Academia Stack Exchange

17 votes

8 answers

4k views

What are good reasons for declining to referee a manuscript that hasn't been posted on arXiv?

Dikran Marsupial

5,978

answered yesterday

1 vote

1 answer

136 views

Should you ever pick "recommended" or "opposed" reviewers for journal submissions in social science?

Buffy

375k

answered Jul 17 at 18:58

1 vote

2 answers

140 views

Status of a manuscript whose required reviews are completed

Allure

133k

answered Jul 16 at 3:32

3 votes

4 answers

3k views

Does quick review means likely rejection?

Shern Ren Tee

3,089

answered Jul 16 at 1:56

33 votes

3 answers

5k views

Is this an invitation to submit or a polite rejection?

Dan Romik

193k

answered Jul 12 at 7:47

1 vote

1 answer

216 views

Waited almost a year and a half for a review. The reviewer reviewed the wrong paper. What to do?

Buffy

375k

answered Jul 11 at 18:33

9 votes

3 answers

6k views

Reviewing papers for MDPI: general feeling as a reviewer

cag51♦

70.5k

modified Jul 11 at 17:41

9 votes

2 answers

864 views

Can I still publish a paper on peer reviewed journals several years after publishing it on ArXiv?

BioBrains

4,513

modified Jul 7 at 11:27

2 votes

0 answers

139 views

Refereeing for American Journal Experts

Rooibos

29

asked Jul 4 at 8:40

3 votes

2 answers

106 views

Do you think that publishing a documented script in R (e.g. on GitHub) can increase the chance of publication?

BioBrains

4,513

answered Jun 30 at 16:37

16 votes

3 answers

3k views

How to write a review for a strong paper?

CommunityBot

1

modified Jun 25 at 12:43

8 votes

2 answers

1k views

What should I do if I uploaded my manuscript in arxiv and plan to pass it on a peer reviewed journal?

Nate Eldredge

134k

modified Jun 23 at 22:06

11 votes

5 answers

2k views

How much is simplicity of ideas/approaches in a paper appreciated by journals and reviewers?

Cait

1

modified Jun 19 at 5:02

4 votes

3 answers

3k views

Reviewers do not live up to own quality standards

CommunityBot

1

modified Jun 18 at 23:34

Stack Exchange Network

Explore our questions

What are good reasons for declining to referee a manuscript that hasn't been posted on arXiv?

Should you ever pick "recommended" or "opposed" reviewers for journal submissions in social science?

Status of a manuscript whose required reviews are completed

Does quick review means likely rejection?

Is this an invitation to submit or a polite rejection?

Waited almost a year and a half for a review. The reviewer reviewed the wrong paper. What to do?

Reviewing papers for MDPI: general feeling as a reviewer

Can I still publish a paper on peer reviewed journals several years after publishing it on ArXiv?

Refereeing for American Journal Experts

Do you think that publishing a documented script in R (e.g. on GitHub) can increase the chance of publication?

How to write a review for a strong paper?

What should I do if I uploaded my manuscript in arxiv and plan to pass it on a peer reviewed journal?

How much is simplicity of ideas/approaches in a paper appreciated by journals and reviewers?

Reviewers do not live up to own quality standards

Hot Network Questions