-
The 33 M$_\odot$ black hole Gaia BH3 is part of the disrupted ED-2 star cluster
Authors:
E. Balbinot,
E. Dodd,
T. Matsuno,
C. Lardo,
A. Helmi,
P. Panuzzo,
T. Mazeh,
B. Holl,
E. Caffau,
A. Jorissen,
C. Babusiaux,
P. Gavras,
L. Wyrzykowski,
L. Eyer,
N. Leclerc,
A. Bombrun,
N. Mowlavi,
G. M. Seabroke,
I. Cabrera-Ziri,
T. M. Callingham,
T. Ruiz-Lara,
E. Starkenburg
Abstract:
The Gaia Collaboration has recently reported the detection of a 33 M$_\odot$ black hole in a wide binary system located in the Solar neighbourhood. Here we explore the relationship between this black hole, known as Gaia BH3, and the nearby ED-2 halo stellar stream. We study the orbital characteristics of the Gaia BH3 binary and present measurements of the chemical abundances of ED-2 member stars d…
▽ More
The Gaia Collaboration has recently reported the detection of a 33 M$_\odot$ black hole in a wide binary system located in the Solar neighbourhood. Here we explore the relationship between this black hole, known as Gaia BH3, and the nearby ED-2 halo stellar stream. We study the orbital characteristics of the Gaia BH3 binary and present measurements of the chemical abundances of ED-2 member stars derived from high-resolution spectra obtained with the VLT. We find that the Galactic orbit of the Gaia BH3 system and its metallicity are entirely consistent with being part of the ED-2 stream. The characteristics of the stream, particularly its negligible spread in metallicity and in other chemical elements as well as its single stellar population, suggest that it originated from a disrupted star cluster of low mass. Its age is comparable to that of the globular cluster M92 that has been estimated to be as old as the Universe. This is the first black hole unambiguously associated with a disrupted star cluster. We infer a plausible mass range for the cluster to be relatively narrow, between $2\times 10^3M_\odot$ and $4.2\times 10^4M_\odot$. This implies that the black hole could have formed directly from the collapse of a massive very-metal-poor star, but that the alternative scenario of binary interactions inside the cluster environment also deserves to be explored.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2024; v1 submitted 17 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Insurance pricing for breast cancer under different multiple state models
Authors:
Ayse Arik,
Andrew J. G. Cairns,
Erengul Dodd,
Angus S. Macdonald,
Adam Shao,
George Streftaris
Abstract:
In this paper we consider pricing of insurance contracts for breast cancer risk based on three multiple state models. Using population data in England and data from the medical literature, we calibrate a collection of semi-Markov and Markov models. Considering an industry-based Markov model as a baseline model, we demonstrate the strengths of a more detailed model while showing the importance of a…
▽ More
In this paper we consider pricing of insurance contracts for breast cancer risk based on three multiple state models. Using population data in England and data from the medical literature, we calibrate a collection of semi-Markov and Markov models. Considering an industry-based Markov model as a baseline model, we demonstrate the strengths of a more detailed model while showing the importance of accounting for duration dependence in transition rates. We quantify age-specific cancer incidence and cancer survival by stage along with type-specific mortality rates based on the semi-Markov model which accounts for unobserved breast cancer cases and progression through breast cancer stages. Using the developed models, we obtain actuarial net premiums for a specialised critical illness and life insurance product. Our analysis shows that the semi-Markov model leads to results aligned with empirical evidence. Our findings point out the importance of accounting for the time spent with diagnosed or undiagnosed pre-metastatic breast cancer in actuarial applications.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
ED-2: a cold but not so narrow stellar stream crossing the Solar neighbourhood
Authors:
E. Balbinot,
A. Helmi,
T. Callingham,
T. Matsuno,
E. Dodd,
T. Ruiz-Lara
Abstract:
ED-2 is a stellar stream identified as a compact group in integrals of motion space in a local sample of halo stars from the third Gaia data release. Here we investigate its nature and possible association with known halo substructures. We explore the current properties of ED-2 members in phase-space, and also analyse the expected distribution via orbit integration. In addition, we study the metal…
▽ More
ED-2 is a stellar stream identified as a compact group in integrals of motion space in a local sample of halo stars from the third Gaia data release. Here we investigate its nature and possible association with known halo substructures. We explore the current properties of ED-2 members in phase-space, and also analyse the expected distribution via orbit integration. In addition, we study the metallicity of ED-2 using APOGEE DR17 and LAMOST DR8 (and re-calibrated DR3). ED-2 forms a compact group in the $x-z$ (or $R-z$) plane, showing a pancake-like structure as it crosses the Solar neighbourhood. Dynamically it is most similar the globular clusters NGC 3201 and NGC 6101, and the stellar stream Ylgr and Phlegethon. However, its orbit is sufficiently different that none of these objects is likely to be ED-2's progenitor. We also find ED-2 to be quite metal-poor, with all of its stars $\mathrm{[Fe/H]} \leq -2.42$, with a median $\mathrm{[Fe/H]} = -2.60^{+0.20}_{-0.21}$. At this low metallicity, it is unlikely that ED-2 stems from any known globular cluster, instead, ED-2 seems to be in a similar category as the recently discovered Phoenix and C-19 stellar streams. We find that ED-2 members are scattered across the whole sky, which is due to its current orbital phase. We predict that as this object moves to its next apocentre it will acquire an on-sky morphology that is akin to cold stellar streams. Finally, since ED-2 is nearing pericentre, we predict that additional members found below the plane should have large radial velocities, close to $\sim$ 500 km/s in the present-day direction of the globular cluster NGC 6101.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2023; v1 submitted 5 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
The effect of the COVID-19 health disruptions on breast cancer mortality for older women: A semi-Markov modelling approach
Authors:
Ayse Arik,
Andrew J. G. Cairns,
Erengul Dodd,
Angus S. Macdonald,
George Streftaris
Abstract:
We propose a methodology to quantify the impact on breast cancer mortality of diagnostic delays caused by public health measures introduced as a response to the COVID-19 pandemic. These measures affected cancer pathways by halting cancer screening, delaying diagnostic tests, and reducing the numbers of patients starting treatment. We introduce a semi-Markov model, to quantify the impact of the pan…
▽ More
We propose a methodology to quantify the impact on breast cancer mortality of diagnostic delays caused by public health measures introduced as a response to the COVID-19 pandemic. These measures affected cancer pathways by halting cancer screening, delaying diagnostic tests, and reducing the numbers of patients starting treatment. We introduce a semi-Markov model, to quantify the impact of the pandemic based on publicly available population data for women age 65{89 years in England and relevant medical literature. We quantify age-specific excess deaths, for a period up to 5 years, along with years of life expectancy lost and change in cancer mortality by cancer stage. Our analysis suggests a 3-6% increase in breast cancer deaths, corresponding to more than 40 extra deaths, per 100,000 women, after age 65 years old over 5 years, and a 4-6% increase in registrations of advanced (Stage 4) breast cancer. Our modelling approach exhibits consistent results in sensitivity analyses, providing a model that can account for changes in breast cancer diagnostic and treatment services.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2023; v1 submitted 29 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
The Gaia DR3 view of dynamical substructure in the stellar halo near the Sun
Authors:
Emma Dodd,
Thomas M. Callingham,
Amina Helmi,
Tadafumi Matsuno,
Tomás Ruiz-Lara,
Eduardo Balbinot,
Sofie Lövdal
Abstract:
The debris from past merger events is expected and, to some extent, known to populate the stellar halo near the Sun. We aim to identify and characterise such merger debris using Gaia DR3 data supplemented by metallicity and chemical abundance information from LAMOST LRS and APOGEE for halo stars within 2.5 kpc from the Sun. We utilise a single linkage-based clustering algorithm to identify over-de…
▽ More
The debris from past merger events is expected and, to some extent, known to populate the stellar halo near the Sun. We aim to identify and characterise such merger debris using Gaia DR3 data supplemented by metallicity and chemical abundance information from LAMOST LRS and APOGEE for halo stars within 2.5 kpc from the Sun. We utilise a single linkage-based clustering algorithm to identify over-densities in Integrals of Motion space that could be due to merger debris. Combined with metallicity information and chemical abundances, we characterise these statistically significant over-densities. We find that the local stellar halo contains 7 main dynamical groups, some of in-situ and some of accreted origin, most of which are already known. We report the discovery of a new substructure, which we name ED-1. In addition, we find evidence for 11 independent smaller clumps, 5 of which are new: ED-2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 are typically rather tight dynamically, depict a small range of metallicities, and their abundances when available, as well as their location in Integrals of Motion space, suggest an accreted origin. The local halo contains an important amount of substructure, of both in-situ and accreted origin.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2022; v1 submitted 22 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
High-precision chemical abundances of Galactic building blocks. II. Revisiting the chemical distinctness of the Helmi streams
Authors:
Tadafumi Matsuno,
Emma Dodd,
Helmer H. Koppelman,
Amina Helmi,
Miho N. Ishigaki,
Wako Aoki,
Jingkun Zhao,
Zhen Yuan,
Kohei Hattori
Abstract:
Context: The Helmi streams are a kinematic substructure whose progenitor is likely a dwarf galaxy. Although 20 years have passed since their discovery, it is still unclear whether their members are chemically distinguishable from other halo stars in the Milky Way. Aim: We aim to precisely characterize the chemical properties of the Helmi streams. Methods: We analyzed high-resolution, high signal-t…
▽ More
Context: The Helmi streams are a kinematic substructure whose progenitor is likely a dwarf galaxy. Although 20 years have passed since their discovery, it is still unclear whether their members are chemically distinguishable from other halo stars in the Milky Way. Aim: We aim to precisely characterize the chemical properties of the Helmi streams. Methods: We analyzed high-resolution, high signal-to-noise ratio spectra for 11 Helmi stream stars through a line-by-line abundance analysis. We compared the derived abundances to homogenized literature abundances of the other halo stars, including those belonging to other kinematic substructures, such as Gaia-Enceladus and Sequoia. Results: Compared to typical halo stars, the Helmi stream members clearly show low values of [X/Fe] in elements produced by massive stars, such as Na and $α$-elements. This tendency is seen down to metallicities of at least [Fe/H]$\sim -2.2$, suggesting type~Ia supernovae already started to contribute to the chemical evolution at this metallicity. We find that the [$α$/Fe] ratio does not evolve significantly with metallicity, making the Helmi stream stars less distinguishable from Gaia-Enceladus stars at [Fe/H]$\gtrsim -1.5$. The almost constant but low value of [$α$/Fe] might be indicative of quiescent star formation with low efficiency at the beginning and bursty star formation at later times. We also find extremely low values of [Y/Fe] at low metallicity, providing further support for the claim that light neutron-capture elements are deficient in Helmi streams. While Zn is deficient at low metallicity, it shows a large spread at high metallicity. The origin of the extremely low Y abundances and Zn variations remains unclear. Conclusion: The Helmi stream stars are distinguishable from the majority of the halo stars if homogeneously derived abundances are compared.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2023; v1 submitted 22 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Substructure in the stellar halo near the Sun. II. Characterisation of independent structures
Authors:
Tomás Ruiz-Lara,
Tadafumi Matsuno,
S. Sofie Lövdal,
Amina Helmi,
Emma Dodd,
Helmer H. Koppelman
Abstract:
In Lövdal et al, we presented a data-driven method for clustering in Integrals of Motion space and applied it to a large sample of nearby halo stars with 6D phase-space information. We identified a large number of clusters, many of which could tentatively be merged into larger groups. Our goal is to establish the reality of the clusters through a combined study of their stellar populations to gain…
▽ More
In Lövdal et al, we presented a data-driven method for clustering in Integrals of Motion space and applied it to a large sample of nearby halo stars with 6D phase-space information. We identified a large number of clusters, many of which could tentatively be merged into larger groups. Our goal is to establish the reality of the clusters through a combined study of their stellar populations to gain more insights into the accretion history of the Milky Way. We develop a procedure that quantifies the similarity of clusters based on KS tests using their metallicity distribution functions, and an isochrone fitting method to determine their average age, which is also used to compare the distribution of stars in the Colour-Absolute magnitude diagram. This allows us to group clusters into substructures, and to compare substructures with one another. The clusters identified are merged into 12 extended substructures, while 8 small clusters remain as such. The large substructures include the previously known Gaia-Enceladus, Helmi streams, Sequoia, and Thamnos 1 and 2. We identify overdensities associated with the hot thick disc and hosting a metal-poor population. Especially notable is our largest substructure which, although peaking at the metallicity characteristic of the thick disk has a well populated metal-poor component, and dynamics in-between hot thick disc and halo. We identify additional debris in the region occupied by Sequoia with distinct kinematics, likely remnants of three different accretion events with progenitors of similar mass. We also identify different trends of [Mg/Fe] vs [Fe/H] for the various substructures confirming our dissection of the nearby halo. At least 20\% of the halo near the Sun is associated to substructures. When comparing their global properties, we note that those substructures on retrograde orbits are not only more metal-poor on average but also older.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2022; v1 submitted 7 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Substructure in the stellar halo near the Sun. I. Data-driven clustering in Integrals of Motion space
Authors:
S. Sofie Lövdal,
Tomás Ruiz-Lara,
Helmer H. Koppelman,
Tadafumi Matsuno,
Emma Dodd,
Amina Helmi
Abstract:
Aims: Develop a data-driven and statistically based method for finding such clumps in Integrals of Motion space for nearby halo stars and evaluating their significance robustly. Methods: We use data from Gaia EDR3 extended with radial velocities from ground-based spectroscopic surveys to construct a sample of halo stars within 2.5 kpc from the Sun. We apply a hierarchical clustering method that us…
▽ More
Aims: Develop a data-driven and statistically based method for finding such clumps in Integrals of Motion space for nearby halo stars and evaluating their significance robustly. Methods: We use data from Gaia EDR3 extended with radial velocities from ground-based spectroscopic surveys to construct a sample of halo stars within 2.5 kpc from the Sun. We apply a hierarchical clustering method that uses the single linkage algorithm in a 3D space defined by the commonly used integrals of motion energy $E$, together with two components of the angular momentum, $L_z$ and $L_\perp$. To evaluate the statistical significance of the clusters found, we compare the density within an ellipsoidal region centered on the cluster to that of random sets with similar global dynamical properties. We pick out the signal at the location of their maximum statistical significance in the hierarchical tree. We estimate the proximity of a star to the cluster center using the Mahalanobis distance. We also apply the HDBSCAN clustering algorithm in velocity space. Results: Our procedure identifies 67 highly significant clusters ($ > 3σ$), containing 12\% of the sources in our halo set, and in total 232 subgroups or individual streams in velocity space. In total, 13.8\% of the stars in our data set can be confidently associated to a significant cluster based on their Mahalanobis distance. Inspection of our data set reveals a complex web of relationships between the significant clusters, suggesting that they can be tentatively grouped into at least 6 main structures, many of which can be associated to previously identified halo substructures, and a number of independent substructures. This preliminary conclusion is further explored in an accompanying paper by Ruiz-Lara et al., where we also characterize the substructures in terms of their stellar populations. Conclusions: We find... (abridged version)
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2022; v1 submitted 7 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Substructures, Resonances and debris streams
Authors:
Emma Dodd,
Amina Helmi,
Helmer H. Koppelman
Abstract:
The local stellar halo of the Milky Way contains the debris from several past accretion events. Here we study in detail the structure and properties of nearby debris associated with the Helmi streams, originally identified as an overdensity in integrals of motion space. We use 6D phase-space information from Gaia EDR3 combined with spectroscopic surveys, and we analyse the orbits and frequencies o…
▽ More
The local stellar halo of the Milky Way contains the debris from several past accretion events. Here we study in detail the structure and properties of nearby debris associated with the Helmi streams, originally identified as an overdensity in integrals of motion space. We use 6D phase-space information from Gaia EDR3 combined with spectroscopic surveys, and we analyse the orbits and frequencies of the stars in the streams using various Galactic potentials. We also explore how the Helmi streams constrain the flattening q, of the Galactic dark matter halo. We find that the streams are split into substructures in integrals of motion space, most notably into two clumps in angular momentum space. The clumps have consistent metallicity distributions and stellar populations, supporting a common progeny. In all the realistic Galactic potentials explored, the Helmi streams stars depict a diffuse distribution close to Omega_z /Omega_R ~0.7. At the same time, the reason for the substructure in angular momentum space appears to be a Omega_z : Omega_phi resonance close to the 1:1. This resonance is exactly the 1:1 in the case that the (density) flattening of the dark halo is q = 1.2. For this halo shape the substructure in angular momenta is also long lasting. Our findings suggest that the structure of the Galactic potential leaves a clear imprint on the properties of phase-mixed debris streams.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2021; v1 submitted 20 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
High-Energy Density Hohlraum Design Using Forward and Inverse Deep Neural Networks
Authors:
Ryan G. McClarren,
I. L. Tregillis,
Todd J. Urbatsch,
E. S. Dodd
Abstract:
We present a study of using machine learning to enhance hohlraum design for opacity measurement experiments. For opacity experiments we desire a hohlraum that, when its interior walls are illuminated by theNational Ignition Facility (NIF) lasers, will produce a high radiation flux that heats a central sample to a temperature that is constant over a measurement time window. Given a baseline hohlrau…
▽ More
We present a study of using machine learning to enhance hohlraum design for opacity measurement experiments. For opacity experiments we desire a hohlraum that, when its interior walls are illuminated by theNational Ignition Facility (NIF) lasers, will produce a high radiation flux that heats a central sample to a temperature that is constant over a measurement time window. Given a baseline hohlraum design and a computational model, we train a deep neural network to predict the time evolution of the radiation temperature as measured by the Dante diagnostic. This enables us to rapidly explore design space and determine the effect of adjusting design parameters. We also construct an "inverse" machine learning model that predicts the design parameters given a desired time history of radiation temperature. Calculations using the machine learning model demonstrate that improved performance over the baseline hohlraum would reduce uncertainties in experimental opacity measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Endpoints for randomized controlled clinical trials for COVID-19 treatments
Authors:
Lori E Dodd,
Dean Follmann,
Jing Wang,
Franz Koenig,
Lisa L Korn,
Christian Schoergenhofer,
Michael Proschan,
Sally Hunsberger,
Tyler Bonnett,
Mat Makowski,
Drifa Belhadi,
Yeming Wang,
Bin Cao,
France Mentre,
Thomas Jaki
Abstract:
Introduction: Endpoint choice for randomized controlled trials of treatments for COVID-19 is complex. A new disease brings many uncertainties, but trials must start rapidly. COVID-19 is heterogeneous, ranging from mild disease that improves within days to critical disease that can last weeks and can end in death. While improvement in mortality would provide unquestionable evidence about clinical s…
▽ More
Introduction: Endpoint choice for randomized controlled trials of treatments for COVID-19 is complex. A new disease brings many uncertainties, but trials must start rapidly. COVID-19 is heterogeneous, ranging from mild disease that improves within days to critical disease that can last weeks and can end in death. While improvement in mortality would provide unquestionable evidence about clinical significance of a treatment, sample sizes for a study evaluating mortality are large and may be impractical. Furthermore, patient states in between "cure" and "death" represent meaningful distinctions. Clinical severity scores have been proposed as an alternative. However, the appropriate summary measure for severity scores has been the subject of debate, particularly in relating to the uncertainty about the time-course of COVID-19. Outcomes measured at fixed time-points may risk missing the time of clinical benefit. An endpoint such as time-to-improvement (or recovery), avoids the timing problem. However, some have argued that power losses will result from reducing the ordinal scale to a binary state of "recovered" vs "not recovered."
Methods: We evaluate statistical power for possible trial endpoints for COVID-19 treatment trials using simulation models and data from two recent COVID-19 treatment trials.
Results: Power for fixed-time point methods depends heavily on the time selected for evaluation. Time-to-improvement (or recovery) analyses do not specify a time-point. Time-to-event approaches have reasonable statistical power, even when compared to a fixed time-point method evaluated at the optimal time.
Discussion: Time-to-event analyses methods have advantages in the COVID-19 setting, unless the optimal time for evaluating treatment effect is known in advance. Even when the optimal time is known, a time-to-event approach may increase power for interim analyses.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Forecasting Fertility with Parametric Mixture Models
Authors:
Jason Hilton,
Erengul Dodd,
Jonathan J. Forster,
Peter W. F. Smith,
Jakub Bijak
Abstract:
This paper sets out a forecasting method that employs a mixture of parametric functions to capture the pattern of fertility with respect to age. The overall level of cohort fertility is decomposed over the range of fertile ages using a mixture of parametric density functions. The level of fertility and the parameters describing the shape of the fertility curve are projected foward using time serie…
▽ More
This paper sets out a forecasting method that employs a mixture of parametric functions to capture the pattern of fertility with respect to age. The overall level of cohort fertility is decomposed over the range of fertile ages using a mixture of parametric density functions. The level of fertility and the parameters describing the shape of the fertility curve are projected foward using time series methods. The model is estimated within a Bayesian framework, allowing predictive distributions of future fertility rates to be produced that naturally incorporate both time series and parametric uncertainty. A number of choices are possible for the precise form of the functions used in the two-component mixtures. The performance of several model variants is tested on data from four countries; England and Wales, the USA, Sweden and France. The former two countries exhibit multi-modality in their fertility rate curves as a function of age, while the latter two are largely uni-modal. The models are estimated using Hamiltonian Monte Carlo and the `stan` software package on data covering the period up to 2006, with the period 2007-2016 held back for assessment purposes. Forecasting performance is found to be comparable to other models identified as producing accurate fertility forecasts in the literature.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Projecting UK Mortality using Bayesian Generalised Additive Models
Authors:
Jason Hilton,
Erengul Dodd,
Jonathan J. Forster,
Peter W. F. Smith
Abstract:
Forecasts of mortality provide vital information about future populations, with implications for pension and health-care policy as well as for decisions made by private companies about life insurance and annuity pricing. Stochastic mortality forecasts allow the uncertainty in mortality predictions to be taken into consideration when making policy decisions and setting product prices. Longer lifesp…
▽ More
Forecasts of mortality provide vital information about future populations, with implications for pension and health-care policy as well as for decisions made by private companies about life insurance and annuity pricing. Stochastic mortality forecasts allow the uncertainty in mortality predictions to be taken into consideration when making policy decisions and setting product prices. Longer lifespans imply that forecasts of mortality at ages 90 and above will become more important in such calculations.
This paper presents a Bayesian approach to the forecasting of mortality that jointly estimates a Generalised Additive Model (GAM) for mortality for the majority of the age-range and a parametric model for older ages where the data are sparser. The GAM allows smooth components to be estimated for age, cohort and age-specific improvement rates, together with a non-smoothed period effect. Forecasts for the United Kingdom are produced using data from the Human Mortality Database spanning the period 1961-2013. A metric that approximates predictive accuracy under Leave-One-Out cross-validation is used to estimate weights for the `stacking' of forecasts with different points of transition between the GAM and parametric elements.
Mortality for males and females are estimated separately at first, but a joint model allows the asymptotic limit of mortality at old ages to be shared between sexes, and furthermore provides for forecasts accounting for correlations in period innovations. The joint and single sex model forecasts estimated using data from 1961-2003 are compared against observed data from 2004-2013 to facilitate model assessment.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Expansion of Liquid 4He Through the Lambda Transition
Authors:
M. E. Dodd,
P. C. Hendry,
N. S. Lawson,
P. V. E. McClintock,
C. D. H. Williams
Abstract:
Zurek suggested [Nature 317 (1985) 505] that the Kibble mechanism, through which topological defects such as cosmic strings are believed to have been created in the early Universe, can also result in the formation of topological defects in liquid 4He, i.e. quantised vortices, during rapid quenches through the superfluid transition. Preliminary experiments [Hendry et al, Nature 368 (1994) 315] se…
▽ More
Zurek suggested [Nature 317 (1985) 505] that the Kibble mechanism, through which topological defects such as cosmic strings are believed to have been created in the early Universe, can also result in the formation of topological defects in liquid 4He, i.e. quantised vortices, during rapid quenches through the superfluid transition. Preliminary experiments [Hendry et al, Nature 368 (1994) 315] seemed to support this idea in that the quenches produced the predicted high vortex-densities. The present paper describes a new experiment incorporating a redesigned expansion cell that minimises vortex creation arising from conventional hydrodynamic flow. The post-quench line-densities of vorticity produced by the new cell are no more than 10^10 m^{-2}, a value that is at least two orders-of-magnitude less than the theoretical prediction. We conclude that most of the vortices detected in the original experiment must have been created through conventional flow processes.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 1998;
originally announced October 1998.
-
Non-Appearance of Vortices in Fast Mechanical Expansions of Liquid 4He Through the Lambda Transition
Authors:
M. E. Dodd,
P. C. Hendry,
N. S. Lawson,
P. V. E. McClintock,
C. D. H. Williams
Abstract:
A new experiment has been performed to study the formation of topological defects (quantized vortices) during rapid quenches of liquid 4He through the superfluid transition, with particular care taken to minimise vortex creation via conventional hydrodynamic flow processes. It is found that the generated vortices, if any, are being produced at densities at least two orders of magnitude less than…
▽ More
A new experiment has been performed to study the formation of topological defects (quantized vortices) during rapid quenches of liquid 4He through the superfluid transition, with particular care taken to minimise vortex creation via conventional hydrodynamic flow processes. It is found that the generated vortices, if any, are being produced at densities at least two orders of magnitude less than might be expected on the basis of the Kibble-Zurek mechanism.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 1998; v1 submitted 11 August, 1998;
originally announced August 1998.