-
An unsupervised machine learning based algorithm for detecting Weak Impulsive Narrowband Quiet Sun Emissions and characterizing their morphology
Authors:
Shabbir Bawaji,
Ujjaini Alam,
Surajit Mondal,
Divya Oberoi,
Ayan Biswas
Abstract:
The solar corona is extremely dynamic. Every leap in observational capabilities has been accompanied by unexpected revelations of complex dynamic processes. The ever more sensitive instruments now allow us to probe events with increasingly weaker energetics. A recent leap in the low-frequency radio solar imaging ability has led to the discovery of a new class of emissions, namely Weak Impulsive Na…
▽ More
The solar corona is extremely dynamic. Every leap in observational capabilities has been accompanied by unexpected revelations of complex dynamic processes. The ever more sensitive instruments now allow us to probe events with increasingly weaker energetics. A recent leap in the low-frequency radio solar imaging ability has led to the discovery of a new class of emissions, namely Weak Impulsive Narrowband Quiet Sun Emissions \citep[WINQSEs;][]{mondal2020}. They are hypothesized to be the radio signatures of coronal nanoflares and could potentially have a bearing on the long standing coronal heating problem. In view of the significance of this discovery, this work has been followed up by multiple independent studies. These include detecting WINQSEs in multiple datasets, using independent detection techniques and software pipelines, and looking for their counterparts at other wavelengths. This work focuses on investigating morphological properties of WINQSEs and also improves upon the methodology used for detecting WINQSEs in earlier works. We present a machine learning based algorithm to detect WINQSEs, classify them based on their morphology and model the isolated ones using 2D Gaussians. We subject multiple datasets to this algorithm to test its veracity. Interestingly, despite the expectations of their arising from intrinsically compact sources, WINQSEs tend to be resolved in our observations. We propose that this angular broadening arises due to coronal scattering. WINQSEs can, hence, provide ubiquitous and ever-present diagnostic of coronal scattering (and, in turn, coronal turbulence) in the quiet sun regions, which has not been possible till date.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Exploring Coronal Heating Using Unsupervised Machine-Learning
Authors:
Shabbir Bawaji,
Ujjaini Alam,
Surajit Mondal,
Divya Oberoi
Abstract:
The perplexing mystery of what maintains the solar coronal temperature at about a million K, while the visible disc of the Sun is only at 5800 K, has been a long standing problem in solar physics. A recent study by Mondal(2020) has provided the first evidence for the presence of numerous ubiquitous impulsive emissions at low radio frequencies from the quiet sun regions, which could hold the key to…
▽ More
The perplexing mystery of what maintains the solar coronal temperature at about a million K, while the visible disc of the Sun is only at 5800 K, has been a long standing problem in solar physics. A recent study by Mondal(2020) has provided the first evidence for the presence of numerous ubiquitous impulsive emissions at low radio frequencies from the quiet sun regions, which could hold the key to solving this mystery. These features occur at rates of about five hundred events per minute, and their strength is only a few percent of the background steady emission. One of the next steps for exploring the feasibility of this resolution to the coronal heating problem is to understand the morphology of these emissions. To meet this objective we have developed a technique based on an unsupervised machine learning approach for characterising the morphology of these impulsive emissions. Here we present the results of application of this technique to over 8000 images spanning 70 minutes of data in which about 34,500 features could robustly be characterised as 2D elliptical Gaussians.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Are $H_0$ and $σ_8$ tensions generic to present cosmological data?
Authors:
Archita Bhattacharyya,
Ujjaini Alam,
Kanhaiya Lal Pandey,
Subinoy Das,
Supratik Pal
Abstract:
Yes, for a wide range of cosmological models ($Λ$CDM, non-interacting $w_z$CDM or models with possible interactions between dark energy and dark matter, in either phantom or non-phantom regimes). In the recent past there have been many attempts to solve the tension between direct measurements of $H_0$ and $σ_8 \sqrt{Ω_{0 {\rm m}}}$ from the respective low redshift observables and indirect measurem…
▽ More
Yes, for a wide range of cosmological models ($Λ$CDM, non-interacting $w_z$CDM or models with possible interactions between dark energy and dark matter, in either phantom or non-phantom regimes). In the recent past there have been many attempts to solve the tension between direct measurements of $H_0$ and $σ_8 \sqrt{Ω_{0 {\rm m}}}$ from the respective low redshift observables and indirect measurements of these quantities from the cosmic microwave background (CMB). In this work we reconstruct a model independent approach that boils down to different classes of cosmological models under suitable parameters choices. We test this parameterization against the latest Planck CMB data combined with recent BAO, SNeIa datasets and the R16 direct $H_0$ measurements, and compare among different cosmological models. Our analysis reveals that a strong positive correlation between $H_0$ and $σ_8$ is more or less generic, irrespective of the choice of cosmological models. We also find that present data slightly prefers a phantom equation of state for dark energy and a slight negative value for effective equation of state for dark matter (which is a direct signature of interacting models) with a relatively high value for $H_0$ consistent with R16 and simultaneously, a consistent value for $Ω_{0 {\rm m}}$. Thus, even though the tensions cannot be fully resolved, interacting models with phantom equation of state get a slight edge over the others for currently available data. We also see that allowing interaction between dark energy and dark matter may resolve the tension between the high redshift CMB data and individual low redshift datasets, but the low redshift datasets have inconsistencies between them (e.g. between BAO and $H_0$, SNeIa and BAO, and cluster counts and $H_0$) that are practically independent of the cosmological model.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2019; v1 submitted 12 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
An Exploration of Heterogeneity in Supernova Type Ia Samples
Authors:
Ujjaini Alam,
Jeremie Lasue
Abstract:
We examine three SNe Type Ia datasets: Union2.1, JLA and Panstarrs to check their consistency using cosmology blind statistical analyses as well as cosmological parameter fitting. We find that Panstarrs dataset is the most stable of the three to changes, although it does not, at the moment, go to high enough redshifts to tightly constrain the dark energy equation of state, $w$. Union2.1, drawn fro…
▽ More
We examine three SNe Type Ia datasets: Union2.1, JLA and Panstarrs to check their consistency using cosmology blind statistical analyses as well as cosmological parameter fitting. We find that Panstarrs dataset is the most stable of the three to changes, although it does not, at the moment, go to high enough redshifts to tightly constrain the dark energy equation of state, $w$. Union2.1, drawn from many different sources, appears somewhat susceptible to changes within the dataset. JLA reconstructs well for a smaller number of cosmological parameters. At higher degrees of freedom, the dependence of its errors on redshift can lead to varying results between subsets. Panstarrs is inconsistent with the other two at about $2σ$, and JLA and Union2.1 are about $1σ$ away from each other. For the $Ω_{0m}-w$ cosmological reconstruction, the $1σ$ range of values in $w$ for selected subsets of each dataset is two times larger for JLA and Union2.1 as compared to Panstarrs. The range in $Ω_{0m}$ for the same subsets remains approximately similar for all three datasets. Although there are differences in the fitting and correction techniques used in the different samples, the most important criterion is SNe selection, a slightly different SNe selection can lead to noticeably different results both in the purely statistical analysis and cosmological reconstruction. We note that a single, high quality low redshift sample could help decrease the uncertainties in the result. We also note that lack of homogeneity in the magnitude errors may bias the results and should either be modeled, or its effect neutralized by using other, complementary datasets. A supernova sample with high quality data at both high and low redshifts, constructed from a few surveys to avoid heterogeneity in the sample, and with homogeneous errors, would result in a more robust cosmological reconstruction.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2017; v1 submitted 9 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Constraining the Cosmology of the Phantom Brane using Distance Measures
Authors:
Ujjaini Alam,
Satadru Bag,
Varun Sahni
Abstract:
The phantom brane has several important distinctive features: (i) Its equation of state is phantom-like, but there is no future `big rip' singularity, (ii) the effective cosmological constant on the brane is dynamically screened, because of which the expansion rate is {\em smaller} than that in $Λ$CDM at high redshifts. In this paper, we constrain the Phantom braneworld using distance measures suc…
▽ More
The phantom brane has several important distinctive features: (i) Its equation of state is phantom-like, but there is no future `big rip' singularity, (ii) the effective cosmological constant on the brane is dynamically screened, because of which the expansion rate is {\em smaller} than that in $Λ$CDM at high redshifts. In this paper, we constrain the Phantom braneworld using distance measures such as Type Ia supernovae (SNeIa), Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO), and the compressed Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) data. We find that the simplest braneworld models provide a good fit to the data. For instance, BAO +SNeIa data can be accommodated by the braneworld for a large region in parameter space $0 < Ω_l < 0.3$ at $1σ$. The Hubble parameter can be as high as $H_0 < 78$ km/s/Mpc, and the effective equation of state at present can show phantom-like behaviour with $w_0 < -1.2$ at $1σ$. We note a correlation between $H_0$ and $w_0$, with higher values of $H_0$ leading to a lower, and more phantom-like, value of $w_0$. Inclusion of CMB data provides tighter constraints $Ω_l < 0.1$. (Here $Ω_l$ encodes the ratio of the five and four dimensional Planck mass.) The Hubble parameter in this case is more tightly constrained to $H_0 < 71$ km/s/Mpc, and the effective equation of state to $w_0 < -1.1$. Interestingly, we find that the universe is allowed be closed or open, with $-0.5 < Ω_κ < 0.5$, even on including the compressed CMB data. There appears to be some tension in the low and high $z$ BAO data which may either be resolved by future data, or act as a pointer to interesting new cosmology.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2017; v1 submitted 16 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Nonparametric Reconstruction of the Dark Energy Equation of State from Diverse Data Sets
Authors:
Tracy Holsclaw,
Ujjaini Alam,
Bruno Sanso,
Herbie Lee,
Katrin Heitmann,
Salman Habib,
David Higdon
Abstract:
The cause of the accelerated expansion of the Universe poses one of the most fundamental questions in physics today. In the absence of a compelling theory to explain the observations, a first task is to develop a robust phenomenology. If the acceleration is driven by some form of dark energy, then, the phenomenology is determined by the dark energy equation of state w. A major aim of ongoing and u…
▽ More
The cause of the accelerated expansion of the Universe poses one of the most fundamental questions in physics today. In the absence of a compelling theory to explain the observations, a first task is to develop a robust phenomenology. If the acceleration is driven by some form of dark energy, then, the phenomenology is determined by the dark energy equation of state w. A major aim of ongoing and upcoming cosmological surveys is to measure w and its time dependence at high accuracy. Since w(z) is not directly accessible to measurement, powerful reconstruction methods are needed to extract it reliably from observations. We have recently introduced a new reconstruction method for w(z) based on Gaussian process modeling. This method can capture nontrivial time-dependences in w(z) and, most importantly, it yields controlled and unbaised error estimates. In this paper we extend the method to include a diverse set of measurements: baryon acoustic oscillations, cosmic microwave background measurements, and supernova data. We analyze currently available data sets and present the resulting constraints on w(z), finding that current observations are in very good agreement with a cosmological constant. In addition we explore how well our method captures nontrivial behavior of w(z) by analyzing simulated data assuming high-quality observations from future surveys. We find that the baryon acoustic oscillation measurements by themselves already lead to remarkably good reconstruction results and that the combination of different high-quality probes allows us to reconstruct w(z) very reliably with small error bounds.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Reconstructing Dark Energy : A Comparison of Cosmological Parameters
Authors:
Alexander V. Pan,
Ujjaini Alam
Abstract:
A large number of cosmological parameters have been suggested for obtaining information on the nature of dark energy. In this work, we study the efficacy of these different parameters in discriminating theoretical models of dark energy, using both currently available supernova (SNe) data, and simulations of future observations. We find that the current data does not put strong constraints on the n…
▽ More
A large number of cosmological parameters have been suggested for obtaining information on the nature of dark energy. In this work, we study the efficacy of these different parameters in discriminating theoretical models of dark energy, using both currently available supernova (SNe) data, and simulations of future observations. We find that the current data does not put strong constraints on the nature of dark energy, irrespective of the cosmological parameter used. For future data, we find that the although deceleration parameter can accurately reconstruct some dark energy models, it is unable to discriminate between different models of dark energy, therefore limiting its usefulness. Physical parameters such as the equation of state of dark energy, or the dark energy density do a good job of both reconstruction and discrimination if the matter density is known to high accuracy. However, uncertainty in matter density reduces the efficacy of these parameters. A recently proposed parameter, Om(z), constructed from the first derivative of the SNe data, works very well in discriminating different theoretical models of dark energy, and has the added advantage of not being dependent on the value of matter density. Thus we find that a cosmological parameter constructed from the first derivative of the data, for which the theoretical models of dark energy are sufficiently distant from each other, and which is independent of the matter density, performs the best in reconstructing dark energy from SNe data.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Nonparametric Dark Energy Reconstruction from Supernova Data
Authors:
Tracy Holsclaw,
Ujjaini Alam,
Bruno Sanso,
Herbert Lee,
Katrin Heitmann,
Salman Habib,
David Higdon
Abstract:
Understanding the origin of the accelerated expansion of the Universe poses one of the greatest challenges in physics today. Lacking a compelling fundamental theory to test, observational efforts are targeted at a better characterization of the underlying cause. If a new form of mass-energy, dark energy, is driving the acceleration, the redshift evolution of the equation of state parameter w(z) wi…
▽ More
Understanding the origin of the accelerated expansion of the Universe poses one of the greatest challenges in physics today. Lacking a compelling fundamental theory to test, observational efforts are targeted at a better characterization of the underlying cause. If a new form of mass-energy, dark energy, is driving the acceleration, the redshift evolution of the equation of state parameter w(z) will hold essential clues as to its origin. To best exploit data from observations it is necessary to develop a robust and accurate reconstruction approach, with controlled errors, for w(z). We introduce a new, nonparametric method for solving the associated statistical inverse problem based on Gaussian Process modeling and Markov chain Monte Carlo sampling. Applying this method to recent supernova measurements, we reconstruct the continuous history of w out to redshift z=1.5.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
-
Nonparametric Reconstruction of the Dark Energy Equation of State
Authors:
Tracy Holsclaw,
Ujjaini Alam,
Bruno Sanso,
Herbert Lee,
Katrin Heitmann,
Salman Habib,
David Higdon
Abstract:
A basic aim of ongoing and upcoming cosmological surveys is to unravel the mystery of dark energy. In the absence of a compelling theory to test, a natural approach is to better characterize the properties of dark energy in search of clues that can lead to a more fundamental understanding. One way to view this characterization is the improved determination of the redshift-dependence of the dark en…
▽ More
A basic aim of ongoing and upcoming cosmological surveys is to unravel the mystery of dark energy. In the absence of a compelling theory to test, a natural approach is to better characterize the properties of dark energy in search of clues that can lead to a more fundamental understanding. One way to view this characterization is the improved determination of the redshift-dependence of the dark energy equation of state parameter, w(z). To do this requires a robust and bias-free method for reconstructing w(z) from data that does not rely on restrictive expansion schemes or assumed functional forms for w(z). We present a new nonparametric reconstruction method that solves for w(z) as a statistical inverse problem, based on a Gaussian Process representation. This method reliably captures nontrivial behavior of w(z) and provides controlled error bounds. We demonstrate the power of the method on different sets of simulated supernova data; the approach can be easily extended to include diverse cosmological probes.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
-
Galaxy Clusters as a probe of early dark energy
Authors:
Ujjaini Alam,
Zarija Lukić,
Suman Bhattacharya
Abstract:
We study a class of early dark energy (EDE) models, in which, unlike in standard dark energy models, a substantial amount of dark energy exists in the matter-dominated era. We self-consistently include dark energy perturbations, and show that these models may be successfully constrained using future observations of galaxy clusters, in particular the redshift abundance, and the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (…
▽ More
We study a class of early dark energy (EDE) models, in which, unlike in standard dark energy models, a substantial amount of dark energy exists in the matter-dominated era. We self-consistently include dark energy perturbations, and show that these models may be successfully constrained using future observations of galaxy clusters, in particular the redshift abundance, and the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) power spectrum. We make predictions for EDE models, as well as LCDM for incoming X-ray (eROSITA) and microwave (South Pole Telescope) observations. We show that galaxy clusters' mass function and the SZ power spectrum will put strong constraints both on the equation of state of \de today and the redshift at which EDE transits to present-day LCDM like behavior for these models, thus providing complementary information to the geometric probes of dark energy. Not including perturbations in EDE models leads to those models being practically indistinguishable from LCDM. An MCMC analysis of future galaxy cluster surveys provides constraints for EDE parameters that are competitive with and complementary to background expansion observations such as supernovae.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2010; v1 submitted 3 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
-
Constraining Perturbative Early Dark Energy with Current Observations
Authors:
Ujjaini Alam
Abstract:
In this work, we study a class of early dark energy (EDE) models, in which, unlike in standard DE models, a substantial amount of DE exists in the matter-dominated era, self-consistently including DE perturbations. Our analysis shows that, marginalizing over the non DE parameters such as $Omega_m, H_0, n_s$, current CMB observations alone can constrain the scale factor of transition from early D…
▽ More
In this work, we study a class of early dark energy (EDE) models, in which, unlike in standard DE models, a substantial amount of DE exists in the matter-dominated era, self-consistently including DE perturbations. Our analysis shows that, marginalizing over the non DE parameters such as $Omega_m, H_0, n_s$, current CMB observations alone can constrain the scale factor of transition from early DE to late time DE to $a_t \geq 0.44$ and width of transition to $Delta_t \leq 0.37$. The equation of state at present is somewhat weakly constrained to $w_0 \leq -0.6$, if we allow $H_0 < 60$ km/s/Mpc. Taken together with other observations, such as supernovae, HST, and SDSS LRGs, the constraints are tighter-- $w_0 \leq -0.9, a_t \leq 0.19, Δ_t \leq 0.21$. The evolution of the equation of state for EDE models is thus close to $Λ$CDM at low redshifts. Incorrectly assuming DE perturbations to be negligible leads to different constraints on the equation of state parameters, thus highlighting the necessity of self-consistently including DE perturbations in the analysis. If we allow the spatial curvature to be a free parameter, then the constraints are relaxed to $w_0 \leq -0.77, a_t \leq 0.35, Δ_t \leq 0.35$ with $-0.014 < Ω_κ < 0.031$ for CMB+other observations. For perturbed EDE models, the $2σ$ lower limit on $σ_8$ ($σ_8 \geq 0.59$) is much lower than that in $Λ$CDM ($σ_8 \geq 0.72$), thus raising the interesting possibility of discriminating EDE from $Λ$CDM using future observations such as halo mass functions or the Sunyaev-Zeldovich power spectrum.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2010; v1 submitted 5 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
Reconstructing Cosmological Matter Perturbations using Standard Candles and Rulers
Authors:
Ujjaini Alam,
Varun Sahni,
Alexei A. Starobinsky
Abstract:
For a large class of dark energy (DE) models, for which the effective gravitational constant is a constant and there is no direct exchange of energy between DE and dark matter (DM), knowledge of the expansion history suffices to reconstruct the growth factor of linearized density perturbations in the non-relativistic matter component on scales much smaller than the Hubble distance. In this paper…
▽ More
For a large class of dark energy (DE) models, for which the effective gravitational constant is a constant and there is no direct exchange of energy between DE and dark matter (DM), knowledge of the expansion history suffices to reconstruct the growth factor of linearized density perturbations in the non-relativistic matter component on scales much smaller than the Hubble distance. In this paper we develop a non-parametric method for extracting information about the perturbative growth factor from data pertaining to the luminosity or angular size distances. A comparison of the reconstructed density contrast with observations of large scale structure and gravitational lensing can help distinguish DE models such as the cosmological constant and quintessence from models based on modified gravity theories as well as models in which DE and DM are either unified, or interact directly. We show that for current SNe data, the linear growth factor at z = 0.3 can be constrained to 5%, and the linear growth rate to 6%. With future SNe data, such as expected from the JDEM mission, we may be able to constrain the growth factor to 2-3% and the growth rate to 3-4% at z = 0.3 with this unbiased, model-independent reconstruction method. For future BAO data which would deliver measurements of both the angular diameter distance and Hubble parameter, it should be possible to constrain the growth factor at z = 2.5 to 9%. These constraints grow tighter with the errors on the datasets. With a large quantity of data expected in the next few years, this method can emerge as a competitive tool for distinguishing between different models of dark energy.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2009; v1 submitted 15 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
-
Exploring the Properties of Dark Energy Using Type Ia Supernovae and Other Datasets
Authors:
Ujjaini Alam,
Varun Sahni,
Alexei A. Starobinsky
Abstract:
We reconstruct dark energy properties from two complementary supernova datasets -- the newly released Gold+HST sample and SNLS. The results obtained are consistent with standard $Λ$CDM model within $2σ$ error bars although the Gold+HST data favour evolving dark energy slightly more than SNLS. Using complementary data from baryon acoustic oscillations and the cosmic microwave background to constr…
▽ More
We reconstruct dark energy properties from two complementary supernova datasets -- the newly released Gold+HST sample and SNLS. The results obtained are consistent with standard $Λ$CDM model within $2σ$ error bars although the Gold+HST data favour evolving dark energy slightly more than SNLS. Using complementary data from baryon acoustic oscillations and the cosmic microwave background to constrain dark energy, we find that our results in this case are strongly dependent on the present value of the matter density $Ω_m$. Consequently, no firm conclusions regarding constancy or variability of dark energy density can be drawn from these data alone unless the value of $Ω_m$ is known to an accuracy of a few percent. However, possible variability is significantly restricted if this data is used in conjunction with supernova data.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2006;
originally announced December 2006.
-
Confronting Braneworld Cosmology with Supernova data and Baryon Oscillations
Authors:
Ujjaini Alam,
Varun Sahni
Abstract:
Braneworld cosmology has several attractive and distinctive features. For instance the effective equation of state in braneworld models can be both quintessence-like (w_0 \geq -1) as well as phantom-like (w_0 \leq -1). Models with w_0 \geq -1 (w_0 \leq -1) are referred to as Brane 2 (Brane 1) and correspond to complementary embeddings of the brane in the bulk. (The equation of state in Brane 1 c…
▽ More
Braneworld cosmology has several attractive and distinctive features. For instance the effective equation of state in braneworld models can be both quintessence-like (w_0 \geq -1) as well as phantom-like (w_0 \leq -1). Models with w_0 \geq -1 (w_0 \leq -1) are referred to as Brane 2 (Brane 1) and correspond to complementary embeddings of the brane in the bulk. (The equation of state in Brane 1 can successfully cross the `phantom divide' at w = -1.) In this paper we compare the predictions of braneworld models to two recently released supernova data sets: the `Gold' data (Riess et al, 2004) and the data from the Supernova Legacy Survey (SNLS) (Astier et al, 2005). We also incorporate the recent discovery of the baryon acoustic peak in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (Eisenstein et al, 2005) into our analysis. Our main results are that braneworld models satisfy both sets of SNe data. Brane 1 (with w_0 \leq -1) shows very good agreement with data for values of the matter density bounded {\em from below}: Ω_m \geq 0.25 (Gold) and $Ω_m \geq 0.2 (SNLS). On the other hand Brane 2 (with w_0 \geq -1) shows excellent agreement with data for values of the matter density which are bounded {\em from above}: Ω_m \leq 0.45 (Gold) and Ω_m \leq 0.35 (SNLS). The DGP model is excluded at 3σby SNLS and at 1σby the Gold dataset. Braneworld models with future `quiescent' singularities (at which the Hubble parameter and the matter density remain finite but higher derivatives of the expansion factor diverge) are excluded by both datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2006; v1 submitted 16 November, 2005;
originally announced November 2005.
-
Smoothing Supernova Data to Reconstruct the Expansion History of the Universe and its Age
Authors:
Arman Shafieloo,
Ujjaini Alam,
Varun Sahni,
Alexei A. Starobinsky
Abstract:
We propose a non-parametric method of smoothing supernova data over redshift using a Gaussian kernel in order to reconstruct important cosmological quantities including H(z) and w(z) in a model independent manner. This method is shown to be successful in discriminating between different models of dark energy when the quality of data is commensurate with that expected from the future SuperNova Ac…
▽ More
We propose a non-parametric method of smoothing supernova data over redshift using a Gaussian kernel in order to reconstruct important cosmological quantities including H(z) and w(z) in a model independent manner. This method is shown to be successful in discriminating between different models of dark energy when the quality of data is commensurate with that expected from the future SuperNova Acceleration Probe (SNAP). We find that the Hubble parameter is especially well-determined and useful for this purpose. The look back time of the universe may also be determined to a very high degree of accuracy (\lleq 0.2 %) in this method. By refining the method, it is also possible to obtain reasonable bounds on the equation of state of dark energy. We explore a new diagnostic of dark energy-- the `w-probe'-- which can be calculated from the first derivative of the data. We find that this diagnostic is reconstructed extremely accurately for different reconstruction methods even if Ω_m is marginalized over. The w-probe can be used to successfully distinguish between $Λ$CDM and other models of dark energy to a high degree of accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2007; v1 submitted 16 May, 2005;
originally announced May 2005.
-
Rejoinder to "No Evidence of Dark Energy Metamorphosis", astro-ph/0404468
Authors:
Ujjaini Alam,
Varun Sahni,
Tarun Deep Saini,
A. A. Starobinsky
Abstract:
In a recent paper (astro-ph/0311364) Alam et al argued that the SNe data of Tonry et al 2003 and Barris et al 2003 appear to favour DE which evolves in time, provided no other priors are invoked. (The effect of invoking priors such as the age of the Universe, the values of $H_0$ and $Ω_m$ and CMB/LSS observations could modify this conclusion, as demonstrated in astro-ph/0403687 and other recent…
▽ More
In a recent paper (astro-ph/0311364) Alam et al argued that the SNe data of Tonry et al 2003 and Barris et al 2003 appear to favour DE which evolves in time, provided no other priors are invoked. (The effect of invoking priors such as the age of the Universe, the values of $H_0$ and $Ω_m$ and CMB/LSS observations could modify this conclusion, as demonstrated in astro-ph/0403687 and other recent papers.) The approach adopted by Alam et al to reconstruct the properties of DE was severely (and, as we shall show below -- unfairly) criticized by Jönsson et al in astro-ph/0404468. In this paper we re-examine the parametrisation used in astro-ph/0311364 and show that, contrary to the claims of Jönsson et al, the results obtained from this reconstruction are robust and therefore representative of the true nature of dark energy.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2004;
originally announced June 2004.
-
The case for dynamical dark energy revisited
Authors:
Ujjaini Alam,
Varun Sahni,
A. A. Starobinsky
Abstract:
We investigate the behaviour of dark energy using the recently released supernova data of Riess et al ~(2004) and a model independent parameterization for dark energy (DE). We find that, if no priors are imposed on $Ω_{0m}$ and $h$, DE which evolves with time provides a better fit to the SNe data than $Λ$CDM. This is also true if we include results from the WMAP CMB data.
From a joint analysis…
▽ More
We investigate the behaviour of dark energy using the recently released supernova data of Riess et al ~(2004) and a model independent parameterization for dark energy (DE). We find that, if no priors are imposed on $Ω_{0m}$ and $h$, DE which evolves with time provides a better fit to the SNe data than $Λ$CDM. This is also true if we include results from the WMAP CMB data.
From a joint analysis of SNe+CMB, the best-fit DE model has $w_0 < -1$ at the present epoch and the transition from deceleration to acceleration occurs at $z_T = 0.39 \pm 0.03$. However, DE evolution becomes weaker if the $Λ$CDM based CMB results $Ω_{0m} = 0.27 \pm 0.04$, $h = 0.71 \pm 0.06$ are incorporated in the analysis. In this case, $z_T = 0.57 \pm 0.07$. Our results also show that the extent of DE evolution is sensitive to the manner in which the supernova data is sampled.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2004; v1 submitted 30 March, 2004;
originally announced March 2004.
-
Is there Supernova Evidence for Dark Energy Metamorphosis ?
Authors:
Ujjaini Alam,
Varun Sahni,
Tarun Deep Saini,
A. A. Starobinsky
Abstract:
We reconstruct the equation of state $w(z)$ of dark energy (DE) using a recently released data set containing 172 type Ia supernovae without assuming the prior $w(z) \geq -1$ (in contrast to previous studies). We find that dark energy evolves rapidly and metamorphoses from dust-like behaviour at high $z$ ($w \simeq 0$ at $z \sim 1$) to a strongly negative equation of state at present (…
▽ More
We reconstruct the equation of state $w(z)$ of dark energy (DE) using a recently released data set containing 172 type Ia supernovae without assuming the prior $w(z) \geq -1$ (in contrast to previous studies). We find that dark energy evolves rapidly and metamorphoses from dust-like behaviour at high $z$ ($w \simeq 0$ at $z \sim 1$) to a strongly negative equation of state at present ($w \lleq -1$ at $z \simeq 0$). Dark energy metamorphosis appears to be a robust phenomenon which manifests for a large variety of SNe data samples provided one does not invoke the weak energy prior $ρ+ p \geq 0$. Invoking this prior considerably weakens the rate of growth of $w(z)$. These results demonstrate that dark energy with an evolving equation of state provides a compelling alternative to a cosmological constant if data are analysed in a prior-free manner and the weak energy condition is not imposed by hand.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2004; v1 submitted 16 November, 2003;
originally announced November 2003.
-
Exploring the Expanding Universe and Dark Energy using the Statefinder Diagnostic
Authors:
Ujjaini Alam,
Varun Sahni,
Tarun Deep Saini,
A. A. Starobinsky
Abstract:
The coming few years are likely to witness a dramatic increase in high quality Sn data as current surveys add more high redshift supernovae to their inventory and as newer and deeper supernova experiments become operational. Given the current variety in dark energy models and the expected improvement in observational data, an accurate and versatile diagnostic of dark energy is the need of the ho…
▽ More
The coming few years are likely to witness a dramatic increase in high quality Sn data as current surveys add more high redshift supernovae to their inventory and as newer and deeper supernova experiments become operational. Given the current variety in dark energy models and the expected improvement in observational data, an accurate and versatile diagnostic of dark energy is the need of the hour. This paper examines the Statefinder diagnostic in the light of the proposed SNAP satellite which is expected to observe about 2000 supernovae per year. We show that the Statefinder is versatile enough to differentiate between dark energy models as varied as the cosmological constant on the one hand, and quintessence, the Chaplygin gas and braneworld models, on the other. Using SNAP data, the Statefinder can distinguish a cosmological constant ($w=-1$) from quintessence models with $w \geq -0.9$ and Chaplygin gas models with $κ\leq 15$ at the $3σ$ level if the value of $\om$ is known exactly. The Statefinder gives reasonable results even when the value of $\om$ is known to only $\sim 20%$ accuracy. In this case, marginalizing over $\om$ and assuming a fiducial LCDM model allows us to rule out quintessence with $w \geq -0.85$ and the Chaplygin gas with $κ\leq 7$ (both at $3σ$). These constraints can be made even tighter if we use the Statefinders in conjunction with the deceleration parameter. The Statefinder is very sensitive to the total pressure exerted by all forms of matter and radiation in the universe. It can therefore differentiate between dark energy models at moderately high redshifts of $z \lleq 10$.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2003; v1 submitted 1 March, 2003;
originally announced March 2003.
-
Can dark energy be decaying?
Authors:
Ujjaini Alam,
Varun Sahni,
A. A. Starobinsky
Abstract:
We explore the fate of the universe given the possibility that the density associated with `dark energy' may decay slowly with time. Decaying dark energy is modeled by a homogeneous scalar field which couples minimally to gravity and whose potential has {\em at least one} local quadratic maximum. Dark energy decays as the scalar field rolls down its potential, consequently the current accelerati…
▽ More
We explore the fate of the universe given the possibility that the density associated with `dark energy' may decay slowly with time. Decaying dark energy is modeled by a homogeneous scalar field which couples minimally to gravity and whose potential has {\em at least one} local quadratic maximum. Dark energy decays as the scalar field rolls down its potential, consequently the current acceleration epoch is a transient. We examine two models of decaying dark energy. In the first, the dark energy potential is modeled by an analytical form which is generic close to the potential maximum. The second potential is the cosine, which can become negative as the field evolves, ensuring that a spatially flat universe collapses in the future. We examine the feasibility of both models using observations of high redshift type Ia supernovae. A maximum likelihood analysis is used to find allowed regions in the $\lbrace m, φ_0\rbrace$ plane ($m$ is the tachyon mass modulus and $φ_0$ the initial scalar field value; $m\sim H_0$ and $φ_0\sim M_P$ by order of magnitude). For the first model, the time for the potential to drop to half its maximum value is larger than $\sim 8$ Gyrs. In the case of the cosine potential, the time left until the universe collapses is always greater than $\sim 18$ Gyrs (both estimates are presented for $\om = 0.3$, $m/H_0 \sim 1$, $H_0 \simeq 70$ km/sec/Mpc, and at the 95.4% confidence level).
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2003; v1 submitted 15 February, 2003;
originally announced February 2003.
-
Supernova Constraints on Braneworld Dark Energy
Authors:
Ujjaini Alam,
Varun Sahni
Abstract:
Braneworld models of dark energy are examined in the light of observations of high redshift type Ia supernovae. Braneworld models admit several novel and even exotic possibilities which include: (i) The effective equation of state of dark energy can be more negative than in LCDM: $w \leq -1$; (ii) A class of braneworld models can encounter a `quiescent' future singularity at which the energy den…
▽ More
Braneworld models of dark energy are examined in the light of observations of high redshift type Ia supernovae. Braneworld models admit several novel and even exotic possibilities which include: (i) The effective equation of state of dark energy can be more negative than in LCDM: $w \leq -1$; (ii) A class of braneworld models can encounter a `quiescent' future singularity at which the energy density and the Hubble parameter remain well behaved, but higher derivatives of the expansion factor ($\stackrel{..}{a}$, $\stackrel{...}{a}$ etc.) diverge when the future singularity is reached; (iii) The current acceleration of the universe is a {\em transient feature} in a class of models in which dark energy `disappears' after a certain time, giving rise to a matter dominated universe in the future. Since horizons are absent in such a space-time, a braneworld model with {\em transient acceleration} might help reconcile current supernova-based observations of an accelerating universe with the demands of string/M-theory. A maximum likelihood analysis reveals that braneworld models satisfy the stringent demands imposed by high redshift supernovae and a large region in parameter space agrees marginally better with current observations than LCDM. For instance, models with $w < -1 (> -1)$ provide better agreement with data than LCDM for $Ω_m \ggeq 0.3 (\lleq 0.25)$.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2002;
originally announced September 2002.
-
Statefinder -- a new geometrical diagnostic of dark energy
Authors:
Varun Sahni,
Tarun Deep Saini,
A. A. Starobinsky,
Ujjaini Alam
Abstract:
We introduce a new cosmological diagnostic pair $\lbrace r,s\rbrace$ called Statefinder. The Statefinder is dimensionless and, like the Hubble and deceleration parameters $H(z)$ and $q(z)$, is constructed from the scale factor of the Universe and its derivatives only. The parameter $r(z)$ forms the next step in the hierarchy of geometrical cosmological parameters used to study the Universe after…
▽ More
We introduce a new cosmological diagnostic pair $\lbrace r,s\rbrace$ called Statefinder. The Statefinder is dimensionless and, like the Hubble and deceleration parameters $H(z)$ and $q(z)$, is constructed from the scale factor of the Universe and its derivatives only. The parameter $r(z)$ forms the next step in the hierarchy of geometrical cosmological parameters used to study the Universe after $H$ and $q$, while the parameter $s(z)$ is a linear combination of $q$ and $r$ chosen in such a way that it does not depend upon the dark energy density $Ω_X(z)$. The Statefinder pair $\lbrace r,s\rbrace$ is algebraically related to the the dark energy pressure-to-energy ratio $w=p/ε$ and its time derivative, and sheds light on the nature of dark energy/quintessence. Its properties allow to usefully differentiate between different forms of dark energy with constant and variable $w$, including a cosmological constant ($w = -1$). The Statefinder pair can be determined to very good accuracy from a SNAP type experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2003; v1 submitted 30 January, 2002;
originally announced January 2002.
