-
Evidence for large baryonic feedback at low and intermediate redshifts from kinematic Sunyaev-Zel'dovich observations with ACT and DESI photometric galaxies
Authors:
B. Hadzhiyska,
S. Ferraro,
B. Ried Guachalla,
E. Schaan,
J. Aguilar,
N. Battaglia,
J. R. Bond,
D. Brooks,
E. Calabrese,
S. K. Choi,
T. Claybaugh,
W. R. Coulton,
K. Dawson,
M. Devlin,
B. Dey,
P. Doel,
A. J. Duivenvoorden,
J. Dunkley,
G. S. Farren,
A. Font-Ribera,
J. E. Forero-Romero,
P. A. Gallardo,
E. Gaztañaga,
S. Gontcho Gontcho,
M. Gralla
, et al. (48 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Recent advances in cosmological observations have provided an unprecedented opportunity to investigate the distribution of baryons relative to the underlying matter. In this work, we robustly show that the gas is much more extended than the dark matter at 40$σ$ and the amount of baryonic feedback at $z \lesssim 1$ strongly disfavors low-feedback models such as that of state-of-the-art hydrodynamic…
▽ More
Recent advances in cosmological observations have provided an unprecedented opportunity to investigate the distribution of baryons relative to the underlying matter. In this work, we robustly show that the gas is much more extended than the dark matter at 40$σ$ and the amount of baryonic feedback at $z \lesssim 1$ strongly disfavors low-feedback models such as that of state-of-the-art hydrodynamical simulation IllustrisTNG compared with high-feedback models such as that of the original Illustris simulation. This has important implications for bridging the gap between theory and observations and understanding galaxy formation and evolution. Furthermore, a better grasp of the baryon-dark matter link is critical to future cosmological analyses, which are currently impeded by our limited knowledge of baryonic feedback. Here, we measure the kinematic Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (kSZ) effect from the Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT), stacked on the luminous red galaxy (LRG) sample of the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) imaging survey. This is the first analysis to use photometric redshifts for reconstructing galaxy velocities. Due to the large number of galaxies comprising the DESI imaging survey, this is the highest signal-to-noise stacked kSZ measurement to date: we detect the signal at 13$σ$ and find that the gas is more spread out than the dark matter at $\sim$40$σ$. Our work opens up the possibility to recalibrate large hydrodynamical simulations using the kSZ effect. In addition, our findings point towards a way of alleviating inconsistencies between weak lensing surveys and cosmic microwave background (CMB) experiments such as the `low $S_8$' tension, and shed light on long-standing enigmas in astrophysics such as the `missing baryon' problem.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Informed Total-Error-Minimizing Priors: Interpretable cosmological parameter constraints despite complex nuisance effects
Authors:
Bernardita Ried Guachalla,
Dylan Britt,
Daniel Gruen,
Oliver Friedrich
Abstract:
While Bayesian inference techniques are standard in cosmological analyses, it is common to interpret resulting parameter constraints with a frequentist intuition. This intuition can fail, e.g. when marginalizing high-dimensional parameter spaces onto subsets of parameters, because of what has come to be known as projection effects or prior volume effects. We present the method of Informed Total-Er…
▽ More
While Bayesian inference techniques are standard in cosmological analyses, it is common to interpret resulting parameter constraints with a frequentist intuition. This intuition can fail, e.g. when marginalizing high-dimensional parameter spaces onto subsets of parameters, because of what has come to be known as projection effects or prior volume effects. We present the method of Informed Total-Error-Minimizing (ITEM) priors to address this. An ITEM prior is a prior distribution on a set of nuisance parameters, e.g. ones describing astrophysical or calibration systematics, intended to enforce the validity of a frequentist interpretation of the posterior constraints derived for a set of target parameters, e.g. cosmological parameters. Our method works as follows: For a set of plausible nuisance realizations, we generate target parameter posteriors using several different candidate priors for the nuisance parameters. We reject candidate priors that do not accomplish the minimum requirements of bias (of point estimates) and coverage (of confidence regions among a set of noisy realizations of the data) for the target parameters on one or more of the plausible nuisance realizations. Of the priors that survive this cut we select the ITEM prior as the one that minimizes the total error of the marginalized posteriors of the target parameters. As a proof of concept, we apply our method to the Density Split Statistics (DSS) measured in Dark Energy Survey Year 1 data. We demonstrate that the ITEM priors substantially reduce prior volume effects that otherwise arise and allow sharpened yet robust constraints on the parameters of interest.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Bounds on galaxy stochasticity from halo occupation distribution modeling
Authors:
Dylan Britt,
Daniel Gruen,
Oliver Friedrich,
Sihan Yuan,
Bernardita Ried Guachalla
Abstract:
The joint probability distribution of matter overdensity and galaxy counts in cells is a powerful probe of cosmology, and the extent to which variance in galaxy counts at fixed matter density deviates from Poisson shot noise is not fully understood. The lack of informed bounds on this stochasticity is currently the limiting factor in constraining cosmology with the galaxy-matter PDF. We investigat…
▽ More
The joint probability distribution of matter overdensity and galaxy counts in cells is a powerful probe of cosmology, and the extent to which variance in galaxy counts at fixed matter density deviates from Poisson shot noise is not fully understood. The lack of informed bounds on this stochasticity is currently the limiting factor in constraining cosmology with the galaxy-matter PDF. We investigate stochasticity in the conditional distribution of galaxy counts at fixed matter density and present a halo occupation distribution (HOD)-based approach for obtaining plausible ranges for stochasticity parameters. To probe the high-dimensional space of possible galaxy-matter connections, we derive HODs which conserve linear galaxy bias and number density to produce redMaGiC-like galaxy catalogs within the AbacusSummit suite of N-body simulations. We study the impact of individual HOD parameters and cosmology on stochasticity and perform a Monte Carlo search in HOD parameter space, subject to the constraints on bias and density. In mock catalogs generated by the selected HODs, shot noise in galaxy counts spans both sub-Poisson and super-Poisson values, ranging from 80% to 133% of Poisson variance at mean matter density. Nearly all derived HODs show a positive relationship between local matter density and stochasticity. For galaxy catalogs with higher stochasticity, quadratic galaxy bias is required for an accurate description of the conditional PDF of galaxy counts at fixed matter density. The presence of galaxy assembly bias also substantially extends the range of stochasticity in the super-Poisson direction. This HOD-based approach leverages degrees of freedom in the galaxy-halo connection to obtain informed bounds on model nuisance parameters and can be adapted to other parametrizations of stochasticity, in particular to motivate prior ranges for cosmological analyses.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Velocity reconstruction in the era of DESI and Rubin (part I): Exploring spectroscopic, photometric & hybrid samples
Authors:
Bernardita Ried Guachalla,
Emmanuel Schaan,
Boryana Hadzhiyska,
Simone Ferraro
Abstract:
Peculiar velocities of galaxies and halos can be reconstructed from their spatial distribution alone. This technique is analogous to the baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) reconstruction, using the continuity equation to connect density and velocity fields. The resulting reconstructed velocities can be used to measure imprints of galaxy velocities on the cosmic microwave background (CMB) like the…
▽ More
Peculiar velocities of galaxies and halos can be reconstructed from their spatial distribution alone. This technique is analogous to the baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) reconstruction, using the continuity equation to connect density and velocity fields. The resulting reconstructed velocities can be used to measure imprints of galaxy velocities on the cosmic microwave background (CMB) like the kinematic Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (kSZ) effect or the moving lens effect. As the precision of these measurements increases, characterizing the performance of the velocity reconstruction becomes crucial to allow unbiased and statistically optimal inference. In this paper, we quantify the relevant performance metrics: the variance of the reconstructed velocities and their correlation coefficient with the true velocities. We show that the relevant velocities to reconstruct for kSZ and moving lens are actually the halo -- rather than galaxy -- velocities. We quantify the impact of redshift-space distortions, photometric redshift errors, satellite galaxy fraction, incorrect cosmological parameter assumptions and smoothing scale on the reconstruction performance. We also investigate hybrid reconstruction methods, where velocities inferred from spectroscopic samples are evaluated at the positions of denser photometric samples. We find that using exclusively the photometric sample is better than performing a hybrid analysis. The 2 Gpc$/h$ length simulations from AbacusSummit with realistic galaxy samples for DESI and Rubin LSST allow us to perform this analysis in a controlled setting. In the companion paper Hadzhiyska et al. 2024, we further include the effects of evolution along the light cone and give realistic performance estimates for DESI luminous red galaxies (LRGs), emission line galaxies (ELGs), and Rubin LSST-like samples.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2024; v1 submitted 19 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Velocity reconstruction in the era of DESI and Rubin (part II): Realistic samples on the light cone
Authors:
Boryana Hadzhiyska,
Simone Ferraro,
Bernardita Ried Guachalla,
Emmanuel Schaan
Abstract:
Reconstructing the galaxy peculiar velocity field from the distribution of large-scale structure plays an important role in cosmology. On one hand, it gives us an insight into structure formation and gravity; on the other, it allows us to selectively extract the kinetic Sunyaev-Zeldovich (kSZ) effect from cosmic microwave background (CMB) maps. In this work, we employ high-accuracy synthetic galax…
▽ More
Reconstructing the galaxy peculiar velocity field from the distribution of large-scale structure plays an important role in cosmology. On one hand, it gives us an insight into structure formation and gravity; on the other, it allows us to selectively extract the kinetic Sunyaev-Zeldovich (kSZ) effect from cosmic microwave background (CMB) maps. In this work, we employ high-accuracy synthetic galaxy catalogs on the light cone to investigate how well we can recover the velocity field when utilizing the three-dimensional spatial distribution of the galaxies in a modern large-scale structure experiment such as the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) and Rubin Observatory (LSST). In particular, we adopt the standard technique used in baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) analysis for reconstructing the Zeldovich displacements of galaxies through the continuity equation, which yields a first-order approximation to their large-scale velocities. We investigate variations in the number density, bias, mask, area, redshift noise, and survey depth, and smoothing. Since our main goal is to provide guidance for planned kSZ analysis between DESI and the Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT), we apply velocity reconstruction to a faithful representation of DESI spectroscopic and photometric targets. We report the cross-correlation coefficient between the reconstructed and the true velocities along the line of sight. For the DESI Y1 spectroscopic survey, we expect the correlation coefficient to be $r \approx 0.64$, while for a photometric survey with $σ_z/(1+z) = 0.02$, as is approximately the case for the Legacy Survey used in the target selection of DESI galaxies, $r$ shrinks by half to $r \approx 0.31$. We hope the results in this paper can be used to inform future kSZ stacking studies. All scripts used in this paper can be found here: \url{https://github.com/boryanah/abacus_kSZ_recon}.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
