared a high signal-to-noise spectrum of Miranda to synthetic and laboratory spectra of various candidate compounds to shed light on what species may be responsible for the 2.2-$μ$m band. We conclude that the 2.2-$μ$m absorption is best matched by a combination of NH$_3$ ice with NH$_3$-hydrates or NH$_3$-H$_2$O mixtures. NH$_4$-bearing salts like NH$_4$Cl are also promising candidates that warrant further investigation.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Giant Planet Observations in NASA's Planetary Data System
Authors:
Nancy J. Chanover,
James M. Bauer,
John J. Blalock,
Mitchell K. Gordon,
Lyle F. Huber,
Mia J. T. Mace,
Lynn D. V. Neakrase,
Matthew S. Tiscareno,
Raymond J. Walker
Abstract:
While there have been far fewer missions to the outer Solar System than to the inner Solar System, spacecraft destined for the giant planets have conducted a wide range of fundamental investigations, returning data that continues to reshape our understanding of these complex systems, sometimes decades after the data were acquired. These data are preserved and accessible from national and internati…
▽ More
While there have been far fewer missions to the outer Solar System than to the inner Solar System, spacecraft destined for the giant planets have conducted a wide range of fundamental investigations, returning data that continues to reshape our understanding of these complex systems, sometimes decades after the data were acquired. These data are preserved and accessible from national and international planetary science archives. For all NASA planetary missions and instruments the data are available from the science discipline nodes of the NASA Planetary Data System (PDS). Looking ahead, the PDS will be the primary repository for giant planets data from several upcoming missions and derived datasets, as well as supporting research conducted to aid in the interpretation of the remotely sensed giant planets data already archived in the PDS.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Exploring Jupiter's Polar Deformation Lengths with High Resolution Shallow Water Modeling
Authors:
Ali Hyder,
Wladimir Lyra,
Nancy Chanover,
Raúl Morales-Juberías,
Jason Jackiewicz
Abstract:
The polar regions of Jupiter host a myriad of dynamically interesting phenomena including vortex configurations, folded-filamentary regions (FFRs), and chaotic flows. Juno observations have provided unprecedented views of the high latitudes, allowing for more constraints to be placed upon the troposphere and the overall atmospheric energy cycle. Moist convective events are believed to be the prima…
▽ More
The polar regions of Jupiter host a myriad of dynamically interesting phenomena including vortex configurations, folded-filamentary regions (FFRs), and chaotic flows. Juno observations have provided unprecedented views of the high latitudes, allowing for more constraints to be placed upon the troposphere and the overall atmospheric energy cycle. Moist convective events are believed to be the primary drivers of energetic storm behavior as observed on the planet. Here, we introduce a novel single layer shallow water model to investigate the effects of polar moist convective events at high resolution, the presence of dynamical instabilities over long timescales, and the emergence of FFRs at high latitudes. We use a flexible, highly parallelizable, finite-difference hydrodynamic code to explore the parameter space set up by previous models. We study the long term effects of deformation length (Ld), injected pulse size, and injected geopotential. We find that models with Ld beyond 1500 km (planetary Burger number, Bu$=4.4\times10^{-4}$) tend to homogenize their potential vorticity (PV) in the form of dominant stable polar cyclones, while lower Ld cases tend to show less stability with regards to Arnol'd-type flows. We also find that large turbulent forcing scales consistently lead to the formation of high latitude FFRs. Our findings support the idea that moist convection, occurring at high latitudes, may be sufficient to produce the dynamical variety seen at the Jovian poles. Additionally, derived values of localized horizontal shear and Ld may constrain FFR formation and evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Longitudinal Variation of H$_2$O Ice Absorption on Miranda
Authors:
Riley A. DeColibus,
Nancy J. Chanover,
Richard J. Cartwright
Abstract:
Many tidally locked icy satellites in the outer Solar System show leading/trailing hemispherical asymmetries in the strength of near-infrared (NIR) H$_2$O ice absorption bands, in which the absorption bands are stronger on the leading hemisphere. This is often attributed to a combination of magnetospheric irradiation effects and impact gardening, which can modify grain size, expose fresh ice, and…
▽ More
Many tidally locked icy satellites in the outer Solar System show leading/trailing hemispherical asymmetries in the strength of near-infrared (NIR) H$_2$O ice absorption bands, in which the absorption bands are stronger on the leading hemisphere. This is often attributed to a combination of magnetospheric irradiation effects and impact gardening, which can modify grain size, expose fresh ice, and produce dark contaminating compounds that reduce the strength of absorption features. Previous research identified this leading/trailing asymmetry on the four largest classical Uranian satellites but did not find a clear leading/trailing asymmetry on Miranda, the smallest and innermost classical moon. We undertook an extensive observational campaign to investigate variations of the NIR spectral signature of H$_2$O ice with longitude on Miranda's northern hemisphere. We acquired 22 new spectra with the TripleSpec spectrograph on the ARC 3.5m telescope and 4 new spectra with GNIRS on Gemini North. Our analysis also includes 3 unpublished and 7 previously published spectra taken with SpeX on the 3m IRTF. We confirm that Miranda has no substantial leading/trailing hemispherical asymmetry in the strength of its H$_2$O ice absorption features. We additionally find evidence for an anti-Uranus/sub-Uranus asymmetry in the strength of the 1.5-$μ$m H$_2$O ice band that is not seen on the other Uranian satellites, suggesting that additional endogenic or exogenic processes influence the longitudinal distribution of H$_2$O ice band strengths on Miranda.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2023; v1 submitted 22 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Europa's Surface Water-ice Crystallinity and Correlations between Lineae and Hydrate Composition
Authors:
Jodi R. Berdis,
James R. Murphy,
Nancy J. Chanover
Abstract:
Europa's surface composition and evidence for cryovolcanic activity can provide insight into the properties and composition of the subsurface ocean, allowing the evaluation of its potential habitability. One promising avenue for revealing the surface processing and subsurface activity are the relative fractions of crystalline and amorphous water-ice observed on the surface, which are influenced by…
▽ More
Europa's surface composition and evidence for cryovolcanic activity can provide insight into the properties and composition of the subsurface ocean, allowing the evaluation of its potential habitability. One promising avenue for revealing the surface processing and subsurface activity are the relative fractions of crystalline and amorphous water-ice observed on the surface, which are influenced by temperature, charged particle bombardment, vapor deposition, and cryovolcanic activity. The crystallinity observed on Europa's leading hemisphere cannot be reproduced by thermophysical and particle flux modeling alone, indicating that there may be additional processes influencing the surface. We performed a spectral mixture analysis on hyperspectral image cubes from the Galileo Near-Infrared Mapping Spectrometer (NIMS) to identify how surface crystallinity is influenced by physical processing at a high spatial resolution scale. We focus specifically on two image cubes, 15e015 closer to the equator and 17e009 closer to the south pole, both on the leading hemisphere. We performed a nonnegative least-squares spectral mixture analysis to reveal both the non-ice composition and the water-ice crystallinity of the surface. We found that amorphous water-ice dominates the spectrum at the equator and the south pole. We estimated a mean crystallinity of ~35% within the 15e015 NIMS cube and a mean crystallinity of ~15% within the 17e009 NIMS cube, which is consistent with ground-based spectroscopically derived crystallinities. We also identified a correlation of magnesium sulfate, magnesium chloride, and hydrated sulfuric acid with lineae and ridges, which may provide evidence for surface processing by upwelling subsurface material.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Evaluation of short-term temporal evolution of Pluto's surface composition from 2014-2017 with APO/TripleSpec
Authors:
Bryan J. Holler,
Maya D. Yanez,
Silvia Protopapa,
Leslie A. Young,
Anne J. Verbiscer,
Nancy J. Chanover,
William M. Grundy
Abstract:
In this work we present the results of a spectral observing campaign of Pluto to search for temporal changes in surface composition on 1- to 3-year timescales. Near-infrared spectra of Pluto were obtained from June 2014 to August 2017 with the TripleSpec cross-dispersed spectrograph at the Apache Point Observatory's 3.5-meter Astrophysical Research Consortium (ARC) telescope. Observations were req…
▽ More
In this work we present the results of a spectral observing campaign of Pluto to search for temporal changes in surface composition on 1- to 3-year timescales. Near-infrared spectra of Pluto were obtained from June 2014 to August 2017 with the TripleSpec cross-dispersed spectrograph at the Apache Point Observatory's 3.5-meter Astrophysical Research Consortium (ARC) telescope. Observations were requested in order to obtain spectra of approximately the same sub-observer hemisphere $\sim$14 months apart, thus removing the effects of viewing geometry and rotation phase. Comparison of the CH$_4$ (methane) band areas and band center shifts between each component of these "matched pairs" revealed a surface in transition. Band areas for the 1.66 and 1.72 $μ$m CH$_4$ absorption features exhibited a $>$5-$σ$ increase between 2014-06-17 and 2015-08-19, corresponding to a sub-observer hemisphere centered at $\sim$280$^{\circ}$E, with the latter date only 1 month after the New Horizons flyby of Pluto. The majority of matched pairs were obtained of the anti-Charon hemisphere, home to the bright, volatile-rich Sputnik Planitia, and did not present statistically significant changes in CH$_4$ band areas. CH$_4$ band center shifts, which provide information on the mixing state of CH$_4$ and N$_2$ in solid solution, were calculated between components of each matched pair, with no significant band shifts detected. The favored explanation for these combined results is the sublimation of more-volatile N$_2$ from the northern latitudes of Pluto in the lead-up to northern hemisphere summer solstice in 2029, leading to an increase in CH$_4$ concentration.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Mars Astrobiological Cave and Internal habitability Explorer (MACIE): A New Frontiers Mission Concept
Authors:
Charity M. Phillips-Lander,
Ali Agha-Mohammadi,
J. J. Wynne,
Timothy N. Titus,
Nancy Chanover,
Cansu Demirel-Floyd,
Kyle Uckert,
Kaj Williams,
Danielle Wyrick,
Jen Blank,
Penelope Boston,
Karl Mitchell,
Akos Kereszturi,
Javier Martin-Torres,
Svetlana Shkolyar,
Nicole Bardebelias,
Saugata Datta,
Kurt Retherford,
Lydia Sam,
Anshuman Bhardwaj,
Alberto Fairen,
David Flannery,
Roger Weins
Abstract:
Martian subsurface habitability and astrobiology can be evaluated via a lava tube cave, without drilling. MACIE addresses two key goals of the Decadal Survey (2013-2022) and three MEPAG goals. New advances in robotic architectures, autonomous navigation, target sample selection, and analysis will enable MACIE to explore the Martian subsurface.
Martian subsurface habitability and astrobiology can be evaluated via a lava tube cave, without drilling. MACIE addresses two key goals of the Decadal Survey (2013-2022) and three MEPAG goals. New advances in robotic architectures, autonomous navigation, target sample selection, and analysis will enable MACIE to explore the Martian subsurface.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Vertical Structure and Color of Jovian Latitudinal Cloud Bands during the Juno Era
Authors:
Emma K. Dahl,
Nancy J. Chanover,
Glenn S. Orton,
Kevin H. Baines,
James A. Sinclair,
David G. Voelz,
Erandi A. Wijerathna,
Paul D. Strycker,
Patrick G. J. Irwin
Abstract:
The identity of the coloring agent(s) in Jupiter's atmosphere and the exact structure of Jupiter's uppermost cloud deck are yet to be conclusively understood. The Crème Brûlée model of Jupiter's tropospheric clouds, originally proposed by Baines et al. (2014) and expanded upon by Sromovsky et al. (2017) and Baines et al. (2019), presumes that the chromophore measured by Carlson et al. (2016) is th…
▽ More
The identity of the coloring agent(s) in Jupiter's atmosphere and the exact structure of Jupiter's uppermost cloud deck are yet to be conclusively understood. The Crème Brûlée model of Jupiter's tropospheric clouds, originally proposed by Baines et al. (2014) and expanded upon by Sromovsky et al. (2017) and Baines et al. (2019), presumes that the chromophore measured by Carlson et al. (2016) is the singular coloring agent in Jupiter's troposphere. In this work, we test the validity of the Crème Brûlée model of Jupiter's uppermost cloud deck using spectra measured during the Juno spacecraft's 5$^{\mathrm{th}}$ perijove pass in March 2017. These data were obtained as part of an international ground-based observing campaign in support of the Juno mission using the NMSU Acousto-optic Imaging Camera (NAIC) at the 3.5-m telescope at Apache Point Observatory in Sunspot, NM. We find that the Crème Brûlée model cloud layering scheme can reproduce Jupiter's visible spectrum both with the Carlson et al. (2016) chromophore and with modifications to its imaginary index of refraction spectrum. While the Crème Brûlée model provides reasonable results for regions of Jupiter's cloud bands such as the North Equatorial Belt and Equatorial Zone, we find that it is not a safe assumption for unique weather events, such as the 2016-2017 Southern Equatorial Belt outbreak that was captured by our measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Ice Giant Atmospheric Science
Authors:
Emma K. Dahl,
Shawn Brueshaber,
Richard Cosentino,
Csaba Palotai,
Naomi Rowe-Gurney,
Ramanakumar Sankar,
Kunio Sayanagi,
Shahid Aslam,
Kevin Baines,
Erika Barth,
Nancy J. Chanover,
Leigh N. Fletcher,
Sandrine Guerlet,
Heidi Hammel,
Mark Hofstadter,
Ali Hyder,
Erin Leonard,
Timothy A. Livengood,
Tom Momary,
Glenn Orton,
Imke de Pater,
Kurt Retherford,
James Sinclair,
Krista Soderlund,
Linda Spilker
, et al. (2 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This white paper, written in support of NASA's 2023-2032 Planetary Decadal Survey, outlines 10 major questions that focus on the origin, evolution, and current processes that shape the atmospheres of Uranus and Neptune. Prioritizing these questions over the next decade will greatly improve our understanding of this unique class of planets, which have remained largely unexplored since the Voyager f…
▽ More
This white paper, written in support of NASA's 2023-2032 Planetary Decadal Survey, outlines 10 major questions that focus on the origin, evolution, and current processes that shape the atmospheres of Uranus and Neptune. Prioritizing these questions over the next decade will greatly improve our understanding of this unique class of planets, which have remained largely unexplored since the Voyager flybys. Studying the atmospheres of the Ice Giants will greatly inform our understanding of the origin and evolution of the solar system as a whole, in addition to the growing number of exoplanetary systems that contain Neptune-mass planets.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Transformative Planetary Science with the US ELT Program
Authors:
Michael H. Wong,
Karen J. Meech,
Mark Dickinson,
Thomas Greathouse,
Richard J. Cartwright,
Nancy Chanover,
Matthew S. Tiscareno
Abstract:
The proposed US Extremely Large Telescope (ELT) Program would secure national open access to at least 25% of the observing time on the Thirty Meter Telescope in the north and the Giant Magellan Telescope in the south. ELTs would advance solar system science via exceptional angular resolution, sensitivity, and advanced instrumentation. ELT contributions would include the study of interstellar objec…
▽ More
The proposed US Extremely Large Telescope (ELT) Program would secure national open access to at least 25% of the observing time on the Thirty Meter Telescope in the north and the Giant Magellan Telescope in the south. ELTs would advance solar system science via exceptional angular resolution, sensitivity, and advanced instrumentation. ELT contributions would include the study of interstellar objects, giant planet systems and ocean worlds, the formation of the solar system traced through small objects in the asteroid and Kuiper belts, and the active support of planetary missions. We recommend that (1) the US ELT Program be listed as critical infrastructure for solar system science, that (2) some support from NASA be provided to ensure mission support capabilities, and that (3) the US ELT Program expand solar-system community participation in development, planning, and operations.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Water Within a Permanently Shadowed Lunar Crater: Further LCROSS Modeling and Analysis
Authors:
Kristen M. Luchsinger,
Nancy J. Chanover,
Paul D. Strycker
Abstract:
The 2009 Lunar CRater Observation and Sensing Satellite (LCROSS) impact mission detected water ice absorption using spectroscopic observations of the impact-generated debris plume taken by the Shepherding Spacecraft, confirming an existing hypothesis regarding the existence of water ice in permanently shadowed regions within Cabeus crater. Ground-based observations in support of the mission were a…
▽ More
The 2009 Lunar CRater Observation and Sensing Satellite (LCROSS) impact mission detected water ice absorption using spectroscopic observations of the impact-generated debris plume taken by the Shepherding Spacecraft, confirming an existing hypothesis regarding the existence of water ice in permanently shadowed regions within Cabeus crater. Ground-based observations in support of the mission were able to further constrain the mass of the debris plume and the concentration of the water ice ejected during the impact. In this work, we explore additional constraints on the initial conditions of the pre-impact lunar sediment required in order to produce a plume model that is consistent with the ground-based observations. We match the observed debris plume lightcurve using a layer of dirty ice with an ice concentration that increases with depth, a layer of pure regolith, and a layer of material at about 6 meters below the lunar surface that would otherwise have been visible in the plume but has a high enough tensile strength to resist excavation. Among a few possible materials, a mixture of regolith and ice with a sufficiently high ice concentration could plausibly produce such a behavior. The vertical albedo profiles used in the best fit model allows us to calculate a pre-impact mass of water ice within Cabeus crater of $5 \pm 3.0 \times 10^{11}$ kg and a mass concentration of water in the lunar sediment of $8.2 \pm 0.001$ %wt, assuming a water ice albedo of 0.8 and a lunar regolith density of 1.5 g cm$^{-3}$, or a mass concentration of water of $4.3 \pm 0.01$ %wt, assuming a lunar regolith density of 3.0. These models fit to ground-based observations result in derived masses of regolith and water ice within the debris plume that are consistent with \emph{in situ} measurements, with a model debris plume ice mass of 108 kg.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
The science enabled by a dedicated solar system space telescope
Authors:
Cindy L. Young,
Michael H. Wong,
Kunio M. Sayanagi,
Shannon Curry,
Kandis L. Jessup,
Tracy Becker,
Amanda Hendrix,
Nancy Chanover,
Stephanie Milam,
Bryan J. Holler,
Gregory Holsclaw,
Javier Peralta,
John Clarke,
John Spencer,
Michael S. P. Kelley,
Janet Luhmann,
David MacDonnell,
Ronald J. Vervack Jr.,
Kurt Retherford,
Leigh N. Fletcher,
Imke de Pater,
Faith Vilas,
Lori Feaga,
Oswald Siegmund,
Jim Bell
, et al. (13 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The National Academy Committee on Astrobiology and Planetary Science (CAPS) made a recommendation to study a large/medium-class dedicated space telescope for planetary science, going beyond the Discovery-class dedicated planetary space telescope endorsed in Visions and Voyages. Such a telescope would observe targets across the entire solar system, engaging a broad spectrum of the science community…
▽ More
The National Academy Committee on Astrobiology and Planetary Science (CAPS) made a recommendation to study a large/medium-class dedicated space telescope for planetary science, going beyond the Discovery-class dedicated planetary space telescope endorsed in Visions and Voyages. Such a telescope would observe targets across the entire solar system, engaging a broad spectrum of the science community. It would ensure that the high-resolution, high-sensitivity observations of the solar system in visible and UV wavelengths revolutionized by the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) could be extended. A dedicated telescope for solar system science would: (a) transform our understanding of time-dependent phenomena in our solar system that cannot be studied currently under programs to observe and visit new targets and (b) enable a comprehensive survey and spectral characterization of minor bodies across the solar system, which requires a large time allocation not supported by existing facilities. The time-domain phenomena to be explored are critically reliant on high spatial resolution UV-visible observations. This paper presents science themes and key questions that require a long-lasting space telescope dedicated to planetary science that can capture high-quality, consistent data at the required cadences that are free from effects of the terrestrial atmosphere and differences across observing facilities. Such a telescope would have excellent synergy with astrophysical facilities by placing planetary discoveries made by astrophysics assets in temporal context, as well as triggering detailed follow-up observations using larger telescopes. The telescope would support future missions to the Ice Giants, Ocean Worlds, and minor bodies across the solar system by placing the results of such targeted missions in the context of longer records of temporal activities and larger sample populations.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Architectures and Technologies for a Space Telescope for Solar System Science
Authors:
Kunio M. Sayanagi,
Cindy L. Young,
Lynn Bowman,
Joseph Pitman,
Bo Naasz,
Bonnie Meinke,
Tracy Becker,
Jim Bell,
Richard Cartwright,
Nancy Chanover,
John Clarke,
Joshua Colwell,
Shannon Curry,
Imke de Pater,
Gregory Delory,
Lori Feaga,
Leigh N. Fletcher,
Thomas Greathouse,
Amanda Hendrix,
Bryan J. Holler,
Gregory Holsclaw,
Kandis L. Jessup,
Michael S. P. Kelley,
Robert Lillis,
Rosaly M. C. Lopes
, et al. (15 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We advocate for a mission concept study for a space telescope dedicated to solar system science in Earth orbit. Such a study was recommended by the Committee on Astrobiology and Planetary Science (CAPS) report "Getting Ready for the Next Planetary Science Decadal Survey." The Mid-Decadal Review also recommended NASA to assess the role and value of space telescopes for planetary science. The need f…
▽ More
We advocate for a mission concept study for a space telescope dedicated to solar system science in Earth orbit. Such a study was recommended by the Committee on Astrobiology and Planetary Science (CAPS) report "Getting Ready for the Next Planetary Science Decadal Survey." The Mid-Decadal Review also recommended NASA to assess the role and value of space telescopes for planetary science. The need for high-resolution, UV-Visible capabilities is especially acute for planetary science with the impending end of the Hubble Space Telescope (HST); however, NASA has not funded a planetary telescope concept study, and the need to assess its value remains. Here, we present potential design options that should be explored to inform the decadal survey.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Europa's surface water ice crystallinity: Discrepancy between observations and thermophysical and particle flux modeling
Authors:
Jodi R. Berdis,
Murthy S. Gudipati,
James R. Murphy,
Nancy J. Chanover
Abstract:
Physical processing of Europan surface water ice by thermal relaxation, charged particle bombardment, and possible cryovolcanic activity can alter the percentage of the crystalline form of water ice compared to that of the amorphous form of water ice (the ''crystallinity'') on Europa's surface. The timescales over which amorphous water ice is thermally transformed to crystalline water ice at Europ…
▽ More
Physical processing of Europan surface water ice by thermal relaxation, charged particle bombardment, and possible cryovolcanic activity can alter the percentage of the crystalline form of water ice compared to that of the amorphous form of water ice (the ''crystallinity'') on Europa's surface. The timescales over which amorphous water ice is thermally transformed to crystalline water ice at Europan surface temperatures suggests that the water ice there should be primarily in the crystalline form, however, surface bombardment by charged particles induced by Jupiter's magnetic field, and vapor deposition of water ice from Europan plumes, can produce amorphous water ice surface deposits on short timescales. The purpose of this investigation is to determine whether the Europan surface water ice crystallinity derived from ground-based spectroscopic measurements is in agreement with the crystallinity expected based on temperature and radiation modeling. Using a 1D thermophysical model of Europa's surface, we calculate a full-disk crystallinity of Europa's leading hemisphere by incorporating the thermal relaxation of amorphous to crystalline water ice and the degradation of crystalline to amorphous water ice by irradiation. Concurrently, we derive the full-disk crystallinity of Europa's leading hemisphere using a comparison of near-infrared ground-based spectral observations from Grundy et al. (1999), Busarev et al. (2018), and the Apache Point Observatory with laboratory spectra from Mastrapa et al. (2018) and the Ice Spectroscopy Lab at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory. We calculate a modeled crystallinity significantly higher than crystallinities derived from ground-based observations and laboratory spectra. This discrepancy may be a result of geophysical processes, such as by vapor-deposited plume material, or it may arise from assumptions and uncertainties in the crystallinity calculations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Astro2020 APC White Paper: Tying Research Funding to Progress on Inclusion
Authors:
Dara Norman,
Terri Brandt,
Zack Berta-Thompson,
Natalia Lewandowsha,
Karen Knierman,
Nancy Chanover,
Jena Whitley,
Aparna Venkatesan,
Kim Coble,
Adam Burgasser,
Marie Lemoine-Busserolle,
Kelle Cruz,
Christopher S. Moore,
Kwame Osei-Sarfo,
Sheila Kannappan
Abstract:
The US professional astronomy and astrophysics fields are not representative of the diversity of people in the nation. For example, 2017 AIP reports show that in 2014, women made up only about 20 percent of the faculty in astronomy and physics departments, and the numbers for under-represented minorities (men and women) were, and remain, low. However numerous studies have demonstrated that diverse…
▽ More
The US professional astronomy and astrophysics fields are not representative of the diversity of people in the nation. For example, 2017 AIP reports show that in 2014, women made up only about 20 percent of the faculty in astronomy and physics departments, and the numbers for under-represented minorities (men and women) were, and remain, low. However numerous studies have demonstrated that diverse groups (in both cognition and identity) outperform groups that are more homogeneous, even when the homogeneous group is comprised of all "high achieving experts." (Hong and Page, 2004, Kleinberg and Raghu, 2018). This has been shown to be the case on a variety of complex tasks. Thus, if we want the best opportunity to make progress on and answer the research questions of the 2020s, we must employ diverse teams who bring different heuristics and perspectives to those problems. However, currently in the field there are few tangible motivations to encourage projects, missions or programs to employ teams that are diverse in both cognitive areas and identity to take on these complex problems. Managing groups and organizations contracted to run these efforts are currently not required or incentivized to employ an identity diverse workforce.
In this position (white) paper, we recommend that agency funding (from NSF, NASA, DOE, etc.), especially for missions, projects and programs, encourage the development and retention of diverse teams by requiring documentation of and progress on metrics related to diversity, inclusion and equity. We further recommend that documented progress on diversity and inclusion metrics should be monitored in reviews alongside project management and budget reporting. Managing groups and organizations proposing to administer projects on behalf of agencies should be required to demonstrate competency with respect to diversity and inclusion metrics.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Astro2020 APC White Paper: Providing a Timely Review of Input Demographics to Advisory Committees
Authors:
Dara Norman,
Terri J. Brandt,
Nancy D. Morrison,
Sarah Tuttle,
Julie Rathbun,
Zach Berta-Thompson,
Edmund Bertschinger,
Nancy Chanover,
Karen Knierman,
Aparna Venkatesan,
Kim Coble,
Jonathan Fraine,
Adam Burgasser,
Ivelina Momcheva,
Marie Lemoine-Busserolle
Abstract:
Organizations that support science (astronomy) such as federal agencies, research centers, observatories, academic institutions, societies, etc. employ advisory committees and boards as a mechanism for reviewing their activities and giving advice on practices, policies and future directions. As with any scientific endeavor, there is concern over complementing these committees with enough members w…
▽ More
Organizations that support science (astronomy) such as federal agencies, research centers, observatories, academic institutions, societies, etc. employ advisory committees and boards as a mechanism for reviewing their activities and giving advice on practices, policies and future directions. As with any scientific endeavor, there is concern over complementing these committees with enough members who have as broad a range of expertise and understanding as possible, so that bias is mitigated. However, for a number of reasons (logistical, practical, financial, etc.), committees can also not be infinitely large and thus trade-offs must be made. It is often recognized that conflicts of interest must be acknowledged within these committees, but what is not often recognized it the potential for unmitigated biases and "group think" that can be introduced as part of these committees.
In this white paper, we recommend that advisory committees that collect community input, (e.g., the Decadal Survey review committee), also collect, compile and review input demographic data before finalizing reports, (e.g., the final 2020 Decadal Survey Report). A summary of these data should be released alongside the final survey report. This information would enable the committee to understand potential "blind spots" and biases of the data collection phase and inform future data collections of any barriers that affect the omission of perspectives from various demographics.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Astro2020 Science White Paper: Triggered High-Priority Observations of Dynamic Solar System Phenomena
Authors:
Nancy Chanover,
Michael H. Wong,
Thomas Greathouse,
David Trilling,
Al Conrad,
Imke de Pater,
Eric Gaidos,
Richard Cartwright,
Michael Lucas,
Karen Meech,
Glenn Orton,
Noemi Pinilla-Alonso,
Kunio Sayanagi,
Megan E. Schwamb,
Matthew Tiscareno,
Christian Veillet,
Bryan Holler,
Katherine de Kleer,
Heidi Hammel,
Amanda Hendrix,
Angel Otarola,
Conor Nixon,
Susan Benecchi,
Amy Simon,
Kathleen Mandt
, et al. (8 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Unexpected dynamic phenomena have surprised solar system observers in the past and have led to important discoveries about solar system workings. Observations at the initial stages of these events provide crucial information on the physical processes at work. We advocate for long-term/permanent programs on ground-based and space-based telescopes of all sizes - including Extremely Large Telescopes…
▽ More
Unexpected dynamic phenomena have surprised solar system observers in the past and have led to important discoveries about solar system workings. Observations at the initial stages of these events provide crucial information on the physical processes at work. We advocate for long-term/permanent programs on ground-based and space-based telescopes of all sizes - including Extremely Large Telescopes (ELTs) - to conduct observations of high-priority dynamic phenomena, based on a predefined set of triggering conditions. These programs will ensure that the best initial dataset of the triggering event are taken; separate additional observing programs will be required to study the temporal evolution of these phenomena. While not a comprehensive list, the following are notional examples of phenomena that are rare, that cannot be anticipated, and that provide high-impact advances to our understandings of planetary processes. Examples include: new cryovolcanic eruptions or plumes on ocean worlds; impacts on Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, or Neptune; extreme eruptions on Io; convective superstorms on Saturn, Uranus, or Neptune; collisions within the asteroid belt or other small-body populations; discovery of an interstellar object passing through our solar system (e.g. 'Oumuamua); and responses of planetary atmospheres to major solar flares or coronal mass ejections.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Solar system Deep Time-Surveys of atmospheres, surfaces, and rings
Authors:
Michael H. Wong,
Richard Cartwright,
Nancy Chanover,
Kunio Sayanagi,
Thomas Greathouse,
Matthew Tiscareno,
Rohini Giles,
Glenn Orton,
David Trilling,
James Sinclair,
Noemi Pinilla-Alonso,
Michael Lucas,
Eric Gaidos,
Bryan Holler,
Stephanie Milam,
Angel Otarola,
Amy Simon,
Katherine de Kleer,
Conor Nixon,
Patrick Fry,
Máté Ádámkovics,
Statia H. Luszcz-Cook,
Amanda Hendrix
Abstract:
Imaging and resolved spectroscopy reveal varying environmental conditions in our dynamic solar system. Many key advances have focused on how these conditions change over time. Observatory-level commitments to conduct annual observations of solar system bodies would establish a long-term legacy chronicling the evolution of dynamic planetary atmospheres, surfaces, and rings. Science investigations w…
▽ More
Imaging and resolved spectroscopy reveal varying environmental conditions in our dynamic solar system. Many key advances have focused on how these conditions change over time. Observatory-level commitments to conduct annual observations of solar system bodies would establish a long-term legacy chronicling the evolution of dynamic planetary atmospheres, surfaces, and rings. Science investigations will use these temporal datasets to address potential biosignatures, circulation and evolution of atmospheres from the edge of the habitable zone to the ice giants, orbital dynamics and planetary seismology with ring systems, exchange between components in the planetary system, and the migration and processing of volatiles on icy bodies, including Ocean Worlds. The common factor among these diverse investigations is the need for a very long campaign duration, and temporal sampling at an annual cadence.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Spatial Variations in Titan's Atmospheric Temperature: ALMA and Cassini Comparisons from 2012 to 2015
Authors:
A. E. Thelen,
C. A. Nixon,
N. J. Chanover,
E. M. Molter,
M. A. Cordiner,
R. K. Achterberg,
J. Serigano,
P. G. J. Irwin,
N. A. Teanby,
S. B. Charnley
Abstract:
Submillimeter emission lines of carbon monoxide (CO) in Titan's atmosphere provide excellent probes of atmospheric temperature due to the molecule's long chemical lifetime and stable, well constrained volume mixing ratio. Here we present the analysis of 4 datasets obtained with the Atacama Large Millimeter/Submillimeter Array (ALMA) from 2012 to 2015 that contain strong CO rotational transitions.…
▽ More
Submillimeter emission lines of carbon monoxide (CO) in Titan's atmosphere provide excellent probes of atmospheric temperature due to the molecule's long chemical lifetime and stable, well constrained volume mixing ratio. Here we present the analysis of 4 datasets obtained with the Atacama Large Millimeter/Submillimeter Array (ALMA) from 2012 to 2015 that contain strong CO rotational transitions. Utilizing ALMA's high spatial resolution in the 2012, 2014, and 2015 observations, we extract spectra from 3 separate regions on Titan's disk using datasets with beam sizes of ~0.3''. Temperature profiles retrieved by the NEMESIS radiative transfer code are compared to Cassini Composite Infrared Spectrometer (CIRS) and radio occultation science results from similar latitude regions. Small seasonal variations in atmospheric temperature are present from 2012 to 2015 in the stratosphere and mesosphere (~100-500 km) of spatially resolved regions. We measure the stratopause (320 km) to increase in temperature by 5 K in northern latitudes from 2012-2015, while temperatures rise throughout the stratosphere at lower latitudes. While retrieved temperature profiles cover a range of latitudes in these observations, deviations from CIRS nadir maps and radio occultation measurements convolved with the ALMA beam-footprint are not found to be statistically significant, and discrepancies are often found to be less than 5 K throughout the atmosphere. ALMA's excellent sensitivity in the lower stratosphere (60-300 km) provides a highly complementary dataset to contemporary CIRS and radio science observations. The demonstrated utility of CO emission lines in the submillimeter as a tracer of Titan's atmospheric temperature lays the groundwork for future studies of other molecular species, as temperature profiles are found to consistently vary with latitude in all three years by up to 15 K.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Abundance Measurements of Titan's Stratospheric HCN, HC$_3$N, C$_3$H$_4$, and CH$_3$CN from ALMA Observations
Authors:
A. E. Thelen,
C. A. Nixon,
N. J. Chanover,
M. A. Cordiner,
E. M. Molter,
N. A. Teanby,
P. G. J. Irwin,
J. Serigano,
S. B. Charnley
Abstract:
Previous investigations have employed more than 100 close observations of Titan by the Cassini orbiter to elucidate connections between the production and distribution of Titan's vast, organic-rich chemical inventory and its atmospheric dynamics. However, as Titan transitions into northern summer, the lack of incoming data from the Cassini orbiter presents a potential barrier to the continued stud…
▽ More
Previous investigations have employed more than 100 close observations of Titan by the Cassini orbiter to elucidate connections between the production and distribution of Titan's vast, organic-rich chemical inventory and its atmospheric dynamics. However, as Titan transitions into northern summer, the lack of incoming data from the Cassini orbiter presents a potential barrier to the continued study of seasonal changes in Titan's atmosphere. In our previous work (Thelen et al., 2018), we demonstrated that the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) is well suited for measurements of Titan's atmosphere in the stratosphere and lower mesosphere (~100-500 km) through the use of spatially resolved (beam sizes <1'') flux calibration observations of Titan. Here, we derive vertical abundance profiles of four of Titan's trace atmospheric species from the same 3 independent spatial regions across Titan's disk during the same epoch (2012 to 2015): HCN, HC$_3$N, C$_3$H$_4$, and CH$_3$CN. We find that Titan's minor constituents exhibit large latitudinal variations, with enhanced abundances at high latitudes compared to equatorial measurements; this includes CH$_3$CN, which eluded previous detection by Cassini in the stratosphere, and thus spatially resolved abundance measurements were unattainable. Even over the short 3-year period, vertical profiles and integrated emission maps of these molecules allow us to observe temporal changes in Titan's atmospheric circulation during northern spring. Our derived abundance profiles are comparable to contemporary measurements from Cassini infrared observations, and we find additional evidence for subsidence of enriched air onto Titan's south pole during this time period. Continued observations of Titan with ALMA beyond the summer solstice will enable further study of how Titan's atmospheric composition and dynamics respond to seasonal changes.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Giant Planet Observations with the James Webb Space Telescope
Authors:
James Norwood,
Julianne Moses,
Leigh N. Fletcher,
Glenn Orton,
Patrick G. J. Irwin,
Sushil Atreya,
Kathy Rages,
Thibault Cavalié,
Agustin Sánchez-Lavega,
Ricardo Hueso,
Nancy Chanover
Abstract:
This white paper examines the benefit of the upcoming James Webb Space Telescope for studies of the Solar System's four giant planets: Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune. JWST's superior sensitivity, combined with high spatial and spectral resolution, will enable near- and mid-infrared imaging and spectroscopy of these objects with unprecedented quality. In this paper we discuss some of the myri…
▽ More
This white paper examines the benefit of the upcoming James Webb Space Telescope for studies of the Solar System's four giant planets: Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune. JWST's superior sensitivity, combined with high spatial and spectral resolution, will enable near- and mid-infrared imaging and spectroscopy of these objects with unprecedented quality. In this paper we discuss some of the myriad scientific investigations possible with JWST regarding the giant planets. This discussion is preceded by the specifics of JWST instrumentation most relevant to giant planet observations. We conclude with identification of desired pre-launch testing and operational aspects of JWST that would greatly benefit future studies of the giant planets.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Evolution of H$_2$O, CO, and CO$_2$ Production in Comet C/2009 P1 Garradd During the 2011-2012 Apparition
Authors:
Adam J. McKay,
Anita L. Cochran,
Michael A. DiSanti,
Geronimo Villanueva,
Neil Dello Russo,
Ronald J. Vervack Jr.,
Jeffrey P. Morgenthaler,
Walter M. Harris,
Nancy J. Chanover
Abstract:
We present analysis of high spectral resolution NIR spectra of CO and H$_2$O in comet C/2009 P1 (Garradd) taken during its 2011-2012 apparition with the CSHELL instrument on NASA's Infrared Telescope Facility (IRTF). We also present analysis of observations of atomic oxygen in comet Garradd obtained with the ARCES echelle spectrometer mounted on the ARC 3.5-meter telescope at Apache Point Observat…
▽ More
We present analysis of high spectral resolution NIR spectra of CO and H$_2$O in comet C/2009 P1 (Garradd) taken during its 2011-2012 apparition with the CSHELL instrument on NASA's Infrared Telescope Facility (IRTF). We also present analysis of observations of atomic oxygen in comet Garradd obtained with the ARCES echelle spectrometer mounted on the ARC 3.5-meter telescope at Apache Point Observatory and the Tull Coude spectrograph on the Harlan J. Smith 2.7-meter telescope at McDonald Observatory. The observations of atomic oxygen serve as a proxy for H$_2$O and CO$_2$. We confirm the high CO abundance in comet Garradd and the asymmetry in the CO/H$_2$O ratio with respect to perihelion reported by previous studies. From the oxygen observations, we infer that the CO$_2$/H$_2$O ratio decreased as the comet moved towards the Sun, which is expected based on current sublimation models. We also infer that the CO$_2$/H$_2$O ratio was higher pre-perihelion than post-perihelion. We observe evidence for the icy grain source of H$_2$O reported by several studies pre-perihelion, and argue that this source is significantly less abundant post-perihelion. Since H$_2$O, CO$_2$, and CO are the primary ices in comets, they drive the activity. We use our measurements of these important volatiles in an attempt to explain the evolution of Garradd's activity over the apparition.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Solar System Observations with the James Webb Space Telescope
Authors:
James Norwood,
Heidi Hammel,
Stefanie Milam,
John Stansberry,
Jonathan Lunine,
Nancy Chanover,
Dean Hines,
George Sonneborn,
Matthew Tiscareno,
Michael Brown,
Pierre Ferruit
Abstract:
The James Webb Space Telescope will enable a wealth of new scientific investigations in the near- and mid-infrared, with sensitivity and spatial/spectral resolution greatly surpassing its predecessors. In this paper, we focus upon Solar System science facilitated by JWST, discussing the most current information available concerning JWST instrument properties and observing techniques relevant to pl…
▽ More
The James Webb Space Telescope will enable a wealth of new scientific investigations in the near- and mid-infrared, with sensitivity and spatial/spectral resolution greatly surpassing its predecessors. In this paper, we focus upon Solar System science facilitated by JWST, discussing the most current information available concerning JWST instrument properties and observing techniques relevant to planetary science. We also present numerous example observing scenarios for a wide variety of Solar System targets to illustrate the potential of JWST science to the Solar System community. This paper updates and supersedes the Solar System white paper published by the JWST Project in 2010 (Lunine et al., 2010). It is based both on that paper and on a workshop held at the annual meeting of the Division for Planetary Sciences in Reno, NV in 2012.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2015; v1 submitted 26 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
CLOUDS search for variability in brown dwarf atmospheres
Authors:
B. Goldman,
M. C. Cushing,
M. S. Marley,
É. Artigau,
K. S. Baliyan,
V. J. S. Béjar,
J. A. Caballero,
N. Chanover,
M. Connelley,
R. Doyon,
T. Forveille,
S. Ganesh,
C. R. Gelino,
H. B. Hammel,
J. Holtzman,
S. Joshi,
U. C. Joshi,
S. K. Leggett,
M. C. Liu,
E. L. Martín,
V. Mohan,
D. Nadeau,
R. Sagar,
D. Stephens
Abstract:
Context: L-type ultra-cool dwarfs and brown dwarfs have cloudy atmospheres that could host weather-like phenomena. The detection of photometric or spectral variability would provide insight into unresolved atmospheric heterogeneities, such as holes in a global cloud deck.
Aims: It has been proposed that growth of heterogeneities in the global cloud deck may account for the L- to T-type transit…
▽ More
Context: L-type ultra-cool dwarfs and brown dwarfs have cloudy atmospheres that could host weather-like phenomena. The detection of photometric or spectral variability would provide insight into unresolved atmospheric heterogeneities, such as holes in a global cloud deck.
Aims: It has been proposed that growth of heterogeneities in the global cloud deck may account for the L- to T-type transition as brown dwarf photospheres evolve from cloudy to clear conditions. Such a mechanism is compatible with variability. We searched for variability in the spectra of five L6 to T6 brown dwarfs in order to test this hypothesis.
Methods: We obtained spectroscopic time series using VLT/ISAAC, over 0.99-1.13um, and IRTF/SpeX for two of our targets, in J, H and K bands. We search for statistically variable lines and correlation between those.
Results: High spectral-frequency variations are seen in some objects, but these detections are marginal and need to be confirmed. We find no evidence for large amplitude variations in spectral morphology and we place firm upper limits of 2 to 3% on broad-band variability, on the time scale of a few hours. The T2 transition brown dwarf SDSS J1254-0122 shows numerous variable features, but a secure variability diagnosis would require further observations.
Conclusions: Assuming that any variability arises from the rotation of patterns of large-scale clear and cloudy regions across the surface, we find that the typical physical scale of cloud cover disruption should be smaller than 5-8% of the disk area for four of our targets. The possible variations seen in SDSS J1254-0122 are not strong enough to allow us to confirm the cloud breaking hypothesis.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Vertical Structure Modeling of Saturn's Equatorial Region Using High Spectral Resolution Imaging
Authors:
T. Temma,
N. J. Chanover,
A. A. Simon-Miller,
D. A. Glenar,
J. J. Hillman,
D. M. Kuehn
Abstract:
Saturn was observed on 6-11 February 2002 using an Acousto-optic Imaging Spectrometer (AImS) to study Saturn's vertical cloud structure. The 3.67-m Advanced Electro-Optical System telescope at the Maui Space Surveillance Complex was used. The high spectral resolution and wide spectral coverage of AImS (500 - 1000 nm) enabled us to sample the Saturnian atmosphere with high vertical resolution and…
▽ More
Saturn was observed on 6-11 February 2002 using an Acousto-optic Imaging Spectrometer (AImS) to study Saturn's vertical cloud structure. The 3.67-m Advanced Electro-Optical System telescope at the Maui Space Surveillance Complex was used. The high spectral resolution and wide spectral coverage of AImS (500 - 1000 nm) enabled us to sample the Saturnian atmosphere with high vertical resolution and to derive the wavelength dependence of aerosol properties. The model center-limb profiles were fit to the observed profiles in the equatorial region. Adopting four different cloud models with three aerosol phase functions, we varied up to nine free parameters to seek the best solution. The results of the simultaneous fits to nine different profiles around the 890-nm and 727-nm methane bands suggest that : 1) a cloud model having higher aerosol density in the lower troposphere (0.15 - 1.5 bar) is favorable, 2) the tropospheric cloud extends into the stratosphere, 3) the wavelength dependence of the upper cloud optical thickness indicates that the average aerosol size is larger than 0.7 - 0.8 micron, 4) the average aerosol size of the upper tropospheric cloud increases with depth from about 0.15 micron to between 0.7--0.8 and 1.5 micron, 5) the aerosol properties in February 2002 are similar to those observed during the 1990 equatorial disturbance.
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2003;
originally announced July 2003.
-
L-Band Photometry of L and T Dwarfs
Authors:
D. C. Stephens,
M. S. Marley,
K. S. Noll,
N. Chanover
Abstract:
We present K- and L-band photometry obtained with the Keck I telescope for a representative sample of L and T dwarfs. These observations were motivated in part by the dominant role water and methane play in shaping the flux near 2 and 3 microns and by the potential use of these bands as indicators of spectral class in the infrared. In addition, these observations aid the determination of the bol…
▽ More
We present K- and L-band photometry obtained with the Keck I telescope for a representative sample of L and T dwarfs. These observations were motivated in part by the dominant role water and methane play in shaping the flux near 2 and 3 microns and by the potential use of these bands as indicators of spectral class in the infrared. In addition, these observations aid the determination of the bolometric luminosity of L and T dwarfs. Here we report the K, L' and Ls magnitudes of our objects and the trends observed in the (K-L') and (K-Ls) colors as a function of L- and T-dwarf spectral class. We compare these colors with theoretical models, derive a relationship between effective temperature and L-spectral class, and compare our temperature estimates with others.
△ Less
Submitted 25 June, 2001;
originally announced June 2001.
