-
Fast as Potoroo: Radio Continuum Detection of a Bow-Shock Pulsar Wind Nebula Powered by Pulsar J1638-4713
Authors:
Sanja Lazarević,
Miroslav D. Filipović,
Shi Dai,
Roland Kothes,
Adeel Ahmad,
Rami Z. E. Alsaberi,
Joel C. F. Balzan,
Luke A. Barnes,
William D. Cotton,
Philip G. Edwards,
Yjan A. Gordon,
Frank Haberl,
Andrew M. Hopkins,
Bärbel S. Koribalski,
Denis Leahy,
Chandreyee Maitra,
Marko Mićić,
Gavin Rowell,
Manami Sasaki,
Nicholas F. H. Tothill,
Grazia Umana,
Velibor Velović
Abstract:
We report the discovery of a bow-shock pulsar wind nebula (PWN), named Potoroo, and the detection of a young pulsar J1638-4713 that powers the nebula. We present a radio continuum study of the PWN based on 20-cm observations obtained from the Australian Square Kilometre Array Pathfinder (ASKAP) and MeerKAT. PSR J1638-4713 was identified using Parkes radio telescope observations at frequencies abov…
▽ More
We report the discovery of a bow-shock pulsar wind nebula (PWN), named Potoroo, and the detection of a young pulsar J1638-4713 that powers the nebula. We present a radio continuum study of the PWN based on 20-cm observations obtained from the Australian Square Kilometre Array Pathfinder (ASKAP) and MeerKAT. PSR J1638-4713 was identified using Parkes radio telescope observations at frequencies above 3 GHz. The pulsar has the second-highest dispersion measure of all known radio pulsars (1553 pc/cm^3), a spin period of 65.74 ms and a spin-down luminosity of 6.1x10^36 erg/s. The PWN has a cometary morphology and one of the greatest projected lengths among all the observed pulsar radio tails, measuring over 21 pc for an assumed distance of 10 kpc. The remarkably long tail and atypically steep radio spectral index are attributed to the interplay of a supernova reverse shock and the PWN. The originating supernova remnant is not known so far. We estimated the pulsar kick velocity to be in the range of 1000-2000 km/s for ages between 23 and 10 kyr. The X-ray counterpart found in Chandra data, CXOU J163802.6-471358, shows the same tail morphology as the radio source but is shorter by a factor of 10. The peak of the X-ray emission is offset from the peak of the radio total intensity (Stokes I) emission by approximately 4.7", but coincides well with circularly polarised (Stokes V) emission. No infrared counterpart was found.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2024; v1 submitted 11 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
MeerKAT view of the Dancing Ghosts -- Peculiar Galaxy Pair PKS 2130-538 in Abell 3785
Authors:
Velibor Velović,
William D. Cotton,
Miroslav D. Filipovi'c,
Ray P. Norris,
Luke A. Barnes,
James J. Condon
Abstract:
We present MeerKAT L-band (886-1682 MHz) observations of the extended radio structure of the peculiar galaxy pair PKS 2130-538 known as the "Dancing Ghosts". The complex of bending and possibly interacting jets and lobes originate from two Active Galactic Nuclei hosts in the Abell 3785 galaxy cluster, one of which is the brightest cluster galaxy. The radio properties of the PKS 2130-538 flux densi…
▽ More
We present MeerKAT L-band (886-1682 MHz) observations of the extended radio structure of the peculiar galaxy pair PKS 2130-538 known as the "Dancing Ghosts". The complex of bending and possibly interacting jets and lobes originate from two Active Galactic Nuclei hosts in the Abell 3785 galaxy cluster, one of which is the brightest cluster galaxy. The radio properties of the PKS 2130-538 flux density, spectral index and polarization - are typical for large, bent-tail galaxies. We also investigate a number of thin extended low surface brightness filaments originating from the lobes. Southeast from the Dancing Ghosts, we detect a region of low surface brightness emission that has no clear origin. While it could originate from the Abell 3785 radio halo, we investigate the possibility that it is a radio relic or emission associated with the two PKS 2130-538 hosts. We find no evidence of interaction between the two PKS 2130-538 hosts.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
On Cosmological Low Entropy After the Big Bang: Universal Expansion and Nucleosynthesis
Authors:
Charlie F. Sharpe,
Luke A. Barnes,
Geraint F. Lewis
Abstract:
We investigate the sensitivity of a universe's nuclear entropy after Big Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) to variations in both the baryon-to-photon ratio and the temporal evolution of cosmological expansion. Specifically, we construct counterfactual cosmologies to quantify the degree by which these two parameters must vary from those in our Universe before we observe a substantial change in the degree…
▽ More
We investigate the sensitivity of a universe's nuclear entropy after Big Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) to variations in both the baryon-to-photon ratio and the temporal evolution of cosmological expansion. Specifically, we construct counterfactual cosmologies to quantify the degree by which these two parameters must vary from those in our Universe before we observe a substantial change in the degree of fusion, and thus nuclear entropy, during BBN. We find that, while the post-BBN nuclear entropy is indeed linked to baryogenesis and the Universe's expansion history, the requirement of leftover light elements does not place strong constraints on the properties of these two cosmological processes.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
A Search for Missing Radio Sources at $z\gtrsim4$ Using Lyman Dropouts
Authors:
Devika Shobhana,
Ray P. Norris,
Miroslav D. Filipović,
Luke A. Barnes,
Andrew M. Hopkins,
Isabella Prandoni,
Michael J. I. Brown,
Stanislav S. Shabala
Abstract:
Using the Lyman Dropout technique, we identify 148 candidate radio sources at $z \gtrsim 4 - 7$ from the 887.5 MHz Australian Square Kilometer Array Pathfinder (ASKAP) observations of the GAMA23 field. About 112 radio sources are currently known beyond redshift $z\sim4$. However, simulations predict that hundreds of thousands of radio sources exist in that redshift range, many of which are probabl…
▽ More
Using the Lyman Dropout technique, we identify 148 candidate radio sources at $z \gtrsim 4 - 7$ from the 887.5 MHz Australian Square Kilometer Array Pathfinder (ASKAP) observations of the GAMA23 field. About 112 radio sources are currently known beyond redshift $z\sim4$. However, simulations predict that hundreds of thousands of radio sources exist in that redshift range, many of which are probably in existing radio catalogues but do not have measured redshifts, either because their optical emission is too faint or because of the lack of techniques that can identify candidate high-redshift radio sources (HzRSs). Our study addresses these issues using the Lyman Dropout search technique. This newly built sample probes radio luminosities that are 1-2 orders of magnitude fainter than known radio-active galactic nuclei (AGN) at similar redshifts, thanks to ASKAP's sensitivity. We investigate the physical origin of radio emission in our sample using a set of diagnostics: (i) radio luminosity at 1.4 GHz, (ii) 1.4 GHz-to-3.4 $μ$m flux density ratio, (iii) Far-IR detection, (iv) WISE colour, and (v) SED modelling. The radio/IR analysis has shown that the majority of radio emission in the faint and bright end of our sample's 887.5 MHz flux density distribution originates from AGN activity. Furthermore, $\sim10\%$ of our sample are found to have a 250 $μ$m detection, suggesting a composite system. This suggests that some high-$z$ radio-AGNs are hosted by SB galaxies, in contrast to low-$z$ radio-AGNs, which are usually hosted by quiescent elliptical galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
New ASKAP Radio Supernova Remnants and Candidates in the Large Magellanic Cloud
Authors:
Luke M. Bozzetto,
Miroslav D. Filipović,
H. Sano,
R. Z. E. Alsaberi,
L. A. Barnes,
I. S. Bojičić,
R. Brose,
L. Chomiuk,
E. J. Crawford,
S. Dai,
M. Ghavam,
F. Haberl,
T. Hill,
A. M. Hopkins,
A. Ingallinera,
T. Jarrett,
P. J. Kavanagh,
B. S. Koribalski,
R. Kothes,
D. Leahy,
E. Lenc,
I. Leonidaki,
P. Maggi,
C. Maitra,
C. Matthew
, et al. (12 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present a new Australian Square Kilometre Array Pathfinder (ASKAP) sample of 14 radio Supernova Remnant (SNR) candidates in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC). This new sample is a significant increase to the known number of older, larger and low surface brightness LMC SNRs. We employ a multi-frequency search for each object and found possible traces of optical and occasionally X-ray emission in…
▽ More
We present a new Australian Square Kilometre Array Pathfinder (ASKAP) sample of 14 radio Supernova Remnant (SNR) candidates in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC). This new sample is a significant increase to the known number of older, larger and low surface brightness LMC SNRs. We employ a multi-frequency search for each object and found possible traces of optical and occasionally X-ray emission in several of these 14 SNR candidates. One of these 14 SNR candidates (MCSNR J0522-6543) has multi-frequency properties that strongly indicate a bona fide SNR. We also investigate a sample of 20 previously suggested LMC SNR candidates and confirm the SNR nature of MCSNR J0506-6815. We detect lower surface brightness SNR candidates which were likely formed by a combination of shock waves and strong stellar winds from massive progenitors (and possibly surrounding OB stars). Some of our new SNR candidates are also found in a lower density environments in which SNe type Ia explode inside a previously excavated interstellar medium (ISM).
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2022; v1 submitted 10 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
The Fine-Tuning of the Universe for Life
Authors:
Luke A. Barnes
Abstract:
When a physicist says that a theory is fine-tuned, they mean that it must make a suspiciously precise assumption in order to explain a certain observation. This is evidence that the theory is deficient or incomplete. One particular case of fine-tuning is particularly striking. The data in question are not the precise measurements of cosmology or particle physics, but a more general feature of our…
▽ More
When a physicist says that a theory is fine-tuned, they mean that it must make a suspiciously precise assumption in order to explain a certain observation. This is evidence that the theory is deficient or incomplete. One particular case of fine-tuning is particularly striking. The data in question are not the precise measurements of cosmology or particle physics, but a more general feature of our universe: it supports the existence of life. This chapter reviews this Fine-Tuning of the Universe for Life.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Big Bang Nucleosynthesis Initial Conditions: Revisiting Wagoner et al. (1967)
Authors:
Charlie Sharpe,
Geraint F. Lewis,
Luke A. Barnes
Abstract:
We revisit Wagoner et al. (1967), a classic contribution in the development of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis. We demonstrate that it presents an incorrect expression for the temperature of the early universe as a function of time in the high temperature limit, $T \gtrsim 10^{10}$K. As this incorrect expression has been reproduced elsewhere, we present a corrected form for the initial conditions require…
▽ More
We revisit Wagoner et al. (1967), a classic contribution in the development of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis. We demonstrate that it presents an incorrect expression for the temperature of the early universe as a function of time in the high temperature limit, $T \gtrsim 10^{10}$K. As this incorrect expression has been reproduced elsewhere, we present a corrected form for the initial conditions required for calculating the formation of the primordial elements in the Big Bang.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
The Trouble with "Puddle Thinking": A User's Guide to the Anthropic Principle
Authors:
Geraint F. Lewis,
Luke A. Barnes
Abstract:
Are some cosmologists trying to return human beings to the centre of the cosmos? In the view of some critics, the so-called "anthropic principle" is a desperate attempt to salvage a scrap of dignity for our species after a few centuries of demotion at the hands of science. It is all things archaic and backwards - teleology, theology, religion, anthropocentrism - trying to sneak back in scientific…
▽ More
Are some cosmologists trying to return human beings to the centre of the cosmos? In the view of some critics, the so-called "anthropic principle" is a desperate attempt to salvage a scrap of dignity for our species after a few centuries of demotion at the hands of science. It is all things archaic and backwards - teleology, theology, religion, anthropocentrism - trying to sneak back in scientific camouflage. We argue that this is a mistake. The anthropic principle is not mere human arrogance, nor is it religion in disguise. It is a necessary part of the science of the universe.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
The One-Way Speed of Light and the Milne Universe
Authors:
Geraint F. Lewis,
Luke A. Barnes
Abstract:
In Einstein's Special Theory of Relativity, all observers measure the speed of light, $c$, to be the same. However, this refers to the round trip speed, where a clock at the origin times the outward and return trip of light reflecting off a distant mirror. Measuring the one-way speed of light is fraught with issues of clock synchronisation, and, as long as the average speed of light remains $c$, t…
▽ More
In Einstein's Special Theory of Relativity, all observers measure the speed of light, $c$, to be the same. However, this refers to the round trip speed, where a clock at the origin times the outward and return trip of light reflecting off a distant mirror. Measuring the one-way speed of light is fraught with issues of clock synchronisation, and, as long as the average speed of light remains $c$, the speeds on the outward and return legs could be different. One objection to this anisotropic speed of light is that views of the distant universe would be different in different directions, especially with regards to the ages of observed objects and the smoothness of the Cosmic Microwave Background. In this paper, we explore this in the Milne universe, the limiting case of a Friedmann-Robertson-Walker universe containing no matter, radiation or dark energy. Given that this universe is empty, it can be mapped onto flat Minkowski space-time, and so can be explored in terms of the one-way speed of light. The conclusion is that the presence of an anisotropic speed of light leads to anisotropic time dilation effects, and hence observers in the Milne universe would be presented with an isotropic view of the distant cosmos.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Under an Iron Sky: On the Entropy at the Start of the Universe
Authors:
Luke A. Barnes,
Geraint F. Lewis
Abstract:
Curiously, our Universe was born in a low entropy state, with abundant free energy to power stars and life. The form that this free energy takes is usually thought to be gravitational: the Universe is almost perfectly smooth, and so can produce sources of energy as matter collapses under gravity. It has recently been argued that a more important source of low-entropy energy is nuclear: the Univers…
▽ More
Curiously, our Universe was born in a low entropy state, with abundant free energy to power stars and life. The form that this free energy takes is usually thought to be gravitational: the Universe is almost perfectly smooth, and so can produce sources of energy as matter collapses under gravity. It has recently been argued that a more important source of low-entropy energy is nuclear: the Universe expands too fast to remain in nuclear statistical equilibrium (NSE), effectively shutting off nucleosynthesis in the first few minutes, providing leftover hydrogen as fuel for stars. Here, we fill in the astrophysical details of this scenario, and seek the conditions under which a Universe will emerge from early nucleosynthesis as almost-purely iron. In so doing, we identify a hitherto-overlooked character in the story of the origin of the second law: matter-antimatter asymmetry.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2021; v1 submitted 13 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Radio Emission from Interstellar Shocks: Young Type Ia Supernova Remnants and the Case of N 103B in the Large Magellanic Cloud
Authors:
R. Z. E. Alsaberi,
L. A. Barnes,
M. D. Filipovic,
N. I. Maxted,
H. Sano,
G. Rowell,
L. M. Bozzetto,
S. Gurovich,
D. Urovsevic,
D. Onic,
B. Q. For,
P. Manojlovic,
G. Wong,
T. Galvin,
P. Kavanagh,
N. Ralph,
E. J. Crawford,
M. Sasaki,
F. Haberl,
P. Maggi,
N. F. H. Tothil,
Y. Fukui
Abstract:
Here we present a radio continuum study based on new and archival data from the Australia Telescope Compact Array towards N 103B, a young (<=1000 yrs) spectroscopically confirmed type Ia SNR in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) and proposed to have originated from a single degenerate progenitor. The radio morphology of this SNR is asymmetrical with two bright regions towards the north-west and sout…
▽ More
Here we present a radio continuum study based on new and archival data from the Australia Telescope Compact Array towards N 103B, a young (<=1000 yrs) spectroscopically confirmed type Ia SNR in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) and proposed to have originated from a single degenerate progenitor. The radio morphology of this SNR is asymmetrical with two bright regions towards the north-west and south-west of the central location as defined by radio emission.
N 103B identified features include: a radio spectral index of -0.75+-0.01 (consistent with other young type Ia SNRs in the Galaxy); a bulk SNR expansion rate as in X-rays; morphology and polarised electrical field vector measurements where we note radial polarisation peak towards the north-west of the remnant at both 5500 and 9000 MHz. The spectrum is concave-up and the most likely reason is the non-linear diffusive shock acceleration effects or presence of two different populations of ultra-relativistic electrons.
We also note unpolarized clumps near the south-west region which is in agreement with this above scenario. We derive a typical magnetic field strength for N 103B, of 16.4 microG for an average rotation measurement of 200 rad m^-2. However, we estimate the equipartition field to be of the order of ~235 microG with an estimated minimum energy of Emin=6.3*10^48 erg. The close (~0.5 degree) proximity of N 103B to the LMC mid-plane indicates that an early encounter with dense interstellar medium may have set an important constrain on SNR evolution.
Finally, we compare features of N 103B, to six other young type Ia SNRs in the LMC and Galaxy, with a range of proposed degeneracy scenarios to highlight potential differences due to a different models. We suggest that the single degenerate scenario might point to morphologically asymmetric type Ia supernova explosions.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
The ASKAP-EMU Early Science Project:Radio Continuum Survey of the Small Magellanic Cloud
Authors:
T. D. Joseph,
M. D. Filipović,
E. J. Crawford,
I. Bojičić,
E. L. Alexander,
G. F. Wong,
H. Andernach,
H. Leverenz,
R. P. Norris,
R. Z. E. Alsaberi,
C. Anderson,
L. A. Barnes,
L. M. Bozzetto,
F. Bufano,
J. D. Bunton,
F. Cavallaro,
J. D. Collier,
H. Dénes,
Y. Fukui,
T. Galvin,
F. Haberl,
A. Ingallinera,
A. D. Kapinska,
B. S. Koribalski,
R. Kothes
, et al. (31 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present two new radio continuum images from the Australian Square Kilometre Array Pathfinder (ASKAP) survey in the direction of the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC). These images are part of the Evolutionary Map of the Universe (EMU) Early Science Project (ESP) survey of the Small and Large Magellanic Clouds. The two new source lists produced from these images contain radio continuum sources observ…
▽ More
We present two new radio continuum images from the Australian Square Kilometre Array Pathfinder (ASKAP) survey in the direction of the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC). These images are part of the Evolutionary Map of the Universe (EMU) Early Science Project (ESP) survey of the Small and Large Magellanic Clouds. The two new source lists produced from these images contain radio continuum sources observed at 960 MHz (4489 sources) and 1320 MHz (5954 sources) with a bandwidth of 192 MHz and beam sizes of 30.0"x30.0" and 16.3"x15.1", respectively. The median Root Mean Squared (RMS) noise values are 186$μ$Jy beam$^{-1}$ (960 MHz) and 165$μ$Jy beam$^{-1}$ (1320 MHz). To create point source catalogues, we use these two source lists, together with the previously published Molonglo Observatory Synthesis Telescope (MOST) and the Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA) point source catalogues to estimate spectral indices for the whole population of radio point sources found in the survey region. Combining our ASKAP catalogues with these radio continuum surveys, we found 7736 point-like sources in common over an area of 30 deg$^2$. In addition, we report the detection of two new, low surface brightness supernova remnant candidates in the SMC. The high sensitivity of the new ASKAP ESP survey also enabled us to detect the bright end of the SMC planetary nebula sample, with 22 out of 102 optically known planetary nebulae showing point-like radio continuum emission. Lastly, we present several morphologically interesting background radio galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Galaxy Formation Efficiency and the Multiverse Explanation of the Cosmological Constant with EAGLE Simulations
Authors:
Luke A. Barnes,
Pascal J. Elahi,
Jaime Salcido,
Richard G. Bower,
Geraint F. Lewis,
Tom Theuns,
Matthieu Schaller,
Robert A. Crain,
Joop Schaye
Abstract:
Models of the very early universe, including inflationary models, are argued to produce varying universe domains with different values of fundamental constants and cosmic parameters. Using the cosmological hydrodynamical simulation code from the eagle collaboration, we investigate the effect of the cosmological constant on the formation of galaxies and stars. We simulate universes with values of t…
▽ More
Models of the very early universe, including inflationary models, are argued to produce varying universe domains with different values of fundamental constants and cosmic parameters. Using the cosmological hydrodynamical simulation code from the eagle collaboration, we investigate the effect of the cosmological constant on the formation of galaxies and stars. We simulate universes with values of the cosmological constant ranging from Lambda = 0 to Lambda_0 = 300, where Lambda_0 is the value of the cosmological constant in our Universe. Because the global star formation rate in our Universe peaks at t = 3.5 Gyr, before the onset of accelerating expansion, increases in Lambda of even an order of magnitude have only a small effect on the star formation history and efficiency of the universe. We use our simulations to predict the observed value of the cosmological constant, given a measure of the multiverse. Whether the cosmological constant is successfully predicted depends crucially on the measure. The impact of the cosmological constant on the formation of structure in the universe does not seem to be a sharp enough function of Lambda to explain its observed value alone.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2018; v1 submitted 26 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Bell's Spaceships: The Views from Bow and Stern
Authors:
Geraint F. Lewis,
Luke A. Barnes,
Martin J. Sticka
Abstract:
Unravelling apparent paradoxes has proven to be a powerful tool for understanding the complexities of special relativity. In this paper, we focus upon one such paradox, namely Bell's spaceship paradox, examining the relative motion of two uniformly accelerating spaceships. We consider the view from either spaceship, with the exchange of photons between the two. This recovers the well known result…
▽ More
Unravelling apparent paradoxes has proven to be a powerful tool for understanding the complexities of special relativity. In this paper, we focus upon one such paradox, namely Bell's spaceship paradox, examining the relative motion of two uniformly accelerating spaceships. We consider the view from either spaceship, with the exchange of photons between the two. This recovers the well known result that the leading spaceship loses sight of the trailing spaceship as it is redshifted and disappears behind what is known as the `Rindler horizon'. An immediate impact of this is that if either spaceship tries to measure the separation through `radar ranging', bouncing photons off one another, they would both eventually fail to receive any of the photon `pings' that they emit. We find that the view from this trailing spaceship is, however, starkly different, initially, seeing the leading spaceship with an increasing blueshift, followed by a decreasing blueshift. We conclude that, while the leading spaceship loses sight of the trailing spaceship, for the trailing spaceship the view of the separation between the two spaceships, and the apparent angular size of the leading spaceship, approach asymptotic values. Intriguingly, for particular parametrization of the journey of the two spaceships, these asymptotic values are identical to those properties seen before the spaceships began accelerating, and the view from the trailing spaceship becomes identical to when the two spaceships were initially at rest.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
The impact of dark energy on galaxy formation. What does the future of our Universe hold?
Authors:
Jaime Salcido,
Richard G. Bower,
Luke A. Barnes,
Geraint F. Lewis,
Pascal J. Elahi,
Tom Theuns,
Matthieu Schaller,
Robert A. Crain,
Joop Schaye
Abstract:
We investigate the effect of the accelerated expansion of the Universe due to a cosmological constant, $Λ$, on the cosmic star formation rate. We utilise hydrodynamical simulations from the EAGLE suite, comparing a $Λ$CDM Universe to an Einstein-de Sitter model with $Λ=0$. Despite the differences in the rate of growth of structure, we find that dark energy, at its observed value, has negligible im…
▽ More
We investigate the effect of the accelerated expansion of the Universe due to a cosmological constant, $Λ$, on the cosmic star formation rate. We utilise hydrodynamical simulations from the EAGLE suite, comparing a $Λ$CDM Universe to an Einstein-de Sitter model with $Λ=0$. Despite the differences in the rate of growth of structure, we find that dark energy, at its observed value, has negligible impact on star formation in the Universe. We study these effects beyond the present day by allowing the simulations to run forward into the future ($t>13.8$ Gyr). We show that the impact of $Λ$ becomes significant only when the Universe has already produced most of its stellar mass, only decreasing the total co-moving density of stars ever formed by ${\approx}15\%$. We develop a simple analytic model for the cosmic star formation rate that captures the suppression due to a cosmological constant. The main reason for the similarity between the models is that feedback from accreting black holes dramatically reduces the cosmic star formation at late times. Interestingly, simulations without feedback from accreting black holes predict an upturn in the cosmic star formation rate for $t>15$ Gyr due to the rejuvenation of massive ($ > 10^{11} \mathrm{M}_{\odot}$) galaxies. We briefly discuss the implication of the weak dependence of the cosmic star formation on $Λ$ in the context of the anthropic principle.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2018; v1 submitted 18 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Fine-Tuning in the Context of Bayesian Theory Testing
Authors:
Luke A. Barnes
Abstract:
Fine-tuning in physics and cosmology is often used as evidence that a theory is incomplete. For example, the parameters of the standard model of particle physics are "unnaturally" small (in various technical senses), which has driven much of the search for physics beyond the standard model. Of particular interest is the fine-tuning of the universe for life, which suggests that our universe's abili…
▽ More
Fine-tuning in physics and cosmology is often used as evidence that a theory is incomplete. For example, the parameters of the standard model of particle physics are "unnaturally" small (in various technical senses), which has driven much of the search for physics beyond the standard model. Of particular interest is the fine-tuning of the universe for life, which suggests that our universe's ability to create physical life forms is improbable and in need of explanation, perhaps by a multiverse. This claim has been challenged on the grounds that the relevant probability measure cannot be justified because it cannot be normalized, and so small probabilities cannot be inferred. We show how fine-tuning can be formulated within the context of Bayesian theory testing (or \emph{model selection}) in the physical sciences. The normalizability problem is seen to be a general problem for testing any theory with free parameters, and not a unique problem for fine-tuning. Physical theories in fact avoid such problems in one of two ways. Dimensional parameters are bounded by the Planck scale, avoiding troublesome infinities, and we are not compelled to assume that dimensionless parameters are distributed uniformly, which avoids non-normalizability.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Testing the Multiverse: Bayes, Fine-Tuning and Typicality
Authors:
Luke A. Barnes
Abstract:
Theory testing in the physical sciences has been revolutionized in recent decades by Bayesian approaches to probability theory. Here, I will consider Bayesian approaches to theory extensions, that is, theories like inflation which aim to provide a deeper explanation for some aspect of our models (in this case, the standard model of cosmology) that seem unnatural or fine-tuned. In particular, I wil…
▽ More
Theory testing in the physical sciences has been revolutionized in recent decades by Bayesian approaches to probability theory. Here, I will consider Bayesian approaches to theory extensions, that is, theories like inflation which aim to provide a deeper explanation for some aspect of our models (in this case, the standard model of cosmology) that seem unnatural or fine-tuned. In particular, I will consider how cosmologists can test the multiverse using observations of this universe.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Producing the Deuteron in Stars: Anthropic Limits on Fundamental Constants
Authors:
Luke A. Barnes,
Geraint F. Lewis
Abstract:
Stellar nucleosynthesis proceeds via the deuteron (D), but only a small change in the fundamental constants of nature is required to unbind it. Here, we investigate the effect of altering the binding energy of the deuteron on proton burning in stars. We find that the most definitive boundary in parameter space that divides probably life-permitting universes from probably life-prohibiting ones is b…
▽ More
Stellar nucleosynthesis proceeds via the deuteron (D), but only a small change in the fundamental constants of nature is required to unbind it. Here, we investigate the effect of altering the binding energy of the deuteron on proton burning in stars. We find that the most definitive boundary in parameter space that divides probably life-permitting universes from probably life-prohibiting ones is between a bound and unbound deuteron. Due to neutrino losses, a ball of gas will undergo rapid cooling or stabilization by electron degeneracy pressure before it can form a stable, nuclear reaction-sustaining star. We also consider a less-bound deuteron, which changes the energetics of the $pp$ and $pep$ reactions. The transition to endothermic $pp$ and $pep$ reactions, and the resulting beta-decay instability of the deuteron, do not seem to present catastrophic problems for life.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2017; v1 submitted 21 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Primordial Nucleosynthesis in the Rh = ct cosmology: Pouring cold water on the Simmering Universe
Authors:
Geraint F. Lewis,
Luke A. Barnes,
Rajesh Kaushik
Abstract:
Primordial nucleosynthesis is rightly hailed as one of the great successes of the standard cosmological model. Here we consider the initial forging of elements in the recently proposed Rh = ct universe, a cosmology that demands linear evolution of the scale factor. Such a universe cools extremely slowly compared to standard cosmologies, considerably depleting the available neutrons during nucleosy…
▽ More
Primordial nucleosynthesis is rightly hailed as one of the great successes of the standard cosmological model. Here we consider the initial forging of elements in the recently proposed Rh = ct universe, a cosmology that demands linear evolution of the scale factor. Such a universe cools extremely slowly compared to standard cosmologies, considerably depleting the available neutrons during nucleosynthesis; this has significant implications for the resultant primordial abundances of elements, predicting a minuscule quantity of helium which is profoundly at odds with observations. The production of helium can be enhanced in such a "simmering universe" by boosting the baryon to photon ratio, although more than an order of magnitude increase is required to bring the helium mass fraction into accordance with observations. However, in this scenario, the prolonged period of nucleosynthesis results of the efficient cooking of lighter into heavier elements, impacting the resultant abundances of all elements so that, other than hydrogen and helium, there are virtually no light elements present in the universe. Without the addition of substantial new physics in the early universe, it is difficult to see how the Rh = ct universe can be considered a viable cosmological model.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Binding the Diproton in Stars: Anthropic Limits on the Strength of Gravity
Authors:
Luke A. Barnes
Abstract:
We calculate the properties and investigate the stability of stars that burn via strong (and electromagnetic) interactions, and compare their properties with those that, as in our Universe, include a rate-limiting weak interaction. It has been suggested that, if the diproton were bound, stars would burn ~10^{18} times brighter and faster via strong interactions, resulting in a universe that would…
▽ More
We calculate the properties and investigate the stability of stars that burn via strong (and electromagnetic) interactions, and compare their properties with those that, as in our Universe, include a rate-limiting weak interaction. It has been suggested that, if the diproton were bound, stars would burn ~10^{18} times brighter and faster via strong interactions, resulting in a universe that would fail to support life. By considering the representative case of a star in our Universe with initially equal numbers of protons and deuterons, we find that stable, "strong-burning" stars adjust their central densities and temperatures to have familiar surface temperatures, luminosities and lifetimes. There is no "diproton disaster". In addition, strong-burning stars are stable in a much larger region of the parameter space of fundamental constants, specifically the strength of electromagnetism and gravity. The strongest anthropic bound on stars in such universes is not their stability, as is the case for stars limited by the weak interaction, but rather their lifetime. Regardless of the strength of electromagnetism, all stars burn out in mere millions of years unless the gravitational coupling constant is extremely small, α_G < 10^{-30}.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Lyman Alpha and MgII as Probes of Galaxies and their Environments
Authors:
Luke A. Barnes,
Thibault Garel,
Glenn G. Kacprzak
Abstract:
Lyα emission, Lyα absorption and MgII absorption are powerful tracers of neutral hydrogen. Hydrogen is the most abundant element in the universe and plays a central role in galaxy formation via gas accretion and outflows, as well as being the precursor to molecular clouds, the sites of star formation. Since 21cm emission from neutral hydrogen can only be directly observed in the local universe, we…
▽ More
Lyα emission, Lyα absorption and MgII absorption are powerful tracers of neutral hydrogen. Hydrogen is the most abundant element in the universe and plays a central role in galaxy formation via gas accretion and outflows, as well as being the precursor to molecular clouds, the sites of star formation. Since 21cm emission from neutral hydrogen can only be directly observed in the local universe, we rely on Lyα emission, and Lyα and MgII absorption to probe the physics that drives galaxy evolution at higher redshifts. Furthermore, these tracers are sensitive to a range of hydrogen densities that cover the interstellar medium, the circumgalactic medium and the intergalactic medium, providing an invaluable means of studying gas physics in regimes where it is poorly understood. At high redshift, Lyα emission line searches have discovered thousands of star-forming galaxies out to z = 7. The large Lyα scattering cross-section makes observations of this line sensitive to even very diffuse gas outside of galaxies. Several thousand more high-redshift galaxies are known from damped Lyα absorption lines and absorption by the MgII doublet in quasar and GRB spectra. MgII, in particular, probes metal-enriched neutral gas inside galaxy haloes in a wide range of environments and redshifts (0.1 < z < 6.3), including the so-called redshift desert. Here we review what observations and theoretical models of Lyα emission, Lyα and MgII absorption have told us about the interstellar, circumgalactic and intergalactic medium in the context of galaxy formation and evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
The SAMI Galaxy Survey: Early Data Release
Authors:
J. T. Allen,
S. M. Croom,
I. S. Konstantopoulos,
J. J. Bryant,
R. Sharp,
G. N. Cecil,
L. M. R. Fogarty,
C. Foster,
A. W. Green,
I. -T. Ho,
M. S. Owers,
A. L. Schaefer,
N. Scott,
A. E. Bauer,
I. Baldry,
L. A. Barnes,
J. Bland-Hawthorn,
J. V. Bloom,
S. Brough,
M. Colless,
L. Cortese,
W. J. Couch,
M. J. Drinkwater,
S. P. Driver,
M. Goodwin
, et al. (23 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present the Early Data Release of the Sydney-AAO Multi-object Integral field spectrograph (SAMI) Galaxy Survey. The SAMI Galaxy Survey is an ongoing integral field spectroscopic survey of ~3400 low-redshift (z<0.12) galaxies, covering galaxies in the field and in groups within the Galaxy And Mass Assembly (GAMA) survey regions, and a sample of galaxies in clusters.
In the Early Data Release,…
▽ More
We present the Early Data Release of the Sydney-AAO Multi-object Integral field spectrograph (SAMI) Galaxy Survey. The SAMI Galaxy Survey is an ongoing integral field spectroscopic survey of ~3400 low-redshift (z<0.12) galaxies, covering galaxies in the field and in groups within the Galaxy And Mass Assembly (GAMA) survey regions, and a sample of galaxies in clusters.
In the Early Data Release, we publicly release the fully calibrated datacubes for a representative selection of 107 galaxies drawn from the GAMA regions, along with information about these galaxies from the GAMA catalogues. All datacubes for the Early Data Release galaxies can be downloaded individually or as a set from the SAMI Galaxy Survey website.
In this paper we also assess the quality of the pipeline used to reduce the SAMI data, giving metrics that quantify its performance at all stages in processing the raw data into calibrated datacubes. The pipeline gives excellent results throughout, with typical sky subtraction residuals in the continuum of 0.9-1.2 per cent, a relative flux calibration uncertainty of 4.1 per cent (systematic) plus 4.3 per cent (statistical), and atmospheric dispersion removed with an accuracy of 0."09, less than a fifth of a spaxel.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2014; v1 submitted 22 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
The SAMI Galaxy Survey: Cubism and covariance, putting round pegs into square holes
Authors:
R. Sharp,
J. T. Allen,
L. M. R. Fogarty,
S. M. Croom,
L. Cortese,
A. W. Green,
J. Nielsen,
S. N. Richards,
N. Scott,
E. N. Taylor,
L. A. Barnes,
A. E. Bauer,
M. Birchall,
J. Bland-Hawthorn,
J. V. Bloom,
S. Brough,
J. J. Bryant,
G. N. Cecil,
M. Colless,
W. J. Couch,
M. J. Drinkwater,
S. Driver,
C. Foster,
M. Goodwin,
M. L. P. Gunawardhana
, et al. (24 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present a methodology for the regularisation and combination of sparse sampled and irregularly gridded observations from fibre-optic multi-object integral-field spectroscopy. The approach minimises interpolation and retains image resolution on combining sub-pixel dithered data. We discuss the methodology in the context of the Sydney-AAO Multi-object Integral-field spectrograph (SAMI) Galaxy Sur…
▽ More
We present a methodology for the regularisation and combination of sparse sampled and irregularly gridded observations from fibre-optic multi-object integral-field spectroscopy. The approach minimises interpolation and retains image resolution on combining sub-pixel dithered data. We discuss the methodology in the context of the Sydney-AAO Multi-object Integral-field spectrograph (SAMI) Galaxy Survey underway at the Anglo-Australian Telescope. The SAMI instrument uses 13 fibre bundles to perform high-multiplex integral-field spectroscopy across a one degree diameter field of view. The SAMI Galaxy Survey is targeting 3000 galaxies drawn from the full range of galaxy environments. We demonstrate the subcritical sampling of the seeing and incomplete fill factor for the integral-field bundles results in only a 10% degradation in the final image resolution recovered. We also implement a new methodology for tracking covariance between elements of the resulting datacubes which retains 90% of the covariance information while incurring only a modest increase in the survey data volume.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2014; v1 submitted 19 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
The bias of DLAs at z ~ 2.3: contraining stellar feedback in shallow potential wells
Authors:
Luke A. Barnes,
Martin G. Haehnelt
Abstract:
We discuss the recent Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey measurement of a rather high bias factor for the host galaxies/haloes of Damped Lyman-alpha Absorbers (DLAs), in the context of our previous modelling of the physical properties of DLAs within the $Λ$ cold dark matter paradigm. Joint modelling of the column density distribution, the velocity width distribution of associated low ionizati…
▽ More
We discuss the recent Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey measurement of a rather high bias factor for the host galaxies/haloes of Damped Lyman-alpha Absorbers (DLAs), in the context of our previous modelling of the physical properties of DLAs within the $Λ$ cold dark matter paradigm. Joint modelling of the column density distribution, the velocity width distribution of associated low ionization metal absorption, and the bias parameter suggests that DLAs are hosted by galaxies with dark matter halo masses in the range $10 < \log M_v < 12$, with a rather sharp cutoff at the lower mass end, corresponding to virial velocities of 35 km/sec. The observed properties of DLAs appear to suggest efficient (stellar) feedback in haloes with masses/virial velocities below the cutoff and a large retained baryon fraction (> 35 %) in haloes above the cutoff.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2015; v1 submitted 7 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
The Fine-Tuning of the Universe for Intelligent Life
Authors:
Luke A. Barnes
Abstract:
The fine-tuning of the universe for intelligent life has received a great deal of attention in recent years, both in the philosophical and scientific literature. The claim is that in the space of possible physical laws, parameters and initial conditions, the set that permits the evolution of intelligent life is very small. I present here a review of the scientific literature, outlining cases of fi…
▽ More
The fine-tuning of the universe for intelligent life has received a great deal of attention in recent years, both in the philosophical and scientific literature. The claim is that in the space of possible physical laws, parameters and initial conditions, the set that permits the evolution of intelligent life is very small. I present here a review of the scientific literature, outlining cases of fine-tuning in the classic works of Carter, Carr and Rees, and Barrow and Tipler, as well as more recent work. To sharpen the discussion, the role of the antagonist will be played by Victor Stenger's recent book The Fallacy of Fine-Tuning: Why the Universe is Not Designed for Us. Stenger claims that all known fine-tuning cases can be explained without the need for a multiverse. Many of Stenger's claims will be found to be highly problematic. We will touch on such issues as the logical necessity of the laws of nature; objectivity, invariance and symmetry; theoretical physics and possible universes; entropy in cosmology; cosmic inflation and initial conditions; galaxy formation; the cosmological constant; stars and their formation; the properties of elementary particles and their effect on chemistry and the macroscopic world; the origin of mass; grand unified theories; and the dimensionality of space and time. I also provide an assessment of the multiverse, noting the significant challenges that it must face. I do not attempt to defend any conclusion based on the fine-tuning of the universe for intelligent life. This paper can be viewed as a critique of Stenger's book, or read independently.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2012; v1 submitted 20 December, 2011;
originally announced December 2011.
-
Galactic Winds and Extended Lya Emission from the Host Galaxies of High Column Density QSO Absorption Systems
Authors:
Luke A. Barnes,
Martin G. Haehnelt,
Edoardo Tescari,
Matteo Viel
Abstract:
We present 3D resonant radiative transfer simulations of the spatial and spectral diffusion of the Lya radiation from a central source in the host galaxies of high column density absorption systems at z ~ 3. The radiative transfer simulations are based on a suite of cosmological galaxy formation simulations that reproduce a wide range of observed properties of damped Lya absorption systems. The Ly…
▽ More
We present 3D resonant radiative transfer simulations of the spatial and spectral diffusion of the Lya radiation from a central source in the host galaxies of high column density absorption systems at z ~ 3. The radiative transfer simulations are based on a suite of cosmological galaxy formation simulations that reproduce a wide range of observed properties of damped Lya absorption systems. The Lya emission is predicted to be spatially extended up to several arcsec, and the spectral width of the Lya emission is broadened to several hundred (in some case more than thousand) km/s. The distribution and the dynamical state of the gas in the simulated galaxies is complex, the latter with significant contributions from rotation and both in- and out-flows. The emerging Lya radiation extends to gas with column densities of N_HI ~ 10^{18} cm^{-2} and its spectral shape varies strongly with viewing angle. The strong dependence on the central \hi column density and the HI velocity field suggests that the Lya emission will also vary strongly with time on timescales of a few dynamical times of the central region. Such variations with time should be especially pronounced at times where the host galaxy undergoes a major merger and/or starburst. Depending on the pre-dominance of in- or out-flow along a given sightline and the central column density, the spectra show prominent blue peaks, red peaks or double-peaked profiles. Both spatial distribution and spectral shape are very sensitive to details of the galactic wind implementation. Stronger galactic winds result in more spatially extended Lya emission and - somewhat counterintuitively - a narrower spectral distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2011;
originally announced January 2011.
-
Faint extended Lyalpha emission due to star formation at the centre of high-column density QSO absorption systems
Authors:
Luke A. Barnes,
Martin G. Haehnelt
Abstract:
We use detailed Lyalpha radiative transfer calculations to further test the claim of Rauch et al. (2008) that they have detected spatially extended faint Lyalpha emission from the elusive host population of Damped Lyalpha Absorption systems (DLAs) in their recent ultra-deep spectroscopic survey. We investigate the spatial and spectral distribution of Lyalpha emission due to star-formation at the…
▽ More
We use detailed Lyalpha radiative transfer calculations to further test the claim of Rauch et al. (2008) that they have detected spatially extended faint Lyalpha emission from the elusive host population of Damped Lyalpha Absorption systems (DLAs) in their recent ultra-deep spectroscopic survey. We investigate the spatial and spectral distribution of Lyalpha emission due to star-formation at the centre of DLAs, and its dependence on the spatial and velocity structure of the gas. Our model simultaneously reproduces the observed properties of DLAs and the faint Lyalpha emitters, including the velocity width and column density distribution of DLAs and the large spatial extent of the emission of the faint emitters. Our modelling confirms previous suggestions that DLAs are predominately hosted by Dark Matter (DM) halos in the mass range 10^{9.5}-10^{12} M_sun, and are thus of significantly lower mass than those inferred for L_* Lyman Break Galaxies (LBGs). Our modelling suggests that DM halos hosting DLAs retain up to 20% of the cosmic baryon fraction in the form of neutral hydrogen, and that star formation at the centre of the halos is responsible for the faint Lyalpha emission. The scattering of a significant fraction of the Lyalpha emission to the observed radii, which can be as large as 50 kpc or more, requires the amplitude of the bulk motions of the gas at the centre of the halos to be moderate. The observed space density and size distribution of the emitters together with the incidence rate of DLAs suggests that the Lyalpha emission due to star formation has a duty cycle of ~ 25%.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
A joint model for the emission and absorption properties of damped Lyman alpha absorption systems
Authors:
Luke A. Barnes,
Martin G. Haehnelt
Abstract:
The recently discovered population of ultra-faint extended line emitters can account for the majority of the incidence rate of Damped Lyman Alpha systems (DLAs) at z ~ 3 if the line emission is interpreted as Ly alpha. We show here that a model similar to that proposed by Haehnelt, Steinmetz, & Rauch (2000), which explains the incidence rate and kinematics of DLAs in the context of $Λ$CDM models…
▽ More
The recently discovered population of ultra-faint extended line emitters can account for the majority of the incidence rate of Damped Lyman Alpha systems (DLAs) at z ~ 3 if the line emission is interpreted as Ly alpha. We show here that a model similar to that proposed by Haehnelt, Steinmetz, & Rauch (2000), which explains the incidence rate and kinematics of DLAs in the context of $Λ$CDM models for structure formation, also reproduces the size distribution of the new population of faint Ly alpha emitters for plausible parameters. This lends further support to identification of the emitters with the hitherto elusive population of DLA host galaxies. The observed incidence rate of DLAs together with the observed space density and size distribution of the emitters suggest a duty cycle of ~ 0.2 - 0.4 for the Ly alpha emission from DLA host galaxies. We further show that Ly alpha cooling is expected to contribute little to the Ly alpha emission for the majority of emitters. This leaves centrally concentrated star formation at a rate of a few tenths M_sun/yr, surrounded by extended Ly alpha halos with radii up to 30-50 kpc, as the most plausible explanation for the origin of the emission. Both the luminosity function of Ly alpha emission and the velocity width distribution of low ionization absorption require that galaxies inside Dark Matter (DM) halos with virial velocities < 50 - 70 km/s contribute little to the incidence rate of DLAs at z ~ 3, suggesting that energy and momentum input due to star formation efficiently removes gas from these halos. Galaxies with DM halos with virial velocities of 100 - 150 km/s appear to account for the majority of DLA host galaxies. DLA host galaxies at z ~ 3 should thus become the building blocks of typical present-day galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2008;
originally announced September 2008.
-
Cosmological Radar Ranging in an Expanding Universe
Authors:
Geraint F. Lewis,
Matthew J. Francis,
Luke A. Barnes,
Juliana Kwan,
J. Berian James
Abstract:
While modern cosmology, founded in the language of general relativity, is almost a century old, the meaning of the expansion of space is still being debated. In this paper, the question of radar ranging in an expanding universe is examined, focusing upon light travel times during the ranging; it has recently been claimed that this proves that space physically expands. We generalize the problem i…
▽ More
While modern cosmology, founded in the language of general relativity, is almost a century old, the meaning of the expansion of space is still being debated. In this paper, the question of radar ranging in an expanding universe is examined, focusing upon light travel times during the ranging; it has recently been claimed that this proves that space physically expands. We generalize the problem into considering the return journey of an accelerating rocketeer, showing that while this agrees with expectations of special relativity for an empty universe, distinct differences occur when the universe contains matter. We conclude that this does not require the expansion of space to be a physical phenomenon, rather that we cannot neglect the influence of matter, seen through the laws of general relativity, when considering motions on cosmic scales.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2008;
originally announced May 2008.
-
Coordinate Confusion in Conformal Cosmology
Authors:
Geraint F. Lewis,
Matthew J. Francis,
Luke A. Barnes,
J. Berian James
Abstract:
A straight-forward interpretation of standard Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) cosmologies is that objects move apart due to the expansion of space, and that sufficiently distant galaxies must be receding at velocities exceeding the speed of light. Recently, however, it has been suggested that a simple transformation into conformal coordinates can remove superluminal recession velociti…
▽ More
A straight-forward interpretation of standard Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) cosmologies is that objects move apart due to the expansion of space, and that sufficiently distant galaxies must be receding at velocities exceeding the speed of light. Recently, however, it has been suggested that a simple transformation into conformal coordinates can remove superluminal recession velocities, and hence the concept of the expansion of space should be abandoned. This work demonstrates that such conformal transformations do not eliminate superluminal recession velocities for open or flat matter-only FRLW cosmologies, and all possess superluminal expansion. Hence, the attack on the concept of the expansion of space based on this is poorly founded. This work concludes by emphasizing that the expansion of space is perfectly valid in the general relativistic framework, however, asking the question of whether space really expands is a futile exercise.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
-
Expanding Space: the Root of all Evil?
Authors:
Matthew J. Francis,
Luke A. Barnes,
J. Berian James,
Geraint F. Lewis
Abstract:
While it remains the staple of virtually all cosmological teaching, the concept of expanding space in explaining the increasing separation of galaxies has recently come under fire as a dangerous idea whose application leads to the development of confusion and the establishment of misconceptions. In this paper, we develop a notion of expanding space that is completely valid as a framework for the…
▽ More
While it remains the staple of virtually all cosmological teaching, the concept of expanding space in explaining the increasing separation of galaxies has recently come under fire as a dangerous idea whose application leads to the development of confusion and the establishment of misconceptions. In this paper, we develop a notion of expanding space that is completely valid as a framework for the description of the evolution of the universe and whose application allows an intuitive understanding of the influence of universal expansion. We also demonstrate how arguments against the concept in general have failed thus far, as they imbue expanding space with physical properties not consistent with the expectations of general relativity.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
-
Joining the Hubble Flow: Implications for Expanding Space
Authors:
Luke A. Barnes,
Matthew J. Francis,
J. Berian James,
Geraint F. Lewis
Abstract:
The concept of expanding space has come under fire recently as being inadequate and even misleading in describing the motion of test particles in the universe. Previous investigations have suffered from a number of shortcomings, which we seek to correct. We study the motion of test particles in the universe in detail, solving the geodesic equations of General Relativity for a number of cosmologi…
▽ More
The concept of expanding space has come under fire recently as being inadequate and even misleading in describing the motion of test particles in the universe. Previous investigations have suffered from a number of shortcomings, which we seek to correct. We study the motion of test particles in the universe in detail, solving the geodesic equations of General Relativity for a number of cosmological models. In particular, we use analytic methods to examine whether particles removed from the Hubble flow asymptotically rejoin the Hubble flow, a topic that has caused confusion because of differing definitions and invalid reasoning. We conclude that particles in eternally expanding but otherwise arbitrary universes do not in general rejoin the Hubble flow.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2006;
originally announced September 2006.
