-
A Comparative Study of the Ground State Transitions of CO and [C I] as Molecular Gas Tracers at High Redshift
Authors:
Marta Frias Castillo,
Matus Rybak,
Jacqueline A. Hodge,
Paul Van der Werk,
Ian Smail,
Joshua Butterworth,
Jasper Jansen,
Theodoros Topkaras,
Chian-Chou Chen,
Scott C. Chapman,
Axel Weiss,
Hiddo Algera,
Jack E. Birkin,
Elisabete da Cunha,
Jianhang Chen,
Helmut Dannerbauer,
E. F. Jiménez-Andrade,
Soh Ikarashi,
Cheng-Lin Liao,
Eric J. Murphy,
A. M. Swinbank,
Fabian Walter,
Gabriela Calistro Rivera,
R. J. Ivison,
Claudia del P. Lagos
Abstract:
The CO(1--0) and [\ion{C}{1}](1--0) emission lines are well-established tracers of cold molecular gas mass in local galaxies. At high redshift, where the interstellar medium (ISM) is likely to be denser, there have been limited direct comparisons of both ground state transitions. Here we present a study of CO(1--0) and [\ion{C}{1}](1--0) emission in a sample of 20 unlensed dusty, star-forming gala…
▽ More
The CO(1--0) and [\ion{C}{1}](1--0) emission lines are well-established tracers of cold molecular gas mass in local galaxies. At high redshift, where the interstellar medium (ISM) is likely to be denser, there have been limited direct comparisons of both ground state transitions. Here we present a study of CO(1--0) and [\ion{C}{1}](1--0) emission in a sample of 20 unlensed dusty, star-forming galaxies at $z=2-5$. The CO(1--0)/[\ion{C}{1}](1--0) ratio is constant up to at least $z=5$, supporting the use of [CI](1-0) as a gas mass tracer. PDR modelling of the available data indicates a median H$_2$ density of log$(n~[$cm$^{-3}])=4.7\pm0.2$, and UV radiation field log$(G_{\mathrm{UV}} [G$_0$])=3.2\pm0.2$. We use the CO(1--0), [\ion{C}{1}](1--0) and 3mm dust continuum measurements to cross--calibrate the respective gas mass conversion factors, finding no dependence of these factors on either redshift or infrared luminosity. Assuming a variable CO conversion factor then implies [\ion{C}{1}] and dust conversion factors that differ from canonically assumed values but are consistent with the solar/super-solar metallicities expected for our sources. Radiative transfer modelling shows that the warmer CMB at high redshift can significantly affect the [\ion{C}{1}] as well as CO emission, which can change the derived molecular gas masses by up to 70\% for the coldest kinetic gas temperatures expected. Nevertheless, we show that the magnitude of the effect on the ratio of the tracers is within the known scatter of the $L'_\mathrm{CO}-L'_\mathrm{[CI]}$ relation. Further determining the absolute decrease of individual line intensities will require well-sampled spectral line energy distributions (SLEDs) to model the gas excitation conditions in more detail.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
At the end of cosmic noon: Short gas depletion times in unobscured quasars at $z \sim$ 1
Authors:
M. Frias Castillo,
M. Rybak,
J. Hodge,
P. van der Werf,
L. J. Abbo,
F. J. Ballieux,
S. Ward,
C. Harrison,
G. Calistro Rivera,
J. P. McKean,
H. R. Stacey
Abstract:
Unobscured quasars (QSOs) are predicted to be the final stage in the evolutionary sequence from gas-rich mergers to gas-depleted, quenched galaxies. Studies of this population, however, find a high incidence of far-infrared-luminous sources -suggesting significant dust-obscured star formation-but direct observations of the cold molecular gas fuelling this star formation are still necessary. We pre…
▽ More
Unobscured quasars (QSOs) are predicted to be the final stage in the evolutionary sequence from gas-rich mergers to gas-depleted, quenched galaxies. Studies of this population, however, find a high incidence of far-infrared-luminous sources -suggesting significant dust-obscured star formation-but direct observations of the cold molecular gas fuelling this star formation are still necessary. We present a NOEMA study of CO(2-1) emission, tracing the cold molecular gas, in ten lensed z=1-1.5 unobscured QSOs. We detected CO(2-1) in seven of our targets, four of which also show continuum emission (λ_rest = 1.3mm). After subtracting the foreground galaxy contribution to the photometry, spectral energy distribution fitting yielded stellar masses of 10^9-11 M_\odot, with star formation rates of 25-160 M_\odot yr^-1 for the host galaxies. These QSOs have lower $L'_\mathrm{CO}$ than star-forming galaxies with the same L_IR, and show depletion times spanning a large range (50-900 Myr), but with a median of just 90 Myr. We find molecular gas masses in the range 2-40 x 10^9(alpha_CO/4) M_\odot, which suggest gas fractions above ~50% for most of the targets. Despite the presence of an unobscured QSO, the host galaxies are able to retain significant amounts of cold gas. However, with a median depletion time of ~90 Myr, the intense burst of star formation taking place in these targets will quickly deplete their molecular gas reservoirs in the absence of gas replenishment, resulting in a quiescent host galaxy. The non-detected QSOs are three of the four radio-loud QSOs in the sample, and their properties indicate that they are likely already transitioning into quiescence. Recent cosmological simulations tend to overestimate the depletion times expected for these z~1 QSO-host galaxies, which is likely linked to their difficulty producing starbursts across the general high-redshift galaxy population.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2024; v1 submitted 9 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
An ALMA Spectroscopic Survey of the Brightest Submillimeter Galaxies in the SCUBA-2-COSMOS Field (AS2COSPEC): Physical Properties of z=2-5 Ultra- and Hyperluminous Infrared Galaxies
Authors:
Cheng-Lin Liao,
Chian-Chou Chen,
Wei-Hao Wang,
Ian Smail,
Yiping Ao,
Scott C. Chapman,
Ugne Dudzeviciute,
Marta Frias Castillo,
Minju M. Lee,
Stephen Serjeant,
A. Mark Swinbank,
Dominic J. Taylor,
Hideki Umehata,
Yinghe Zhao
Abstract:
We report physical properties of the brightest ($S_{870\,μ\rm m}=12.4$-$19.2\,$mJy) and not strongly lensed 18 870$\,μ$m selected dusty star-forming galaxies (DSFGs), also known as submillimeter galaxies (SMGs), in the COSMOS field. This sample is part of an ALMA band$\,$3 spectroscopic survey (AS2COSPEC), and spectroscopic redshifts are measured in 17 of them at $z=2$-$5$. We perform spectral ene…
▽ More
We report physical properties of the brightest ($S_{870\,μ\rm m}=12.4$-$19.2\,$mJy) and not strongly lensed 18 870$\,μ$m selected dusty star-forming galaxies (DSFGs), also known as submillimeter galaxies (SMGs), in the COSMOS field. This sample is part of an ALMA band$\,$3 spectroscopic survey (AS2COSPEC), and spectroscopic redshifts are measured in 17 of them at $z=2$-$5$. We perform spectral energy distribution analyses and deduce a median total infrared luminosity of $L_{\rm IR}=(1.3\pm0.1)\times10^{13}\,L_{\odot}$, infrared-based star-formation rate of ${\rm SFR}_{\rm IR}=1390\pm150~M_{\odot}\,\rm yr^{-1}$, stellar mass of $M_\ast=(1.4\pm0.6)\times10^{11}\,M_\odot$, dust mass of $M_{\rm dust}=(3.7\pm0.5)\times10^9\,M_\odot$, and molecular gas mass of $M_{\rm gas}= (α_{\rm CO}/0.8)(1.2\pm0.1)\times10^{11}\,M_\odot$, suggesting that they are one of the most massive, ISM-enriched, and actively star-forming systems at $z=2$-$5$. In addition, compared to less massive and less active galaxies at similar epochs, SMGs have comparable gas fractions; however, they have much shorter depletion time, possibly caused by more active dynamical interactions. We determine a median dust emissivity index of $β=2.1\pm0.1$ for our sample, and by combining our results with those from other DSFG samples, we find no correlation of $β$ with redshift or infrared luminosity, indicating similar dust grain compositions across cosmic time for infrared luminous galaxies. We also find that AS2COSPEC SMGs have one of the highest dust-to-stellar mass ratios, with a median of $0.02\pm0.01$, significantly higher than model predictions, possibly due to too strong of a AGN feedback implemented in the model. Finally, our complete and uniform survey enables us to put constraints on the most massive end of the dust and molecular gas mass functions.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2024; v1 submitted 29 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
VLA Legacy Survey of Molecular Gas in Massive Star-forming Galaxies at High Redshift
Authors:
Marta Frias Castillo,
Jacqueline Hodge,
Matus Rybak,
Paul van der Werf,
Ian Smail,
Jack Birkin,
Chian-Chou Chen,
Scott Chapman,
Ryley Hill,
Claudia del P. Lagos,
Cheng-Lin Liao,
Elisabete da Cunha,
Gabriela Calistro Rivera,
Jianhang Chen,
Eric Jimenez Andrade,
Eric Murphy,
Douglas Scott,
Mark Swinbank,
Fabian Walter,
Rob Ivison,
Helmut Dannerbauer
Abstract:
We present initial results of an ongoing survey with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array targeting the CO($J$ = 1-0) transition in a sample of 30 submillimeter-selected, dusty star-forming galaxies at $z =$ 2-5 with existing mid--$J$ CO detections from ALMA and NOEMA, of which 17 have been fully observed. We detect CO(1-0) emission in 11 targets, along with three tentative ($\sim$1.5-2$σ$) detecti…
▽ More
We present initial results of an ongoing survey with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array targeting the CO($J$ = 1-0) transition in a sample of 30 submillimeter-selected, dusty star-forming galaxies at $z =$ 2-5 with existing mid--$J$ CO detections from ALMA and NOEMA, of which 17 have been fully observed. We detect CO(1-0) emission in 11 targets, along with three tentative ($\sim$1.5-2$σ$) detections; three galaxies are undetected. Our results yield total molecular gas masses of 6-23$\times$10$^{10}$ ($α_\mathrm{CO}$/1) M$_\odot$, with gas mass fractions, $f_\mathrm{gas}$=$M_\mathrm{mol}$/($M_*$+$M_\mathrm{mol}$), of 0.1-0.8 and a median depletion time of (140$\pm$70) Myr. We find median CO excitation ratios of $r_{31}$ = 0.75$\pm$0.39 and $r_{41}$ = 0.63$\pm$0.44, with a significant scatter. We find no significant correlation between the excitation ratio and a number of key parameters such as redshift, CO(1-0) line width or $Σ_\mathrm{SFR}$. We only find a tentative positive correlation between $r_{41}$ and the star-forming efficiency, but we are limited by our small sample size. Finally, we compare our results to predictions from the SHARK semi-analytical model, finding a good agreement between the molecular gas masses, depletion times and gas fractions of our sources and their SHARK counterparts. Our results highlight the heterogeneous nature of the most massive star-forming galaxies at high-redshift, and the importance of CO(1--0) observations to robustly constrain their total molecular gas content and ISM properties.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2023; v1 submitted 7 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Kiloparsec-scale imaging of the CO(1-0)-traced cold molecular gas reservoir in a z~3.4 submillimeter galaxy
Authors:
Marta Frias Castillo,
Matus Rybak,
Jacqueline Hodge,
Paul van der Werf,
Dominik A. Riechers,
Daniel Vieira,
Gabriela Calistro Rivera,
Laura N. Martinez-Ramirez,
Fabian Walter,
Erwin de Blok,
Desika Narayanan,
Jeff Wagg
Abstract:
We present a high-resolution study of the cold molecular gas as traced by CO(1-0) in the unlensed z$\sim$3.4 submillimeter galaxy SMM J13120+4242, using multi-configuration observations with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (JVLA). The gas reservoir, imaged on 0.39" ($\sim$3 kpc) scales, is resolved into two components separated by $\sim$11 kpc with a total extent of 16 $\sim$3 kpc. Despite the…
▽ More
We present a high-resolution study of the cold molecular gas as traced by CO(1-0) in the unlensed z$\sim$3.4 submillimeter galaxy SMM J13120+4242, using multi-configuration observations with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (JVLA). The gas reservoir, imaged on 0.39" ($\sim$3 kpc) scales, is resolved into two components separated by $\sim$11 kpc with a total extent of 16 $\sim$3 kpc. Despite the large spatial extent of the reservoir, the observations show a CO(1-0) FWHM linewidth of only 267 $\pm$ 64 km s$^{-1}$. We derive a revised line luminosity of L'$_\mathrm{CO(1-0)}$ = (10 $\pm$ 3) $\times$ 10$^{10}$ K km s$^{-1}$ pc$^2$ and a molecular gas mass of M$_\mathrm{gas}$ = (13 $\pm$ 3) $\times$ 10$^{10}$ ($α_\mathrm{CO}$/1) M$_{\odot}$. Despite the presence of a velocity gradient (consistent with previous resolved CO(6-5) imaging), the CO(1-0) imaging shows evidence for significant turbulent motions which are preventing the gas from fully settling into a disk. The system likely represents a merger in an advanced stage. Although the dynamical mass is highly uncertain, we use it to place an upper limit on the CO-to-H$_2$ mass conversion factor $α_\mathrm{CO}$ of 1.4. We revisit the SED fitting, finding that this galaxy lies on the very massive end of the main sequence at z = 3.4. Based on the low gas fraction, short gas depletion time and evidence for a central AGN, we propose that SMM J13120 is in a rapid transitional phase between a merger-driven starburst and an unobscured quasar. The case of SMM J13120 highlights the how mergers may drive important physical changes in galaxies without pushing them off the main sequence.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.