He’s a master of grand pronouncements that amount to very little.

This is an edition of Deep Shtetl, a curious person’s guide to the stories behind the stories, demystifying how politics, culture, and religion shape society.

Did someone forward you this newsletter? Sign up here.

Yair Rosenberg

Staff writer

Recently, I’ve been away for the best of reasons—parental leave—and will be in and out of your inboxes through the new year as a result. Thankfully, I’m assured that the world has been calm and serene in my absence this past month. But in all seriousness, thank you to all those who reached out to check in.

(Photo by Win McNamee / Getty)

He’s a master of grand pronouncements that amount to very little.

“We can’t rely on miracles. We need action to eliminate the threat. Only one action will accomplish this, and that’s to topple the Hamas regime in Gaza.” These fighting words were uttered by Benjamin Netanyahu—in 2009, when he was running to become Israel’s next prime minister. “I want to say here and now: We won’t stop … We’ll complete the task. We’ll topple the regime of Hamas terror.” A few months after making this promise, Netanyahu took office. He did not, in fact, topple Hamas.

Fifteen years later, Netanyahu is about to address a joint session of the U.S. Congress. He’ll be the first foreign leader to have done so four times, more even than Winston Churchill. And nothing he says will matter.

That’s not just because the speech is happening in the shadow of extraordinary electoral upheaval, days after President Joe Biden dropped his reelection bid and hours before Biden will address the nation from the Oval Office. No, the Israeli premier’s speech will be forgotten for a more fundamental reason: Although Netanyahu is very good at delivering portentous pronouncements, his words tend to have few consequences beyond the immediate attention they attract.

One would think that onlookers would have figured this out by now.

Inspire your summer. Enrich your life.

How will you make the most of your summer? An Atlantic subscription is the perfect companion for a summer well-spent. For less than $2 a week, enjoy unlimited access to journalism that helps you travel to new places, guides you through the current moment, and deepens your connections to the world around you.

Subscribe Today

This email was sent to newsletters@theatlantic.com
You've signed up to receive newsletters from The Atlantic.

If you wish to unsubscribe from The Atlantic newsletters, click here.

To update your email preferences, click here.

The Atlantic Monthly Group LLC · 610 Water Street, SW · Washington, DC 20024