-
Star-by-star dynamical evolution of the physical pair of the Collinder 135 and UBC 7 open clusters
Authors:
Maryna Ishchenko,
Dana A. Kovaleva,
Peter Berczik,
Nina V. Kharchenko,
Anatoly E. Piskunov,
Evgeny Polyachenko,
Ekaterina Postnikova,
Andreas Just,
Olga Borodina,
Chingis Omarov,
Olexandr Sobodar
Abstract:
In a previous paper using Gaia DR2 data, we demonstrated that the two closely situated open clusters Collinder 135 and UBC 7 might have formed together about 50 Myr ago. In this work, we performed star-by-star dynamical modelling of the evolution of the open clusters Collinder 135 and UBC 7 from their supposed initial state to their present-day state, reproducing observational distributions of mem…
▽ More
In a previous paper using Gaia DR2 data, we demonstrated that the two closely situated open clusters Collinder 135 and UBC 7 might have formed together about 50 Myr ago. In this work, we performed star-by-star dynamical modelling of the evolution of the open clusters Collinder 135 and UBC 7 from their supposed initial state to their present-day state, reproducing observational distributions of members. Modelling of the Collinder 135 and UBC 7 dynamical evolution was done using the high-order parallel N-body code φ-GPU with up-to-date stellar evolution. Membership and characteristics of the clusters were acquired based on Gaia DR3 data. The comparison of the present-day radial cumulative star count obtained from the N-body simulations with the current observational data gave us full consistency of the model with observational data, especially in the central 8 pc, where 80% of the stars reside. The proper motion velocity components obtained from the N-body simulations of the stars are also quite consistent with the observed distributions and error bars. These results show that our numerical modelling is able to reproduce the open clusters' current complex 6D observed phase-space distributions with a high level of confidence. Thus, the model demonstrates that the hypothesis of a common origin of Collinder 135 and UBC 7 complies with present-day observational data.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2024; v1 submitted 18 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
On the Tremaine-Weinberg method: how much can we trust gas tracers to measure pattern speeds?
Authors:
Olga Borodina,
Thomas G. Williams,
Mattia C. Sormani,
Sharon Meidt,
Eva Schinnerer
Abstract:
Pattern speeds are a fundamental parameter of the dynamical features (e.g. bars, spiral arms) of a galaxy, setting resonance locations. Pattern speeds are not directly observable, so the Tremaine-Weinberg (TW) method has become the most common method used to measure them in galaxies. However, it has not been tested properly whether this method can straightforwardly be applied to gas tracers, despi…
▽ More
Pattern speeds are a fundamental parameter of the dynamical features (e.g. bars, spiral arms) of a galaxy, setting resonance locations. Pattern speeds are not directly observable, so the Tremaine-Weinberg (TW) method has become the most common method used to measure them in galaxies. However, it has not been tested properly whether this method can straightforwardly be applied to gas tracers, despite this being widely done in the literature. When applied to observations, the TW method may return invalid results, which are difficult to diagnose due to a lack of ground truth for comparison. Although some works applying the TW method to simulated galaxies exist, only stellar populations have been tested. Therefore, here we explore the applicability of the TW method for gas gracers, by applying it to hydrodynamical simulations of galaxies, where we know the true value of the bar pattern speed. We perform some simple tests to see if the TW method has a physically reasonable output. We add different kinds of uncertainties (e.g. in position angle or flux) to the data to mock observational errors based on the magnitude of uncertainty present in the observations. Second, we test the method on 3D simulations with chemical networks. We show that in general, applying TW to observations of gas will not recover the true pattern speed. These results have implications for many "pattern speeds" reported in the literature, and based on these tests we also give some best practices for measuring pattern speeds using gas tracers going forwards.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
The bound mass of Dehnen models with centrally peaked star formation efficiency
Authors:
B. Shukirgaliyev,
A. Otebay,
M. Sobolenko,
M. Ishchenko,
O. Borodina,
T. Panamarev,
S. Myrzakul,
M. Kalambay,
A. Naurzbayeva,
E. Abdikamalov,
E. Polyachenko,
S. Banerjee,
P. Berczik,
R. Spurzem,
A. Just
Abstract:
Understanding the formation of star clusters with low star-formation efficiency (SFE) is very important to know about the star-formation history. In N-body models of star cluster evolution after gas expulsion, the Plummer model with outer power law density profile has been used massively. We study the impact of the density profile slopes on the survivability of the low-SFE star clusters after inst…
▽ More
Understanding the formation of star clusters with low star-formation efficiency (SFE) is very important to know about the star-formation history. In N-body models of star cluster evolution after gas expulsion, the Plummer model with outer power law density profile has been used massively. We study the impact of the density profile slopes on the survivability of the low-SFE star clusters after instantaneous gas expulsion. We compare cases when stellar cluster has Plummer profile and Dehnen profiles with cusp of different slopes at the time of formation. We determine the corresponding density profile of the residual gas for a given global SFE, assuming that our model clusters formed with a constant efficiency per free-fall time and hence have shallower density profile of gas than that of stars. We perform direct $N$-body simulations of evolution of clusters initially in virial equilibrium within gas potential after gas removal. We find that the violent relaxation lasts no longer than 20~Myr independently of the density profile power law slopes. Dehnen model clusters survive after violent relaxation with significantly lower SFEs when the global SFE measured within the Jacobi radius or within a half-mass radius. Dehnen $γ=0$ model clusters show similar final bound fraction with the Plummer model clusters if global SFE is measured within 10 scale radii. The final bound fraction increases with $γ$ values for a given global SFE. We conclude that Dehnen clusters better resist the consequences of the violent relaxation followed the instantaneous gas expulsion than the Plummer clusters. Thus the shallower the outer density slope of the low-SFE clusters, the better for their survivability after gas expulsion. Among Dehnen clusters we find that the steeper the inner slope (cusp) the higher the bound mass fraction is retained after violent relaxation for a given global SFE.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2021; v1 submitted 20 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Damped perturbations in stellar systems: Genuine modes and Landau-damped waves
Authors:
Evgeny V. Polyachenko,
Ilia G. Shukhman,
Olga I. Borodina
Abstract:
This research was stimulated by the recent studies of damping solutions in dynamically stable spherical stellar systems. Using the simplest model of the homogeneous stellar medium, we discuss nontrivial features of stellar systems. Taking them into account will make it possible to correctly interpret the results obtained earlier and will help to set up decisive numerical experiments in the future.…
▽ More
This research was stimulated by the recent studies of damping solutions in dynamically stable spherical stellar systems. Using the simplest model of the homogeneous stellar medium, we discuss nontrivial features of stellar systems. Taking them into account will make it possible to correctly interpret the results obtained earlier and will help to set up decisive numerical experiments in the future. In particular, we compare the initial value problem versus the eigenvalue problem. It turns out that in the unstable regime, the Landau-damped waves can be represented as a superposition of van Kampen modes {\it plus} a discrete damped mode, usually ignored in the stability study. This mode is a solution complex conjugate to the unstable Jeans mode. In contrast, the Landau-damped waves are not genuine modes: in modes, eigenfunctions depend on time as $\exp (-{\rm i} ωt)$, while the waves do not have eigenfunctions on the real $v$-axis at all. However, `eigenfunctions' on the complex $v$-contours do exist. Deviations from the Landau damping are common and can be due to singularities or cut-off of the initial perturbation above some fixed value in the velocity space.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2021; v1 submitted 20 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Unresolved multiple stars and Galactic clusters' mass estimates
Authors:
Olga I. Borodina,
Giovanni Carraro,
Anton F. Seleznev,
Vladimir M. Danilov
Abstract:
If not properly accounted for, unresolved binary stars can induce a bias in the photometric determination of star cluster masses inferred from star counts and the luminosity function. A correction factor close to 1.15 (for a binary fraction of 0.35) was found in \citep{Boro19}, which needs to be applied to blind photometric mass estimates. This value for the correction factor was found to be small…
▽ More
If not properly accounted for, unresolved binary stars can induce a bias in the photometric determination of star cluster masses inferred from star counts and the luminosity function. A correction factor close to 1.15 (for a binary fraction of 0.35) was found in \citep{Boro19}, which needs to be applied to blind photometric mass estimates. This value for the correction factor was found to be smaller than literature values. In an attempt to lift this discrepancy, in this work the focus is on higher order multiple stars with the goal of investigating the effect of triple and quadruple systems adopting the same methodology and data-set as in the quoted work. Then the result is found that when triple and quadruple together with binary systems are properly accounted for, the actual cluster mass (computed as all stars were single) should be incremented by a factor of 1.18$-$1.27, depending on the cluster and when the binary fraction $α$ is 0.35. Fitting formulae are provided to derive the increment factor for different binary star percentages.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Unresolved binaries and Galactic clusters' mass estimates
Authors:
Olga I. Borodina,
Anton F. Seleznev,
Giovanni Carraro,
Vladimir M. Danilov
Abstract:
Binary stars are present in all stellar systems, yet their role is far from being fully understood. We investigate the effect of unresolved binaries in the derivation of open clusters' mass by star counts. We start from the luminosity functions of five open clusters: IC 2714, NGC 1912, NGC 2099, NGC 6834 and NGC 7142. Luminosity functions are obtained via star counts extracted from the 2MASS datab…
▽ More
Binary stars are present in all stellar systems, yet their role is far from being fully understood. We investigate the effect of unresolved binaries in the derivation of open clusters' mass by star counts. We start from the luminosity functions of five open clusters: IC 2714, NGC 1912, NGC 2099, NGC 6834 and NGC 7142. Luminosity functions are obtained via star counts extracted from the 2MASS database. The fraction of binaries is considered to be independent on stellar magnitude. We take into account different assumptions for the binary mass ratio distribution and assign binary masses using the so-called {\it luminosity-limited pairing} method and Monte-Carlo simulations. We show that cluster masses increase when binary stars are appropriately taken into account.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
