Large-scale replication study reveals a limit on probabilistic prediction in language comprehension
- PMID: 29631695
- PMCID: PMC5896878
- DOI: 10.7554/eLife.33468
Large-scale replication study reveals a limit on probabilistic prediction in language comprehension
Abstract
Do people routinely pre-activate the meaning and even the phonological form of upcoming words? The most acclaimed evidence for phonological prediction comes from a 2005 Nature Neuroscience publication by DeLong, Urbach and Kutas, who observed a graded modulation of electrical brain potentials (N400) to nouns and preceding articles by the probability that people use a word to continue the sentence fragment ('cloze'). In our direct replication study spanning 9 laboratories (N=334), pre-registered replication-analyses and exploratory Bayes factor analyses successfully replicated the noun-results but, crucially, not the article-results. Pre-registered single-trial analyses also yielded a statistically significant effect for the nouns but not the articles. Exploratory Bayesian single-trial analyses showed that the article-effect may be non-zero but is likely far smaller than originally reported and too small to observe without very large sample sizes. Our results do not support the view that readers routinely pre-activate the phonological form of predictable words.
Keywords: N400; human; language comprehension; neuroscience; prediction.
© 2018, Nieuwland et al.
Conflict of interest statement
MN, SP, EH, KS, ED, NK, SV, FB, VK, AI, DM, DB, GR, HF, SB, XF, JT, EK, EH, DD, ZK, SR, FH No competing interests declared
Figures
![Figure 1.](https://cdn.statically.io/img/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/instance/5896878/bin/elife-33468-fig1.gif)
![Figure 2.](https://cdn.statically.io/img/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/instance/5896878/bin/elife-33468-fig2.gif)
![Figure 3.](https://cdn.statically.io/img/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/instance/5896878/bin/elife-33468-fig3.gif)
![Figure 4.](https://cdn.statically.io/img/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/instance/5896878/bin/elife-33468-fig4.gif)
![Figure 5.](https://cdn.statically.io/img/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/instance/5896878/bin/elife-33468-fig5.gif)
![Figure 6.](https://cdn.statically.io/img/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/instance/5896878/bin/elife-33468-fig6.gif)
![Figure 7.](https://cdn.statically.io/img/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/instance/5896878/bin/elife-33468-fig7.gif)
![Figure 8.](https://cdn.statically.io/img/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/instance/5896878/bin/elife-33468-fig8.gif)
Similar articles
-
Prior Context and Individual Alpha Frequency Influence Predictive Processing during Language Comprehension.J Cogn Neurosci. 2024 May 30:1-39. doi: 10.1162/jocn_a_02196. Online ahead of print. J Cogn Neurosci. 2024. PMID: 38820550
-
Probabilistic word pre-activation during language comprehension inferred from electrical brain activity.Nat Neurosci. 2005 Aug;8(8):1117-21. doi: 10.1038/nn1504. Epub 2005 Jul 10. Nat Neurosci. 2005. PMID: 16007080
-
Overlapping dual ERP responses to low cloze probability sentence continuations.Psychophysiology. 2011 Sep;48(9):1203-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-8986.2011.01199.x. Epub 2011 Apr 1. Psychophysiology. 2011. PMID: 21457275 Free PMC article.
-
Do 'early' brain responses reveal word form prediction during language comprehension? A critical review.Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2019 Jan;96:367-400. doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2018.11.019. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2019. PMID: 30621862 Review.
-
Prediction during language comprehension: benefits, costs, and ERP components.Int J Psychophysiol. 2012 Feb;83(2):176-90. doi: 10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2011.09.015. Epub 2011 Oct 19. Int J Psychophysiol. 2012. PMID: 22019481 Review.
Cited by
-
On the Mathematical Relationship Between Contextual Probability and N400 Amplitude.Open Mind (Camb). 2024 Jun 28;8:859-897. doi: 10.1162/opmi_a_00150. eCollection 2024. Open Mind (Camb). 2024. PMID: 39077107 Free PMC article.
-
Understanding words in context: A naturalistic EEG study of children's lexical processing.J Mem Lang. 2024 Aug;137:104512. doi: 10.1016/j.jml.2024.104512. Epub 2024 Mar 8. J Mem Lang. 2024. PMID: 38855737 Free PMC article.
-
Explaining the Sentence Superiority Effect and N400s Elicited by Words and Short Sentences with OB1-Reader.J Cogn. 2024 Apr 17;7(1):34. doi: 10.5334/joc.358. eCollection 2024. J Cogn. 2024. PMID: 38638462 Free PMC article.
-
Language prediction in monolingual and bilingual speakers: an EEG study.Sci Rep. 2024 Mar 21;14(1):6818. doi: 10.1038/s41598-024-57426-y. Sci Rep. 2024. PMID: 38514713 Free PMC article.
-
A predictive coding model of the N400.Cognition. 2024 May;246:105755. doi: 10.1016/j.cognition.2024.105755. Epub 2024 Feb 29. Cognition. 2024. PMID: 38428168
References
-
- Baayen RH, Davidson DJ, Bates DM. Mixed-effects modeling with crossed random effects for subjects and items. Journal of Memory and Language. 2008;59:390–412. doi: 10.1016/j.jml.2007.12.005. - DOI
-
- Baggio G, Hagoort P. The balance between memory and unification in semantics: A dynamic account of the N400. Language and Cognitive Processes. 2011;26:1338–1367. doi: 10.1080/01690965.2010.542671. - DOI
Publication types
MeSH terms
Grants and funding
LinkOut - more resources
Full Text Sources
Other Literature Sources