-
Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Surveys: Analytic treatment of cluster detection
Authors:
James G. Bartlett
Abstract:
Thanks to advances in detector technology and observing techniques, true Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) surveys will soon become a reality. This opens up a new window into the Universe, in many ways analogous to the X-ray band and inherently well-adapted to reaching high redshifts. I discuss the nature, abundance and redshift distributions of objects detectable in ground-based searches with state-of-th…
▽ More
Thanks to advances in detector technology and observing techniques, true Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) surveys will soon become a reality. This opens up a new window into the Universe, in many ways analogous to the X-ray band and inherently well-adapted to reaching high redshifts. I discuss the nature, abundance and redshift distributions of objects detectable in ground-based searches with state-of-the-art technology. An advantage of the SZ approach is that the total SZ flux density depends only on the thermal energy of the intracluster gas and not on its spatial or temperature structure, in contrast to the X-ray luminosity. Because ground-based surveys will be characterized by arcminute angular resolution, they will resolve a large fraction of the cluster population. I quantify the resulting consequences for the cluster selection function; these include less efficient cluster detection compared to idealized point sources and corresponding steeper integrated source counts. This implies, contrary to expectations based on a point source approximation, that deep surveys are better than wide ones in terms of maximizing the number of detected objects. At a given flux density sensitivity and angular resolution, searches at millimeter wavelengths (bolometers) are more efficient than centimeter searches (radio), due to the form of the SZ spectrum. Possible ground-based surveys could discover up to $\sim 100$ clusters per square degree at a wavelength of 2 mm and $\sim 10$/sq. deg. at 1 cm, modeling clusters as a simple self-similar population.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2000;
originally announced January 2000.
-
A New Local Temperature Distribution Function for X-ray Clusters: Cosmological Applications
Authors:
A. Blanchard,
R. Sadat,
J. G. Bartlett,
M. Le Dour
Abstract:
(abridged) We present a new determination of the local temperature function of X-ray clusters. We use a new sample comprising fifty clusters for which temperature information is now available, making it the largest complete sample of its kind. It is therefore expected to significantly improve the estimation of the temperature distribution function of moderately hot clusters. We find that the res…
▽ More
(abridged) We present a new determination of the local temperature function of X-ray clusters. We use a new sample comprising fifty clusters for which temperature information is now available, making it the largest complete sample of its kind. It is therefore expected to significantly improve the estimation of the temperature distribution function of moderately hot clusters. We find that the resulting temperature function is higher than previous estimations, but agrees well with the temperature distribution function inferred from the BCS and RASS luminosity function. We have used this sample to constrain the amplitude of the matter fluctuations on cluster's scale of $8\sqrt[3]{Ω_0}^{-1}h^{-1}$Mpc, assuming a mass-temperature relation based on recent numerical simulations. We find $σ_8 = 0.6\pm 0.02$ for an $Ω_0 = 1$ model. Our sample provides an ideal reference at $z \sim 0$ to use in the application of the cosmological test based on the evolution of X-ray cluster abundance (Oukbir & Blanchard 1992, 1997). Using Henry's sample, we find that the abundance of clusters at $z = 0.33$ is significantly smaller, by a factor larger than 2, which shows that the EMSS sample provides strong evidence for evolution of the cluster abundance. A likelihood analysis leads to a rather high value of the mean density parameter of the universe: $Ω=0.92 \pm 0.22$ (open case) and $Ω=0.86 \pm 0.25$ (flat case), which is consistent with a previous, independent estimation based on the full EMSS sample by Sadat et al.(1998). Some systematic uncertainties which could alter this result are briefly discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 26 December, 2000; v1 submitted 4 August, 1999;
originally announced August 1999.
-
The Standard Cosmological Model and CMB Anisotropies
Authors:
James G. Bartlett
Abstract:
This is a course on cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropies in the standard cosmological model, designed for beginning graduate students and advanced undergraduates. ``Standard cosmological model'' in this context means a Universe dominated by some form of cold dark matter (CDM) with adiabatic perturbations generated at some initial epoch, e.g., Inflation, and left to evolve under gravity…
▽ More
This is a course on cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropies in the standard cosmological model, designed for beginning graduate students and advanced undergraduates. ``Standard cosmological model'' in this context means a Universe dominated by some form of cold dark matter (CDM) with adiabatic perturbations generated at some initial epoch, e.g., Inflation, and left to evolve under gravity alone (which distinguishes it from defect models). The course is primarily theoretical and concerned with the physics of CMB anisotropies in this context and their relation to structure formation. Brief presentations of the uniform Big Bang model and of the observed large--scale structure of the Universe are given. The bulk of the course then focuses on the evolution of small perturbations to the uniform model and on the generation of temperature anisotropies in the CMB. The theoretical development is performed in the (pseudo--)Newtonian gauge because it aids intuitive understanding by providing a quick reference to classical (Newtonian) concepts. The fundamental goal of the course is not to arrive at a highly exact nor exhaustive calculation of the anisotropies, but rather to a good understanding of the basic physics that goes into such calculations.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 1999;
originally announced March 1999.
-
An Approximation to the Likelihood Function for Band-Power Estimates of CMB Anisotropies
Authors:
J. G. Bartlett,
M. Douspis,
A. Blanchard,
M. Le Dour
Abstract:
Band-power estimates of cosmic microwave background fluctuations are now routinely used to place constraints on cosmological parameters. For this to be done in a rigorous fashion, the full likelihood function of band-power estimates must be employed. Even for Gaussian theories, this likelihood function is not itself Gaussian, for the simple reason that band-powers measure the {\em variance} of t…
▽ More
Band-power estimates of cosmic microwave background fluctuations are now routinely used to place constraints on cosmological parameters. For this to be done in a rigorous fashion, the full likelihood function of band-power estimates must be employed. Even for Gaussian theories, this likelihood function is not itself Gaussian, for the simple reason that band-powers measure the {\em variance} of the random sky fluctuations. In the context of Gaussian sky fluctuations, we use an ideal situation to motivate a general form for the full likelihood function from a given experiment. This form contains only two free parameters, which can be determined if the 68% and 95% confidence intervals of the true likelihood function are known. The ansatz works remarkably well when compared to the complete likelihood function for a number of experiments. For application of this kind of approach, we suggest that in the future both 68% and 95% (and perhaps also the 99.7%) confidence intervals be given when reporting experimental results.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2001; v1 submitted 2 March, 1999;
originally announced March 1999.
-
The ESO Slice Project (ESP) Galaxy Redshift Survey. VII. The Redshift and Real-Space Correlation Functions
Authors:
L. Guzzo,
J. G. Bartlett,
A. Cappi,
S. Maurogordato,
E. Zucca,
G. Zamorani,
C. Balkowski,
A. Blanchard,
V. Cayatte,
G. Chincarini,
C. A. Collins,
D. Maccagni,
H. MacGillivray,
R. Merighi,
M. Mignoli,
D. Proust,
M. Ramella,
R. Scaramella,
G. M. Stirpe,
G. Vettolani
Abstract:
We present analyses of the two-point correlation properties of the ESP galaxy redshift survey. From the redshift-space correlation function xi(s), we see positive clustering out to separations ~50/h Mpc, with a smooth break on larger scales and zero-crossing between 60 and 80/h Mpc. xi(s) is reasonably well described by a shallow power law with γ~1.5 between 3 and 50/h Mpc, while on smaller scal…
▽ More
We present analyses of the two-point correlation properties of the ESP galaxy redshift survey. From the redshift-space correlation function xi(s), we see positive clustering out to separations ~50/h Mpc, with a smooth break on larger scales and zero-crossing between 60 and 80/h Mpc. xi(s) is reasonably well described by a shallow power law with γ~1.5 between 3 and 50/h Mpc, while on smaller scales (0.2-2/h Mpc) it has a shallower slope (γ~ 1). We examine the full effect of redshift-space distortions through the two-dimensional correlation function xi(rp,pi), from which we project out the real-space xi(r) below 10/h Mpc. This function is well described by a power-law model (r/r_o)^{-γ}, with r_o=4.15^{+0.20}_{-0.21} h^{-1} Mpc and γ=1.67^{+0.07}_{-0.09}. Comparison to other redshift surveys shows a consistent picture in which clustering remains positive out to separations of 50/h Mpc or larger, in substantial agreement with the results obtained from angular surveys like the APM and EDSGC. Also the shape of the two-point correlation function is remarkably unanimous among these data sets, in all cases requiring more power above 5/h Mpc (a `shoulder'), than a simple extrapolation of the canonical xi(r)=(r/5)^{-1.8}. xi(s) for volume-limited subsamples shows evidence of luminosity segregation only for the most luminous sample with M_{b_J}\le -20.5. When redshift-space distortions are removed through projection of xi(rp,pi), however, a weak dependence on luminosity is seen at small separations also at fainter magnitudes. This effect is masked in redshift space, as the mean pairwise velocity dispersion experiences a parallel increase, basically erasing the effect of the clustering growth on xi(s).
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 1999;
originally announced January 1999.
-
Constraints on Cosmological Parameters from Current CMB Data
Authors:
J. G. Bartlett,
A. Blanchard,
M. Douspis,
M. Le Dour
Abstract:
We discuss the constraints one can place on cosmological parameters using current cosmic microwave background data. A standard $χ^2$--minimization over band--power estimates is first presented, followed by a discussion of the more correct likelihood approach. We propose an approximation to the complete likelihood function of an arbitrary experiment requiring only limited and easily found informa…
▽ More
We discuss the constraints one can place on cosmological parameters using current cosmic microwave background data. A standard $χ^2$--minimization over band--power estimates is first presented, followed by a discussion of the more correct likelihood approach. We propose an approximation to the complete likelihood function of an arbitrary experiment requiring only limited and easily found information about the observations. Examination of both open models -- $(Ω,h,Q,n)$ -- and flat models ($Ω+Ω_Λ=1$) -- $(Ω,Ω_b,h,Q,n)$ -- leaves one rather robust result: models with small curvature are favored.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 1998;
originally announced October 1998.
-
Approximating the Likelihood Function of CMB Experiments
Authors:
J. G. Bartlett,
A. Blanchard,
M. Douspis,
M. Le Dour
Abstract:
We discuss the problem of constraining cosmological parameters with cosmic microwave background band--power estimates. Because these latter are variances, they do not have gaussian distribution functions and, hence, the standard $χ^2$--approach is not strictly applicable. A general purpose approximation to experimental band--power likelihood functions is proposed, which requires only limited exp…
▽ More
We discuss the problem of constraining cosmological parameters with cosmic microwave background band--power estimates. Because these latter are variances, they do not have gaussian distribution functions and, hence, the standard $χ^2$--approach is not strictly applicable. A general purpose approximation to experimental band--power likelihood functions is proposed, which requires only limited experimental details. Comparison with the full likelihood function calculated for several experiments shows that the approximation works well.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 1998;
originally announced October 1998.
-
Real and Redshift-Space Clustering in the ESP Galaxy Redshift Survey
Authors:
L. Guzzo,
J. G. Bartlett,
A. Cappi
Abstract:
We discuss the two-point correlation properties of galaxies in the ESO Slice Project (ESP) redshift survey, both in redshift and real space. The redshift-space correlation function xi(s) for the whole magnitude-limited survey is well described by a power law with γ~ 1.55 between 3 and ~40/h Mpc, where it smoothly breaks down, crossing the zero value on scales as large as ~80/h Mpc. On smaller sc…
▽ More
We discuss the two-point correlation properties of galaxies in the ESO Slice Project (ESP) redshift survey, both in redshift and real space. The redshift-space correlation function xi(s) for the whole magnitude-limited survey is well described by a power law with γ~ 1.55 between 3 and ~40/h Mpc, where it smoothly breaks down, crossing the zero value on scales as large as ~80/h Mpc. On smaller scales (0.2-2/h Mpc), the slope is shallower, mostly due to redshift-space depression by virialized structures. This effect is found to be enhanced by the J3 optimal-weighting estimator for xi. We explicitly evidence these effects by computing xi(r_p,pi) and the projected function w_p(r_p). In this way we recover the real-space correlation function xi(r), which we fit below 10/h Mpc with a power-law model. This gives a reasonable fit, with r_o=4.15^{+0.20}_{-0.21} /h Mpc and γ=1.67^{+0.07}_{-0.09}. This results on xi(r) and xi(s), and the comparison with other surveys, clearly confirm how the shape of spatial correlations above ~3/h Mpc is characterised by a significant `shoulder' with respect to the small-scale ~ -1.8 power law, corresponding to a steepening of P(k) near the turnover.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 1998;
originally announced October 1998.
-
The Redshift and Real-Space Correlation Functions from the ESP Galaxy Redshift Survey
Authors:
L. Guzzo,
J. G. Bartlett,
A. Cappi
Abstract:
We discuss the behaviour of the redshift- and real-space correlation functions from the ESO Slice Project (ESP) galaxy redshift survey. xi(s) for the whole survey is positive out to ~80/h Mpc, with a smooth break from a shallow power law. Comparison to xi(s) from two other wide-angle, moderately deep surveys, the LCRS and Stromlo-APM, shows a very good agreement of all data sets, despite the dif…
▽ More
We discuss the behaviour of the redshift- and real-space correlation functions from the ESO Slice Project (ESP) galaxy redshift survey. xi(s) for the whole survey is positive out to ~80/h Mpc, with a smooth break from a shallow power law. Comparison to xi(s) from two other wide-angle, moderately deep surveys, the LCRS and Stromlo-APM, shows a very good agreement of all data sets, despite the different selections and geometries. By projecting xi(r_p, pi), we recover the real--space correlation function xi(r), which below 10/h Mpc is reasonably well described by a power law xi(r) = (r/r_o)^{-γ} with r_o=4.15^{+0.20}_{-0.21} /h Mpc and γ=1.67^{+0.07}_{-0.09}. The same analysis, applied to four volume-limited subsamples, evidences a small but significant growth of clustering with luminosity (r_o varies from 3.4 to 5.2/h Mpc when the luminosity threshold is increased from -18. to -20).
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 1998;
originally announced October 1998.
-
Galactic H alpha emission and the Cosmic Microwave Background
Authors:
M. Marcelin,
P. Amram,
J. G. Bartlett,
D. Valls-Gabaud,
A. Blanchard
Abstract:
We present observations of Galactic H alpha emission along two declination bands where the South Pole cosmic microwave background experiment reports temperature fluctuations. The high spectral resolution of our Fabry-Perot system allows us to separate the Galactic signal from the much larger local sources of H alpha emission, such as the Earth's geocorona. For the two bands (at declination -62 a…
▽ More
We present observations of Galactic H alpha emission along two declination bands where the South Pole cosmic microwave background experiment reports temperature fluctuations. The high spectral resolution of our Fabry-Perot system allows us to separate the Galactic signal from the much larger local sources of H alpha emission, such as the Earth's geocorona. For the two bands (at declination -62 and -63 degrees), we find a total mean emission of about 1 Rayleigh with variations of about 0.3 R. The variations are within the estimated uncertainty of our total intensity determinations. For an ionized gas at T around 10**4 K, this corresponds to a maximum free-free brightness temperature of less than 10 microK at 30 GHz (K-band). Thus, unless there is a hot gas component with T around 10**6 K, our results imply that there is essentially no free-free contamination of the SP91 (Schuster et al. 1993) and SP94 (Gunderson et al.1995) data sets.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 1998;
originally announced September 1998.
-
The mean density of the Universe from cluster evolution
Authors:
Alain Blanchard,
James G. Bartlett,
Rachida Sadat
Abstract:
The determination of the mean density of the Universe is a long standing problem of modern cosmology. The number density evolution of x-ray clusters at a fixed temperature is a powerful cosmological test, new in nature (Oukbir and Blanchard, 1992), somewhat different from standard analyses based on the dynamical measurement of individual objects. However, the absence of any available sample of x…
▽ More
The determination of the mean density of the Universe is a long standing problem of modern cosmology. The number density evolution of x-ray clusters at a fixed temperature is a powerful cosmological test, new in nature (Oukbir and Blanchard, 1992), somewhat different from standard analyses based on the dynamical measurement of individual objects. However, the absence of any available sample of x-ray selected clusters with measured temperatures at high redshift has prevented this test from being applied earlier. Recently, temperature measurements of ten EMSS clusters at $0.3 \le z \le 0.4$ have allowed the application of this test (Henry, 1997). In this work, we present the first results of a new analysis we have performed of this data set as well as a new estimation of the local temperature distribution function of clusters: a likelihood analysis of the temperature distribution functions gives a preferred value for the mean density of the universe which corresponds to 75% of the critical density. An open model with a density smaller than 30% of the critical density is rejected with a level of significance of 95%.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 1998;
originally announced September 1998.
-
New Territory: SZ Cluster Surveys
Authors:
J. G. Bartlett,
A. Blanchard,
D. Barbosa
Abstract:
The potential of the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect for cluster studies has long been appreciated, although not yet fully exploited. Recent technological advances and improvements in observing strategies have changed this, to the point where it is now possible to speak of this subject at a meeting devoted to {\em surveys} in Cosmology. We will discuss SZ surveys by distinguishing what may be cal…
▽ More
The potential of the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect for cluster studies has long been appreciated, although not yet fully exploited. Recent technological advances and improvements in observing strategies have changed this, to the point where it is now possible to speak of this subject at a meeting devoted to {\em surveys} in Cosmology. We will discuss SZ surveys by distinguishing what may be called {\em pointed surveys}, dedicated to pre-selected clusters, from {\em blind surveys}, those searching for clusters in blank fields. Surveys of the former type already have significant numbers of clusters with very good signal-to-noise images; surveys of the second type are currently possible, but as yet not undertaken. The discussion will focus on the kind of science that can be done in this ``new territory''.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 1998;
originally announced August 1998.
-
Galactic Free-free Emission and H$α$
Authors:
J. G. Bartlett,
P. Amram
Abstract:
We review present understanding of Galactic free-free emission and its possible importance to CMB fluctuation measurements. Current results, from both ``direct'' observations in the microwave band and from H$α$ studies, suggest that this foreground does not represent a serious obstacle to mapping the CMB; however, this is based on limited information and we emphasize the need for more exhaustive…
▽ More
We review present understanding of Galactic free-free emission and its possible importance to CMB fluctuation measurements. Current results, from both ``direct'' observations in the microwave band and from H$α$ studies, suggest that this foreground does not represent a serious obstacle to mapping the CMB; however, this is based on limited information and we emphasize the need for more exhaustive studies. We also present some preliminary results based on our recent H$α$ observations near the South Pole CMB data sets. The fluctuation amplitude seen in H$α$ indicates that the detected CMB fluctuations are not significantly contaminated by free-free emission, at least if the diffuse gas is at a temperature of $T\sim 10^4$ K.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 1998;
originally announced April 1998.
-
Constraints on Cosmological Parameters from Existing CMB Data
Authors:
J. G. Bartlett,
A. Blanchard,
M. Le Dour,
M. Douspis,
D. Barbosa
Abstract:
We use current cosmic microwave background data to constrain cosmological parameters. The results are presented as confidence regions in the ($Ω$--$H_o$) -- plane for both open and flat geometries, and are based on a $χ^2$ minimization to the power spectrum. Although such an approach does not strictly apply to power spectrum estimates, the results should nonetheless be indicative. We find that p…
▽ More
We use current cosmic microwave background data to constrain cosmological parameters. The results are presented as confidence regions in the ($Ω$--$H_o$) -- plane for both open and flat geometries, and are based on a $χ^2$ minimization to the power spectrum. Although such an approach does not strictly apply to power spectrum estimates, the results should nonetheless be indicative. We find that purely open, low--$Ω$ models are strongly disfavored, due to the position of the ``Doppler Peak'' at high $l$; flat models are less strongly constrained. The parameter space explored is the largest to date, covering $Ω$, $H_o$, $n$, $Q$ and $Ω_B h^2$.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 1998;
originally announced April 1998.
-
A Tale of Two SZ Sources
Authors:
J. G. Bartlett,
A. Blanchard,
D. Barbosa
Abstract:
The recent discovery of two flux decrements in deep radio maps obtained by the VLA and the Ryle Telescope can have powerful implications for the density parameter of the Universe, $\Omo$. We outline these implications by modeling the decrements as the thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect from two clusters assuming their properties are similar to those of the low redshift population. In this ca…
▽ More
The recent discovery of two flux decrements in deep radio maps obtained by the VLA and the Ryle Telescope can have powerful implications for the density parameter of the Universe, $\Omo$. We outline these implications by modeling the decrements as the thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect from two clusters assuming their properties are similar to those of the low redshift population. In this case, the absence of any optical or X-ray counterparts argues that the clusters must be at large redshifts. We highlight the difficulty this poses for a critical cosmology by a comparison with a fiducial open model with $\Omo=0.2$ ($\lamo=0$). Applying the phenomenological X-ray luminosity-temperature relation needed to explain the EMSS cluster redshift distribution, as inferred by Oukbir and Blanchard (1997), we convert the X-ray band upper limits to lower limits on the clusters' redshifts. Comparison of the counts implied by these two SZ detections with model predictions, for clusters with redshifts larger than these lower limits, illustrates quantitatively the inability of the critical cosmology to account for such high-redshift clusters. On the other hand, the open model with $\Omo=0.2$ remains consistent with the existence of the two objects; it possibly has, however, difficulties with current limits on spectral distortions and temperature fluctuations of the cosmic microwave background. The discussion demonstrates the value of SZ cluster searches for testing cosmological models and theories of structure formation.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 1998;
originally announced February 1998.
-
What Does Cluster Redshift Evolution Reveal ?
Authors:
A. Blanchard,
J. G. Bartlett
Abstract:
Evolution of the cluster population has been recognized as a powerful cosmological tool. While the present--day abundance of X-ray clusters is degenerate in $σ_8$, $n$ and $Ω_0$, Oukbir and Blanchard (1992, 1997) have pointed out that the number density evolution of X-ray clusters with redshift can be used to determine $Ω_0$. Here, we clarify the origin of this statement by identifying those par…
▽ More
Evolution of the cluster population has been recognized as a powerful cosmological tool. While the present--day abundance of X-ray clusters is degenerate in $σ_8$, $n$ and $Ω_0$, Oukbir and Blanchard (1992, 1997) have pointed out that the number density evolution of X-ray clusters with redshift can be used to determine $Ω_0$. Here, we clarify the origin of this statement by identifying those parameters to which the evolution of cluster number density is most sensitive. We find that the evolution is controlled by only two parameters: the amplitude of fluctuations, $σ_M$, on the scale associated with the mass under consideration, $R = 9.5h^{1/3} Ω_0^{-1/3}$ $ M_{15}^{1/3} h^{-1}$Mpc, and the cosmological background density, $Ω_0$. In contrast, evolution is remarkably insensitive to the slope of the power spectrum. We verify that the number density evolution of clusters is a powerful probe of the mean density of the universe, under the condition that $σ_M$ is chosen to reproduce current-day abundances. Comparison of the cluster abundance at $z \sim 0.5-0.6$, from the EMSS, to the present-day abundance, from the ROSAT BCS sample, unambiguously reveals the existence of significant negative evolution. This number evolution, in conjunction with the absence of any negative evolution in the luminosity-temperature relation, provides robust evidence in favor of a critical density universe ($Ω_0=1$), in agreement with the analysis by Sadat et al. (1998).
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 1998; v1 submitted 4 December, 1997;
originally announced December 1997.
-
Holes in the Microwave Sky
Authors:
J. G. Bartlett,
A. Blanchard,
D. Barbosa,
J. Oukbir
Abstract:
We discuss the implications of two possible, recent Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) detections for which no optical or X--ray counterparts have been found. This suggests that the objects reside at high redshift, which is difficult to reconcile with a critical cosmology. We develop this argument and find that an open model with $\Omo=0.2$ remains consistent with what we currently know about the two objec…
▽ More
We discuss the implications of two possible, recent Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) detections for which no optical or X--ray counterparts have been found. This suggests that the objects reside at high redshift, which is difficult to reconcile with a critical cosmology. We develop this argument and find that an open model with $\Omo=0.2$ remains consistent with what we currently know about the two objects. The reasoning also demonstrates the utility of SZ cluster searches.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 1997;
originally announced July 1997.
-
Galaxy Clusters in Cosmology: Cluster Abundance as a Probe of Structure Formation
Authors:
James G. Bartlett
Abstract:
In gaussian theories of structure formation, the galaxy cluster abundance is an extremely sensitive probe of the density fluctuation power spectrum and of the density parameter, $Ω$. We develop this theme by deriving and studying in detail the mass function of collapsed objects and its relation to these quantities. Application to current data yields constraints which are degenerate between the a…
▽ More
In gaussian theories of structure formation, the galaxy cluster abundance is an extremely sensitive probe of the density fluctuation power spectrum and of the density parameter, $Ω$. We develop this theme by deriving and studying in detail the mass function of collapsed objects and its relation to these quantities. Application to current data yields constraints which are degenerate between the amplitude of the perturbations and the density parameter; we nevertheless obtain an important limit on the present day mass perturbation amplitude as a function of $Ω$ and can rule-out the `standard' cold dark matter (CDM) model. Future observations of the evolution of the cluster abundance will break the degeneracy and provide important constraints on both the power spectrum and the density parameter, individually. We focus primarily on X-ray clusters in the discussion, and finish with a presentation of the promising new field of Sunyaev-Zel'dovich observations of cluster evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 1997; v1 submitted 13 March, 1997;
originally announced March 1997.
-
X-Ray galaxy clusters: constraints on models of galaxy formation
Authors:
J. Oukbir,
J. G. Bartlett,
A. Blanchard
Abstract:
We present a self-consistent approach to the modeling of X-ray clusters of galaxies in a flat universe. Employing the Press and Schechter (1974) formalism to derive the mass function and relating the observable properties of clusters to their virial mass allows us to study the cluster X-ray distribution functions and their evolution with redshift. This approach differs from some results based on…
▽ More
We present a self-consistent approach to the modeling of X-ray clusters of galaxies in a flat universe. Employing the Press and Schechter (1974) formalism to derive the mass function and relating the observable properties of clusters to their virial mass allows us to study the cluster X-ray distribution functions and their evolution with redshift. This approach differs from some results based on the X-ray luminosity function, which we argue is subject to modeling uncertainties. We obtain stringent constraints on the power spectrum of the initial density perturbations assumed to seed galaxy formation by comparing the theoretical temperature function with available data: the amplitude $σ_8$ is found to be $0.57 \pm 0.05$, while the local spectral index $n$ is falling in the range $-2.4 \leq n \leq -1.5$ on scales between 5 and 15 $h^{-1}$ Mpc: the standard CDM model is clearly ruled out, independently of the normalization. We further examine the evolutionary properties of X-ray clusters. Our approach greatly clarifies the situation: contrary to some previous claims, we find that flat models are in reasonable agreement with the observed number of clusters at high redshif ts. We also examine the contribution of clusters to the X-ray counts and to the soft X-ray background and compare the expected values in the case of the $Ω_0=1$ and $Ω_0=0.2$ universes. The number counts are in agreement with the observations, further confirming the relevance of our modeling. We conclude that although clusters are not the primary source of the soft X-ray background, their contribution is nevertheless non-negligible. This is particularly important for they could escape the constraints imposed on possible point sources contributing to the background. Finally, we briefly
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 1996;
originally announced November 1996.
-
Constraints on Hubble's Constant, Omega_baryon and Lambda from Cosmic Microwave Background Observations
Authors:
Charles H. Lineweaver,
Domingos Barbosa,
Alain Blanchard,
James G. Bartlett
Abstract:
In this paper we compare data to theory. We use a compilation of the most recent cosmic microwave background (CMB) measurements to constrain Hubble's constant h, the baryon fraction Omega_b, and the cosmological constant lambda. We fit h-, Omega_b- and lambda-dependent power spectra to the data. The models we consider are flat cold dark matter (CDM) dominated universes with flat (n=1) power spec…
▽ More
In this paper we compare data to theory. We use a compilation of the most recent cosmic microwave background (CMB) measurements to constrain Hubble's constant h, the baryon fraction Omega_b, and the cosmological constant lambda. We fit h-, Omega_b- and lambda-dependent power spectra to the data. The models we consider are flat cold dark matter (CDM) dominated universes with flat (n=1) power spectra, thus the results obtained apply only to these models. CMB observations can exclude more than half of the h - Omega_b parameter space explored. The CMB data favor low values of Hubble's constant; h \approx 0.35. Low values of Omega_b are preferred (Omega_b ~ 0.03) but the chi-squared minimum is shallow and we obtain Omega_b < 0.28. A model with h \approx 0.40, Omega_b \approx 0.15 and Omega_CDM \approx 0.85 is permitted by constraints from the CMB data, BBN, cluster baryon fractions and the shape parameter Gamma derived from the mass density power spectra of galaxies and clusters. For flat-lambda models, the CMB data, combined with BBN constraints exclude most of the h - lambda plane. Models with Omega_o \approx 0.3, lambda \approx 0.7 with h \approx 0.75 are fully consistent with the CMB data but are excluded by the strict new q_{o} limits from supernovae (Perlmutter et al. 1996). A combination of CMB data goodness-of-fit statistics, BBN and supernovae constraints in the h-lambda plane, limits Hubble's constant to the interval 0.23 < h < 0.72.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 1997; v1 submitted 16 October, 1996;
originally announced October 1996.
-
Cross Wavelength Comparison of Images and Catalogs
Authors:
James G. Bartlett,
Daniel Egret
Abstract:
We discuss some aspects of data management important to cross-wavelength comparison of images and catalogs. We then consider the application of statistics to the general problem of object cross-identification. Finally, two software systems developed as tools to aid the comparison of catalogs and images are briefly presented.
We discuss some aspects of data management important to cross-wavelength comparison of images and catalogs. We then consider the application of statistics to the general problem of object cross-identification. Finally, two software systems developed as tools to aid the comparison of catalogs and images are briefly presented.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 1996;
originally announced October 1996.
-
The Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect as a Probe of $Ω_{o}$
Authors:
Domingos Barbosa,
James G. Bartlett,
Alain Blanchard,
Jamila Oukbir
Abstract:
We examine how the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect of clusters can probe $Ω_{o}$. Using self-consistent models of X-ray clusters in the context of hierarchical models of structure formation, we show that both the mean Compton {\it y} parameter and the number of clusters observed via the SZ effect strongly depend on $Ω_{o}$. These quantities are higher in open cosmological models due to the earlie…
▽ More
We examine how the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect of clusters can probe $Ω_{o}$. Using self-consistent models of X-ray clusters in the context of hierarchical models of structure formation, we show that both the mean Compton {\it y} parameter and the number of clusters observed via the SZ effect strongly depend on $Ω_{o}$. These quantities are higher in open cosmological models due to the earlier epoch of structure formation. Specifically, we compare two models which are able to reproduce the present abundance of X-ray clusters, one for $Ω_{o}=0.2$ and the other $Ω= 1$. For $Ω_{o}=0.2$, ${\ymean}$ exceeds the current FIRAS limit of $1.5\times10^{-5}$. Also, the SZ redshift source distribution considerably differs in the two cosmological models. Thus, these results show that both an improvement in our knowledge of CMB spectral distortions and the realization of millimeter surveys to look for SZ sources over a large area of the sky should produce interesting constraints on $Ω_{o}$ and on the evolution of the baryonic fractionof virialized structures.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 1996;
originally announced July 1996.
-
The Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect and the Value of Omega
Authors:
D. Barbosa,
J. G. Bartlett,
A. Blanchard,
J. Oukbir
Abstract:
We consider the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect as a probe of Omega_o: Using a self-consistent modeling of X-ray clusters, we examine the dependence of both the mean Compton y parameter and the SZ source counts on Omega_o. These quantities increase with decreasing Omega_o due to the earlier epoch of structure formation in low-density cosmogonies; the results depend only on the quantity of gas hea…
▽ More
We consider the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect as a probe of Omega_o: Using a self-consistent modeling of X-ray clusters, we examine the dependence of both the mean Compton y parameter and the SZ source counts on Omega_o. These quantities increase with decreasing Omega_o due to the earlier epoch of structure formation in low-density cosmogonies; the results depend only on the quantity of gas heated to the virial temperature of collapsed objects and are independent of the spatial distribution of the gas in the potential wells. Specifically, we compare two models which reproduce the present-day abundance of clusters - a biased, critical universe and an unbiased, open model with Omega_o=0.3. We find that the mean y parameter approaches the current FIRAS limit of y<2.5 10^{-5} for the open model, demonstrating the importance of improving this limit on spectral distortions, and that the SZ source counts and corresponding redshift distribution differ significantly between the two cosmogonies; millimeter surveys covering a large area should thus provide interesting constraints on the density parameter of the Universe and on the evolution of the heated gas fraction in virialized objects.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 1995;
originally announced November 1995.
-
The Physical State of the Intergalactic Medium or Can We Measure Y?
Authors:
J. G. Bartlett,
D. Barbosa,
A. Blanchard
Abstract:
We present an argument for a {\it lower limit} to the Compton-$y$ parameter describing spectral distortions of the cosmic microwave background (CMB). The absence of a detectable Gunn-Peterson signal in the spectra of high redshift quasars demands a high ionization state of the intergalactic medium (IGM). Given an ionizing flux at the lower end of the range indicated by the proximity effect, an I…
▽ More
We present an argument for a {\it lower limit} to the Compton-$y$ parameter describing spectral distortions of the cosmic microwave background (CMB). The absence of a detectable Gunn-Peterson signal in the spectra of high redshift quasars demands a high ionization state of the intergalactic medium (IGM). Given an ionizing flux at the lower end of the range indicated by the proximity effect, an IGM representing a significant fraction of the nucleosynthesis-predicted baryon density must be heated by sources other than the photon flux to a temperature $\go {\rm few} \times 10^5\, K$. Such a gas at the redshift of the highest observed quasars, $z\sim 5$, will produce a $y\go 10^{-6}$. This lower limit on $y$ rises if the Universe is open, if there is a cosmological constant, or if one adopts an IGM with a density larger than the prediction of standard Big Bang nucleosynthesis.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 1995;
originally announced June 1995.
-
The Significance of the Cosmic Virial Theorem
Authors:
James G. Bartlett,
Alain Blanchard
Abstract:
We discuss the development and physics of the cosmic virial theorem and its traditional application as an indicator of the cosmic mean density. The standard result that the density must be sub-critical relies on the assumption that the galaxy three-point correlation function accurately describes the mass distribution around a typical pair of galaxies. To challenge this assumption, we develop a s…
▽ More
We discuss the development and physics of the cosmic virial theorem and its traditional application as an indicator of the cosmic mean density. The standard result that the density must be sub-critical relies on the assumption that the galaxy three-point correlation function accurately describes the mass distribution around a typical pair of galaxies. To challenge this assumption, we develop a simple model of this mass distribution based on the extension of galactic halos. In such a model, one sees clearly the importance of the local mass distribution around pairs to the prediction of the galaxy pair-wise velocity dispersion. The model provides insight into the mechanics of the theorem and demonstrates that a flat universe is {\it consistent} with the observations. More generally, we conclude that the relative pair-wise velocity dispersion probes the mass clustered around galaxies and that the observations, viewed in this light, indicate a lower bound of $\sim 300\; h^{-1}$kpc on the radius of galactic halos.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 1995;
originally announced June 1995.
-
The Case for a Hubble Constant of 30 km/s/Mpc
Authors:
J. G. Bartlett,
A. Blanchard,
J. Silk,
M. S. Turner
Abstract:
Although cosmologists have been trying to determine the value of the Hubble constant for nearly 65 years, they have only succeeded in limiting the range of possibilities: most of the current observational determinations place the Hubble constant between 50 km/s/Mpc and 90 km/s/Mpc. The uncertainty is unfortunate because this fundamental parameter of cosmology determines both the distance scale a…
▽ More
Although cosmologists have been trying to determine the value of the Hubble constant for nearly 65 years, they have only succeeded in limiting the range of possibilities: most of the current observational determinations place the Hubble constant between 50 km/s/Mpc and 90 km/s/Mpc. The uncertainty is unfortunate because this fundamental parameter of cosmology determines both the distance scale and the time scale, and thereby affects almost all aspects of cosmology. Here we make the case for a Hubble constant that is even smaller than the lower bound of the accepted range, arguing on the basis of the great advantages, all theoretical in nature, of a Hubble constant of around 30 km/s/Mpc. Those advantages are: (1) a comfortable expansion age that avoids the current age crisis; (2) a cold dark matter power spectrum whose shape is in good agreement with the observational data and (3) which predicts an abundance of clusters in close agreement with that of x-ray selected galaxy clusters; (4) a nonbaryonic to baryonic mass ratio that is in better agreement with recent determinations based upon cluster x-ray studies. In short, such a value for the Hubble constant cures almost all the ills of the current theoretical orthodoxy, a flat Universe comprised predominantly of cold dark matter.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 1994;
originally announced July 1994.
