-
The Puzzling Structure of Solar Convection: Window into the Dynamo
Authors:
Nicholas A. Featherstone,
Kyle C. Augustson,
Jonathan M. Aurnou,
Catherine Blume,
Benjamin P. Brown,
Nicholas Brummell,
Keaton J. Burns,
Michael A. Calkins,
Maria Camisassa,
Mausumi Dikpati,
Yuhong Fan,
J. R. Fuentes,
Gustavo Guerrero,
Bradley W. Hindman,
Keith Julien,
Irina N. Kitiashvili,
Lydia Korre,
Daniel Lecoanet,
Bhishek Manek,
Loren Matilsky,
Mark Miesch,
Nicholas J. Nelson,
Jeffrey S. Oishi,
Whitney T. Powers,
Matthias Rempel
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The operation of the solar dynamo, with all of its remarkable spatio-temporal ordering, remains an outstanding problem of modern solar physics. A number of mechanisms that might plausibly contribute to its operation have been proposed, but the relative role played by each remains unclear. This uncertainty stems from continuing questions concerning the speed and structure of deep-seated convective…
▽ More
The operation of the solar dynamo, with all of its remarkable spatio-temporal ordering, remains an outstanding problem of modern solar physics. A number of mechanisms that might plausibly contribute to its operation have been proposed, but the relative role played by each remains unclear. This uncertainty stems from continuing questions concerning the speed and structure of deep-seated convective flows. Those flows are in-turn thought to sustain both the Sun's turbulent EMF and the large-scale flows of differential rotation and meridional circulation suspected of influencing the dynamo's organization and timing. Continued progress in this area is complicated by (i) inconsistencies between helioseismic measurements of convective and meridional flow made with different techniques and instruments, and (ii) a lack of high-latitude data for convection, differential rotation, and meridional flow. We suggest that the path forward to resolving these difficulties is twofold. First, the acquisition of long-term helioseismic and emissivity measurements obtained from a polar vantage point is vital to complete our picture of the Sun's outer convection zone. Second, sustained and expanded investment in theory-oriented and combined theory/observational research initiatives will be crucial to fully exploit these new observations and to resolve inconsistencies between existing measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
A model of rotating convection in stellar and planetary interiors: II -- gravito-inertial wave generation
Authors:
K. C. Augustson,
S. Mathis,
A. Astoul
Abstract:
Gravito-inertial waves are excited at the interface of convective and radiative regions and by the Reynolds stresses in the bulk of the convection zones of rotating stars and planets. Such waves have notable asteroseismic signatures in the frequency spectra of rotating stars, particularly among rapidly rotating early-type stars, which provides a means of probing their internal structure and dynami…
▽ More
Gravito-inertial waves are excited at the interface of convective and radiative regions and by the Reynolds stresses in the bulk of the convection zones of rotating stars and planets. Such waves have notable asteroseismic signatures in the frequency spectra of rotating stars, particularly among rapidly rotating early-type stars, which provides a means of probing their internal structure and dynamics. They can also transport angular momentum, chemical species, and energy from the excitation region to where they dissipate in radiative regions. To estimate the excitation and convective parameter dependence of the amplitude of those waves, a monomodal model for stellar and planetary convection as described in Paper I is employed, which provides the magnitude of the rms convective velocity as a function of rotation rate. With this convection model, two channels for wave driving are considered: excitation at a boundary between convectively stable and unstable regions and excitation due to Reynolds-stresses. Parameter regimes are found where the sub-inertial waves may carry a significant energy flux, depending upon the convective Rossby number, the interface stiffness, and the wave frequency. The super-inertial waves can also be enhanced, but only for convective Rossby numbers near unity. Interfacially excited waves have a peak energy flux near the lower cutoff frequency when the convective Rossby number of the flows that excite them are below a critical Rossby number that depends upon the stiffness of the interface, whereas that flux decreases when the convective Rossby number is larger than this critical Rossby number.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Transport of angular momentum by stochastically excited waves as an explanation for the outburst of the rapidly rotating Be star HD49330
Authors:
C. Neiner,
U. Lee,
S. Mathis,
H. Saio,
C. C. Lovekin,
K. C. Augustson
Abstract:
HD49330 is a Be star that underwent an outburst during its five-month observation with the CoRoT satellite. An analysis of its light curve revealed several independent p and g pulsation modes, in addition to showing that the amplitude of the modes is directly correlated with the outburst. We modelled the results obtained with CoRoT. We modelled the flattening of the structure of the star due to ra…
▽ More
HD49330 is a Be star that underwent an outburst during its five-month observation with the CoRoT satellite. An analysis of its light curve revealed several independent p and g pulsation modes, in addition to showing that the amplitude of the modes is directly correlated with the outburst. We modelled the results obtained with CoRoT. We modelled the flattening of the structure of the star due to rapid rotation in two ways: Chandrasekhar-Milne's expansion and 2D structure computed with ROTORC. We then modelled kappa-driven pulsations. We also adapted the formalism of the excitation and amplitude of stochastically excited gravito-inertial modes to rapidly rotating stars, and we modelled those pulsations as well. We find that while pulsation p modes are excited by the kappa mechanism, the observed g modes are a result of stochastic excitation. In contrast, g and r waves are stochastically excited in the convective core and transport angular momentum to the surface, increasing its rotation rate. This destabilises the external layers of the star, which then emits transient stochastically excited g waves. These transient waves produce most of the low-frequency signal detected in the CoRoT data and ignite the outburst. During this unstable phase, p modes disappear at the surface because their cavity is broken. Following the outburst and ejection of the surface layer, relaxation occurs, making the transient g waves disappear and p modes reappear. This work includes the first coherent model of stochastically excited gravito-inertial pulsation modes in a rapidly rotating Be star. It provides an explanation for the correlation between the variation in the amplitude of frequencies detected in the CoRoT data and the occurrence of an outburst. This scenario could apply to other pulsating Be stars, providing an explanation to the long-standing questions surrounding Be outbursts and disks.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Magnetism in Massive Stars
Authors:
Kyle C. Augustson
Abstract:
Massive stars are the drivers of star formation and galactic dynamics due to their relatively short lives and explosive demises, thus impacting all of astrophysics. Since they are so impactful on their environments, through their winds on the main sequence and their ultimate supernovae, it is crucial to understand how they evolve. Recent photometric observations with space-based platforms such as…
▽ More
Massive stars are the drivers of star formation and galactic dynamics due to their relatively short lives and explosive demises, thus impacting all of astrophysics. Since they are so impactful on their environments, through their winds on the main sequence and their ultimate supernovae, it is crucial to understand how they evolve. Recent photometric observations with space-based platforms such as CoRoT, K2, and now TESS have permitted access to their interior dynamics through asteroseismology, while ground-based spectropolarimetric measurements such as those of ESPaDOnS have given us a glimpse at their surface magnetic fields. The dynamics of massive stars involve a vast range of scales. Extant methods can either capture the long-term structural evolution or the short-term dynamics such as convection, magnetic dynamos, and waves due to computational costs. Thus, many mysteries remain regarding the impact of such dynamics on stellar evolution, but they can have strong implications both for how they evolve and what they leave behind when they die. Some of these dynamics including rotation, tides, and magnetic fields have been addressed in recent work, which is reviewed in this paper.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Does magnetic field impact tidal dynamics inside the convective zone of low-mass stars along their evolution?
Authors:
A. Astoul,
S. Mathis,
C. Baruteau,
F. Gallet,
A. Strugarek,
K. C. Augustson,
A. S. Brun,
E. Bolmont
Abstract:
The dissipation of the kinetic energy of wave-like tidal flows within the convective envelope of low-mass stars is one of the key physical mechanisms that shapes the orbital and rotational dynamics of short-period exoplanetary systems. Although low-mass stars are magnetically active objects, the question of how the star's magnetic field impacts large-scale tidal flows and the excitation, propagati…
▽ More
The dissipation of the kinetic energy of wave-like tidal flows within the convective envelope of low-mass stars is one of the key physical mechanisms that shapes the orbital and rotational dynamics of short-period exoplanetary systems. Although low-mass stars are magnetically active objects, the question of how the star's magnetic field impacts large-scale tidal flows and the excitation, propagation and dissipation of tidal waves still remains open. Our goal is to investigate the impact of stellar magnetism on the forcing of tidal waves, and their propagation and dissipation in the convective envelope of low-mass stars as they evolve. We have estimated the amplitude of the magnetic contribution to the forcing and dissipation of tidally induced magneto-inertial waves throughout the structural and rotational evolution of low-mass stars (from M to F-type). For this purpose, we have used detailed grids of rotating stellar models computed with the stellar evolution code STAREVOL. The amplitude of dynamo-generated magnetic fields is estimated via physical scaling laws at the base and the top of the convective envelope. We find that the large-scale magnetic field of the star has little influence on the excitation of tidal waves in the case of nearly-circular orbits and coplanar hot-Jupiter planetary systems, but that it has a major impact on the way waves are dissipated. Our results therefore indicate that a full magneto-hydrodynamical treatment of the propagation and dissipation of tidal waves is needed to properly assess the impact of star-planet tidal interactions throughout the evolutionary history of low-mass stars hosting short-period massive planets.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Probing the shape of the mixing profile and of the thermal structure at the convective core boundary through asteroseismology
Authors:
Mathias Michielsen,
May G. Pedersen,
Kyle C. Augustson,
Stéphane Mathis,
Conny Aerts
Abstract:
Aims: We investigate from a theoretical perspective if space asteroseismology can be used to distinguish between different thermal structures and shapes of the near-core mixing profiles for different types of coherent oscillation modes in massive stars with convective cores, and if this capacity depends on the evolutionary stage of the models along the main sequence. Methods: We compute 1D stellar…
▽ More
Aims: We investigate from a theoretical perspective if space asteroseismology can be used to distinguish between different thermal structures and shapes of the near-core mixing profiles for different types of coherent oscillation modes in massive stars with convective cores, and if this capacity depends on the evolutionary stage of the models along the main sequence. Methods: We compute 1D stellar structure and evolution models for four different prescriptions of the mixing and temperature gradient in the near-core region. Their effect on the frequencies of dipole prograde gravity modes in both Slowly Pulsating B and $β$ Cep stars is investigated, as well as for pressure modes in $β$ Cep stars. Results: A comparison between the mode frequencies of the different models at various stages during the main sequence evolution reveals that they are more sensitive to a change in temperature gradient than to the exact shape of the mixing profile in the near-core region. Depending on the duration of the observed light curve, one can distinguish between either just the temperature gradient, or also between the shapes of the mixing coefficient. The relative frequency differences are in general larger for more evolved models, and are largest for the higher-frequency pressure modes in $β$ Cep stars. Conclusions:In order to unravel the core boundary mixing and thermal structure of the near-core region, one must have asteroseismic masses and radii with $\sim 1\%$ relative precision for hundreds of stars.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2019; v1 submitted 12 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Rotating Convection and Gravito-Inertial Wave Generation in Stellar Interiors
Authors:
Kyle C. Augustson,
Stéphane Mathis
Abstract:
Gravito-inertial waves can be excited at the interface of convective and radiative regions and by the Reynolds stresses in the bulk of the convection zone. The magnitude of their energy flux will therefore vary with the properties of the convection. To assess how convection changes with rotation, a simplified local monomodal model for rotating convection is presented that provides the magnitude of…
▽ More
Gravito-inertial waves can be excited at the interface of convective and radiative regions and by the Reynolds stresses in the bulk of the convection zone. The magnitude of their energy flux will therefore vary with the properties of the convection. To assess how convection changes with rotation, a simplified local monomodal model for rotating convection is presented that provides the magnitude of the rms velocity, degree of superadiabaticity, and characteristic length scale as a function of the convective Rossby number as well as with thermal and viscous diffusivities. In the context of this convection model, two models for assessing the gravito-inertial wave flux are considered: an interfacial model and a full treatment of the Reynolds stress impact on the waves. It is found that there are regimes where the sub-inertial waves may carry a significant energy flux relative to pure gravity waves that depend upon the convective Rossby number, the ratio of the buoyancy time-scale in the stable region to the convective overturning time, and the wave frequency.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
A model of rotating convection in stellar and planetary interiors: I - convective penetration
Authors:
Kyle C. Augustson,
Stéphane Mathis
Abstract:
A monomodal model for stellar and planetary convection is derived for the magnitude of the rms velocity, degree of superadiabaticity, and characteristic length scale as a function of rotation rate as well as with thermal and viscous diffusivities. The convection model is used as a boundary condition for a linearization of the equations of motion in the transition region between convectively unstab…
▽ More
A monomodal model for stellar and planetary convection is derived for the magnitude of the rms velocity, degree of superadiabaticity, and characteristic length scale as a function of rotation rate as well as with thermal and viscous diffusivities. The convection model is used as a boundary condition for a linearization of the equations of motion in the transition region between convectively unstable and stably-stratified regions, yielding the depth to which convection penetrates into the stable region and establishing a relationship between that depth and the local convective Rossby number, diffusivity, and pressure scale height of those flows. Upward and downward penetrative convection have a similar scaling with rotation rate and diffusivities, but they depend differently upon the pressure scale height due to the differing energetic processes occurring in convective cores of early-type stars versus convective envelopes of late-type stars.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Does magnetic field modify tidal dynamics in the convective envelope of Solar mass stars?
Authors:
Aurélie Astoul,
Stéphane Mathis,
Clément Baruteau,
Florian Gallet,
Kyle C. Augustson,
Emeline Bolmont,
Allan S. Brun,
Antoine Strugarek
Abstract:
The energy dissipation of wave-like tidal flows in the convective envelope of low-mass stars is one of the key physical mechanisms that shape the orbital and rotational dynamics of short-period planetary systems. Tidal flows, and the excitation, propagation, and dissipation of tidally-induced inertial waves can be modified by stellar magnetic fields (e.g., Wei 2016, 2018, Lin and Ogilvie 2018). It…
▽ More
The energy dissipation of wave-like tidal flows in the convective envelope of low-mass stars is one of the key physical mechanisms that shape the orbital and rotational dynamics of short-period planetary systems. Tidal flows, and the excitation, propagation, and dissipation of tidally-induced inertial waves can be modified by stellar magnetic fields (e.g., Wei 2016, 2018, Lin and Ogilvie 2018). It is thus important to assess for which stars, at which location of their internal structure, and at which phase of their evolution, one needs to take into account the effects of magnetic fields on tidal waves. Using scaling laws that provide the amplitude of dynamo-generated magnetic fields along the rotational evolution of these stars (e.g., Christensen et al. 2009, Brun et al. 2015), combined with detailed grids of stellar rotation models (e.g., Amard et al. 2016), we examine the influence of a magnetic field on tidal forcing and dissipation near the tachocline of solar-like stars. We show that full consideration of magnetic fields is required to compute tidal dissipation, but not necessarily for tidal forcing.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
On differential rotation and overshooting in solar-like stars
Authors:
Allan Sacha Brun,
Antoine Strugarek,
Jacobo Varela,
Sean P. Matt,
Kyle C. Augustson,
Constance Emeriau,
Olivier Long DoCao,
Benjamin Brown,
Juri Toomre
Abstract:
We seek to characterize how the change of global rotation rate influences the overall dynamics and large scale flows arising in the convective envelopes of stars covering stellar spectral types from early G to late K. We do so through numerical simulations with the ASH code, where we consider stellar convective envelopes coupled to a radiative interior with various global properties. As solar-like…
▽ More
We seek to characterize how the change of global rotation rate influences the overall dynamics and large scale flows arising in the convective envelopes of stars covering stellar spectral types from early G to late K. We do so through numerical simulations with the ASH code, where we consider stellar convective envelopes coupled to a radiative interior with various global properties. As solar-like stars spin down over the course of their main sequence evolution, such change must have a direct impact on their dynamics and rotation state. We indeed find that three main states of rotation may exist for a given star: anti-solar-like (fast poles, slow equator), solar-like (fast equator, slow poles), or a cylindrical rotation profile. Under increasingly strict rotational constraints, the latter profile can further evolve into a Jupiter-like profile, with alternating prograde and retrograde zonal jets. We have further assessed how far the convection and meridional flows overshoot into the radiative zone and investigated the morphology of the established tachocline. Using simple mixing length arguments, we are able to construct a scaling of the fluid Rossby number $R_{of} = \tildeω/2Ω_* \sim \tilde{v}/2Ω_* R_*$, which we calibrate based on our 3-D ASH simulations. We can use this scaling to map the behavior of differential rotation versus the global parameters of stellar mass and rotation rate. Finally, we isolate a region on this map ($R_{of} \gtrsim 1.5-2$) where we posit that stars with an anti-solar differential rotation may exist in order to encourage observers to hunt for such targets.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Magnetic Helicity Reversals in a Cyclic Convective Dynamo
Authors:
Mark S. Miesch,
Mei Zhang,
Kyle C. Augustson
Abstract:
We investigate the role of magnetic helicity in promoting cyclic magnetic activity in a global, 3D, magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulation of a convective dynamo. This simulation is characterized by coherent bands of toroidal field that exist within the convection zone, with opposite polarities in the northern and southern hemispheres. Throughout most of the cycle, the magnetic helicity in these ban…
▽ More
We investigate the role of magnetic helicity in promoting cyclic magnetic activity in a global, 3D, magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulation of a convective dynamo. This simulation is characterized by coherent bands of toroidal field that exist within the convection zone, with opposite polarities in the northern and southern hemispheres. Throughout most of the cycle, the magnetic helicity in these bands is negative in the northern hemisphere and positive in the southern hemisphere. However, during the declining phase of each cycle, this hemispheric rule reverses. We attribute this to a global restructuring of the magnetic topology that is induced by the interaction of the bands across the equator. This band interaction appears to be ultimately responsible for, or at least associated with, the decay and subsequent reversal of both the toroidal bands and the polar fields. We briefly discuss the implications of these results within the context of solar observations, which also show some potential evidence for toroidal band interactions and helicity reversals.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Velocity Amplitudes in Global Convection Simulations: The Role of the Prandtl Number and Near-Surface Driving
Authors:
Bridget O'Mara,
Mark S. Miesch,
Nicholas A. Featherstone,
K. C. Augustson
Abstract:
Several lines of evidence suggest that the velocity amplitude in global simulations of solar convection, U, may be systematically over-estimated. Motivated by these recent results, we explore the factors that determine U and we consider how these might scale to solar parameter regimes. To this end, we decrease the thermal diffusivity $κ$ along two paths in parameter space. If the kinematic viscosi…
▽ More
Several lines of evidence suggest that the velocity amplitude in global simulations of solar convection, U, may be systematically over-estimated. Motivated by these recent results, we explore the factors that determine U and we consider how these might scale to solar parameter regimes. To this end, we decrease the thermal diffusivity $κ$ along two paths in parameter space. If the kinematic viscosity $ν$ is decreased proportionally with $κ$ (fixing the Prandtl number $P_r = ν/κ$), we find that U increases but asymptotes toward a constant value, as found by Featherstone & Hindman (2016). However, if $ν$ is held fixed while decreasing $κ$ (increasing $P_r$), we find that U systematically decreases. We attribute this to an enhancement of the thermal content of downflow plumes, which allows them to carry the solar luminosity with slower flow speeds. We contrast this with the case of Rayleigh-Benard convection which is not subject to this luminosity constraint. This dramatic difference in behavior for the two paths in parameter space (fixed $P_r$ or fixed $ν$) persists whether the heat transport by unresolved, near-surface convection is modeled as a thermal conduction or as a fixed flux. The results suggest that if solar convection can operate in a high-$P_r$ regime, then this might effectively limit the velocity amplitude. Small-scale magnetism is a possible source of enhanced viscosity that may serve to achieve this high-$P_r$ regime.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
The Magnetic Furnace: Intense Core Dynamos in B-stars
Authors:
Kyle C. Augustson,
Allan Sacha Brun,
Juri Toomre
Abstract:
The dynamo action achieved in the convective cores of main-sequence massive stars is explored here through 3D global simulations of convective core dynamos operating within a young $\Msun{10}$ B-type star, using the anelastic spherical harmonic (ASH) code. These simulations capture the inner 65\% of this star by radius, encompassing the convective nuclear-burning core (about 23\% by radius) and a…
▽ More
The dynamo action achieved in the convective cores of main-sequence massive stars is explored here through 3D global simulations of convective core dynamos operating within a young $\Msun{10}$ B-type star, using the anelastic spherical harmonic (ASH) code. These simulations capture the inner 65\% of this star by radius, encompassing the convective nuclear-burning core (about 23\% by radius) and a portion of the overlying radiative envelope. Eight rotation rates are considered, ranging from 0.05\% to 16\% of the surface breakup velocity, thereby capturing both convection that barely senses the effects of rotation and other situations in which the Coriolis forces are prominent. The vigorous dynamo action realized within all of these turbulent convective cores builds magnetic fields with peak strengths exceeding a megagauss, with the overall magnetic energy (ME) in the faster rotators reaching super-equipartition levels compared to the convective kinetic energy (KE). The core convection typically involves turbulent columnar velocity structures roughly aligned with the rotation axis, with magnetic fields threading through these rolls and possessing complex linkages throughout the core. The very strong fields are able to coexist with the flows without quenching them through Lorentz forces. The velocity and magnetic fields achieve such a state by being nearly co-aligned, and with peak magnetic islands being somewhat displaced from the fastest flows as the intricate evolution proceeds. As the rotation rate is increased, the primary force balance shifts from nonlinear advection balancing Lorentz forces to a magnetostrophic balance between Coriolis and Lorentz forces.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2016; v1 submitted 11 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Dynamo modeling of the Kepler F star KIC 12009504
Authors:
S. Mathur,
K. C. Augustson,
A. S. Brun,
R. A. Garcia,
T. S. Metcalfe
Abstract:
The Kepler mission has collected light curves for almost 4 years. The excellent quality of these data has allowed us to probe the structure and the dynamics of the stars using asteroseismology. With the length of data available, we can start to look for magnetic activity cycles. The Kepler data obtained for the F star, KIC 12009504, shows a rotation period of 9.5 days and additional variability th…
▽ More
The Kepler mission has collected light curves for almost 4 years. The excellent quality of these data has allowed us to probe the structure and the dynamics of the stars using asteroseismology. With the length of data available, we can start to look for magnetic activity cycles. The Kepler data obtained for the F star, KIC 12009504, shows a rotation period of 9.5 days and additional variability that could be due to the magnetic activity of the star. Here we present recent and preliminary 3D global-scale dynamo simulations of this star with the ASH and STELEM codes, capturing a substantial portion of the convection and the stable radiation zone below it. These simulations reveal a multi-year activity cycle whose length tentatively depends upon the width of the tachocline present in the simulation. Furthermore, the presence of a magnetic field and the dynamo action taking place in the convection zone appears to help confine the tachocline, but longer simulations will be required to confirm this.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Convection and dynamo action in B stars
Authors:
Kyle C. Augustson,
Allan S. Brun,
Juri Toomre
Abstract:
Main-sequence massive stars possess convective cores that likely harbor strong dynamo action. To assess the role of core convection in building magnetic fields within these stars, we employ the 3-D anelastic spherical harmonic (ASH) code to model turbulent dynamics within a 10 solar mass main-sequence (MS) B-type star rotating at 4 times the solar rate. We find that strong (900 kG) magnetic fields…
▽ More
Main-sequence massive stars possess convective cores that likely harbor strong dynamo action. To assess the role of core convection in building magnetic fields within these stars, we employ the 3-D anelastic spherical harmonic (ASH) code to model turbulent dynamics within a 10 solar mass main-sequence (MS) B-type star rotating at 4 times the solar rate. We find that strong (900 kG) magnetic fields arise within the turbulence of the core and penetrate into the stably stratified radiative zone. These fields exhibit complex, time-dependent behavior including reversals in magnetic polarity and shifts between which hemisphere dominates the total magnetic energy.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
