-
Quasars as standard candles VI: spectroscopic validation of the cosmological sample
Authors:
Bartolomeo Trefoloni,
Elisabeta Lusso,
Emanuele Nardini,
Guido Risaliti,
Alessandro Marconi,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Andrea Sacchi,
Matilde Signorini
Abstract:
A sample of quasars has been recently assembled to investigate the non-linear relation between their monochromatic luminosities at 2500Å, and 2 keV and to exploit quasars as a new class of standardized candles. The use of this technique for cosmological purposes relies on the non-evolution with redshift of the UV-optical spectral properties of quasars, as well as on the absence of possible contami…
▽ More
A sample of quasars has been recently assembled to investigate the non-linear relation between their monochromatic luminosities at 2500Å, and 2 keV and to exploit quasars as a new class of standardized candles. The use of this technique for cosmological purposes relies on the non-evolution with redshift of the UV-optical spectral properties of quasars, as well as on the absence of possible contaminants such as dust extinction and host-galaxy contribution. We address these possible issues by analysing the spectral properties of our cosmological quasar sample. We produced composite spectra in different bins of redshift and accretion parameters (black hole mass, bolometric luminosity), to investigate any possible evolution of the spectral properties of the continuum of the composites with these parameters. We found a remarkable similarity amongst the various stacked spectra. The overall shape of the continuum does not show any statistically significant trend with the accretion parameters nor with the redshift. The composite spectrum of our quasar sample is consistent with negligible levels of both intrinsic reddening (with a colour excess E(B-V)< 0.01) and host-galaxy emission (less than 10%) in the optical. We tested whether unaccounted dust extinction could explain the discrepancy between our cosmographic fit of the Hubble-Lemaitre diagram and the concordance ΛCDM model. The average colour excess required to solve the tension should increase with redshift up to unphysically high values (E(B-V)=0.1 at z>3) that would imply that the intrinsic emission of quasars is much bluer and more luminous than ever reported in observed spectra. The similarity of quasar spectra across the parameter space excludes a significant evolution of the average continuum properties with any of the explored parameters, confirming the reliability of our sample for cosmological applications.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
The Scavenger Hunt for Quasar Samples to Be Used as Cosmological Tools
Authors:
Maria Giovanna Dainotti,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Aleksander Łukasz Lenart,
Salvatore Capozziello
Abstract:
Although the $Λ$ Cold Dark Matter model is the most accredited cosmological model, information at high redshifts ($z$) between type Ia supernovae ($z=2.26$) and the Cosmic Microwave Background ($z=1100$) is crucial to validate this model further. To this end, we have discovered a sample of 1132 quasars up to $z=7.54$ exhibiting a reduced intrinsic dispersion of the relation between ultraviolet and…
▽ More
Although the $Λ$ Cold Dark Matter model is the most accredited cosmological model, information at high redshifts ($z$) between type Ia supernovae ($z=2.26$) and the Cosmic Microwave Background ($z=1100$) is crucial to validate this model further. To this end, we have discovered a sample of 1132 quasars up to $z=7.54$ exhibiting a reduced intrinsic dispersion of the relation between ultraviolet and X-ray fluxes, $δ_\mathrm{F}=0.22$ vs. $δ_\mathrm{F}=0.29$ ($24\%$ less), than the original sample. This gold sample, once we correct the luminosities for selection biases and redshift evolution, enables us to determine the matter density parameter $Ω_M$ with a precision of 0.09. Unprecedentedly, this quasar sample is the only one that, as a standalone cosmological probe, yields such tight constraints on $Ω_M$ while being drawn from the same parent population of the initial sample.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Quasars as Standard Candles V. Evaluation of a $\leq$ 0.06 dex intrinsic dispersion in the LX-LUV relation
Authors:
Matilde Signorini,
Guido Risaliti,
Elisabeta Lusso,
Emanuele Nardini,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Andrea Sacchi,
Bartolomeo Trefoloni
Abstract:
A characteristic feature of quasars is the observed non-linear relationship between their monochromatic luminosities at rest-frame 2500 Å and 2 keV. This relationship is evident across all redshifts and luminosities and, due to its non-linearity, can be implemented to estimate quasar distances and construct a Hubble Diagram for quasars. Historically, a significant challenge in the cosmological app…
▽ More
A characteristic feature of quasars is the observed non-linear relationship between their monochromatic luminosities at rest-frame 2500 Å and 2 keV. This relationship is evident across all redshifts and luminosities and, due to its non-linearity, can be implemented to estimate quasar distances and construct a Hubble Diagram for quasars. Historically, a significant challenge in the cosmological application of this relation has been its high observed dispersion. Recent studies have demonstrated that this dispersion can be reduced by excluding biased objects from the sample. Nevertheless, the dispersion remains considerable ($δ\sim 0.20$ dex), especially when compared to the Phillips relation for supernovae Ia. Given the absence of a comprehensive physical model for the relation, it remains unclear how much of the remaining dispersion is intrinsically tied to the relation itself and how much can be attributed to observational factors not addressed by the sample selection and by the choice of X-ray and UV indicators. Potential contributing factors include (i) the scatter produced by using X-ray photometric results instead of spectroscopic ones, (ii) the intrinsic variability of quasars, and (iii) the inclination of the accretion disc relative to our line of sight. In this study, we thoroughly examine these three factors and quantify their individual contributions to the observed dispersion. Based on our findings, we argue that the intrinsic dispersion of the X-ray/UV luminosity relation is likely below 0.06 dex. We also discuss why high-redshift subsamples can show a significantly lower dispersion than the average one.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Tensions with the flat $\boldsymbolΛ$CDM model from high-redshift cosmography
Authors:
G. Bargiacchi,
M. G. Dainotti,
S. Capozziello
Abstract:
The longstanding search for the cosmological model that best describes the Universe has been made more intriguing since the recent discovery of the Hubble constant, $H_{0}$, tension observed between the value of $H_{0}$ from the Cosmic Microwave Background and from type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia). Hence, the commonly trusted flat $Λ$CDM model is under investigation. In this scenario, cosmography is a…
▽ More
The longstanding search for the cosmological model that best describes the Universe has been made more intriguing since the recent discovery of the Hubble constant, $H_{0}$, tension observed between the value of $H_{0}$ from the Cosmic Microwave Background and from type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia). Hence, the commonly trusted flat $Λ$CDM model is under investigation. In this scenario, cosmography is a very powerful technique to investigate the evolution of the Universe without any cosmological assumption, thus revealing tensions between observational data and predictions from cosmological models in a completely model-independent way. We here employ a robust cosmographic technique based on an orthogonal logarithmic polynomial expansion of the luminosity distance to fit quasars (QSOs) alone and QSOs combined with Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs), SNe Ia, and Baryon Acoustic Oscillations. To apply QSOs and GRBs as probes we use, respectively, the Risaliti-Lusso relation between ultraviolet and X-ray luminosities and the ``Dainotti GRB 3D relation" among the rest-frame end time of the X-ray plateau emission, its corresponding luminosity, and the peak prompt luminosity. We also correct QSOs and GRBs for selection biases and redshift evolution and we employ both the traditional Gaussian likelihood and the newly discovered best-fit likelihoods for each probe investigated. This comprehensive analysis reveals a strong tension ($> 4 \, σ$) between our data sets and the flat $Λ$CDM model proving the power of both the cosmographic approach and high-redshift sources, such as QSOs and GRBs, which can probe the Universe at early epochs.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Quasars as Standard Candles IV. Analysis of the X-ray and UV indicators of the disc-corona relation
Authors:
Matilde Signorini,
Guido Risaliti,
Elisabeta Lusso,
Emanuele Nardini,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Andrea Sacchi,
Bartolomeo Trefoloni
Abstract:
Context: A non-linear relation between quasar monochromatic luminosities at 2500A and 2 keV holds at all observed redshifts and luminosities, and it has been used to derive quasar distances and to build a Hubble Diagram of quasars. The choice of the X-ray and UV indicators has so far been somewhat arbitrary, and has typically relied on photometric data. Aims: We want to determine the X-ray and UV…
▽ More
Context: A non-linear relation between quasar monochromatic luminosities at 2500A and 2 keV holds at all observed redshifts and luminosities, and it has been used to derive quasar distances and to build a Hubble Diagram of quasars. The choice of the X-ray and UV indicators has so far been somewhat arbitrary, and has typically relied on photometric data. Aims: We want to determine the X-ray and UV proxies that provide the smallest dispersion of the relation, in order to obtain more precise distance estimates, and to confirm the reliability of the X-ray to UV relation as a distance indicator. Methods: We performed a complete UV spectroscopic analysis of a sample of $\sim$1800 quasars with SDSS optical spectra and XMM- Newton X-ray serendipitous observations. In the X-rays, we analysed the spectra of all the sample objects at redshift z $>$1.9, while we relied on photometric measurements at lower redshifts. As done in previous studies, we analysed the relation in small redshift bins, using fluxes instead of luminosities. Results: We show that the monochromatic fluxes at 1 keV and 2500A are, respectively, the best X-ray and UV continuum indicators among those that are typically available. We also find a tight relation between soft X-ray and Mg ii2800A line fluxes, and a marginal dependence of the X-ray to UV relation on the width of the Mg ii line. Conclusions: Our analysis suggests that the physical quantities that are more tightly linked to one another are the soft X-ray flux at $\sim$1 keV and the ionizing UV flux blueward of the Lyman limit. However, the "usual" monochromatic fluxes at 2 keV and 2500A estimated from photometric data provide an almost as-tight X-ray to UV relation, and can be used to derive quasar distances. The Hubble diagram obtained using spectroscopic indicators is fully consistent with the one presented in previous papers, based on photometric data.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Quasars: standard candles up to z=7.5 with the precision of Supernovae Ia
Authors:
Maria Giovanna Dainotti,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Aleksander Łukasz Lenart,
Shigehiro Nagataki,
Salvatore Capozziello
Abstract:
Currently, the $Λ$ Cold Dark Matter model, which relies on the existence of cold dark matter and a cosmological constant $Λ$, best describes the Universe. However, we lack information in the high-redshift ($z$) region between Type Ia Supernovae (SNe Ia) (up to $z=2.26$) and the Cosmic Microwave Background ($z=1100$), an interval crucial to test cosmological models and their possible evolution. We…
▽ More
Currently, the $Λ$ Cold Dark Matter model, which relies on the existence of cold dark matter and a cosmological constant $Λ$, best describes the Universe. However, we lack information in the high-redshift ($z$) region between Type Ia Supernovae (SNe Ia) (up to $z=2.26$) and the Cosmic Microwave Background ($z=1100$), an interval crucial to test cosmological models and their possible evolution. We have defined a sample of 983 Quasars up to $z=7.54$ with reduced intrinsic dispersion $δ=0.007$ which determines the matter density parameter $Ω_M$ with the same precision of SNe Ia. Although previous analysis have been used Quasars as cosmological tools (e.g. Risaliti and Lusso 2019), this is the first time that high-redshift sources, in this case Quasars, as standalone cosmological probes yield such tight constraints on $Ω_M$. Our results show the importance of correcting cosmological relationships for selection biases and redshift evolution and how the choice of a golden sample reduces considerably the intrinsic scatter. This proves the reliability of Quasars as standard cosmological candles.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Reducing the uncertainty on the Hubble constant up to 35\% with an improved statistical analysis: different best-fit likelihoods for Supernovae Ia, Baryon Acoustic Oscillations, Quasars, and Gamma-Ray Bursts
Authors:
Maria Giovanna Dainotti,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Małgorzata Bogdan,
Aleksander Łukasz Lenart,
Kazunari Iwasaki,
Salvatore Capozziello,
Bing Zhang,
Nissim Fraija
Abstract:
Cosmological models and their parameters are widely debated, especially about whether the current discrepancy between the values of the Hubble constant, $H_{0}$, obtained by type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia), and the Planck data from the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation could be alleviated when alternative cosmological models are considered. Thus, combining high-redshift probes, such as Gamma-Ray B…
▽ More
Cosmological models and their parameters are widely debated, especially about whether the current discrepancy between the values of the Hubble constant, $H_{0}$, obtained by type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia), and the Planck data from the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation could be alleviated when alternative cosmological models are considered. Thus, combining high-redshift probes, such as Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs) and Quasars (QSOs), together with Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO) and SNe Ia is important to assess the viability of these alternative models and if they can cast further light on the Hubble tension. In this work, for GRBs, we use a 3-dimensional relation between the peak prompt luminosity, the rest-frame time at the end of the X-ray plateau, and its corresponding luminosity in X-rays: the 3D Dainotti fundamental plane relation. Regarding QSOs, we use the Risaliti-Lusso relation among the UV and X-ray luminosities for a sample of 2421 sources. We correct both the QSO and GRB relations by accounting for selection and evolutionary effects with a reliable statistical method. We here use both the traditional Gaussian likelihoods ($\cal L_G$) and the new best-fit likelihoods ($\cal L_N$) to infer cosmological parameters of a non-flat $Λ$CDM and flat $w$CDM models. We obtain for all the parameters reduced uncertainties, up to $35\%$ for $H_{0}$, when applying the new $\cal L_N$ likelihoods in place of the Gaussian ones. Our results remain consistent with a flat $Λ$CDM model, although with a shift of the dark energy parameter $w$ toward $w<-1$ and a curvature density parameter toward $Ω_k<0$.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
The most luminous blue quasars at 3.0<z<3.3 -- III. LBT spectra and accretion parameters
Authors:
Bartolomeo Trefoloni,
Elisabeta Lusso,
Emanuele Nardini,
Guido Risaliti,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Susanna Bisogni,
Francesca M. Civano,
Martin Elvis,
Giuseppina Fabbiano,
Roberto Gilli,
Alessandro Marconi,
Gordon T. Richards,
Andrea Sacchi,
Francesco Salvestrini,
Matilde Signorini,
Cristian Vignali
Abstract:
We present the analysis of the rest frame ultraviolet and optical spectra of 30 bright blue quasars at $z\sim3$, selected to examine the suitability of AGN as cosmological probes. In our previous works, we found an unexpectedly high fraction ($\approx 25 \%$) of X-ray weak quasars in the sample. The latter sources also display a flatter UV continuum and a broader and fainter CIV profile in the arc…
▽ More
We present the analysis of the rest frame ultraviolet and optical spectra of 30 bright blue quasars at $z\sim3$, selected to examine the suitability of AGN as cosmological probes. In our previous works, we found an unexpectedly high fraction ($\approx 25 \%$) of X-ray weak quasars in the sample. The latter sources also display a flatter UV continuum and a broader and fainter CIV profile in the archival UV data with respect to their X-ray normal counterparts. Here we present new observations with the LBT in both the $zJ$ (rest-frame $\simeq$2300-3100 $\rm \mathring{A}$) and the $K_S$ ($\simeq$4750-5350 $\rm \mathring{A}$) bands. We estimated black hole masses ($M_{\rm BH}$) and Eddington ratios ($λ_{\rm Edd}$) from the from the H$β$ and MgII emission lines, finding that our $z\sim3$ quasars are on average highly accreting ($\langle λ_{\rm Edd} \rangle\simeq 1.2$ and $\langle M_{\rm BH} \rangle\simeq 10^{9.7}M_\odot$), with no difference in $λ_{\rm Edd}$ or $M_{\rm BH}$ between X-ray weak and X-ray normal quasars. From the $zJ$ spectra, we derive flux and equivalent width of MgII and FeII, finding that X-ray weak quasars display higher FeII/MgII ratios with respect to typical quasars. FeII/MgII ratios of X-ray normal quasars are instead consistent with other estimates up to $z\simeq6.5$, corroborating the idea of already chemically mature BLRs at early cosmic time. From the $K_S$ spectra, we find that all the X-ray weak quasars present generally weaker [OIII] emission (EW<10 $\rm \mathring{A}$) than the normal ones. The sample as a whole, however, abides by the known X-ray/[OIII] luminosity correlation, hence the different [OIII] properties are likely due to an intrinsically weaker [OIII] emission in X-ray weak objects, associated to the shape of the spectral energy distribution. We interpret these results in the framework of accretion-disc winds.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Quasars as high-redshift standard candles
Authors:
Guido Risaliti,
Elisabeta Lusso,
Emanuele Nardini,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Susanna Bisogni,
Andrea Sacchi,
Matilde Signorini,
Bartolomeo Trefoloni
Abstract:
In the past few years, we built a Hubble diagram of quasars up to redshift z$\sim$7, based on the nonlinear relation between quasars' x-ray and UV luminosities. Such a Hubble diagram shows a >4$σ$ deviation from the standard flat $Λ$CDM model at z>1.5. Given the important consequences of this result, it is fundamental to rule out any systematic effect in the selection of the sample and/or in the f…
▽ More
In the past few years, we built a Hubble diagram of quasars up to redshift z$\sim$7, based on the nonlinear relation between quasars' x-ray and UV luminosities. Such a Hubble diagram shows a >4$σ$ deviation from the standard flat $Λ$CDM model at z>1.5. Given the important consequences of this result, it is fundamental to rule out any systematic effect in the selection of the sample and/or in the flux measurements, and to investigate possible redshift dependences of the relation, that would invalidate the use of quasars as standard candles. Here we review all the observational results supporting our method: the match of the Hubble diagram of quasars with that of supernovae in the common redshift range, the constant slope of the relation at all redshifts, the redshift non-evolution of the spectral properties of our sources both in the x-rays and in the UV. An independent test of our results requires the observation of other standard candles at high redshift. In particular, we expect that future observations of supernovas at z>2 will confirm the deviation from the concordance model found with the Hubble diagram of quasars.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Gamma-Ray Bursts, Quasars, Baryonic Acoustic Oscillations, and Supernovae Ia: new statistical insights and cosmological constraints
Authors:
G. Bargiacchi,
M. G. Dainotti,
S. Nagataki,
S. Capozziello
Abstract:
The recent $\sim 4 \, σ$ Hubble constant, $H_{0}$, tension is observed between the value of $H_{0}$ from the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and Type Ia Supernovae (SNe Ia). It is a decade since this tension is excruciating the modern astrophysical community. To shed light on this problem is key to consider probes at intermediate redshifts between SNe Ia and CMB and reduce the uncertainty on…
▽ More
The recent $\sim 4 \, σ$ Hubble constant, $H_{0}$, tension is observed between the value of $H_{0}$ from the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and Type Ia Supernovae (SNe Ia). It is a decade since this tension is excruciating the modern astrophysical community. To shed light on this problem is key to consider probes at intermediate redshifts between SNe Ia and CMB and reduce the uncertainty on $H_0$. Toward these goals, we fill the redshift gap by employing Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs) and Quasars (QSOs), reaching $z=9.4$ and $z=7.6$, respectively, combined with Baryonic Acoustic Oscillations (BAO) and SNe Ia. To this end, we employ the ``Dainotti GRB 3D relation" among the rest-frame end time of the X-ray plateau emission, its corresponding luminosity, and the peak prompt luminosity, and the ``Risaliti-Lusso" QSO relation between ultraviolet and X-ray luminosities. We inquire the commonly adopted Gaussianity assumption on GRBs, QSOs, and BAO. With the joint sample, we fit the flat $Λ$ Cold Dark Matter model with both the Gaussian and the newly discovered likelihoods. We also investigate the impact of the calibration assumed for \textit{Pantheon} and \textit{Pantheon +} SNe Ia on this analysis. Remarkably, we show that only GRBs fulfill the Gaussianity assumption. We achieve small uncertainties on the matter density parameter $Ω_M$ and $H_0$. We find $H_0$ values compatible within 2 $σ$ with the one from the Tip of the Red Giant Branch. Finally, we show that the cosmological results are heavily biased against the arbitrary calibration choice for SNe Ia.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Reduced uncertainties up to 43\% on the Hubble constant and the matter density with the SNe Ia with a new statistical analysis
Authors:
Maria Giovanna Dainotti,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Malgorzata Bogdan,
Salvatore Capozziello,
Shigehiro Nagataki
Abstract:
Type Ia Supernovae (SNe Ia) are considered the most reliable \textit{standard candles} and they have played an invaluable role in cosmology since the discovery of the Universe's accelerated expansion. During the last decades, the SNe Ia samples have been improved in number, redshift coverage, calibration methodology, and systematics treatment. These efforts led to the most recent \textit{``Pantheo…
▽ More
Type Ia Supernovae (SNe Ia) are considered the most reliable \textit{standard candles} and they have played an invaluable role in cosmology since the discovery of the Universe's accelerated expansion. During the last decades, the SNe Ia samples have been improved in number, redshift coverage, calibration methodology, and systematics treatment. These efforts led to the most recent \textit{``Pantheon"} (2018) and \textit{``Pantheon +"} (2022) releases, which enable to constrain cosmological parameters more precisely than previous samples. In this era of precision cosmology, the community strives to find new ways to reduce uncertainties on cosmological parameters. To this end, we start our investigation even from the likelihood assumption of Gaussianity, implicitly used in this domain. Indeed, the usual practise involves constraining parameters through a Gaussian distance moduli likelihood. This method relies on the implicit assumption that the difference between the distance moduli measured and the ones expected from the cosmological model is Gaussianly distributed. In this work, we test this hypothesis for both the \textit{Pantheon} and \textit{Pantheon +} releases. We find that in both cases this requirement is not fulfilled and the actual underlying distributions are a logistic and a Student's t distribution for the \textit{Pantheon} and \textit{Pantheon +} data, respectively. When we apply these new likelihoods fitting a flat $Λ$CDM model, we significantly reduce the uncertainties on $Ω_M$ and $H_0$ of $\sim 40 \%$. This boosts the SNe Ia power in constraining cosmological parameters, thus representing a huge step forward to shed light on the current debated tensions in cosmology.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2024; v1 submitted 13 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
A bias-free cosmological analysis with quasars alleviating $H_0$ tension
Authors:
Aleksander Łukasz Lenart,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Maria Giovanna Dainotti,
Shigehiro Nagataki,
Salvatore Capozziello
Abstract:
Cosmological models and their parameters are widely debated because of theoretical and observational mismatches of the standard cosmological model, especially the current discrepancy between the value of the Hubble constant, $H_{0}$, obtained by Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia), and the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMB). Thus, considering high-redshift probes like quasars (QSOs), having inter…
▽ More
Cosmological models and their parameters are widely debated because of theoretical and observational mismatches of the standard cosmological model, especially the current discrepancy between the value of the Hubble constant, $H_{0}$, obtained by Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia), and the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMB). Thus, considering high-redshift probes like quasars (QSOs), having intermediate redshifts between SNe Ia and CMB, is a necessary step. In this work, we use SNe Ia and the most updated QSO sample, reaching redshifts up to $z\sim7.5$, applying the Risaliti-Lusso QSO relation based on a non-linear relation between ultraviolet and X-ray luminosities. We consider this relation both in its original form and corrected for selection biases and evolution in redshift through a reliable statistical method also accounting for the circularity problem. We also explore two approaches: with and without calibration on SNe Ia. We then investigate flat and non-flat standard cosmological models and a flat $w$CDM model, with a constant dark energy equation of state parameter $w$. Remarkably, when correcting for the evolution as a function of cosmology, we obtain closed constraints on $Ω_M$ using only non-calibrated QSOs. We find that considering non-calibrated QSOs combined with SNe Ia and accounting for the same correction, our results are compatible with a flat $Λ$CDM model with $Ω_M = 0.3$ and $H_0 = 70 \, \mathrm{km\,s^{-1}\,Mpc^{-1}}$. Intriguingly, the $H_0$ values obtained place halfway between the one from SNe Ia and CMB, paving the way for new insights into the $H_0$ tension.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2023; v1 submitted 19 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Quasars as high-redshift standard candles
Authors:
A. Sacchi,
G. Risaliti,
M. Signorini,
E. Lusso,
E. Nardini,
G. Bargiacchi,
S. Bisogni,
F. Civano,
M. Elvis,
G. Fabbiano,
R. Gilli,
B. Trefoloni,
C. Vignali
Abstract:
The non-linear relation between the X-ray and ultraviolet (UV) luminosity in quasars has been used to derive quasar distances and to build a Hubble diagram at redshifts up to $z\sim$ 7. This cosmological application is based on the assumption of independence of the relation on redshift and luminosity. We want to test the reliability of this hypothesis by studying the spectroscopic properties of hi…
▽ More
The non-linear relation between the X-ray and ultraviolet (UV) luminosity in quasars has been used to derive quasar distances and to build a Hubble diagram at redshifts up to $z\sim$ 7. This cosmological application is based on the assumption of independence of the relation on redshift and luminosity. We want to test the reliability of this hypothesis by studying the spectroscopic properties of high-redshift quasars in the X-ray and UV bands. We performed a one-by-one analysis of a sample of 130 quasars at $z>$ 2.5 with high-quality X-ray and UV spectroscopic observations. We found that not only the X-ray to UV correlation still holds at these redshifts, but its intrinsic dispersion is as low as 0.12 dex (previous works reached 0.20$-$0.22 dex). For a sample of quasars at $z\sim$ 3 with particularly high-quality observations the dispersion further drops to 0.09 dex, a value entirely accountable for by intrinsic variability and source geometry effects. The composite spectra of these quasars, in both the X-rays and the UV, do not show any difference with respect to the average spectra of quasars at lower redshifts. The absence of any spectral difference between high- and low-$z$ quasars and the tightness of the X-ray to UV relation suggests that no evolutionary effects are present in the relation. Therefore, it can be safely employed to derive quasar distances. Under this assumption, we obtain a measurement of the luminosity distance at $z\sim$ 3 with 15 % uncertainty, and in a 4$σ$ tension with the concordance model.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Optical and X-ray GRB Fundamental Planes as Cosmological Distance Indicators
Authors:
Maria Giovanna Dainotti,
Via Nielson,
Giuseppe Sarracino,
Enrico Rinaldi,
Shigehiro Nagataki,
Salvatore Capozziello,
Oleg Y. Gnedin,
Giada Bargiacchi
Abstract:
Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs), can be employed as standardized candles, extending the distance ladder beyond Supernovae Type Ia (SNe Ia, $z=2.26$). We standardize GRBs using the 3D fundamental plane relation (the Dainotti relation) among the rest-frame end time of the X-ray plateau emission, its corresponding luminosity, and the peak prompt luminosity. Combining SNe Ia and GRBs, we constrain…
▽ More
Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs), can be employed as standardized candles, extending the distance ladder beyond Supernovae Type Ia (SNe Ia, $z=2.26$). We standardize GRBs using the 3D fundamental plane relation (the Dainotti relation) among the rest-frame end time of the X-ray plateau emission, its corresponding luminosity, and the peak prompt luminosity. Combining SNe Ia and GRBs, we constrain $Ω_{\text{M}}= 0.299 \pm 0.009$ assuming a flat $Λ$CDM cosmology with and without correcting GRBs for selection biases and redshift evolution. Using a 3D optical Dainotti correlation, we find this sample is as efficacious in the determination of $Ω_{\text{M}}$ as the X-ray sample. We trimmed our GRB samples to achieve tighter planes to simulate additional GRBs. We determined how many GRBs are needed as standalone probes to achieve a comparable precision on $Ω_{\text{M}}$ to the one obtained by SNe Ia only. We reach the same error measurements derived using SNe Ia in 2011 and 2014 with 142 and 284 simulated optical GRBs, respectively, considering the errorbars on the variables halved. These error limits will be reached in 2038 and in 2047, respectively. Using a doubled sample (obtained by future machine learning approaches allowing a lightcurve reconstruction and the estimates of GRB redhifts when z is unknown) compared to the current sample, with errorbars halved we will reach the same precision as SNe Ia in 2011 and 2014, now and in 2026, respectively. If we consider the current SNe precision, this will be reached with 390 optical GRBs by 2054.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2022; v1 submitted 29 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Revealing Intrinsic Flat $Λ$CDM Biases with Standardizable Candles
Authors:
Eoin Ó Colgáin,
M. M. Sheikh-Jabbari,
Rance Solomon,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Salvatore Capozziello,
Maria Giovanna Dainotti,
Dejan Stojkovic
Abstract:
Emerging high redshift cosmological probes, in particular quasars (QSOs), show a preference for larger matter densities, $Ω_{m} \approx 1$, within the flat $Λ$CDM framework. Here, using the Risaliti-Lusso relation for standardizable QSOs, we demonstrate that the QSOs recover the \textit{same} Planck-$Λ$CDM Universe as Type Ia supernovae (SN), $Ω_m \approx 0.3$ at lower redshifts…
▽ More
Emerging high redshift cosmological probes, in particular quasars (QSOs), show a preference for larger matter densities, $Ω_{m} \approx 1$, within the flat $Λ$CDM framework. Here, using the Risaliti-Lusso relation for standardizable QSOs, we demonstrate that the QSOs recover the \textit{same} Planck-$Λ$CDM Universe as Type Ia supernovae (SN), $Ω_m \approx 0.3$ at lower redshifts $ 0 < z \lesssim 0.7$, before transitioning to an Einstein-de Sitter Universe ($Ω_m =1$) at higher redshifts $z \gtrsim 1$. We illustrate the same trend, namely increasing $Ω_{m}$ and decreasing $H_0$ with redshift, in SN but poor statistics prevent a definitive statement. We explain physically why the trend is expected in the flat $Λ$CDM cosmology, illustrate the intrinsic bias and non-Gaussian tails with mock Pantheon data, and identify a similar trend in BAO below $z=1$. Our results highlight an intrinsic bias in the flat $Λ$CDM Universe, whereby $Ω_m$ increases, $H_0$ decreases and $S_8$ increases with effective redshift, thus providing a new perspective on $Λ$CDM tensions; even in a Planck-$Λ$CDM Universe the current tensions might have been expected.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2022; v1 submitted 20 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Quasar cosmology: dark energy evolution and spatial curvature
Authors:
G. Bargiacchi,
M. Benetti,
S. Capozziello,
E. Lusso,
G. Risaliti,
M. Signorini
Abstract:
We analyse some open debates in cosmology in light of the most updated quasar (QSO) sample, covering a wide redshift range up to $z\sim7.5$, combined with type Ia supernovae (SNe) and baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO). Indeed, extending the cosmological analyses with high-redshift data is key to distinguishing between different cosmological models that are degenerate at low redshifts, and allowin…
▽ More
We analyse some open debates in cosmology in light of the most updated quasar (QSO) sample, covering a wide redshift range up to $z\sim7.5$, combined with type Ia supernovae (SNe) and baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO). Indeed, extending the cosmological analyses with high-redshift data is key to distinguishing between different cosmological models that are degenerate at low redshifts, and allowing better constraints on a possible dark energy (DE) evolution. Also, we discuss combinations of BAO, SNe, and QSO data to understand their compatibility and implications for extensions of the standard cosmological model. Specifically, we consider a flat and non-flat $Λ\mathrm{CDM}$ cosmology, a flat and non-flat DE model with a constant DE equation of state parameter ($w$), and four flat DE models with variable $w$, namely the Chevallier-Polarski-Linder and Jassal-Bagla-Padmanabhan models, and an "exponential" and Barboza-Alcaniz parameterisations. We find that a joint analysis of QSO+SNe with BAO is only possible in the context of a flat Universe. Indeed BAO confirms the flatness condition assuming a curved geometry, whilst SNe+QSO show evidence of a closed space. We also find $Ω_{M,0}=0.3$ in all data sets assuming a flat $Λ\mathrm{CDM}$ model. Yet, all the other models show a statistically significant deviation at 2-3$σ$ with the combined SNe+QSO+BAO data set. In the models where DE density evolves with time, SNe+QSO+BAO data always prefer $Ω_{M,0}>0.3$, $w_{0}<-1$ and $w_{a}>0$. This DE phantom behaviour is mainly driven by SNe+QSO, while BAO are closer to the flat $Λ\mathrm{CDM}$ model.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2022; v1 submitted 3 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
The most luminous blue quasars at 3.0<z<3.3. II. CIV/X-ray emission and accretion disc physics
Authors:
Elisabeta Lusso,
Emanuele Nardini,
Susanna Bisogni,
Guido Risaliti,
Roberto Gilli,
Gordon T. Richards,
Francesco Salvestrini,
Cristian Vignali,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Francesca Civano,
Martin Elvis,
Giuseppina Fabbiano,
Alessandro Marconi,
Andrea Sacchi,
Matilde Signorini
Abstract:
We analyse the properties of the CIV broad emission line in connection with the X-ray emission of 30 bright SDSS quasars at z~3.0-3.3 with pointed XMM-Newton observations, which were selected to test the suitability of AGN as cosmological tools. In our previous work, we found that a large fraction (~25%) of the quasars in this sample are X-ray underluminous by factors of >3-10. As absorbing column…
▽ More
We analyse the properties of the CIV broad emission line in connection with the X-ray emission of 30 bright SDSS quasars at z~3.0-3.3 with pointed XMM-Newton observations, which were selected to test the suitability of AGN as cosmological tools. In our previous work, we found that a large fraction (~25%) of the quasars in this sample are X-ray underluminous by factors of >3-10. As absorbing columns of >10$^{23}$ cm$^{-2}$ can be safely ruled out, their weakness is most likely intrinsic. Here we explore possible correlations between the UV and X-ray features of these sources to investigate the origin of X-ray weakness. We fit their UV SDSS spectra and analyse their CIV properties (e.g., equivalent width, EW; line peak velocity, $\upsilon_{\rm peak}$) as a function of the X-ray photon index and 2-10 keV flux. We confirm the trends of CIV $\upsilon_{\rm peak}$ and EW with UV luminosity at 2500 angstrom for both X-ray weak and X-ray normal quasars, as well as the correlation between X-ray weakness and CIV EW. In contrast to some recent work, we do not observe any clear relation between the 2-10 keV luminosity and $\upsilon_{\rm peak}$. We find a correlation between the hard X-ray flux and the integrated CIV flux for X-ray normal quasars, whilst X-ray weak quasars deviate from the main trend by more than 0.5 dex. We argue that X-ray weakness might be interpreted in a starved X-ray corona picture associated with an ongoing disc-wind phase. If the wind is ejected in the vicinity of the black hole, the extreme-UV radiation that reaches the corona will be depleted, depriving the corona of seeds photons and generating an X-ray weak quasar. Yet, at the largest UV luminosities (>10$^{47}$ erg s$^{-1}$), there will still be an ample reservoir of ionising photons that can explain the excess CIV emission observed in the X-ray weak quasars with respect to normal sources of similar X-ray luminosities.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Cosmography by orthogonalized logarithmic polynomials
Authors:
Giada Bargiacchi,
G. Risaliti,
M. Benetti,
S. Capozziello,
E. Lusso,
A. Saccardi,
M. Signorini
Abstract:
Cosmography is a powerful tool to investigate the Universe kinematic and then to reconstruct dynamics in a model-independent way. However, recent new measurements of supernovae Ia and quasars have populated the Hubble diagram up to high redshifts ($z \sim 7.5$) and the application of the traditional cosmographic approach has become less straightforward due to the large redshifts implied. Here we i…
▽ More
Cosmography is a powerful tool to investigate the Universe kinematic and then to reconstruct dynamics in a model-independent way. However, recent new measurements of supernovae Ia and quasars have populated the Hubble diagram up to high redshifts ($z \sim 7.5$) and the application of the traditional cosmographic approach has become less straightforward due to the large redshifts implied. Here we investigate this issue through an expansion of the luminosity distance-redshift relation in terms of "orthogonal" logarithmic polynomials. In particular we point out the advantages of a new procedure of "orthogonalization" and we show that such an expansion provides a very good fit in the whole $z=0÷7.5$ range to both real and mock data obtained assuming various cosmological models. Moreover, despite of the fact that the cosmographic series is tested well beyond its convergence radius, the parameters obtained expanding the luminosity distance - redshift relation for the $Λ$CDM model are broadly consistent with the results from a fit of mock data obtained with the same cosmological model. This provides a method to test the reliability of a cosmographic function to study cosmological models at high redshifts and it demonstrates that the logarithmic polynomial series can be used to test the consistency of the $Λ$CDM model with the current Hubble diagram of quasars and supernovae Ia. We confirm a strong tension (at $>4σ$) between the concordance cosmological model and the Hubble diagram at $z>1.5$. Such a tension is dominated by the contribution of quasars at $z>2$ and starts to be present also in the few supernovae Ia observed at $z>1$.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2021; v1 submitted 20 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Quasars as standard candles III. Validation of a new sample for cosmological studies
Authors:
E. Lusso,
G. Risaliti,
E. Nardini,
G. Bargiacchi,
M. Benetti,
S. Bisogni,
S. Capozziello,
F. Civano,
L. Eggleston,
M. Elvis,
G. Fabbiano,
R. Gilli,
A. Marconi,
M. Paolillo,
E. Piedipalumbo,
F. Salvestrini,
M. Signorini,
C. Vignali
Abstract:
We present a new catalogue of ~2,400 optically selected quasars with spectroscopic redshifts and X-ray observations from either Chandra or XMM-Newton. The sample can be used to investigate the non-linear relation between the UV and X-ray luminosity of quasars, and to build a Hubble diagram up to redshift z~7.5. We selected sources that are neither reddened by dust in the optical/UV nor obscured by…
▽ More
We present a new catalogue of ~2,400 optically selected quasars with spectroscopic redshifts and X-ray observations from either Chandra or XMM-Newton. The sample can be used to investigate the non-linear relation between the UV and X-ray luminosity of quasars, and to build a Hubble diagram up to redshift z~7.5. We selected sources that are neither reddened by dust in the optical/UV nor obscured by gas in the X-rays, and whose X-ray fluxes are free from flux-limit related biases. After checking for any possible systematics, we confirm, in agreement with our previous works, that (i) the X-ray to UV relation provides distance estimates matching those from supernovae up to z~1.5, and (ii) its slope shows no redshift evolution up to z~5. We provide a full description of the methodology for testing cosmological models, further supporting a trend whereby the Hubble diagram of quasars is well reproduced by the standard flat $Λ$CDM model up to z~1.5-2, but strong deviations emerge at higher redshifts. Since we have minimized all non-negligible systematic effects, and proven the stability of the $L_{\rm X}-L_{\rm UV}$ relation at high redshifts, we conclude that an evolution of the expansion rate of the Universe should be considered as a possible explanation for the observed deviation, rather than some systematic (redshift-dependent) effect associated with high-redshift quasars.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
